Tunnelling in The Himalayan Region: Geological Problems and Solutions

You might also like

Download as pdf or txt
Download as pdf or txt
You are on page 1of 6

See discussions, stats, and author profiles for this publication at: https://www.researchgate.

net/publication/269407897

Tunnelling in the Himalayan Region: geological problems and solutions

Article  in  International Water Power and Dam Construction · September 2012

CITATIONS READS

4 4,281

1 author:

A. N. Tiwari
Engie
4 PUBLICATIONS   58 CITATIONS   

SEE PROFILE

All content following this page was uploaded by A. N. Tiwari on 12 December 2014.

The user has requested enhancement of the downloaded file.


Construction
Raveling of
small wedges in
closely jointed
rock mass.

Tunnelling in the
Himalayan Region:
geological problems
and solutions
Tunnels are an essential and important component of run-of-river hydroelectric schemes and
constitute a substantial percentage of the overall cost of the project. Geological problems
encountered in tunneling projects in the Himalayan Region are presented by Dr. H. R. Sharma and
Dr. A. N. Tiwari.

I
n a run-of-river hydroelectric scheme most and at many places are heavily charged with Eastern states, particularly in Arunachal Pradesh,
of the project components are underground, underground water. Meghalaya and Sikkim. From a geological
be it the diversion tunnel, desilting The most commonly encountered geological perspective the Himalayan region is a tectonically
chambers, silt flushing tunnel, headrace tunnel, problems during tunnelling for hydroelectric active zone created by the collision of Indian and
powerhouse cavern, surge tank, pressure shafts, projects in the Himalayan Region are Sino-Tibetan plates during Eocene-Oligocene
tailrace tunnel, various access tunnels etc. The Fault/Thrust/Shear zones, running ground period. During the collision the convergence of
construction of these underground structures can conditions, squeezing, heaving and swelling, rock Indian and Sino-Tibetan plates resulted in the
be a challenge for engineers, especially when the bursting, ground water inflow, wedge/block crustal shortening that was largely
locations of these structures encounter weak, failures, hot temperature conditions, and gases in accommodated by south directed deformation
fragile and sheared rocks. Particularly in the case rock etc. The major geological problems resulting in tectonic transport and thrusting all
of tunnels, if the alignment passes through such a experienced and their possible remedial along the arcuate length of the Himalayan range
terrain of active tectonic zone with mixed measures are discussed in the following sections. (DeCelles et al, 2001; Joshi & Tiwari, 2009).
lithology and trapped water, the tunnelling There is hardly any tunnel in the Himalayan
becomes hazardous and very costly due to Fault/thrust/shear zones region where shear zones of varying thickness
problems of running/flowing ground, squeezing, The majority of the hydroelectric projects are have not been encountered. A shear zone is a
swelling, sudden ingress of water, hot located in deep dissected valleys favourable for zone with sub-parallel walls in which high
temperature condition and gases in rocks. In large storage and relatively high water heads for deformations are localized as a result of folding,
tectonically active young mountains like the power generation. The bulk of hydropower faulting and thrusting. The severity of problems in
Himalayas, the rocks found during tunnelling are potential in India (about 75%) is located in the tunnelling, due to encountering shear, depends on
relatively incompetent and affected by a number Himalayan hill states of Himachal Pradesh, the thickness, extent, nature and orientation of
of folds, faults and thrusts of various magnitudes Uttarakhand, Jammu & Kashmir and the North- shear in relation to tunnel alignment. The

