Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Dual Polarizedslotcoupled Antenna
Dual Polarizedslotcoupled Antenna
Dual Polarizedslotcoupled Antenna
DOI: 10.1002/mop.32138
RESEARCH ARTICLE
monostatic antenna with high The future wireless networks including 5G systems will
require high throughput in limited bandwidth in order to
isolation for 2.4 GHz full improve the spectral efficiency. The in-band full duplex
(IBFD) radio with monostatic antenna has the potential to
duplex applications double the spectral efficiency through simultaneous transmit
and receive (STAR) operation within same frequency band.1-3
Haq Nawaz | Muhammad A. Basit | Furthermore, the IBFD operation can effectively resolve
Furqan Shaukat many problems and issues in wireless communication net-
works and the STAR/IBFD transceivers can be implemented
with reduced cost by using current multi-in multi-out
Electronics Engineering, University of Engineering and Technology (UET),
Taxila, Chakwal, Pakistan
(MIMO) transceivers.4,5
However, the practical realization of IBFD operation
Correspondence requires high levels of self-interference cancellation (SIC) on
Haq Nawaz, Electronics Engineering, University of Engineering and
receive side for successful detection of very low power
Technology (UET) Taxila, Sub-Campus Chakwal, 48800, Chakwal,
Pakistan.
received signal of interest (SOI) as these high levels of SIC
Email: hnawaz@sabanciuniv.edu prevent the degradation in signal to noise (SNR) ratio resulted
from high power SI induced by co-located transmit chain.6
Abstract Such high levels of SI are comprised of both linear and
nonlinear components and should be effectively suppressed to
This paper presents a compact, dual polarized, differen-
achieve all potential gains of IBFD wireless operation.1,6,7 The
tially fed monostatic slot coupled patch antenna with
required SIC levels are defined by the various parameters
high isolation between transmit (Tx) and receive (Rx)
ports for 2.4GHz simultaneous transmit and receive including the levels of radiated power from transmitter in addi-
(STAR) or in-band full duplex (IBFD) wireless applica- tion to noise figure and bandwidth of system.6 For instance,
tions. By using the proposed differential feeding for the required levels of SIC for a radio transceiver with
receive (Rx) mode operation through symmetrically +30 dBm transmit power (Pt), 20 MHz bandwidth (B.W) and
placed feeds of radiating patch, the self-interference 11 dB typical noise Figure (NF) can be determined as6:
(SI) is well canceled to demonstrate high Tx-Rx interport Noise Power ðPn Þ = −174dBm + 10logðBWÞ + NF
isolation. The simulation and measurement results for
presented IBFD antenna indicate very high levels of = −174dBm + 73 + 11 = −90dBm ð1Þ
interport isolation achieved through differential feeding
Required SIC levels = Pt − Pn = 30 + 90 = 120dB ð2Þ
based self-interference cancellation (SIC) mechanism.
The implemented prototype (validation model) of pro- The SIC levels given by (2) are required to obtain 0 dB
posed dual port, dual polarized, slot coupled antenna residual SI for given specifications as indicated in Figure 1.
achieves more than 95 dB peak isolation and 90 dB iso- A low Tx power can relax the required SIC levels, however,
lation in 20 MHz bandwidth. Moreover, the achieved Tx- the coverage or range will also be reduced accordingly when
Rx isolation is around 85 dB within antenna’s 10 dB- Tx power is lowered.
return loss impedance bandwidth of 45 MHz. To the best In order to achieve such high levels of required SIC,
of our knowledge, these are the highest levels of interport multiple SIC techniques at successive stages across the
RF isolation reported for dual polarized monostatic patch transceiver are deployed.8 Normally, these stages utilize
antenna. techniques based on SI suppression in both analog/RF and
digital domain in conjunction with an antenna having high
KEYWORDS Tx-Rx interport isolation.9 However, a large amount of SIC
dual polarized antenna, full duplex antenna, high interport isolation, should be performed at RF front to avoid the saturation of
self-interference cancellation (SIC), slot coupled antenna receive chain from very strong SI signal.7,10 In other words,
the analog/RF domain SIC and a monostatic antenna with
Microw Opt Technol Lett. 2019;1–8. wileyonlinelibrary.com/journal/mop © 2019 Wiley Periodicals, Inc. 1
