Gender and Food Security

You might also like

Download as pdf or txt
Download as pdf or txt
You are on page 1of 10

Gender and Food Security

Food in the market: A Kyrgyz woman sells her farm produce by the roadside
(© HELVETAS Swiss Intercooperation)

This guidance sheet is one of a series


written to support SDC staff in en- Key issues
suring that gender issues are taken
into account transversally in differ- A. Labour: who does what in the food world, men own assets such as land
ent thematic domains – in this case, system? Whether a project addresses and equipment, and have primary
food security. It outlines key gender food production, processing, storage, decision-making power over them.
issues regarding food security, and marketing, preparation or consump- Nevertheless, local norms always need
how these can be integrated into the tion, it is essential to analyse the di- to be investigated, and project activi-
design, implementation, monitoring vision of tasks between women and ties framed according to the intended
and evaluation of cooperation strat- men and take this into account when change.
egies and project interventions. designing interventions. What is the
project’s theory of change in terms of C. External factors: How are women’s
how women’s and men’s activities will and men’s roles in the food sys-
be altered? How will this impact on the tem influenced by factors beyond
time used by women and men in other their control? The impacts of external
tasks – particularly women’s unpaid factors ranging from climate change,
care work? international commodity prices to
government policies are rarely gender
B. Assets: who has decision-making neutral, and their impact on project
control over the key assets in the activities needs to be analysed.
food system? In many parts of the

Gender and Food Security 1


1. Definitions: food systems and
food security

rity – that is, all the factors that go into


“Gender equality…is the single shaping the way that food is produced,
most important determinant of processed, traded, distributed, consumed
food security” Dr. Olivier de Schutter, former and potentially wasted in a given context.
UN Special Rapporteur on the Right to Food (2013) Food systems are heavily shaped by culture
and traditions, politics, the environmental
context, and national and international
An understanding of the food system is market systems.
necessary when working on food secu-

Physical availability Economic & physical


ood
of food access to food
foo
Gen
Ge derr d
Gender
nde division
ivision of labour,
labour,
related gender roles
related roles & (p
(practical
ractical
strategic) n
& strategic) eedss
eed
needs

W men’s access
omen’ss and men’s
omen’
Women’s
to & co
con
ntrol o
control ver rresources
over esources
esources
Food security is a “Situation in which all
W omen’ss and men’s
omen’
Women’s men’s people at all times have physical, social and
p articipation in d
participation ecisionmak
ecisionma king
decisionmaking economic access to sufficient, safe and
in NRM/f
NRM/ food policies
NRM/food policies nutritious food to meet their dietary needs
od
Food Enablin
Enabling and food preferences for an active and
healthy life” (FAO).
utilization environment
Food security rests upon four building blocks, all of which are highly gender sensitive.

Better nutrition: Home gardening by ethnic minority women in the highlands of Northern Laos
(© Helvetas / Patrick Rohr)

Gender and Food Security 2


2. Gender analysis related to food
systems and food security
2.1. Division of labour, gender roles and needs in food systems

Any project seeking to intervene in food areas of production, postharvest manage-


chains needs to analyse and understand the ment, distribution and management, and
different roles of women and men. Often processing and consumption.
these are very clearly drawn in all the four

Gendered tasks

Clear gender divisions in tasks tends to result on the shape of ploughs, and be interested interested in mulches to reduce weed infes-
in different spheres of knowledge and practi- in mechanised soil rotators; women may tation. Both interventions will reduce physical
cal needs. For example, men may be respon- be responsible for weeding, have detailed labour, but one will be more beneficial to
sible for ploughing, have detailed knowledge knowledge of different weed species, and be men, and the other, to women.

