61

Namita L a w S e r i c s ©

English-1

NOVEMBER 08
1. (a) Answer
wer the following (1-2 sentences)
deny me, fie upon your
law'". What is the speaker
i. If you
concerned about being denied to him and in which court
is he?
ylock Jew, concerned about
the is the pound of
Thespeaker
which he had demanded being denied. in the Court
A. He is
flesh
ofthe Duke of Venice.
wMercy upon me", said Mr. Pickwick struggling violently.
in this way because Mrs Bardell had
A.Mr. Pickwick exclaimed and he was
been fainted in his arms struggling to deposit her
back on the chair.

taking to the little thing and being

ii, I couldn't help in which
about it. What is this "little thing" and
anxious
novel does it appear. The name of the
here is Hetty's new born child.
A. The littlething"
George Eliot.
novelis Adam Bede'by
with
corner sat Chambers, also Roxy,
iv. In the 'nigger in her pocket.
clothes on, and her bill of sale
good corner' and what
w a s in the 'nigger
Explain why Roxy
was 'her bill for sale'? she waS a black
because
A.
A. Roxy sitting in nigger corner that stated she has been
was
a
was a deed
slave and her bill of saleand therefore is no longer a salve.
Purchased back by Tom,
sentences.
Answer in not more then 2/3
(b)
nation". Who
of the English
the name
impeach him in mean?
and what does "impeach" charge on
Is the speaker and impeach'
means
Edmund Burke and here Warren
h e Speaker is his misconduct
nolder of a public ffice for misconduct
towards
impeached for his
Hastings had been

English Government.
 ) The Khilafat promise was not to be redeemed. What was
the Khilafat promise and to w h o m was it made? Write the meani
A. The promse was made e Sultan or urkey known as Khalif, by in toto - entirely
of egal terms
modus -

the Bntish during First Worid War in order to secure the caveat nanner, mode
The British assured them actor let the doer
cooperation of the Indian Muslims.
-

de jure in law aware

that they would not harm
h e position of Khalif and after the faux pass a false
-

war they oid

not keep their promise. ad hoc- for the step, a
mistake
special purpose
private relationship to clo.
i ) Gandhiji n e v e r Whose w o rhis
permitted 2. Answer Briefly-
ds are these and in which bo
a public issue.
do they appear?
his autobiography 'Rosee.
The triumph of
justice
These are MCChagla's words from in A. Refer to Q24. over
legality in
"Murder".
Decemder.

have to be in prison,
for money have I none
and
O'Henry's satire on the law In "The
A. Refer to Q22.
v ) I should profession and what Cop and the
What is
cannot pay.
the speaker's is Anthem",
h e accused of?
and he was accused
C.Denning's
AThe defense
case of of the Welsh students.
to practice philosophy of Welsh
Socrates used
corupting the vouth Athens
of
a n d ot not believing
90us in the was a
dramatic case. students,
haut Ehe Students Morris
of Wales vs. Crown Office: It
Welsh
the programmes language
were
the atyY-State. and they were veryvery enthusiastic
(indirect) welsh. They to wales were being upset
in English andbecause
Rewrite the
following a s
reported speech:
the London anddemonstrated to make protest. They
a not in
men and young invaded
(c) the
Court. A came upto
Lord, a m I?" said
the chemist. women, invaded the group of students, young
( ) " I am t o be s w o r n ,
my
replied the testy
little judge. prearranged. They strode into the court.
DUblic gallery. They shouted
court. It was completely
C e r t a i n l y , Sir, w h e t h e r he was to sworn. The They flocked into the
inquired the Judge They sang songs and broke slogans and
distributed
The chemist
adjourn. They were removed.up
the
hearing. The pamphlets.
Order was restored. judge had to
affirmative.
replied in
testy judge
The judge sentenced some of
as
directed
for contempt of court and those them three months imprisonment
(d) Do he grew pale. (Use who apologise were fined fifty
the verdict, pounds. The
judge
éxcessive. It was stated
that the
As s o o n a s
the jury gave
necessary for
punishment given was not
(i) "No sooner") v e r d i c t than
he grew pale. studentS everywhere that this kindhimofto show them and all the
thing
the jury gave
the Let students demonstrate, if they cannot be tolerated.
A. No s o o n e r Affirmative)
please,
which they believe. They can demonstrate, but for the causes in
sincerity.
(Make by lawfu means. It is only by the they must do it
did n o t
d o u b t his maintenance
thatthey are privileged to be students and to study of law and order
(ii) I doubtless.
and live in
His sincerity
was
not say what peace.
A. if I did
failed in my duty
I would
have
"Unless'") have
failed in
(iii) now. (Use now, I would
h a v e to s a y to say
what I have
Unless I say
duty.
 and to release the
Namita L a w S e r i e s c
Denning, gas in the court
So the gas, he ought
Lord would enliven the speeches and
of Appeal before special would
Court he had a oe
diverting for other
case came to effort
as
was a
and a relief from tedium of
When the the case With
extra
World War
he
pornography. So he installed the
the First_ to cylinder at the roof top and next
he considered
Wales. During was attached
morning he sat
adjacent to the pornography case court as the in the court
r e l a t i o n s h i p with
before them.
Engineerswhich

the royal
lieutenant_in the case came from that court. But he got caught for the way to roof was
second Division. When which the judge theft of bottle of
the38th (welsh) vindicated by
the sentences
order must nitrous oxide. At the end of the
has been
t h a t law and
court had brought him before him.day's hearing, the judge of that
the law He h a s shown appeal, Fh The police
But on this
passed a week and
before. maintained. the law evidence. Balogh admitted that it was inspector gave
true but he meant it
will be no longer dery
bemaintained T h e s e students here respect for it. Tha oractical joke not to hurt anyone. But the judge
for
things changed. to t h i s
c o u r t a n d shown
It is not necesan.
differentlyand was not amused. To
him it was thought
They
have appealed
week in
the prison.
are nok matter. It was a serious contempt of court. not a laughing
senved one I h e s e young people Balogh tried his
have already longer. them, best to convince the judge that it was
inside any or vice in n not meant for his
but the judge got annoyed and convict court
tokeep themThere is no
violence,
dishonesty
t h a t one should
applaud. The
They him and gave him
criminals. there w a s much the welsh language
as the nunishment of six
years jail not for the theft but for the
in
the contrary, preserve contempt of court.
wish to do all
they can to wrong in going
to extreme h
They have done They should he be
are proud of it.should shoW mercy on them. to their parents nd
an After eleven days in jalil Balogh considered
his mistake and
did but one to
t h e i r studies,
wronah wrote a letter of apology to the official
Solicitor
permitted to go back Wnich thney nave _so the case to upper court. Ihe case was who forwarded
the g00d cOurse opened, it occurred to
continue everyone present in the court that
was he
guilty of the
disturbed.
be of aood
of contempt of court. He was offence
future. They must
undoubtedly guilty of stealing the
for the the gas cylinder. No proceedings were
must be security the peace. There is power in
But there
disturbed
upset. Nothing untoward took place. No gas was and no trial was
must keep necessary, this cout
behavior. They has to be done by him which he did not released. A lot
it should become to prison
them. If and commit them he would have been able to do get any chance. Even if
court, to recall to callthem back from the what he intended to
would not hesitate should be released very undoubtful whether it would have do, it is
sentence. They be_of good any effect at all. The gas
bound over to
the
for the rest of shuld be f
would have been so diluted by air that it
they thejudgment would not have been
prison today, but the peace and to come up for noticeable. So here Balogh had the criminal
intent to
to convict him. He wasdisrupt
behavior, to keep months. the court, but that is not
the next 12 of enough guilty
called upon
within stealing, but no more.
case.
gas
in the laughing films and books
in
On this short
The punishment pornographic
ground,
and the sentenceeveryone thought that the judge was in
d. about he was a
tried each day as error
A case was being was there a5 of six months was
A. Balogh just excessive. Balogh
Crown Court.
Stephen for the defense, spent 14 days in the
employed by the solicitors
on and He go
on. prison;
enough to purge his contempt, if and has apologized. That is
casual hand dragged
no law. The
case
it up. He kne contempt it was.
a clerk, knowing
made a plan
to enliven
exceedingly
bored. He
nitrous
oxide. It gives e.
A. Seriousness of
"Contempt of Court" cases in early times.
about a gas
called
called laughing
gas. Refer to Q18.
Something inhaled. It is
effect when
exhilarating
of it and
carried inn
half a cylinder
the inlet sys
trial he took a cylinder at
During the the
was to put
brief case. His plan
Nanmita Law SeriesO 3. (a) Read the following passage and answer the
of Court.
In the case guestions. following
court.
Contempt of
Silence as as
contempt
silent if thev
a s k e d to keep (b) Make
is
considered
are sentences of the
A. Silence
discussed
here the judges
satisfactorily
were

but w h i l e
doing this they
wrote for Punch meaning in a following terms to bring out their
legal context
can't judge
a case

