Download as pdf or txt
Download as pdf or txt
You are on page 1of 22

World Journal of Entrepreneurship, Management and

Sustainable Development
An assessment of international liquidity and higher oil prices
Amer Al-Roubaie
Article information:
To cite this document:
Amer Al-Roubaie, (2010),"An assessment of international liquidity and higher oil prices",
World Journal of Entrepreneurship, Management and Sustainable Development, Vol. 6
Iss 3 pp. 161 - 180
Downloaded by MAHIDOL UNIVERSITY At 02:15 23 February 2015 (PT)

Permanent link to this document:


http://dx.doi.org/10.1108/20425961201000013
Downloaded on: 23 February 2015, At: 02:15 (PT)
References: this document contains references to 0 other documents.
To copy this document: permissions@emeraldinsight.com
The fulltext of this document has been downloaded 190 times since 2010*
Users who downloaded this article also downloaded:
Mansor H. Ibrahim, Rusmawati Said, (2012),"Disaggregated consumer prices and oil
price pass-through: evidence from Malaysia", China Agricultural Economic Review, Vol. 4
Iss 4 pp. 514-529 http://dx.doi.org/10.1108/17561371211284858
Hugo Chávez Frías, (2000),"The price of oil in a world of equals", foresight, Vol. 2 Iss 4
pp. 375-378 http://dx.doi.org/10.1108/14636680010802780
Frank Bracho, (2000),"The future of oil and energy: consequences
for oil producing countries", foresight, Vol. 2 Iss 4 pp. 379-390 http://
dx.doi.org/10.1108/14636680010802726

Access to this document was granted through an Emerald subscription provided by


294800 []
For Authors
If you would like to write for this, or any other Emerald publication, then please
use our Emerald for Authors service information about how to choose which
publication to write for and submission guidelines are available for all. Please visit
www.emeraldinsight.com/authors for more information.
About Emerald www.emeraldinsight.com
Emerald is a global publisher linking research and practice to the benefit of society.
The company manages a portfolio of more than 290 journals and over 2,350 books and
book series volumes, as well as providing an extensive range of online products and
additional customer resources and services.
Emerald is both COUNTER 4 and TRANSFER compliant. The organization is a partner
of the Committee on Publication Ethics (COPE) and also works with Portico and the
LOCKSS initiative for digital archive preservation.
*Related content and download information correct at
time of download.
Downloaded by MAHIDOL UNIVERSITY At 02:15 23 February 2015 (PT)
World Journal of Enterprenuership, Management and Sustainable Development, Vol. 6, No. 3, 2010

AN ASSESSMENT OF INTERNATIONAL
LIQUIDITY AND HIGHER OIL PRICES
Amer Al-Roubaie1
Ahlia University, Bahrain

Abstract: Energy represents an important component of production costs and


therefore, an increase in energy prices directly impacts economic productivity, un-
employment, inflation, and balance of payments equilibrium – often engendering
currency devaluations. Until recently, the growth in demand for conventional fuels,
Downloaded by MAHIDOL UNIVERSITY At 02:15 23 February 2015 (PT)

mainly oil and gas, has widened imbalances between demand for and supply of en-
ergy. The effects of the surge in oil prices ripple across the entire global economy re-
sulting in a redistribution of international liquidity. The latter creates global
imbalances characterized by increasing balance of payment deficits and deteriorating
the terms of trade, reducing the flow of non-energy goods and services and
increasing uncertainty of future global transactions. The aim of this paper is to shed
some light on the impact of higher fuel prices on global liquidity management.

Keywords: oil revenues; price volatility; global liquidity; balances of payments; global-
ization; the Middle East; China; India.

INTRODUCTION stitute for hydrocarbons remains unachieved


and illusive.
In this age of industrialization, transporta-
tion and mass production of goods and Currently, most production and exports
services, energy and energy prices play a of oil and gas come from developing coun-
crucial role in the overall development of all tries with low population density. The gap
societies. Modernization and future between production and consumption of
prospects of rapid and sustained growth de- energy stems from the uneven distribution
pends on the supply of energy. In other of fossil fuels where most consumers are
words, such high dependency on energy has highly industrialized countries with heavy
linked the future development of mankind dependence on imported oil to meet do-
to the existence of conventional energy mestic requirements. Due to the narrow
sources to ensure the meeting of human economic base and small absorptive capacity
needs and the enhancement of productivity of most oil exporting countries, they are
growth. Exacerbating matters, the prospect able to accumulate large reserves and enjoy
of developing alternate sources of energy to current account surpluses. Such trends could
substitute for fossil fuel has shown very little have spillover effects by creating global im-
sign of encouragement. Despite investment balances through higher prices, liquidity
in technologies geared to developing non- shortages, inadequate global demand and
fossil fuels, the potential for finding a sub- currency devaluations.
Prof. Amer Al-Roubaie, Dean, College of Business and Finance, Ahlia University, Bahrain, Email:
amer@ahliauniversity.edu.bh

Copyright © 2010 WASD 161


162 A. Al-Roubaie

International liquidity is important for duction for exports and promote global
maintaining balance of payments equilib- competitiveness. In addition, higher oil
rium, strengthening global economic man- prices weaken the effectiveness of national
agement and enhancing international economic policies by reducing the country’s
financial stability. Higher petroleum prices capacity to import, especially capital goods
could produce adverse effects on global sta- and raw materials. Economic development
bility by redistributing income in favor of underscores the importance of access to
oil producing countries and reducing flows global knowledge, skills, technology and in-
of international transactions. The main ob- formation for building capacity capable of
jective of this paper is to highlight the im- increasing productivity and sustaining eco-
portance of liquidity imbalances and its nomic growth.
impact on global trade and finance.
Downloaded by MAHIDOL UNIVERSITY At 02:15 23 February 2015 (PT)