Production: Often women are respon- labour migration, the division of tasks may
sible for subsistence crops, and men for forcibly change, and place particular strain
commercial crops, although local norms on those left behind. The “feminisation of
should always be checked. Where women agriculture” is a common trend.
or men household members are absent on

Gender preferences for crops

The separate roles of women and men are mainly a women’s crop – produced, stored of what to sell is generally taken by both
often reflected in differing responsibilities and also sold with only minor involvement men and women, depending on the crop.
for, and ownership of, different crops. of men. In Benin, women often go to local
In West Africa, for instance, cowpeas are markets to sell crops; however, the decision

Postharvest management: Although ties in which men (through better access to


often considered mainly the preserve education) are more numerate and literate
of women, men may also have roles in than women. Nevertheless, in many parts
post-harvest management, especially more of the world, norms are changing.
technical aspects. Specific taboos or beliefs
(for example concerning food handling by Preparation and consumption: Whilst
women during their menstruation) can also this is mainly done by women, in different
influence who undertakes what task. communities men may also be involved
to a greater or lesser extent in preparing
Distribution and marketing: Most small food. Access to clean drinking water and
farm households sell a certain part/number sanitation is of course a pre-requisite for
of their crops and animals to buyers on local healthy food preparation and consump-
or national markets. Often men are particu- tion – but this topic is beyond the scope
larly active in marketing, especially in socie- of this note.

Gender and Food Security 3


Unpaid care and domestic work: An lecting water and firewood, processing and
important aspect regarding the division preparing food, travelling and transporting,
of labour cutting across the four areas of and caregiving. These tasks are unpaid,
production, postharvest management, dis- restrict a woman’s time and mobility and
tribution and consumption is the division are a major constraint to the ability of
of unpaid care and domestic work, which smallholder farmers to increase agricultural
lies largely in the hands of women. Rural productivity and achieve food and nutrition
women of all ages spend much of their day security.
engaged in domestic chores, including col-

Reducing the burden of unpaid domestic chores

Labour-saving technologies and practices in decision-making processes and devel- eficiaries but men also benefit, depending
promote inclusive development by reducing opment opportunities, and to enjoy more on the extent to which they perform these
the domestic workload and freeing up time leisure time. When the domestic workload tasks. Source: IFAD toolkit 2016
to perform productive tasks, to participate is reduced, women are the principal ben-

2.2. Access to and control over resources related to food

It is also important to analyse women’s and Physical assets – land and water: Access
men’s access to and control over resources to land and water is fundamental for food
related to food – here divided into physical, production, hence it is crucial to understand
financial and knowledge assets. who controls these resources, and decides
upon their use.

Care and ownership of livestock

Animals are an important asset of rural of production (e.g. manure, cattle for of the animal care. Small ruminants and
households in terms of food security. They ploughing). Often, large livestock such as backyard poultry are very often owned by
are a source of food (milk, meat), a capi- cattle are considered a family asset, but as well as cared for by women – but men
tal asset which can be sold in periods of are effectively owned (bought and sold) may become more involved in large scale
shortage, as well as an essential means by men, whilst women undertake most commercial production.

In most parts of the world, more land decision-making. More often than not,
is owned by men than by women (the men control land use, deciding what crops
exception being in matrilineal societies), should be grown, where. Nevertheless, the
and in many countries women are legally facts on land ownership vary by country
discriminated regarding land rights. Fur- and should always be carefully investigated,
thermore, where “joint” ownership is the not assumed.
norm, this does not necessarily equate joint

Land ownership and control

In Niger and Mali, most agricultural land improve the land (they cannot raise any that women formed saving groups. With
is controlled by men, and it is common loan, due to a lack of collateral). Productivi- the benefits they rented or bought the land
for men to lend fields to women family ty is thus low – to the detriment of the food from their husbands or other community
members, but to claim it back whenever security of the entire family. An innovative members and thus became autonomous
they wish. As a consequence, women have strategy initiated by some programs to gain land owners.
neither incentive nor much opportunity to better access and control over land was

Gender and Food Security 4


Financial assets – capital and access to given the opportunity, women spend more
credit: Who controls the household financ- of the household budget on children’s food
es and essential capital goods such as the than men.
house, machinery or animals has important
implications on access to other food rele- Knowledge assets – access to informa-
vant resources. Often women are unable to tion: Women and men in rural communi-
access credit as they have no capital assets ties often have differing knowledge bases
to serve as collateral – although in some as a result of differing experience, levels of
countries, micro-credit schemes recognis- education (higher illiteracy in women), mo-
ing this difficulty are available. Remittances bility, and time (to listen to the radio, attend
from family members working as migrant meetings, etc). Most rural advisory services
labourers may be channelled to women, in developing countries are oriented to-
but are often sent to male relatives. Women wards men’s needs, with the advice being
and men tend to have different priorities; provided mostly by men to men. Reaching
for example, women may favour organic women often requires special thought and
food production, whilst men are more likely tailoring, taking into account local gender
to use chemical inputs. Studies in countries norms – included those related to mobility,
such as India and Bangladesh show that and interaction in public.

