Professional Documents
Culture Documents
The Wall Street Journal March 02 2022
The Wall Street Journal March 02 2022
KYIV, Ukraine—Russian
their highest level since 2014, forces, frustrated in plans for
as Russia’s invasion of Ukraine a quick victory, shifted to a
continued to whipsaw through new strategy of pummeling ci-
markets. The S&P 500, Dow vilian areas in an attempt to
and Nasdaq slid 1.5%, 1.8% demoralize Ukrainian resis-
and 1.6%, respectively. B1 tance and reignite their slow-
ing military advance.
Exxon Mobil said it is
Russia’s Defense Ministry
halting operations at a mul-
said Tuesday afternoon it
tibillion-dollar oil and gas
would strike Ukrainian intelli-
project in Russia and will
gence and communications fa-
make no further invest-
cilities in central Kyiv that it
ments in the country. A10
said are being used for “infor-
The U.S. and other major
mation attacks” against Rus-
oil-consuming nations said
sia, and urged residents living
they would release 60 mil-
nearby to leave for their own
lion barrels of oil from their
safety.
PAVEL DOROGOY/ASSOCIATED PRESS
Biden said Putin is more lated from the rest of the would roll over. Instead he met Ukraine to the U.S., attended as
isolated from the rest of the world than ever after invading a wall of strength he never a guest of first lady Jill Biden.
world than ever after invad- Ukraine, using Tuesday’s State imagined,” Mr. Biden said in The president addressed
ing Ukraine, using the State of the Union address to high- his speech to a joint session of the nation as Russia shifted to
of the Union address to light the coordinated response Congress. a new strategy of pummeling
highlight the coordinated re- of the U.S. and its allies and In addition to sanctions, Mr. civilian areas, part of a cam-
sponse of the U.S. and allies rally the country behind de- Biden said the U.S. would close paign by Moscow that has
and rally the country behind fending democracy. American airspace to all Rus- prompted the U.S. and other
defending democracy. A1 Mr. Biden said Mr. Putin sian flights and assemble a nations to take steps to isolate
President Biden addressing the joint session of Congress Tuesday. “sought to shake the founda- Justice Department task force Please turn to page A4
The U.S. will ban Rus-
sian aircraft from American
airspace, Biden said during
the address, broadening Greg Ip: Sanctions bring U.S. faces hurdles to In a Kyiv hospital, Exxon halts investments Stocks fall further as
aviation restrictions as the real pain, and risks sending in weapons children suffer doubly in Russia oil tops $100
West expands sanctions A2 A6 A7 A10 B1
over the war in Ukraine. A6
Republican Gov. Abbott
MLB Cancels Games INSIDE
Salesforce.
and former Democratic
presidential candidate
O’Rourke won their respec-
tive primaries in Texas, the As Labor Talks Stall
AP said, setting up a high-
profile race for governor. A3
The Pfizer-BioNTech BY JARED DIAMOND had made enough headway
during a marathon session
#1 CRM.
Ranked #1 for CRM Applications based on
Covid-19 vaccine was highly
JUPITER, Fla.—The first two Monday to justify further dis- IDC 2021 H1 Revenue Market Share Worldwide.
effective at reducing the risk
series of the Major League cussions.
of severe disease in children
Baseball regular season have But progress stalled Tuesday
17 years and younger during
been canceled after owners and on the economic issues at the
the Omicron surge but didn’t
work as well at preventing
locked-out players failed to core of the dispute, prompting PERSONAL JOURNAL
agree on a new labor contract the parties to break off talks Some interns are
infection, a study found. A3
ahead of a management-im- with no immediate plans to re-
Fallout from federal judges posed deadline. sume. After convening for nine
changing their minds
violating financial-conflict Opening day had been consecutive days at a spring as recruiters present
laws is spreading to appeals scheduled for March 31. training stadium here, the sides sweeter deals. A15
courts, which now have to “We worked hard to avoid will now retrench and figure
decide whether wiping out an outcome that’s bad for our out next steps.
VICTOR J. BLUE/BLOOMBERG NEWS
rulings is warranted. A4 fans, bad for our players and The gridlock has stoked the
bad for our clubs,” MLB com- possibility of a prolonged dis-
CONTENTS Personal Journal A15-16 missioner Rob Manfred said. “I pute that extends far beyond
Arts in Review... A17 Property Report... B6
Business News.. B3,5 Sports....................... A18 want to assure our fans that what Mr. Manfred announced
Crossword.............. A18 Technology............... B4 our failure to reach an agree- Tuesday.
Heard on Street. B12 U.S. News............. A2-4 ment was not due to a lack of “A lockout is the ultimate
Markets..................... B11 Weather................... A18 Source: IDC, Worldwide Semiannual Software Tracker, October 2021.
Opinion.............. A19-21 World News A6-14,22
effort by either party.” economic weapon,” union exec-
MLB had previously indi- utive director Tony Clark said.
cated if a deal wasn’t in place “In a $10 billion industry, the
> by the end of February, it owners have made a conscious BUSINESS & FINANCE
would begin taking down decision to use this weapon Many big companies
games with no intention to re- against the greatest asset they
schedule them or compensate have: the players.”
are planning broader salesforce.com/number1CRM
players. The league agreed to The players always viewed office reopenings this CRM market includes the following IDC-defined functional markets: Sales Force Productivity and Management,
Marketing Campaign Management, Customer Service, Contact Center, Advertising, and Digital Commerce
s 2022 Dow Jones & Company, Inc.
All Rights Reserved keep negotiating until 5 p.m. MLB’s deadline as an artificial month. B1 Applications. © 2021 salesforce.com, inc. All rights reserved. Salesforce.com is a registered trademark of
salesforce.com, inc., as are other names and marks.
U.S. NEWS
CAPITAL ACCOUNT | By Greg Ip
T
to unfold with smaller rogue to buy up the ruble to defend Source: CEIC Data he war and accompa- In the end, a Russia kicked
states like Iran and North its value, pay interest and nying sanctions are al- out of the global economy is
Korea. A Biden administra- principal on foreign debt, or at the Institute of Interna- will increase that burden. ready threatening an- also a Russia beyond the
tion official on Saturday supply foreign currency to tional Finance, predicted Rus- The long-run cost to Rus- other supply shock that slows reach of economic leverage.
made the goal clear: turn commercial banks. Russian sia’s economy will contract at sia will be even steeper. growth and raises inflation in China is likely to respond by
Russia into “a global, eco- importers can’t be certain least 10%, more than in 1998. Western prohibitions on Europe and the U.S., and stepping up its own efforts to
nomic, and financial pariah.” anyone will take their money. Russia is still cushioned by sales of technology will “un- that’s without an embargo on decouple from the West; it is
The fall in the ruble since its hefty exports of oil and dermine the capabilities of Russian oil and natural gas. already developing alterna-
A
nd yet as with actual Russia invaded Ukraine could gas, which are largely ex- the Russian military and ci- Refiners and banks are avoid- tives to the dollar-based pay-
war, all-out economic add 4 to 5 percentage points empted by sanctions. That vilian industry, restrain the ing Russian crude nonethe- ment systems, domestic
war has repercussions to Russian inflation, which cushion has limits, growth potential of the less, pushing prices sharply sources of key technology
that the U.S. and its allies stood at 8.7% in January, ac- though: Russian oil is now economy, and increase Rus- higher Tuesday. As the ef- through President Xi Jin-
may not yet see. It is not at cording to Sergey Aleksash- selling at a sizable discount, sia’s technological backward- fects filter down to the pub- ping’s “dual circulation” pol-
all clear that sanctions will enko, a former Russian cen- and global prices, now more ness,” Mr. Aleksashenko lic, the remarkable unity of icy, and its own economic
change Mr. Putin’s behavior, tral bank official now living in than $100 per barrel, are at wrote in a newsletter. Western governments against sphere of influence through
and they may cause far- the U.S. To defend the cur- risk if the world economy While sanctions are prov- Russia will be tested. the Belt and Road Initiative.
reaching disruption for the rency and limit the inflation- slumps. Russia already ing more devastating than Sanctions have rarely The global economy was
West. ary impact, the central bank spends more of its gross do- thought likely before this forced the targeted country subdividing into competing
Since 2014, when Russia raised interest rates Monday mestic product on the mili- week, their full consequences to change its behavior. Auto- blocs before Russia invaded
was hit with targeted sanc- to 20% from 9.5%. Elina Riba- tary than the U.S. and a sus- may not be apparent. Kicking crats like Mr. Putin simply Ukraine. Sanctions are simply
tions for annexing Crimea, kova, deputy chief economist tained insurgency in Ukraine such a large economy out of aren’t that exposed to their hastening the process.
U.S. WATCH
U.S. Policy
MICHIGAN
Baby Formula Recall
after an unusually dry January.
A nearly 15-mile stretch of
State Route 7 in Washington
On China
Expands After Death
Abbott Laboratories is ex-
was shut down Tuesday because
of severe flooding and there was
no estimate on when it would re-
Trade to Be
panding its previously announced
recall of baby formula after be-
ing informed of the death of an-
open. A number of ski resorts on
Oregon’s Mount Hood shut down
Monday due to heavy rain and
Realigned
other infant who consumed the high winds. BY YUKA HAYASHI
company’s product. Olympia, Wash., and the Seat-
Abbott said this week that it tle area exceeded rainfall records WASHINGTON—The Biden
was voluntarily recalling one lot Monday set in 1972, while parts administration said it is re-
of Similac PM 60/40 manufac- of northwest Oregon got nearly 3 aligning its trade policy to-
tured in its Sturgis, Mich., plant. inches of rain. ward China, looking at all ex-
Last month, the company re- Flood watches were in effect isting tools and potentially
called its Similac, Alimentum and throughout the region Tuesday new ones to combat Beijing’s
EleCare products that are pro- and authorities asked home- state-led nonmarket practices.
duced at the same plant. owners to be aware of the possi- In its annual trade policy
This comes after another in- bility of landslides, particularly in agenda released Tuesday, the
fant died from an illness that areas that have recently burned Office of the U.S. Trade Repre-
the Food and Drug Administra- in wildfires. sentative said the U.S. is rais-
tion is investigating as part of —Associated Press ing its concerns with China
the recall. and accelerating joint work
The FDA said it is investigat- NEW MEXICO with allies and partners.
ing complaints of four “We are clear-eyed about
cronobacter illnesses and one Bill Signed Giving China’s doubling down on its
salmonella illness that resulted Teachers Raises harmful trade and economic
in infant hospitalizations as early abuses,” the USTR said in the
as September in Minnesota, New Mexico’s governor report, noting that its “holistic
Texas and Ohio. signed law four bills into law and pragmatic” approach to
Cronobacter illnesses, which that will increase funding for ed- the bilateral relations will fo-
include sepsis and meningitis, ucation, including major in- cus on long-term benefits for
are rare but can be lethal for in- creases in teacher salaries. American workers.
fants, according to the Centers Democratic Gov. Michelle Lu- “Lack of protections for
for Disease Control and Preven- jan Grisham held the ceremony workers, a weak environmental
tion. Salmonella can cause fever Tuesday outdoors at an elemen- regime, and anticompetitive
and digestive issues, and some- tary school in Santa Fe, follow- subsidies are the hallmarks of
times severe illness, according to ing the passage of the bills by China’s artificial comparative
the CDC. the Legislature last month. She advantage. It is an advantage
Recalled products were previ- signed one bill that will increase that puts others out of busi-
ously distributed across the U.S. teacher and counselor salary ness and violates any notion of
as well as some international minimums by $10,000. fair competition,” it said.
markets, according to the FDA. “We have to pay our educa- Chinese Embassy spokesman
Abbott said it tests for tors a salary that is commensu- Liu Pengyu said: “China and the
pathogens including cronobacter rate with their incredible…experi- U.S. share common interests,
and salmonella before releasing ence, education and the fact and cooperation is the only
MIKE BLAKE/REUTERS
its products. A spokeswoman that they are working more than right choice. It is hoped that the
said Tuesday that none of Ab- full time supporting their stu- U.S. adopt reasonable and prac-
bott’s distributed products dents,” Ms. Lujan Grisham said. tical China trade policies...and
tested positive for the presence Currently, teachers make at push China-U.S. relations back
of cronobacter or salmonella. least $40,000 when they start onto the correct track of sound
—Omar Abdel-Baqui PRICKLY SITUATION: Percy the Porcupine, a giant puppet built to promote a new area at the San out, $50,000 after additional train- and stable development.”
Diego Zoo, was unveiled to schoolchildren in Los Angeles on Tuesday. ing and experience, and $60,000 While the USTR emphasized
CALIFORNIA when they pass an intensive mas- it is “laser-focused” on en-
ing order against him requested fore turning the gun on himself, PACIFIC NORTHWEST ter teacher certification. Starting gagement with friendly nations
Man Kills His 3 Kids, by the children’s mother, was on Mr. Jones said. teachers and counselors earning a as a key part of its strategy,
Adult in Church a supervised visit with his chil- “If he was the person in a do- Record Rains Bring minimum salary would benefit the the agency provided few de-
dren at the church during the mestic violence restraining order, Floods, Road Closure most, with a 22% raise. tails on what measures consti-
A California man shot and shooting, Sacramento County he shouldn’t have had a Ms. Lujan Grisham, who is tuted its realigned policy. Nei-
killed his three children, an adult Sheriff Scott Jones said. weapon,” the sheriff said. Heavy rain brought flooding running for re-election this year, ther did it offer details on the
and himself in a Sacramento- The suspect killed the person The mother of the children and concerns about landslides to is also set to approve a $15 min- administration’s plan to launch
area church Monday, law-en- supervising the visit and the wasn’t at the church during the the Pacific Northwest, with many imum wage for school and state a broad economic program for
forcement officials said. three children, who were all shooting, police said. locations in western Oregon and workers. the Asia-Pacific region.
The man, who had a restrain- younger than 15 years old, be- —Omar Abdel-Baqui Washington getting record rainfall —Associated Press The new Indo-Pacific Eco-
nomic Framework, announced
by President Biden in October, is
THE WALL STREET JOURNAL
(USPS 664-880) (Eastern Edition ISSN 0099-9660)
CORRECTIONS AMPLIFICATIONS eagerly awaited by some Asian
allies and U.S. businesses to fill
(Central Edition ISSN 1092-0935) (Western Edition ISSN 0193-2241)
the gap left by Washington’s
Editorial and publication headquarters: 1211 Avenue of the Americas, New York, N.Y. 10036
Russia has a $1.7 trillion nanosatellite maker AAC Clyde rately compared the use of the 2017 departure from the Trans-
Published daily except Sundays and general legal holidays. economy. A Page One article Space as ACC in one instance. Flair Pro 2 to the firing and
Periodicals postage paid at New York, N.Y., and other mailing offices.
Pacific Partnership, a regional
Monday about sanctions cleaning of a bayonet. Bayonets trade agreement designed as a
Postmaster: Send address changes to The Wall Street Journal,
200 Burnett Rd., Chicopee, MA 01020. against Russia incorrectly said Hong Kong’s flagship Hang do not have the capacity to be counterweight to China. The
All Advertising published in The Wall Street Journal is subject to the applicable rate card, $1.7 billion. Seng Index ended Monday at fired, nor do they need to be USTR said it will release details
copies of which are available from the Advertising Services Department, Dow Jones & Co. Inc., its lowest closing level since cleaned in order to be reused. “in the near future.” Some top
1211 Avenue of the Americas, New York, N.Y. 10036. The Journal reserves the right not to A Virginia couple died March 2020. In some editions U.S. business groups jointly
accept an advertiser’s order. Only publication of an advertisement shall constitute final
acceptance of the advertiser’s order. when their car was hit by a Tuesday, a Markets article urged the administration last
Letters to the Editor: Fax: 212-416-2891; email: wsj.ltrs@wsj.com vehicle driven by an on-duty about FWD Group Holdings Notice to readers week to move forward this year
Need assistance with your subscription?
sheriff’s deputy. A headline in Ltd. filing for an initial public Some Wall Street Journal with the framework.
By web: customercenter.wsj.com; By email: wsjsupport@wsj.com Monday’s U.S. Watch incorrectly offering incorrectly said the in- staff members are working re- The USTR report comes as
By phone: 1-800-JOURNAL (1-800-568-7625) said the deputy was off duty. dex reached that level Feb. 22. motely during the pandemic. pressure builds on the admin-
Reprints & licensing: Please send reader comments istration to articulate its China
By email: customreprints@dowjones.com
By phone: 1-800-843-0008
A Heard on the Street col- An Off Duty article Satur- only by email or phone, using trade policy and respond to
umn Saturday about space day about espresso makers in- the contacts below, not via China’s failure to meet its
WSJ back issues and framed pages: wsjshop.com
stocks incorrectly referred to cluded a quote that inaccu- U.S. Mail. pledges to sharply increase
Our newspapers are 100% sourced from sustainably certified mills.
purchases of U.S. products un-
GOT A TIP FOR US? SUBMIT IT AT WSJ.COM/TIPS Readers can alert The Wall Street Journal to any errors in news articles by emailing wsjcontact@wsj.com or by calling der a bilateral agreement
888-410-2667. signed in early 2020.
.
U.S. NEWS
governor, according to the Asso- Mr. Paxton’s rivals sought to wide election in Texas since an
ciated Press. make an issue of the fact that election bill passed last year
Mr. Abbott, who is seeking a he has been under indictment that tightened voting procedures
U.S. shareholders third term, and Mr. O’Rourke on securities-fraud charges across the state. Democrats said
accused a Chinese were heavy favorites in Tues- since 2015 and in 2020 was ac- the bill would disenfranchise
day’s primaries, the first of the cused of illegal activities by voters. Republicans said it would
investor of hollowing 2022 midterm elections. The pri- eight of his top-ranking depu- make elections more secure.
out Icon Aircraft. maries are deciding many of the ties. He has denied wrongdoing Before the election, and dur-
matchups for statewide offices in both incidents. ing two weeks of early voting,
and Texas’ 38 congressional dis- Signs proliferated outside a polling site Tuesday in Austin, Texas. In Buda, a rapidly growing the state’s largest counties re-
tricts. Several contests are being suburb south of Austin, Kris ported a significant uptick in re-
in water with a wave height closely watched for what they keep it that way, because our support of New York Rep. Alex- Viehe, a 58-year-old Republi- jections of both mail-in ballot
higher than 12 inches. say about the state of the Demo- opponents, they want a com- andria Ocasio-Cortez and other can voter, said Mr. Paxton’s in- applications and ballots them-
Cfius began its review of cratic and Republican parties as pletely different Texas.” figures in the party’s progressive dictment, as well as insight selves. Most of the rejections
PDSTI’s investment in late No- they vie for control of Congress. The second-term governor wing, lost by fewer than 3,000 from friends who work in the were due to voters missing an
vember after the group of Speaking to a crowd of sup- fended off two primary oppo- votes to Mr. Cuellar in the 2020 attorney general’s office, led identification number on the
American shareholders urged it porters in the Fort Worth area, nents, former state Sen. Don primary. him to vote for Mr. Bush. ballot that matched what they
to intervene, the Journal has Mr. O’Rourke said: “I want to Huffines and ex-Texas GOP The two candidates have con- “We’ve got to get rid of Pax- provided when they registered,
reported. be a governor for each and ev- chairman Allen West, who at- trasting positions on immigra- ton,” Mr. Viehe said. election officials said. The state
“Based upon its review and ery single one of you, and I tempted to run to his right on tion—and how to win in a bor- Joe Box, a 47-year-old GOP has also seen a marked decrease
investigation, and after full want us to do the big things we several issues. der district that includes areas voter, said Mr. Paxton’s legal in mail voting overall, particu-
consideration of all relevant are truly capable of, once we Beyond the governor’s race, where Republicans made in- troubles don’t bother him. “I’m larly among Republicans.
national security factors…Cfius get past the smallness and cru- early results showed a tight race roads in 2020. An FBI raid of Mr. pretty sure they’re trying to get In Texas, as in several states
has determined that there are elty and divisiveness of this in the Democratic primary in Cuellar’s home and campaign of- rid of him because he’s doing this election cycle, partisan
no unresolved national security moment.” Texas’ 28th Congressional Dis- fice in January is also hanging such a good job,” Mr. Box said. congressional primaries will
concerns,” the letter said, add- In Corpus Christi, Mr. Abbott trict between lawyer Jessica Cis- over the race. He has said he is Voters in the Democratic pri- play an outsize role in deciding
ing that action with respect to said, “We’re building a safer, neros and nine-term Rep. Henry cooperating with the probe. . mary said they hoped Mr. the general election because
the deal “is concluded.” smarter, freer and more pros- Cuellar, one of the party’s most On the Republican side, At- O’Rourke would get enough once-a-decade redistricting has
The letter, dated Monday, perous state for everybody.” He conservative members. Ms. Cis- torney General Ken Paxton ad- momentum to succeed in the reduced the number of compet-
was sent by the Treasury De- added, “But we have to fight to neros, who has attracted the vanced to a May runoff, AP general election, and they criti- itive House seats.
partment, which leads the
Cfius panel, to a lawyer for the
Chinese investors. A person
close to the Chinese investors
said the panel didn’t require
California Faces Higher Risk
Of Fires After Two Dry Months
them to sign on to any mitiga-
tion agreement to resolve na-
350+
tional-security issues. P R I VAT E R E S I D E N C E S
An Icon spokesman said:
“We’re pleased to confirm that BY JIM CARLTON estly models never would have
after a monthslong, thorough,
Percentage of California
predicted before,” said David 75
and comprehensive investiga- California’s snowpack has
snowpack on March 1st for
each year compared to normal Rizzardo, hydrology section S O U G H T-AF T E R D E ST I N AT I O N S
tion, Cfius has cleared PDSTI’s shrunk to about two-thirds of manager for the state water
investment in ICON Aircraft.” normal, as the state’s relent- 200% agency.