Mr.
Quintin Hogg he was adjourn, acquittal. mitigate, affidavit, fine,
of court. charge that
contempt Blackburn
on
the Appeali 4. (a) Answer the following-
doing Mr. the Court of n
himself up by criticized

found c o u r t . He the golden rule

of that
contempt He sald al i) Assess Mr.
quilty of
which
were quite
strong.
dicta is silence. Silence is Scout's strategy to please
preventing Joseph Lady Booby by
words matter of
obiter
contempt
of court and Andrew's wedding.
judges in the convicted
of
that the article A. Refer to Q5.
He w a s He
maintained

an option. of Appeals. state publicly,

to Court which he
had a rightto () Comment on the
Pickwick's trial and evidence
brought of
criticism
constituted a
those examined at
on to consider an his conviction. Mr.
court has been called
It is
a jurisdiction which
A. Mrs. Bardell, the landlady of Mr.
In this case
the
against
itself. It
will moe against him for a breach of promisePickwick had slapped a suit
of contempt
which they she had laid her damages at
of
marriage, and for which
allegation to judges but an interestt iin fifteen
undoubtedly
belongs
more
as they have
particulariy had been in London cOurt and the hundred pounds. The trial
sparingly
exercise,
Stareleigh and Sergeant Buzfuzz was judge was Mr. Justice
the matter. plaintiff's lawyer and
use this jurisdiction as a
said that
w e will never
not fear criticism, nor did
Sergeant Snubbin was defendant's lawyer.
w e do
Lord Denning o u r dignity. of
uphold in Parliament or out
m e a n s to of every man,
make a fair
comment Sergeant opened the trial with his witness Elizabet
r e s e n t it. It
is the right b r o a d c a s t , to friend of Cluppins, a
we the
public interest. We
are plaintiff.
She gave her witness
with a litte
it,in the press
or over
on
m a t t e r s of
by thi
When she came to plaintiff's house
just to say hello, she said
hesitation.
comment, which is said that she Mr. Pickwick and Mrs
outspoken nothing
even of criticism, or that, will
Bardell were talking so
the winds
written by this pen some topic which she couldn't loudly on
exposed to which is that t understand, that she was forced
o r that,
nothing requires, provided to hear it when she
person what the
occasion
Silence is not
an option
was
coming
coming from the front room and sheupstairs. The voices were
from doing hand.
deter us m a t t e r in of court if by back room and the door was coming towards the
to the a m o u n t s to
contempt of the room was
is pertinent
a r e ill
done. It
to a person. couldn't see anything but she partly open so she
when things something
wrong
had heard. There gave full version of talk which she
silent you
did was nothing new or
remaining
doing so, he which should have strange in her witness
but in convicted defendant. But she presented
the court, The artict herself with so much of
has
criticized
freedom of speech.
could emotions and helplessness that anyone
right of
contemp
Mr. Hogg
his
undoubted
errors do not
make it sympathizes with her.
exercising
no doubt, but
Contains a n error,
was
dismissed.
Next to come was Mr. Winkle, one of the members of Mr.
the application
of court and ICKWICk's club. Themoment hecame to the witness box
Veryone was for sure quessed that he was a confused man
easily
ne
asked
be fooled. The
prosecutor of plaintiff did the same.
him so many of meaningless and confusing questions
 68
with
(ili) Show how there was
enough circumstantial evider
Namita Law Series
a
bundle of
nerves

convict the twins for the murder of Judge

o
his
witness
he was
confused
that at
that stage A. Refer to Q10. Driscoll.
before giving was so or was
that m i n d . He r e v e a l a n y t h i n g

s t a t e of his this
tO and in
(b) Critically write
reluctant
confused
too he
knew
on
was
either everything
and his witnece
he to say be told
too
willing
secrets
not to with hi
nis
s o m e t i m e s

only he
revealed
Similar
i n s t a n c e s
happened
T h e claims of Lord Russell and Lord
Denning to be called
haste
his
friend.
and Mr.
Snodgrass.
"Portia Man".
against
went Tupman Refer to Q21.
Mr. A.
other two friends plaintiff's
neighbor were
all
Sanders, against Mr. Pickwick
Witnesses
of Susannah
which
talks
went

did support
the defendant
ii) The judgment
Trial, 1922'.
pronounced on M.K. Gandhi at The
Great
female gossiping
evidence
Although Sam Weller's
been
done. A. Refer to Q14.
worse had
then
by and pleas given
speech ii) The Rasu v/s Pertamina case.
and the emotional went against the defenda
All the
evidences
the trick
and This is a Mareva Injunction case. In Rasu
best to save him but at last he
B u z f u z z did vs.
Sergeant tried his
ffifty a Liberian company, issued a writ
Pertemina, Rasu,
Tndonesian state-owned company. Rasuagainst
lawyer s e v e n hundred and
though
his
a s k e d to pay Pertamina, an
even
and was claimed damages of
convicted nearly million sterling pounds for
2
OaS Sought to attach the assets breach
was
of a
pounds to
the plaintiff.
Mr. Pickwint of Pertaminacharterparty.
attack by the plaintiff's, wick in many
countries; but Pertamina had been busy getting rid of its
emotional
the this novel was written in ar Dutting them out of reach of assets
So due to in that
e when
time
male its
creditors. At length Rasu
convicted as an e n g a g e m e n t or nake
was
century, if
a man broke off found there were assets of Pertamina in
nineteenth the girl
coOuld s u e for
damages as
Ivina at the West Gladstone Dock England. They were
breach of
promise
for girls.
This had a bad effect. awaiting shipment.
parts of equipment for making a floating fertilizer They weree
a felt sorry
generally juries applied for a Mareva injunction to plant. rasu
in modern
times would
have been totall
taken out of the jurisdiction of thestop this equipment
Court. On the ex
being
trial e v i d e n c e . Mrs. Bardells
Mr Pickick's to modern laws
of
application the judge granted the injunction. parte
different according of marriage really
looks unusual in to discharge it. Pertamina applied
breach of promise nineteenth
c o m m o n in the
action for apparently
But it was
the girl could sue In this case
today's time. broke off an
engagement,
This had a
both the sides
were heard.
century. If
a man
juries felt sorry for girls.
in accusing each other at lengths. The case They both were
as generally corroborate
and for Pertamina there argued for the
to plaintiffs by Mr. was
plaintiff had
The judges werePhillips
for damages, the an
Later in 1869, evidence such as was Mr. Mustill.
bad effect. material Lord Justice
support of
the promise
other
to breach
of mariage Then Justice Denning and Lord Justice Orr.
m a t t e r s pertaining when the of the seizureDenning made a historical and
But
ring.
finally ended
in 1961, of assets comparative survey
judgment states that thisbefore
engagement

became fewer
gradually
and
be abolished. So judgment. The judges in their
they shouldPickwick if thesto is not a case in which
Law
Commission
recommended

against Mr.
should be granted to
restrain the defendants in injunction
an
have been no
case
disposal of the the use or
there would
advance of goods Liverpool. The courts have a discretion,
In at
time.
today's
has been set in judgment, to issue an injunction to
removal of assets-
whether the defendant is restrain the
within the
ama w Senes
Namita L a w S e r i e s C
11 English-1
Engi
Sdicton or outsice it. This discretion should not ho APRIL 09
oy ngic ules and it shouid be exercised be etterec
wnen it
Cut t De jLSt and convenient. appears to the
Answer the following (1-2 sentences)
1.
cecsior was a good way or things done. By their here". Whose
Lcges dic mucn toestesn Mareva injunction words s. "have no more Vagabonds settled
rnccie out by tneir decsion they avoided as a nene decision is this
and to whom does it refer?

Se of Lores. They decced on the

any appeal to tha AThis is Lady Bobby's decision. She is referring to Joseph
ments in favour of Andrews and his
fiancée Fanny.
cefencans mus preduding any appeal by them; but the
-ade t cear nat a t new prindple the
was to be
available b."It's Lord, to get any evidence
perfectly useless, my
r e Engis lam. of this witness".
through the impenetrable stupidity
Buzfuz to make this
What has perturbed Sergeant
(c) Along with your résumé, write a letter to
an
advocate remark about the witness?
you admire, asking him to allow some untoward remarks about
while you you to work for him A. The witness Sam Weller passed
are
completing your degree. the attorneys Dodson and Fogg
and was answering all the
OR Buzfuzz
A questions in absurd manner which perturbed Sergeant
large open water tank
brought in by the road repairing and the attorneys and he made that
remark.
contractor is still ying on the pavement. Write to
ward offcer asking him to your heart must
take action. Hetty could not be guilty of the crime-her
and what
have clung to the baby". Whose view is this
( Write as essay on was the crime?
A. Adam Bede was thinking this in the court and the crime
() What does the wortd that she has murdered her
(A atical assessment need: food her beloved Hetty was
or fuel? committed by
()Industrial growth in of21theCentury
institution of marriage.
India.
illegitimate child.

revelation! And for twenty

a.
It's so! Heavens, what a
was not
suspected it". What
threeyears no m a n has e v e r
revealed for twenty-three years7
Namita's Three Test A.
For last twenty-three years no one knew
that Tom' the Judge
Papers with Solution Dnscoll's nephew was not his brother's
real son but he was son

For LLB Course of their black slave Roxy.

for
a man to death
another world they do not put
(Based on University In
asking questions: assuredly not". Why does the speaker
words?
criticismn in these
this and what is the implied
Say
Question Papers) ne speaker Socrates,
wnen he was
said these words
sentenced to death as
he
in his address to jurors
was found guilty
and

the youth
1deal for last
moment FULL VIEW ne allegation against him was that
he is corrupting
that he was only preaching9
he had asked the jury
glance at a
or
Athens and do in their life and he did
people about what should they really
 English I
73
amia Law Scnest Namita Lan SeriesC

Englsh the degree).

not forced them to follow him and it was not his
now (Change
youth folowed his teachings.
fault that the
thas
(il)I
am
better

as g00d as anything
now,

feeling
AIam
f."She has become so poor that she has little power 2. Answer Briefly-

resisting famines". Who is the speaker and about whowof

Harder's action as "a social act".
is he speaking? om Camment o n
Lomax

A. Manatma Gandhi said these words .

duning his trial at Refer to Q23.
Anemaoadad and he was speaking about his A.
deserve to be
motheriand India at what point does Soapy
Accoding to you
.The one class, I am proud o
say, that
showed couraoe
h. arrested? Give reasons.