2 NAWAZ ET AL.
F I G U R E 1 A, Various components of self-interference (SI), B, around 120 dB SIC across transceiver using monostatic antenna with 90 dB
interport isolation with 30 dB digital SIC [Color figure can be viewed at wileyonlinelibrary.com]
high port to port isolation are required to obtain required ~20 dB additional isolation compared to its basic configura-
levels of Tx-Rx isolation at RF front end. In general, the digi- tion.13 Furthermore, multilayered antenna structures with
tal domain SIC techniques (time or frequency based) can hybrid feeding networks can be used to improve the Tx-Rx
provide 25-30 dB SIC and an antenna having around 90 dB isolation.14 For example, the multilayer IBFD antenna15 or
interport isolation can be used to realize an IBFD operation patch antenna with hybrid feedings16 can provide additional
with 30 dBm transmit power and 20 MHz bandwidth as 15-20 dB Tx-Rx isolation on the top of interport isolation
indicated in Figure 1. Such implementation without addi- achieved with polarization diversity (dual polarization). The
tional analog/RF domain SIC provides an effective solution additional isolation in this case is resulted through sand-
to implement IBFD transceiver with reduced complexity and wiched layer of ground plane which isolates the Tx and Rx
cost for low power (up to 30 dBm transmit power for ports electromagnetically. The reported antenna in Reference
20 MHz bandwidth) full duplex wireless applications as 17, utilizes additional path with ring mono-radiator to obtain
shown in Figure 1. around 20 dB isolation in 1.85-2.62 GHz bandwidth. The
A separate Tx and Rx antennas (bistatic antenna system) interport isolation for such dual polarized patch antenna can
can be used for IBFD transceiver where the physical spacing also be improved through differential feeding18-20 or by
between both antennas can be increased to achieve improved using analog domain based SIC circuits.21-23 An analog SIC
Tx-Rx isolation. However, such bistatic antenna system can circuit with circulator can also be used to obtain >40 dB
itself be utilized in half duplex MIMO systems to improve SIC within 65 MHz bandwidth as reported in Reference 24.
the throughput, thus weakening the real motive and purpose The RF circulator separates the Tx and Rx signals at first
of IBFD.11 The bistatic antenna system also hinders the stage. Then, the inherent secondary SI signals reflected at
implementation of compact transceiver as very large inter- antenna/circulator interface are used to cancel the intended
antenna spacing is required for high Tx-Rx isolation. An SI coupled to Rx port. Moreover, the frequency response of
IBFD transceiver with single/shared antenna (monostatic the secondary SI signals is modified by using a recon-
antenna system) can achieve the real gains of IBFD opera- figurable impedance mismatched terminal circuit to achieve
tion.11 The monostatic IBFD antenna having high Tx-Rx port the reported isolation levels.
to port isolation can be deployed to realize a compact IBFD In this work, the proposed antenna is comprised of three
transceiver and such antenna with high interport isolation at ports radiating patch having two symmetrically placed slot
transceiver’s front end also suppresses the strong SI signal to coupled ports with respect to a third port with thin quarter-
prevent the saturation of analog to digital converter (ADC) wave (λ/4) co-planar feed. The proposed differential feeding
in Rx chain.6,12 for Rx mode through slot coupled ports effectively sup-
Normally, the monostatic antennas have dual polarized presses the Tx coupling to achieve high interport isolation. A
characteristics to generate horizontal and vertical polariza- simple 3 dB/180 power divider/combiner with nice ampli-
tions (TM01 and TM10 modes) when excited from respective tude and phase balance performance has been used as differ-
edges through two perpendicular feeds. This basic configura- ential SIC circuit. The mathematical description is also given
tion provides ~35-40 dB interport isolation through for differential feeding based SIC operation and the effect of
uncorrelated Tx and Rx mode characteristics. Using defected magnitude and phase error of differential circuit on SIC
ground structure (DGS) for such antennas can provide levels has been analytically analyzed. A prototype of
NAWAZ ET AL. 3
F I G U R E 6 ADS Momentum simulated surface currents for compact, differential fed antenna [Color figure can be viewed at
wileyonlinelibrary.com]
The three ports antenna and 3 dB/180 power combiner F I G U R E 8 The simulated and measured S11, S22, and interport
are integrated to realize a compact antenna for full duplex isolation (S21) results for compact, dual port, differential fed IBFD
transceiver as shown in Figure 6. The radiating patch with antenna [Color figure can be viewed at wileyonlinelibrary.com]
co-planar Tx port and 3 dB/180 power combiner are placed
on top and bottom side of double layered FR-4 substrate
dimensions of compact antenna are also shown in Figure 7
respectively. The simulated surface currents and gain pat-
with designated Tx and Rx ports for IBFD operation. The
terns shown in Figure 6 demonstrate the dual polarized char-
compact antenna was implemented on double-layered FR-4
acteristics of proposed compact IBFD antenna.
substrate (εr = 4.4, tanδ = .02) with 1.6 mm thickness of
each layer.
