Download as pdf or txt
Download as pdf or txt
You are on page 1of 12

1 (12)

Perspectives on Perspective

Rune Pettersson

In his book on photography Freeman According to The Oxford Dictionary


(1988) provides the following broad and Thesaurus (Tulloch, 1995) the word
definition of the word perspective (page perspective has five different meanings
156): (page 136):

Perspective is the appearance of objects in 1 a the art of drawing solid objects on a


space, and their relationships to each other two-dimensional surface so as to give the
and the viewer. right impression on relative positions,
size, etc. b a picture drawn in this way. 2
The New Websters Dictionary and the apparent relation between visible
Thesaurus (Ottenheimer, 1991) provides objects as to position, distance, etc. 3 a
the following two definitions of the word mental view of the relative importance of
perspective (page 282): things (keep the right perspective). 4 a
geographical or imaginary prospect.
the art of drawing objects on a plane
surface to give the impression of the
relative distance of objects, indicated by Perception of Depth
the convergence of their receding lines; We have two eyes, and we naturally see in
relation of parts of the problem, etc. in the three dimensions rather than in one or two
mind dimensions. The illusion of depth is
The Longman Dictionary of created when our brains interpret the
Contemporary English (Longman, 1990) slightly different views from our two eyes.
has three definitions of the word perspective The stereoscope, and the Viewmaster,
(page 767): presents two slightly different two-
dimensional photographs. When the
the art of drawing solid objects on a flat photographs are viewed simultaneously by
surface so that they give a natural effect of the eyes, the brain merges the two images
depth, distance, and solidity to one combined three-dimensional image.
... the way in which a situation or problem The stereoscope was very popular during
is judged, so that (proper) consideration the later half of the last century as a source
and importance is given to each part for education and entertainment.
... a view, esp. one stretching far into the
Stereocards viewed through stereoscopes
distance
were the main source of pictorial news.
2 (12)

E ve n t h o u g h m o s t p i c t u r e s a r e disc (the natural way of things). However, the figure


presented on a two-dimensional plane or may actually represent an incomplete black disc
nestled against the white disc, as demonstrated to
flat surface with a length and width, we the right, where the objects are separated.
expect them to have the illusion of depth,
a third dimension. When we look at a still According to Freeman (1988) a
picture, or view a motion picture, time can heightened sense of depth through strong
be seen as a fourth dimension. People will perspective tends to improve the realism in
employ their individual viewing behaviour, a photograph. It makes more of the
and see and interpret different messages in representational qualities of the subject,
the same picture. and less of the graphic structure.
Depth is related to volume, weight, and Painters and photographers often use
mass. Spatial perception is not the several different types of perspectives to
perception of space as such but of the enhance the effect of depth in their pictures.
learned meaning of the relationship Line perspectives, aerial perspectives,
between different objects seen in space. The color perspectives, and overlapping
perception of depth is related to the relative perspectives may well be used at the same
size of known objects, to lighting time to interact with each other and create
conditions, to illumination and shadows, to lifelike pictures that are good
judicious croppings, to linear perspective, representations of reality. However, for
to change of line weight, to texture schematic pictures that are meant to show
gradients in the picture, to upward angular three-dimensionality, it is usually more
location of grounded objects, to inter- appropriate to use only one of the different
position and overlap of picture elements, line perspectives at the same time.
and to filled and empty space. Image
elements conveying a sense of depth should
be clear and easy to comprehend. Depth Linear Perspectives
perception is also based on the different In a realistic linear perspective, objects
colors’ of varying wavelengths. Warmer are conceived as being placed behind a
colors emphasize a foreground. Cooler picture plane onto which straight beams of
colors emphasize a background. light are projected. Linear perspectives are
The spatial perspectives are important based on the idea that an object appears to
for our perception of depth. Compared with grow larger in size as the distance between
visual language factors like space, size, it and the observer decreases. A view
color, lighting, and texture, the spatial along a road with identical trees will
perspectives are usually complex depth produce the familiar convergence of lines.
cues. A person’s cultural heritage and social The trees appear to be successively
situation is always of vital importance for smaller. This is sometimes called
the perception of depth cues. diminishing perspective.
In the western world the position in a
picture of a known object, like a car, with
a known actual size will give us a depth cue.
Regardless of distance there is a constancy
in the perception of the size of known
objects (size constancy). The perception of
Perspective or not? We easily interpret the left
distance is related to the perceived size, and
pattern as a black disc partially occluded by a white
the perception of size is reciprocally related
3 (12)

