Download as pdf or txt
Download as pdf or txt
You are on page 1of 5

UIB 2612

Gan Yu Lin

LECTURE 7 IJARAH DIFFERENCES OF OPINION


Some jurist including Hassan al-Basri, al-
RECAP: Mudarabah, Musharakah, Murabahah,
Nahrawani and others forbids contract of Ijarah.
Bay’Bithaman Ajil
Reasons:
DEFINITION  Ijarah is the sale of usufruct or services, and
Literally: services is something intangible and does not
Ijarah means compensation or ‫ضوع‬. It also exist at the time of contract.
means the sale of usufruct. (the right to the use,  It only can be achieve gradually over certain
profit and benefit of something belonging to period and something that not exist cannot be
another). sold.
Technically:  It is not permissible to associate bay’ (trade)
It means 'to give something on rent'. with something that could only be realized
It is a contract where the financier (bank) and achieved in the future
buys and leases equipment or other assets to
Majority of jurist including Ibn Rushd allowed
the business owner (customer) for a fee or
contracts of Ijarah.
more often called rental income.
Reasons:
The duration of the lease as well as the fee
 Even though usufruct does not exist at the
must be set in advance and mutually agreed.
time of contract, normally it could be realized
The term 'Ijarah' is used for two different or achieved
situations  This type of usufruct or benefit could
 relates to the usufructs of assets and ordinarily be accomplished, or its
properties accomplishment or non-accomplishment is
 Services of human beings rather similar
NATURE OF AL-IJARAH EVIDENCE
Lease is a contract by which the owner of land, a Al-Quran
building allows another person to use it for a (28:26) Said one of the (damsels): "O my (dear)
specific time, usually in return for a rent. father! engage him on wages: truly the best of
Al-Ijarah means a lease contract as well as a men for thee to employ is the (man) who is strong
hire contract. and trusty"....
Al-Ijarah, is also known as al-Kira’. It is like (28:27) He said: "I intend to wed one of these my
someone who is selling to someone else a right daughters to thee, on condition that thou serve
to benefit or as a payment for services with a me for eight years; but if thou complete ten years,
certain price to be paid for it. it will be (grace) from thee. But I intend not to
In the context of Islamic banking it is a lease place thee under a difficulty: thou wilt find me,
contract under which the bank or financial indeed, if Allah wills, one of the righteous."
institution leases equipment or a building to one Hadith
of its clients against a fixed charge. “Give a servant his fee before his sweat dries
up”(Al-Baihaqi)
UIB 2612
Gan Yu Lin

Ijma Ijarah based on Subject Matter


The ummah had came to a consensus during the 1. Ijarah ‘Ain
time of companion on permissibility of Ujrah  To lease the usufruct from the specific goods
since the need of people for usufruct is similar to or asset
 Comprises all tangible assets.
their need to physical good.
 Comprises all tangible assets.
PILLARS OF AL-IJARAH 2. Ijarah ‘Amal
Muajjir: A person who give something for hire  To lease out the works or self skills
– Lessor, landlord, owner etc.  To employ the services of a person on wages
given to him as a consideration for his hired
Musta’jir: A person who takes on hire – Lessee,
services.
tenant, renter etc.  Two type of workers:
Ma’jur: A thing given for rent Employee: person/entity that work only for
Al-Manfaah: The benefit from a thing – the interest of a particular employer or
usufruct, services etc. independent contractor; does not have right
Ujrah: Price or fee given for the payment of rent to work for any other lessee during contract.
Independent contractor: offer services to the
or lease
general public
Sighah: Offer (Ijab) and Acceptance (Qabul)  E.g: consultant, lawyer, contractor
3. Ijarah Mawsufah fi al-Zimmah
FLOWS OF AL-IJARAH  Form of ijarah where asset need to be
described in advance
 The leased item/asset is not available
during contract
 The asset must be delivered on a future
agreed date

Ijarah based on Contractual Relationship


1. Operating Lease
 Originated form of ijarah ‘ain
 Features of operating lease:
a. Asset acqusition is in full ownership of
the lessor – legal and beneficial
TYPES OF IJARAH ownership
b. Responsibility to maintain bear by the
Based on Subject Based on the lessor in administrative affairs and
Matter contractual relationship maintenance of asset; lessee only
responsible in the maintenance due to
Tangible asset Operating Lease the usage and has to pay rent per agreed.
c. Risk on the asset is under liability and
Labour Financial lease responsibility of the lessor
d. High risk in nature.
2. Financial Lease
Description of asset
 Normally used and offered by Islamic
bank as financial intermediaries in:
UIB 2612
Gan Yu Lin