Petroleum and petroleum products are


THE OIL QUESTION among the most important commodities
traded globally; therefore, the stability of
During the last few years, oil prices have the oil market is essential for international
been volatile rising to over US$140/bbl. in financial flows, promoting trade and ensur-
July 2008 and declining to $35/b by De- ing global economic growth. It is estimated
cember in the same year. However, higher that the primary demand for oil is to in-
oil prices could engender substantial nega- crease by 1.3 percent per year over 2005 –
tive financial, social and economic imbal- 2030 or the equivalent of 99 million barrels
ances, particularly in non-oil producing in 2005 and 116 million barrels in 2030.
countries. In addition, rapid economic About two thirds of this increase in demand
growth, especially in Asia in recent years, will originate in developing countries. Meet-
has widened the gap between the demand ing such demand requires that the oil in-
for petroleum products and the existing ca- dustry invest a total of $4.3 trillion over the
pacity of supply. Heavy dependence of many period 2005 – 2030 or $164 billion per
industrialized and non-industrialized coun- year.ii In addition, most of the known-re-
tries on imported oil to meet their demand serves of oil and gas are located in non-in-
requirements could impose constraints on dustrialized countries with low population
government budgets, balance of payments density and low economic productivity. It is
equilibrium, aggregate expenditures, human unlikely that a substitute for fossil fuel will
development, poverty alleviation programs be found in the near future and, therefore,
and economic growth. The negative impact the risk of imbalances between demand and
of rising energy prices will be on low income supply is expected to continue keeping the
countries as well as on industries which rely global energy market volatile.iii
on oil as a key input in production.i
Table 1 illustrates that world proven re-
In developing countries, earning of for- serves of oil amounted to 1,295 billion bar-
eign exchange depends largely on produc- rels in 2008, about 60 percent of which is
tion and export of a limited number of located in the Middle East and North Africa.
primary products, mainly minerals and agri- Table 1 also shows that the Middle East en-
cultural-based products. As a consequence, joys the largest share of world proven re-
higher petroleum prices could weaken the serves of natural gas amounting to more
ability of these countries to increase pro- than 42 percent.
An assessment of international liquidity and higher oil prices 163

Table 1: World proven crude oil and natural gas reserves by region, 2008

Region Proven crude oil % of total world Proven natural % of total world
reserves (m/b) gas reserves
(billion cu m)
North America 26.217 2 9,168 5

Latin America 210.507 16.3 8,007 4.4

Eastern Europe 128.979 10 55,000 30

West. Europe 14.805 1.1 5,292 2.9


Downloaded by MAHIDOL UNIVERSITY At 02:15 23 February 2015 (PT)

Middle East 762.265 58.9 75,298 41.2

Africa 122.041 9.4 14,692 8

Asia & pacific 40.278 3.1 15,394 8.4

Total World 1,295.09 ---- 182,842 -----

OPEC 1,027.38 79.3 93,347 51.1

Source: Organization of the Petroleum Exporting Countries (OPEC), Annual Statistical Bulletin 2008
(Vienna, 2008)

This implies that the region will remain ices. This bias imposes constraints on non-
the most important supplier of oil for several industrialized countries to get a fair share in
decades to come. Given the global demand world trade and foreign direct investment.
for energy, it is uncertain whether the Mid-
dle East can continue to supply a sufficient GLOBAL TRENDS
amount of oil to meet future global demand.
The Organization of the Petroleum Export- Since the start of the millennium, energy
ing Countries (OPEC), with less than 10 prices in general and oil prices in particular
percent of world population, controls about have been volatile causing a major concern
80 percent of world known oil reserves. for policy makers, energy analysts, (OPEC),
Bridging the gap between demand and sup- international organizations and industry.
ply not only requires collective cooperation Throughout the 1980s and 1990s, the fact
among producers and consumers, but also that oil prices were very low discouraged in-
the construction of an effective strategy for vestment and reduced supply. Low invest-
crisis management. Such collective action ment in conventional sources as well as in
will ensure stability of financial markets and alternative sources of energy was met with
reduce the risk of global recession. Interna- rapid global demand for energy during the
tional trade is biased in favor of exporters of last few years, especially in Asia, where
manufactured goods, technology and serv- China and India have become prime con-
164 A. Al-Roubaie

sumers of energy. Economic growth rates in controlled by these companies, better


China and India have surpassed all world known as the seven sisters. Due to the im-
regions by growing at 9.7% and 7.6% in portance of oil trade and because of the rise
2008 compared to 11.9% and 8.6% in in oil prices in recent years, these companies
2007 respectively.iv exercise tremendous economic and financial
powers over the global markets. For exam-
In recent years, globalization has in- ple, in 2008, total revenues of the top five
creased global interdependencies among na- major oil companies (BP, ExxonMobil,
tions by liberalizing trade and financial Total, Royal Dutch/Shell and Chevron)
transactions, promoting capital flows, and were about $1.4 trillion. As shown in Table
increasing labor mobility. Modern informa- 2, net income earned by major oil compa-
tion and communication technologies nies more than doubled between 2003 and
Downloaded by MAHIDOL UNIVERSITY At 02:15 23 February 2015 (PT)

(ICTs) have enhanced financial services by 2008 increasing from $61,429 million to
connecting global markets through elec- $138,597 million respectively.
tronic networks and satellite broadcasting.
Such trends gave rise to new markets domi- Globalization has eased restrictions on
nated by key players, mainly multinational global trade and finance by giving greater
business, industrial countries and global in- access to global markets. Export-led growth
stitutions. Similarly, information technolo- policies require building capacity capable of
gies speeded up international transactions facilitating global connection for absorbing
by linking individuals, businesses, markets knowledge and disseminating information.
and organizations worldwide. Globalization, Balance of payments disequilibrium weak-
though its meaning is vague, involves world- ens the ability of the economy to sustain
wide exchanges of goods and services, capital growth by imposing constraints on its in-
flows, and telecommunication technologies. ternational trade transactions. As a conse-
Taking advantage of the new global knowl- quence, availability of foreign exchange
edge-based economy driven by globalization becomes necessary to pay for the country’s
requires countries to deepen global integra- global obligations. A deficit in the balance
tion and increase global competitiveness of payments could cause devaluation of the
through production and exports of high- national currency which reduces the coun-
tech products. Higher petroleum prices try’s ability to meet its external obligations,
could have an adverse effect on global trade especially serving the foreign debt and pay-
because of the increase in production costs ing for imported goods. Such trends create
of intermediate goods including fertilizers, uncertainty about future growth by discour-
chemicals, plastic products and fuels. Not aging foreign direct investment in the local
only the demand for oil comes from its di- economy. In other words, without liquidity,
rect need for fuel, but also from its indirect the country suffers from capital flows caus-
usage as intermediate goods that enter in ing brain drain, disinvestment, skill short-
production of many products.v ages, knowledge denial and limitation on
technology transfer. Petroleum import price
As multinational nationals, oil companies increases is referred to as an OPEC tax be-
are fully integrated in the globalization cause of the transfer of wealth from oil im-
process for being key players in the global porters to exporters. The money paid to oil
energy markets. Almost two thirds of oil producers, is not invested back in the coun-
production, distribution and shipping are try and represents a loss of resources. Higher
An assessment of international liquidity and higher oil prices 165