to the perceived distance. (Compare with with a window on the left wall, is drawn in a one-
value perspective.) point perspective with one single vanishing point
(Vp) on the horizon line.
The perception of size is influenced by
color and grey scale. Open and light forms We have to distinguish between optical
are perceived as being larger than closed and perceptual reality. Optical reality is
and darker forms of the same shape. The governed by geometry and is only visual.
perception of size is very much influenced However, perceptual reality is governed by
by contextual variables. Large cannot exist object constancy, and combines what we
without small. already know about the subject with what
In visuals used for information we need we can see, hear, smell, etc. A central
to show scale and contrast. It is usually a perspective is the graphic equivalent of
good idea to include a person or a familiar optical reality.
object to supply the scale for judging the The central perspective is a rather recent
size of unfamiliar objects. The perceived perceptual acquisition, developed in the
size of an object is relative to the size of early Renaissance by artists who learned to
other objects. Thus, the size of an see form and space in a new way. The
unfamiliar object is perceived as relative to mathematical laws of perspective were
the size of familiar objects. discovered by the Italian architect Filippo
Brunelleschi. He worked out some of the
One-Point Perspective fundamental principles, including the
A linear perspective uses the principle concept of the vanishing point. The laws of
that, as parallel lines recede, they seem to perspective had been known to the Greeks
converge, or meet at a distant point. In a and Romans but had been lost.
view of a long straight road, the sides and The first textbook to explain the basics
telegraph wires appear to meet at a of perspective was issued as early as in
vanishing point on the horizon even 1492. Before then, several manuscripts had
though they are parallel in reality. been written. Pictorial art was regarded as
An artist represents linear perspective a science that could be applied to explore
by moving all lines on the canvas toward a the laws of nature. Some woodcuts by
vanishing point on the horizon line. The eye Albrecht Dürer demonstrates a drawing
level of the observer determines the table called a “Leonardo box”, named after
location of the horizon line. If all lines Leonardo da Vinci. This was a perspective
vanish in a single point, the picture is in a tool using a frame with a square grid to
one-point perspective. This is also called achieve an accurate linear perspective of an
central perspective and Renaissance object, when the artist worked on a surface
perspective. with a similar grid. Using this method, the
artist could be sure that all the lines drawn
represented the objects in correct central
perspective positions. Some painters
accomplished such an accuracy that their
Vp Horizon works stand comparison with projection
line drawings, or even with photographs. In
early Renaissance paintings, the floor is
often made out of marble squares. These
One-point perspective. This drawing of a room,
4 (12)

squares form a perfect linear perspective in


the pictures.
Vanishing point Horizon line Vanishing point
Some artists used to draw accurate
landscapes using a large camera obscura.
The artists actually worked inside the box,
where they traced the upside-down image
on a thin sheet of paper on the inner wall.
Much later, light-sensitive material became
the basis for photography.
In “The Last Supper”, one of Leonardo
Two-point perspective. This box is drawn in a
da Vinci’s most famous paintings, the artist two-point perspective, with two vanishing points on
used central linear perspective to express the horizon line.
the social importance of Christ. All of the
diagonal lines in the image converge on the
face of Christ, at the vanishing point in the
middle of the painting.

Two-Point Perspective 1 2 3

Lines that vanish in two directions to two


different vanishing points produce a two-
point perspective. This is also called 4 5
angular perspective and oblique
perspective. All linear perspectives have Cubes. The first cube (1) has a correct perspective.
The other four cubes contain common
exact formulas with many and
perspectional errors. The second cube is too wide.
complicated rules. The third cube is too tall. The fourth cube is out of
convergence, and the fifth cube is out of proportion.