The Treasury Department less drought produced the dri-
2022
Now, California will have to 1
declined to comment. Mr. Haw- est January and February on
63%
once again brace for two of MEMBERSHIP
kins and a lawyer for the record and raised the likeli- the major consequences of
American shareholders didn’t hood of more wildfires and 150 drought: heightened wildfire
respond to requests for com- deeper water cuts to cities and danger and diminished water
ment on this article. farms. supplies. After 2.6 million
“The most interesting thing A manual survey conducted Normal acres burned last year and a
100 level
to me is that, in this climate, Tuesday by the state Depart- record 4.3 million in 2020,
getting anything through Cfius ment of Water Resources state officials say this year
with a China angle is a chal- showed a snowfield near Lake could be just as bad because
lenge. If there’s a meaningful Tahoe was at 68% of normal. 50 new grass and brush started
element of sensitive technology Electronic readings of snow growing during December and
that is credible, then it’s very across the Sierra Nevada quickly turned dry—a flamma-
unlikely to get through Cfius range, which supplies much of ble combination.
without mitigation,” said John California’s water when it 0 Temperatures have been
Kabealo, founder of Washing- melts, stood at 63% of normal 2002 ’05 ’10 ’15 ’20 above normal, too, with San
ton, D.C., firm Kabealo Law, for March 1. With forecasts Source: California Cooperative Snow Surveys
Francisco recording daytime
which wasn’t involved in the showing no major storms on highs of 2.2 degrees higher
Icon case. the horizon, state officials ex- shriveled, as a high pressure than normal in January and
Icon earlier alleged that Mr. pressed little hope that March ridge moved into place along 3.5 higher in February, accord-
Hawkins has been motivated by would make up for the deficit the coast and deflected ing to the National Weather
self-interest. The company re- by the time the California wet storms. Service. Besides raising the
leased to the Journal what it season ends in April. Downtown San Francisco fire danger, Mr. Rizzardo said
said was a strategy document “It’s safe to say we will end recorded 0.65 inches of rain in the warmer temperatures are
emailed by Mr. Hawkins in this [water] year dry,” Sean de January and February, com- melting snow before it can run
March 2020 outlining a plan to Guzman, manager of the pared with a normal of 8.77 off into the state’s reservoirs
threaten to take the case to agency’s snow surveys, said at inches, said National Weather as happened last spring.
Cfius if PDSTI didn’t buy him a briefing after taking the Service meteorologist Drew With major reservoirs such
out of Icon. manual measurement Tuesday. Peterson. as Shasta Lake at 37% of ca-
Asked about that, Mr. Haw- The dry spell comes after State officials blame cli- pacity and Lake Oroville at
kins said PDSTI had offered California experienced one of mate change for the increased 47%, state and federal officials
him and other minority share- its wettest Decembers on re- frequency and severity of have instituted cutbacks to us-
holders a buyout if they helped cord and snow piled up more drought, which is also plagu- ers. The federal Bureau of Rec-
support a Cfius approval. They than 15 feet in the Sierra Ne- ing many other parts of the lamation on Feb. 23 an- exclusiveresorts.com
declined, he said, and decided vada. But the statewide snow- American West. “We are see- nounced an initial allocation
to “contact Cfius to ask for pack that measured 154% of ing these extremes we have of 0% to many farmers in the
help.” normal on Jan. 1 steadily never seen before, and hon- state’s Central Valley.
.
U.S. NEWS
McConnell Criticizes
Scott Over Tax Proposal
BY LINDSAY WISE curity and Medicare within dates are being asked whether
AND ALEX LEARY five years,” Mr. McConnell told they support the plan. Mr.
reporters Tuesday. “That will Scott is the head of the Na-
WASHINGTON—Senate Mi- not be part of the Republican tional Republican Senatorial
nority Leader Mitch McCon- Senate majority agenda.” Committee but said he re-
nell rebuked a policy agenda With the Senate split 50-50, leased the agenda on his own.
crafted by fellow Republican control of the chamber is at Mr. McConnell said Tuesday
Sen. Rick Scott, saying it stake in the November elec- that a GOP agenda would fo-
would raise taxes on lower-in- tions. Mr. McConnell, who cus “on what the American
come Americans, as Democrats could regain the majority post, people are concerned about:
seized on the proposal for and other Republicans fear that inflation, energy, defense, the
their midterm elections mes- Mr. Scott’s idea could blunt mo- border and crime.”
sage against the GOP. mentum in what looks to be a Mr. Scott’s proposal was
Mr. Scott’s 11-point “Rescue favorable climate for the party. reminiscent of comments by
GRAEME SLOAN/EPA/SHUTTERSTOCK
America” plan was released Mr. Scott, a wealthy former 2012 GOP presidential nomi-
last week and he has paid for Florida governor and business- nee Mitt Romney, who said
television and online advertis- man, was elected in 2018 and that 47% of Americans would
ing. It covers a range of topics, quickly sought to grow a na- vote to re-elect President Ba-
and includes proposals to tional profile. He is seen as a rack Obama because they are
name the border wall after for- possible 2024 presidential can- dependent on the government
mer Republican President Don- didate, should Mr. Trump de- and pay no income tax. Mr.
ald Trump, balance the federal cide against running again. Mr. Scott has denied he would
budget, prohibit the govern- Scott has stayed close to Mr. raise taxes and his plan
ment from asking people to Trump while Mr. McConnell doesn’t provide details, but Sen. Rick Scott, left, and Minority Leader Mitch McConnell in Washington on Tuesday. Mr.
disclose their race on any fed- has urged the GOP to move on Mr. McConnell and outside an- McConnell said Mr. Scott’s policy agenda would raise taxes on lower-income Americans.
eral form and sunset all fed- from the former president. Mr. alysts say it could raise taxes.
eral legislation after five years. Trump has encouraged Mr. Mr. Scott reiterated in a cause of basic provisions such use every resource at our dis- ference Tuesday, Mr. McConnell
But a line about taxes gained Scott to challenge Mr. McCon- statement Tuesday that he as limitations on tax for low- posal to make sure voters said that Mr. Scott was behind
the most attention. “All Ameri- nell for the position of party didn’t want to raise taxes. “I do, income earners. Both parties know exactly what Republi- him and could answer to that.
cans should pay some income leader, according to people fa- however, want to have a con- have also supported breaks for cans stand for,” the Demo- But Mr. Scott had left the gag-
tax to have skin in the game, miliar with the discussions. versation about able-bodied older Americans. cratic National Committee said gle moments before, leaving
even if a small amount. Cur- Some senators raised con- Americans who are living off of Democrats and the Biden in launching digital ads. fellow Republican leaders to
rently over half of Americans cerns about Mr. Scott’s pro- government programs instead administration blasted the Mr. McConnell’s statement smirk at the awkwardness.
pay no income tax,” it reads. posal during a private GOP of working, a reality caused by proposal and have sought to Tuesday was an attempt to Republican Gov. Ron DeSan-
“We will not have as part of leadership meeting Monday, Democrat policies,” he said. pressure Republican candi- stop that message from taking tis of Florida, another possible
our agenda a bill that raises according to a person familiar Roughly half of U.S. house- dates to take a position. “This hold. 2024 candidate, has also criti-
taxes on half the American with the discussion, and holds that pay no federal in- is the Republican Party’s offi- After being asked about the cized the idea, though without
people and sunsets Social Se- warned that Republican candi- come tax are exempted be- cial platform, and the DNC will plan during a routine news con- invoking Mr. Scott’s name.
VALENTYN OGIRENKO/REUTERS
Western small arms ammuni- lar priority for antitank and an- weapons. Ukrainian citizens
tion incompatible with those tiair capabilities, but also cer- this week have been photo-
produced in the Eastern Bloc. tain types of ammunition.” graphed carrying an AK-74, an
While acknowledging the Efforts are under way to updated Russian version of
challenges moving weapons move equipment into Ukraine the assault rifle, which uses a
into Ukraine amid escalating via the “limited ingress points” different size caliber than
Russian attacks, the Pentagon available, the diplomat said. standard-issue U.S. military
believes U.S. and Western assis- Alongside the U.S. Army’s 18th weapons.
tance is proving effective. “We Airborne Corps, European gov- Javelin antitank missiles, delivered to Ukraine last month as part of a U.S. military support package. “Small differences can make
believe it is getting into the ernments are working to estab- the weapon inoperable,” said
right hands, that they are ac- lish a sort of “international do- hitchhiking to join the was also implicated in an at- vision gear, armored vests and Peter A. Wilson, adjunct senior
tively using these systems,” a nor coordination center” that fight. These shipments haven't tack on Czech weapons depots helmets and antitank missile national security analyst at the
senior defense official said would establish lines of contact been hidden; rather, the Polish that supplied Ukraine. systems. RAND Corporation.
Tuesday. for countries seeking to provide government has openly boasted Ukraine’s only ammunition A State Department spokes- While the U.S. has sent sev-
On Saturday, the Biden ad- materiel to Ukraine, while re- of sending lethal aid to Ukraine. plant is located in an area that man said the U.S. and its allies eral shipments of weapons and
ministration said that Washing- ducing the strain on local More arms and ammunition has been under Russian con- and partners “are utilizing all ammunition toward Ukraine
ton would provide up to an ad- forces. are expected to flow through trol since 2014. available security cooperation since the invasion began, small
ditional $350 million in The Pentagon has said it has Poland’s overland routes, or Oleksandra Ustinova, a tools to expedite security assis- arms going to Ukraine are likely
additional military aid to had no U.S. aircraft flying in those of neighboring countries, member of the Ukrainian Par- tance to Ukraine,” adding that not U.S.-made but rather ob-
Ukraine, including lethal defen- Ukrainian airspace since the as Western governments shell liament, said Tuesday on the U.S. welcomes other na- tained from other U.S.-allied
sive assistance to Kyiv. Feb. 24 invasion. Instead, some out hundreds of millions of dol- MSNBC that the government tions’ contributions to and former Soviet states like
The weapons Washington in- of the more than 5,500 U.S. lars to send Ukraine’s army had to turn away volunteer Ukraine’s self-defense. Romania, Poland and Bulgaria
tends to provide to Ukraine in- troops currently stationed in fresh equipment. soldiers because “we ran out While citing prohibitions that had excess amounts in
clude U.S.-made Javelin anti- Poland are at the Polish-Ukrai- Despite the influx from Eu- of guns. We literally don’t against confirming or com- storage, Mr. Wilson said.
tank weapons, Stinger nian border where some of the rope during the past six days, have helmets, bulletproof menting on specific cases, the After the Cold War, “there
antiaircraft missiles as well as shipments are traveling from. Ukrainian officials have repeat- vests. We don’t have basic spokesman said the U.S. efforts was a downsizing and modern-
small arms and ammunition, In Poland, for days, convoys edly said they are short on am- guns to fight with.” include direct commercial sales ization of these armies which
U.S. officials said. of military transport trucks, es- munition and other small arms. In a Feb. 28 letter reviewed of defense articles to Ukraine. led to a lot of this ammunition
The U.S. has previously sent corted by police vehicles, have Several Ukrainian weapons by The Wall Street Journal, The drawdown on military and weapons to remain in stor-
Javelins among other battle- been headed over land to the depots were destroyed after Ukrspecexport, a state-owned assistance the administration age,” Mr. Wilson said.
field systems, and in January Polish border with Ukraine, 2014 in accidents Kyiv blamed arms trading company, re- announced over the weekend, —Drew Hinshaw
gave approval for Latvia and passing young Ukrainian men on Russian sabotage. Russia quested urgent supply of night- which allows for government- contributed to this article.
A Ukrainian woman sat with her sick daughter on Monday within a temporary shelter made in the basement of the Okhmatdyt pediatric hospital in Kyiv. Bullets have hit the hospital’s windows.
KYIV, Ukraine—Krystyna
Krayevska came to Kyiv from
Poland, where she normally
lives and works, for her niece
Darynka’s sixth birthday in
January. A few days later,
Darynka was diagnosed with a
brain tumor and, after compli-
cations following surgery, now
Images that the Kremlin by your president.” side. Authorities at first denied
doesn’t want Russians to see The Ukrainian channel Ukraine estimates that any involvement, then sug-
flash up every few minutes on shows videos of Russian pris- more than 5,000 Russian sol- gested any Russian soldiers
a Ukrainian channel on the oners, including several saying diers have died in combat and there were on vacation. When
Telegram messaging app that their commanders aban- more than 200 have been Ukraine captured a unit of
called Look for Yours. doned them and that they had taken prisoner. Those figures paratroopers, Russian officials
In one, the body of a man in been sent to Belarus for mili- couldn’t be independently ver- said they had got lost and
camouflage uniform lies rigid tary exercises last month not ified. strayed over the border.
in a snowy field, with mangled knowing that they would be Since the beginning of the This time, Russian media
flesh and blood where his face invading Ukraine. new, full-scale invasion last has played down the invasion
used to be. “Unidentified,” Russia has long paraded week, senior Ukrainian offi- and fighting, using Mr. Putin’s
reads the caption. Ukrainian prisoners on state cials including President Vo- euphemism of a “special mili-
The channel and a website, television. On Sunday, it lodymyr Zelensky, have re- tary operation” aimed at halt-
run by officials from Ukraine’s showed what it described as peatedly appealed to Russians ing what they falsely portray
interior ministry, focus on what the interrogation of a Ukrai- to protest against the war. as a Ukrainian assault.
Kyiv sees as a Russian vulnera- nian soldier taken prisoner. The online efforts take a Some parents of Russian
bility: morale on the home The International Commit- A Russian tank, destroyed by Ukrainian forces, in Lugansk region. more pugnacious tone. conscripts and professional
front and in the ranks of the tee of the Red Cross says that On the Look for Yours web- soldiers sent into Ukraine have
military. For days at the start of under international law, com- he said were being treated bor from a hostile Western- site, Mr. Andrusiv, the interior started a campaign to locate
Moscow’s invasion of Ukraine, batants must treat captured or well and receiving medical backed government that is ministry official, appealed to their sons.
Russian officials denied they killed soldiers humanely. care if needed. holding ordinary Ukrainians relatives of Russian soldiers. The Soldiers’ Mothers’
were facing significant popular “They must be protected, He said the government ini- hostage. “Do everything you can to end Committee, a Russian nongov-
resistance and said no Russians particularly against acts of vi- tiative was aimed at helping That stance has become this war, and so that your chil- ernmental organization, has
had been killed. olence or intimidation and Russians find and get in touch harder to maintain as dren, husbands and sons don’t been fielding calls at its
Some pictures and videos against insults and public curi- with relatives in the military Ukraine’s military has battled die in our country,” he said. branches across the country
on Look for Yours depict grue- osity,” said an ICRC spokes- who had been sent into tenaciously and ordinary citi- In one video, a blindfolded from relatives seeking infor-
some scenes of charred woman. “We call on all sides Ukraine. Ukraine’s Defense zens have joined the fight, man speaks on a cellphone mation about their loved ones.
corpses and twisted bodies to handle the dead with re- Ministry has opened a hotline, causing the Russian offensive proffered by his captors. “I’ve lost count of how
amid wrecked vehicles. They spect and refrain from display- called “Return Alive from to stall and casualties to “Mum, I’m a prisoner in many people have called,” said
also show videos of prisoners ing dead bodies on open Ukraine” for Russians looking mount. On Sunday, the Russian Ukraine,” he says. Svetlana Golub, the organiza-
and identification documents sources as it causes additional for relatives. Defense Ministry said for the “How can it be?” a female tion’s head. “A mother might
of the captured and dead. pain to their families.” The Russian Defense Minis- first time that service mem- voice responds. call, then a grandmother, then
“Unfortunately, it’s not pos- Vadym Denysenko, a try didn’t respond to a request bers had been killed. Russia has long tried to ob- a father, then the nephew,
sible to recognize the person spokesman for the Ukrainian to comment. “Unfortunately there are scure the extent of its military friends and everyone else. Our
in every photograph,” says interior ministry, said Ukraine Russian President Vladimir dead and wounded among our operations in Ukraine, which hotline is inundated, and we
Viktor Andrusiv, a Ukrainian wasn’t violating the rights of Putin has told Russians that comrades,” said the ministry’s included its seizing of Crimea try to speak with everyone
interior ministry official, the dead or prisoners, whom they are liberating their neigh- spokesman, Maj. Gen. Igor Ko- and direct military interven- and listen.”
.
Residents
Hit Hard
By Shelling
Continued from Page One
dents to leave some areas of
the capital ahead of bombing.
A video of the aftermath of a
shelling, shared by a resident of
a residential district in the
northeast of Kherson, showed a
crater, blood and body parts.
The man who shot the video
noted a body had been torn in
half.
“Can you tell me what hap-
pened here?” asked another
stunned man in the video. “My
relative lives here.”
Shocked residents sheltered
in basements amid explosions
and gunfire as armored vehi-
cles rolled through the streets.
“The situation is awful,” Maria
Masonkova, a graduate student,
wrote in a text message. “We
are in a trap.”
She sheltered in her base-
ment in Kherson’s Severnyi dis-
JUSTYNA MIELNIKIEWICZ/MAPS FOR THE WALL STREET JOURNAL (3)
Russia
Targets
FROM TOP: SERGEY KOZLOV/EPA/SHUTTERSTOCK; SERGEY BOBOK/AGENCE FRANCE-PRESSE/GETTY IMAGES; VYACHESLAV MADIYEVSKYY/REUTERS
Civilians
Continued from Page One
Ukraine’s second-largest city,
showed a missile landing just
outside the local government’s
headquarters at 8:01 a.m. local
time, with a fireball charring
nearby buildings and cars.
Ukraine’s national emergency
service said seven people were
killed and 24 injured in the
strike.
Later in the day, additional
Russian airstrikes hit
Kharkiv’s residential neighbor-
hoods, killing more than 10 ci-
vilians, local authorities said.
“A missile targeting the
central square of a city is
open, undisguised terrorism,”
said President Volodymyr Zel-
ensky of Ukraine, adding that
numerous children had died in
other attacks. “It’s terrorism
that aims to break us, to break
our resistance.”
The strike came amid signs
that Russia’s military forces
were pausing their advance on
Kyiv, having encountered a
range of obstacles since enter-
ing Ukraine. A senior U.S. de-
fense official said the Russian
advance has stalled amid food der temporary military admin-
and fuel shortages, Ukrainian istration, naming Gen. Mykola
resistance and slower-than-ex- Zhernov to oversee the city
pected troop movement to- alongside elected Mayor Vitali
ward Kyiv. Klitschko.
The Russians “are regroup- Russian forces overnight
ing and trying to adjust to the encircled the southern city of
challenges they have had,” the Kherson, establishing check-
U.S. official said. points around it, local authori-
An airstrike on the capital’s ties said.
iconic television tower on Video footage showed Rus-
Tuesday afternoon killed five sian patrols detaining local
people who were nearby and men.
injured another five, Ukraine’s Protests began to break out
state emergency service said. in the few Ukrainian towns un-
It also temporarily disabled der Russian occupation. In the
the broadcasting ability of town of Kupyansk, east of
Ukraine’s central TV channels, Kharkiv, several dozen un-
Ukraine’s communications au- armed local residents took to
thority said. The authority the streets with Ukrainian
said it would switch on re- flags, with some trying to stop
serve broadcast facilities. a Russian military vehicle.
The TV tower, erected in Similar protests took place
1973, stands in the Babyn Yar on Monday in the newly Rus-
area, where much of Kyiv’s sian-occupied town of
Jewish population was massa- Berdyansk.
cred by the Nazis during In the eastern Sumy region,
World War II. regional governor Dmytro
President Vladimir Putin of Zhyvytski said a salvo from
Russia has said his goal is to Russian rocket launchers in
“de-Nazify” Ukraine, falsely the town of Akhtyrka killed as
claiming that Mr. Zelensky, many as 70 Ukrainian soldiers.
who is Jewish, is beholden to In the large southern city of
U.S.-guided neo-Nazis. Mariupol, which advancing
“Putin seeking to distort Russian missiles targeted the regional administration building, top, in Kharkiv, Ukraine’s second-largest city, on Tuesday. The national Russian forces have nearly en-
and manipulate the Holocaust emergency service said seven people were killed in the shelling, including one carried from the building, above, and 24 injured. circled, most neighborhoods
to justify an illegal invasion of were without power or heat-
a sovereign democratic coun- jugate its rebellious province Kharkiv last week and then where Ukrainian volunteers in control of Ukraine’s airspace, ing Tuesday morning after
try is utterly abhorrent. It is of Chechnya in 1999-2000. The killed or captured a unit of 2014 displayed the remains of leading Russian forces to shift Russian shelling hit electricity
symbolic that he starts attack- new barrages indicate that Russian troops that entered a Russian rocket that hit the to nighttime operations in an substations, local authorities
ing Kyiv by bombing the site this relative restraint is falling the city over the weekend. city of Kramatorsk in the east- attempt to reduce losses. said.
of the Babyn Yar, the biggest away as Moscow seeks to On Monday, Russian forces ern Donbas region, where “The use of heavy artillery “Enemy forces are coming
of Nazi massacres,” said Na- crush Ukrainian resistance. unleashed a barrage of rocket Ukrainian troops have been at in densely populated urban ar- at Mariupol from all direc-
than Sharansky, the chairman Heavy fighting continued fire against residential neigh- war with Russian-backed eas greatly increases the risk tions, destroying our infra-
of the Babyn Yar Holocaust throughout Ukraine on Tues- borhoods in Kharkiv, killing at forces for the past eight years. of civilian casualties,” defense structure, killing our women,
Memorial Center and a former day, with Russian forces ad- least 10 civilians, including “Is Kharkiv Next?” read a intelligence said. children and elderly, and call-
Israeli deputy prime minister vancing in the country’s south three children and their par- banner that used to stand on Air-raid sirens and the thud ing it a war to liberate us,”
who was born in Donetsk, and trying to push into Kyiv. ents who were incinerated in a the spot before the Russian in- of explosions sounded all Mariupol Mayor Vadym Boy-
Ukraine. A large column of Russian car struck by a Russian projec- morning in Kyiv. chenko said in a video address
In an emotional video ad- forces kept heading toward tile, and injuring at least 40, Video footage released by recorded Tuesday morning.
dress to the European Parlia- Kyiv from the northwest, U.S. Kharkiv officials said. Ukrainian news channels on Later in the day, Russia
ment on Tuesday, Mr. Zelensky officials said. Satellite imagery Some 87 Kharkiv apartment
The Kharkiv strike Tuesday showed about a shelled several of the city’s
said Ukrainians were dying in from Maxar Technologies buildings have been damaged, came amid signs dozen smoldering Russian mil- residential high-rises, he said.
a struggle for the country’s showed a long convoy of vehi- and several parts of Kharkiv itary vehicles with “V” identi- In the western Ukrainian
survival. “We are giving our cles snaking toward Russia’s no longer have water, electric-
Russia was pausing fying signs in the town of city of Lviv, Dmytro Bugo-
lives for the right to be equal,” forward positions. However, ity or heating, Mayor Ihor Ter- the advance on Kyiv. Borodyanka, along the route of slavskyi, director of retail for
he said, unshaven and wearing the front line in the battle for ekhov told Ukrainian TV chan- the long convoy heading to- the Ukrainian branch of U.S.-
a green army T-shirt. “Prove Kyiv remained stationary near nels. ward Kyiv, the result of what based Winner Auto Group, has
that you are with us and will the town of Bucha on Tuesday. Kharkiv, which served as they said was a Ukrainian been supplying cars to the
not let us go.” A first round of cease-fire the capital of Ukraine in the vasion began. The missile left strike. Ukrainian military since the
President Biden spoke with talks between Russian and 1920s and 1930s, is home to a large crater in the square on “For the enemy, Kyiv is the war began.