 Obtaining desired asset due to his negligence, the lessee is liable to


 Obtaining cash money for various pay the compensation (dhaman).
purposes 8. The lessee cannot lease the property to
 Normally used and offered by Islamic another tenant and the second contract is
bank as financial intermediaries in: considered as illegitimate.
 Obtaining desired asset 9. The sale of a lease property is legitimate.
 Obtaining cash money for various However, the lessee has a right to use the
purposes property until the lease contract has expired,
where the property will then be submitted to
SUBJECT MATTER OF AL-IJARAH the buyer.
Since Ijarah is the sale of usufruct, majority of
jurist forbid Ijarah on trees and grapevines, since CONDITIONS OF AL-IJARAH
fruit are physical goods and Ijarah is the sale of The conditions for Usufruct
usufruct and not physical goods. 1. The use of the service (usufruct) can be
It is also not permissible to conduct Ijarah on valued with money.
animal for its milk; ghee, wool or offspring; 2. The usufruct must be valid according to
water in the river or well or canal since all these Islamic commercial law.
are goods, and not eligible to be under contract 3. The lessee should be able to make use of the
of Ijarah. property on lease.
Basic principle of Ijarah: every item that could 4. The usage of the property should be made
be utilized with its original substance and part clear in order to avoid any argument.
consistently being conserved or preserved is 5. The usufruct does not entitled the lessee to
allowed for Ijarah, and if not is illegal. own the property.
6. The lessee is not obliged to inform the lessor
CONDITIONS OF AL-IJARAH his intention for using the property, except
The conditions for Property in the case of possible destruction.
1. The property must be belong to the lessor. 7. The usufruct of property beyond its normal
2. The property is known to both parties and is usage is considered as an act of intention.
specified. The conditions for Payment
3. The property can be acquired by the lessee 1. The amount of payment of rent must be
for his use until the end of tenancy or lease. known. If the payment is not in form of cash
4. The property should be in a good condition money, the goods in return must be specified
possible for leasing. its quantity, types and its characteristics.
5. It is the liability of the lessor to repair 2. The payment of rent can be made in advance.
damages of the property in order to make it 3. If the condition for payment does not
possible for leasing. prescribed to be paid in advance, the
6. It is the liability of the lessee to ensure the payment begins when usufruct started.
cleanliness and safety of the property. 4. If the payment is made on daily, weekly or
7. The liability of the lessee over the property monthly basis, the payment should be made
is under the concept of trust (wadiah yadd at the end of period unless otherwise stated
amanah). However, in the case of damages on the agreement.
UIB 2612
Gan Yu Lin

5. If the property cannot be used the payment rental, with an agreement that the owner will
is not obliged upon the user. transfer the rented asset to the hirer at the end of
The conditions for Sighah the agreed period or during the period, provided
1. The contract of offer and acceptance should all rental payments or installments have been
follow all the conditions of the contract of made in entirety
sale in Islam; i.e. it should be on mutual In theory, the contract of AITAB shall consist
consent. of two different contracts, namely:
The contract of lease (al-ijarah ‘ain)
DIFFERENCES BETWEEN IJARAH & The contract of sale (al-bay’)
NORMAL SALES AITAB is a contract of leasing with a promise to
1. Duration
sell the asset.
 Ijarah: based solely on a predetermined
FLOWS OF AITAB
time frame as part of the requirement of
In AITAB, the contract of al-ijarah runs
the contract
separately from the contract of al-bay’. These
 Normal sales: does not permit any time
stages are:
frame
Stage 1: Executing the contract of true leasing
2. Nature
(al-ijarah ‘ain)
 Ijarah: a temporary contract with a
Stage 2: Executing the contract of sale (al-bay’)
specified time frame for its expiry and due
at a nominal value agreed upon by both parties.
time
 Normal sales: a permanent contract
FLOWS OF AITAB
without any specified period of expiration
3. Ownership
 Ijarah: no transfer of ownership
 Normal sales: transfer of ownership
occurs
4. Subject
 Ijarah: Usufruct and services
 Normal sales: physical goods and
property

MODERN APPLICATION
Eg: Simple ijarah, AITAB, Musharakah
mutanaqisah
Differences between AITAB & Hire Purchase
AL-IJARAH THUMMA AL-BAY’ (AITAB)
Number of contract
AITAB also known as ijarah wa iqtina’ (‫ةراجإ‬
 Hire purchase – using single contract
‫ )ءانتقاو‬or al-ijarah muntahiya bi-tamlik (‫ارراجإ‬
covering both rental and sale aspects
‫)كايتهللب ايهقتملا‬
 AITAB – comprises two separate contract
Definition:
‘ijarah’ and al’bai
Owning the benefit of certain assets for a specific
period of time, by paying an agreed sums of
UIB 2612
Gan Yu Lin

Contract terms
 Hire purchase - Considered as a loan to
customer, the bank charge interest on loan
 AITAB – considered as a financing to the
customer and the bank charge fixed profit on
the cost of financing
Source of funds
 Hire purchase- no restriction on sources of
fund
 AITAB – sourced from halal funds
Acceptance letter
 Hire purchase – no such agreement
 AITAB – customer has to sign the Aqad
letter to denote the offer and acceptance of
transaction
Insurance
 Hire purchase – using conventional
insurance
 AITAB – using Takaful

AITAB PROCESS IN CAR FINANCING


1. Bank (lessor) purchase the car from dealer
2. Bank hire the car to the customer
3. Dealer deliver car to hirer
4. Customer (as lessee) pay monthly payment
as agreed

You might also like