3 | MEASURE M E N T R E SUL T S F O R Figure 8 presents the measured and simulated return loss
COMPACT D I F F E R E N T I A L FE D (S11, S22) and Tx-Rx isolation (S21) results for implemented
IBFD ANTENNA prototype of compact, dual port, differential fed IBFD
antenna. The implemented antenna provides more than
The implemented prototype of compact dual port, dual polar- 45 MHz impedance bandwidth (referred to return loss
ized, differential fed IBFD antenna is shown in Figure 7.The ≥10 dB) and the measured peak interport isolation >95 dB
6 NAWAZ ET AL.
as indicated in Figure 8. Moreover, the implemented proto- presented antenna are low because the FR-4 dielectric has
type of IBFD antenna achieves >85 dB and > 90 dB port to high loss (loss tangent). The radiation efficiencies and conse-
port isolation within 45 MHz and 20 MHz bandwidths quently the gains of both Tx and Rx modes can be improved
respectively. As stated earlier, a dual port, dual polarized significantly if a low loss substrate is used for antenna
antenna with co-planar Tx port and slot coupled Rx port pro- implementation.
vides around 55-60 dB interport isolation, so our proposed The independent in-band and simultaneous Tx and Rx
differential circuit with three ports antenna has achieved capabilities of presented antenna with high isolation can be
30-35 dB additional isolation through SIC with differential endorsed through Envelope Correlation Coefficient (ECC)
feeding at Rx port for implemented IBFD antenna. As clear metric. The ECC metric or performance indicator is used to
from Figure 8, the simulated results for compact, differential ensure the minimum value of interport isolation for multiport
fed IBFD antenna are well endorsed by measurement results. antenna. The ECC for multiport antennas should be as low
The measured 2D gain patterns for implemented proto- as possible and the acceptable antenna’s ECC for reliable
type of compact, dual port, differential fed IBFD antenna are IBFD performance is reported to be <0.5.27 The ECC can be
presented in Figure 9. The implemented antenna provides directly computed from far-field patterns. Moreover, it can
>3.8 dBi gain for each polarization. The implemented be determined through S-parameters results as detailed in
antenna demonstrates excellent polarization purity and mea- Reference 28. The computed values of ECC for presented
sured cross-polarization levels are below -35 dB and -55 dB antenna are <0.01 based on both measured S-parameters and
within half power beam-width (HPBW) of 80 as clearly radiation patterns measurements throughout the 45 MHz
indicated in Figure 9. The radiation efficiencies of presented bandwidth. These results are not presented here for brevity.
antenna are around 55% and 52% for Tx and Rx ports respec- The computed ECC values ensure that implemented dual
tively at center/resonant frequency. These results are not polarized antenna can be effectively employed for IBFD
presented here for brevity. The radiation efficiencies of operation over intended bandwidth of 45 MHz.
The measured interport isolation results for implemented
validation model demonstrate improved interport isolation
performance compared to previously reported antenna
designs detailed in References 14, 18, 20, and 29. These
interport isolation improvements for presented antenna can
be attributed to effective cancellation of SI through well-
balanced differential feeding network. The interport isolation
performance comparison for presented antenna with previ-
ously reported antennas is detailed in Table 1. As clear from
Table 1, the reported antenna in14 provides wider bandwidth
of 18.8% but the port to port isolation for this antenna is lim-
ited to around 28 dB. The reported antennas in References
18, 20, and 29 also employ differential feeding for SIC oper-
ation to achieve improved interport isolation. However, the
EM coupling between SIC circuit and co-located radiating
F I G U R E 9 The measured 2D gain patterns for compact, dual port, patch limits the achievable isolation levels for these anten-
differential fed IBFD antenna [Color figure can be viewed at nas. The novelty of our current work is that the electromag-
wileyonlinelibrary.com] netically isolated monostatic patch and differential feeding
TABLE 1 Performance comparison of presented antenna with previously reported monostatic antennas reported in References 14, 18, 20,
and 29
Antenna designs Maximum isolation 10 dB return loss bandwidth Isolation/bandwidth Dimensions (mm3)
Reference 14 33 dB 18.8% 28 dB/410 MHz 100 × 43 × 9.2
Reference 18-1 67 dB 50 MHz 62 dB/50 MHz 110 × 90 × 1.6
Reference 18-2 90 dB 50 MHz 70 dB/50 MHz 120 × 90 × 3.2
79 dB/20 MHz
Reference 20 98 dB 50 MHz 80 dB/40 MHz 125 × 84 × 1.6
90 dB/20 MHz
Reference 29 78 dB 50 MHz 64 dB/50 MHz 105 × 88 × 1.6
Presented antenna 95 dB 45 MHz 85 dB/45 MHz 100 × 95 × 3.2
90 dB/20 MHz
NAWAZ ET AL. 7
network through the slotted ground plane demonstrate [7] L. Anttila, D. Korpi, V. Syrjälä, et al. Cancellation of power
improved interport isolation performance (~ 10 dB) com- amplifier induced nonlinear self-interference in full-duplex trans-
pared to previously reported differentially excited antennas ceivers. Paper presented at: Asilomar Conference on Signals, Sys-
tems and Computers; 2013; Pacific Grove, CA, pp. 1193–1198.