Mr. Zelensky for more than 30 Ukrainian delegations meeting some 1.4 million people. Tuesday. key aim. They want to destroy “Lviv is preparing,” he said.
minutes on Tuesday, the White in Belarus on Monday pro- “This is not a random mis- Buildings all around the our statehood, and that is why “Everybody realizes the
House said. The two leaders duced no immediate results, taken salvo, but a conscious square were severely dam- the capital is under constant threat. Nobody’s secure any-
discussed U.S. and allied assis- and the two sides initially extermination of people. The aged, with their windows threat,” Mr. Zelensky said. where. If you see what’s going
tance for Ukraine and Russia’s agreed to meet again in the Russians knew what they were blown out and walls cracked Russia, he added, is trying to on in Kharkiv, these guys can
escalation of attacks on sites coming days on the Ukrainian- firing at,” Mr. Zelensky said and pockmarked. blow up the city’s main power do anything. So we’re prepar-
used by civilians, including the Polish border. about Monday’s shelling. British defense intelligence station and leave the capital ing for the resistance.”
strike near Babyn Yar, the Russia is facing growing in- Tuesday’s missile struck said early Tuesday that Russia without electricity. The Kremlin cited on Mon-
White House said. ternational isolation and its fi- Freedom Square near the spot still hadn’t managed to gain On Tuesday, he put Kyiv un- day Mr. Putin’s demands for
Russia’s invasion of nancial system is reeling un- ending the conflict as Ukraine
Ukraine—launched on Thurs- der the impact of Western recognizing the 2014 annexa-
day by Mr. Putin with the aim sanctions imposed over the tion by Russia of its Crimean
of overthrowing the country’s weekend. Peninsula by Russia, neutral-
elected government and end- The ruble plunged and Rus- ity, and “demilitarization and
ing its alignment with the sia’s central bank more than de-Nazification” of the coun-
West—has made slower prog- doubled its key interest rate to try.
ress than most military ana- 20% on Monday in an attempt President Emmanuel Ma-
lysts had expected. Russian to prevent a run on Russian cron of France, who spoke to
forces are struggling with banks as sanctions curb their Mr. Putin on Monday, said that
fierce Ukrainian resistance and access to international mar- the Russian leader agreed dur-
logistical problems. kets. ing the call to his request not
Russian troops appear to be The U.S. and the European to attack Ukraine’s civilian tar-
“risk averse,” the U.S. official Union said over the weekend gets and infrastructure and
said, adding that there is evi- they would hinder Russia’s not to encircle Kyiv.
dence that some Russian central bank from using its In previous conversations
forces have surrendered and foreign reserves and exclude a this year, Mr. Putin promised
that troop morale is weak. The number of Russian banks from Mr. Macron he wouldn’t in-
U.S. official said no evidence the international Swift pay- vade Ukraine.
has emerged that Russia is ments network, among other Mr. Zelensky asked EU lead-
considering retreating from its measures. ers on Monday to allow the
aim of capturing Kyiv. The EU also closed its air- country to immediately join
Russia has gained a swath space to all Russian planes. the club, signing an applica-
of land in southern Ukraine, Kharkiv, whose population tion letter, but membership is
including capturing Kherson is mostly Russian-speaking, a request the bloc is unlikely
city, in addition to its push in has put up stiff resistance to to grant.
the northeast and northwest. Russian advances since Mr. The EU membership pro-
Mr. Putin, who claims Rus- Putin began the invasion, cit- cess can take years and in-
sians and Ukrainians are the ing alleged discrimination volves broad economic, legal
same people, initially ab- against Ukraine’s Russian and political changes.
stained from the kind of indis- speakers as one of his reasons. —Brett Forrest
criminate shelling of civilian Ukrainian forces repelled a and Nancy A. Youssef
areas that Russia used to sub- tank column heading to Russian missiles caused a fireball, charring nearby buildings and cars in central Kharkiv on Tuesday, contributed to this article.
.
© 2022 DOW JONES & COMPANY, INC. ALL RIGHTS RESERVED. 6DJ8714
.
Concerts, Films
Giving Russia
Cold Shoulder
Cancellations mount no longer put on shows or do
business in Russia, a spokes-
for Western events in woman said Tuesday. The en-
symbolic protests of tertainment giant is reviewing
its global suppliers and ven-
nation’s aggression dors and will cut ties with any
Russian-based firms, she said.
BY ROBBIE WHELAN Russia represents a small
AND ANNE STEELE but significant market for
Western entertainment. Con-
The entertainment industry cert touring trade magazine
is turning its back on Russia. Pollstar reported $26.6 million
Hollywood studios, Netflix in ticket sales for 83 shows in
Inc., big-ticket rock bands and Russia in 2019, before the pan-
Vladimir Putin, as Western “all-out economic and financial was up 4.7%. XRP was up 0.7%.
countries threaten to squeeze war on Russia.” Avalanche was up 3.3% and
their assets with an unprece- In response, Dmitry Medve- Cardano was up 0.9%.
MIKHAIL JAPARIDZE/TASS/ZUMA PRESS
dented sanctions drive. dev, deputy chair of the Secu- On Tuesday, the tech heavy
rity Council of Russia, tweeted: Nasdaq Composite Index fell
By Max Colchester, “Watch your tongue, gentle- 1.6%.
MAXIM SHEMETOV/REUTERS
Jenny Strasburg men! And don’t forget that in Because bitcoin trades 24-
and Nick Kostov human history, economic wars hours a day, in some cases it
quite often turned into real has been leading risk assets,
In recent days, a parade of ones.” Mr. Le Maire later said not just following.
Russian businessmen burnished his use of the word “war” was Last Wednesday, when Rus-
their antiwar stances as govern- inappropriate. sian President Vladimir Putin
ments tightened a noose around Lawyers caution that the po- announced his invasion of
Kremlin-connected businesses From left, Mikhail Fridman held off on condemning Vladimir Putin, while Oleg Tinkov said his litical rhetoric may not match Ukraine, U.S. equities markets
and property. Oligarch Roman foundation helped children and Roman Abramovich said he is helping to negotiate peace. the legal reality. “This is all go- were closed. Bitcoin fell about
Abramovich, who hasn’t been ing to be subject to enormous 6% overnight, then rallied 13%.
put under sanctions, said he group VIY Management and some of their assets. Mr. Biden businessmen to its sanctions list, litigation,” said Olivier Dor- On Thursday, U.S. stocks closed
was helping Ukraine negotiate son of Vladimir Yakunin, for- didn’t elaborate on the Justice freezing assets and imposing gans, economic-sanctions law- slightly higher after a day of
peace with Russia. Oleg Tinkov, mer president of OAO Russian Department’s task force and de- travel bans. The U.K. is expected yer at Ashurst. Authorities are wild trading.
the billionaire founder of Rus- Railways. The U.S. imposed partment spokespeople didn’t to target more oligarchs in com- going to have to prove that the Bitcoin dropped almost 9%
sia’s Tinkoff Bank, a unit of TCS sanctions on the elder Mr. provide details. ing days. Even Monaco, famed sanctioned individuals own from the afternoon of Friday,
Group Holding PLC, highlighted Yakunin a few years ago. The events in Ukraine over for its generous tax rules, said it those assets outright, a poten-
the work his foundation does to On Tuesday night, President the past week have ruptured a was clamping down on Russians tially difficult job since many of
help children and his desire for Biden during his State of the delicate compact between West- under sanctions. them are held through opaque
no war. Mr. Tinkov also hasn’t Union address said the Justice ern governments and Russian The British Parliament will ownership structures, he said.
The Russian invasion
been put under sanctions. Oleg Department is assembling a task businessmen. For years, the vote on a law in the coming In reality, few assets will prob- of Ukraine has driven
Deripaska, a raw-materials mag- force “to go after the crimes of West tolerated funneling billions weeks to force anonymous for- ably be seized, he said.
nate who was previously sanc- Russian oligarchs.” “We are join- of dollars out of the ruins of the eign owners of U.K. properties For some targeted Russians,
demand for crypto in
tioned in the U.S., wrote on so- ing with our European allies to Soviet Union. The benefit to gov- to reveal their identities and the fight back is under way. both countries.
cial media on Sunday that peace find and seize your yachts, your ernments was massive invest- strengthen provisions to freeze Mikhail Fridman, a founder of
“is very important.” luxury apartments, your private ment by many of these individu- the assets of alleged klepto- Alfa Bank, Russia’s largest pri-
“Please don’t draw an equal jets,” Mr. Biden said. “We are als, boosting local economies. crats who can’t prove the ori- vate bank, was hit with EU sanc-
sign between Russians, the coming for your ill-begotten Western governments now hope gins of their wealth. tions late Monday. The EU said Feb. 18, through the evening of
Russian state and the Govern- gains.” that punishing a cadre of well- France announced on Tues- he cultivated strong ties to Mr. Monday, Feb. 21, amid news of
ment of [the] Russian Federa- The Justice Department is ex- connected people with deep day the creation of a task force Putin and acquired state assets the worsening crisis in Ukraine.
tion. There are many Russians pected to step up its efforts to links to Russia will in turn put to hunt down sanctioned Rus- through these connections. Mr. U.S. stock markets, closed on
strongly opposing the current investigate whether assets of pressure on Mr. Putin. sian oligarchs and their families’ Fridman said he would contest Monday for a holiday, didn’t
military action, and I am one of some oligarchs could be linked The European Union said assets in the country. French Fi- the designation, and that he isn’t get a chance to react to the
them,” said Andrey Yakunin, to illicit activity, which would al- Monday night that it added 26 nance Minister Bruno Le Maire politically or financially con- news until Tuesday. When they
the founder of private-equity low the U.S. government to seize prominent Russian officials and said the French state was explor- nected to Mr. Putin. did, the major indexes all lost
more than 1%.
Attention has also fallen on
Teenager Takes On Tracking Tycoons’ Jets—and Putin’s cryptocurrencies for their po-
tential to be an outlet for Rus-
sians trying to get around
BY GINGER ADAMS OTIS garchs. The freshman at the vatek, Russia’s largest private sanctions.
University of Central Florida natural-gas company, and Al- While cryptocurrencies
Jack Sweeney, the Florida has made a hobby out of fol- isher Usmanov, often cited as themselves haven’t been part
teenager who garnered atten- lowing the private aircraft of Russia’s richest man. of the sanctions, the White
tion for tracking the private jet billionaires and some celebri- Mr. Usmanov is now on the House has been considering
of Tesla Inc. Chief Executive ties. His new Twitter bots fo- European Union’s sanctions adding them.
Elon Musk, is now publicizing cused on Russia use the same list of 26 Russian officials and On Twitter on Sunday morn-
the movements of planes technology as the one that businessmen, freezing their ing, Mykhailo Fedorov,
owned by Russian oligarchs and tracks the jet Mr. Sweeney be- assets and imposing travel Ukraine’s vice prime minister,
aircraft associated with Russian lieves is owned by Mr. Musk, bans. Some oligarchs in recent requested cryptocurrency ex-
JACK SWEENEY
President Vladimir Putin. he said. days have distanced them- changes block Russian ac-
Mr. Sweeney, 19, said he Mr. Sweeney’s hobby gar- selves from Mr. Putin. counts. “It’s crucial to freeze
made the new Twitter bots— nered national attention after Mr. Sweeney said he is still not only the addresses linked
@RUOligarchJets and @Putin- he said Mr. Musk personally tracking Tesla’s CEO and reit- to Russian and Belarusian poli-
jet—over the weekend after reached out to him on Twitter Jack Sweeney is publicizing the movements of oligarchs’ jets. erated that he would take the ticians, but also to sabotage or-
Russia invaded Ukraine. asking that he shut down account down in exchange for dinary users.”
“Even before this war @ElonJet, which publicly he created in 2020. leaving the country right now,” a new Tesla Model 3. Ukraine’s Mr. Fedorov didn’t
started, people were saying to shares the movements of the His @RUOligarchJets ac- Mr. Sweeney said. He said he has no desire to make clear if the request was
me, ‘Oh, you should track Pu- Tesla executive’s plane. Mr. count has amassed more than Mr. Sweeney’s bot follows gain anything from the ac- personal or one on behalf of
tin,’ ” he said on Tuesday. Sweeney’s bots rely on public 175,000 followers as of Tuesday planes owned by Roman Abra- counts targeting Mr. Putin and the government. An attempt to
Once the Russian attacks data from plane transponders afternoon. The bot tracking movich, the oligarch owner of the oligarchs. “I definitely reach him wasn’t successful.
began, he got messages from that log longitude, latitude planes that might be used by England’s Chelsea Football Club, think we should not be at Crypto exchanges largely de-
online followers urging him to and altitude and calculate lo- Mr. Putin had more than 30,000 as well as aircraft owned by Le- war,” he said. “We should be murred from enacting any vol-
focus on the country’s oli- cation based on an algorithm followers. “I don’t think he’ll be onid Mikhelson, head of No- more peaceful.” untary restrictions in Russia.
.
PERSONAL JOURNAL.
© 2022 Dow Jones & Company. All Rights Reserved. THE WALL STREET JOURNAL. Wednesday, March 2, 2022 | A15
R
BY LINDSAY ELLIS according to a survey of more than told them no, citing his happiness ternship offers in the fall without of Business.
100 students by research and ana- with the offer’s starting salary and something else lined up. Unlike last Abby Scott, assistant dean for
arely—if ever—has lytics company Veris Insights. the company’s culture. year, when he took the first offer M.B.A. career management and
there been a bidding Corporate recruiters, including “Competition has been fero- he received, Mr. Eshleman said he corporate partnerships at the Haas
war for summer in- at Liberty Mutual Insurance Co. cious,” said Graham Donald, the felt sure he’d find a better position School, said most years fewer than
terns. and General Mills Inc., said more founder and president of Campus eventually. He recently took an of- 10 students raise the possibility of
Many college stu- students are backing out of intern- Talent Lab, a company that brings fer from PNC Financial Services reneging on an internship with her
dents are juggling mul- ship offers this year. Liberty Mu- campus recruiters and HR profes- Group Inc. after several interviews office. The first step in determin-
tiple summer internship offers as tual said it is reviewing pay bench- sionals together for professional de- and an “intern super day” where he ing a sanction, she said, is to un-
companies try to lock in entry- marks. Other employers and velopment and networking. “We’re met employees over Zoom, which derstand the student’s motiva-
level talent. So fierce is this year’s campus career offices said some seeing students saying, ‘I can he said made him feel more con- tions. For example, a student
competition, recruiters and career companies have boosted intern change my mind at any point.’ ” nected to the organization. might have a new family obliga-
advisers said, that some students pay for certain in-demand stu- Students used to feel sheepish Reneging on offers can have tion that requires a different role.
are reneging on summer stints dents. Still more employers are about backing out of offers, but consequences at some universities. But if a Haas graduate student
they accepted back in the fall as stepping up contact with students Elizabeth Diley, campus talent ac- Campus career offices, wary of accepts a job with a big tech com-
recruiters barrage them with inter- between the time they accept of- quisition leader at General Mills, damaging relationships with em- pany while still aggressively inter-
view requests and richer offers. fers and when they start jobs to said she has observed less remorse. ployers, consider such moves a viewing with a startup, Ms. Scott
Companies and colleges say reneg- keep them engaged. The cereal and food maker usually breach of professional norms. said, “we really push on them and
ing is still rare, but it is becoming At Michigan question, ‘How did you feel that
more pervasive in the current re- State University, you could be in good conscience?’ ”
cruiting frenzy. undergraduates Mark W. Nelson, dean of Cor-
What’s causing them to change Najaah Chambliss had said who renege on nell’s business school, said stu-
their minds? More money, housing yes to an internship but then accepted offers dents are reminded of “expecta-
stipends, flexible work hours, the got a better offer. won’t be able to tions and responsibilities as they
ability to live in a student’s pre- access Hand- approach the job market.” Money
ferred city and work at big-name Tyler Eshleman turned shake, an online from the fines levied against stu-
companies that can add heft to down two offers before he job platform that dents who renege on offers bol-
new graduates’ résumés. accepted a position. many colleges sters the salaries of their peers
Najaah Chambliss, a computer- pay for to help who pursue less-lucrative intern-
science major, accepted an intern- students and ships, such as in the nonprofit sec-
ship in October for the summer of new grads find tor, according to policies reviewed
2022 at a defense company. Then, listings for en- by The Wall Street Journal.
earlier this year, the 21-year-old Maura Quinn, who leads Liberty hires about 150 interns each year; try-level work. Lehigh University, Punishing students for pursuing
senior got an offer from Microsoft Mutual’s campus recruiting and now it plans to over-hire, betting which does the same, asks students the best job offer they can get is
Corp. at nearly double the salary, early-talent programs, said her team that some percentage of interns who change their minds to send a out of step with the job market,
FROM LEFT: NAJAAH CHAMBLISS; TYLER ESHLEMAN
with money for relocating to Seat- uses a “keep in touch campaign” will renege on offers before their letter of apology to the company. said Beth Hendler-Grunt, president
tle and a housing stipend. that includes months of company summer jobs start, she said. Both colleges said that reneging on of Next Great Step, a career coun-
“It was definitely a no-brainer,” social hours and coffee chats as part Companies typically recruit offers is serious and that most stu- seling firm whose clients are stu-
she said, adding that she wanted of an extended onboarding and get- summer interns early in the aca- dents don’t do so, though Michigan dents and recent grads seeking
to diversify her résumé with a big- to-know-you process. demic year to lock in potential tal- State officials acknowledged there their first jobs.
tech role after prior internships in The company also encourages ent. The problem this year with have been more cases this year. “They’re not thinking about
the defense sector. accepted interns to post a com- commitments made months ago is M.B.A. candidates can face what’s good for the students—
Interns are rejoicing at their pany logo on social media to an- that the hot job market is generat- steeper penalties for reneging, in- their skill set, their financial
new leverage in a hot labor mar- nounce the new position. Incoming ing lots of new offers that can lure cluding a fine of up to $2,500 at needs,” she said of institutions
ket. Some 15% of students who had intern José Eduardo Reyes said he students away. Cornell University’s SC Johnson that impose such penalties. “I
accepted a 2022 internship offer in did so on LinkedIn and received a Tyler Eshleman, a senior study- College of Business and a 16-hour don’t think that’s how the real
November said they were still “ac- flurry of messages from other em- ing finance at Grand Valley State service project at the University of world works. People change jobs
tively searching” for another offer, ployers trying to poach him. He University, turned down two in- California, Berkeley’s Haas School all the time.”
R
fable about Congress, underper- among younger generations.
alph Nader spent a career formed. He and the publishers In 2000, he was criticized by some
bashing corporate executives. largely blame the pandemic, which Democrats for affecting the outcome
Now he’s written a book kept him from promoting the books. of that year’s ultra-close presidential
praising some. It’s not going down Getting outside one’s comfort zone election. In the swing states of Flor-
too well. is never easy. Michael Jordan’s base- ida and New Hampshire, Mr. Nader,
Tentatively called “Twelve CEOs I ball career lasted one season. Black running as the Green Party candi-
Have Known and Admired,” the Panthers co-founder Bobby Seale Consumer date, won far more votes than the
book is more than a little off-brand took some by surprise when he pub- critic Ralph margin by which Republican George
for the man who upended the world lished a barbecue cookbook. Crooner Nader has W. Bush edged Democrat Al Gore in
of auto safety with the blockbuster Pat Boone’s heavy metal album, written the states.
“Unsafe at Any Speed” and then at- made in his 60s, startled his fans. books, but “The Democratic Party is very
tacked corporate behavior in a num- “It was so out of character that it so far no good at scapegoating,” Mr. Nader
ber of other industries. was literally front-page news,” said one wants said when asked about it. “The
Based on a string of rejection let- Mr. Boone, 87. “I was dressed in to publish duopolies think they own the voters.”
ters from publishers, Mr. Nader said leather pants, chains and earrings. The youngest living CEO in his latest. When Mr. Nader pitched “Unsafe
he fears he’s been typecast, making My image was well known and ev- the book is Andy Shallal, the 66- at Any Speed,” in the 1960s, the
any accolades he might have for erybody thought they knew me.” year-old founder of Busboys and feedback wasn’t encouraging. “It’s
corporate tycoons a hard sell. His Mr. Nader, 88, disputes the idea Poets, a chain of community for comment. an interesting book but I fear it
literary agent, Ronald Goldfarb, ad- his book is out of step with his gathering places in and around Mr. Shallal would be of interest only to insur-
vised him to change course and go consumer activism, saying he sees Washington, D.C. D said he was ance agents,” Mr. Nader said he
negative, he says. it as a natural extension of his life’s Mr. Shallal said he was never a little sur- was told by Jason Epstein, a re-
“He wanted chapters on bad work. He said he had been thinking formally interviewed. “We’ve had prised to hear his friend was strug- nowned editor who died last
CEOs,” Mr. Nader said of Mr. Goldfarb. about this book for decades. That dinner together,” he said. “I like to gling to get his book published. “It month.
“I didn’t tell him what to write,” might explain why three-quarters of think we’re buddies. He was proba- would be fascinating to know what “Unsafe at Any Speed” has sold
ANDREW SULLIVAN FOR THE WALL STREET JOURNAL
Mr. Goldfarb retorts. “I told him its subjects are no longer alive. bly interviewing me at some point Ralph Nader thinks makes a good more than a million copies world-
what I could sell.” The two parted Among the dead executives he and I didn’t know it.” CEO,” he said. wide, Mr. Nader said.
ways after working on the manu- lauds are index-fund pioneer John Mr. Nader said he spoke to Mr. Publishers don’t seem to think so. He hasn’t given up on finding a
script for three months. Bogle and The Body Shop founder Shallal extensively for the book: “I “There’s a lot to admire in this taker for his CEO book, although he
Mr. Nader has sold plenty of books Anita Roddick. Another one, Gordon interviewed him for 15 years in his project, Ralph, but ultimately the has ruled out two particular ave-
over his career. His 1965 car-safety Sherman, former president of the restaurant.” book is not quite a fit for our list,” nues: self-publishing or turning to
exposé changed the industry. It is Midas muffler chain, died in 1987. The two other living executives Trish Daly, a senior editor at Portfo- Amazon Publishing, which in recent
credited with spurring seat-belt laws Asked why he didn’t write about featured are Yvon Chouinard, the lio, an imprint of Penguin Random years has attracted a number of
and a range of other car-safety mea- executives from a younger genera- 83-year-old founder of outdoor House, told Mr. Nader in an email. well-known writers.
sures now taken for granted. tion, Mr. Nader said, “I don’t know clothing and gear retailer Patagonia Yaniv Soha, a senior editor at “I want to break up Amazon,” Mr.