2.3. Participation in decision-making in natural resource ma-


nagement and food regulation policies

Tackling strategic needs in food security a very effective means to improve house-
interventions requires a long-term horizon, hold food security.
since this means questioning and re-ne-
gotiating existing labour divisions, deci- Food policies and regulatory frame-
sion-making patterns and power relations works: It is particularly important that
that may be deeply rooted in culture and women’s opinions and needs as well as
history. those of men are taken into account in mak-
ing political decisions over food production
Access and control over resources re- systems and food chains. Examples of such
lated to food: One important strategic decisions include introducing new quali-
intervention is to promoting more equitable ty standards for staple crops on national
decision-making over resources closely tied markets, policies related to improved seed
to food production. For instance, promot- production and distribution, or campaigns
ing secure access to land for women can be fostering nutrition sensitive agriculture.

New eating patterns: Women in Ethiopia prepare prickly pear cactus as a vegetable
(@Helvetas / Annette Boutellier)

Gender and Food Security 5


3. External factors and policy environ­-
ment on gender and food security

Gender roles and relationships are constantly impacts on women and men are neverthe-
changing. Some changes are small and local, less often different.
such as women representatives voted into lo-
cal government offices; others are more fun- Migration and remittances: Seasonal or
damental and may concern an entire region permanent migration of family members
or country – such as a policy to allocate food can have a major impact on the division of
tokens or cash to women members of poor labour and decision making in the house-
households. To understand the dynamics holds and communities. Remittances may
of gender aspects in food security, it is im- also influence the distribution of, access to,
portant to be aware of the impact of wider and control over resources related to the
trends such as climate change or the price of local food economy and food security.
commodities on the international market.
Commodity prices: Falling or rising prices
Climate change: Changes in the ecosystem of major commodities such as wheat, sug-
such as global warming or the extension of ar, coffee and cocoa, and how these are
dry or rainy periods often have an impact on communicated to small-holder farmers, in-
the type of locally produced food, the pro- evitably influence their production choices.
duction systems, and food conservation prac- International food companies play a signifi-
tices. This may in turn influence gendered cant role in this respect.
divisions of labour and decision making.
Food culture: The consumption pattern
Deterioration of natural resources and of food may alter considerably due to eco-
natural disasters: Soil degradation, de- nomic development, wealth, or imported
forestation, and the pollution or shortage “foreign” food culture. Much potential lies
of water sources due to unsustainable use in rendering traditional, nutritious foods
can have a massive impact on local or re- more convenient (less laborious) to prepare;
gional food production. The same is true of women are usually particularly targeted in
natural disasters such as earthquakes. The this respect.

Food culture

In the Andean highlands, the traditional male) migrant labour. With the “discovery” to climate change) are being investigated,
high protein crops of quinoa and cañahua of quinoa as a health food, and a growing as are labour-saving methods of prepara-
had until recently largely given way to the export demand for the crop, there has been tion – working particularly with indigenous
potato – or even reliance on imported food- a revival of its cultivation. Varieties better women’s groups.
stuffs paid with remittances from (mainly adapted to changing weather patterns (due

Traditional food crop: A man harvests quinoa in the Bolivian highlands


(© Helvetas / Simon B. Opladen)

Gender and Food Security 6


Summary of key considerations in a gendered analysis of food systems

Division of labour, gender roles and needs in food systems

Production Who does the clearing and ploughing of the field, the preparing or buying of the seeds,
manures, other inputs? Who does the sowing, manuring, weeding, protecting, irrigating
and harvesting? Who organises helpers or hires external workers? Who looks after live-
stock feeding, stalling, fodder production, manure management, and health care (e.g.
vaccination)?

Postharvest management Who does the drying, threshing, winnowing, sorting, storage and conservation of crops?
For each of these steps: how much time is invested by women and men? What are the
specific needs of women and men in postharvest management?