14 INTERNATIONAL WATER POWER & DAM CONSTRUCTION September 2012


Construction

holes of 75-100mm diameter with perforated pipes To tackle the geological problems as
at crown level ahead of a tunnel face were used to encountered in the form of shear zone the
ascertain the presence of groundwater. following remedial measures are suggested.
In the Himalayan region a number of ■ Advance Probe hole(s).
hydroelectric projects have been delayed due to ■ Core drilling at face, if necessary, to ascertain
encountering thrust/shear zone during precise location of shear zone.
underground excavations. At Tapovan-Vishnugad ■ Drainage holes around tunnel periphery.
hydropower project the work was delayed for ■ Umbrella Forepoling (Figure 2).
about 17 months due to engineers encountering a ■ Pre-Grouting/Grouting.
thrust/shear zone which resulted into the ■ Reduction in pull length.
formation of a cavity at the crown during ■ Reduction in tunnel span by Multiple Drifting
tunnelling. The critical situation was tackled by method (Figure 3).
adopting the following treatments: ■ Face advancement with concurrent rib support
■ Advance cement grouting for face and crown and backfill concrete as required.
stabilization.
■ Umbrella pipe roofing with perforated seamless Running ground conditions
pipes of 114mm ϕ, 15m long @ 0.3m spacing The running ground condition can be defined as
from SPL to SPL to ensure the crown stability. water soaked fragmented rocks often containing
■ Installations of drainage holes of 76mm ϕ, 5.0m larger rock fragments embedded in a matrix of
long at appropriate locations for ground water finer grained material that has almost no strength
seepage control. and flows into tunnel as slurry (Figure 1). In the
■ Excavation by Multiple Drifting Method past such ground was described as “swimming”
Figure 1 (a&b): Muck flow from shear zones
■ Pull length restricted to 1.00m which aptly describes the importance of the
encountered during tunnelling in Dul-Hasti
hydroelectric project. ■ Provision of steel ribs (ISMB 250) at 0.6m water and the strength deficiency of the material.
spacing The initial pressures generated by running
occurrence of shear zone results into rock fall, ground may be high to cause failure of even very
muck flow and formation of cavities. This affects heavy supports. The running ground is quite a
the progress of tunnelling very adversely. The common feature associated with faults, thick
shear zones if combined with water ingress, shear zone, thrusts and buried fossil valleys in the
which is mostly the case, hampers the progress of Himalayan region as encountered in several
tunnelling considerably and in some cases projects e.g. Dul-Hasti hydroelectric project,
applies a complete break. Figure 1 shows the Nathpa-Jhakri hydroelectric project and Tapovan-
flowing matrix conditions encountered at Dul- Vishnugad hydroelectric project.
Hasti hydroelectric project after puncture of the To overcome the running ground condition
shear zone rendering the tunnelling extremely under water pressure the ground is required to be
difficult. The encountered shear zones were drained and strengthened ahead of the working
steeply dipping, striking oblique to the tunnel axis face. In Nathpa-Jhakri running ground conditions
at 300 to 400 and covering a length of 15 to 20m were encountered with heavy ground water flow
along the tunnel alignment. At most of the places
shear zones were associated with confined
aquifers under high hydrostatic head.
Figure 2: Installation of Umbrella Forepoling.
The adverse effects of shear zone in tunnelling
can be minimized if orientation of the strike of the
shear zone runs across the tunnel alignment. The In another example, the 5.6km long and 7m
shear zones along the tunnel are generally diameter Khodri headrace tunnel of Chibro-Khodri
projected from surface geological mapping as hydroelectric system passes through sedimentary
drilling up to the tunnel grade is difficult, costly rocks of Nahan, Subathu and Mandhali formations
and time consuming because of high cover. If the separated by Nahan and Krol Thrusts. The tunnel
rock, particularly in metamorphic terrain, is was to pass through the bands of sandstone and
severely folded and faulted by tectonic events the siltstone on the downstream side and quartzite and
geology can significantly differ from that slate on the upstream side. In between these two
interpreted from surface geological mapping. In formations, an intra thrust zone of about 1000m
such terrain, advance probe hole technique during width bounded by Krol and Nahan thrusts, Figure 3: Excavation by Multi Drift Method.
tunnelling has proved very successful to ascertain comprising shear red shale “Sabathu” clays was
the nature of expected geological conditions. At met along the tunnel alignment. During actual associated with about 40m thick very soft and
Dul-Hasti, the advance probe holes of about 45m excavation of the tunnel the red shales were sheared rock zone. In another example a major
length were found to be very effective during encountered again and again in the intra thrust portion of the 6.8m diameter headrace tunnel of
tunnelling in a shear zone associated with zone, causing problems in excavation of the tunnel Tala hydroelectric project, Bhutan flowing
confined aquifers. In the tunnel of Maneri due to rock mass failure. This delayed the condition was encountered causing considerable
hydroelectric project stage-II, the roof and face completion of the tunnel nearly six years. delay in tunnelling. In running ground condition
collapses were associated with water-inrush when Ultimately it was decided to triplicate the 7m the DRESS (Drainage, Reinforcement, Excavation
a fractured and jointed rock mass in contact with diameter tunnel into three tunnels of small and Support Solution) technique has been widely
an impervious rock mass was encountered. Probe diameter (~5m) in the intra thrust zone (Goel, 2000). used and has now become a very successful

