Professional Documents
Culture Documents
At.3216 - Considering Other Specific Audit Areas
At.3216 - Considering Other Specific Audit Areas
At.3216 - Considering Other Specific Audit Areas
Since 1977
AT.3216 SOLIMAN/UY/RICAFRENTE
Considering Other Specific Audit Areas MAY 2022
References:
a. PSA 402 (Revised and Redrafted), Audit Considerations Relating to an Entity Using a Service Organization
b. PSA 510 (Redrafted), Initial Audit Engagements – Opening Balances
c. PSA 540 (Revised and Redrafted) Auditing Accounting Estimates, Including Fair Value Accounting Estimates, and
Related Disclosures
d. PSA 550 Related Parties
e. PSA 600 (Revised and Redrafted), Special Considerations – Audits of Group Financial Statements
f. PSA 610 (Revised 2013), Using the Work of Internal Auditors and Related Conforming Amendments
g. PSA 620 (Revised and Redrafted), Using the Work of an Auditor’s Expert
LECTURE NOTES
PSA 402—Audit Considerations Relating to an Entity To achieve the objectives set out above, the auditor
Using a Service Organization performs the risk-based audit procedures below:
In responding to assessed risks, the user auditor shall: The auditor shall read the most recent financial statements,
a. Determine whether sufficient appropriate audit if any, and the predecessor auditor’s report thereon, if any,
evidence concerning the relevant financial statement for information relevant to opening balances, including
assertions is available from records held at the user disclosures.
entity; and, if not,
b. Perform further audit procedures to obtain sufficient The auditor shall obtain sufficient appropriate audit
appropriate audit evidence or use another auditor to evidence about whether the opening balances contain
perform those procedures at the service organization on misstatements that materially affect the current period’s
the user auditor’s behalf. financial statements by:
PSA 540—Auditing Accounting Estimates, Fair Value • Loans with no scheduled terms
Accounting Estimates and Related Disclosures • Business with major customers, suppliers, etc.
• Services being provided (received) at unreasonable
Management is responsible for making accounting prices
estimates that are reasonable when preparing and • Accounting records for large, unusual transactions
presenting financial statements.
• Confirmations
The objective of the auditor is to obtain sufficient
• Invoices from lawyers
appropriate audit evidence about whether:
In particular, the auditor shall inspect the following for
indications of the existence of related party relationships or
1. accounting estimates, including fair value accounting
transactions that management has not previously identified
estimates, in the financial statements, whether
or disclosed to the auditor:
recognized or disclosed, are reasonable; and
1. Bank and legal confirmations obtained as part of the
2. related disclosures in the financial statements are
auditor’s procedures;
adequate, in the context of the applicable financial
2. Minutes of meetings of shareholders and of those
reporting framework.
charged with governance; and
3. Such other records or documents as the auditor
Obtaining sufficient appropriate evidence is particularly
considers necessary in the circumstances of the entity,
difficult when auditing client accounting estimates (e.g.,
such as SEC filings, conflict of interest
allowance for doubtful accounts, loss reserves, pension
statements, pensions, other trusts, and identify officers
expenses). When evaluating reasonableness, the auditor
thereof, etc.
concentrates on assumptions or factors
• Significant to the estimate PSA 600—Audits of Group Financial Statements—
• Sensitive to variation Including Work of Component Auditors
• Apparent deviations from historical patterns
• Subjective and susceptible to bias or misstatement Group audit is the audit of group financial statements.
The three basic approaches for evaluating the Group financial statements refer to financial statements
reasonableness of these estimates are: that include the financial information of more than one
component.
1. to review and test management’s process of deriving
the estimate (consider the reasonableness and accuracy A component is an entity or business activity for which
of management’s approach); group or component management prepares financial
2. develop one’s own expectation of the accounting information that should be included in the group financial
estimate and compare it to management’s; and statements.
3. review subsequent events or transactions occurring
prior to the completion of fieldwork which bear on the Component auditor is defined as an auditor who, at the
estimate. request of the group engagement team, performs work on
financial information related to a component for the group
PSA 550—Related Parties audit.