Dondis (1973) pointed out that


Object perspective dominates in photography.
Today, any standard camera with ordinary
lenses provides us with linear perspective
Two-point perspective Two-point perspective
pictures. The camera lens has some of the
One-point-perspecive
perspectives of the eye, and simulation of
dimension is one of its prime abilities.
Horizontal viewpoints. In a one-point perspective
Some photographers use linear perspective
we look right at the object at a 90o angle. All other and its vanishing points to create dynamic
angles give a two-point perspective. In multi-view compositions. By association, diagonal
perspectives several different views appear at the lines of all kinds contain a suggestion of
same time in a picture. In this illustration the arrows
show the observer’s line of sight in different depth.
situations. T h e fi e l d o f t h e c a m e r a l e n s i s
changeable. What we can see and record is
determined by the focal length of the lens.
The normal lens has nowhere near the range
of field of the human eye, but from a depth
point of view, what it records is close to the
perspective of the eye. A telephoto lens will
5 (12)

narrow, and a wide angle lens will broaden Objects are usually viewed straight
the field. from the front and at the same level as the
viewer. This “normal picture angle” and the
normal way of viewing could be said to
object object object represent the eye-level perspective , or
normal perspective.
It is easier to comprehend a frontal
1 2 3 projection in which the subject is rendered
film film film f r o m n o r m a l ey e l eve l t h a n o t h e r
projections and angles.
The angle of view to a surface that
Camera lenses 1. A telephoto lens (1), a normal carries converging lines determines the
lens (2), and a wide angle lens (3) all have a
different ranges of field. strength of the perspective effect. Too low
view fails to read clearly, too high view
Regardless of the lens used during shows little convergence.
photography, the actual light sensitive film
in the camera is the same. Thus, only a Bird’s-eye perspective
normal lens provides a “good” Military perspective
representation of an object on the film. At
the same distance all other lenses give some Gentleman’s perspective
distortions. Compared with a normal lens,
the narrow field from the telephoto lens Eye-level perspective
makes the representation of an object Object

broader on the film. The wide field provided


by a wide angle lens makes the
representation of an object narrow on the Worm’s-eye perspective
film. Wide-angle lenses have a propensity
to enhance linear perspective, while Vertical viewpoints 1. Our perception of an object
is very much dependent on the vertical viewpoint
telephoto lenses tend to flatten the we select. The arrows show the observer’s line of
perspective. sight in different vertical perspectives.

Low view of the object


object

object
object Vp Horizon line Vp

1 2 3
film film film

Camera lenses 2. Different lenses are usually


used for different distances. High view of the object

Vertical viewpoints 2. Here, we can see a high


6 (12)

view, like a Military perspective (bottom), and a low


view (top) of an object.

