Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Acupuncture For Muscle-Skeletal Issues in A Group of Musicians
Acupuncture For Muscle-Skeletal Issues in A Group of Musicians
Acupuncture For Muscle-Skeletal Issues in A Group of Musicians
Universidade de Aveiro
Mafalda.vilan.pires@gmail.com
Keywords: Alternative Medicine, Acupuncture, Musicians, Muscle-
Skeletal Pahtologies, Anxiety in Performance
Abstract:
Introduction
circulation of energy through the human body meridians. It seeks to apply the
understanding of both the treatment of diseases and the maintenance of
health through several methods.
Western and modern medicine, however, suggests that the method
stimulates the release of chemical substances that alter the nervous system
and can affect the rest of the body, thus promoting a balanced organism (Abe
2006). Krist Federspiel and Vera Herbst present several theories that explain
the effects of acupuncture:
incorrect food habits, injuries and sexual excesses can be the cause of
diseases (Rothfeld and Le Vert 1997). Generally, one considers that a
disease is more than the consequence of the disturbances that occur in the
normal flow of vital energy (Chi), by blocks and a sense of excessive or lack
of something in the organism (Federspiel and Herbst 2001).
By believing in the real value of this therapy as a science and an
efficient therapeutical technique, I intend to find out if it is truly beneficial to
musicians. It is my intention to know if one can reduce, controlo and/or
prevent muscle-skeletal pathologies and thus diminish the state of anxiety
which surrounds us before and during a performance.
anxiety of the individuals. For those who have problems with myopia and
astigmatism, the state of anxiety can aggravate this condition, it overloads the
nervous system, sending wrong information to the brain, which may result in
blurred vision (Grohol 2014).
The inventory and the tests were analysed and evaluated by the
psychologist Sofia Pires.
The survey relating to the musicians’ complaints of muscular pains
consisted of four drawings of the human body, from four perspectives: the
front, the back, the left profile and the right profile, whereby before the first
acupuncture session the participants indicated the zones in which they had
complaints, and using a scale of 0 – 10, described the intensity of the pain. In
order to determine whether the acupuncture improved the problems, after
each session, the musicians used the same scale to indicate the intensity of
pain they were feeling.
Results
Resistance to Fatigue. This is the case of two female individuals (Female 3
and Female 4) who, before the acupuncture sessions, presented negative
values, and after treatment, had the most notable increases in the entire
group (table 1). This data shows that the therapy significantly improved levels
of Resistance to Fatigue.
Table I
participants (Male 2 and Male 9) did not show any significant alterations, but
all the others showed improvements. With regard to gender, as with the
previous test, the female group demonstrated a more accentuated evolution,
in this case corresponding to a greater decline in values between the initial
and final test. Before the therapy, the female group had an average of 49.95,
which afterwards descended significantly to 17.03. In the case of the male
group, apart from always maintaining higher levels of Concentrated Attention,
their evolution was not so marked. The test conducted before the acupuncture
sessions presented an average value of 39.85 (10.10 lower, or better, than
the female group), with the repetition showing an average of 16.56 (just 0.47
less than the females). These results show that, in relation to Concentrated
Attention levels, the therapy also had a significantly positive effect and these
musicians were able to greatly improve their levels of concentration.
Table II
10
In relation to the Spielberger questionnaires, the results obtained
before the application of acupuncture show that the values presented by the
participating musicians are, in the case of the STAIY 1 questionnaire, very
close to the Portuguese National Average, although in the case of the STAIY
2 questionnaire, these values were slightly higher than this average. In other
words, a slight tendency towards a permanent state of anxiety was detected,
which was marginally more elevated in men than in women.
For a more detailed analysis, the values that lie between the national
average and the lowest value, on applying the standard deviation, was called
lower average and the values that fall between the national average and the
highest value, equally applying standard deviation, was called upper average,
11
as these values are considered normal. Therefore, we can more accurately
understand the anxiety levels of this sample in comparison to the values
considered normal in Portugal, as shown in Table III.