September 2012 WWW.WATERPOWERMAGAZINE.COM 15


Construction

The failure of rock mass due to over stressing and shotcrete, bending and buckling of ribs and
movement of the failed rock mass into tunnel reduction of tunnel section, tunnel closures being
opening is called squeezing. The squeezing of the order of 300mm to 500mm. This problem
behaviour is associated with poor rock mass was tackled by over excavating the tunnel and
deformability and strength properties. supporting it with steel ribs of appropriate size.
A high order of closures and support pressures is To tackle the problem of squeezing rock mass in
observed in squeezing ground often resulting in tunnelling through high stress zones the following
buckling of the steel rib supports as shown in measures have being successfully adopted:
Figure 5. In a number of cases the tunnel sections
had to be re-excavated to get the required opening. ■ Yielding Supports: One of the solutions to the
Swelling pressure on tunnel support is also problem of squeezing rock mass is to adopt
mobilised due to volumetric expansion of the rock yielding supports. The number of yielding joints
mass around the tunnel opening. The volumetric can be modified to suit the site conditions. It
Figure 4: Rock reinforcement with expansion is caused due to an increase of volume has been found essential to shotcrete the gaps
grouted pipe. by absorption and adsorption of water. once the closure nears the limit allowed without
The degree of squeezing can be represented the steel sections actually butting together. In
method. The process involves: by tunnel convergence as follows (Singh and the case of swelling rock containing clay and/or
■ Drainage of rock mass in advance ahead Goel, 1999; Barla, 2001): anhydrite the problem stems from the capacity
of the face. ■ Mild squeezing – convergence 1-3% tunnel of these rock types to increase their volume by
■ Rock mass reinforcement with grouted diameter absorbing water and thus leading to heaving of
perforated pipe forepoles (Figure 5) and face ■ Moderate squeezing – convergence 3-5% the base of the tunnel. The solution to the
shotcreting. tunnel diameter problem is provided by designing a lining
■ Excavation of rock mass in parts ■ High squeezing – convergence >5% tunnel system that allows a given amount of base
(By Multi Drift Method). diameter heave without violating operational
■ Support installation (mainly steel ribs). requirements. Inserting highly compressible
materials of a specified high resistance between
This method has been successfully employed rock and invert provides a satisfactory solution.
in Nathpa-Jhakri and Tala hydroelectric projects. The steel support is provided with sliding joints
During the excavation of the 4.0m diameter and yielding beam elements are inserted in the
headrace tunnel of Allain Duhangan, severe shotcrete lining as shown in Figure 6 (Kovári,
geological problems were encountered in the 2009). In this way the lining is capable of
form of flowing ground conditions due to sheared providing considerable rock support (so called
rock mass occurring almost parallel to the long lining resistance) and at the same time also
stretch of the tunnel and heavy ingress of water permitting convergence leading to a reduction
up to 200lps to 300lps from the face (Madan, Figure 5: Severe squeezing in tunnel. of rock pressure for the final lining.
2011). The following measures were adopted for
stabilizing the flowing ground condition:
■ Pressure relief hole/Drainage holes of 89mm ϕ Squeezing in as high as 17% of the Tunnel
of 15m length installed in crown periphery. section was reported in Chibro-Khodri, Maneri-
■ The face was plugged with sand bags covered Bhali, Uri-I and Nathpa Jhakri Projects.
with thick layer of dry shotcrete. As discussed earlier, the 5.6km long Chibro-
■ Pipe roofing was carried out using 89mm ϕ Khodri Tunnel of Yamuna Stage-II faced severe
seamless perforated pipes of 10 - 12 m length problems in excavation and tunnel support due to
by creating an umbrella of pipes. squeezing. In the end the 7m-diameter tunnel
■ Probe hole investigation before next excavation. was divided into three 5m-diameter tunnels.
■ Pre-grouting with long holes with packer The Maneri Bhali Stage-II project has
assembly was carried out through the same experienced squeezing problem within a 40m
probe holes. reach of 6m diameter tunnel. The highly crushed,
■ Excavation was carried out by multi drift method. pulverised and thick contact of metabasics and
■ Ribs were provided with vertical support at a quartzite was encountered at this span. This zone
spacing of 0.5m to zero spacing. acting as a water reservoir created high hydrostatic Figure 6: Steel cylinders inserted into slots
pressure. The metabasics were highly strained due of the Shotcrete lining.
Squeezing, heaving and swelling to accumulated tectonic forces. To overcome the
The state of stress within the rock mass at depth is problem, the cross section was changed from
disturbed on driving the tunnel. The stresses are re- horseshoe to circular shape. Instruments have been ■ Pressure Relief Holes: The pore pressure
distributed with time to a new state of equilibrium. installed in the troubled zone by Central Mining distribution and the piezometric head
As long as the stresses are low and are well within Research Station (CMRS) to monitor the squeezing influence the rock mass stress-strain
the in - situ strength of the rock mass there are no rock condition (Saini et al. 1989). behaviour. Drainage measures causing a
tunnel stability problems. However, the stresses In the headrace tunnel of Nathpa-Jhakri, highly reduction in piezometric head help inhibiting
exceeding the in-situ strength of the rock mass converging ground conditions were observed due development of ground deformations.
initiate the process of progressive failure around to high ground stresses where quartz mica schist
the periphery of the tunnel opening. The failure of a striking sub parallel to tunnel were encountered For successful tunnelling in squeezing ground
rock mass is associated with volumetric expansion. which were reflected in the form of cracks in it is desirable to develop reliable, easy-to-use