Distribution & marketing Who goes to the market or negotiates with local traders to sell grains, vegetables or
animals? Who collects relevant information on market prices and selling opportunities?
Who selects and controls the quality of marketed products? How far are women and men
involved in running local stalls, shops or businesses for food trade? Who manages the
money earned from food sales? Especially in sparsely populated, remote areas, how are
women and men organised in transporting food products?

Preparation & consumption Who is in charge of fetching or buying the required food items and preparing the meals?
Who carries out milking or slaughtering of animals? Who allocates the food to the different
family members including children, elderly and disabled, making sure the diet is balanced
and nutritious? Are certain food items reserved for men, women, elderly, or children?

Access & control over resources

Physical assets Who owns and controls the land and decides on its allocation to family members or third
parties? Who decides what crop is produced when, how, and on which land? Do women
and men have access to equally productive land? Do men and women have equal access
to water for agriculture, or to land that is close to water resources? What access do men
and women have to drinking water, and who controls its use? Who owns, as opposed to
who cares for, animals? Who decides where animals are allowed to graze and from where
fodder can be cut?

Financial assets Who manages the overall household budget? Who buys seeds, manure, fertilizers, pesti-
cides, fodder and medication for animals, and equipment? Who employs labourers? Who
owns grain granaries, and who controls the stored produce? Who owns the food as such
(this can sometimes be used as collateral for bank loans)? Who decides upon the buying
of food?

Knowledge assets How is information related to agricultural innovations, postharvest management, mar-
keting and healthy preparation of food provided? How can it be specifically orientated to
women’s and men’s needs?

Participation in decision-making

Strategic access to resources What is the impact on small holder farmers of external factors beyond their control – cli-
mate change, environmental disasters, migration, changing consumer preferences? Does
this result in any change in the roles and decision making processes of women and men
in the production system?

Policies, regulatory frameworks What national policies are in place regarding food – especially subsidies for particular
foodstuffs? Do these have an impact on the project interventions, and are there different
implications for women and men?

Gender and Food Security 7


4. Gender-responsive interventions
in food security
4.1. Gender-sensitive (mainstreamed) and gender-specific
(targeted) interventions

It is common for those planning food se- (often especially in food processing) or im-
curity projects to focus on a particular part prove their knowledge on nutrition (when
of the food system, and to identify activi- it is primarily they who are responsible for
ties that will improve the efficiency of this preparing meals). Gender-targeted inter-
system. As long as a thorough analysis is ventions should not only focus on women,
made of who undertakes which activities, but also promote understanding and agree-
and interventions then targeted in a gen- ment amongst men. This may be particular-
der-responsive manner, the result is gender ly necessary if the intervention requires a
mainstreaming. However, there may also financial outlay by the household. Gender
be situations in which there is a clear need mainstreaming and gender-targeting are
for a gender-targeted intervention – for not mutually exclusive; both approaches
example, to reduce women’s labour burden can be incorporated in a single project.

Enhancing the nutrition of upland farming families in Laos

The incidence of stunting amongst chil- issue has a number of components, available food from the monoculture of
dren of ethnic communities in the up- focused at household, regional and na- maize). The second is an educational
lands of Northern Laos is amongst the tional policy level. Two interventions are programme raising awareness about
highest in the world, being estimated specifically targeted towards women. balanced diets and how to prepare nu-
to effect over 60% of all children under One is the promotion of home gardens tritional meals.
the age of five in such communities. An in which a variety of nutritious vegeta-
SDC-supported project addressing this bles are cultivated (thus diversifying the

Labour-saving devices and changes to the division of labour

In many countries, women thresh maize not automatically mean that work time machines are introduced, unless they
cobs by hand, one by one, prior to is reduced for both sexes. In Northern can be driven manually, they are usually
each meal. A mechanical thresher can Benin, women and men are both in- only used by men.
reduce this labour burden – but may volved in threshing, but once threshing

4.2. Considering the gender-responsiveness of partners

Projects usually work with a variety of sensitivity during project implementation


implementing partners – government, should be built into the project design.
non-government, and the private sector. There may also be some flexibility to select
The gender awareness of such partners partners that demonstrate knowledge of,
can vary considerably, and should be and commitment to, gender equality. For
assessed at the time of project design. example, food processing companies are
Whilst there may be good reason to work increasingly conscious of demonstrating
with certain partners that are not particu- “corporate responsibility”, including gen-
larly gender sensitive, ways to raise such dered aspects.