12
In the questionnaire completed after the therapy, the results show a
significant improvement in the levels of anxiety presented by the participating
musicians. As previously verified by the results of the repetition of the STAIY
1 questionnaire, the effect of acupuncture on the musicians is also obvious in
this case. Both the male and female groups demonstrated an average which,
after therapy, fell below the national average. The female group showed
values of 37.38, and the male group 36.7, which is a significant decrease of
4.75 and 4.0 respectively.
Table III
13
In relation to the pathologies presented by the musicians, as shown in
Table IV, we can verify that the majority (15) of the musicians (from a group of
28), experienced shoulder pains, 4 felt lower back pain, 2 reported thoracic
spine pain, in addition to shoulder and neck pain, 1 felt pain along the spine, 1
complained of shoulder, hand and leg pains, 1 felt shoulder and lower back
pain, 1 had elbow pains and 1 had wrist and arm pain. In relation to
aggravating or easing the pain, 22 confirmed that the pain was aggravated by
movement and 6 confirmed that the pain was aggravated by rest. For the
majority (22/28) rest brought improvements, and for 6 participants, the pain
improved with movement. Blood pressure levels were considered normal for
25 participants, but considered high for 3 participants. With regard to vision,
14 participants had no complaints, 5 had myopia, 1 had astigmatism, and 4
presented with myopia and astigmatism. In this case, as this majority of the
participants presented normally, we cannot consider that their existing vision
problems had an impact that should be taken into account in diagnosing each
musician.
14
reduced to 1 in the lower back, shoulders and neck and 0 in the thoracic
spine. Seven musicians identified level 3 pains – three with shoulder pain, one
with lower back pain, one with elbow pain, one with thoracic spine pain, and
one with shoulder, hand and leg pain. After the acupuncture treatment, these
pain levels reduced to level 2 in the lower back and shoulders, 1 for shoulder
hand and leg pain, and 0 for elbow/thoracic spine pain. Three musicians
considered their pains as level 2. Two had shoulder pain, and one had wrist
and arm pain. This pain level reduced to 0. Only one musician selected level
1, with shoulder pain, but this diminished to level 0 after the acupuncture
sessions. One musician did not respond.
Table IV
15
Discussion
The aim of this study was to investigate the effect which acupuncture
could have on musicians with skeletal muscular pathologies and anxiety
problems.
participating women, the two individuals that presented above normal values
before the therapy now present values within the lower average range, and in
general, more participants now fall into this range than before the therapy. On
the other hand, another female individual, who had been in the upper average
range, now has above average values. In the case of the men, not one
individual now presents values which are higher than considered normal, and
four diminished their values to below the national average, which means that
they have significantly decreased their levels of anxiety.
In the case of the female group, it was proven that of the two
individuals who presented above average values, only one maintained these
levels after the acupuncture sessions, and now there are more individuals
with values below those considered normal, whereas beforehand only one
presented these values, and now three fall into this category. Again, in the
male group, none of the participants now present values which are above
normal, and one presents values below the national average, therefore as
three were in this category before the therapy, now four are below the national
average, which shows that the therapy diminished their anxiety levels.
17
level of pain after the treatment, as in many cases, the treatment was the
solution of eliminating these pathologies. The most important cases are those
in which the pain levels indicated by the musicians were levels 7 and 8,
considered the most severe. Following the acupuncture sessions, it can be
stated that acupuncture was beneficial, reducing the pain levels to 3, 2 and 0,
which are considered mild.
Conclusion
18
in, and enjoy, their musical performance. These musicians now suffer
substantially less muscular pain, and are thus more concentrated, calmer, and
more relaxed.
Bibliography
19
Lossow, Jacob Francone (1990) Anatomia e fisiologia Humana. Rio de
Janeiro: Editora Guanabara.
20