Management is responsible identifying and ensuring The following illustration presents the auditor’s objectives in
sufficiency of related party disclosures on the FSs. the audit of group financial statements, including
considering the work component auditors.
The auditor shall obtain evidence about the sufficiency and
appropriateness of related party disclosures. Communicate scope, timing, and
XYZ, CPAs
ABC, CPAs findings of component auditors
(Component
(Group Auditor) on their work on component
Auditor)
financial information,
The auditor shall inquire of management regarding:
1. The identity of the entity’s related parties, including Obtain sufficient appropriate audit evidence
about the financial information of the
changes from the prior period; component by (1) performing audit of
component or (2) using the work of component
2. The nature of the relationships between the entity auditor on the audit of component.
Indications of the existence of related parties may include: To achieve the objectives set out above, the auditor
• Borrowing or lending at no interest or at rates performs risk-based audit procedures below:
significantly different from market rates
• Sales of real estate at prices significantly different from Risk Assessment
appraised values
• Exchanges of similar property in nonmonetary • Agree the terms of engagement to conclude client
transactions acceptance and continuance decision.
• Establish and develop group audit plans. PSA 610—Using the Work of Internal Auditors
• Determine group and component materiality.
• Obtain understanding of the group, its components and The figure below summarizes the external auditor’s
their environments, including component auditors, to consideration of the work of internal auditor.
identify and assess risks of material misstatement.
Risk Response
Not significant The group engagement team should In determining whether the work of the internal auditors is
perform analytical procedures at the likely to be adequate for purposes of the audit, the external
group level. Audit additional auditor shall evaluate:
components if sufficient appropriate
audit evidence has not been obtained. 1. The objectivity (by identifying its line of reporting of
Significant due The group auditor or component results of internal audit that normally is directly to
to its auditor should perform audit of BOD’s audit committee) of the internal audit function;
individual component, adapted as necessary to 2. The technical competence (such as education,
financial the needs of the group engagement experience, professional certification, etc.) of the
significance to team, using the materiality of the internal auditors;
the group component. 3. Whether the work of the internal auditors is likely to be
carried out with due professional care (by reviewing
Significant The group auditor or the component adequate planning, supervision and documentation of
because it is auditor should perform one or more work); and
likely to of: 4. Whether there is likely to be effective
include • Audit component, adapted as communication between the internal auditors and the
significant necessary to the needs of the external auditor.
risks of group engagement team, using
material the materiality of the component.
misstatement • Audit one or more component PSA 620—Using the Work of an Auditor’s Expert
of the group account balances, classes of
financial transactions or disclosures that An expert (or a specialist) refers to a person or firm
statements relate to the significant risks. possessing special skill, knowledge, and experience in a
• Perform specified audit particular field other than accounting and auditing. An
procedures relating to the likely expert may be engaged by the entity or by the auditor,
significant risks of material employed by the entity or by the auditor. Under PSAs, they
misstatement of the group are classified into the following two categories:
financial statements.
1. Auditor’s expert—An individual or organization
possessing expertise in a field other than accounting or
auditing, whose work in that field is used by the auditor
to assist the auditor in obtaining sufficient appropriate
audit evidence. An auditor’s expert may be either an
auditor’s internal expert (who is a partner or staff,
Risk response
DISCUSSION QUESTIONS
The Entity’s Use of a Service Organization b. A report that comprises a description, prepared by
management of the service organization, of the
1. Which of the following statements is true with respect service organization’s system, control objectives
to Type 1 Report as referred to in PSA 402 and related controls, their design and
a. Report on the description and design of controls at implementation as at a specified date or throughout
a service organization. a specified period and, in some cases, their
b. A report that comprises a description, prepared by operating effectiveness throughout a specified
management of the service organization, of the period
service organization’s system, control objectives c. A report that comprises a report by the service
and related controls that have been designed and auditor with the objective of conveying reasonable
implemented as at a specified date. assurance that includes: (a) The service auditor’s
c. A report that comprises a report by the service opinion on the description of the service
auditor with the objective of conveying reasonable organization’s system, control objectives and
assurance that includes the service auditor’s opinion related controls, the suitability of the design of the
on the description of the service organization’s controls to achieve the specified control objectives,
system, control objectives and related controls and and the operating effectiveness of the controls; and
the suitability of the design of the controls to (b) A description of the service auditor’s tests of the
achieve the specified control objectives. controls and the results thereof.