He has since written or co-au- anybody under 40 who has been Inc., and Paul Hawken, a 76-year-old Penguin Random House’s Double- Nader said. “It’s bad enough you
thored more than 30 other books, ballyhooed the way these 12 have. environmentalist, author and entre- day imprint, wrote that the busi- have to rely on them for online
although his latest two, a collection That doesn’t mean they don’t exist.” preneur. They couldn’t be reached ness-book market was “not our par- sales.”
.
PERSONAL JOURNAL.
BY J.J. MCCORVEY
P
eople using buy-now-
pay-later services such
as Klarna and Afterpay
take note: Those pur-
chases—and payment
records—will soon show
up on credit reports.
Starting Feb. 28, Equifax Inc.
said it would begin recording the
popular “pay-in-four” installment WHAT TO KNOW ABOUT HOW
Buy-Now-
loans, which have attracted mil-
lions of shoppers but have largely
gone untracked by traditional
credit-reporting methods. The
move is part of a larger effort by
Pay-Later
all three major credit bureaus to
offer lenders a wider view of a
borrower’s financial obligations.
Carnival Cruise Line now recommends but doesn’t require masks on board its ships.
M
have medical, isolation and not broadly mandated,
ajor cruise lines in- quarantine facilities on site. masks may be required in
cluding Carnival and Cruise ships operating in certain venues and events.
Norwegian have U.S. waters reported 1,050 Under the CDC program,
started loosening onboard Covid-19 cases among pas- cruises can exempt unvacci-
mask rules. sengers and crew between nated children under 5 when
Carnival Cruise Line rec- Feb. 12 and 25, according to calculating the ship’s vacci-
ommends—but doesn’t re- CDC data. Between Dec. 15 nation rates.
quire—masks on board as of Norwegian previously re-
Tuesday. The same policy quired all cruise line guests
goes for Norwegian Cruise to be fully vaccinated, but
Line ships departing from
U.S. ports. Royal Caribbean
Cruises relaxed its mask re-
quirements for fully vacci-
1,050
Covid-19 cases on cruise ships
will allow unvaccinated chil-
dren under age 12. A spokes-
person said all guests who
are 12 and older and crew
nated guests in February. in U.S. waters Feb. 12-25 must be fully vaccinated.
They are optional for fully Guardians of unvaccinated
vaccinated guests. passengers under 12 need to
The Centers for Disease be aware of any travel re-
Control and Prevention low- and 29, there were 5,013 strictions in place at the vis-
ered the risk advisory for Covid cases among passen- iting destinations and be
cruises from a “very high” to gers and crew on ships. ready for additional tests at
“high” in February. The Masks are still required the time of sailing and dis-
agency now advises passen- during the embarkation and embarkation from a U.S.
gers to be up-to-date with debarkation process, as the port.
vaccinations before cruise federal mask mandate re- Booster shots are recom-
ship travel. Some cruise lines mains until at least March mended, but generally not
canceled or postponed sail- 18. Under the policy, face required. A Norwegian
ings as a result of the Omi- masks must be worn over spokesperson notes that
cron variant of Covid-19 in the mouth and nose by all many countries, especially in
January. travelers on airplanes, ships, Europe, now require booster
Many of the mask policies trains, subways, buses, taxis shots to visit if guests have
come after major cruise lines and ride-shares and inside been fully vaccinated more
opted into the CDC’s updated airports, bus or ferry termi- than a certain number of
voluntary Covid-19 program nals, train or subway sta- months.
.
ARTS IN REVIEW
Pablo Picasso’s ‘The Blue Room’
(1901), left, and ‘The Soup’ (1903),
below, both included in the show
G
with the Barcelona vanguard at tender scene of a mother feeding a
Washington the café Els Quatre Gats, having child. But equally persistent is Pi-
iven the countless exhi- abandoned formal art studies and casso’s constant testing of the im-
bitions and the vast lit- beginning to exhibit in Spain. On plications of other works of art.
erature dedicated to his first sojourn in Paris, working Through side-by-side comparisons
Pablo Picasso in a borrowed Montmartre studio with significant examples by El
(1881-1973), is there from September through Decem- Greco, Honoré Daumier, Puvis de
anything more to say? ber that year, his scenes of louche Chavannes, Rodin, Degas and
“Picasso: Painting the Blue Period,” Parisian café life (and the occa- more, we are made privy to what
at the Phillips Collection, affirms sional Spanish subject) won him a Picasso wished to absorb, emulate,
that the answer is “yes.” Organized contract with a Catalan expatriate challenge, reject or rival. It’s like
by Kenneth Brummel, associate cu- who promoted Spanish art to col- watching the preternaturally gifted
rator, Modern Art, at the Art Gal- lectors and dealers. Back in Paris young man think, as he discovered
lery of Ontario, Toronto, and Susan in late May 1901, Picasso’s meeting and invented himself.
Behrends Frank, curator at the Phil- with the prestigious gallerist Am- A coda of paintings and sculp-
lips, the show is a deep dive into broise Vollard resulted in plans for tures from 1904-1906—mostly sen-
the heady years—1901-1904—when an exhibition in late June and a suous, firmly articulated nudes
the eager, barely fledged painter month of feverish effort, as the made in the Pyrenees town of Go-
first found his voice. still teenage painter rushed to pro- sol—signals a change in mood. The
The exhibition is structured duce new works for the show. brooding darkness of the Blue Pe-
around three works, the Phillips’s Eight of these are on view—ur- riod gives way to the seductive
“The Blue Room” (1901) and the gent, vibrantly colored—a salable, warmth of the Rose Period, with
AGO’s “Crouching Beggarwoman” self-promoting miscellany: bou- its shifts between delicacy and
(1902) and “The Soup” (1903), all quets; café scenes; a brushy head hardened form. We learn a lot. Try
young paintings, full of near-ado- of an extravagantly hatted woman; not to miss “Picasso: Painting the
lescent angst and intense feeling. ods. The histories of the trio, their tive works, documentary materials splayed, titillating nudes. There’s Blue Period.”
Together, they embody Picasso’s place within Picasso’s evolution, and multimedia accounts of the one tough outlier, “Nude With
main themes during this early pe- and the world in which they were revelations of recent technical Cats” (1901), a tightly folded girl Picasso: Painting the Blue Period
riod—intimacy, compassion and created are brought to life by a analysis of the three central paint- on a bed, with three black felines. The Phillips Collection, through
sympathy for the unfortunate, es- stellar selection of his drawings, ings enrich the story. And the cat- Beside this small, fierce painting, June 12
pecially women—while also mak- canvases and sculptures that in- alog is a good read, informative Auguste Rodin’s “Crouching
ing plain his ambition and his cludes rarely seen examples from and intelligently organized. Woman” (1880-82) reveals the Ms. Wilkin is an independent cura-
awareness of art from many peri- collections world-wide. Compara- We meet the 19-year-old Pi- source of the odd, compressed tor and critic.
TELEVISION REVIEW | JOHN ANDERSON gets sidestepped. A character like lennial con artistry that’s in vogue
Walgreens’ Jay Rosan (Alan Ruck), right now. No one is a greater mas-
E
behalf with the devotion of a reli- Kalanick character in “Super Pumped:
lizabeth Holmes, who rode Sili- What’s not is how Holmes se- self-made female tech billionaire— gious convert. His dubious col- The Battle for Uber” (Showtime) is
con Valley’s “fake it till you duced so many people, from her and a Stanford dropout besides— leagues include his boss, Wade Mi- no Elizabeth Holmes—he’s selling an
make it” ethos all the way to a Stanford professor and future Thera- was not something anyone wanted quelon (Josh Pais), who is less actual idea from a real company—he’s
four-count felony conviction, isn’t in- nos board member Channing Robert- to deflate with facts, not the inves- confident in Theranos than he is also scamming his way through life.
teresting because she’s a victim. son (Bill Irwin) to George P. Shultz tors and not the media. Still, what fearful of being left behind by up- What the fraudsters also share is a
She’s interesting because, by every (Sam Waterston). Bill Clinton, Henry counterfeit benevolence: Everyone is
indication, she’s a sociopath. And Kissinger and David Boies were also doing what they’re doing—and steal-
yet, by the end of episode 1 of among her acolytes, and the question ing what they’re stealing—for the
Hulu’s dramatic series “The Drop- one hopes will be explored and/or an- benefit of mankind. It’s what helped
out,” a viewer will be wondering if swered by “The Dropout” is why. Ms. Holmes get over on people like
the subject’s misbehavior is going to Seyfried, who was Oscar-nominated Shultz.
be blamed on her chilly mother, her for “Mank” last year, is just as revela- There’s a super team of support-
feckless father, her own frigidity, tory here, but strictly as an actress, ing actors in “The Dropout,” includ-
mean girls, a sexual assault at Stan- not as a window into the phenome- ing the great Laurie Metcalf as
ford, or the fact that she couldn’t non of Holmes. The portrayal is ab- Holmes-doubter Phyllis Gardner, and
run as fast as the other kids in sorbing, committed and morbidly fas- the endearing Stephen Fry, whose
grade school. cinating—one of the more memorable genial, opera-loving Ian Gibbons,
The eight-part series finally stops aspects of the Holmes persona was head chemist at Theranos, is a prin-
imposing sympathy on the story in her unnaturally deep voice, which cipal player in the company melo-
episode 4, when Holmes (Amanda seemed intended to enthrall and drama but too nice a guy to suspect
Seyfried) becomes a fully paranoid probably did. A conceit of “The Drop- the obvious. (Other decent people at
burner of bridges at Theranos, her out” is the Holmes character’s delib- Theranos, and there aren’t many, in-
“disruptive” company that was built erately cultivating her near-baritone clude the scientists Edmond and
on a blood-testing technology that and Ms. Seyfried’s gradual Jekyll-and- Rakesh, given memorable portrayals
never actually worked. She shops it Hyde-ish adoption of Holmesian facial by James Hiroyuki Liao and Utkarsh
anyway, to CVS, Safeway and ulti- gestures. (The way the actress con- Ambudkar). Kate Burton is Ian’s
mately Walgreens, whose team of torts her mouth is nothing short of wife, and late in the series she, Mr.
HULU
older male executives—who should heroic.) But at the same time, there Macy and Ms. Metcalf create the
be running for the hills—partner in- are aspects to the Holmes allure, so kind of scene one imagines must
stead with a woman willing to test to speak, that seem beyond the Amanda Seyfried as Elizabeth Holmes in ‘The Dropout’ have been a hoot for them as their
her unworkable process on terminal scope of acting, writing or directing. characters collect facts for Wall
cancer patients, spy on her employ- (The show’s creator is Elizabeth ineffable magic the woman pos- start startups. But regardless of Street Journal reporter John Carrey-
ees and lie shamelessly in the face Meriwether, who based it on the pod- sessed is beyond explanation, as far their motives, few of these alleged rou (Ebon Moss-Bachrach) and plot
of incontrovertible facts. “I don’t cast of the same name by Taylor as the show is concerned. “She’s authority figures (episode 4 is titled to “burn Theranos to the ground.” At
feel things the way other people Dunn, Rebecca Jarvis and Victoria pretty and blond,” sputters Holmes “Old White Men”) comes off looking that point, Holmes and company al-
feel things,” she tells her age-inap- Thompson. Worth seeking out for antagonist Richard Fuisz (William H. very sage. (Only seven of the eight ready are self-immolating. But view-
propriate boyfriend and alleged ac- hard facts is Alex Gibney’s “The In- Macy), and he seems to be on to episodes were available for review.) ers will be cheering the arsonists on.
complice, Sunny Balwani (a won- ventor: Out for Blood in Silicon Val- something—she humiliated a lot of Whether Holmes was an enchant-
drously vile Naveen Andrews). That ley.”) older men who should have known ress remains mysterious, though she The Dropout
much is clear. That Holmes was the youngest better. But how she actually did it certainly represents the kind of mil- Begins Thursday, Hulu
.
SPORTS
are entering the game and produc-
ing at high levels,” said New York
Mets pitcher Max Scherzer, one of
Baffert Seeks
eight players on the union’s execu-
tive subcommittee. “We still feel To Overturn
Churchill Ban
there’s dollars to be allocated to-
ward them that would fairly com-
pensate their contributions on the
field more so than what’s at the ta- BY JIM CHAIRUSMI
ble at this point.”
The events of Tuesday were the TRAINER BOB BAFFERT SUED
culmination of a long process that Churchill Downs Inc., the com-
began not long after the ratification pany’s chief executive and its
of the previous CBA. It quickly be- chairman, alleging that the race-
came evident that the 2016 deal fa- track didn’t have the legal author-
vored the owners, and the average ity to issue a two-year ban after
player salary decreased throughout the Baffert-trained Medina Spirit
its term. failed a drug test following last
Middle-class free agents felt year’s Kentucky Derby.
squeezed as teams began treating Kentucky racing officials last
the luxury tax more and more like a week disqualified Medina Spirit as
line never to cross. The rebuilding the winner of the 2021 Kentucky
strategy known as “tanking” swept Derby, after the colt tested posi-
across the league, further hamper- tive for betamethasone, a corticos-
ing demand for some players. teroid, in post-race testing. Regu-
Meanwhile, team valuations and lations in Kentucky don’t allow
league revenues soared. betamethasone in a horse’s system
Mr. Manfred pointed out that the on race day. The board also or-
players’ dissatisfaction was with a dered a 90-day suspension for Baf-
deal they agreed to. fert and fined him $7,500. Baffert
Nonetheless, their anger led to is appealing that decision to a
the relationship between the league Kentucky state court.
and union sinking to its lowest The lawsuit, filed on Tuesday in
point in more than a quarter-cen- federal court in the Western Dis-
tury, with players gearing up for a trict of Kentucky, says that
clash years before this Churchill Downs, chief executive
Baseball’s lockout.
“We’ve seen this com-
ing,” said pitcher Andrew
Bill Carstanjen and chairman Alex
Rankin rushed to judgment and
deprived Baffert of his right to due
more than a decade. Mr. Manfred eral key areas that the players have mechanisms designed to promote union’s turn to offer a proposal. Mr. are meritless and consistent with
said last month that postponing identified as their top priorities. compensation for young players, an Meyer responded that the league his pattern of failed drug tests, de-
opening day would be “a disastrous Chief among them is the competi- increasingly crucial part of rosters used the words “best and final” on nials, excuses and attempts to
outcome for this industry.” tive balance tax, which penalizes who are paid relatively little. The Tuesday, implying that there was no blame others and identify loop-
Now baseball is facing just that, teams for spending over certain union asked for the minimum salary reason to counter. holes in order to avoid taking re-
an outcome that threatens to antag- limits and has been used by some to grow from $570,500 to $725,000 It creates the impression that sponsibility for his actions. These
onize fans of a sport that has strug- in 2022, with set annual raises after this could go on for a while–and the actions have harmed the reputa-
gled in recent years to maintain its that. The league is at $700,000, players say they are ready to hold tions of the Kentucky Derby,
position in a crowded entertain- ending at $740,000 in 2026. out as long as necessary. Churchill Downs and the entire
ment landscape. Attendance and
Rob Manfred said last Players want $85 million put into “We’re prepared,” Mr. Miller Thoroughbred racing industry.”
television ratings have decreased in month that postponing a performance-based bonus pool for said. “Our communication, our will-
recent years, with the younger de- players who don’t yet qualify for ingness to see each other’s point of
mographic, especially, not embrac-
opening day would be ‘a salary arbitration with $5 million views and to find solutions and to
ing longer, slower games and less disastrous outcome.’ increases each year, while the fight for what’s right is like nothing
action on the field. league has pitched $30 million. like I’ve seen before.”
The owners presented what they MLB’s proposal also featured the On Monday, the players rallied
JEFF ROBERSON/ASSOCIATED PRESS
described as their best offer Tues- designated hitter in the National around the announcement that Hall
day, though Mr. Manfred later clari- as a de facto salary cap. League, a 12-team postseason field of Famer Derek Jeter had stepped
fied that he didn’t mean that in a The players are seeking that instead of 10 and a draft lottery for down as chief executive of the Mi-
legal sense. Though he called the threshold to be raised to $238 mil- the first five picks. ami Marlins, saying: “The vision for
negotiations “deadlocked,” he said lion from $210 million and climb to Player leaders quickly rejected the future of the franchise is differ-
the sides are not at an impasse. $263 million over the life of the the league’s proposal, and the ent than the one I signed up to
“Take it or leave it in a negotia- five-year deal. Management offered union’s bargaining unit in Florida lead.” Players interpreted his state-
tion is not something that I think is $220 million, topping out at $230 led by attorney Bruce Meyer said it ment as one of their own leaving
usually productive,” Mr. Manfred million. MLB’s tax numbers were was going home. management and returning to their
said. “I think always at the end unchanged from its last proposal on “Young players more than ever side. Bob Baffert sued Churchill Downs.
OPINION
The Putin Endgame BOOKSHELF | By Hugo Restall
Modern sig-
nals moni-
toring means
to slaughter his way to Kyiv
and Western public opinion
will make sure economic sanc-
that we can only hold out for
a few more years.”
Choices always exist, just
Vladimir Putin were not
around? Do they really want
Russia in harm’s way as Mr.
Strokes
U.S. spooks
can hardly
store all the
information
tions are a one-way ratchet.
Ukrainians will fight on and
suffer more, with the consola-
tion that a great nation is be-
not for a Hitler or Putin. They
need to drag the world into
disaster to secure their own
positions.
Putin continues his desper-
ate, flailing campaign, now
with nuclear threats, to save
himself from his Ukraine
Of Genius
BUSINESS
they collect. ing born. (Meanwhile, if you Mr. Putin’s isolation and blunders?
WORLD
So when Sen. thought China, which could miscalculation make him dan- Events can be momentous
Kingdom of Characters
By Holman W.
Marco Rubio have prevented all this, was gerous but they also make him without meriting grandilo- By Jing Tsu
Jenkins, Jr.
tweeted this ready for global responsibility, vulnerable. Seventeen years quent description. There can’t (Riverhead, 314 pages, $28)
T
week about you’re over that now.) ago, I wrote the West didn’t be a new cold war because the
intelligence he can’t describe Mr. Putin’s retreat into so- realize Mr. Putin “fancied him- Russia of today can’t sustain a he proliferation of Mandarin immersion schools across
that shed doubt on Vladimir lipsism didn’t begin with self a conqueror, an empire cold war. It’s not the U.S.S.R. the U.S. suggests that a growing number of American
Putin’s mental state, he may Covid but the Arab Spring, builder, a man of destiny,” like Economically, it’s not even parents believe the Chinese language, including its
not have been referring to the which he saw as harbinger of another figure in the news at Spain. Operative all along writing system, will prepare their children for academic
work of CIA profilers but what his own ending. He saw every- the time—Saddam Hussein. hasn’t been Russia’s historical success. China’s primary- and secondary-school students
Mr. Putin’s colleagues are say- one around him as a potential and geographic imperatives, regularly top global rankings in math and science, even as
ing in their undoubtedly copi- enemy and the feeling became but the grotty nature of the the study of Confucian classics enjoys a resurgence. Perhaps
ous exchanges. mutual. When he showed a His regime is current regime. A kleptocracy Chinese characters are the key to the country’s ability to
Mr. Rubio has become our video of Russian helicopters is reaching its natural ending. churn out talented professionals?
designated declassifier. He battling militants in Syria to a destroying itself over It couldn’t create a stable If the central figures of Jing Tsu’s “Kingdom of
was the vehicle for a fleeting visiting Oliver Stone, it was a fictional threat of governance model any more Characters: The Language Revolution That Made China
and obviously purposeful air- video of U.S. helicopters lifted than the one-man 1970s Afri- Modern” were alive to see this, they would marvel at how
ing of Mr. Putin’s dirtiest, from YouTube. I doubt his NATO aggression. can dictatorships it resem- history has reversed itself. For more than a century, language
most secret laundry (to which aides informed him of the, um, bles. Mr. Putin’s geopolitical reformers and innovators struggled with the challenge of
I will return at the end) dur- embarrassment. posturing is absurd. His re- meshing Chinese characters with the Western world.
ing a 2017 confirmation hear- But he knows one thing: The two men’s paths were gime is destroying itself over Ms. Tsu, a professor of East Asian languages and
ing with Rex Tillerson. This day was coming. He oddly similar, and anybody an entirely fictional threat of literatures at Yale University, describes how intellectuals
I’ve been wondering for planned for it. Like his role who saw Mr. Putin’s televised NATO aggression from believed that the Chinese language was a major reason for
weeks now how Mr. Putin can model, he exploited the Olym- bullying of aides last week Ukraine. the country’s backwardness.
survive his Ukraine gambit. pics for their internationalist might have thought of Sad- The sanction that might As China was being carved up
His basic bet failed a month sheen, then launched a discor- dam’s televised Baath Party help Kremlin decision makers into spheres of influence by
ago, when Volodymyr Zel- dant drumbeat about how Rus- purge before the Iran war. come to the right decision to- colonial powers during the 19th
ensky, Joe Biden and Olaf sia is surrounded by enemies. Except with a difference: day is the truth. Open the century, the West’s dominance
Scholz refused to concede Like his role model, his mil- Saddam’s untrusted associates CIA’s files about his regime’s seemed to show that alphabet-
Ukraine’s independence to ap- itary spendfest in the 2010s were dragged off to his dun- murders and thefts and bi- based scripts were a better fit
pease the Russian dictator. wasn’t for signaling purposes geons to be tortured and exe- zarre corruption. Open the for the scientific and industrial
That ended any chance of an but to implement a deliberate cuted. Mr. Putin, after his files about Ryazan. That’s the revolutions then under way.
outcome that actually plan for staying in power. bitchy treatment, had to let city where a spate of murder- Some influential figures, such as
strengthens him. His speech last week was his march out of the room ous apartment-block bomb- the left-wing writer Lu Xun,
A military victory in redolent of Hitler gambler with one more reason to relish ings by Chechen terrorists argued that Chinese characters
Ukraine now will be indistin- phrases: No choice. No option. his eventual comeuppance. came to an end in 1999. They should be scrapped to save the
guishable from defeat. If Mr. “We could not act otherwise.” These cronies have a stopped after then-presiden- nation.