Gender and Food Security 8


4.3. Gender-responsiveness of staff

Project partners cannot be expected to be staff job descriptions and taken seriously in
gender-sensitive if project staff fail to demon- performance assessments is an important
strate such awareness themselves. Ensuring part of any project intervention.
that gender-responsiveness is written into

4.4. The potential for “up-scaling”

Often promising gender-responsive op- applications. These should be assessed,


portunities with regard to food security lie included in the project theory of change,
in improving women’s access to and con- and specific steps for replication built into
trol over resources; however, many other the project design.
interventions can also have wide-ranging

Riverbed farming: making land available to the landless, especially women

In the Tarai region of Nepal, the to flash flooding; when well managed to save and invest in future livelihood
seasonal cultivation of vegetables in small plots, they can be highly opportunities. Since first trials in 2006,
on riverbeds is being promoted as a productive. Plots are leased to target the Riverbed Farming Project has ex-
means to improve the food security individuals for a maximum three year panded to reach well over 6,000 lease
and income of landless and land-poor period. Those targeted are particularly holders, and an alliance of government
households. Such riverbeds are mainly women; men in these households are and non-government actors working
owned by the district authorities, and often absent on labour migration. on the issue has been established to
were previously uncultivated. They are Lessees have not only been able to im- exchange experiences and contribute
generally very fertile although at risk prove their family’s nutrition, but also to national policy.

Land for the landless: Women prepare a riverbed for vegetable cultivation in lowland Nepal
(© Helvetas / Simon B. Opladen)

Gender and Food Security 9


5. Important aspects for monitoring
& evaluation

The following points should be given par- or preparation activities; the degree of
ticular consideration. access to and control over resources;
>> Develop a theory of change that and the extent of participation in
explicitly mentions how the role of decisions related to food security.
women and men in the part of the food >> Allow for the monitoring of not only
system addressed will change as a result intended results, but also possible
of project interventions. unintended results – for example, that
>> Ensure that a sex-disaggregated baseline women’s work burden will be increased
is established, along with gender-specif- as a result of a particular intervention.
ic indicators and targets of numbers of >> Ensure that findings – both positive and
women and men engaged in activities. negative – are fed back into interven-
Key indicators may include the amount tion design through gender-sensitive
of time used in food production, storage processes.

Selected references

ADB, 2013 Gender Equality and Food Se- Guest writer on Oxfam From Poverty to
curity Women’s Empowerment as a Tool Power blog. https://oxfamblogs.org/fp2p/
against Hunger FAO and Asian Development killer-factcheck-women-own-2-of-land-
Bank. http://www.srfood.org/images/sto- not-true-what-do-we-really-know-about-
ries/pdf/otherdocuments/20130724_gen- women-and-land/
derfoodsec_en.pdf
SDC, Enhancing Nutrition of Upland Farm-
Bridge, 2014, Gender and Food Security. ing Families: project in Laos. https://www.
Towards gender-just food and nutrition eda.admin.ch/deza/en/home/activities-pro-
security. Institute of Development Stud- jects/projects.html/content/projects/SDC/
ies. http://www.bridge.ids.ac.uk/food-se- en/2015/7F09364/phase99?oldPagePath=/
curity content/deza/en/home/aktivitaeten_pro-
jekte/projekte.html
Carter, J. and Weigel, N., 2011 Targeting
Women in Rural Advisory Services (RAS)
Agriculture and Food Security Network
Brief 1. https://www.shareweb.ch/site/ Main author
Agriculture-and-Food-Security/focusareas/ Raphael Dischl, with contributions by Jane
Documents/ras_targeting_women_nw_ Carter, Helvetas Swiss Intercooperation
brief1.pdf
Commissioned and overseen by
Doss, C., 2014 Killer fact check: ‘Women Ursula Keller, Senior Gender Policy Adviser,
own 2% of land’ = not true. What do Swiss Agency for Development and
we really know about women and land? Cooperation

Gender and Food Security 10

You might also like