Table 2: Net income of major oil companies, 2003 – 2008 (m$)

Oil company 2003 2005 2008

BP 12,432 19,314 25,593

ExxonMobil 21,510 36,130 45,220

Total 7,944 14,885 15,576

Royal Dutch/Shell 12,313 25,311 28,272


Downloaded by MAHIDOL UNIVERSITY At 02:15 23 February 2015 (PT)

Chevron 5,294 11,098 23,931

Total 61,429 109739 138,597

Source: Organization of the Petroleum Exporting Countries (OPEC), Annual Statistical Bulletin 2007
(Vienna: OPEC, 2008) (Vienna, 2008)

petroleum prices siphons financial resources country’s balance of trade position, causing
outside the circular flows of the local econ- gross international reserves to increase from
omy. This weakens multiplier effects and $821,514 million in 2005 to $2,340,000
reduces potential for higher growth. Under million in 2008. On the other hand, current
such circumstances, management of macro- account balance increased from $160,818
economic variables becomes more difficult million to $284,100 million respectively.vii
stemming from increasing uncertainty about Similar build up in reserves is occurring in
future energy prices impacting the ability of oil exporting countries where the recent
the economy to sustain stable growth.vi surge in oil prices has resulted in transferring
large amounts of global liquidity to few
GLOBAL LIQUIDITY countries, mainly those in the Middle East
and North Africa. For example, current ac-
Global liquidity constitutes monetary assets count balance of OPEC increased from
used mainly for financing international $263,129 million in 2005 to 466,546 mil-
trade transactions and correcting balances lion in 2008. In the case of Saudi Arabia,
of payments disequilibrium. Liquidity is a the biggest oil exporter, current account bal-
stock measured in a given time period show- ance increased from $89,990 million in
ing the distribution of international reserves 2005 to $141,800 in 2008.viii Due to the
among various countries. The need for these small size of their economies and because of
reserves is vital for facilitating trade transac- the limitation of their absorptive capacity,
tions and settlement of foreign obligations. these countries have been enjoying a favor-
Enhancing the reserves position depends able balance of trade position by accumu-
largely on the country’s export trade as well lating a substantial amount of surplus.
as on global demand for its products. In
China, for example, rapid economic growth In recent years, the balance of payments
in recent years considerably improved the situation has been aggravated by rising
166 A. Al-Roubaie

global food prices which have added addi- resources. Low levels of economic develop-
tional burden on net export earnings of ment in these countries encourage calls for
most non-oil importing countries. The chal- higher prices to pay for their development
lenges facing many of these countries are so projects. In addition, political instability
great that it will take much needed financial and external interference undermines mar-
and technical assistances to correct imbal- ket stability, especially in the Middle East,
ances in their economies. In other words, where historical trends have proven to be
urgency is need for reengineering the inter- disruptive to oil flows. For many energy
national financial system in order to ensure consumers, especially the United States, oil
global financial stability and maintain bal- is a strategic commodity which falls into
ances of payments equilibrium. Greater the domain of national security. Such im-
management over the global financial sys- portance gives oil high priority in construct-
Downloaded by MAHIDOL UNIVERSITY At 02:15 23 February 2015 (PT)

tem is also due to the current financial crisis ing future energy policies. In recent years
sweeping the economies of Western coun- the relationship between consumers of oil,
tries. Uncertainty about future financial mainly Western countries and oil producing
transactions will worsen economic growth countries has deteriorated because of the
prospects and weaken management of the events in Iraq, Venezuela, Iran, Algeria and
global economy.ix Nigeria. Western military intervention and
the threat of embargos and sanctions against
In particular, the least developed coun- economic interest of oil producing countries
tries with high dependency on imported oil could have destabilizing effects on the global
could suffer from liquidity shortages needed economy.x The rise of anti-western feelings
to finance their international obligations. in many of the developing countries, in-
In these countries, settlement of interna- cluding the Arab world, increases uncer-
tional transactions is usually resolved tainty about the future flow of oil by
through revenues earned from export of pri- encouraging people to use force for achiev-
mary products, the prices of which are ing their national objectives. Oil prices are
volatile. In recent years, serving the foreign sensitive to changes in global demand and
debt has increased economic vulnerability security problems which in turn undermine
by subjecting the economies of these coun- efforts to increase market stability.xi
tries to liquidity shortages and balance of
payments disequilibria. In additions, capital ENERGY IMBALANCES
flows into these countries are restricted due
to economic and political considerations Because of its significant components of pro-
which in turn cause disequilibrium in bal- duction costs, higher oil prices are expected
ances of payments. Poor countries usually to have a negative impact on growth
do not have investments abroad to supple- prospects of both local and global economies.
ment their foreign reserves earnings, i.e. In OECD countries, for example, produc-
they rely heavily on export earnings to sup- tivity growth is to decline from 2 percent
port the demand for imported goods and currently to about 1.5 percent per year in
services. 2030 which in turn could slow the demand
for energy consumption. However, recent
On the other hand, oil producers con- growth trends in Asia, especially China and
tinue to argue in favor of higher prices to India, are expected to continue to pressure
maximize the return from non-renewable demand for oil in order to meet productivity
An assessment of international liquidity and higher oil prices 167

requirements and population increase. Meet- oil may comes from rapid economic growth
ing global requirements for oil, demand is to in the Middle East where demand is esti-
rise by 29 million barrels per day from 2006 mated to reach 9.7 million barrels per day
to reach to 113 million barrels per day in in 2030 compared to 2 million barrels per
2030. Most of the increase is expected to day in 1980. Latin America’s requirement
come from developing countries with energy for oil demand is to reach to 7.0 million
consumption is to double reaching 56 million barrels per day whereas in Asia the demand
barrels a day by 2030. The Asian countries for oil will be reaching to 29.7 million bar-
alone are to see an increase of 17 million bar- rels of oil per day in 2030 compared to that
rels a day or two thirds that of all developing of 4.4 million barrels per day in 1980. In
countries combined.xii China, the demand is expected to reach
15.3 million barrels of oil in 2030 or at an
Downloaded by MAHIDOL UNIVERSITY At 02:15 23 February 2015 (PT)