Putin is sentient, he will look Hitler, before his Poland chance to earn their billions. tial candidate Putin’s own in- There are several reasons why
for ways to limit the costs of invasion, said: “It is easy for They aren’t fools. Would any telligence agents were caught China ultimately held on to its
his miscalculation, which I us to make decisions. We of this be happening if not unloading sacks of explosive characters. Most important, the
doubt the U.S and its allies have nothing to lose. . . . Our for Vladimir Putin? Would it into the basement of a large prevalence of homophones in the Chinese language means
will afford him. He will have economic situation is such continue one second longer if apartment complex. that a phonetic script would lead to endless misunder-
standings. Ms. Tsu reprints a 92-character parable by the
linguist Zhao Yuanren about a gentleman who tries to eat 10
Scholz and Biden Stand Tall Against Russia stone lions. Every character is pronounced “shi,” making a
phonetic rendering unintelligible. It’s an extreme case, but
the point is certainly valid.
This has been ourselves to set limits on a many’s former Defense Minis- and these efforts have borne So how could China make its characters fit into a world
quite a week. warmonger like Putin.” ter Annegret Kramp-Karren- fruit. The sanctions against dominated by alphabetic languages? The book opens with
The Russian Since the fall of the Berlin bauer wrote, “I’m so angry at Russia will deliver a hard the story of Wang Zhao, a former Qing dynasty official who
invasion of Wall, Germany has allowed its ourselves for our historical blow to its economy, and the sneaked back into the country from exile to publish in 1903
U k r a i n e armed force to wither from failure.” Despite multiple Rus- European Union’s decision to the first homegrown phonetic script. Wang’s “Mandarin
ended the nearly half a million person- sian attacks on its neighbors, fund and deliver weapons to Combined Tone Alphabet,” a set of 62 symbols borrowed
POLITICS p o s t - C o l d nel to only 180,000 while she says, “we have not pre- Ukraine is unprecedented. from Japanese and Manchu, was quickly superseded by
War era and slashing its battle-tank force pared anything that would NATO is united and more nec- another bespoke system. But Wang’s alphabet did play a
& IDEAS
silenced the from 5,000 to 300. For the have really deterred Putin.” essary than ever. transitional role in education reforms that promoted
By William
endless chat- past three decades, the coun- Russia’s invasion of While the defense of de- literacy. After the collapse of the Qing and the founding of
A. Galston
ter that the try has relied on international Ukraine has had the same ef- mocracy in Europe is crucial, a nationalist republic in 1912, Wang continued to champion
North Atlantic law and institutions, bolstered fect on Germans that Ger- we face critical challenges in the Beijing dialect used by imperial officials as the standard
Treaty Organization is obso- by trade and economic inte- many’s invasion of Poland did Asia as well. We can’t choose form of the language. That gave us today’s Mandarin, known
lete. And for Germany, World gration, to maintain the peace one region over the other. Mr. in the People’s Republic as putonghua, or “common speech.”
War II is finally over. of Europe. The invasion of Biden must persuade Con- Many problems persisted in the years before the advent
The changes in German Ukraine has shattered the illu- As Germany begins its gress and the American peo- of powerful computers. The complicated tables for encoding
policy have come with breath- sion that this approach would ple that our vital interests are characters into numbers for telegrams meant that Chinese
taking speed. Better known suffice. rearmament, the U.S. at stake in both and must be messages were slower to arrive and more expensive to send.
for caution than daring, Chan- “We have to ask ourselves: must continue to help protected. The rise of China is Chinese typewriters were cumbersome and difficult to use.
cellor Olaf Scholz halted Nord What capacities does Putin’s threatening American’s econ- New systems to index knowledge along the lines of alpha-
Stream 2 (probably for good), Russia have?” Mr. Scholz told Ukraine’s resistance. omy as well as the security of betical order were hard to learn.
ended Germany’s ban on Parliament. “And which ca- its friends in the Indo-Pacific
weapons exports to Ukraine, pacities do we need to coun- region. The U.S. must respond
accepted financial sanctions ter his threats? It’s clear that on Brits in 1939, and the joint by investing more in key tech- Many believe Mandarin to be a language of
on Russia—including the re- we will need to invest a lot Russian-Chinese declaration nologies, strengthening its al- the future, but it was once considered a
moval of some Russian banks more in the security of our at the beginning of February liances in the region, and en-
from the Swift system and a country to defend our free- may turn out to be this cen- suring that the U.S. and its stumbling block to Chinese modernization.
ban on transactions with Rus- dom and our democracy.” tury’s Molotov-Ribbentrop allies gather the armed forces
sia’s central bank—and autho- With apparent approval pact. needed to deter Xi Jinping
rized the construction of two across party lines, he called Mr. Scholz has risen to the from doing to Taiwan what The most successful innovations were spearheaded by the
new liquefied-natural-gas ter- for an emergency appropria- occasion. Now it is President Vladimir Putin is doing to Communists after their 1949 victory as Mao Zedong sought
minals to reduce his country’s tion of $112 billion—about Biden’s turn. Ukraine. new means to indoctrinate the “poor and blank” peasantry.
dependence on Russian en- double Germany’s annual de- Long before he became As always, freedom isn’t Mao appointed a committee of 12 language reformers that
ergy permanently. Germany fense budget—along with a president, he depicted Amer- free. In the short term, the first simplified more than 2,200 commonly used Chinese
also supported the European permanent annual increase in ica’s global challenge as a conflict in Ukraine may mean characters. In more than 80% of cases, they adopted
Union’s unprecedented deci- the defense budget to 2% of struggle between democracy higher fuel prices. In the lon- shorthands already in common use in handwriting and
sion to finance the purchase his country’s gross domestic and autocracy. Nothing illus- ger term, it may require a calligraphy. Once these shorthands were officially recognized
of weapons for Ukraine. product. trates this better than larger military budget. It is as the official forms, learning to read and write became
Most important, Mr. Scholz Many other German leaders Ukraine’s brave struggle to re- Mr. Biden’s job to prepare the easier and printing clearer.
has begun rearming Germany. have endorsed this shift, often main independent and free. American people for whatever The committee then turned to a new system of
In a speech Sunday to a spe- in blunt and personal terms. The U.S. can’t actively fight sacrifices lie ahead. But what- romanization, known today as pinyin. It was based on
cial session of Parliament, he Erich Vad, who served as mili- for them, but it is Mr. Biden’s ever hardships we may en- Latin New Script, devised in Soviet Russia in 1929 to
declared that the invasion of tary adviser to former Chan- responsibility, working with dure, they will not approach spread communist propaganda to illiterate Chinese.
Ukraine “marks an historic cellor Angela Merkel, ex- Congress, to make sure the the sacrifices that the defend- Pinyin also helped Chinese students learn to read and
turning point in the history of pressed humiliation that “our U.S. gives Ukrainians what ers of Ukraine are making ev- speak standard Mandarin. It had the additional benefit of
our continent.” The question, army is a laughingstock and they need to defend them- ery hour. Their bravery should helping foreigners understand the real sounds—hence
he said, is “whether we allow [Russia’s] is menacing the selves. inspire all of us to set aside “Peking” gave way to “Beijing.”
Putin to turn back the hands world.” The chief of the Ger- For months his administra- our differences and unite China may have been first to use movable-type printing
of time to the days of the man army admitted that “the tion has worked with Euro- around a strategy that pro- 1,000 years ago, but its typesetters were left far behind by
great powers of the 19th cen- armed forces that I lead are pean allies to coordinate a re- tects our interests and re- the invention of the linotype machine in the 1880s. By the
tury, or whether we find it in more or less powerless.” Ger- sponse to the Russian threat, flects our principles. mid-1970s, developed countries had moved on to photo-
mechanical typesetting, while Chinese printers were still
composing type using outdated methods. So the Communist
T
anticipated. After noting the old clippings, and Stolzen- next month your parents will making the use of characters virtually as fast and easy as
he voice, from more student council elections that burg was very close. United be privileged to vote in a na- alphabetic languages.
than 60 years ago, was were coming up, he said, “Mr. Press International reported tional, a state and a local elec- Today the world is suddenly interested in learning about
remarkably clear and, Khrushchev, who I’m sure you that Khrushchev, speaking tion, deciding how they will be China’s language and culture. One downside is that this
to my ears, instantly recog- know, is in New York City at from the balcony of a build- governed. I believe that no na- shift, along with China’s explosive economic development,
nizable. “I’m very happy to the present time . . .” ing on Park Avenue while in tion in which the people serve has flipped an inferiority complex into triumphalism. The
welcome you boys and girls Nikita Khrushchev, the So- Manhattan for a meeting of the government can be consid- propaganda motive behind China’s most successful language
to the first assembly of the viet premier, was as ominous the United Nations General ered a great nation. Only a na- innovations should also give observers pause. The use of
1960-61 school year,” said and widely distrusted a fig- Assembly, had boasted that tion in which the government Chinese is exploding on the internet, but the renaissance is
Floyd V. Stolzenburg, princi- ure in the U.S. in 1960 as “there is no more democratic serves the people can be a corralled behind the Great Firewall, a layered system of
pal of Cassingham Elemen- system than ours.” How many great nation.” censorship that keeps out inconvenient truths and dissenting
tary School in Bexley, Ohio. votes had he received in the He said that, in this com- opinions.
A buddy of mine from My school principal in most recent election? munity in the American Mid- China has now come full circle. As in imperial times, an
those days had found the old 1960 called the Soviet “99.9%.” west, “Your parents will have authoritarian regime maintains its grip on power by
reel-to-reel tape in a box. As So Floyd Stolzenburg, who an opportunity to vote as controlling how language is used. It has even assimilated
a child he had been a mem- Union a ‘slave nation.’ lived with his family on Elm their conscience, and as their the Confucian classics into its arsenal. Confucius Institutes,
ber of the school’s audiovi- Avenue across from the intellect, dictates to them.” funded by Beijing and proliferating within U.S. schools and
sual club and a volunteer school’s baseball field and He asked us to think about universities, offer Chinese-language studies and help spread
projectionist for the noon Vladimir Putin is today. Four was the public-address an- what that meant. He said we Communist propaganda abroad.
movies (“Our Friend, the years earlier he had issued a nouncer for Friday-night should always remember that Ms. Tsu largely steers clear of politics in her book. And
Atom”) in the auditorium. In threat to Western nations: football games, explained to “yours indeed is a great she doesn’t break enough new ground to attract readers
autumn 1960 he had lugged “We will bury you.” us why he was discussing the land,” and on that tape from familiar with China’s modern history. Nevertheless, this is
his bulky Wollensak tape ma- Stolzenburg told all of us Soviet leader: long ago the sounds of the an enjoyable light read and may be useful for parents
chine to that auditorium to children in the auditorium “In other words, less than assembly went on. sending their children to learn Mandarin. If nothing else, it
record Floyd Stolzenburg’s that in New York Khrushchev 1% of the people dared to ex- will give them an appreciation of the complexity and beauty
speech. “was asked what percentage press any dissatisfaction with Mr. Greene’s books include of the language.
As I listened the other day, of the people voted for him Mr. Khrushchev. This is a “And You Know You Should
I was startled to hear the in the last election. He said it slave nation.” Be Glad: A True Story of Life- Mr. Restall is a former editor of The Wall Street Journal
principal’s reedy, friendly was 99.86%.” His tone was gentle, his long Friendship.” Asia’s editorial page.
.
OPINION
REVIEW & OUTLOOK LETTERS TO THE EDITOR
Biden Misses the Moment On the Sidelines as Ukraine Fights for Its Life
P
resident Biden is no Olaf Scholz. The new What we also didn’t hear was a vow that Russia What happens in Ukraine is a mat- It isn’t too late for Kyiv to put per-
Chancellor upended decades of center- will not be allowed to conquer and hold Ukraine. ter of freedom, life and death for the manent Ukrainian neutrality on the
courageous resisters to Vladimir Pu- agenda. The alternative is too dire to
left German defense and energy policy There was no warning to Mr. Putin not to launch
tin’s invasion (“Ukraine Leads the accept. Ukraine’s future, territorial in-
this week after Vladimir Putin missiles into residential neigh- World,” Review & Outlook, Feb. 28). It tegrity and many innocent lives hang
invaded Ukraine, and Mr. Biden Nice words for Ukraine, borhoods or surround and also matters to the fate of political in the balance.
had a similar opportunity in but no domestic or starve cities into submission like freedom in the world. Ukraine is the ISTVAN DOBOZI
his State of the Union address a medieval siege. This was not Gettysburg of our time. Read Lincoln’s Sarasota, Fla.
Tuesday. He missed the mo- defense policy reset. Harry Truman at the dawn of immortal words: Gettysburg was not
ment. The President remained the Cold War calling the world only about us, but also about our obli- Russia’s invasion has the look and
on the same policy course of to meet a new danger. gation to promote freedom in the feel of Stalin’s attack on Finland. When
his first year, albeit dressed up in new anti-infla- On his domestic agenda, Mr. Biden acknowl- world in a thoughtful yet committed the Soviets invaded in November 1939,
tion packaging. edged inflation, as he had to given the polls. But manner. Gettysburg is also a symbol they exuded confidence, believing vic-
More defense spending to meet the threats he blamed rising prices on the pandemic and of the sacrifice this can require. I have tory would be quick. That didn’t hap-
read about the “rapture” that Ukraine pen. The Finns fought back fiercely,
from autocrats? No. A new appreciation for the greedy businesses, and his solutions are to un-
resisters share in risking their lives stopping Soviet invaders in their
contribution of fossil fuels to American and Eu- leash prosecutors and antitrust cops, and to together to protect their freedom. The tracks. But Stalin could not afford to
ropean security? Not a word. A note that govern- spend even more money on social welfare and flame is alive in them. Is it with us? lose—Soviet military invincibility was
ment spending contributed to the highest infla- entitlements. His most other-worldly line was EM. PROF. DONALD A. DOWNS at stake and the world was watching.
tion in 40 years? Nope. A word of praise for the that his program would “cut energy costs for University of Wisconsin-Madison The Red Army halted, reorganized and
private Pharma innovation that developed Covid families an average of $500 a year by combating smashed the main Finnish defense for-
therapies and vaccines? He proposed govern- climate change.” In “Zelensky Challenges the West” tifications in a costly final offensive.
ment price controls instead. The entire point of his climate agenda is to (op-ed, Feb. 24), Joe Lieberman pro- Only then did the overwhelmed Finns
Mr. Biden did offer stirring support for raise the price of energy for Americans by reduc- poses to “accelerate Ukraine’s applica- agree to Russian terms.
Ukraine and its fight for freedom, which received ing the supply and increasing the cost of coal, tion for membership in the European Mr. Putin follows in Stalin’s foot-
Union” and have it join NATO. This steps. The aura of Russian military in-
bipartisan applause. His Administration de- oil and natural gas. His regulators are working
would likely lead to a military con- vincibility is at stake; he has to double
serves credit for helping to rally Europe and to do that every day in every way. It was as if the frontation between Russia and the U.S. down. As infantry and armored col-
other nations to impose sanctions and provide horror of the last week, which exposed the folly As Henry Kissinger wrote in 2014: umns close in on Kyiv; as NATO and
more military aid. He was properly condemning of Europe’s dependence on Russian oil and gas, “The West must understand that, to the West cheer but only watch from
of Mr. Putin. had never happened. The climate left still has a Russia, Ukraine can never be just a the sidelines, maybe brave Ukrainians
But his self-congratulation ignored the failure choke hold on this Presidency. foreign country.” For Ukraine, he advo- can do to the Russians what they did
to deter the Russian autocrat. “We were ready” An anxious world is looking for American cated “a posture comparable to that of to the Germans in 1942-43, and turn
if Mr. Putin invaded, Mr. Biden said. But if the leadership in a dangerous new era. Instead Mr. Finland,” carefully avoiding hostility to Kyiv into Mr. Putin’s Stalingrad.
U.S. had been ready, Mr. Putin wouldn’t have in- Biden offered a rehash of his first-year domestic Russia. Finland shows that neutrality COL. JOHN BOYD, USA (RET.)
vaded. The Russian invaded because he thought agenda that has brought him to his low political need not involve a satellite status. Lexington, S.C.
the West would do little. And Mr. Putin finds ebb. It’s dispiriting that a White House facing so
himself in a struggle now because of the bravery many daunting challenges could come up with
of 41 million Ukrainians, not the strength of Eu- so little. The President really does need to fire
rope or the United States. some people and get better advice. No One Source Should Provide All That Power
“The Power Struggle” (Exchange, able energy. We work with regulators
Feb. 19) is compelling on the need to and other stakeholders to make grid
Britain’s Labour Party to the Defense upgrade aging power-transmission in- investments that will serve customers
P
frastructure. We need to think as care- for decades.
acifism runs through the veins of most marker about his party’s official stand on secu- fully about where we will get our While some argue that deregulation
European political parties of the left, rity policy and how far afield lawmakers are al- power. No source of electricity is infal- or market structures like RTOs and
but Vladimir Putin’s Ukraine invasion lowed, or not, to stray from that message. lible. That’s why we need a mix of coal, ISOs are necessary for decarboniza-
highlights the urgent need for a transfusion. Mr. Starmer is also showing he understands natural gas, nuclear power and renew- tion, Southern Co. has reduced our
able energy. When some of these un- emissions nearly in half with plans to
German Chancellor Olaf Scholz is attempting Labour needs to be credible on national security
derperform, others can fill the gap. achieve net zero by 2050. Our state-
such a treatment for his Social Democrats, and for voters to trust it at the ballot box. In Parlia- This makes the grid more reliable and regulated, vertically integrated market
he’s been joined by Keir Starmer of Britain’s ment last week, he warned Conservative Prime electricity prices more affordable and structure and robust wholesale energy
Labour Party. Minister Boris Johnson that the initial round of stable. It can also help save lives. competition make rapid decarboniza-
Mr. Starmer put tough action behind his pro- sanctions Mr. Johnson’s government proposed During extreme cold weather a year tion possible without government
NATO words when he threatened last week to wouldn’t be enough to deter Mr. Putin from in- ago, average capacity factors in a 15- mandates and without sacrificing
expel 11 sitting lawmakers from the party if they vading Ukraine. state region of the Midwest were 90% safety, reliability or affordability.
didn’t recant a letter they signed criticizing the Mr. Starmer made that speech on Wednes- for nuclear plants, 84% for coal-fired TOM FANNING
Western alliance. Prominent party figures such day, and on Thursday he was proven right. This plants, 40% for natural-gas plants and CEO, Southern Co.
as Diane Abbott and John McConnell, who is the kind of clear-eyed opposition that can 17% for wind. Wind was the only elec- Atlanta
tricity source whose capacity factor
served in the shadow cabinet under former hold Mr. Johnson’s government accountable and
declined during the cold weather. The Four of the 10 most powerful and
leader Jeremy Corbyn, had put their names to push the country toward smarter policy. capacity factor for coal increased destructive hurricanes and five of the
a Stop the War Coalition statement blaming the Western governments face wrenching deci- more than any of the others. This 10 worst wildfires on record have hap-
British government and NATO for provoking Mr. sions as Mr. Putin tears up Europe’s post-World doesn’t mean that wind is a bad pened over the past decade. Recogniz-
Putin and “refut[ing] the idea that NATO is a de- War II order. Mr. Starmer does his country and source of electricity. Rather, these ing the increased risk of these extreme
fensive alliance.” Labour a favor by showing that Britain’s party numbers show the value of having a weather events and natural disasters,
Mr. Starmer won this intraparty battle when of the center-left will engage fully in these de- mix of resources that includes coal. America’s investor-owned electric
the 11 removed their signatures from the letter. bates rather than retreating into wooly paci- As the electricity grid becomes less companies have invested more than $1
The veteran leftists are unlikely to have changed fism. American conservatives who want to re- carbon-intensive, we still have to keep trillion over the past decade to build
their views apologizing for Russia’s imperial- treat from the world could learn from the the lights on by modernizing the na- stronger and more resilient energy in-
ism. But Mr. Starmer has set down an important British Labour leader. tion’s transmission system and main- frastructure that also enables them to
taining a reliable mix of resources. continue integrating clean-energy re-
BOB BERRY sources. For the 10th consecutive year,
E
tric Corp. and chairman of America’s $143.3 billion in 2021.
uropean governments are scrambling to rendered to Russian energy dominance. Power, a trade group that advocates Investment in adaptation, harden-
shore up their natural gas supply if Rus- Former NATO secretary general Anders Fogh coal-fueled electricity. ing and resilience already makes up
sia cuts off exports. But one question Rasmussen blamed Russia for fueling the frack- more than one-third of spending on
worth raising: How in the world did Europe ing opposition. “Russia, as part of their sophisti- While extreme weather can happen transmission and distribution infra-
leave itself so vulnerable to Vladimir Putin’s en- cated information and disinformation opera- anywhere, states that have suffered structure. These investments help pro-
ergy extortion? tions, engaged actively with the most are also those that have pur- tect the energy grid from extreme
The nearby chart shows Here’s how Europe made so-called nongovernmental or- sued market structures such as Re- weather and cyberattacks; help pre-
gional Transmission Organizations dict, mitigate and prevent outages;
how Russian gas exports have itself vulnerable to ganizations—environmental
(RTOs) and Independent System Oper- and help companies restore electricity
increased in tandem with de- organizations working against ators (ISOs), which treat electricity as faster when outages do occur.
clining European production. Putin’s gas blackmail. shale gas—to maintain depen- a commodity instead of a necessity. TOM KUHN
A mere 15 years ago, countries dence on imported Russian These markets carve up accountability President, Edison Electric Institute
in the European Union pro- gas,” he noted in 2014. for serving customers and often prior- Washington
duced more gas than Russia exported. Yet Eu- Meantime, multinationals diversified by hop- itize short-term financial gains over The EEI represents all U.S. investor-
ropean production has plunged by more than ping into bed with Russia. BP acquired a 19.75% customers’ long-term well-being. owned electric companies.
half over the last decade. Mr. Putin has happily stake in Rosneft in 2013. The transaction “gives In state-regulated, vertically inte-
filled the supply gap. us a wonderful opportunity to forge a new part- grated markets, companies like ours
In 2020 Russia exported nearly three times nership with a great Russian oil company,” BP’s are accountable to regulators for bal- Ukraine Needs Zelensky Alive
ancing clean, safe, reliable and afford-
more gas than Europe produced. What’s amaz- then CEO Bob Dudley declared. Your editorial “Putin’s New World
ing is that Europe increased its reliance on Rus- Shell and Exxon Mobil developed joint ven- Disorder” (Feb. 25) explains that Rus-
sian gas even after Gazprom repeatedly sus- tures with Gazprom and Rosneft. Exxon Mobil sia “is betting on more appeasement
pended pipeline exports to Ukraine. Germany’s described its partnership with Rosneft in east-
Pandemic Excuses Won’t Fly after the fall of Kyiv and the installa-
response: Build the Nord Stream 2 pipeline to ern Russia as “one of the largest single interna- Your editorial “The School Shut- tion of a puppet government.” At
make itself less dependent on gas flowing tional direct investments in Russia and an ex- downs and Lost Literacy” (Feb. 25) some point not too far off, President
notes that reading skills among kin- Volodymyr Zelensky should decamp
through Ukraine. cellent example of how advanced technologies
dergartners have declined after with as much of his cabinet as possi-
Poland and Lithuania were smarter and built are being applied to meet the challenges of the school shutdowns. Even more disturb- ble and establish a government in ex-
terminals to import liquefied natural gas (LNG). world’s growing energy demand.” ing is that only 55% were on track for ile. There would be not the slightest
But Europe had another Natural Gas Production, Russia vs. Europe, The point isn’t to reading before the pandemic. Nearly a reason for anyone not otherwise in-
option: fracking. Euro- 1990-2020 shame Western energy third were “far behind.” This is an in- clined to recognize a “puppet.”
pean gas production has Russian Federation Exports European Union Production companies for accept- dictment of the education system. STUART L. MEYER
naturally fallen as older ing Russia’s invitation STEPHEN HAPPEL Hollywood, Fla.