d. All of the above. d. All of the above
2. Which of the following statements is true with respect 3. Which of the following is least likely entitled to the
to Type 2 Report as referred to in PSA 402 report of the service organization auditor on the
a. Report on the description, design, and operating suitability of the design and operating effectiveness of
effectiveness of controls at a service organization the service organization?
a. Service organization’s management
appropriate audit evidence regarding opening balances, 19. In evaluating the assumptions on which the estimate is
except: based, the auditor would need to pay particular
a. Reading the most recent financial statements, if attention to assumptions which are
any, and the predecessor auditor’s report thereon, a. Reasonable in light of actual results in prior periods.
if any, for information relevant to opening balances, b. Consistent with those used for other accounting
including disclosures. estimates.
b. Reviewing the predecessor auditor’s audit c. Consistent with management’s plans which appear
engagement letter. appropriate.
c. Evaluating whether audit procedures performed in d. Subjective or susceptible to bias resulting in
the current period provide evidence relevant to the material misstatement.
opening balances.
Fair Value
d. Performing specific audit procedures to obtain
evidence regarding the opening balances.
20. The degree to which a fair value measurement is
susceptible to misstatement is a(an)
13. Which of the following accounts is most difficult for the
a. Audit risk c. Control risk
auditor to be satisfied as to the balance at the beginning
b. Inherent risk d. Detection risk
of the period?
a. Accounts receivable c. Inventory 21. Regarding fair value measurements and disclosures, the
b. Accounts payable d. Accrued interest payable auditor is not required to
a. Obtain evidence about management's intent to
14. If the opening balances contain misstatements which carry out specific courses of action, and consider its
could materially affect the current period's financial ability to do so, where relevant to the fair value.
statements and the effect of the misstatement is not b. Evaluate whether the entity's method for its fair
properly accounted for and adequately disclosed, the value measurements is applied consistently.
auditor should express a c. Use the work of an expert.
a. Unqualified opinion with explanatory paragraph. d. Test the entity's fair value measurements and
b. Qualified or adverse opinion. disclosures.
c. Qualified or disclaimer of opinion.
d. Adverse or disclaimer of opinion. 22. When testing the entity's fair value measurements and
disclosures, the auditor evaluates whether:
Auditing Accounting Estimates, Fair Value Accounting a. The assumptions used by management are
Estimates and Related Disclosures reasonable.
b. The fair value measurement was determined using
15. It means an approximation of the amount of an item in an appropriate model, if applicable.
the absence of a precise means of measurement c. Management used relevant information that was
a. Accounting estimate c. Accounting error reasonably available at the time.
b. Accounting policy d. Accounting change d. All of the above.
25. Which of the following least likely indicates the c. Obtain written permission from the other CPA to
existence of previously unidentified related parties? omit the reference in the principal auditor’s report.
a. Transactions which have abnormal terms of trade, d. Perform additional audit procedures based on the
such as unusual prices, interest rates, guarantees, significance of the subsidiary.
and repayment terms.
b. Transactions which lack an apparent logical 30. In the auditor’s report, the group engagement partner
business reason for their occurrence. decides not to make reference to a component auditor
c. Transactions in which substance does not differ who audited a client’s subsidiary. The group
from form. engagement partner could justify this decision if, among
d. Unrecorded transactions such as the receipt or other requirements, he or she
provision of management services at no charge. a. Issues an unmodified opinion on the consolidated
financial statements.