In the bird's-eye perspective, an object


is viewed from a high position; in the
worm's-eye perspective it is instead viewed
from below (at an oblique angle). Several
historical paintings of troops and battles
show a military perspective. Higher than
the eye-level perspective, this was perfect
Parallel perspective. Parallel lines of an object are
to see the different groups of soldiers on the parallel in the picture too (adopted from Zimmer
b a t t l e - fi e l d . A l s o t h e ge n t l e m a n ' s and Zimmer, 1978: page 59). The mechanical
perspective is higher than the eye-level orthographic drawing of a table, to the left, shows
perspective. proportions exactly. A freehand orthographic
drawing, to the right, is not so exact.
In visuals that are used for information
or instruction we should usually use only Parallel perspective combined with a
one of these vertical level perspectives. As viewpoint from above is common in
noted earlier there is a constancy in the traditional Chinese painting. Often foliage
perception of known objects. is used to crop the parallel lines before they
extend far enough to cause a building to
Parallel Perspective appear warped.
In the western cultural sphere, we are used
to seeing visuals with one- and two-point
perspectives. In some cultures it is better Reversed Linear Perspective
to use orthographic views. Mechanical In a reversed linear perspective, the
orthographic drawings show proportions foreground seems to be smaller than the
accurately with a parallel projection. background. The straight lines converge
Parallel lines of an object are parallel in in the direction of the viewer. This
the picture too. perspective is frequent in Japanese and
W h e n o r t h o g r a p h i c d r aw i n g i s Chinese art, which seeks to draw the
traditional in a culture, it is usually drawn viewer into the picture to take an active
freehand, and accuracy is not so important. part in the events depicted. In early Asian
In some places, only man-made objects and art there are no shadows.
buildings can be drawn orthograpically; It is conceivable that a reversed line
natural things, including people may not be perspective can be either a reversed parallel
drawn. Zimmer and Zimmer (1978) called p e r s p e c t ive o r a r eve r s e d c e n t r a l
orthographic views non-perspective, but perspective.
they are sometimes called parallel
perspectives.
Intuitive Perspectives
In painting and photography, the depth of
a picture can be visualised in several ways
and not only through a linear perspective.
Photographs often have well-defined
foregrounds and backgrounds, and parts in
between. In photography the depth of field
7 (12)

is influenced by the distance to the object that neither exist nor need to exist.
and by the camera aperture. The depth of Sometimes shadows may fall in different
field can vary from several meters to a few directions in the same picture.
decimetres. By making the foreground
sharp and the background blurred, the
interest of the viewer is directed to the
foreground, and vice versa.
Wrong Correct
Overlapping Perspective
Shadows. Avoid drop shadows behind picture
In the overlapping perspective, or the elements in schematic pictures! They impair
playing-card perspective, certain objects reading of the actual information.
are placed in front of other objects.
Overlapping is used to enhance the The playing-card perspective should
impression of depth in a picture. The always be used with cautiousness – in a
overlapping perspective was quite correct, logical, well thought-out, and
common in European mediaeval art. consistent manner. Otherwise, the risk of
misinterpretation is obvious.

Aerial, Tonal and Color Perspectives


In a picture of an open landscape, without
a natural line perspective, an impression
Overlapping perspective. We easily see this
pattern as objects partially occluded by one
of depth is created by means of an aerial
another. perspective, and a tonal perspective
combined with a color perspective.
Projected cast shadows, or drop The air is never absolutely clear. It is
shadows, may be seen as a simple playing- filled with a grey or greyish blue haze,
card perspective. Cast shadows are sharply moisture, and dust. This acts like a filter and
accentuated as a means of displaying the makes distant objects seem obscure and
location of different objects and their wrapped in mist and partly hidden. As a
spatial relationships to each other. Even consequence, objects viewed from a long
some of the old rock paintings, made 10- distance are indistinct and pale. This
20.000 years ago, reveal attempts at phenomenon is called aerial perspective.
producing an impression of depth, by the An artist draws objects nearest to the
suggestion of simple cast shadows. observer in sharp, heavy lines and bright
In schematic pictures and news colors. Sections of a painting that are
graphics a cast shadow behind individual intentionally made indistinct, without
picture elements, or behind two edges of the sharp outlines and in neutral colors, will
complete picture, may create feelings of appear as being located far away. They fade
three dimensions and depth. If this is done away into the distance. In photography the
correctly, the picture seems to be floating effect of aerial perspective appears strongly
above the page. However, cast shadows in backlighting.
may create confusion and they may actually Light tones appear to advance and dark
impair legibility and communication. In tones appear to recede. A light object
particular, it is confusing when the shadows against a dark background will normally
in a picture are of different sizes, implying stand forward, with a strong sense of depth.
a three-dimensionality and a perspective
8 (12)

