Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Sykes' Regulars at Antietam Battery Robinett Scale Creep Miniatures 15mm ACW
Sykes' Regulars at Antietam Battery Robinett Scale Creep Miniatures 15mm ACW
Sykes' Regulars at Antietam Battery Robinett Scale Creep Miniatures 15mm ACW
Issue 12 The Official Newsletter of the Johnny Reb Gaming Society $5.00
Table of Contents
Sykes’ Regulars . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 2
Commanders in Blue / Gray . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .5
Sons of the South . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .. 6
Rockbridge Railhead . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . ..7
Sutler’s Corner . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .9
Vignettes . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 10
JR3 and the Hex Grid . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 12
Civil War Blogging . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .14
Johnny Con Report . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 16
The Budget Gamer . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .19
Battery Robinett . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .20
Johnny Con Convention. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .24
Guilford Courthouse . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 25
Sykes’ Regulars
handled had McClellan thrown forward all his
reserves in a coordinated fashion. Sykes lamented in
his official report, “The troops under Captain Dryer
at Antietam behaved in the handsomest manner, and, had there
been an available force for their support, there is no
doubt he could have crowned the Sharpsburg crest.”
Wednesday, September 17, 1862
THE WARGAME
Sharpsburg, Maryland The table size is 4’x6’ for Johnny Reb 3, 15mm.
By Scott Mingus All woods are light; roll for visibility in full inches.
Antietam Creek may not be forded. The streams,
“The time for attack! The chance for victory!" fences and stonewalls require a 1” movement
Capt. Thomas M. Anderson, 12 th U.S. Infantry penalty. The scenario runs from 12:20 p.m. until 6
p.m.
BACKGROUND
CSA – All deployed artillery is unlimbered.
As fighting waned around the sunken road, Miller’s Battery is frozen unless Yankees come
Maj. Gen. George B. McClellan sent some of Alfred within 6”. It is accompanied by elements of R. H.
Pleasonton’s cavalry and horse artillery clattering Anderson’s division, which are not used in the game
across Antietam Creek via the Boonsboro Turnpike as they are facing parts of the Union II Corps near the
bridge. His position being greatly exposed and sunken road. Stevens is in skirmish line. The 1 GA /
unsupported, Pleasonton soon sought infantry to 17 SC / Holcombe Legion are hidden behind
protect his guns. Brig. Gen. George Sykes responded haystacks, which offer light cover and a –1 modifier
and sent forward a battalion of the 2nd / 10th US to combat. Jenkins’ brigade arrives at B at 3 p.m. in
Infantry under Capt. John S. Poland, as well as part line. At 3:20, Miller’s battery (and Colonel Walton)
of the 12th US. withdraws and is replaced by S. D. Lee’s limbered
After two of Pleasonton's batteries exhausted battalion (enter by the church). Maurin arrives there
their ammunition, Fifth Corps commander Fitz John at 4:00 p.m. There are no opening volley benefits for
Porter ordered Sykes to relieve the horse artillery any CSA units.
with his own guns. Against his judgment, Sykes U.S. – The Union batteries on the table are
reluctantly sent Randol's and Van Reed's batteries unlimbered and do not get opening volley modifiers,
across the stone bridge, along with four additional as they have already been in action. Tidball’s Battery
battalions of regulars under the command of Capt. is in front of a gap in the wooden fence. Gibson is in
Hiram Dryer of the 4th US Infantry. Lieutenant a small grove of trees and rock outcroppings.
Randol, finding his horses exposed to Confederate
sharpshooters and his position untenable, soon The 4th PA Cavalry (mounted) enters on turn 1 at
withdrew his battery. Van Reed, posted farther to the A on the turnpike, immediately followed by
right, attracted less enemy fire. The battalion of the Robertson’s Battery (limbered). The latter receives an
2nd / 10th Infantry, thrown well forward as skirmishers opening volley benefit provided it unlimbers and
in a cornfield, compelled the Confederate artillerists stays put for 1 full game turn before firing.
to leave their guns. However, being few in number Historically, Robertson split his battery, sending one
and unsupported, the regulars were unable to bring section north of Tidball and one behind Gibson on
the enemy guns off. Dryer advanced to Cemetery Hill higher ground. Gibson and Hains must withdraw by 3
about 4:30 p.m. and called for reinforcements for a p.m.
general assault. However, Porter and McClellan The 12th and 2nd / 10th US enter in column on turn
deferred, and the attack faltered. 2, with Capt. Dryer and the 4th and 14th US at 2 p.m.