and fearlessness was the legal

profession".
the courage shown and who were the When was A. Refer to Q22.
to be feaarless?
classes that failed
Thalidomide case.
c. The in AG v Times Newspapers
A. The courage was shown by the In the Court of Appeal
lawyers reported
pericd and ciasses that failed to be during A. It is thalidomlde.
emergenqy had taken the drug
fearless were the Ltd. Mothers when pregnant That was in 1962.
intelligentsia and the industnalists. been born deformed.
Their children have Distillers, who
were started at once for damages.
Actions All parents
h."Imade ahistorical and comparative distributed the drug, to settle the actions.
tried
seirure of assets before survey of the five of them refused for settlement.
judgment".
the survey made and who made For which case was agreed to settlement but remove those parents
but the
it? An application was moved to
The casewas Ras five parents.
vs. Perusahaan (Pertamina) and the survey court refused to remove those
was made by Lord Denning. the report of
The editor of Times' told the court that
'Sunday
(b) Rewritte the Over 10 years had passed
following as reported speech: that case caused him great anxlety.
deformitles, and still no
these
Since the children were born with to
() Describe the occasion to which Distillers. He determined
you refer". compensation had been paid by to take a
My Lord", said Mr. Winkle. "I I'd and persuade Distillers
A. The judge ordered Mr. rather not"
-

investigate the matter in depth to all the thalldomide

Winkle to describe the fresh look at their moral responsibilitles
he referred. Mr.
Winkle answered occasion to which writs had been issued and those
hesitatingly in negative. children, both those where made and launched
where they had not. He had investigations
(c) Do as directed:
a campaign against Distillers.
Times
() Oh, you do remember that writ against the Sunday
Mr. Weller (Add Th Attorney General issued a publlshing the
Tag) a
question restrain them from
A. Oh, you do remember that Mr. clalming an injunction to when litlgation is pending
Weller, didnt you? draft article. It is undoubted law that, comment on It
shall
no one
suit before the court,
actlvely in of
(i) My client's hopes and and real and substantial danger
voice) prospects are ruined. (Chanae the In such a way that there is a
for lnstance by
of the action, as
A. prejudice to the trlal witnesses, or even by
The hopes and prospects of my cllent are the jurors, or the
the judge, to the c a u s e .
ruined. influencing
mankind in general against a party
prejudicing
 14 15
Namita Law Senesc Enghsh 1
English-
Namita Law SeriesC

The thalidomide children are the living reminders of

tragedy. There has

been n0 public inquiry as to
offered is elieved by
it came
a
national Miss Stone was often present in the court. She had made an
applica but It was rejectec She was sitting on the front seat
about. The compensation
be too
have passed and still no settlemen
manyto a book rack. he picked up a book and threw at the
small. Nearly 12 years near
have been reached. On sucn a matter the law can daes. She had hopea that sne would be booked for Contemot
and
authorize the newSpapers to make fair comment. No perdoes of Court-just to
draw more attention to her.
can stop comment by serving a writ and letting it lie
he stop it by entering an appearan and dle; nor extent did the Welsh students deserve
can doing what

more. It is active litigation

which is othing
protected by thelav e.
To
punishment?

contempt, not the absence of it. Applying th

all A. Refer Q2 (c) Nov 08.
considerations the court gave verdict in favor of Sunday Tim
But their decision was reversed by the House of Lorde Discuss the case of a refusal to give evidence?
.
said that no satisfactory definition can be found which does A. If a person refuses to glve satisfactory answers in the court or
have direct reference the mischlef
to which the law of
contem wlthhold important information related to the proceedings of
is and always has been designed to suppress. That mischief the Court, he is gullty of contempt of court. If the Inqulry has to
the isk of prejudice to the due administration of justice. be as thorough as the circumstances demanded, It is duty of
Derson concerned to glve all Information and that also should
Everyone always expected a decision of House of Lords tohe be rlght. In case of two Journalists, "Attorney-General v
final and condlusive. But Thalidomide case showed the contrary Mulholland" and "Attorney-General v Foster", the journalists
The Sunday Times took it to the European Court of Human refused to tell the source from which they get information they
Rights. They by majority of 11 to 9, upheld the claim of the had given In their article. Lord Radcliffe Informed the
Attorney
Sunday Times. It had a right to impart information about he General. He moved the Court to punish the journalist for
Thalidomide case. Inferentially they thought that the House of contempt of court. They were sentenced to slx months prison.
Lords were wrong and the Court of Appeal was right. The journalist appealed to the Court of Appeal. It raised the
questlon whether a journalist has any prlvilege in the matter.
d. When do Impulsive actions deserve contempt A preliminary pointarose as to the relevancy of the
proceedings according to Denning?
witness Is
question. A
A. According to Denning impulsive actions deserve contempt only bound to answer a relevant question, not the
Irrelevant one. Then arise the question of
proceedings when they harm someone present in the court privilege. The
hinder the proceedings of the court. If a person's impulsive Journalists argue that however relevant these questions were
and however
action is Just for seeking attention of people present in proper to be answered for the purpose of inquiry,
out or just to play prank on people
the
without intention d aJournalist has a privilege by law entitling him to refuse to give
nis sources of Information. When the journalists were asked
hurting them then it does not amount to contempt of court.
cney sald that source of information should be kept in secret
otherwise the person concerned would be in trouble and
OnOe a man threw a tomato at the fudges, but missed the shd he
moy refuse to help next time if needed. He claims to be entitled
ut it did hinder the
proceedings of
the court. He was o publish all hls information without ever being under any
immediately imprisoned for six nonths for contempt ofcourt ODligation, even when directed by the court or a judge.
Once t nas a hot
day. The atmosphere inside the court
ais hot.A man wit
stands up and smashed the glass to law by
$c wiro
the fresh air in. He was not commited f
n e court malntained there is no privilege known
o let Cn a person can refuse to answer a question which Is
Remp of coun as t was not done to hurt
anyboay.
 AanutaLa Sernes
11 English I

a eN N s dne which is
Engh
proper for hi. write on

The protession which is given him to be Critically

views of Lord Russell and Lord
privilege (b) differing Denning in
nNmaton to a dourt of law is the from The
Yvette" case.

h s
legal
o t he pmvilege or the layer du of hid profess (0)
the
"Little
Catings Ltd., it was not a will but a document of
Sydall
v
R he sourve of intormation w one
can nt. By In
ature, a group insuran scheme. Mr. Sydall's
be a gossinbelieve h by which,
similar
stn nas ot r invenbon or t may had a schen on a workman's death,
ployees
tmng to sm attention. So, this is in public interest. an was payable to his dependants or relations. Mr. Sydall
nd £ 300 was payable. He had four grown-up children by
tempt
money

wife. But
he had separated from her and formed a
old
his
inown to the
law by which a nent association with a lady with whom he lived and had
e N DVNe
eanswer 3 question which is elevant to the canjournalist p e r m a n e n

airl. Yvette, aged three years. The trustees wanted to

s ne icn, the the inquiry come of the £ 300 for the benefit of the baby girl; but the
ot
judge, it is proper for hima
in
opinion
a s e c In ths pertiaular case it is in the to P t held that none was payable. They did it on the grounds
HUnai to inguine as to the sources of
public interest
for illegitimate.
information. that she
was

The cou nave anxiously considered the sentences of Lord Denning protested. His views were that according to
Sx words Yvette is a relation of her father
hs end three months respectivey which Gorman J
passa rdinary meaning of the
Mhand and Foster, and after tull consideration the cour ssed and a descendant from him. She should therefore, be included
etnedie to adopt the view that the sentences are among those qualified for benefit. But Lord Russell, the counsel
Ospropotionete to the senious nature of the offence. oressed that relations includes only legitimate relations. Since
Yvette was illegitimate, she was to be excluded from any
Read the benefit. Lord Denning said that it was acceptable in olden times
3.(a) following passage and answer the questions, as judges in those days used to think that if they allowed
(b) Nake sentences of the following terms to bring out their illegitimate children to rake a benefit they were encouraging
meaning in a legal context- immorality. But now the times have changed and the old rules
be
writ, convict (Verb), defend, appeal, penal. should replaced by a more
relations and dependants in a
rational approach. The words
group assurance scheme are
wide enough to include illegitimate children and should be
4. (a) Answer the following- interpreted like that.
(0) Comment on the sentence passed on Shylock.
A. Refer to Q1.
But Lord Russell took the traditional view and said that he see
no sufficient
(ü) Summarize the factors which led to Mr. Pickwick losing ground for departing from the normal rule of
construction. In his judgment descendant is to be construed as
the case filed by Mrs. Bardell.
descendant in the legitimate line.
A. Refer to Q4 (a) (i) (Nov 08).

(ii) Analyze John Olding's evidence and point out any weak SO little Yvette, because she was
illegitimate took nothing
Quite contrary to what her father would have wished and
points which would favor the accused. contrary to what the trustees desired.
A. Refer to Q7.
 19
Namita Law SenesC Lnglih
English
Namila Law SeriesC

(i) Macaulay's attitude to the prosecutors Nov 20009

A.
Hastings.
Macaulay's attitude towards the prosecutors of
ren
Warreen in not more than two sentences any three of
in
prit Hastingshis
was rather satirical. He wrote that neither
er the A n s w e r

nor (a)
advocates attracted so much attention as the acci
1. the following

s. He the victims of circumstances and I the

in the court
explained their presence very critically. Burhad stWho has victimized the speaker and under
head was present in his full dress who was ignorant their g r e a t e s t " .

ndeed, o
negligent of the art of adapting his reasoning and his.
w h a t c i r c u m s t a n c e s ?

Pickwick has been victimized

by her landlady
the capacity and taste of style
hearers, but in amplitude
A.
Thes speaker Mr.
Martha Bardell. He was talking about hiring a servant and
comprehension and richness or imagination superior
to thought that he is proposing her and this lead
to
generally every
orator, ancient or modern. Fox his frie who his landlady

had paid to the illustrious is so

of his
m i s u n d e r s t a n d i n g s .

regardless appearance,
the compliment of wearing a wig worn specially trib by
bond doth give the here no jot of blood". Who is
prosecutors and sword. The box in which the managers the ii) "Thiss
bond?
and what is the
contained an array of speakers such as perhaps hadstood the speaker
These words are of Portia at the trial. If Antonio fails to pay
appeared together since the great age of Athenian eloquen not A.
hack lent money within three months, Shylock will take a pound
There was Demosthenes and Hyperides. The younaest
of his body.
intelligent among all of them was Windham. All who stoodand of flesh from any part
at
that bar, save him alone are gone, culprit, advocates, accuse
sers. i "My name is Sarah Stone". In which novel does she
appear and what is her role when she says this?
A. She appears in the novel Adam Bede by George Eliot. She said
( ) M.C. Chagla's presentation of Indira Gandhi.
these words at the trial of Hetty Sorrel as an eye witness.
A. Refer to Q17.