Audits of Group Financial Statements—Including b. Learns that the component auditor issued an
Work of Component Auditors unmodified opinion on the subsidiary’s financial
statements.
26. When using the work of another auditor (component c. Is unable to review the audit plan (programs) and
auditor), the principal auditor should ordinarily perform working papers of the component auditor.
the following procedure d. Is satisfied as to the independence and professional
a. Obtain information regarding the professional reputation of the other CPA.
competence of the other auditor in the context of
the specific assignment undertaken by the other Division of Responsibility
auditor.
b. Advise the other auditor of the applicable 31. Reference in a principal auditor’s report to the fact that
independence requirements as regards both the part of the audit was performed by another auditor most
entity and the component and obtain representation likely would be an indication of the
as to his compliance with them. a. Divided responsibility between the auditors who
c. Advise the other auditor of the applicable conducted the audits of the components of the
accounting, auditing and reporting requirements overall financial statements.
and obtain representation of compliance. b. Lack of materiality of the portion of the financial
d. All of the above statements audited by the other auditor.
c. Principal auditor’s recognition of the other auditor’s
27. The financial statements of a company (investee) in competence, reputation and professional
which another company (investor) has a financial certification.
interest are most likely to be included in a set of d. Different opinions the auditors are expressing on
consolidated financial statements of the investor the components of the financial statements that
company in which of the following situations? each audited.
a. The investee is a joint venture by the investor
32. The principal auditor is satisfied with the independence
company and another company in which each
and professional reputation of the other auditor who has
investor owns a 50% equity interest.
audited a subsidiary but wants to indicate the division
b. The investor owns 30% of the non-voting shares of
of responsibility. The principal auditor should
the investee.
a. Modify only the scope paragraph of the report.
c. The investor holds 20% of the shares of the
b. Modify only the opinion paragraph of the report.
investee as a temporary investment.
c. Modify both the scope and opinion paragraphs of
d. The investor holds 60% of the outstanding debt of
the report.
the investee.
d. Modify the introductory, scope and opinion
paragraphs of the report
28. A client follows full PFRSs for its domestic operations
and foreign GAAP for a foreign subsidiary. The foreign 33. The introductory paragraph of an auditor’s report
subsidiary is audited by a component auditor, while the contains the following sentences:
group auditor audits the remainder of the corporation
We did not audit the financial statements of EZ Inc., a
and issues an audit report on consolidated operations.
wholly-owned subsidiary, which statements reflect total
Which auditor(s) is (are) responsible for evaluating the
assets and revenues constituting 27 percent and 29
appropriateness of the adjustment of the foreign GAAP
percent, respectively, of the related consolidated totals.
statements to full PFRSs?
Those statements were audited by other auditors whose
Group auditor Component auditor report has been furnished to us, and our opinion, insofar
a. Yes Yes as it relates to the amounts included for EZ Inc., is
b. Yes No based solely on the report of the other auditors.
c. No Yes
These sentences
d. No No
a. Indicate division of responsibility.
b. Assume responsibility for the other auditor.
29. A group engagement partner decides not to refer to the
c. Require a departure from an unqualified opinion.
audit of another CPA who audited a component of the
d. Are an improper form of reporting.
overall group financial statements. After making
inquiries about the other CPA’s professional reputation
and independence, the principal auditor most likely Using the Work of Internal Auditors
would
a. Add an emphasis-of-matter paragraph. 34. The independent auditors might consider the
b. Document in the engagement letter that the procedures performed by the internal auditors because:
principal auditor assumes no responsibility for the a. They are employees whose work must be reviewed
other CPA’s work and opinion. during substantive testing.