11,000,000 TJ-gross
fields get tapped out. to develop its energy Tempe, Ariz.
But producers could use 10,000,000 resources, which Mr.
hydraulic fracturing and
9,000,000
Putin has now weap- Pepper ...
horizontal drilling to ex- onized against Europe. How to Keep a Pitcher Honest And Salt
ploit shale and squeeze 8,000,000 BP and Shell will suffer Regarding Ed Condon’s op-ed
more gas out of the hefty losses as they try “Down With the Designated Hitter’’ THE WALL STREET JOURNAL
7,000,000
ground, as they have in to exit these invest- (Feb. 23): Another reason, only
the U.S. 6,000,000 ments amid pressure hinted at, to require pitchers to bat is
Europe had an esti- 5,000,000 from their home gov- the expectation of golden-rule treat-
mated 966 trillion cu- ernments. The point is ment. If a hurler has thrown high and
bic feet of technically 4,000,000 to highlight Europe’s tight to an opposing batter, that
recoverable wet natu- 3,000,000 energy masochism. pitcher might also be exposed to
ral gas resources as of Even as Gazprom some chin music when he takes his
2013, about enough to 1990 '95 2000 '05 '10 '15 '20 slowed deliveries to Eu- turn at the plate. At its best, baseball
Source: IEA Natural Gas Information retains the unique, out-of-left-field
supply the EU for some rope last fall, a British
elements that appeal to fans. How
60 years. Much of this is located in Eastern Eu- regulator nixed Shell’s plans to develop an enor- else to explain this and other Balti-
rope, including Ukraine, Poland, Romania and mous gas field in the North Sea. Reuters reported more Oriole fans’ loyalty?
Bulgaria. But France, U.K., the Netherlands and in January that the regulator has revived discus- ART FOREMAN
Germany are also sitting on shale deposits. sions with Shell as power prices climb. So maybe Winston-Salem, N.C.
A decade ago, multinational energy compa- the cold, hard reality that Europe can’t run its
nies including Chevron, Exxon Mobil, Shell economy on wind and solar is starting to set in.
Letters intended for publication should
and TotalEnergies were exploring Europe’s Europe offers another reminder to the U.S. be emailed to wsj.ltrs@wsj.com. Please
unconventional gas deposits with ambitions that blocking fossil-fuel development here include your city, state and telephone
to repeat the U.S. shale boom. Then protests won’t keep carbon “in the ground.” It merely number. All letters are subject to
against fracking erupted across the continent, hands a strategic weapon to dictators that they editing, and unpublished letters cannot “Wishes? Nope but you get
be acknowledged.
and one by one European governments sur- will turn around and use against us. three do-overs.”
.
OPINION
W
oppose Russia’s annexation of Cri- to provide Ukrainian fighters with a sistance efforts. U.S. special-opera- oppose aiding Ukrainian fighters
ith Russian forces in mea in 2014 or the seizure of terri- continuing stream of antitank mis- tions forces and Central Intelligence because they fear Russian retalia-
Kyiv, Vladimir Putin tory in eastern Ukraine by Russian- sile systems, surface-to-air missile Agency paramilitary units are the tion, being cowed by Mr. Putin is
is attempting to backed rebels beginning in 2014. The systems, electronic warfare and cy- best in the world, thanks to de- precisely how the West stumbled
overthrow the demo- Biden administration cannot let Mr. ber defense systems, unmanned cades of experience in the Balkans, into the current crisis.
cratically elected Putin dictate terms in Ukraine by aerial vehicles, artillery, small Libya, Afghanistan, Syria, Iraq and History offers an important les-
Ukrainian government and replace force. arms, ammunition, and demolition other countries. Ukraine’s borders son on resisting Russian aggres-
it with a pro-Russian regime. The Thankfully, Mr. Putin is not a materiel like explosives, fuses and with members of the North Atlantic sion. Brigadier Mohammed Yousaf,
Biden administration now needs to chess grandmaster, and Russia is mines. Treaty Organization provide ideal who headed the Afghan war for
make clear that it will oppose any vulnerable to an insurgency in locations for U.S. military and intel- Pakistan’s Directorate for Inter-Ser-
Russian-installed government in Ukraine. Ukrainian nationalism will ligence forces to aid an insurgency, vices Intelligence, said it best when
Kyiv and provide sustained military, be difficult if not impossible for Mr. Provide weapons and create havens and establish supply referring to the Soviet invasion of
economic and other aid to Ukrai- Putin to extinguish. His government lines into Ukraine. Afghanistan in the 1980s: “Death by
nian resistance efforts. is also riddled with cronyism and intelligence—and steadfast Along with military aid, the U.S. a thousand cuts—this is the time-
The U.S. and Europe failed to de- corruption, and his domestic stand- opposition to Russian- and its European partners need to honored tactic of the guerrilla army
ter a Russian invasion because sanc- ing would take a major hit if his escalate sanctions if Mr. Putin against a large conventional force.
tions and diplomacy alone do not military is bogged down. In addi- installed puppet rulers. continues to wage war in Ukraine, In Afghanistan it was the only way
deter dictators like Mr. Putin. Russia tion, Western sanctions will only and the targets should include to bring the Soviet bear to its
now needs to pay a heavy price for make Russia’s sluggish economy Russian oil and natural-gas ex- knees.”
his strategic miscalculation. and high inflation worse. In addition, the U.S. should pro- ports. They should also cut off ad- Death by a thousand cuts—from
A successful Russian overthrow The U.S. goal should be to ensure vide intelligence about Russian mil- ditional Russian banks from Swift, sanctions, political isolation, and
of the Ukrainian government would that Ukrainians—not the Kremlin— itary activity to Ukrainian fighters, the messaging network that facili- Ukrainian resistance—may yet
have far-reaching implications. It choose their political leaders and which would allow Ukraine to plan tates transactions among banks again be the best way to bring the
would erode faith in U.S. security insist that Russian forces withdraw operations, disrupt Russian com- around the world, and impose Kremlin to its knees.
commitments around the globe, from Ukraine. Assuming that Ukrai- munication and supply lines, warn sanctions against any puppet
which suffered a major blow last nians are willing to keep fighting of airborne and ground attacks, leader Moscow tries to install in Mr. Jones is senior vice president
year following the disastrous with- for their country—and every indica- and give the location of Russian Kyiv. and director of the International
drawal from Afghanistan. It would tion suggests they are—the U.S. and units. Timely information opera- Russia has ruthlessly targeted Security Program at the Center for
also be a triumph for authoritarian its Western partners should take tions are crucial to countering Rus- resistance efforts in Chechnya and Strategic and International Studies,
regimes, which have been gaining several steps immediately. sia’s disinformation and psycholog- Syria and will do so again in a former senior civilian in U.S. Spe-
momentum with 16 consecutive First, President Biden should ical operations. Ukraine. Any sanctuary used by cial Operations Command, and au-
years of declining democracy, ac- make it explicitly clear that the U.S. The U.S. shouldn’t deploy its own Ukrainian rebels, whether in Ukrai- thor of “Three Dangerous Men: Rus-
cording to Freedom House. will reject any Russian-installed military forces to Ukraine, which nian territory or NATO countries, sia, China, Iran, and the Rise of
Appeasing dictators only increases government in Kyiv. Words must be would risk escalation to nuclear could be subject to Russian attacks. Irregular Warfare.”
A
pended on industrial policy should focus on instituting a
s the U.S. pounds plowshares or government subsidies. It spending pause to stop the in-
into swords for a second Cold has come from the relative flation and winning the 2022
War, lessons from the first absence of government plan- congressional elections. Em-
one may serve those who care to ning and subsidies. This is powered by the American
consider them. The American policy hardly news. The U.S. gov- people, Republicans
of peace through strength, market- ernment provided support could pass a competi-
driven economic growth, and open for the efforts of Samuel tiveness bill next year
trade defeated the Soviet Union. Langley, the greatest avia- that makes the 2017
The emerging conflict with China, tion expert of the 1890s, in tax cuts permanent,
excepting the military threat to Tai- his effort to make America imposes work require-
wan, will for the foreseeable future first in powered flight. His ments for able-bodied
be almost entirely economic. That manned Aerodrome flopped adults receiving welfare bene-
will make it unlike the military con- into the Potomac River. It fits, expands employment, fixes
flicts with the Soviet Union and its was the Wright brothers, two America’s supply chain, and
proxies in Eastern Europe, Korea, unsubsidized but determined funds scientific research.
Vietnam, Cuba and countless global bicycle makers from Dayton, A more competitive America
insurrections. If the U.S. maintains Ohio, who flew at Kitty requires resurrecting and
peace through strength, it can lose Hawk, N.C., and changed the strengthening fiduciary stan-
this struggle only by forfeiting the world. dards to guarantee that retire-
source of its economic success: eco- There has always been an ment and mutual funds act in
MARTIN KOZLOWSKI
WORLD NEWS
Bank of Canada Is Poised to Raise Rates
Surveyed economists pressure. supply.” After Wednesday, the
Twelve economists sur- central bank has six more pol-
agree a series of veyed by The Wall Street Jour- icy decisions to issue in the
increases will begin nal, all of whom closely track calendar year.
the Canadian market, agreed While economists surveyed
to counter inflation that they expect the Bank of agree on a rate rise Wednes-
Canada to raise its benchmark day, opinions vary on how
BY PAUL VIEIRA rate by a quarter percentage many more rises are in store
point, to 0.5%, in a decision for 2022. Some economists,
OTTAWA—The Canadian scheduled for release on such as Avery Shenfeld at
economics community is unan- Wednesday at 10 a.m. Eastern CIBC Capital Markets, antici-
imous: The Bank of Canada Standard Time. pate three more increases. The
will raise its benchmark inter- The Bank of Canada cut its central bank “will want to
est rate on Wednesday, the main interest rate to 0.25% in stretch the hikes out a bit to
first in a series of increases March 2020 to provide sup- gauge how the economy is re-
this year as it begins the task port for the economy as the sponding, particularly if we do
DAVID KAWAI/BLOOMBERG NEWS
of tamping down historically pandemic hit North America. see a bout with a new variant
high inflation. It also, for the first time, en- of the Covid-19 virus later this
Should it opt to increase gaged in large-scale asset pur- year,” he said.
rates, the Bank of Canada chases, or quantitative easing, Carlos Capistran, economist
would become the second to keep longer-term borrowing at BofA Securities, expects an
Group of Seven central bank to costs steady and offer finan- additional five more increases
do so since the pandemic. The cial stability. in 2022, to take the bench-
Bank of England raised its pol- The economy has recovered mark rate to 1.75%, as it moves
icy rate twice in recent months, faster than expected. Canadian The Bank of Canada is expected to boost its benchmark interest rate by a quarter percentage point. aggressively to bring inflation
and is expected to do so again gross domestic product ad- back to its comfort zone and
in March with annual inflation vanced 6.7% annualized in the increase at the Bank of Can- self on the back foot in its ada’s central bank has tended keep pace with the Federal Re-
forecast to surpass the 7% fourth quarter, ahead of cen- ada’s Jan. 26 meeting. fight against above-target in- to be cautious, citing the deci- serve.
threshold in the second quarter. tral-bank expectations for a Instead, the central bank flation,” said economists at sion in late January to take a Finally, markets will also
The Russian invasion of 5.8% increase. Employment is opted to keep rates unchanged National Bank Financial. The pass on a rate increase while watch Wednesday’s rate deci-
Ukraine has complicated the now above pre-pandemic lev- while telling Canadians that central bank’s mandate is to telegraphing intent to push sion for guidance on when and
outlook. Some economists say els. Companies say labor higher borrowing costs were in set interest rates to achieve borrowing costs higher. Rus- how the central bank decides
the conflict might prompt the shortages are acute, and they the offing because spare capac- and maintain 2%. “There’s un- sia’s invasion of Ukraine has to reduce its balance sheet af-
Bank of Canada to take a cau- intend to accelerate wage in- ity had largely disappeared and doubtedly a very strong case added a dollop of uncertainty. ter quantitative easing. The
tious approach on further rate creases to maintain and at- inflation was at uncomfortable to be made for going big with Bank of Canada Gov. Tiff Bank of Canada halted its
increases. Others suggest the tract workers. Housing prices levels. a 50-basis-point move but Macklem, in a Feb. 9 speech, quantitative-easing program in
resulting upward pressure on have surged. Annual inflation Some economists say there we’ve not seen enough from said a series of interest-rate the fall, and since then has
energy prices will benefit Can- is at a 30-year high, surpass- is a strong case to raise rates the central bank to suggest increases were necessary “to purchased only enough new
ada as a net oil exporter, boost ing the 5% level. Wednesday by a half-point. that’s coming.” moderate growth in spending bonds to replace those that
income and add to inflationary Traders had priced in a rate The Bank of Canada “finds it- Other economists say Can- and bring demand in line with are maturing.
WORLD WATCH
ISRAEL arrangement, a process that LIBYA The appointment of Mr. UNITED KINGDOM cials and the public. The palace’s
could take years or may not be Bashagha last month is part of a Feb. 20 announcement that the
Evictions Halted on carried out at all, according to Ir Lawmakers Approve road map that also involves con- Queen Holds Virtual queen had tested positive test
Palestinian Families Amim, an advocacy group that New Government stitutional amendments and sets Events After Illness for the coronavirus virus
wasn’t involved in the court case. the date for elections within 14 prompted concern and get-well
Israel’s Supreme Court ruled For now, the four families re- Libyan lawmakers confirmed months. Queen Elizabeth II held two wishes from across Britain’s po-
that a group of families slated siding in the homes will be recog- a new transitional government The move deepened divisions virtual audiences after more litical spectrum.
for eviction from a flashpoint nized as protected tenants. Each Tuesday, a move that is likely to among Libyan factions and raised than a week of suffering cold- The country’s longest-reigning
east Jerusalem neighborhood can will deposit a largely symbolic lead to parallel administrations fears that fighting could return like symptoms from Covid-19. monarch has a series of engage-
remain in their homes for now. rent to a trust until the property’s and fuel mounting tensions in a after more than a year and a Buckingham Palace said the ments coming up as she cele-
Tuesday’s ruling could work ownership is settled. country that has been mired in half of relative calm. 95-year-old monarch held virtual brates her Platinum Jubilee, mark-
to ease tensions in Jerusalem’s Sami Arsheid, a lawyer repre- conflict for the past decade. Mr. Bashagha has formed an sessions with the ambassadors of ing 70 years on the throne. She is
Sheikh Jarrah neighborhood, senting the families’ case before Prime Minister-designate alliance with powerful east- Chad and Andorra. She canceled due to attend the Commonwealth
which helped ignite the 11 days the court, said the decision was Fathi Bashagha submitted his based commander Khalifa Haf- several sessions last week, so the Service at Westminster Abbey on
of fighting between Israel and “something huge” that ran counter cabinet to the east-based House tar. That alliance has caused sessions suggest she is recover- March 14, and then a March 26
Hamas in Gaza last year. to the previous 63 rulings by Is- of Representatives, where 92 of concerns among anti-Haftar fac- ing. memorial service, also at the Ab-
The court ruled that the fami- raeli courts on the issue of Pales- 101 lawmakers in attendance ap- tions in western Libya and their The monarch’s age, Covid-19 bey, for her late husband, Prince
lies can stay in their homes for tinian properties in Sheikh Jarrah. proved it in a vote broadcast live main foreign backer, Turkey. diagnosis and a health scare last Philip, who died in April at age 99.
now until Israel carries out a land —Associated Press from the city of Tobruk. —Associated Press year caused worry among offi- —Associated Press
Claim Your selection. This month’s must-listen titles include: podcaster Dan Carlin’s
exploration of human survival from historical and futuristic lenses, the
compelling story of African-Americans continuing the centuries-old
tradition of cowboys in America, leadership guru Hal Gregersen’s guide to
Monthly asking the right questions to produce innovative insights, and a fast-paced
thriller about a lawyer uncovering shady dealings after a death at her firm.
Audiobook
©2022 Dow Jones & Co., Inc. All rights reserved. 6DJ8791
.
DJ TRANS g 1.64%
THE WALL STREET JOURNAL.
Auto transactions by
means of payment
100%
Average dealer profit
from a new vehicle sale
$3,500
Value of auto-loan
originations
$700 billion
Companies Push
80
Cash, check or outside financing 3,000
2,500
Financing and
insurance
600
500
For March Return
Vehicle gross
60 Lease 2,000 400 BY CHIP CUTTER ments,” said Francine Katsou-
das, chief people officer at
40 1,500 300 The office return is in mo- Cisco Systems Inc., which re-
tion. opened its U.S. offices Tuesday.
1,000 200 After two years of remote “This is a moment where our
Dealer financing
20 work, companies including employees can come in.”
500 100
American Express Co., Face- Like many employers, Cisco
0 0 0
book parent Meta Platforms had planned to reopen its of-
Inc. and Wells Fargo & Co. fices far sooner. A small num-
2005 ’10 ’15 ’20 2005 ’10 ’15 ’20 2005 ’10 ’15 ’20 plan broader office reopenings ber of its U.S. employees re-
Sources: Edmunds (transactions); J.D. Power (profit); New York Fed Consumer Credit Panel, Equifax (originations) this month. Many executives turned last summer, and the
say they are uncertain about company had scheduled a
what the future may hold, but broader return for February of
BY BEN EISEN
they can relocate, while a few once naturally have been in to test the entire population
expatriates have decided in re- Hong Kong. Meanwhile, they repeatedly in March. For many
cent months to resign and are struggling to persuade parents, the prospect of forced
move home. Others are consid- some new candidates to relo- separation if a child tests posi-
ering options that could split cate to the city. tive is particularly concerning.
up their families for months or “There’s been a lot of re- Two senior capital-markets
more as they try to move their quests from bankers to their bankers at U.S. investment
children into more stable department heads asking to be banks said their wives and
schooling and away from the transferred to other cities such Customers purchase Covid-19 test kits in Hong Kong. children would move this
risk of mandatory quarantine. as Singapore or back to their month to Singapore and the
PROPERTY REPORT The pressure is hitting the home countries,” said Eugenia nounced that they will be liv- strictest quarantine rules and a U.S., respectively, to flee Hong
Demand for science industry when it is fighting a Bae, a Hong Kong-based re- ing with the virus.” stop-start approach to in-per- Kong’s zero-Covid policy. One
war for talent amid a long- cruiter for banks and invest- Hong Kong was an oasis son schooling has left it more said he might follow his family
lab buildings soars term upsurge in Chinese capi- ment funds. “They want to go earlier in the pandemic. Since isolated just as other global fi- if there were no signs of im-
during the Covid-19 tal raising. A broader boom in home, to places like the U.S., then, a zero-Covid approach nancial hubs such as London, provement in Hong Kong’s
pandemic. B6 global banking has pushed up France, Japan and South Ko- that has featured monthslong New York and Singapore are strict virus stance and that
bonuses as it has yielded re- rea, or cities that have an- flight bans, some of the world’s reopening. Please turn to page B11
.
PORTUGUESE NAVY/EPA/SHUTTERSTOCK
Bank of New York JLL...............................B6
Shell..........................A12
Mellon.....................A12 JPMorgan Chase.......B11
Silverstein Properties B6
BioNTech.....................A3 K Six Flags Entertainment
BlackRock..................B11 Kamaz........................B12 .....................................B3
BP..............................A12 Kohl's...........................B2 Standard Chartered..B11
C-I Kojima Industries.......B3 Starwood Capital........B6
Centripetal Networks.A4 L-P Stellantis.....................B3
Cerberus Capital Stonemont Financial..B6
Leidos..........................B5
Management.............B6 LendLease ................... B6 T-W
Charter Communications Live Nation Target.............A4,B1,B12
...................................A13 Entertainment........A13 Tatneft ...................... B11
Chevron ....................... B1 Macy's.......................B12 Tesla.....................B3,A14
Cisco Systems.......A4,B1 Mastercard................A12 Toyota Motor..............B3
Citigroup................B1,B5
The Felicity Ace fire was one of the first on a major vehicle carrier loaded with a substantial cargo of electric vehicles.
Meta Platforms...A13,B1 Ulta Beauty...............B12
BUSINESS NEWS
Jeep to Offer
Electric SUVs
The move comes Chrysler Automobiles NV, re-
vealed new targets to reduce
as auto makers face carbon emissions and boost
pressure to shift from electric-vehicle sales.
“The competition is fierce,
combustion engines and we are ready to take on
the fight for the top spot,” Mr.