(c) The public sports ground in your locality have been

iv)"I only perform my office to Mr. Joseph". Whose words
are these and when are they spoken.
encroached upon by families of shepherds. Write to your A. These are the words of Parson Adams. He was
ward office asking the authorities to take action. answering the
questions asked by Lady Bobby about the banns he has
OR
announced in the Church about the marriage of Joseph and
Reply to the following advertisements-
Fanny.
"A commercial organization seeks a young committed
legalgraduate to work as an assistant in the H.R (6) Answer any three in not more than two sentences per
department. Apply with resume to Box No. 456 Mumbai answer-
Mirror". 1)"Instead of being an untouchable I became a
member of society. Who is the respectable
(d)Write as essay on speaker? What does he
mean by untouchable?
(0) Threats to Indian Democracy Today. AMCChagla in his autobiography 'Roses in December'said these
(ii) Tackling Unemployment
(iti) Festivals and Urban India. wOrds. During the emergency eminent people like lawyers,
boicians from opposition parties, journalists who wanted to
Capeople aware of circumstanceswere barred from
EKing publicly and if they were able to write or say
 80
Namita Law Serneví 81
Lngish 1

not allowed to be reported T

ngli. Namila L0W Seriest

something it was
untouchables of the soclety.
They al were as the king finished speaking, the people began
treated as ) As s o
No sooner... then)
him. (Use
i ) " I am a Portia man". Who are two claimants to this to
che

ooner
the king hed
finishe speaking then the people began to
man are No
A. The two claimants
to be a Portia
Lord
Lord Denning A cheer him.

Lord Russell.
the eanings of any four of the following legal
Explain
of this part of the case was an
l) "The conduct
Sheridan". What were
Sheridan's qualities? usted to i )
terms

a d n-
i n t e r i m -
for the meantimne

was a great speaker

and master of elocutian bad faith, treacherously
Sheridan
knowledge of stage.
cutlon and ha )
m a l a f i d e -

law
in

jure-in
ii) decentum-a hundred
iv) room,
iv)"The Khilafat promise waswnot to be redeemed i n camera- in a (judgeS private) in secret

words are these and

what this promise?
as
novo-
new
vi) de
A. These are the words or Manatma Gandhi at his trlal. The
tri
any four
promise Sultan of Turkey known Khalf, h
-

was made to as briefly on

British during First World War In order to secur Dy 2) Write
cooperation of the Indian Muslims. The British assured th tal Comment on O' Henry's Presentation of Soapy.
that they would not harm the position of Khalif and af A. Refer to Q22.
the
war they did not keep their promise.
(b) Write a short note on 'The Murder of John Franting'.
the following as reported (indirect) speech A. Refer to Q23.
(c) Rewrite -

She said, "I have lived one hour as a proud rose". He (c) Describe how Lord Denning dealt with the journalists
asked "And then?" who refused to reveal their source of information.
A. She exclaimed that she had lived one hour as a proud rose. He A. Refer to Q2 (f) (April 09).
asked her what's next.
(d) Explain the case of Chapman V Honig, where a tenant is
(d) Do as directed (an two) evicted from his home.
i) If roads do not develop along highways, there will w A. Chapman v/s Honig is a case regarding victimization of witness
traffic problems. (Rewrite using 'unless') which amounted to be contempt of court. The contemnor can
be punished
A. There will be traffic problem unless roads do not develop alog by the courts of law by fine or imprisonment. But
can the sufferer who
has been victimized for being the witness
hlghways can sue the contemnor for damages. The victimization is not
only a criminal offence; it is a civil wrong- a tort as lawyers call
l) Is there any one here who can claim such honor? (Ma it.
assertive)
A. Anyone there can claim such an honor.
n this case, a landlord forcibly evicted one tenant called
daand from his flat. That tenant sued the landlord for
dmages for wrongful eviction.
Chapman, the next floor tenant
tnessed whatever happened on second floor. Harrand
Ed him to be witness and give evidence against the lanaiord.
 Namta Law SeriesC 82
ngliah
Chapman refused but he was
subpoenaed to do
Engish- N a m i t a Lavw S e i e s e

involuntarily gave evidence. Ihe very next day so for Hetty's convection.
served a notice on Chapman to quit his flat and he
th nd ( ü )D i s c u s s the
he
grounds

within
Chapman has givenmoonth.dlord
a t o Q6.
reason he did was simply because
against him. The eviderence
A.
R e f e r

(i)Examine Lady Booby's objections to Joseph's Marriage.

ine Lac

to Q4.
The principle upon which the case was
decided A.
Refer

system of law can compel a witness to

give
Nas
any two
evidencaat
-

write
nn
on finding him victimized for doing it refuses and then (b)
Critically

redress. It is duty of the court to protect the

the notice to quit to be invalid and
tenant bygive him (i) "Lord Dennin ing stresses the spirit.and not the letter of
an granting injun holding
the law". Comment.

restrain the landlord from carrying out his ction

which compels him (subpoenaed) to give threat. Th to
evidence i a A.
Refer to
Q20.

bound to protect him from being punished for doing it. n

duty i ) On what
ground w a s Socrates condemned?
to Q12.
The judge gave judgment for the plaintiff A. Refer
for 50
damages for contempt of court. According to the pounds defense at his 1922 trial.
landlord's notice to evict in order to punish Chapman judoe the (ii)Gandhiji's
for. A. Refer to Q14.
against him, itself is a contempt of court- a criminal offencegoing
3
punishable accordingly. and
() () Along with your resume write a letter of application
for the post of a Legal Advisor in a reputed company.
(e) Silence as contempt of Court.
A. Refer to Q2 (f) (Nov 08). (i) Write a letter to the Editor of a newspaper highlighting
the road mishap problem in your area.
(F) What was Lord Denning's approach towards the Welsh
Student's case? (d) Write an essay on any one -

A. Refer to Q2(c) (Nov 08). (i) The place of English in Our Education System
(ii) My idea of an Ideal Citizen
3. (a) Read the following passage and answer the (ii)The role of Students in Free India.
questions that follow.

(b) Make sentences with any three of the following words t April 2010
bring out their meaning in a legal context-
Public, writ, default, reservation, challenge .(a) Answer in not more than two sentences any three or
the following
4. (a) Attempt any two -
My Lord, here stays without a messenger with letters
rom the doctor." Who is the speaker? Whom does he call
Lord?
(0)Assess the witnesses at Mr. Pickwick's trial.
A. Refer to Q4 (a) (i) (Nov08).
olanlo
Lord.
said these words at the trial and he called the Duke as
Namita Law SeriesC
85
Engl.sh-1
(ii) I know, I ought to do, if I got on as
English.1 N a m i t a L a wS e r i e s O

harm the position of Khalif and after the

deserved, but I don't, my Lord". Whose words ell as 1 would not
that theyY wo
In which novel do they occur? are keep their promise.
A. These are the words of Inomas Grifrin, the chemist these war
they
did not

The name of who cam

as a witness at Mr. Pickwick's trial. expected that my book would run into seven
novelamels
( i v ) " I n e v e r e x p e c t e

The Pickwick Papers' by Charles Dickens. the editio be received so kindly." Whose words
and would

about which book is he talking about?

ece and
are thes
(ii)"Your Ladyship is very much in the right said these words after success of his autobiography
Chagla
Ladyship is referred here? Who is the speaker?
A. Ladyship referred here is Lady B00by. Lawyer
Whose A. MC
Roses in December'

speaker.
Scot Scout is the indirect speech
Rewrite in
(C) "Is it dead?"
(iv)"My name is John Olding. I am a labourer." Sheela said,
whether it was dead.
Sheela enquired
he which
novel does he appear and what is his role when
the above line. utters Raiu replied, "No, I can still feel its heart beating."
A. He appears in the novel Adam Bede by
these words at the trial of Hetty Sorrel as an
George Eliot. He Raiu replied in negative that he could feel its heart beatina
eye witness said then.
(b) Answer in not more than two sentences
any three as directed-
the following- of (d) Do
(G) "He took another strip of glass and (1 This is the largest tree in neighborhood. (Change the
took another strip of glass? Why did he exclaim?
exclaimed"
Who degree)
A. Tom Driscoll took another strip of glass and he
No tree is as large as this tree in the
neighborhood.
exclaimed when
he saw old Roxy's label on the striP and the date on
the strin (i1) The milk is too hot for me to drink.
was about twenty three years back.
The milk is so hot that I cannot drink it.
(Remove too)
(ii) "Let's reflect in another way, and we shall see that ther (e) Explain the
is great reason to hope the death is a good, for
one of mens rea-
meaning of any four-
two things". Who is the speaker? In what situation guilty mind
are memorabilia- things worth
these lines uttered?
pro rata- in remembering
A. Socrates said these words while addressing his fellow Atheniars de facto- in proportion
for the last time before he was condemned to death
actual fact, real
sentence ex
gratia- as an act of grace
(iii)"But all the
hope was shattered. The Khilafat promise 2. Write briefly
two on any
was not to be redeemed". Whose words are these a
what was this promise? a)
A. These the words of Mahatma Gandhi at his trial.
Discuss the
significance
and the Anthem'? of the title of the
are
1* story The Cop
promise was made to Sultan of Turkey known as Khallf, by be A Refer to Q22.
British during First World War in order to secure e
cOoperation of the Indian Muslims. The British assuréo ther Write
A.
an
essay on 'Lomax Harder and
Refer to Q23. John Franting.
Namita Law SeriesC
86
English
c) 87
Describe briefly the
A.
significance?
Refer
Laughing Gas'
incidentt
Engish NamitaLan SenesE

widow a new trial as everyone is entitled

to Q2 (d)
(Novo8). and its aranted the his case properly before the
put
The court grante.