Soon, A. P. Hill’s counterattack drove back Randol and Van Reed (limbered) enter on the next
the Union IX Corps, as well as the regulars to their turn. Upon arrival, Dryer takes overall command of
right flank. Dryer's infantry and Van Reed's battery the regulars. All receive opening volley modifiers.
stayed west of Antietam Creek until 7:30 p.m., when
both were withdrawn in the darkness to the east bank.
The remainder of Sykes’ division was unengaged on
the 17th , but could have been more aggressively
Tidball’s Battery A, 2nd US Art – 4x 3” Rifles, 1/2/V - Lt. Col. Robert C. Buchanan (+1)
elite 3rd US Infantry – 200 men, RM, veteran
Robertson’s Battery B/L, 2nd US Art. – 4x 3” R, 2nd Battalion, 12th US Inf. – 200 men, RM, veteran
vet
Hains’ Battery M, 2nd US Art. – 4x 3” Rifles, vet 2/2/V - Maj. Charles S. Lovell +1
Gibson’s Bttry C/G, 3rd US Art. – 4x 3” Rifles, vet 1st / 6th US Infantry – 182 men, RM, veteran
11th US Infantry – 249 men, RM, veteran
***** 17th US Infantry – 309 men, RM, veteran
OPTIONAL: If the Union commander wants to be
more aggressive than McClellan or Porter, bring on This scenario may be combined with the “Sunken
Brig. Gen. George Sykes (+2) with the rest of the Road” and/or “Up Came Hill” scenarios from
regulars on game turn 7 at A: Undying Courage: Antietam in Miniature.
Anderson
Miller
Park log
house
C H. Piper A
Bondurant 18 SC
Robertson
4 PA
stone
toll
Jones’ Boyce Tidball W. Newcomer house
J.
Btln. Cherry mill
Hill Middle
Keplinger Bridge
Boonsboro
22 SC
Hains Pike
Turner
23 SC
Cemetery Gibson von Kleiser
Hill
Squires
Lutheran
Church
Bachman Weed
Garnett Antietam
Creek
Stevens
Taft
Garden
Sherrick
farm
B
to Rohrbach
(Lower) Bridge
After the war, he was assigned to various posts. In Richard Garnett was commissioned as a second
1853, the 4th Infantry was assigned to the Pacific lieutenant in the 6th U.S. Infantry and he served in a
Coast. He established Fort Humboldt. Under his variety of posts in Florida, fighting the Seminoles,
command was Lieutenant Ulysses S. Grant. When and then in the West, where he commanded Fort
Grant's drinking began to affect his duties, Buchanan Laramie, rode with the Mormon Expedition, and was
asked for and received Grant's resignation from the a noted Indian fighter. During the Mexican War, he
Army. Buchanan commanded the District of served in staff positions in New Orleans
Southern Oregon and Northern California from Fort
Humboldt, and participated in the Rogue River Wars Early in the Civil War, Garnett was a major of
in Oregon. artillery and then a lieutenant colonel of the Georgia
Legion. He was promoted to brigadier general in
Buchanan was stationed in Los Angeles, California, November 1861, and commanded the 1st Brigade of
at the beginning of the Civil War. He was ordered the Valley District. Stonewall Jackson arrested
east and participated in the Peninsula Campaign as Garnett for "neglect of duty" on April 1 and relieved
commander of the 4th U.S. Infantry. He participated him of command. Garnett's court-martial was
in several other Virginia battles and was brevetted a suspended due to Robert E. Lee's Northern Virginia
brigadier general of volunteers in 1862. He Campaign and the Second Battle of Bull Run. Lee
commanded the First Brigade, Second Division, Fifth ordered Jackson to release Garnett from arrest and he
Corps during the Maryland Campaign (part of Sykes’ was assigned to command the injured George
Regulars). Pickett's brigade. Garnett commanded the brigade
credibly at Antietam, after which he assumed
At Antietam, he strongly protested a decision to halt permanent command of the brigade when Pickett was
his advance on what he maintained was a weakly promoted to division.