As shown in Table 3, World’s demand for average yearly increase of 3.4% between
oil increased from 82.5 million barrels in 2005 and 2030. It seems that in the long
2004 to 86.8 million barrels a day in 2008. term most of the demand for oil will origi-
Most of the increase in demand for oil nate in developing countries where average
comes from the Asian countries, where yearly increase is estimated at 2.5% between
China’s demand alone increased from 6.4 2005 and 2030. Unless alternative energy
million barrels a day to 8.0 million barrels a sources are developed, such trends widen
day in 2008. the gap between demand and supply causing
In the long run however, the demand for long-term prices to soar.xiii

Table 3: Global demand for oil (million barrels/day)

Region/World 2004 2005 2006 2007 2008

North America 25.4 25.5 25.3 25.5 25

Europe 15.5 15.6 15.6 15.3 15.3

Pacific 8.5 8.6 8.4 8.3 8.3

China 6.4 6.7 7.2 7.5 8

Other Asia 8.7 8.8 9 9.3 9.4

Latin America 5 5.1 5.3 5.6 5.9

Middle East 5.7 6 6.2 6.5 6.8

Africa 2.8 2.9 3 3.1 3.1

World 82.5 83.8 84.9 86 86.8

Organization of the Petroleum Exporting Countries (OPEC), World Oil Outlook 2008 (Vienna:
OPEC, 2008)
168 A. Al-Roubaie

Table 4: Global Supply of oil (million barrels/day)

Region/World 2004 2005 2006 2007 2008

North America 14.6 14.1 14.2 14.3 14.1

Europe 6.1 5.6 5.2 5 4.6

Pacific 0.6 0.6 0.6 0.6 0.7

China 3.5 3.6 3.7 3.7 3.8

Other Asia 2.7 2.7 2.7 2.7 2.7


Downloaded by MAHIDOL UNIVERSITY At 02:15 23 February 2015 (PT)

Latin America 4.1 4.3 4.4 4.2 4.1

Africa 3.4 3.7 3.9 2.5 2.6

OPEC 33.1 34.2 34.3 35.5 ---

World 83.4 84.6 85.4 85.5 ---

Source: Organization of the Petroleum Exporting Countries (OPEC), World Oil Outlook 2008
(Vienna: OPEC, 2008)

Sources of current supply of oil are shown peated. The Middle East, where most of the
in Table 4 reflecting the importance of oil is produced, remains one of the most
OPEC countries in future energy supply. In volatile regions in the world. Both external
2007, the share of OPEC in total world and internal factors could contribute to the
supply of oil accounted for 42%. Whereas instability of the region reflecting global
North America, the biggest consuming re- disruptions of oil and a sudden hike in
gion of energy, supplied about 17% of world prices.
total or less than half of demand require-
ments. Supply from conventional areas costs
more due to the declining reserves and rising
Creating a global energy balance, both in cost of technology used in production and
terms of security of supply and security de- discovery. Even with new discoveries in
mand for oil are important. OPEC countries Africa and Russia the amount of the new
are under pressure to guarantee supply by reserves fall short of meeting future demand
keeping the flow of oil in line with world requirements. In addition, the supply of oil
demand. However, unlike other globally is influenced by non-economic factors in-
traded commodities, the supply of oil is in- cluding political, social and environmental
fluenced by political, strategic and national forces which increase uncertainty about fu-
security factors which make future flows ture growth to meet demand. As nonrenew-
highly uncertain. The 1973 oil embargo able resources, oil and gas have the tendency
and the rise in petroleum prices is still a re- to deplete faster as output is supplied. Most
minder of the risk that history may be re- oil and gas reserves are located in developing
An assessment of international liquidity and higher oil prices 169

countries with ambitious development plans now and 2012. These investments are to in-
of their own. Supporting these plans, these crease OPEC capacity by 4 million barrels
countries need to make more of their pro- of oil per day. Alternatively, oil consuming
duced supply for domestic consumption in- countries should look closely at the global
stead of exports. Sustaining future economic supply requirements and take some initia-
growth and meeting the challenges of de- tives to increase supply not only through
velopment will require greater investment production of conventional energy sources
in energy alternatives. To this end, global but also by investing in the development of
management of energy resources under- new energy sources, reducing tensions in oil
scores the importance of global cooperation producing countries, maintaining stability
to ensure adequate supply and reduce mar- of the dollar and increasing global coopera-
ket uncertainty. tion. Global energy imbalances are shown
Downloaded by MAHIDOL UNIVERSITY At 02:15 23 February 2015 (PT)

in Table 5. As the table indicates, the global


Oil producers are developing countries supply of oil was less than global demand
facing many challenges including high by -0.98million barrels in 2007.xiv
growth rates of population, greater demand
for services, economic restructuring, new Global imbalances constitute an impor-
job opportunities and social development. tant obstacle for the flow of trade among
Implementing these programs may reduce nations. Not only do imbalances influence
the ability of OPEC countries to meet global international trade movements, but also in-
supply requirements. To increase supply, vestment expenditures. Weakening the na-
OPEC is to invest $150 billion between tional demand for investment could have a

Table 5: Summarized supply/demand balance of supply and demand


for 2007-2008 (mb/d)

Region 2006 2007 2008

(a) World oil demand 84.63 85.78 86.88

Non-OPEC supply 48.88 49.43 50.13


OPEC NGLs and
4.06 4.4 4.93
non-conventional
(b) Total Supply ex-
52.94 53.83 55.06
cluding OPEC Crude
Difference ( a – b ) 31.69 31.95 31.82
OPEC Crude Oil
31.43 30.97 -----
Production
Balance -0.26 -0.98 ------

Source: Organization of the Petroleum Exporting Countries (OPEC), World Oil Outlook 2008
(Vienna: OPEC, 2008)
170 A. Al-Roubaie

negative impact on global trade by reducing GLOBAL LIQUIDITY AND


the capacity to import, especially manufac- GROWTH POTENTIAL
tured products. The stability of the world
economy underscores the importance of Economic growth, especially in develop-
capital flows to facilitate international trans- ing countries, depends heavily on the coun-
actions. Recent increase in oil prices has in- try’s ability to import capital goods and
creased imbalances by redistributing global technology needed for building technologi-
liquidity in favor of small countries. Main- cal capacity and diversifying the productive
taining global balance will require recycling structure. Development is a process of struc-
of excess liquidity earned by oil exporting tural changes that focus on the supply side
countries by buying goods and services in of the economy to strengthen the productive
the global markets. Unfortunately, a large capacity, induce technologic change, diver-
Downloaded by MAHIDOL UNIVERSITY At 02:15 23 February 2015 (PT)

number of developing countries could suffer sify production, increase services and im-
badly from the surge in oil prices in the prove worker skills. The growth potential of
form of balance of payment deficits, higher an economy depends on the creation of
prices, increasing costs and declining profits. productive capacity capable of stimulating
These countries may respond by adopting aggregate demand and increasing investment
policy measures to reduce the impact of spending. Without investment capabilities,
higher oil prices but such polices may prove economic growth remains stagnant due to a
to be unsustainable if oil prices continue to lack of adequate stimulus and weak linkages.
rise. In the longer run, the challenge facing Availability of international reserves is vital
these countries is to invest and develop al- for promoting development and stimulating
ternative energy sources.xv economic growth.xvi