e can
w h i c h he
d) trial a t
Explain the air
Refer to Q2 importance of the Cha
a
A. to

(d) (Novo9). mpan v Honig judge,

for a little
Cas Hallett should Continue to sit
e) ase. a0aed that
of the
Explain the
I t was

has to resign. He
a r r a n g e d

at the endresigned
A.
circumstances
Imbert Perian Hallett had in which
to resign. Honorable Si
while a n d t h e n he

a
poignant
case, as he was able and intelligent
The honourable Sir It w a s
too many questio which cost him his
Hugh Imbert Perian ugh man but he asked
term.

judge.He
experience judgeHallett
was a very was ro a and has to
resign.
grew is
loquacity.
dived deep into
He got so
interested
and with
experie
every detail of it. He in every case
spected position

therience
c)Elucidate the idea of 'question of Privilege' with
asked too many talked too dt he
and the questions one after another appropriate examples?

counsels in their submissions.

to both
both the
the witness
dnd (April 09).
e A. Refer to Q2 (1)
In the case Jones v Coal a3) fal Read the following passage and answer the question
fallen in. a
Board, the roof of a
miner had been buried coal mine given below.
and
person claimed damages. The case died. The widow of th
rejected the widow's claim. The wIdowwas tried by Hallett thate (b) Make Sentences with any three of the following words to
on the among others appeale
ground that the Judge's interruptions bring out their meaning
impossible for her counsel to put the case had made Inflict, Lapse, Supersede, Epilogue.
was argued before the properly. The cast
court. The judges were
the judge was of the view
intervening with the best motives. tha 4) (a)Attempt any two
anxious to understand the details of He was tus
the complicated
asked questions to get them clear in
his mind. case, and i) Write short note on Justice Broomfield's Statement.
A. Refer to Q16.
But the judge part in all of this
is to only
himself to the witness when it is asking questions i) Write an essay on the conflict
necessary and to see that the between
advocates behave properly and keep to the rules
law. One of the Judges remarked that
laid down by
'Antonio' as
Venice'.
it is
presented in the play, 'The'Shylock' and
Merchant of
patience and gravity t Refer to Q1.
hearing is an essential part of justice and an over-speaking
Judge is no welI tuned cymbal. The court was of the opinion i) What
options do you think
that a judge of acute Sorrel and her would be
perception, acknowledged learning ar
actuated by the best of motives has never the less himse he setup of illegitimate child to day? opened to Hetty
intervened so much in the conduct of case that the parte
novel 'Adam Bede' Discuss.
entury in
England. It
is in a
village of Eighteen
Involved has come complaining that they were not allowed Derore Industrial
the depicted truest picture
put their case properly. rtnodoxian Revolution. The society at that of England,
religious belief. Being an
ddoo and according time was or
to laws unwed mother was a
S Hetty was a girl whoalso it was a sin and she
COward was
type. She could not paia To
illiterate, a little folish and
resist
temptations of Arthur
Namita Law Series
88
89 English-I
and he always
after her pregna Lnglih.
made fool of her
and N a m i t a L a wS e r i e s

marriage, he ran away never to

look Gandhi, the people of India
back. cy before eadership
Under t h e l e ad
of Mahatm
for freedom,
national
In today's context, in
become heroic,
audacious fighters
audacious

Today she would 21 century the soclety

has and r e
ceivers
c e i
of hail-storms of bullets of the
be literate and has progresser of jails
difficulty and no one make fool brave enouah urters Mahatma Gandhi injected the people with
enemy.
of her. If atanic" British Government and with
unwed parents today would case
mother, her in face imperla
for the "Sa
hatred

national freedom. He was the highest

orthodoxian beliefs had progressed deep thirst for

today's society. Then she and becomesupport nationalism.

u n q u e n c h a b l e

ubsequently, he incarnated the

set out a
little I her as
alone to search
expression of
now her
parents
have discussed her
would have helped
her. Besides At
beral in very spirit of nationalism,
heroic will
its proud hatred of foreign
and determination to end that
and
problem with Adam the ensla
vement
Legally
there are many law lOug
in today's
context man who e n s l a v e m e n t .

legality of illegitimate child.

Today mother is Sunr
responsible alone for the af the virtues that
Gandhi preached
practiced in his and
legitimacy
responsible. Also it is no more treated but father alsoIs
not hey aa

ofe was fearlessness. "By his exhortations, by his own

but it' equal
as a crime
which can be mended. A mother example and by organizing disciplined movements of defiance
fight in thea faut
can
for her legitimacy and ask for legally ofself-confidence, self respect and a readiness to stand up for
child's rights in the COur
society. themselves. For this as much as for the actual attainment of
(b) Critically write any two- Independence, he deserves the title of Father of Nation".
i) Why did Jury condemn Socrates? l) Discuss what was new and innovative about the Mareva
A. Referto Q12.
injunction?
A. Refer to Q19.
i8) Why is Gandhiji referred to as the 'Father of
A. Mahatma Gandhi has rightly been called the the Natlon? (c) Along with your resume write an
following situation Situation Vacant application
Father of the for the
Nation. He was in every sense of the word -

the Wanted Librarian -

modern India. It was under hlm that Indla creator d for reputed college. Candidate must be
a
won her
independence. It was true that Tllak had anticipated him by Master's Degree in graduate with
Library
apply. Write Box No. BBR 98 Science. Even fresher's may
advocating a policy of strong action the 3K, The Times of India,
Government instead of a pollcy of mendicancy as followed by
against Brtis Mumbal-400 001
the Moderates in India, but it cannot be denied that it was
under Gandhijl that the nationalist movement In Indla became OR
(c) You have
amass movement and not a movement of the met borrowed a book
from College Library, but
Intelligentsla of Indla. He followed varlous methods to achie
his ends,
unfortunately
Principal you have lost it.
Write a letter to the
He started the Non-Co-Operatlon Movement apologizing
for your
started the Clvil DIsobedlence Movement. He vlolated the (d) Write an
carelessness.
of the country. It was under him that the Congress passe essay on any one
del ) Let's
Quit India Resolution. He fasted. He court arrested. e h Stop Child Labor
the might of the British Emplre. But he did all this w
The Place
object and that was the liberatlon of this country. of
W) The ClnemaWomen in Indian Society
Advertlsements.
and the Television as Media of
 0
NanitaLaw Scries

Nov 2010
aghd. Namita L.aW Series

more t h a n
mor
t w o sentances-
not
In
A n s w e r

at's the matter wlth you, Wilsnn? Are

in not more than two sentence
Answer
b)
Q1. a) "Your Ladyship is ce
"Great
Heavens!

) "Madam", says Adam, without any reason". offended wiwith golng

to
faint?"

above words spoken? What ls 1h

me, I protest you are the
hom
What makes Adams to prorest wthout any reason By
situatlon ?
of Joseph Twaln's novel Puddn'hesd
A. Lady Booby was agalnst marrlage and from Ma
Mark
can't bear poor and vagabonds
in her parish an ny aas.
This is
extract

here is Tom Drlscoll. Tom arnd Wilsn were

well- wisher protested this. speaker
fingerprints of Tom when he was seven nonths u
their friend and beng serving
The

i) "Thank you, Sir- thank you", exclaimed rs. and

while observing
then something strange w9s
reesie
which shocked Wilson.
hysterically. Whom did Mrs. Bardell thank and
Mrs. Bardell thanked Mr. Trumpman who helped why?
Bardell
downstairs after she was fainted.
helped her to in the shape
The first shock c a m eWhat
the Rowlatt of Act"
is Rowlatt Act?
Who is the speaker?
Gandhil wrote these lines in his autobiography in the chapter
ii) "Take this villain away" said the agonized Mr. Pickwi
Who is the little villain? why does Mr. Pickwict The Great Trial'. The Imperial Government under the pretest of
controlling insurrection passed the now infamous Rowlatt Act,
someone to take away? Sk
which gave great powers to the Government and the police to
A. The little villain here referred is Master Bardell, Mrs, Bardal
arrest, keep in prison without trial, or to have a secret trial, any
son. The moment he entered the room he saw his mother in person they discovered or suspected.
Mr. Picwick's arms and he thought that he had harmed
his
mother. So he started kicking and busting him and also w ii) "I might say a word about Niren De. He was a friend of
shouting loudly. That's why Mr Pickwick asked someone totake
mine."
him away. Who was Niren De? Whose friend was he?
A. Niren De was
still say I, a second Daniel. I thank theeJew Attorney General at the time of emergency and
iv)"A Daniel, was a good friend of Justice MC Chagla.
for teaching m e that word".
Who is being calleda
By whom are these words spoken? iv) And now, O' men who have
condemned me, I would fain
second Daniel?
words in the Cour
prophesy
Who is
to you, for I am
about to die."
A. Gratiano, the accused in this c a s e said these the speaker? Whom
does he address?
in Shakespeare's 'Merchant of Venice'. He
was calling Portiaa A Socrates said these
at the s words during his address to the
second Denial because she has saved
his life Was
addressing his fellow Athenians in these words. jurors and
moment when all hopes were diminished
and her entry in:
Court was similar to wise Daniel who was famous for his cas
CCUSe c)Rewrite the following in indirect
accuser and
the
du What speech.
nave neverexcellent
an
which he cleverly cross examined the pudding?" said
was convicted of falsehood. A. tasted anything Lady Drummond.
uyDrummond exclaimed inlike this before".
praise that what an excellent
g t was. She further added that she had
anything like that before. never tastea
 Namita Law SeriesC
English 1
93
d) Do as directed- English- A a m u t aL o wS e r i e s

Dockers case and the role of the

he Three
i) There has been no sign of case.