presented in References 18, 20, and 29. Moreover, the pres-
[8] Hong S, Brand J, Choi J, et al. Applications of self-interference
ented antenna is more compact (reduced dimensions) com-
cancellation in 5G and beyond. IEEE Commun Mag. 2014;52(2):
pared to previous antenna designs as detailed in Table 1.
114-121.
[9] Nawaz H, Tekin I. Compact dual-polarized microstrip patch
antenna with high interport isolation for 2.5 GHz in-band full-
4 | CONCLUSION
duplex wireless applications. IET Microwaves Antennas Propag.
2017;11(7):976-981.
A high isolation, compact (95 mm x 100 mm), dual port,
[10] D.-J. van den Broek, E. Klumperink, and B. Nauta. A self-
dual polarized, monostatic patch antenna has been presented interference cancelling receiver for in-band full-duplex wireless
for 2.4GHz IBFD applications. A simple 3 dB/180 micro- with low distortion under cancellation of strong TX leakage.
strip based power combiner with nice amplitude and phase Paper presented at: IEEE International Solid-State Circuits Con-
balance characteristics has been used as differential feeding ference (ISSCC) Dig. Tech. Papers; February 2015; pp. 1–3.
circuit at Rx port for effective suppression of SI to achieve [11] M. E. Knox. Single antenna full duplex communications using a
very high Tx-Rx isolation at receiver’s front end. The differ- common carrier. Paper presented at: IEEE 13th Annual Wireless
ential circuit provides better than 30 dB additional isolation and Microwave Technology Conference; 2012; pp. 1–6.
on the top of inherent 55-60 dB isolation of IBFD antenna [12] Duarte M, Dick C, Sabharwal A. Experiment-driven characteriza-
with hybrid feeding network. Furthermore, the electromag- tion of full-duplex wireless systems. IEEE Trans Wireless
netic isolation between monostatic patch and differential cir- Commun. 2012;11(12):4296-4307.
cuit provides around 10 dB improvement in isolation [13] Younkyu C, Seong-Sik J, Ahn D, et al. High isolation dual-
polarized patch antenna using integrated defected ground struc-
compared to our previously reported work on high isolation
ture. IEEE Microwave Wireless Comp Lett. 2004;14(1):4-6.
IBFD antenna. The implemented prototype of proposed com-
[14] Deng C, Li Y, Zhang Z, Feng Z. A wideband high-isolated dual-
pact antenna with better than 90 dB isolation within 20 MHz
polarized patch antenna using two different Balun feedings. IEEE
bandwidth can be used to realize a low power IBFD trans- Antennas Wireless Propag Lett. 2014;13:1617-1619.
ceiver without additional and complex analog/RF SIC tech-
[15] Y. Rikuta, H. Arai. A self-Diplexing antenna using slitted patch
niques/stages. However, the external RF-SIC circuit can be antenna. Paper presented at: Proceedings of the International Sym-
used with this antenna for further improvement of interport posium on Antennas and Propagation; 2002; Japan.
isolation for presented antenna when Tx power is increased. [16] M. S. Amjad, H. Nawaz, K. Özsoy, Ö. Gürbüz and I. Tekin, “A
low-complexity full-duplex radio implementation with a single
O R C ID antenna,” IEEE Trans Vehicular Technol, vol. 67, no. 3,
pp. 2206–2218, March 2018.