b. They are employees whose work might affect the 41. Hanlon Corp. maintains a large internal audit staff that
independent auditors' work. reports directly to the chief financial officer. Audit
c. Their work impacts upon the cost/benefit tradeoff in reports prepared by the internal auditors indicate that
evaluating inherent limitations. the system is functioning as it should and that the
d. Their degree of independence may be inferred by accounting records are reliable. An independent auditor
the nature of their work. will probably:
35. The work of internal auditors may affect the a. eliminate tests of controls.
independent’s auditor’s b. increase the depth of the study and evaluation of
I. Procedures performed in obtaining an administrative controls.
understanding of internal control c. avoid duplicating the work performed by the
II. Procedures performed in assessing the risk of internal audit staff.
material misstatement d. place limited reliance on the work performed by the
III. Substantive procedures performed in gathering internal audit staff.
direct evidence
a. I and III only c. II and III only 42. For which of the following judgments may an
b. I and II only d. I, II and III independent auditor share responsibility with an entity’s
internal auditor who is assessed to be both competent
36. Which of the following is most correct regarding external and objective?
auditors use of internal auditors directly on the audit a. b. c. d.
engagement? Materiality of
a. Discourage c. Encourage misstatements Yes No No Yes
b. Prohibit d. Permit Evaluation of
accounting estimates No Yes No Yes
37. In making judgments about the effect of the internal
auditors’ work on the external auditor’s procedures in Using the Work of an Auditor’s Expert
specific audit areas, which of the following is not among
three issues related to the audit areas that should be 43. Which statement is incorrect regarding the auditor’s use
considered by the external auditor? of the work of an expert?
a. Materiality of the financial statement amounts. a. “Expert” means a person or firm possessing special
b. Risk of material misstatement of the assertions skill, knowledge and experience in a particular field
related to these financial statement amounts. other than accounting and auditing.
c. Degree of subjectivity involved in the evaluation of b. When using the work performed by an expert, the
the audit evidence gathered in support of the auditor should obtain sufficient appropriate audit
assertions. evidence that such work is adequate for the
d. Review of quality of audit policies, programs, and purposes of the audit.
procedures. c. The auditor's education and experience enable the
auditor to be knowledgeable about business matters
38. Under what circumstance is it appropriate for the in general, but the auditor is not expected to have
auditor to rely on the work of an internal auditor? the expertise of a person trained for or qualified to
a. It is never acceptable for the external auditor to rely engage in the practice of another profession or
upon the work of the internal auditor. occupation.
b. The external auditor may rely on certain of the work d. In all cases, the auditor cannot obtain sufficient
of the internal auditor after making a appropriate audit evidence in areas that are other
comprehensive assessment of the auditor and than accounting and auditing.
his/her work.
c. The external auditor may rely on the work of the 44. Each of the following procedures requires the assistance
internal auditor if he/she is also a CPA. of an expert, except
d. There is no restriction in relying upon the work of a. Determining the physical condition or quantity of
internal auditors. underground mineral.
b. Determining the value of works of art.
39. External auditors would consider internal auditors c. Determining the adequacy of disclosure in the notes
effective if they are: to the financial statements.
a. Independent of the operating units being evaluated. d. Interpreting major contracts.
b. Competent and well trained.
c. Have performed relevant audit tests of the internal 45. In accordance with PSA 620, Using the Work of an
controls and financial statements. Auditor’s Expert, each of the following is the work of an
d. All of the above. expert, except
a. Applying methods of accounting for deferred income
40. To assess the objectivity of the internal auditors, an tax.
independent auditor would most likely b. Applying legal expertise in taxation law
a. Consider the professional qualifications and c. Performing complex modeling for the purpose of
experience of the internal auditors. valuing financial instruments.
b. Consider the proper planning, supervision and d. Valuing of environmental liabilities, and site clean-
documentation of internal auditor’s work. up costs.
c. Consider the nature and extent of the internal
auditors’ assignment. 46. When determining the need to use the work of an
d. Consider the organizational level to which the expert, the auditor would consider the following, except
internal auditors report the results of their work. a. The quantity and quality of other audit evidence
available.
b. The materiality of the F/S item being considered.
48. The auditor shall apply the guidance of PSA 500, Audit
Evidence, instead of PSA 620, Using the Working of an
Auditor’s Expert, when using the work of
a. Management’s expert. c. Either a or b.
b. Auditor’s expert. d. Both a and b.
End of AT.3216