(Add a question tag). improvement in the patient,

Explain

Official
Solicitor
in this

v/s Shop Stewards popularly

known as
Churchman
of Court. One of the
A. There has been no Sign of
improvement in the patient, has i he
Three
case

ockers
Case is regarding
powerS
of
ontempt
con
court of law is its power to give
As soon as the chief guest important
has to make an order commanding a
ii) arrived, the students cla most o f t e n it
Very him in some way. If the
A.
(Use No sooner....than).
No sooner the chief guest arrived, than the
orders.

person too do
something o r
restrai.
Court has one weapon in its
disobeys, the
students ela. dents clapped person
concern
that is it can punish the
use and person
which it can
e) Explain the meaning of the legal terms ury
court. a criminal offence, but
It Is before
for contempt of for contempt of court it must be proved
Per diem - per day rommitting person doubt and there must be several
reasonable
ii) Infra - below, lower down the page beyond strictly observed.
requirements being
iii) Vice- versa -
the order being reversed, terms exchanger
iv) Ultra v i r e s - beyond one's power
was very much evident in
Three Dockers Case. It
This strictness Act 1971 which set up a
v) Status quo the existing state of Industrial Relation
things at any given date
-

arose out of the

vi) Nee- born, used in stating a woman's maiden name the Industrial Relations Court. It was bitterly
new court,
and their members. So much so,
opposed by the trade unions
new court and decided to
2) Write briefly on any four that they refused to recognize the
-

it. A crisis arose when the Dockers

disobey the orders issued by
a) Discuss Bennett's presentation of Dr. Austin Bond as a in the East End of London picketed a depot. The Court issued
detective. an order commanding them to stop picketing. The Dockers did
A. Refer to Q24. not appear before the court nor were they represented. They
continued the picketing.
Write a short note on Soapy's change of heart.
b)
A. Refer to Q22. The Court 9ave their judgment which
has gone far
that the conduct of those men
beyond anything
could be disposed of by
imposition of a fine. Unless they gave proper explanation of
as attention seeking.
c) Contempt of Court thelr conduct, the court
had no alternative but to make orders
A. Refer to Q18. committing them to prison. But they had every opportunity to
journaliss explain their conduct. The court set
which the two a dead line.
d) Explain the circumstances in
w e r e sent to Prison o n
Attorney-General V. Mulhoila he Dockers did not care for court's order as expected from
case. en. They knew that if they would continue to disobey ana
A. Refer to Q 2(1) (April 09). nnue picketing without appearing before the Industna
with t
nt,warrants would be issued against them. They
s o n and would become martyr. Their trade union woulo
will callgo
witness
of a a
e) the Victimization
Explain
approprlate examples. Ke which
the orders. would paralyze the country and court had to aver
A. Refer to Q18 and Q2 (d) (Nov 09).
 Namita Law SericsO
94
95 Englsh
But nothing
like that happened. The
powers to represent his countrymen Official soliets
Lnglish- NamitaL a w S e r i e s t

with any
three of the following
-

stand for their cause, wi Itor, who ha

without ther s e n t e n c e s

Coincidence,
Conversation,
approached the Court o
asklno to
b ) Make.

represented the Dockers. The orderS of thne Justification,

Appeal and
C o r r e s p o n d e n c e , C a l c u l a t i o n .

averted. The Dockers were

gates of depot expecting
disappointed. Thev
to be est
arrested.
Instead tha at
were two
warrants, no arrests, no pison, no th Attempt
any

The Court of martyrdom and were no 4/a) of Warren Hastings'.

Appealrouna
Industrial Court was insufficient.that
the
evidence note on
The accusers

eforestrlkthe.e
short
The Court was unabl Vrite
(ii) (April 09).
with all the sufficiency which is Q4 (b)
uired
before to prove Refer to
evidence, deprivin
his liberty. The Court analyzed the against Joseph?
and felt a man
ng case
Booby's
falls far short of what would be required What is Lady
Therefore, the order of committal was set for sSuch t ii) Refer to Q4.
pu A.
warrants were not executed. aside and sketch of 'Portia' and 'Bassanio'.
the Write character is the heroine of the plaay
3) Read the following passage and Character Sketch of Portia- Portia
answer the questions
au The Merchant of Venice by William Shakespeare.
She is a
given below -
beautiful woman who attacked everybody with her humor,
intelligence and wit. She is full of virtues and all the graces of a
Many studies in recent years have
looked at the perfect wman.
allocation of resoures at the house hold
level, The
reveal that a much greater share of They In the scenes of her choosing her suitors, Portia has intellectual
education,
and food expenditures goes to boys than girls. In
health
many wit, dignity, personality, grace, modesty and wisdom. Some of
cultures, parents think that there are lower benefits from the suitors were conceited and boastful and even they were
investing in girls. This is where vicious circle starts; bores, but Portia keeps her own dignity and does not fail in
leaving many women in a disadvantaged position for lite showing proper courtesy to them.
The losers are not only the women but the entire society
Before her marriage to Bassinio, arrives the
news of
There has been progress in the past few decades. Morn danger. It is Portia then who rises to the occasion. Antonio's
even Bassinio, could None, not
girls in the developing countries are enrolled in Primay have better Antonio's envisaged
Schools. Since 1950s the female labour force has gown And none could have
decided at
danger.
once what
could be done to
twice as fast as the male labour force. Some 30% of the save Antonio from the danger. Her
part of the torma foresight,
ner grasp of realities, her promptitude in her sound sense,
women in the developing coutries are
action,
illustrated anywhere as in the Trial could not have
Deen better
work force. scene.

a) What is the Passage about? eal scene, her

resourcefulness, her insight, her subtle
What do the Parents think in many cultures? eectual power, her accurate
S5ues, her acumen is all understanding of the lega
C) What is the effect of vicious circle on women illustrated. Here she is
dom. Tt is in the trial scene
d) Who
Who are the losers? queen,
Portia shines forth in
are the 0 aress in the past e self. Her intellectual all
been progress
what has favour past few
of
decadesnin
efemales
femac gion, her high honourable powers, her elevated sense ner o
Do you the development
Woman all principles, and her best
here. She maintains at teelin9s
calm self are
country? Why? command, asdisplayed
one sure of
irst
carrying her polnt in the ernda
 96
Namita Law SeriesC Engish- Namita Law SeriesC

in which she 97
uncertaintY ke
heart-thrilling
is not conPs the
"yet painful verges upon dgony, English-
whole until
suspense
ana inevitable. Al Ved b) Write on
any two
effect merely"
it is necessary
in the
first instance are eithee speech
direct ort note on Adam Bede
addressed to Shylock temper and feeli
elings. She w
at
indirect
experiments
on his
to the end d as must be
examining, A. Refer to Q8. Hetty's trial.
from beginning
on his
mind with
understood own wo
of her Mr.
i n t e n s e anxiety,
the effect
that spirit which she hopes and # Do you think Pickwick
would
watching the modern law of evidence? have fared
countenance as
or persuasion.
Her strong exprece aken A. Refer to Q4 (ii) (April 09),.
worse under
either by r e a s o n horror which
to strike as shuddering
are calculated reflection she
through his
interposes, her delay and Comment on the
nerves the
n ii) role of the
time for anyY latent feelina Emergency of 1975. Judiciary during
circumlocution to give pity in the
all a r e neditated and ten AThe
Shylock to display itself,
to the object she
has in view. independence or Juaiciary was severely curtailed
acCOunt of powertul central
same manner on
government ruled by Indian
National Congress. This was during
balanced character. She is the focal point the Indian
Portia is a perfect
force and wit. She is a han
int of (1975-1977) of Indira Gandhi. The constitutional Emergency
ghtness and tenderness, imprisoned persons were rights of
restricted under Preventive
blending of grieve and the gay. She has the quality of the laws passed by the detention
parliament.In the case of
Shiva
ntellect and strength without which she should have become Shukla Additional District Magistrate of Kant
dantic. She has that indefinable charm of manner. The Shukla, popularly known as the Habeas Jabalpur v. Shiv Kant
Corpus case, a bench of
onightness and beneficence of Portia provide an excellenra five senior most judges of
Supreme Court ruled in favour of
contrest with dark, unfortunate and mischief working Shylock. state's right for unrestricted
powers of detention
emergency. Under the declaration of emergency no personduring has
Character Sketch of Bassanio Bassanio is no mere passive any locus to move any writ petition under Article 226 before
a
hero of romance. Good fortunes come to him, but he does nat High Court for habeas corpus or any other writ or order or
wait for it he goes actively in search of it, and he gets it as he direction to challenge the
legality of an order of detention.
ceserves t He is fortune's favorite. He does little for himse
2 t al sorts of tnings are done for him. But he is a The only dissenting opinion was from Justice H. R.
E 2s a 5ympathetic fiber,
gentleman
directness and courage. He is fra
Khanna, who
stated that detention without trial is an anathema to all those
who love personal
to confess t Antonio that he would mend his fortune by liberty. A dissent is an appeal to the
mng aacy nchly left. His emphasis on Portia's fortune s Droodin9 spirit of the law, to the intelligence of a future day,
not due tO
desire or the expectation of his becoming
maste wnen a later decision may possible correct the error into which
ne
e course, but to give Antonio an assurance that there5 dissenting Judge believes the court to have been betrayed.
occ rezs to feel that he will soon be in position to liquida
a nis ceots to his judgment cost his Chief Justice-ship of India. When the
his friend. His open onfession of extravagan agance
central Government is to recommend one of Supreme Court
e very person from whom he is tribut?

soliciting a loan is a
rankness and open heartedness. He is lavish
Judges for the post of Chief Justice in January 1977 Justice
dnna was superseded despite being the most senior Judge at
2
cert. a generous genteman though a fortune seeker; the and thereby Government broke the
convention of
gn a gay e the position of Chier
werd refrement galilant mainly thougn dependant.
He

and delicacY and POInting only the senior most judge tothe other juoges
re eye cf nonour
and rectitude, he stand uSuce of India. In fact, it was felt that The submission ordy dn
Ve gone along for this very reason.
Namita Law Series
98
9

English-
N a m i t aL a w S e r i e s ©

independent judiciary to absolutist Engish-

last step government is virt
in the destruction of a April 2011
Indian Supreme Court's decisiondemocratic societvrtually
and
the
the
surrender. appears close
close to utter not m o r e than two sentences-
Q1. a )
Answer in
Answe

T h e q u a l i ty
of mercy is not straine / It droppeth astthe
During the emergency period, the government also i) ty

39th amendment, which r a i n f r o m heaven

passed
sought to limit judicial review gentle What does the word 'strained' mean
election of the Prime Minister;
only far the Who is
the s p e a k e r ?

