Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Design of Coplanar Waveguide Elliptic Low Pass Filters
Design of Coplanar Waveguide Elliptic Low Pass Filters
Design of Coplanar Waveguide Elliptic Low Pass Filters
ABSTRACT: This article proposes three design topologies of coplanar waveguide elliptic
low pass filters. The design procedure is simple and explained in detail for the first topology.
Numerical results are provided using the commercially available simulation softwares IE3D
and HFSS to show the validity of the design with very good agreement. The proposed filters
yield less than 0.1 dB attenuation in the passband (0–2 GHz), with a controllable slope of
the transition between passband and stopband. The width of the rejection band is increased
by simple filter cascading resulting in a passband to stopband ratio of up to 1:6. V C 2009
Wiley Periodicals, Inc. Int J RF and Microwave CAE 19: 540–548, 2009.
I. INTRODUCTION ities between the very high and very low impedance
line sections degrade the filter performance. Recently,
Low pass filters (LPF) have been widely used to sup- semi-lumped microstrip low-pass filters [3] were
press undesired modes and spurious signals in nonlin- reported with a sharp cutoff frequency response.
ear devices like mixers and frequency multipliers, Unfortunately, soldering-lumped components will
etc. They have also been used to convert analog increase fabrication difficulties and also manufactur-
signals to band-limited signals before sampling and ing repeatability is difficult to maintain. Low-pass
digitization [1]. microstrip filters using coupled lines [4] or stepped-
Several types of low pass filters have been pro- impedance hairpin resonators [5] have finite attenua-
posed in the literature. Among these are stepped tion poles in the cutoff frequency band. However,
impedance filters of the Chebyshev or maximally flat because the capacitance of the coupled lines is too
types [2]. These filters provide only a gradual transi- small, the finite attenuation pole cannot be located
tion from pass-band to stop-band and the discontinu- close to the pass-band. Consequently, the cutoff fre-
quency response is gradual. Dahlan and Eesa [6]
reduced the size of the microstrip hairpin filter of [5]
Correspondence to: N. I. Dib; e-mail: nihad@just.edu.jo by using folded stepped impedance hairpin resona-
DOI 10.1002/mmce.20376
Published online 26 June 2009 in Wiley InterScience (www. tors. Arnedo et al [7] produced a microstrip filter
interscience.wiley.com). with wide rejection band by periodically changing
540
Coplanar Waveguide Elliptic Low Pass Filters 541
Using this table, the lumped element values which capacitive blocks consisting of a wide CPW transmis-
yield the ideal response of Figure 1 for LAr 5 0.1 dB, sion line having low impedance [2]. The series capac-
Xc 5 1, Xs 5 1.6949, and for unity feed and load itance C20 is replaced by a CPW interdigital capacitor,
impedances (Zo 5 Z4 5 1 X) are given by: C1 5 whereas the series inductance L2 is replaced by a
C3 5 0.8333, L2 5 0.8439, and C20 5 0.3252. shorted CPW stub as shown in Figure 3.
The following frequency and load transformations
[17] are applied to the prototype element values of
Figure 2 to achieve the desired cutoff frequency (fc 5 A. Parametric Study of Topology 1
2 GHz) and the desired feed and load impedance of Before going through the design procedure, it is use-
Zo 5 Z4 5 50 X: ful to perform a parametric study of this filter using
Zo L2
L2 ¼ ð2Þ
2pfc
Ci
Ci ¼ for C1 ; C3 and C02 ð3Þ
2pZo fc
the commercial software IE3D [15]. For this particu- increasing the length LC, the cutoff frequency is
lar topology, with no airbridges, IE3D solves for the reduced more significantly if compared with increas-
magnetic current on the slots instead of the electric ing LD. Also, the first transmission zero is shifted
current on the entire conductor surface including the downward and the slope of the transition from pass-
ground plane. This significantly reduces the computa- band to stopband increases.
tion time and memory [15]. Throughout the article,
the dielectric substrate used is RT/Duroid 6010 hav- 3. Effect of LA and LB. Figure 6 shows that
ing er 5 10.8 and thickness 5 0.635 mm. increasing both C1 and C3 (by increasing LA and LB
by same amount) causes a decrease in the cutoff fre-
1. Effect of LD. By increasing LD, C20 is increased quency and an increase in the passband ripple. There
(see Fig. 3). This causes a slight downward shift in is also a slight increase in the width of the stopband.
the cutoff frequency (below 2 GHz) and a more sig-
nificant decrease in the position of the first transmis-
sion null, and hence, an increase in the slope of the
B. Design Procedure of a Single Stage
transition from passband to stopband. This is shown
LPF (Topology 1)
in Figure 4. Also, as LD is further increased above
3.85 mm, a second transmission null appears inside Initially, the substrate is chosen to be RT/Duroid
the frequency range of interest [0–8] GHz. This effect 6010 having er 5 10.8 and thickness 5 0.635 mm.
will be useful when cascading several sections of this Using the software Linegauge of Zeland [15], which
LPF as explained in Section (3.B). has closed form quasi-static expressions for the effec-
tive dielectric constant and characteristic impedance
2. Effect of LC. The series inductance L2 is pre- of a general CPW, the slot width W and strip width S
dominantly controlled by the length LC of the shorted of the feed and load CPW lines are chosen to give a
stub (see Fig. 3). Several simulations were also per- characteristic impedance of 50 X. This corresponds
formed using IE3D [15]. Figure 5 shows that by to S 5 1.42 mm and W 5 0.45 mm.