Haq Nawaz https://orcid.org/0000-0003-4218-3821
[17] Zhang Y, Wang P. Single ring two-port MIMO antenna for LTE
applications. Electron Lett. 2016;52(12):998-1000.
R E F E REN CE S [18] H. Nawaz and I. Tekin, Dual-polarized, differential fed microstrip
[1] A. Sabharwal et al., “In-band full-duplex wireless: challenges and patch antennas with very high Interport isolation for full-duplex
opportunities,” IEEE J Sel Areas Commun, 319, 1637–1652, Sep. communication, IEEE Trans Antennas Propag, vol. 65, no. 12,
2014. pp. 7355–7360, Dec. 2017.
[2] D. Bharadia, E. McMilin, and S. Katti. Full duplex radios. ACM [19] Xie JJ, Yin YZ, Wang JH, Liu XL. Wideband dual-polarized elec-
SIGCOMM; 2013; Hong Kong. tromagnetic fed patch antenna with high isolation and low cross-
[3] Maraševic J, Zhou J, Krishnaswamy H, et al. Resource allocation polarization. Electron Lett. 2013;49(3):171-173.
and rate gains in practical full-duplex systems. IEEE/ACM Trans [20] Nawaz H, Tekin I. Double differential fed, dual polarized patch
Networking. 2017;25(1):292-305. antenna with 90dB Interport RF isolation for 2.4GHz in-band full
[4] Y. Liao, L. Song and Z. Han. Full-Duplex Wireless Communica- duplex transceiver. IEEE Antennas Wireless Propag Lett. 2018;17
tion and Networks: Key Technologeis and Applications. Paper (2):287-290.
presented at: IEEE International Conference on Communications [21] Kolodziej K., McMichael J. and Perry B., “Multitap RF canceller
in China (ICCC); October 2014; Shanghai, China. for in-band full-duplex wireless communications,” IEEE Trans
[5] J. I. Choi, M. Jain, K. Srinivasan, P. Levis, and S. Katti. Achiev- Wireless Commun, 156, 4321–4334, June 2016.
ing single channel full duplex wireless communication. Paper [22] Nawaz H, Tekin I. Dual port single patch antenna with high inter-
presented at: 16th Annual International Conference on Mobile port isolation for 2.4 GHz in-band full duplex wireless applica-
Computing and Networking; 2010; pp. 1–12. tions. Microwave Opt Technol Lett. 2016;58:1756-1759.
[6] Korpi D, Riihonen T, Syrjala V, Anttila L, Valkama M, [23] H. Nawaz and I. Tekin. Dual polarized patch antenna with high
Wichman R. Full-duplex transceiver system calculations: analysis inter-port isolation for 1GHz in-band full duplex applications.
of ADC and linearity challenges. IEEE Trans Wireless Commun. Paper presented at: IEEE International Symposium on Antennas
2014;13(7):3821-3836. and Propagation (APSURSI); 2016; Fajardo, PR, pp. 2153–2154.
8 NAWAZ ET AL.
[24] Khaledian S, Farzami F, Smida B, Erricolo D. Inherent self- [28] Blanch S, Romeu J, Corbella I. Exact representation of antenna
interference cancellation for in-band full-duplex single-antenna system diversity performance from input parameter description.
systems. IEEE Trans Microwave Theory Tech. 2018;66(6):2842- Electron Lett. 2003;39(9):705-707.
2850. [29] Nawaz H, Basit MA. Single layer, dual polarized, 2.4 GHz patch
[25] H. Nawaz and I. Tekin.Three dual polarized 2.4GHz microstrip antenna with very high RF isolation between DC isolated Tx-Rx ports
patch antennas for active antenna and in-band full duplex appli- for full duplex radio. Prog Electromag Res Lett. 2019;85:65-72.
cations. Paper presented at: 16th Mediterranean Microwave
Symposium (MMS); 2016; Abu Dhabi, United Arab Emirates,
pp. 1–4. How to cite this article: Nawaz H, Basit MA,
[26] Liang X-L, Zhong S-S, Wang W. Design of a dual-polarized Shaukat F. Dual polarized, slot coupled monostatic
microstrip patch antenna with excellent polarization purity. Micro- antenna with high isolation for 2.4 GHz full duplex
wave Opt Technol Lett. 2005;44:329-331. applications. Microw Opt Technol Lett. 2019;1–8.
[27] Chung K, Yoon JH. Integrated MIMO antenna with high isolation https://doi.org/10.1002/mop.32138
characteristic. Electron Lett. 2007;43:199-201.