To predict future trends in the oil market During the last several years, many devel-
is extremely difficult because neither de- oping countries have experienced balance
mand for nor supply of oil is easy to estimate of payment deficits and deterioration of
due to the nature of factors that govern de- terms of trades due to weak economic per-
mand and supply. To reduce uncertainty formance and low export demand. Most
and ensure market stability, global coopera- developing countries have a narrow export
tion is needed for bridging the gap between base which imposes constraints on develop-
supply and demand for oil. Such coopera- ment by reducing the ability to meet the
tion increases confidence in international country’s liquidity requirements. Almost two
markets by allowing countries to construct thirds of export of developing countries, in-
policies capable of inducing economic cluding OPEC members, comes from pro-
growth as well as investing in new sources duction and exports of a few primary
of energy. Balance of payments disequilib- products such as petroleum, cotton, coffee,
rium could undermine international trade minerals, bananas and tea. Sharp fluctua-
movements by imposing constraints on oil tions in prices and demand for these prod-
consuming countries to import goods and ucts could impact export earnings reflecting
services to meet their development require- changes in income, prices, unemployment
ments. In addition, many of these countries and government revenues and expenditures.
are in debt, the service of which comes For supplementing their liquidity, many de-
mainly from earning of their exports. veloping countries rely on foreign debt and
foreign direct investment to finance their
An assessment of international liquidity and higher oil prices 171

international obligations and pay for their Increase in oil prices could have a negative
immediate imports. impact on aggregate demand causing expen-
ditures on both public and private invest-
Table 6 illustrates the volume of exports ment, productivity growth and employment
and imports and current account balances to decline. In developing countries, such
of OPEC countries. The importance of oil trends undermine their development projects
to the economies of these countries mani- by disallowing the economy from reaching
fests the large share of oil exports in total its potential. Similarly, higher oil prices in-
exports. Earnings from oil export account crease the cost per unit of output produced
for almost two thirds of total exports re- pushing up the cost of living. Under global-
flecting the heavy dependence on oil pro- ization, macroeconomic policies become less
duction and export. Table 6 also shows the effective due to external forces which in turn
Downloaded by MAHIDOL UNIVERSITY At 02:15 23 February 2015 (PT)

size of surplus these countries were able to make government policies unable to manage
accumulate over the period 1990-2007. the economy and correct financial imbal-
Current account balance increased from ances. The weakening of macroeconomic
$13,717 million in 1990 to $334,301 mil- policies could spell trouble for developing
lion in 2007 reflecting the amount of liq- countries which are in dire needs for financial
uidity transfer to these countries. stability and external balance.xvii

Table 6: OPEC countries exports and imports and current account balances,
1990 – 2007. (M $)

Region 1990 1995 2000 2003 2005 2006 2007

Exports 200,612 220,570 379,267 405,193 746,948 905,589 1,013,427

Imports 123,965 158,226 191,790 240,490 406,440 468,653 580,048

Values of
151,020 138,007 258,117 258,156 535,631 650,258 730,434
oil exports

% of oil
exp. in 75.3 62.6 68.1 63.7 71.7 71.8 72.1
total exp.

Current
13,717 -18,635 94,311 88,052 264,201 332,840 334,301
balance

Source: Organization of the Petroleum Exporting Countries (OPEC), Annual Statistical Bulletin 2007
(Vienna: OPEC, 2007)
172 A. Al-Roubaie

In relation to the economic consequences prises. As a consequence, not only does in-
of higher oil prices, the International Mone- flation reduce the share of the profit in total
tary Fund (IMF) estimates the impact of a income, but also inversely affects aggregate
$10 increase in crude oil prices on the global demand by weakening the purchasing
economy. The results are listed in Table 7 power. Domestically, increase in prices usu-
showing that all regions will suffer a decline ally discourages incentive for growth by de-
in real GDP and experience inflation because stroying the confidence in the local economy
of this increase. As Table 8 illustrates, in which makes it difficult for both foreign
2005 global GDP declined by -0.5 % and local investors to make decisions due to
whereas GDP in the United States decreased uncertainty about future trends and cost
by -0.8 followed by -.06 in industrial coun- movements. Enterprises may be faced with
tries, -0.8 in the Euro area and -0.4 in Japan. devaluation of foreign exchanges which
Downloaded by MAHIDOL UNIVERSITY At 02:15 23 February 2015 (PT)

A more detailed assessment of the impact causes the price of imported goods to rise.
of a permanent rise in oil prices on macro- At a global level, inflation increases prices
economic variables is shown in Table 8. Oil of traded goods and services which induce
importing countries are to experience decline balance of payments deficits. Oil importers,
in real income, consumption and unemploy- especially developing countries are at a dis-
ment. Such impact should highlight the seri- advantage position because of high share of
ousness of energy supply by sending a oil imports in total imports and due to in-
warning to policy makers, national govern- creasing cost in the domestic economy.
ments and international institutions for look- These countries usually have larger foreign
ing seriously into the energy question.xviii debt, the service of which is paid with earn-
ings from exports. In addition, high degree
Inflation is another likely result of higher of concentration in trade making developing
oil prices both locally and globally. Energy countries exports are more vulnerable than
prices represent a major item in production leading to deterioration of the terms of trade
costs which determine the success of enter- and balance of payment disequilibrium. The

Table 7: Impact of a permanent US$10 per barrel increase in crude oil prices after
one year, 2005 (% of 2003 GDP)

Item Real GDP Inflation


World -0.5 n.a.
Industrial countries -0.6 0.4
United States -0.8 0.6
Euro area -0.8 0.6
Japan -0.4 0.2
Others -0.4 0.2

Source: Huntington, Hillard, The Economic Consequences of Higher Crude Oil Prices, Energy Mod-
eling Forum, Stanford University, final report EMF SR 9. 2005 http:/www.stanford.edu.group/EMF/re-
search/doc/summary%2002-08-05.pdf (Vienna: OPEC, 2007)
An assessment of international liquidity and higher oil prices 173

depreciation of the dollar in recent years immediate impact of the rise in prices of oil
has fueled prices and increased speculations will be on the purchasing power. The cost
about the ability of developing countries of living is measured in domestic currency
sustaining higher price increases. which adds to consumer price index. Simi-
larly, producers that face rising costs pass
Because of the importance of energy the increase to consumers by charging
prices in various sectors of the economy, the higher prices for their products and services.