16 INTERNATIONAL WATER POWER & DAM CONSTRUCTION September 2012


Construction

approaches for predicting ground conditions and Structurally controlled instabilities: effective if applied properly. This is because the
identify the need for flexible support systems. An wedge/block failures base of a typical wedge has a large perimeter and
empirical approach can be used for predicting In tunnels excavated in jointed rock masses at hence, even for a relatively thin layer of shotcrete,
ground conditions (Goel et al., 1995b). This relatively shallow depth, the most common types a significant cross sectional area of the material
approach suggests that squeezing ground will be of failure are those involving wedges falling from has to be punched through before the wedge can
encountered when the roof or sliding out of the sidewalls of the fail. For example, the application of a 10cm thick
openings as shown in Figure 8 and on p14. These shotcrete with shear strength of 200t/m2 to the
H.a 0.1 > 260 N0.33 (1) wedges are formed by intersecting structural roof of the tunnel will increase the factor of safety
features, such as bedding planes and joints, from 1.40 (for the rock bolted case) to 8.5.
Where H = tunnel depth (Rock cover) in which separate the rock mass into discrete but
metres, a = tunnel radius in metres, N = rock interlocked pieces. One or more of these wedges Ground water inflow
mass number i.e., Q (Barton et al 1974), Q = can fall or slide from the surface if the bounding Ground water inflow has been a major cause of
Tunnelling Quality Index = planes are continuous or rock bridges along the concern in tunnelling. Sudden ingress of trapped
(RQD/Jn)(Jr/Ja)Jw/SRF, RQD = rock quality discontinuities are broken. ground water may cause a collapse in the tunnel
designation, Jn = joint set number, Jr = joint A characteristic feature of wedge failures in resulting in a drastic reduction of the tunnelling
roughness number, Ja = joint alteration number, blocky rock is that a very little movement occurs progress or even stopping it completely. Roof or
Jw = joint water reduction factor, SRF = stress in the rock mass before failure of the wedge. This face collapses are associated with water ingress
reduction factor (assumed 1) dictates that movement along the surfaces must when a fractured and jointed rock mass is in
It is also necessary to ascertain the expected be minimized. Consequently, the support system contact with an impervious rock mass.
support pressure and the tunnel closure for has to provide a ‘stiff’ response to movement. The best method to discover the presence of
effective handling of squeezing ground. Grimstad This means that mechanically anchored rock ground water is advance probe drilling in the
and Barton (1993) suggest that the relationship bolts need to be tensioned while fully grouted suspected ground water zone. Sometimes it
between the value of Q and the permanent roof rock bolts or other continuously coupled devices becomes essential to carry out grouting before
support pressure Proof is estimated from: can be left untensioned provided that they are further advancement. Advance probing is the
best way to be prepared for ground water inflow
Proof = 2√Jn Q1/3/3Jr condition. About 50m deep advance probe holes
of about 75mm diameter could provide valuable
where, Proof = Roof Support Pressure, advance information on the nature of the
Q = Tunnelling Quality Index, Jn = joint set number, expected problem. Probing ahead of the tunnel
Jr = joint roughness number. face using geophysical means like tomographic
Once the optimum desirable closure is known, analysis and radar is becoming popular but is
flexible supports can be designed to absorb it and comparatively expensive (Goel et al., 1995a).
the excavation size can be increased accordingly Sometimes pressure grouting and chemical
so that re-excavation is not required to grouting methods are adopted to control ground
accommodate the closure. water seepage.
In the headrace tunnel of Allain Duhangan
Figure 7: Rock burst on tunnel wall
Rock bursting, spalling and slabbing heavy water ingress to the extent of 6000 liter per
formed cavity.
Failures known as spalling, popping or rock bursts minute has been encountered during excavation
are caused by overstressing of brittle, massive installed before any movement has taken place between weak rock strata/shear zone.fluvioglacial
rocks often at depths in excess of 1000m below i.e. before the wedge perimeter has been fully deposits and old glacial deposits. The ground
surface. These failures can also be induced at exposed. Mechanically anchored bolts with face water flow was tackled by following treatment:
shallower depth where high horizontal stresses or plates or fully grouted bolts or cables can be ■ Heading was packed with sand bags and
strongly anisotropic stresses are acting. selected to provide support. In addition, a layer of shotcrete was sprayed to prevent leakage of
Rock bursting/spalling (Figure 7) cases were shotcrete can be applied to the excavation grout from the face and to facilitate
reported in Kadamparai and Parbati-II projects surface that plays a vital role in supporting the channelizing of water.
(Infraline Energy Business Report Series, 2009) wedges. ■ Pressure relief holes/drainage holes of 89mm
and in some tunnel portions of Nathpa Jhakri. Shotcrete can be used for additional support of dia and 15m long were provided for
The headrace tunnel of Parbati-II passes wedges in blocky ground, and can be very channelising water flow.
through the lithological sequences of biotite
schist, carbonaceous phyllite, Manikaran
quartzite and schistose granite gneiss. Manikaran
quartzite is brittle and massive in character and
in this stretch severe rock bursts occurred
continuously during tunnelling after almost every
alternate blasting round.
Rock bursts may be prevented, limited or
controlled by De-stress Blasting (Sedlák, 1997). The
application of Thin Spray-on Lining (TSL’s)
materials onto rock, in standalone fashion or in
combination with conventional area support media,
has been found to significantly reduce apparent
surface damage effects caused by rock burst
relative to cases where the rock is left unsupported. Figure 8: Wedge formed in the Roof and Sidewall of tunnel in a jointed rock mass.