BY NORA ECKERT Tavares said.
AND CHRISTINA ROGERS As governments globally
tighten restrictions on tailpipe
Jeep, a historic American pollutants, major car manufac-
brand that has long been turers like Stellantis are under
known for its rugged sport- pressure to shift away from
utility vehicles, plans to offer the combustion-engine vehi-
a line of fully electric SUVs in cles that have long ruled the
the coming years, as part of a car business.
broader strategic road map The U.S. and other coun-
REBECCA COOK/REUTERS
unveiled Tuesday by parent tries overseas are also trying
company Stellantis NV. to speed the transition by of-
The brand will get its first fering tax credits to buyers
all-electric model in the first that lower the higher upfront
half of next year, and by 2025, costs of purchasing an electric
Jeep will offer a comprehen- vehicle.
sive line of battery-powered Mr. Tavares has been out- By 2030, the company said it wants half of its sales in the U.S. and all of its sales in Europe to be fully electric models.
SUVs, covering a range of spoken on the need for gov-
sizes and price points, said ernment incentives, arguing which also include European stiffening competition from ing outlining new financial but it is still heavily depen-
Stellantis Chief Executive Car- that the costs of developing names like Peugeot, Alfa Ro- Tesla Inc. and other new elec- targets. By 2030, Stellantis dent on North America and
los Tavares during a presenta- and building battery-powered meo and Maserati. tric-vehicle startups like Riv- said it aims to more than dou- Europe for its earnings.
tion in Amsterdam. models are still much higher The company’s stock de- ian Automotive Inc. that have ble revenue globally to $337 Mr. Tavares said he is aim-
Jeep will still sell gasoline- than conventional gas-pow- clined nearly 8%. captured the minds and wal- billion, while sustaining dou- ing for a better geographical
engine SUVs, but the move is ered cars and trucks. Mr. Tavares, the former PSA lets of investors. ble-digit operating margins balance, in part by elevating
intended to give buyers the By 2030, the company said Group chief who has led Stel- Mr. Tavares has previously through the entire period. the company’s luxury brands
option of purchasing an emis- it wants half of its sales in the lantis for a little more than a said Stellantis plans to spend Additionally, Stellantis in China.
sions-free version. U.S. and all of its sales in Eu- year now, is racing to catch up more than $35.5 billion on plans to further diversify into North America and Europe
Other well-known Detroit rope to be fully electric mod- with General Motors Co., electric vehicles through 2025, new business lines and boost currently generate about 85%
brands, like Ram, Chrysler and els. Volkswagen AG and other ri- a figure that is roughly on par revenue overseas, including in of the company’s global reve-
Dodge, will also shift more of Now one of the world’s vals that have in recent years with its competitors. China where both PSA and nue. By 2030, he aims for
their lineups to electrics as largest auto manufacturers, taken bold steps to transition On Tuesday, he offered a Fiat Chrysler have long lagged those two regions to be a
Stellantis, a car company Stellantis sold 6.5 million vehi- their global operations to elec- more detailed look at the com- behind rivals in sales. smaller percentage—about
formed last year through the cles last year through its col- tric vehicles. Traditional auto pany’s longer-range plans in Stellantis posted strong 72%—as it grows sales and
merger of PSA Group and Fiat lection of automotive brands, makers are also confronting the U.S. and overseas, includ- revenue and profit in 2021, share in other markets.
ited with helping Domino’s the chain is no longer benefit- each for carryout orders.
grow its sales and helping to ing from federal stimulus Mr. Allison said that Mr.
keep the company’s profit mar- checks that Americans re- Weiner will continue to play a
gins intact by refusing to pay ceived last year. A number of key role in updating the com-
third-party delivery services to restaurant chains credited the pany’s menu and advertising,
handle its pizzas. Domino’s also stimulus payments with fuel- as he has done since joining
gained sales during the pan- ing sales last year. the company as its chief mar-
demic when customers were The Ann Arbor, Mich., com- keting officer in 2008.
sheltering in place and order- pany’s shares ended flat after Domino’s separately named
JAMES J. SHERIN ANNA SMULOWITZ SCHUTZ
ing more pizza from home. falling 7% in premarket trad- Sandeep Reddy, currently the INSTRUCTOR ARTISTIC DIRECTOR
Now, Domino’s faces more ing Tuesday. chief financial officer of Six SR. SYST. ANALYST, PROG. THE TEREZIN PROJECT
competition as cases attributed Domino’s said that it had Flags Entertainment Corp., as
to the Covid-19 Omicron variant serious difficulties staffing its next CFO, effective April 1.
fall and local governments drop stores during the quarter, par- Domino’s will also transition
masking and proof of vaccine ticularly among delivery driv- board Chairman David Brandon
requirements for businesses ers. The shortages hurt the to a newly created post of exec-
such as restaurants. Industry ability for Domino’s restau- utive chairman, effective May 1.
data has shown that consumers rants to deliver pizza to cus- Domino’s reported adjusted
dine out more when Covid-19- tomers, executives said. The earnings of $4.25 a share for 2022 - 2023
related restrictions ease. chain said it is reviewing how the most recent quarter, behind
NADINE LEE WYNN MICHAEL ZURBRIGEN
Domino’s U.S. same-store to make its delivery jobs more analysts’ average estimate of BROKER, TEAM NADINE LLC CEO
sales rose 1% in the three attractive, including by keep- $4.28 a share, according to REALT., KW REALTY L. NORMAN EURO-WALL SYSTEMS, LLC
months ended Jan. 2, missing ing its drivers on the road FactSet. Revenue fell 1% from a
analysts’ expectations. The earning tips for more of their year earlier to $1.34 billion.
company said demand remains shifts. The company said it is —Kimberly Chin
strong, though executives said having drivers fold fewer pizza contributed to this article.
.
TECHNOLOGY WSJ.com/Tech
BY DENNY JACOB ing $7.24 billion in sales for the thing that really has en- billion in December. Marc Benioff following the de- $6 billion
the quarter after Salesforce is- dured is I think this trend to- Its shares are up about 24% parture of co-CEO Keith Block
Business software provider sued guidance below expecta- wards digital transformation,” over the last two years, but in February 2020. 5
Salesforce.com Inc. logged tions late last year. co-Chief Executive Bret Taylor down 16% so far this year In November 2021, the
higher revenue in the fourth For fiscal 2023, the com- said in an interview. He added, amid a broad tech selloff company elevated Mr. Taylor 4
quarter and raised its annual pany is now expecting sales to “The demand environment spurred by inflationary con- to the role of co-CEO and vice
sales outlook, as the company between $32 billion and $32.1 continues to be very strong.” cerns and Russia’s invasion of chairman to serve alongside 3
looks to maintain its leader- billion, an increase from its Salesforce thrived as the Ukraine. Mr. Benioff. He previously
ship role in cloud-based ser- previous range between $31.7 pandemic pushed entire indus- Shares of Salesforce were served as president and chief 2
vices that have expanded in billion and $31.8 billion. It also tries and governments to pur- up roughly 4% in after-hours operating officer.
response to the pandemic. raised its outlook for the cur- chase digital tools as they trading. The stock closed at Salesforce logged a loss of 1
The San Francisco-based rent quarter. shifted to remote work. The $208.89 Tuesday, down 1.6%. $28 million for the fourth
company said its sales rose to “This year has just been company expanded its arsenal The fourth-quarter results quarter, down from a gain of
0
$7.33 billion for the three characterized by a lot of com- of services after it agreed to were the first under Sales- $267 million in the year-ago
months ended Jan. 31, com- plexity, from the pandemic, to buy messaging company Slack force’s second attempt at its period. Adjusted earnings of FY2020 ’21 ’22
pared with $5.82 billion a year inflation, supply chain, and Technologies Inc. in a cash- co-CEO structure. The com- 84 cents a share were below Note: Fiscal year ended Jan. 31
earlier. Analysts were expect- now, this war in Europe, but and-stock deal valued at $27.7 pany has been led by CEO analysts’ expectations of $1. Sources: S&P Capital IQ; the company
BUSINESS NEWS
BY KRISTIN BROUGHTON saying they planned to do so for tomers. Many companies over
Push For a Office occupancy rate in 10 major cities over the past year
60%
For the week ending Feb. 23 Covid-19’s retreat across the
U.S. Many states and local gov-
ernments have pulled back mit-
the tight labor market is im-
pacting business leaders’ will-
ingness to be more aggressive
Return to
Austin
igation efforts in recent weeks, about having their employees
Houston and the Centers for Disease come back to work,” said Owen
50 Control and Prevention last D. Thomas, CEO of office land-
The Office
Dallas
week said masks aren’t neces- lord Boston Properties Inc., on
10 city average sary indoors where Covid-19 is a call with analysts at the end
circulating at low levels. New of January.
40 Philadelphia York City could lift its vaccine Improving Covid conditions
Continued from page B1 10 city average requirement for restaurants, and rising vaccination levels
Los Angeles
cases, and executives felt confi- fitness centers, and entertain- among workers has given many
dent employees could safely re- 30 Washington DC ment venues March 7 if current executives confidence to push
turn, Ms. Katsoudas said. trends continue, Mayor Eric for a return. Citigroup Inc. re-
Should cases rise once more New York Adams said Sunday. cently asked its vaccinated em-
or other circumstances call for Office attendance has ticked ployees at its U.S. offices that
sending employees home, the 20 Chicago
up recently, though it remains hadn’t previously reopened to
company can adapt, she said. San Jose sparse in many places. In 10 return at least two days a week
Cisco used to ask teams to map major U.S. cities, offices were beginning March 21. Many of
out their work schedules over 10 San Francisco on average 36.8% occupied as its employees in cities like New
the coming 90 days; Ms. Kat- of late February, up from about York, Boston and Chicago re-
2021 ’22 0 10 20 30 40 50
soudas said the company now 33% earlier in the month, ac- turned last year. “Although
considers that horizon too Source: Kastle Systems cording to Kastle Systems, a se- Covid-19 may never fully go
long. Instead, she encourages curity company that tracks how away, we are seeing promising
teams to plan in 30-day incre- Bosses are preaching flexibility, in hybrid roles to commute to “After a very long wait, it many people swipe into build- developments. Cases are
ments. careful not to alienate employ- the office at least once a week. will be good for many of us to ings. Some executives note that steadily decreasing across the
“If something changes, we ees who have come to appreci- It will begin what it calls its see each other again in person Americans seem willing to go U.S., and our vaccinated work-
know exactly how to navigate ate the upsides of remote work. full “Amex Flex” program on and enjoy the connections, col- to sporting events, live theater ers face less risk of serious ill-
through that,” she said. To ease employees back into March 15; in this program, laboration, and variety in our performances and restaurants, ness from the virus,” Sara
Many companies, including the rhythm of in-person work, many employees will work, on daily routines,” Stephen J. while still avoiding the office. Wechter, head of human re-
Cisco, are leaving it up to American Express initiated a average, one to three days a Squeri, CEO and chairman of “People are certainly com- sources at Citi, said in a note
teams and managers to deter- soft opening of its New York week in an office, depending on American Express, said in a fortable doing a lot of things in on LinkedIn last week.
mine when and how often em- office on Tuesday. The com- their jobs and team arrange- February memo to employees. person, yet they’re not coming —Ben Eisen contributed to
ployees come into the office. pany is encouraging employees ments, a spokeswoman said. The push to reopen reflects back to the office. So I do think this article.
Square can help — just like we’ve helped 70,000-seat SoFi Stadium
in Los Angeles.
Whether it’s taking payments, expediting orders, managing staff,
integrating data, building customer relationships — or all of the
above — find your customized, connected tools with Square.
square.com/large-businesses
.
ObsidianEnergy OBE 8.83 -2.2
Daseke
DevonEnergy DVN
DSKE 13.17 -2.3
60.74 -0.5
OccidentalPetrolWt OXY.WS
OccidentalPetrol OXY
26.11
47.83
11.4
7.0
Williams
Lows
WMB 32.08 1.2
ChainBridgeIWt CBRGW
Chase CCF
0.29 -4.5
86.69 -5.2
GraniteConstr GVA
GranitePointMtg GPMT
27.84 -7.3
10.73 -2.9
142.09 -0.9 ChavantCapWt CLAYW 0.21 -5.8 GreatElmCap GECC 14.59 -8.8
DiamondbkEner FANG Ovintiv OVV 47.90 2.8
ENI
EOG Rscs
E
EOG
32.11 1.8
117.44 1.3
PDC Energy
PaloAltoNtwks PANW
PDCE 69.05
598.96
3.6
-2.9
AAON AAON 54.74 -2.4
ATI PhysTherapy ATIP 1.77 -3.6
Check-Cap CHEK
ChurchillVII Wt CVII.WS
0.39 -37.0
0.47 -3.0
GridDynamics GDYN
HDFC Bank HDB
10.48 -12.8
60.00 -2.9
EQT EQT 25.22 5.5 PampaEnergia PAM 23.30 10.7 ATIPhysTherapyWt ATIP.WS 0.24 -9.9 ClarivatePfdA CLVTpA 59.41 -2.5 HarpoonTherap HARP 3.75 -2.4
EC 17.14 2.5 ATNI 32.27 -1.5 CLVT 14.14 -4.3 HawksAcqnWt HWKZ.WS 0.24 ...
% * +,
% ""
Ecopetrol PattersonUTIEn PTEN 14.88 -1.9 ATN Intl Clarivate
8iAcqn2 LAX 9.81 ... PembinaPipeline PBA 35.37 1.8 AdaptimmuneTher ADAP 2.38 -7.3 ClarusTherap CRXT 0.79 -14.1 HealthcareRealty HR 25.61 2.6
!"#$ %&#!'
()
!**"+'
,--* .' ()
TEXAS
#""
$ $
!
" #
%" NOTABLE ! "#$ %&'(
COMMERCIAL #) * +", -"
PROPERTIES .! "$ * $,$,*" " "$"
EVERY WEDNESDAY ('/ " ""
**$" $ 0" 01 (! ('' 234 $*
(800) 366-3975
" $$
""
sales.realestate@wsj.com
For more information visit:
! wsj.com/classifieds
)
) ""
"-"$ $
© 2022 Dow Jones & Company, Inc.
All Rights Reserved.
5$ 6.%7 &%.4('(
.
COMMODITIES wsj.com/market-data/commodities
Showroom
To advertise: 800-366-3975 or WSJ.com/classifieds
NatWest Markets
Metropolitan Life Global Funding I
NWG
…
0.800
0.950
2.25
2.00
Aug. 12, ’24
July 2, ’25
97
52
–4
–3
80
n.a.
Bank of New Zealand BZLNZ 2.285 2.41 Jan. 27, ’27 84 –2 80
Comcast CMCSA 4.750 3.64 March 1, ’44 143 –2 n.a.
Citigroup C 6.625 3.46 June 15, ’32 175 –1 n.a.
PORSCHE
Guardian Life Global Funding GUARDN 1.250 2.12 May 13, ’26 57 –1 n.a.
International Business Machines IBM 4.000 3.63 June 20, ’42 139 –1 140
Nationwide Building Society NWIDE 1.500 2.46 Oct. 13, ’26 86 –1 82
Transocean RIG 6.800 12.81 March 15, ’38 59.500 1.50 58.000
FirstEnergy FE 7.375 4.04 Nov. 15, ’31 126.500 1.00 124.811
Lumen Technologies LUMN 7.600 8.87 Sept. 15, ’39 88.799 0.86 88.250
Occidental Petroleum OXY 6.450 4.66 Sept. 15, ’36 118.742 0.84 115.969
Venture Global Calcasieu Pass VENTGL 4.125 4.14 Aug. 15, ’31 99.875 0.68 97.875
Ford Motor F 7.450 4.22 July 16, ’31 124.751 0.56 122.875
Below are the top federally insured offers available nationwide according to Bankrate.com's
//,
45,((6)7'2 89 1&&1 , *('.:,0 5
''&&( ) :&(;)(- <&&: <=& ')
!"2 3
2
weekly survey of highest yields. For latest offers and reviews of these financial institutions, please ,, >&(=.&1 ' +& ?0)/<
*)1@
visit bankrate.com/banking/reviews. Information is believed to be reliable, but not guaranteed.
:()</.)' ',=&1
<,,
A/0<
4
2
=,0/,A0& ,, *0,;)(- >&(=.&1 +,
High yield savings
700 A& 0&=&(,&< ,.()11 +&
3
Yield A/1'&113 %&B/(&1 , C,1&(D1
Bank Bank Yield
<&(&& ' ?)-:/&( >.&'.& )( ,
Phone number Minimum (%) Phone number Minimum (%)
(&0,&< ;&0< ,'< E 6&,(1 ); .)-:/&(
2
2
Money market and savings account Six-month CD &''&&(' &F:&(&'.&3 G0&(',=&062
2 2
2
Live Oak Bank $1 0.60 Luana Savings Bank $1,000 0.65
700 ,..&: , H,.+&0)(D1 <&(&& '
?)-:/&( >.&'.& ,'< 6&,(1 );
@
(866) 518-0286 (800) 666-2012
.)-:/&( &''&&(' &F:&(&'.&3
3
3 !
"
Comenity Direct $100 0.60 Colorado Federal Savings Bank $5,000 0.62
C/1 +,=& +& ;)00)7' &F:&(&'.&I
J)(' 7+ <,, , +& :&,A6&
#
"2
$
2 %
(833) 755-4354 (877) 484-2372
!"# 1.,0&K J)(' 7+ .)-:0&F ++
2
&
Barclays Bank $0 0.55 Live Oak Bank $2,500 0.60 BUSINESS OPPORTUNITIES $%&'( )*+'+ =)0/-& <,, ::&0'&12 <,,
(888) 720-8756 (866) 518-0286
=1/,0L,)'2 ,'< /0L' +& <,, ;)(
'
3 '
(
0,(& 1.,0& -,.+'& 0&,(''
"
One-month CD One-year CD ,::0.,)'1K &1'' ,'< ):&(,'
) "
"
()A/1 <1(A/&< 161&-1K
Colorado Federal Savings Bank $5,000 0.25 Colorado Federal Savings Bank $5,000 0.90 &=&0):' /1' ?0)/< *0,;)(- H@
"
"
(877) 484-2372 (877) 484-2372 ,, >&(=.&1K M1' H ,, &.+
"
Lone Star Bank $1,000 0.20 Live Oak Bank $2,500 0.85 0& ,<)):2 >(&,-' ,::0.,)' *P
)
"
(713) 358-9400 (866) 518-0286
0& >:,( ;)( ,.B/(' ,'<
:().&11' <,, '.0/<' 1(/./(&2
"
)
"
State Bank of India California $1,000 0.15 Popular Direct $10,000 0.85
/'1(/./(&<2 1&-@1(/./(&2
"
<)./-&'2 =<&)2 ,/<)2 ,'< ')-.
(877) 707-1995 (800) 274-5696 !" #
$$
<,,K M1' ,'< <&=&0):' ):&'
)
"
"
Two-month CD Two-year CD
1)/(.& &.+')0)&1 1/.+ ,1
,;,2
'
,<)):2 =&2 *(&1)2 )( >:,(K
Colorado Federal Savings Bank $5,000 0.25 Merrick Bank $25,000 1.25
)
"
%/A62 *6+)'2 ,'< H,1+2 ,=,2
(877) 484-2372
Lone Star Bank $1,000 0.20
(866) 638-6851
Live Oak Bank $2,500 1.10
*6+)'2 ,'< >.,0,K %&0,)',0
<,,A,1&1 ,'< B/&(6 ,/+)('
4>NO ,'< 8)>NO <,,A,1&K
*
"
)
"
"
" "
(713) 358-9400 (866) 518-0286
?)'&F/,0 A,'<1 ;(,-&7)( ;)(
State Bank of India California $1,000 0.15 Popular Direct $10,000 1.10 +, !&-
%. &# /+/ 0 -$ #1$. 2,/
! "
!"#$%&' '#(!)"$* !"# $%& %'$ &F:0)(&P&F:0) <,, ::&0'&1 ,'<
) +
"
"
(877) 707-1995 (800) 274-5696
(
) *
(+() 1&(=&(0&11 .)-:/'K + .)<&
,(
(- !
. / "
. B/,062 ,/)-,&< &1'2 ,'< )+&(
)
Three-month CD Five-year CD #$% & #'%
&''&&(' A&1 :(,..&K
"
0
1 02 3(
)4 *(4 G(.+&.' ,'< <&0=&(' A/1'&11 *
" 3% %
2
Luana Savings Bank $1,000 0.60 Popular Direct $10,000 1.51
(800) 666-2012 (800) 274-5696 5$-
2 # (* 6 $7 8
2
*()
1)0/)'1 +()/+ , .0)/<@',=& ,-2 %
%
)
0
(4 (2(.
&'=()'-&'K C,',' &'<@)@&'<
""
"
" %.
Colorado Federal Savings Bank $5,000 0.40 Luana Savings Bank $1,000 1.31 !
.
90: 02 CAREERS 0;& .6.0& &=>&.Q:1 ;)( GJ> P%. ")
(877) 484-2372 (800) 666-2012 ! " # $%# $% &!!!' +)1&< ';(,1(/./(& ,'< -(,)' );
" $
"2
(&()*+&)!'(, ---)./) &'&(:(1& 7)(0),<K (=' +&
First Internet Bank of Indiana $1,000 0.35 Live Oak Bank $2,500 1.30 ;88
2)4
<()
(
2
*(2
"
2
<&=&0):-&' ,'< /1& ); '&7 ,'<
2 *
(888) 873-3424 (866) 518-0286 )
$% 8 !
. / =2
>
( 8 &??
1&0;@1&(=.& ))0' ) 1/::)( +&
2 *)
):&(,' -)<&0 ;)( +& .0)/<K *
"
"
High yield jumbos - Minimum is $100,000 ! ! " H/0<'2 -,','2 ,'< 1.,0'
" *"
2
# $%#
$ & '( .0)/< )(.+&1(,)' :0,;)(-1 /1'
Money market and savings account Six-month CD )
* + * )*
2
, !' !
* !