Table 8: Impacts of a permanent $10 rise in oil prices


(Oil prices rise from $30 to $40)
Year 1 2 3
Downloaded by MAHIDOL UNIVERSITY At 02:15 23 February 2015 (PT)

Real GDP -0.3 -0.6 -0.4

Real consumption -0.4 -0.7 -0.6

GDP price index 0.2 0.5 0.9

CPI 0.7 1 1.3

Core CPI 0.1 0.3 0.6

Employment (000) -125 -451 -270

Unemployment rate 0.1 0.2 0.1

Short-term interest rate 0 0 -0.1

Current account ($bln) -30 -29 -47

Inferred GDP impact (Billion $) #

Real GDP -36.6 -73.2 -48.8

Oil wealth loss -38.2 -38.2 -38.2

Real income = Real GDP + oil -74.8 -111.2*- -87


wealth loss

Source: Huntington, Hillard, The Economic Consequences of Higher Crude Oil Prices, Energy Mod-
eling Forum, Stanford University, final report EMF SR 9. 2005 http:/www.stanford.edu.group/EMF/re-
search/doc/summary%2002-08-05.pdf
174 A. Al-Roubaie

This may be associated with productivity growth depends on both imports and ex-
declines and loss of jobs due to weakening ports, the financial settlement of which is
competitiveness and diminishing global de- usually done through international curren-
mand. Under such circumstances, it is un- cies, especially the dollar.
likely that real wages will increase enough
to offset the decrease in purchasing power. As a result of increasing global interde-
In the developing countries, such trends pendencies, nations are required to gain ac-
could be devastating to the local economy cess to trade and services for sustaining
by impacting poverty alleviation programs, growth both locally and globally. Poor coun-
investment confidence, government rev- tries with limited exports could suffer from
enues and expenditures, unemployment, in- liquidity shortages to meet their obligations
come distribution and economic growth. due to fluctuations in foreign exchange earn-
Downloaded by MAHIDOL UNIVERSITY At 02:15 23 February 2015 (PT)

Industrial countries may attempts to shift ings and the rise in imported bill for oil and
their production operations, especially pro- other petroleum products. Similarly, eco-
duction of manufactured goods to develop- nomic growth in industrialized countries
ing countries to gain comparative cost depends on the export of manufactured
advantages and remain competitive in the goods and technology, mainly to developing
global markets. Globalization has opened countries. Under such circumstances, the
the door for countries to compete in global existence of adequate liquidity becomes nec-
markets. This in turn has helped in manag- essary for strengthening confidence in global
ing rapid increase in energy prices by pro- markets and by keeping the flow of trade
ducing goods and services in those countries uninterrupted. Higher oil prices cause liq-
which still enjoy low wage rates such as uidity distribution to the oil exporting coun-
China and India. In the case of China, it is tries which have smaller propensity to spend
low wages paid to industrial workers that than oil importing countries. Countries with
are keeping China competitive in the wake high labor costs and capital intensive pro-
of rising petroleum prices. In other words, duction have the tendency to suffer due to
China competitive advantage position is inability to compete and because of loss
maintained by cheap labor. productivity. This makes government task
to manage macroeconomic variables and
LIQUIDITY AND GLOBAL DEMAND stabilize the economy very difficult, i.e.
monetary management over the economy
International liquidity is a stock of monetary weakens because of trade openness and bal-
assets, mainly foreign currencies and gold, ance of payments constraints. Countries
used for settlement of global trade and with heavy dependence on imported oil are
maintaining balance of payments equilib- expected to experience slow economic
rium. In other words, facilitating world growth and deterioration in its external bal-
trade and promoting global stability will ance. In relation to the external account,
depend on the circulation of international the International Monetary Fund points out
liquidity to meet the demand for exports that the decline in export demands leads to
and imports of various nations as well as to deterioration in the external account of oil
ensure lending for foreign capital used in importers causing the GDP to decline and
technology transfer, knowledge acquisition, current account deficits to worsen.xix
short term financing and other international
obligations. In many countries, economic In recent years, the rise in oil prices has
An assessment of international liquidity and higher oil prices 175

greatly influenced the liquidity positions of duce the risk of global recession, financial
many nations by redistributing foreign ex- instability, liquidity shortages and balance
change in favor of small nations, mainly oil of payments disequilibrium. Undertaking
exporting countries with a limited absorp- such action underscores the importance of
tive capacity. Revenues from oil have so far global cooperation and the construction of
exceeded their capacity to spend by gener- collective policies capable of restoring con-
ating pools of unused liquidity. For example, fidence in global financial markets and in-
Table 9 shows that the four oil exporting stitutions.xx Global stability depends on
countries in the Middle East, Saudi Arabia, international demand as well as on the dis-
Qatar, Kuwait and United Arab Emirates, tribution of liquidity among nations. De-
accumulated close to $200 billion in surplus mand for exports induces global growth by
in 2007 whereas current account balances allowing countries to increase production
Downloaded by MAHIDOL UNIVERSITY At 02:15 23 February 2015 (PT)

among OPEC countries accounted for and create employment, particularly in de-
about $350 billion in the same year. In veloping countries. For these countries, ex-
2007, the Gulf countries spent only one port earnings are essential for promoting
half of their earnings from export on im- socio-economic development and sustaining
ported goods and services leaving the rest in growth. To speed up the process of eco-
idle surplus funds. nomic transformation, these countries de-
pend on imported manufactured goods and
INTERNATIONAL LIQUIDITY technology for supporting investment pro-
MANAGEMENT grams and building productive capacity.
Thus rising share of energy in total imports
Managing global liquidity and facilitating could jeopardize growth potential by disal-
global trade require urgent initiatives to re- lowing these countries from meeting basic

Table 9: Total exports, imports and current account balance, selected countries in
the Middle East, 2007

Region Total Exports Share of oil in Total Imports Current account


total exports balance

OPEC 1,013,427 730,434 580,048 334,301

S. Arabia, 299,990 206,480 88,036 95,300

Kuwait 61,427 60,019 19,400 52,734

UAE 156,634 74,552 127,010 31,570

Qatar 37,952 27,801 22,042 5,453

Total GCC 556,003 368852 256,520 185,057

Source: Organization of the Petroleum Exporting Countries (OPEC), Annual Statistical Bulletin 2007
(Vienna: OPEC, 2007)
176 A. Al-Roubaie