18 INTERNATIONAL WATER POWER & DAM CONSTRUCTION September 2012


Construction

■ Grouting with long holes with packer assembly region. Methane gas was encountered during the ■ The rock bursts in overstressed, brittle and
was carried out with OPC and then with Micro excavation of the tailrace tunnel of Uri-I massive rocks may be prevented/ limited or
fine cement/Ultra fine cement/colloidal silica hydroelectric project as well but at a level much controlled by De-stress Blasting.
and adding silica fumes and other chemicals. lower than the hazard limit. ■ The wedge failure can be prevented/
■ At some locations where heading is covered minimized by means of rock bolts as required.
with clayey mass and cement grout was not Conclusions For additional support in blocky ground the use
successful, chemical grouting was done by Geological problems during tunnelling in of shotcrete is very effective, if applied properly.
using Polyurethane to consolidate the tunnel tectonically active terrain of the Himalayan region ■ The ground water problems can be effectively
heading. characterized by widely varying geology with tackled by advance probe drilling in the
folds, faults, thrusts and shear zones etc. cannot be suspected ground water zone; controlling
Hot temperature conditions ruled out. The problems can however be ground water seepage by pressure grouting and
A very serious problem of excessive temperature minimized and mitigated by proper geological chemical grouting; installation of pressure relief
(390 - 400C) was reported in the power tunnel of investigations and adopting certain advance holes/drainage holes at appropriate locations
3.2m excavated diameter at Bhabha hydroelectric measures during excavation, such as probe holes, and providing proper drainage arrangement.
project, Central Himalaya. The project lies within forepoling, pre-grouting, drainage hole installations ■ Excessive temperature and gas problems in
the zone of Lesser and Greater Himalaya. Most of and multidrift methods of excavation etc. tunnelling can be best tackled by supplying
■ In the case of shear zone and running ground fresh air through efficient ventilation; reducing
conditions additional remedial measures such the pull per blast, and introducing the rotation of
as core drilling at face to ascertain precise workmen in order to take care of exhaustion. ■
location of shear zone; reduction in pull length;
face advancement with concurrent rib support About the authors
with backfill concrete, and installation of Dr. H. R. Sharma, Chief Technical Principal
grouted Self Drilling Anchors have proved very - Hydro, hari.sharma@gdfsuez.com and
successful. Dr. A. N. Tiwari, Manager (Geology) –
Hydro, amarnath.tiwari@gdfsuez.com,
■ Squeezing problems can be successfully
Tractebel Engineering pvt. ltd.,
tackled by adopting yielding supports, pressure
10A Shivaji Marg, 110015 New Delhi, India.
relief holes and installation of instruments to www.tractebel-engineering-gdfsuez.com
Figure 9: Ingress of hot water in HRT of monitor the squeezing rock conditions.
Nathpa - Jhakri hydroelectric project.