TABLE I. Design Steps of a Single Section LPF of Topology 1 [See Fig. (3)]
No. LA 5 LB (mm) LC (mm) LD (mm) Im(Y11) (S) Im(Y21) (S) C1 5 C3 (pF) L2 (nH) C20 (pF)
1 6.02 4.947 0.851 0.006286 0.02103 2.17 0.458 2.97
2 4.02 4.947 0.851 20.00276 0.02016 1.38 0.47 3.05
3 4.02 4.947 1.151 20.00225 0.01984 1.4 0.475 3.08
4 4.02 4.947 2.151 20.00039 0.01869 1.46 0.493 3.2
5 3.52 4.947 3.151 0.00167 0.01745 1.52 0.513 3.33
6 3.52 4.947 3.151 20.00042 0.01748 1.36 0.513 3.33
7 3.52 4.947 3.351 0.000024 0.01722 1.37 0.517 3.36
ImðY11 þ Y21 Þ
C1 ¼ C3 ¼ ð6Þ
xc
ImðY21 Þ C0
where A ¼ ImðY 11 Þ
, B ¼ ðx Z 2Þ2 L , g20 5 C2 and g2 5
c o 2
Figure 8. Topology 1, with three sections (er 5 10.8, h 5 0.635 mm, all dimensions are in mm).
Figure 13. Topology 2 with two sections (er 5 10.8, h 5 0.635 mm, airbridge dimensions ha
5 12 lm, Wa 5 30 lm, all dimensions are in mm).
BIOGRAPHIES
Amjad A. Omar received the B.Sc. and GHz, low-temperature co-fired ceramic (LTCC) packaging, and
M.Sc. in Electrical Engineering from Ku- RF microelectromechanical systems (MEMS) switches.
wait University in 1985 and 1988, respec-
tively. He received the Ph.D. in Electrical Maximilian C. Scardelletti (S’96–M’99
Engineering from the University of –SM’06) received the B.S.E.E. and
Waterloo, Canada, in 1993. He worked at M.S.E.E degrees from University of South
the Communications Research Center in Florida, Tampa, FL in 1997 and 1999,
Ottawa for 2 years (1993–1995). Since respectively. He is currently enrolled in
1995, he has been working at several Case Western Reserve University, Cleve-
universities in the UAE and Jordan, and land, OH where he is working towards a
currently, he is an Associate Professor at the Communication Ph.D. in electrical engineering. Maximi-
Engineering Department of the Hijjawi College for Engineer- lian is a senior research engineer with the
ing Technology at Yarmouk University in Jordan. His research Communications, Controls and Instrumen-
interests include computational electromagnetics, design of tation Division at NASA Glenn Research Center in Cleveland,
microwave and millimeter wave circuit components, biomedical OH since 1999. He has authored and coauthored over 40 papers
applications of electromagnetics, and smart antennas. He has over in refereed and symposium proceedings. His research interests
60 publications in various journals and refereed international include micromechanical (MEMS) devices, high temperature cir-
conferences. cuits and systems, and antenna design for wireless communica-
tions. Max is a senior member of IEEE and he is the chair for the
Nihad I. Dib obtained his B.Sc. and IEEE Antennas and Propagation\Microwave Theory and Techni-
M.Sc. in EE from Kuwait University in ques Society Cleveland Chapter.
1985 and 1987, respectively. He obtained
his Ph.D. in EE (major in Electromag- Raed M. Shubair received his B.Sc.
netics and Microwaves) in 1992 from degree from Kuwait University, Kuwait,
University of Michigan, Ann Arbor. in June 1989 and his Ph.D. degree from
Then, he worked as an assistant research the University of Waterloo, Canada, in
scientist in the radiation laboratory at the February 1993, both in Electrical Engi-
same school. In Sep. 1995, he joined the neering. From March 1993 to August
EE department at Jordan University of 1993 he was a Postdoctoral Fellow at the
Science and Technology (JUST) as an assistant professor, and Department of Electrical and Computer
became a full professor in Aug. 2006. His research interests are Engineering, University of Waterloo,
in computational electromagnetics and modeling of planar micro- Canada. In August 1993 he joined Khalifa
wave circuits. University of Science, Technology and Research (formerly Etisalat
University College), UAE, where he is currently an Associate Pro-
Khelifa Hettak (M’05–SM’06) received fessor at the Communication Engineering Department and Leader
the Dipl.-Ing. degree in telecommunica- of the Communication and Information Systems Research Group.
tions from the University of Algiers, His current research interests include adaptive array and multi-
Algiers, Algeria, in 1990, and the M.A.Sc. channel processing, smart antennas, and MIMO systems, as well
and Ph.D. degrees in signal processing as applied and computational electromagnetic modeling of RF and
and telecommunications from the Univer- microwave circuits for wireless communications. He has published
sity of Rennes 1, Rennes, France, in 1992 over 80 papers in refereed technical journals and international
and 1996, respectively. In January 1997, conferences. He has been a member of the technical program,
he was with the Personal Communications organizing, and steering committees of numerous international
Staff of the Institut National de la Recher- conferences and workshops. Dr. Shubair is a founding member of
che Scientifique (INRS)-Télécommunications. In October 1998, the IEEE UAE Signal Processing and Communications Joint Soci-
he joined the Electrical Engineering Department, Laval Univer- eties Chapter. He currently acts as Symposium Vice-Chair of the
sity, where he was an Associate Researcher involved in RF 2008 IEEE Canadian Conference on Electrical and Computer
aspects of smart antennas. Since August 1999, he has been with Engineering: Communications and Networking Symposium. Dr.
Terrestrial Wireless Systems Branch, Communications Research Shubair is Editor for the Journal of Communications, Academy
Centre (CRC) Canada, Ottawa, ON, Canada, as a Research Scien- Publisher. He is listed in Who’s Who in Electromagnetics and in
tist, where he is involved in the development of MMICs at 60 several editions of Who’s Who in Science and Engineering.