Table 10: Expected current account impact of a $10 increase


in petroleum prices in 2004
Region Billions of % of 2003
US$ GDP
Other emerging markets and developing countries 101.7 1.3
Total exporters 133.5 4.3
Total importers -31.8 -0.7
Africa 21.9 3.9
Nigeria 7.4 12.8
Downloaded by MAHIDOL UNIVERSITY At 02:15 23 February 2015 (PT)

Central and Eastern Europe -2.2 -0.3


Former Soviet Union 24.7 4.3
Russia 20.3 4.7
Developing Asia -14.9 -0.5
Indonesia 0.3 0.2
China -7.6 -0.5
India -5.6 -1
Middle East 65.3 9.3
Libya 4.5 18.4
Kuwait 5.9 13.3
Qatar 3.4 16.8
Saudi Arabia 29.3 13.3
United Arab Emirates 8.5 10.6
Iran 9.2 6.7
Iraq 3.4 13.6
Western Hemisphere 6.9 0.3
Venezuela 7.9 9.3
Argentina 1.3 1.1
Brazil -1.2 -0.2
Mexico 6.3 1

Source: Huntington, Hillard, The Economic Consequences of Higher Crude Oil Prices, Energy Mod-
eling Forum, Stanford University, final report EMF SR 9. 2005 http:/www.stanford.edu.group/EMF/re-
search/doc/summary%2002-08-05.pdf
An assessment of international liquidity and higher oil prices 177

development needs. As pointed out by the economy through expenditures on imported


United Nations: goods and services. Most developing coun-
tries are under financial stress due to high
“Higher oil prices affect the economies energy prices. Shortages of liquidity restrain
of developing countries at both the macro – the developmental process by reducing pro-
and micro levels. An important part of the ductivity and slowing down economic
effects are transmitted through changes in growth. Recycling oil money keeps interna-
the terms of trade. According to UNCTD tional flows relatively stable by reducing the
estimates, the terms of trade of countries in impact of balance of payments deficits on
whose exports fuel products play a substan- trade transactions.
tial role increased by 30 per cent during
2002-2004. All fuel-importing developing International reserves represent the coun-
Downloaded by MAHIDOL UNIVERSITY At 02:15 23 February 2015 (PT)

countries with manufacturing-dominated try’s purchasing power in global markets.


exports experienced deterioration in their Most of theses reserves are made of foreign
terms of trade during this period. The terms- currencies, mainly dollar used by the coun-
of-trade losses for East and South Asian try to settle its external transactions. In
economies with predominantly manufac- other words, these reserves are used as a
turing exports ranged from 8 per cent for “buffer stock” for maintaining balance of
the Taiwan Province of China to over 14 payments equilibrium as well as to support
per cent for India in 2003 and 2004.”xxi the country’s exchange rates. Shortages of
reserves could cause substantial demotic
With the increased uncertainty about fu- macroeconomic instability. Minimizing the
ture demand and supply it becomes neces- risk of such instability requires governments
sary to have an emergency scheme for to formulate adequate strategy for managing
financing countries with a high degree of international reserves.
commodity fluctuations. International in-
stitutions such as the IMF can make the Most exporters of technology and manu-
funds available for maintaining capital ac- factured goods are non-developing countries
count convertibility and bailing out coun- which represent the drive behind the growth
tries with balance of payments difficulties. of the global economy. Slow export demand
undermines the stability of the international
Table 10 shows the impact of a $10 in- financial and economic systems and, there-
crease in petreloum prices on current ac- fore, assisting developing countries in meet-
count in several regions and countries. Oil ing their short term liquidity requirements,
exporters, especially those in the Middle reduces the risk of global recession. Benefits
East are to gain most from the increase in from such financing ensure economic and
petroleum prices. Among losers are those financial stability of oil exporting countries
experiencing high economic growth such as by keeping the flow of oil revenues uninter-
India, Brazil and developing Asia. rupted.

Oil producing countries could ease liq- CONCLUSION


uidity shortages by providing financial as-
sistance to countries facing balance of International liquidity provides emergency
payment disequilibrium. Such funds help funding to ensure economic stability and
recycle OPEC’s surplus back into the global correct balance of payments disequilibrium.
178 A. Al-Roubaie

Most developing countries usually suffer BIOGRAPHY


from shortages of reserves to maintain sta-
bility of their economies. Recent trends in Amer Al-Roubaie received his PhD in Eco-
prices of oil have brought fear that produc- nomics from McGill University in Montreal,
tivity of both local and global economies Canada. He taught economics in Canada,
will be negatively affected. Under such cir- the USA and Malaysia. Currently he is the
cumstances, sustaining growth could prove Dean of the College of Business and Fi-
to be difficult which in turn reduces these nance, Ahlia University, Bahrain. He has
countries capabilities to achieve their macro- written over 40 papers and currently he
economic objectives. Overcoming these un- (along with Professor Shafiq Alvi) is editing
predictable trends constitutes developing four-volume set on Islamic Banking and Fi-
global strategies to minimize price vulnera- nance to be published by Routledge at the
Downloaded by MAHIDOL UNIVERSITY At 02:15 23 February 2015 (PT)