+& 0,&1 ):&'@1)/(.& &.+')0)&1
2 "
2
' * - & . ,'< +&0:' -,',& 1,'<,(<1 ,'<
Connexus Credit Union
(800) 845-5025
0.85 Luana Savings Bank
(800) 666-2012
0.75
THE , # / 0# - /,(<@(,01 ;)( .0)/< &'=()'-&'1K
-
) *
"
2 "
MARKETPLACE
#
>/::)(' ?)''/)/1 >&./(6
# $ -,- & '1 ?)-:0,'.& 'Q:1 ,'< ?)1
2
CFG Community Bank 0.63 Colorado Federal Savings Bank 0.62
- - ,
, Q:-L,)'K M1' .)';/(,)'
)
!% !$ S/)
(888) 205-8388 (877) 484-2372 -, 23 43 & -
S/
"
-,',&-&'2 )(.+&1(,)'2 ,'<
Luana Savings Bank 0.60 Live Oak Bank 0.60 1 - & -
#
/1
5 -,',&-&' ))01 ) &'1/(& .0)/< 4$0)
@
"
'
(800) 666-2012 (866) 518-0286
ADVERTISE TODAY 6) -/ 5- ,$ &
&'=()'-&'1 -&& ):&(,)',0 ,'<
!%)
5
1 1&./(6 1,'<,(<1K ,'< *,('&('
'
,#
!%)
One-month CD One-year CD (800) 366-3975
#1
5 7+ )/( ';)(-,)' >&./(6 )' +&
!%
"
Colorado Federal Savings Bank 0.25 Colorado Federal Savings Bank 0.90 7' '-
3
& !# 6, 4/ <&';.,)'2 ,',06112 ,'< -,)' %
$
2 $
& 7' 0# - - ); (11 (&0,&< ) ?0)/< >&(=.&13
2 12
)
(877) 484-2372 (877) 484-2372 -
- - & -, /00@-& &0&.)--/' :&(-&<3
!%
" *@
Lone Star Bank 0.20 Live Oak Bank 0.85 For more information visit: & /
G::06 ,
2
wsj.com/classifieds
0 & - 0# - +:1IPP.,(&&(13(&&'&()'3.)-2
(713) 358-9400 (866) 518-0286 389:;9:: 3 3
"
$
2"
(&;&(&'.& .)<& %3 *&( F&./=& %
2 $
2
,3
State Bank of India California 0.15 Popular Direct 0.85
Q(<&(2 %&&'&()' (&B/(&1 ,00 M3>3
'
2
"
(877) 707-1995 (800) 274-5696 &-:0)6&&1 ) A& ;/006 =,..',&<
43%3
,,'1 ?QR @S2 /'0&11 +&6 ,(&
"
,5#@S62
Two-month CD Two-year CD 0 $ 12 0&,006 &'0&< ) ,' ,..)--)<,)'
"
0.25 1.25 ;)( -&<.,0 )( (&0)/1 (&,1)'13
Colorado Federal Savings Bank
(877) 484-2372
Merrick Bank
(866) 638-6851
0 - .
"
3 $
Lone Star Bank 0.20 Live Oak Bank 1.10 (PP
3
"
32
766&
(713) 358-9400 (866) 518-0286
"3
4 5 1.
State Bank of India California 0.15 Popular Direct 1.10 3 + 6,
!" ! 3 +
(877) 707-1995 (800) 274-5696 6, "< "< -, -#- -
6 0 . 8
$ & - 3
Three-month CD Five-year CD #
$
%& & '& + * )*
, !' COMMERCIAL REAL ESTATE
Luana Savings Bank 0.70 Popular Direct 1.51 (
)#* & & '& * - & .
, # / 0# -
(800) 666-2012 (800) 274-5696 +
&
5 #
!+(
Colorado Federal Savings Bank 0.40 Luana Savings Bank 1.41 -#- & $
,
1 $ $%' !+(
(877) 484-2372 (800) 666-2012 -
First Internet Bank of Indiana 0.35 Live Oak Bank 1.30 ( ' ! 8
$%#
!+(1
5 '32
MARKETS DIGEST
EQUITIES
Dow Jones Industrial Average S&P 500 Index Nasdaq Composite Index
Last Year ago Last Year ago Last Year ago
33294.95 t 597.65, or 1.76% Trailing P/E ratio 18.47 31.94 4306.26 t 67.68, or 1.55% Trailing P/E ratio * 23.83 43.74 13532.46 t 218.94, or 1.59% Trailing P/E ratio *† 31.76 38.46
High, low, open and close for each P/E estimate * 17.90 20.67 High, low, open and close for each P/E estimate * 19.49 22.47 High, low, open and close for each P/E estimate *† 24.78 29.12
trading day of the past three months. Dividend yield 2.09 1.89 trading day of the past three months. Dividend yield * 1.41 1.50 trading day of the past three months. Dividend yield *† 0.74 0.75
All-time high 36799.65, 01/04/22 All-time high 4796.56, 01/03/22 All-time high: 16057.44, 11/19/21
t
Greenwood Village, CO 877-484-2372 year ago Yen Kazakhstan tenge .002043 489.47 12.5 Bahrain dinar 2.6525 .3770 0.01
Federal-funds –0.10 0.00 Macau pataca .1243 8.0430 0.1 Egypt pound .0636 15.7133 0.02
target rate BrioDirect 0.55% –14
Malaysia ringgit .2385 4.1930 0.6 Israel shekel .3101 3.2243 3.7
Montebello, NY 877-369-2746 1 3 6 1 2 3 5 7 10 20 30 2021 2022
–0.20 New Zealand dollar .6757 1.4799 1.2 Kuwait dinar 3.3010 .3029 0.1
TAB Bank 0.55% month(s) years
M A M J J A S O N D J FM Pakistan rupee .00563 177.625 0.8 Oman sul rial 2.5972 .3850 0.01
Ogden, UT 800-355-3063 maturity Philippines peso .0195 51.360 0.7 Qatar rial .2747 3.641 –0.03
2021 2022
Sources: Tradeweb ICE U.S. Treasury Close; Tullett Prebon; Dow Jones Market Data Singapore dollar .7365 1.3577 0.7 Saudi Arabia riyal .2665 3.7519 –0.1
Yield/Rate (%) 52-Week Range (%) 3-yr chg South Korea won .0008296 1205.41 1.4 South Africa rand .0649 15.4070 –3.4
Interest rate Last (l)Week ago Low 0 2 4 6 8 High (pct pts)
Corporate Borrowing Rates and Yields Sri Lanka rupee .0049569 201.74 –0.6
Close Net Chg % Chg YTD%Chg
Federal-funds rate target 0.00-0.25 0.00-0.25 0.00 l 0.25 -2.25 Taiwan dollar .03561 28.080 1.3
Yield (%) 52-Week Total Return (%) Thailand baht .03057 32.710 –1.6 WSJ Dollar Index 90.44 0.43 0.47 1.00
Prime rate* 3.25 3.25 3.25 l 3.25 -2.25 Bond total return index Close Last Week ago High Low 52-wk 3-yr
Libor, 3-month 0.51 0.49 0.11 l 0.52 -2.09 Sources: Tullett Prebon, Dow Jones Market Data
U.S. Treasury, Bloomberg 2352.600 1.650 1.850 1.960 0.780 –1.198 3.432
Money market, annual yield 0.07 0.07 0.07 l 0.10 -0.54
Five-year CD, annual yield 0.43 0.43 0.41 l 0.48 -1.57 U.S. Treasury Long, Bloomberg 4294.930 2.170 2.280 2.410 1.720 1.437 7.619 Commodities
30-year mortgage, fixed† 4.29 4.19 3.00 l 4.29 -0.11 Aggregate, Bloomberg 2190.840 2.270 2.410 2.470 1.340 –1.955 3.552 Tuesday 52-Week YTD
Pricing trends on someClose
raw materials, or commodities
Net chg % Chg High Low % Chg % chg
15-year mortgage, fixed† 3.49 3.42 2.28 l 3.55 -0.33 Fixed-Rate MBS, Bloomberg 2158.490 2.480 2.580 2.640 1.560 –2.598 2.097
Jumbo mortgages, $647,200-plus† 4.33 4.19 3.03 l 4.33 -0.19 DJ Commodity 1139.84 47.02 4.30 1139.84 794.01 40.14 20.46
High Yield 100, ICE BofA 3355.167 5.077 5.263 5.390 3.162 0.426 4.102 Refinitiv/CC CRB Index 280.86 11.78 4.38 280.86 184.08 47.83 20.86
Five-year adj mortgage (ARM)† 2.93 2.93 2.82 l 3.43 -1.41
Muni Master, ICE BofA 585.402 1.630 1.680 1.730 0.687 –0.693 3.052 Crude oil, $ per barrel 103.41 7.69 8.03 103.41 57.76 73.07 37.50
New-car loan, 48-month 3.58 3.55 3.41 l 4.12 -1.09
Bankrate.com rates based on survey of over 4,800 online banks. *Base rate posted by 70% of the nation's largest EMBI Global, J.P. Morgan 844.527 6.082 5.659 6.082 4.516 –6.524 1.501 Natural gas, $/MMBtu 4.573 0.171 3.88 6.312 2.456 61.08 22.60
banks.† Excludes closing costs.
Sources: FactSet; Dow Jones Market Data; Bankrate.com Sources: J.P. Morgan; Bloomberg Fixed Income Indices; ICE Data Services
Gold, $ per troy oz. 1942.40 43.00 2.26 1942.40 1677.70 12.08 6.29
.
MARKETS
investors guessing at the value –50 VanEck of their value on Monday. in his mouth. “The deeper they
of the Russian assets. Russia ETF So far, investors have con- could get into my pockets, the
VanEck Russia ETF, a tinued to put money into the happier I think the guy was,”
–60 iShares MSCI
nearly $700 million fund, Russia ETF Russia-focused funds. Van- Mr. Hebert said. He has since
plans to modify the usual pro- Eck’s ETF has seen about submitted a complaint through
cess by which funds create –70 $556 million of inflows this the Lexus website.
and redeem shares, using a year, including nearly $261 A spokesman for the auto
special basket of securities. –80 million on Friday, its biggest dealership said: “We strive to
BlackRock Inc. suspended the single-day inflow in more make every sales experience
Jan. 2022 Feb. March
creation of new shares of its than a decade, according to excellent and obviously value
iShares MSCI Russia ETF, a Moscow’s stock exchange has been closed this week. Source: FactSet FactSet. The iShares fund, our reputation.” He said the
roughly $105 million fund. meanwhile, has gotten a net dealership didn’t know Mr. He-
Direxion Funds will liquidate at CFRA. apiece versus a NAV of $7.83. period of time, we’re likely to $20 million from investors bert was dissatisfied, citing an
and close its leveraged Russia The net asset value of an Russia’s stock market index see the leading ETFs as good this year. online survey in which he gave
ETF, Direxion Daily Russia ETF is derived from a per- fell 27% last week, its biggest proxies for where the market That doesn’t necessarily the sales experience high
Bull 2x Shares, on March 11. share calculation of its con- drop on record, according to is headed,” Mr. Rosenbluth mean investors are bullish on marks. The spokesman said,
“It is in the best interests stituents. FactSet. Russia’s central bank said. “The same thing hap- Russia. “There is nothing we can rea-
of the fund and its sharehold- Usually, market makers hasn’t indicated how long it pened in Greece in 2015.” Mr. Rosenbluth added that sonably do about the market
ers to liquidate and terminate keep the price of the funds in will keep the stock market Greece closed its stock some of the inflows are at- clearing price” that resulted in
the fund, as it could not con- line with the asset value by closed. market during its financial tributable to investors short- the vehicle selling for above
duct its business and opera- creating and redeeming shares Investors still appeared to crisis for more than a month ing, or betting against, the the suggested retail price.
tions in an economically effi- as needed. In this case, since be using the VanEck and MSCI that year. Yet speculators funds. When investors short A spokeswoman for Lexus
cient manner over the long- shares of various Russian ETFs as a proxy for where used a U.S.-listed ETF, the an ETF, shares are created by said the customer-service team
term,” Direxion said. stocks are frozen, the funds Russia markets are headed, a Global X FTSE Greek 20 ETF, market makers specifically “is aware of the complaint and
More changes could be are unable to update their as- role ETFs have performed as a way of estimating where for that purpose, he added, is actively working with the
coming for other funds. Index set values. when other countries closed Greek securities would end up which can distort fund flow customer to resolve the situa-
maker MSCI Inc. signaled late BlackRock said the prob- their stock markets. once trading resumed. The figures. tion.” A spokeswoman for TD
Monday that it could cut Rus- lems may lead its fund to not Shares of the VanEck Rus- fund’s shares mostly fell dur- For VanEck’s ETF, the num- Bank declined to comment.
sia from many of its widely meet its investment objectives sia ETF and the iShares MSCI ing the closure, reflecting the ber of shares held short by Some 55% of car buyers
followed equity indexes, in- and to experience significant Russia ETF, the two biggest hit Greece’s market would bearish investors jumped to used dealer-arranged financing
cluding those that track premiums or discounts to its funds tracking stocks tied to eventually take after it re- 19.2 million on Friday, near its last year, the greatest share in
emerging markets. net asset value. the country, dropped more opened. highest levels since late 2016, records going back to 2005, ac-
The prices of the Russian The iShares ETF closed than 25% on Monday and con- VanEck’s ETF seeks to according to data from S3 cording to car-shopping web-
funds largely reflect investor Tuesday at $12, a premium to tinued falling on Tuesday. track an index of Russian Partners. site Edmunds. The share using
sentiment rather than the un- its most recently calculated net Both funds are down around stocks, including shares of do- “Some of those flows are cash, check or outside financ-
derlying value of their assets, asset value of $7.62. VanEck’s 70% in 2022. mestic companies and deposi- not a positive indicator but a ing dropped to less than 18%,
said Todd Rosenbluth, head of Russia ETF also trades at a “Even if the [Russian] stock tory receipts of Russian negative indicator,” Mr. Rosen- its lowest on record last year.
ETF and mutual-fund research premium, with shares at $8.26 market remains closed for a stocks listed in New York and bluth said. Dealer-arranged financing
has long been the default for a
swath of buyers. At least some
Bankers 50
Finance 500
Asian-focused investment
bank’s Hong Kong office.
“Hong Kong will become in-
those terms worsened during
the car boom.
But consumer attorneys
Pressured 25
0
Import/
export
400
creasingly isolated as a busi-
ness center as the rest of the
world returns to normal, if the
have observed dealers using
more pressure tactics recently
to steer customers away from
300
current travel restrictions re- bringing outside financing or
Continued from page B1 main in place,” Mr. Kavanagh paying cash, according to John
–25
many of his colleagues also Retail said. He said it was “virtually Van Alst, an attorney at the Na-
wanted to relocate. The second 200 impossible to bring senior tional Consumer Law Center.
plans to stay because his boss –50 hires into Hong Kong in the Regulators have also received
has no plans to leave. current environment.” complaints.
–75 100
Banks themselves aren’t However, Mr. Kavanagh said “When you have 10 people
driving the moves. There is a Hong Kong would eventually who want to buy one vehicle,
lot of business to do in Hong Tourism return to normal and that he and car lots are empty, some of
–100 Quarterly 0
Kong, and visibly pulling back 2017 ’18 ’19 ’20 ’21 2012 ’13 ’14 ’15 ’16 ’17 ’18 ’19 ’20 ’21 ’22 didn’t plan to leave. BDA ex- these things I think are the re-
could offend the local and Bei- pects business to be strong sult of that,” said Christine
jing governments. Moving Sources: Hong Kong Census and Statistics Department via Refinitiv (receipts); Refinitiv (value) this year given an active re- Graham, supervising financial
staff can also throw up tax gional M&A market. examiner at the Texas Office of
and regulatory complications. Murli Maiya, who was about a nior regional role in the bank’s eventual reopening. Standard Chartered PLC Consumer Credit Commis-
But they are trying to be flexi- year into his tenure as the equity sales and trading busi- In October, the Asia Securi- Chief Executive Bill Winters sioner. “We are concerned
ble where possible. bank’s CEO for South Asia and ness, a memo said. In a ties Industry & Financial Mar- recently highlighted the risks about these practices.”
JPMorgan Chase & Co. Southeast Asia and had been LinkedIn post, her predeces- kets Association told the gov- to Hong Kong’s regional posi- The state regulator has re-
named a new head of equity planning to relocate to Singa- sor, Ryan Holsheimer, said it ernment that many members tion from its “relatively re- ceived several dozen com-
capital markets for the Asia- pore. The longtime banker will was time to “hang up the were considering moving em- strictive mobility patterns.” plaints from buyers who say
Pacific in late January after remain in Hong Kong and boots” after 27 years in fi- ployees or functions abroad Another headache is an they were pressured to use
managing director Francesco work with Mr. Lavatelli in the nance and reunite with his and had trouble hiring and re- overall talent shortage as Hong dealer-arranged financing,
Lavatelli, who held the job for coming months to ensure a family in Australia after two taining staff. Some banks have Kong’s population dwindles. many after Dallas news station
the past two years, decided to smooth transition, according years apart during the pan- started reimbursing staff for Quinlan & Associates, a finan- WFAA ran a report on the topic
move to London, where he will to an internal memo. demic. quarantine hotel stays after cial-consulting firm, estimates last summer. The office has
serve as the bank’s global Some senior replacements The new tough policies are personal travel. that net migration over been investigating the claims.
head of corporate-equity de- are moving to Hong Kong. At adding to concerns about Hong “Travel restrictions and 2020-2022 could total 304,000 Texas law prohibits dealers
rivatives. JPMorgan, Sarah Perring will Kong’s growing isolation and quarantine are making Hong residents, or 4% of the popula- from charging different prices
The U.S. lender turned to move from Tokyo to take a se- the lack of a road map for Kong’s historic role as a hub tion. for vehicles based on payment
methods.
The Federal Trade Commis-
HEARD STREET ON
THE
FINANCIAL ANALYSIS & COMMENTARY
high degree of control over the yuan. sia and Ukraine supplying around
The consequences of the crisis one-third of the world’s wheat, a
for global energy flows were metas- quarter of its barley and nearly
tasizing even before the invasion of three-quarters of its sunflower oil,
Ukraine: In early February during according to the International Food
the Olympics, China and Russia Policy Research Institute.
agreed on a new “Power of Siberia War in Ukraine threatens to dis-
2” pipeline that would raise planned rupt this supply if fighting dam-
pipeline gas deliveries to China to a For China, the financial implications of the Ukraine crisis may be alarming. Xi Jinping with Vladimir Putin. ages the country’s ports or pre-
total of around 48 billion cubic vents the planting and harvesting
meters by the second half of the de- putting a permanent, significant clined to add to its roughly $1 tril- trols in terms of how much can be of crops. Countries in the Middle
cade. The agreement stipulates pay- discount on Russian gas—a fact lion in U.S. Treasury holdings, its converted and how the proceeds East and North Africa that import
ment in euros, but that presumably China would no doubt be happy to ability to fight yuan depreciation can be legally used. Those rules a lot of grain from Ukraine look
could be changed to yuan if Russia’s take advantage of in the future. in any theoretical Taiwan confron- tend to shift when overall capital most exposed, while the European
financial isolation called for it—an The situation with tech sanc- tation would be significantly im- outflows or inflows change rapidly. Union gets 6.4% of its total food
additional plus from Beijing’s per- tions is less straightforward but paired if it struggled to sell most That will continue to put a rela- imports from Russia and Ukraine
spective. And, while Bloomberg re- could end up unfolding in a similar of its hard-currency assets. tively low ceiling on global demand combined. The U.S. does less direct
ported that some Chinese banks are manner. In the short run, Chinese All of this will further motivate for yuan relative to the size of trade in food with the two coun-
skittish about financing Russian re- companies seem unlikely to risk China to boost the payments and re- China’s economy. And for now, the tries, but would still feel some ef-
source trading for fear of violating Western and Japanese secondary serve role of the yuan. China is likely macroeconomic risks of removing fects through global commodity
Western sanctions, it seems likely sanctions by continuing to supply to increase the pressure on its trade China’s capital controls—particu- markets.
that the rules will continue to in- Russian customers. In the long and financial partners to do business larly for the heavily indebted real- Uncertainty about supply al-
clude carve-outs for Russian energy run, if China is able to successfully in yuan using its own alternative to estate and state sectors—probably ready is pushing up agricultural fu-
transactions to reduce the impact localize its semiconductor produc- the global financial-messaging sys- outweigh the geopolitical impetus tures. Around 80% of last year’s
on the global economy. tion chain, even at a less cutting- tem SWIFT. Foreign central-bank to push the yuan’s adoption abroad. wheat harvest has been exported
The key point is that, even as- edge technological level, a captive holdings of yuan denominated re- Beijing will accrue some advan- from Ukraine and the next crop has
suming continued strong demand Russian market would be another serve assets, currently tiny at 2.7% tages in the energy and, poten- been planted, according to the IF-
growth, China is very far from be- welcome source of capital. of global reserves in late 2021 ac- tially, tech realms over the long PRI. However, plantings of other
ing a replacement for the European For China, the most alarming cording to the International Mone- term from the current crisis. But crops such as maize, which are due
natural-gas market. Russia piped aspect of the crisis is probably its tary Fund, will likely grow. by acting in concert, the owners of this spring, as well as the harvest
168 billion cubic meters of gas to financial implications. The joint But the problem is that China’s all the major reserve currencies of wheat planted last fall, could be
Europe in 2020, according to data decision by the European Union, currency isn’t fully convertible have sent a strong signal about disrupted by the war.
from BP, or about 70% of its total the U.S., the U.K., Japan and Can- even in normal times, much less in the consequences of direct aggres- Major food producers such as
natural-gas exports. Last year, China ada to sanction Russia’s central a geopolitical crisis. China’s cen- sion against a neighbor by a major Nestlé and Kellogg’s should be able
imported 16.5 billion cubic meters bank—pummeling the ruble and tral bank regularly intervenes in power while showing the limited to find supply elsewhere, as rising
of natural gas from Russia in total. freezing access to many of the for- the onshore currency market and advantages of diversification. The wheat prices in particular have en-
Even assuming pipeline volumes eign assets the central bank would the offshore one in Hong Kong search for financial workarounds couraged farmers to plant more.
reach around 50 billion cubic need to defend it—sets a very when they move in ways it doesn’t will intensify, but viable alterna- Acreage given over to winter wheat
meters by mid-decade, as planned, a tough precedent for any potential like. Yuan deposits held onshore tives still look scarce. This week sowings in the U.S. was the highest
major effort by Europe to diversify future crisis in the Taiwan Strait. are in many cases subject to both has been an unhappy wake-up call in six years. But grain supplies are
away from Russian gas would risk While China in recent years de- quantitative and qualitative con- for Beijing. —Nathaniel Taplin still tight: The global stock-to-use
ratio for cereals—a closely watched
measure of inventories as a propor-
tion of annual demand—is forecast