defended portion of the enemy line. In his opinion,
his regulars could have and should have carried Garnett fought at Fredericksburg, but missed
Cemetery Hill, defended primarily by artillery with Chancellorsville as the division was in Suffolk,
only the depleted Virginia brigade of Richard Garnett Virginia. He was killed during Pickett’s Charge at
in support. Gettysburg, and his body was never identified.
Hobbled by an injury to his leg, he decided to ride
After the Civil War, Buchanan reverted to colonel into the fight. His blood-splattered horse emerged
and was placed in command of the U.S. 1st Infantry from the smoke without Garnett. It is probable that he
Regiment at New Orleans. He then served in the was buried with the common soldiers, and his
Freedmen's Bureau. He subsequently commanded remains most likely were reinterred in Richmond’s
the Department of Louisiana. He retired from the Hollywood Cemetery in the 1870s. Garnett’s sword
Army on December 31, 1870. Buchanan died in appeared in a Baltimore pawn shop, where it was
Washington, D.C., and was buried in the Rock Creek purchased by Gen. George “Maryland” Steuart, who
Cemetery. later presented it to Garnett’s widow.
Defenders
Union: “Buford’s Boys” – John Buford
2 regiments of dismounted cavalry - 6 stands
each (elite) BL carbines
3 sections Light Horse Artillery – 6# Smoothbore
guns (elite)
Walking wounded - rifled muskets (green)
east
barn
house
depot hospital
J.
New
com
er
west
Terrain Tip 2: To make realistic stream or river edges: Gather dark colored mulch from your
landscaping, or dark bark if you have it. Chop them in a Waring blender to your desired
consistency. Then coat the inside edges of river curves or islands with an acrylic glue such as
Elmers™ or a craft tacky glue, and then press in the desired quantity of chopped mulch. It
should look like water-logged splintered wood. This makes a nice effect if used sporadically
on sections that look like they would collect debris (such as bends, curves, bridge abutments,
etc.).
Compliments of NCHWS & Doug Rogers
www.geocities.com/nchws2003
Other scales: Since the table size for Johnny Reb 3 There are also some interesting tactical units in use
is only three by four feet, the size can be doubled for such as heavy and siege artillery by the Union (which
a grand-spectacle game in 28mm and maybe using incidentally, were Parrott guns that could sometimes
JR2 and using 150% increase of the given distances explode at the breech). There is also the possibility of
to explore more of the tactical aspects of the battle. four units of sharpshooters on the Confederate side,
which should make for some effective skirmisher
firing as was noted by the Union troops, who despite
FURTHER NOTES their cover were worsted by the accurate Confederate
fire. As “Johnny Reb” allows sharpshooters to fire at
Corinth was a particularly brutal battle for the full effect, this rule combined with the fact they are
Confederates. They sustained very high losses in the Elite troops shooting at Green troops should work
vain attempt to carry a position with an equal number well in replicating the efficacy of the Texan and
of defenders. Although Lovell’s inaction has been Arkansan sharpshooters.
criticised, had he also attacked the butcher’s bill
would have been higher and perhaps to no avail. As The Confederate attack is interesting in the way they
it was, he pinned three (though depleted) Union employed their large units of recruits – just like a
brigades in place. The Federals had lost ten per cent Napoleonic general would – in columns of attack,
of their force. Price’s corps (two divisions) lost over preceded by a cloud of skirmishers. The use of
3,700 out of 10,500 infantrymen. skirmishers is vital in protecting the columns from
heavy casualties.
For after-game comparison’s sake, the actual losses
including captured and missing were:
2 nd Line
Lawson’s Virginia Brigade – Brig. Gen. Robert
Lawson +1
10 Figures Green
Charles Cornwallis Stevens’ Virginia Brigade – Brig. Gen Edward
Stevens +1
ORDER OF BATTLE 10 Figures Militia