bility and sustain economic growth. end of this year. He is the author of Global-
ization and the Muslim World, which is trans-
The future prospects of the global oil lated into several languages.
market stability will depend on the growth
in demand for energy, especially from the REFERENCES
newly emerging markets in Asia, as well as
the ability of existing supply capacity to sat- Al-Roubaie, A. and Elali, W. (1995).
isfy demand. In recent decades, the discov- The Financial Implications of Economic
Sanctions Agniat Iraq, Arab Studies Quar-
ery of oil reserves hasn’t proven sufficient to terly (ASQ), Vol. 7.
meet rising demand. Investment in an alter-
native energy sources hasn’t proven success- Cordesman, A. and Al-Rodhan, K. (2005).
ful in creating a viable substitute for The Changing Risks in Global Oil
conventional energy sources. The dynamism Supply and Demand: Crisis of Evolving So-
lutions, Center for Strategic and Interna-
of macroeconomic variables and growth in tional Studies (CSIS), Washington.
population are expected to widen energy
imbalances unless adequate energy policies, Energy Watch Group, (2007). Crude Oil: The
both locally and globally, are constructed. Supply Outlook,
Under such circumstances, international co- www.energywatchgroup.org
operation becomes necessary for bridging Holditch, S. and Chianelli, R. (2008).
the gap between supply and demand for en- Factors that will Influence Oil and
ergy. Petroleum-based products are presently Gas Supply and Demand in the 21st Cen-
used directly and indirectly in the produc- tury, MRS Bulletin – Volume 33.
tion of several goods which makes oil even www.mrs.org/bulletin
more critical than just a source of fuel. Huntington, H G. (2005). The Economic
Consequences of Higher Crude Oil Prices,
In developing countries, the private sector Stanford University, Final Report EMF SR9.
and non-governmental institutions must be www.stanford.edu/group/EMF/research/doc/
encouraged to take an active role in the man- summary%2002-08-05.pdf
agement of both the use of energy resources International Monetary Fund (IMF), (2000).
and the utilization of liquidity. Government The Impact of Higher Oil Prices on the
policy is to develop incentives for encourag- Global Economy,
ing private sector to contribute by providing www.imf.org/external/pubs/ft/oil/2000/inde
funding for research and development. x.htm
An assessment of international liquidity and higher oil prices 179

International Monetary Fund (IMF), (2007).


World Economic Outlook: Globalization
vided by International Energy Agency
and Inequality 07, Washington: Interna- (2006), Oil Market Report, www.oilmarke-
tional Monetary Fund treport.org

Mirakhor, A. and Zaidi, I. (2004). Foreign iii


See for details Holditch, Stephen and
Currency Deposits and International
Liquidity Shortages in Pakistan, IMF Work-
Chiaanelli, Russell (2008), Factors that will
ing paper WP/04/167. Influence Oil and Gas Supply and Demand
in the 21st Century, MRS Bulletin, Volume
OECD, International Energy Agency (IEA) 33, April 2008 www.mrs.org/bulletin
(2006). Oil Market Report, June 2006,
Paris, OECD www.oilmarketreport.org iv
See OECD, International Energy Agency,
Organization of Petroleum Exporting Countries Oil Market Report, June 2008
Downloaded by MAHIDOL UNIVERSITY At 02:15 23 February 2015 (PT)

(OPEC), Annual Statistical Bulletin (2007).


Monthly Oil Market Report, June 2008 v
See Cordesman, Anthony and Al-Rodhan,
Khalid (2005), The Changing Risks in
The Royal bank of Scotland (RBS), The Eco-
nomic Impact of High Oil Prices (August
Global Oil Supply and Demand: Crisis or
2004) www.rbs.co.uk/economics Evolving Solutions? Center for Strategic and
International Studies, Washington, DC.
United Nations, (2005). Link Global Economic
Outlook (Geneva: United Nations, 2005) vi
International Monetary Fund (2007),
United Nations (2008). United Nations Con-
World Economic Outlook: Globalization
ference on Trade and Development, Global- and Inequality
ization for Development: The International
Trade Perspective (New York: United Na- vii
Data are taken from Asian Development
tions, 2008). Bank (2010), Asian Development Outlook
United Nations, (2008). Economic and Social (Manila, 2010)
Survey of Asia and the Pacific 2008, New
viii
York: United Nations See OPEC (2008) Annual Statistical Bul-
letin (Austria: OPEC)

END NOTES ix
See United Nations (2005), Link Global
Economic Outlook, Development Policy
i
Details of the macroeconomic impact of and Analysis Division, Geneva
higher energy prices can be found in Inter-
x
national Energy Agency (IEA) (2006), Al-Roubaie, Amer and Elali, Wajeeh,
World Energy Outlook (Paris: IEA). The (1995) The Financial Implications of Eco-
agency argues that an increase in the price nomic Sanctions Against Iraq, Arab Studies
of oil leads to a transfer of income from im- Quarterly (ASQ) Volume 17, Issue 3
porting to exporting countries through a
xi
shift in the terms of trade. This in turn See for details International Monetary
leads to a reduction in the purchasing power Fund (2000), The Impact of Higher Oil
of the export earnings of importing coun- Prices on the Global Economy,
tries. www.imf.org/external/pubs/ft/oil/2000/ind
ex.htm
ii
Numbers are based on information pro-
180 A. Al-Roubaie

xii
See Birol, Fatih (2006) World Energy
xviii
Prospects and Challenges, International En- An emprical study to measure the impact
ergy Agency. He argues that the world en- of high oil prices on macroeconomic vari-
ergy needs would be more than 50% higher ables was conducted by Energy Information
in 2030 than today, an average annual Administration (EIA) showing that for a
growth rate of 1.6%. this increase in output 33-percent increase in the oil price sustained
more than two thirds of which will come for 2 years reduces real GDP by 0.2 percent
from developing countries. www.iea.org/pa- in the first year and 0.5 percent in the sec-
pers/2006/birol.pdf; Also see U.S. Depart- ond year. The study also measured the elas-
ment of Energy, Energy Information ticity response of real GDP to oil price
Administration (2009) International Energy indicating that the percentage change in
Outlook 2009. www.eia.doe.gov/oiaf/ieo/ real GDP relative to the percentage change
Downloaded by MAHIDOL UNIVERSITY At 02:15 23 February 2015 (PT)

index.html. in oil price is approximately 0.01 in the first


year and 0.02 in the second year. For details
xiii
Organization of the Petroleum Exporting see Energy Information Administration
Countries (2007), Annual Statistical Bul- (2006) Economic Effects of High Oil Prices,
letin www.eia.doe.gov/oiaf/aeo/otheranalysis/aeo
_2006analysispapers/efhop.html
xiv
Energy Watch Group (2007), Crude Oil:
xix
The Supply Outlook, www.energywatch- See International Monetary Fund (2000)
group.org The Impact of Higher Oil Prices on the
Global Economy www.imf.org/external/
xv
See The Royal Bank of Scotland (RBS) pubs/ft/oil/2000/index.htm
(2004), The Economic Impact of Higher
xx
Oil Prices, www.rbs.co.uk/economics See Holditch, Stephen and Chianell, Rus-
sell, Ibid
xvi
Mirakhor, Abbas and Zaidi, Iqbal (2004),
xxi
Foreign Currency Deposits and Interna- United Nations (2008), United Nations
tional Liquidity shortages in Pakistan, IMF, Conference on Trade and Development,
Working Paper WP/04/167 Globalization for Development: The Inter-
national Trade Perspective, New York, P.
xvii
See IMF (2000), Ibid. 51.

You might also like