Parliament could review this election. The body constituted h

a
here?
Shakespeare's play "The Merchant of
with this curtailment court lines are from
(1975), despite the earlier tamely agreed A These
lines are said by
Portia when she posed as a
decision.
Subsequently, the parliament, with Keshavanand
most
Venice". These
Duke's Court. The
word strain here m e a n s to take
members in jail during the opposition lawyer in
can't be taken out forcefully
out
Amendment which prevented any emergency, passed the 42nd out. Here it m e a n s that mercy

court from heart.

amendment to the constitution with the reviewing any of a person's
issues concerning ratification. As
exception of procedural
I ever beheld, a poor dirty
a final act during the C r e a t u r e almost
emergency, it was stab The ugliest Who is
on the ii) these lines taken?
The Judges were independence
moved helter-skelter
of the High Court. Drab'. From
which e x t r a c t a r e
across the ' c r e a t u r e ' referred
to?
concurrence with Chief Justice. country, in the
from Henry Fielding's
novel 'Joseph Andrews'.

A. These lines are the lady love of Joseph

But the role mentioned is Fanny,
played
by the The creature here
Emergency was remarkable. When High Court judiciary during the of the novel.
in the Andrews, the protagonist
became imperilled,
Parliament let
seventies, democracy in 1973, I thought
it
media. It was only the down the people. So did the wrote my autobiography
fin) When I
Courts had then judiciary that showed guts. All the High and testament.
rejected the was my last will r e f e r r e d to here.
In which year
under the Constitution no government's contention that Name the autobiography
habeas corpus prisoner had a right to move a titled The
petition
when an
Emergency was
was it written?
renowned lawyer
M C Chagla
clamped. A.
The autobiography is of
c) Along with your It was written
in 1973.
resume, write an Roses in December'.
of Accountant in a application for the Post
company looking for fresh for killing him.
outlandish devils
graduates. Address your letter to The young V) she hated these
and the person
who hated
Chemicals Ltd., Mahalaxmi, Manager, Indian Name the
'outlandish
devils'
Mumbai. maid
OR them. mentioned here by
Roxy, the
Write a letter to the devils brothers- Angel
Municipal Commissioner
about illegal construction A The o u t l a n d i s h
Driscoll are two
Italian twin

area.
of houses
and
complaining servant of Judge
who a r e prime
suspects in the c a s e of
shops in your Capello and Luigi
Capello
Judge Driscoll's murder.
d) Write an essay on any one -
i) Why women education is
ii) Students and Discipline. important.
iii) Craze of sports in 21" Century.
 NamitaLaWSeriesG tag).
b) Answer in not more than question

two
sentences Englisth-1 directed r u i n s .
(Add
it?
a

And when we got there, is

in isnt
rise
building

against a bush. there was the Do

as
b u i l d i n g

in
r u i n s ,

high
prisone. d) is the
Who said these ner sitting The building
occurred, building

words? Identify the The

sooner.than). high
rise

Olding'prisoner,
e a r t h q u a k e

the
A. These words are said by John he
No ocCurred,
than

eyewitness in the case and prisoner a

labourer
here is referred
i ) When

d.
(Use
earthquake

Sorrel who had been convicted for the Was sooner

the

born baby. murder of

of h Hety
her newly No
crumbled. legal
t e r m s -

meaning
of the
b e g i n n i n g

ii) Take this little villain away, he's mad Explain

the from
thne
-
faith
l
Who says these word and to whom. Ab
initio
- in
good

fide
A. The agonized Mr Pickwick said these words to his Bona

other iü) mode

Pickwickian friends and was talking about the little

ii') Jus -law

bov Mar
Master
manner,

to
Bardell, the son of his landlady. These lines are from the
a c c o r d i n g

Modus
iv) through,

The Pickwick Papers' by Charles Dickens. novel v)Per - four

on any
briefly Harder.
Write dressing
There a r e many r e a s o n s why I a m not grieved' 2) of
Lomax
good
iii) sketch
thirties.
He had
a
Harder has
Who said t h e s e words?
c h a r a c t e r

Write a man in his wealth.

Lomax

extract of book 'Apology' by Plato, a) is a delicate

These lines a r e from the
Harder moderate
and a
A from the Socrates address to the Jurors after he
A. Lomax

and had
the air
of
forehead,
fair hair with
These lines a r e
appearance
sense
an
e n o r m o u s

in
and corrupting the youth. features, popular in
corresponds

of impiety refined He
w a s found guilty who is very
m a n n e r .

almost
apologetic he is a poet of first
rate
notion of a
poet and is m a t t e r
have made my task an easy one by popular w h e r e poetry and poetic
'Mr. Gandhi you mad world has a kind
iv) to the charge'.
the tiny trifling
his poetic
n a t u r e he
place for
pleading guilty What was Mr. Gandhi being interest. wing
to
feelings. He had special bear
words? can't
these
heart. He felt
for others Lomax
Who spoke them a lot.
heart and respects was
tried for? Session's Judge Mr. Broomfield
w o m e n in his women
and t h a t ' s why
pronounced by with sedition the cruelties done by
people on
was a person of wits
T h e s e words being charged
are
A. was friend's wife. He the end.
Trial. Mr. Gandhi towards his till
Gandhi's sympathetic not caught
at India. murder and w a s no
in Young and grit. He attempted accordingly leaving
for his article and planned so
indirect speech. He thought intelligently no e x c i t e m e n t and kept his cool HIS
in said. Dehind. He showed morbid.
Rewrite the following Miss
Chowdhury

Magistrate
Es him. He was not
suspect the
c) do noting
for you? s a i d the nat no one can
Although he regretted
we case', c a n t d o anyl was not askew.
Can
to defend your
t h a t why
they PEspective of things twinge of Consclence
ds
T h i s is n o w a y dismay of his act, he felt no better
s a i d in ECEssity was
surely t
Chowdhury to derend to him s o m e o n e has to die and
A. Miss way
no raing enchanting, martyrised
brute should die than a heavenly,
was
that
for himn.
told him
that dt à of passion and couldn't
bear

The
Magistrate
reature. Lomax Harder was a man
wds d i w oy*
nice people and
and cruelty against
case. ne coarseness
ready to help them out.
 English-
Namita Law Series©
102 103

arson Adam's conversation

A. When Parson NonnitaLawSeries

him of having Adams came to meet

with
th Lady Booby.
Engish-1 the
C o u r t .

turned off her ungratefully shown Lady Booby faceof q u e s t i o n s

household
match between him for his respect to she accused In
the Q18. answer
the

misdeeds, anda fellaw

to and

said that and an llow wh0 had A.

Refer
passage

the girl
he had never
heard any apparently well-bred promotir
of
the
ffo
olll
loowing

Joseph aiong
the in
was harm of
parish. Lady concerned,
g i v e n b e l o w -

Read championships
she was the
Booby was and: as fardamsas 3) that
cricket
20
Country wench and enraged to he
she wouldhear him talk
handsomest woman fitness
of t hings
in
f o r m a t today
-
t h e Twenty

beauty again. She saidsaid

subcontinent
n in the
in
the
exci citing in the
of I tis staged
she be sick
did not want if beaut
she heuty in a is the
most

wil be
will h o s t the n e x t
produce vagabonds. Adams said that her to get marrl
what

of
t h efive years. Sri Lanka will
game

followeed by
consummate long ago, and he
the
hadcouple
do
of rersion

for the next

in 2012,
for
desiredand0
The lady said that was is n a t u r a l
2016. It
championship

the sole
in cause and India in
publishing
the banns of delavis fans a r e . The
s c h e d u l e d

performing
no more
his office. The
lady said that he he wasaying it, Bangladesh in in 2 0 1 4
scheduled
where m o s t of its
decision only
without her orders. would puhlich y matches to be C r i c k e t Council (ICC)
assigned a Adams answered that them
International
the largest
proper reason anvan fact t h a t cricket
generates
stop. One reason, Lady against them, he would if
reinforces the a T20 cricket
Booby said, was that be willing ta in South Asia. Hosting
vagabond and would Joseph was revenues and profits
proposition. I t c a n n o t be
beauties. Adams produce a n expensive
a nest of is
were beggars championship
referred to even if thev viable.
him that anyone who
served a year
Lawyer Scout who had told done if it is
not economically
the parish in which he gained a
served. Lawyer Scout settlement from format
to the writer is the most exciting
coxcomb, cried Lady Booby, and ordered was an impudent a) What according
further. But Parson Adams him to produce today?
no
said that he would kept standing there b)Wherewill the Twenty 20 version be staged in the n e a r
obey her in all that was lawful,undaunted. He
but even the feature?
poor had their rights. The lady threatened
dared to publish the banns to remove him if he
again. But Adams replied that as
c)Whowill host the championship after Sri Lanka?
d) What does the Crickets Council's decision reinforce?
long his conscience was
as
pure, he was not afraid of anything
that man could do to him. She
ordered him to leave, telling him
e)Whatis an expensive proposition?
)When is this not economically
that her doors were not
open to a person who ran about the advantageous?
COuntry with beauties. Adams said that he was sure she would b) Make sentences
with any three of the
not blame him when she had
enquired into the matter further. following
Commitment, Conviction, objectionable,
c) Refusing to Answer.
AccessoryY. Interpretation,
A. Refer to Q18. 4(a) Attempt any two -

d) Disobedience to an order of the court.