References
the hot springs are also located along this zone. 1. Saini, G. S., Dubey, A. K. and Singh, B., (1989). “Severe Tunnelling problem in Young
Underground temperatures of water, rock and Himalayan rocks for deep underground opening” ISRM International Symposium, pp. 1 – 11.
humid tunnel atmosphere that exceed a320C
2. Grimstad, E. and Barton, N. (1993). “Updating the Q - System for NMT”. Proc. int. symp.
create very difficult working conditions. An
on sprayed concrete - modern use of wet mix sprayed concrete for underground support,
extensive system of refrigeration or rapid
Fagernes. Oslo: Norwegian Concrete Assn., pp. 46 - 66.
circulation of air in the tunnel is required to work
in tunnels with temperatures beyond 320C. 3. Goel, R. K., Jethwa, J. L. and Paithankar, A. G. (1995b). "An Empirical Approach for
The same kind of thermal problem was also
Predicting Ground Condition for Tunnelling and Its Practical Benefits", Proc. 35th US Rock
Mech. Symposium, USA, June, pp. 431 - 436.
encountered in the tunnel of Nathpa Jhakri
project (Figure 9) in Central Himalaya where 4. Sedlák, V., (1997). “Energy evaluation of de – stress blasting”, Acta Montanistica Slovaca
ingress of hot water with temperature as high as Ročník 2, pp. 11 - 15.
660C was encountered. 5. Singh, B. and Goel, R. K. (1999). “Rock mass classification: a practical approach in Civil
The problem was best tackled by supplying Engineering”, Elsevier Science Ltd. U.K. pp. 267.
fresh air through efficient ventilation, reducing
6. Goel, R.K., (2000). “Challenges of Tunnelling in Fragile Rocks of Himalaya”, Proc. GeoEng,
the pull per blast to 1-1.2m per day and by
Nov., Melbourne, Australia, pp. 19 - 24.
introducing the alternative rotation of workmen
for short periods. 7. Barla, G., (2001). “Tunnelling under squeezing rock conditions”. Euro Summer school on
Tunnel Mechanics. Innsbruck, pp. 1-98 available at website:
http://www2.polito.it/ricarca/rocmech/pubblicazioni/Art_convegni/Innsbruck2001.PDF.
Gases in rock
A variety of natural gases, namely carbon dioxide, 8. DeCelles, P. G., Robinson, D. M., Quade, J., Ojha, T. P., Garzione, C. N., Copeland, P.,
methane, sulphur dioxide and hydrogen sulphide Upreti, B. N., (2001). “Stratigraphy, structure and tectonic evolution of the Himalayan fold-
etc. has been encountered in the tunnels. During thrust belt in western Nepal”. Tectonics 20 (4), pp. 487 - 509.
the excavation of Giri Bata tunnel, gas was 9. Infraline Energy Business Report Series (2009). – Proposed and under Construction Hydro
encountered and many workers had severe burn Power Projects in India, pp. 1 - 4.
injuries due to fire. Another example is the Loktak
10. Joshi, M. and Tiwari, A. N., (2009). “Structural events and metamorphic consequences in
project in the Manipur State of India in North- Almora Nappe, during Himalayan collision tectonics. J. Asian Earth Sci. 34, pp. 326 - 335.
Eastern region of Himalaya (Goel, 2000). Methane
(marsh gas) was encountered in abundance in 11. Kovári, K., (2009). “Design methods with Yielding support in squeezing and swelling
rocks“, World Tunnel Congress, Budapest, Hungary, May, pp. 01 - 10.
the tunnel located in the sedimentary rock
formations. Some 15 people were killed and many 12. Madan, M. M., (2011). “Tunnelling in weak zone – A case study of Tunnel Construction at
had burn injuries of high degree due to explosion Allain Duhangan Hydro Electric project” Workshop on Construction of Dams and Tunnels in
and fire near the heading. A similar case was Weak Rocks, Solan, Himachal Pradesh, india, May, pp. 18 – 36.
experienced in the Ranganadi project in the same

September 2012 WWW.WATERPOWERMAGAZINE.COM 19

View publication stats

You might also like