A. Refer to
Discuss
A.
Refer to Soapy's adventures in
Q18. Q22. The Cop and the
Anthem.
e) Prejudicing a fair trial. An Analyze
A. Refer to Q18.
A.
Refer to Shakespeare'
Q1. s presentation
presentation of
of Shylock.
Shylock
 Namita Law Series© English I
104
105
iii) Discuss Socrates to her
A. Refer to defer of NamitaLawS e r i e s disproportionate

Q12. himself at his tria Engidh.j guilt

are so stly
vast
representative
of suffering
of her ains a s a
b) Write
r e m a i r
vences
she
on any two -
consequ that
nsibility

disaffection
i) his
Comment on humanity. for
Refer to Q10. Puddn'head Wilson's
reasons

A. Gandhi's
G andh
defense of- borate
on

the twins,.
a g a i n s t t h e B r i t i s h .

ii) Discuss Hetty Sorrel mi)

14.
as Q for thhe
A. Adam Bede is story of represented Refer
to
an application
ata, write s o l i c i t o r s .
central figure HettyY Sorrel's by Georae eEliot. with your bio-dat

a firm
of
Address the
of the novel and one sufferings and to
8, Mumbai.
female figures 0 . Box No.
a s s i s t a n t

c) Along

of the novelist of sh
the mact of legal India, P.
George Eliot. Sthe of
a
beautiful, bewitching, She is
Dresen
p o s

to The
Times

story of Hetty's intensely human

s a m e

betrayal
is timid and character, The OR
Commissioner regarding

She is
conventional. whole letter to
the Municipal
a
young girl of seventeen, of write a
w a t e r supply.
Hetty beautiful but her beauty isexceptional physical charn
is the
inadequate

the softness and

beauty of deceptively soft. She h any one
-

hardness. She is so hard and Loamshire but also its corerhas

on
essay environment.
to protect the
Write an
d) individual c a n do
instinct of self-centered of What an cards.
she could eventhat,
of credit
self-preservation,
Like young beautiful kill
moved by her
Advantages and
disadvantages
girls of seventeen, Hetty washer own child, code in colleges.
vain. She was quite conscious frivolous and ii) Dress
of the fact
admirers, and this had made her vain andshe had a number of Nov 2011
was a
sparkling, self-centered. Hers
self-engrossed loveliness. Her dreams were all
of luxuries and fineries. She was
vain and coquettish. She
knew Answer in not m o r e than two
sentences any three of
that Adam was the best and most Q1. (a)
suitable of her admirers, but the following-(6 Marks)
she had no wish to marry him for he is
poor and unable to i) "This isno answer, thou unfeeling men".
provide her with fineries which she loved, but still she took care Who is speaker and who the 'unfeeling man'?
to rekindle his admiration and
encourage him. When she lost all A. Bassinio said these words and the unfeeling man is Shylock.
hopes of Arthur coming back to her and Also Adam was doing
well in his life and was on his way to prosperity, she agreed tu i) "Let me lead down the stairs".
marry him. She thinks of her own well being, of the gratification Identify the speaker of these words.
of her own desires, and no thought of Adam's happiness enters A. of the members of the
Une Pickwick Club, Mr. Tupman said
into her head, so egocentric and self centered she was. these words.

But poor, beautiful Hetty was destined to face great pain an m left the prisoner sitting by the fire in the
her lovely dreams ended in tragedy. Whatever might be u no said these words? From which extract kitchen".
lines taken. are these
novelists' intentions, we are not any time positlvely consod
or Hetty being a criminal, with the crime killing her own
*nese lines are from
George Eliot's 'Adam Bede' and thee
upon her head. She was an innocent victim
of circumst the Ker of these words is Mrs. Sarah
is not absolutely innocent, Du witnesses Stone, one of the
beyond her control. Hetty
Namita Law Series

106 107
iv) "I
Who impeach him in the
A. Referis the person to be name of the NaniaLwSeriest came to a
the trial
to Q1
(b) (i) (Nov Enalist
English
impeached? directed-(2
M a r k s )

w i t h d r a w
w i t h d r a w n ,

(b) Answer in ot 08). nation" d )D oa s

ne
as
he
s
were
w e r e

No s o o n e r . . . . t h a n
c h a r g e s

n) han the
tha
trial came to a

more than
w i t h d r a w n

i) following-(6 Marks) were

two sente ) Whe

entences
close.( U s e

charges
I know aner the
the
that I am any three
sooner
(Add
A.
On which
occasion playing with fire. of the A.
No
their
destination.

Gandhiji said these were reached

CIose

these words have

before his sentence. words during utteres
ng his uttered?
hould
destination,
haven't they?
their
trial at They
question t a g )
reached
ii) "Seervai and I
have not Ahemadadabad, They
should
have
terms- (4 Marks)
Who is the always A. legal

phrase 'eye
speaker
to eye'?
of s
these
e
seen eye
words
words to
eye.
( e Explain
) tthe
he
lain
following

per day
criminal act
A. The speaker and what diem- commit a
whom
of these is mea Per
to
to those to
eant by who is acceptable
words is
Suborned-procured

autobiography-heldRoses in December.
not agree
M C
Chaga, Perso
grata-
a person

or
differing opinions. 'Eye to eye' means thoin his he is sent
testimony
they voce- by oral
iii) "And now, 0 men who
Viva
under
consideration

have Sub judice-

Who is condemned
man
condemned me" Marks)
condemned? and by whom Write briefly
on
any four-(20
A. was h
he 2 .
Socrates is the
condemned Franting.
man and was Benett's presentation of
fellow Athenian Meletus. condemned
Ondemned by a) Discuss
by his Q23.
A. Refer to
iv) "I know not what
and Service".
your Ladyship means by terms Master b) Lawyer Scout's view
on law.
A. Refer to Q5.
Under what circumstances are
A. This conversation is
these words spoken?
between Lady Booby and Paul Adams c)Contemptof Court with regard to the case of laughing
regarding the questions asked by Lady Bobby about the bans gas.
he has announced in the Church about the A. Refer to
marriage of Joseph Q2 (d) (Nov 08).
and Fanny.
d)A. The victimization of witness.
(c) Rewrite the following in indirect speech-(2 Marks) Refer of Q18.
The Judge said, "Mr Mahmoud Ali, I have already warne
you, and unless you sit down I shall exercise m eDisobedience
A. Refer
to
to an order of the Court.
authority." Q18.
A. The Judge warned Mr Mahmoud Ali that he had already warme
him and unless he sat down, he shall exercise his
authont. Wardship
A. Unde proceedings.
head of
disobedience to an order of Court there are
Where a
newspaper publishes a report of proceedings
r e held in private. Most
ara in
public and there is no cases are and are bound to be
bar to fair and accurate
report or
 Namita Law Serieso
108
109

them. But some cases they were in

held in
are NomitaLowSeries©
that
guilty of contempt of
e.
Court if it private and a
Particularly is this the publishes
Eogidh- as
to
warrant
a finding
findi

newspaper is
heir part such

which are usually held in case in report of what todk

ware
contempt o f c o u r t ,

answer the
case reported as Re F, A private. The point passage and
He gave her
drugs and
knowing that she was
girl of 15 ran awav arose in 1976
had
sexual intercou a man of28,
proceedin (a)
R e a d
the
following

below. (6
Marks)

that they applied for heronly

given
15. Her 03. followvi
werese soWIth
with her, questions of the
made parents
to be three
with
Make sentences wi any
girl was placed in a a
stel. A sOcial ward of wOrrled
man of 28 should be
worker COurt. The commencement
Telegraph got to know ofallowe
alternative,
her advised that the
) M

to visit Marks) persuaded,

this
Jailed lover should visit
thought
and
published there. The
hos article
Th Daly
an
Solidarity

that this article girl. The Official neaded,

evidence

which had taken place in disclosed some of the (14 Marks)

private. He moved ro Solic
two-

Daily Telegraph for olicitor 04. (a)

Attempt any
Mareva
Injunction as a great piece of judicial
contempt. to cor
contempt. But Court of Lords, The Judge held that the i)
Discus
the

reform.
reversed it. headed by Lord t
to Q19.
Den A. Refer
They said, thereare cases to on O'Henry's presentation of Soapy.
court of show that it ) Comment
publish
information relating to
was a
contemot
of A. Refer to Q22.
about a ward as the
court is entitled to proceedings
in cout
The public hear the case in detective.
and the
newspaper reporters private. i) Discuss Austin Bond as a

inside. Only are

their legal advisorsnot admitted
the A. Refer to Q24.
parties,
immediately concerned were allowed in. When and those
the Court sat in
private to hear wardship proceedings, the (b) Attempt any two- (14 Marks)
with it a very sitting caried i) How did Shylock conduct his own defense?
prohibition
forbidding publication of anything that took A. Refer to Q1.
place. When a newspaper editor publishes information which
relates to wardship
proceedings, he may or may not be aware
that there is prohibition
i) Comment on the evidence
against publication. In order to be Wilson. put forth by Pudd'nhead
found guilty the accused must have had mind A. Refer to
a guilty Some
Q10.
guilty knowledge or intent.
In this case the
What
A. Refer arguments did Socrates produce at his trial?
parents told the Daily Telegraph that to
Q12.
wardship order had been temporary one and that
expired. The newspaper thought that there was no longera c) an
prohibition on publication. They made inquirles at the application
for the
position of Junior Executive
no one at the
council without getting enlightenment and the
multinational
ress firm and also
your letter to include your resume.
Solicitor office told them that the girl was ward of the coura
the
Mumbai. (10 marks) the Editor, The Hindustan Times,
Finding no prohibition, they published the informationt0 Write a letter OR
Circumstances, there was not any guilty knowledge o
complainin
onthe about the
to
your
neighborhood Corporator
streets where illeg parking of autorickshaws
you live.