This phenomenon is called tonal Multi-view Perspective


perspective. The pictures of young children, like many
In a color perspective, colors and hues of the paintings from ancient Egypt, India,
gradually change from being clear in the and pre-Renaissance European art depict
picture's foreground into being blurred in objects independently from their
its background. Warm-colored objects surroundings. The pictures show objects
appear closer to the viewer than cool- as they are known to be rather than as they
colored objects. A red or orange object are seen to be. Objects and figures are
against a green or blue background will shown in a multi-view perspective from all
have a sense of depth. the different views that best present their
In practice, it is difficult to distinguish most characteristic features. In many
b e t w e e n a e r i a l p e r s p e c t ive , t o n a l Egyptian paintings the head and legs of a
perspective, and color perspective. These person are shown in profile, while the eye
t h r e e p e r s p e c t ive s a r e s o c l o s e l y and torso are shown frontally. This system
interrelated that they may be regarded as produces a sense that objects and
different aspects of the same thing. surroundings have been compressed
When we take photographs of objects within a shallow space.
at a long distance, aerial, tonal, and color Up to the time when Modernism started
perspectives can be intensified by special to question its laws of construction, the
lenses and filters. realistic linear perspective was considered
the only correct type of perspective in
Geometrical Perspective Western art. At the end of the 19th century
The placement of objects within a picture Paul Cézanne flattened the conventional
is important in geometrical perspective. Renaissance central perspective. Inspired
This is common among traditional by Pablo Picasso, the cubists broke off
Japanese and Mayan artwork. Here, completely with the traditional conception
objects close to the viewer are shown in of space, and modern art became totally
the lower part of the picture. Objects that liberated from the time-honoured laws of
are further away from the viewer are perspective.
shown in the image above the near objects Today modern art, oriental art, and
in the lower part. Objects further away illustrations in children's books often use
may be placed on a vertical line, as steps multi-perspectives or multi-view
on a ladder. This kind of geometrical perspectives.
perspective is quite common in children’s
drawings. Value Perspective
The significance, the rank, the status, or
Conceptual Perspectives the value of a depicted object is evident
from the object’s size in a picture.
In art of more ancient date, and even in Geometrical and mathematical laws are
primitive art, there are many examples of set aside. In Egyptian traditional art, the
perspectives based on meaning, contents, gods are larger than Pharaoh, who in turn
value, and social status. A person’s is considerably larger than all his subjects.
cultural heritage is of great importance for In several Middle East countries today,
the perception of all conceptual the most important person in a group picture
perspectives. is larger in size than the other, less important
9 (12)

people. Leaders who happen to be short made individual interpretations of what


appear to be “big” leaders since they are the they saw, and represented these in their
largest in the group. This can be called value paintings.
perspective or social perspective. When we convey information, the
(Compare with linear perspective.) purpose is the opposite: to present facts as
Lester (1995) noted that (page 49): clearly and unambiguously as possible.
Modern examples of imaginary perspective
In a picture of a couple, the man’s are found in pictures created by means of
dominance over the woman often is spherical lenses.
signified by the man being nearer and
larger in the frame with his hand resting
Time Perspective
on or arm wrapped around the woman’s
shoulder. Over the past two decades, A “time-line” is a simple one-dimensional
feminist movement has made advertisers scale with markings for important events.
and others more sensitive to nonverbal, This is often used in graphics and
negative stereotypes such as these. schematic pictures to visualize the
relationships between different historical
Simultaneous Perspective events. Using a time-line makes it easier
In the European medieval simultaneous for the viewer to see the time perspective.
perspective, time is a spatial dimension in
paintings. Several manifestations of the Verbal-linguistic Perspectives
same character or person may be seen in
one picture. The concept “perspective” is also used
The interpretation of medieval images figuratively and in transferred senses:
are to a large degree determined by the verbal-linguistic perspectives. In a
icons, symbols, and allegories used. situational context, for example, we may
Several manuals with directions for say that someone “sees reality from a
understanding visual arts have been child's perspective” (viewpoint).
published. One very important example is We “ p u t a t h i n g i n i t s p r o p e r
“Iconologia”, written by Cesare Ripa at the perspective” (approach), and sometimes it
end of the sixteenth century, first published is important to be able to “view things in
in Rome 1993, and later published in different perspectives” (views), and “keep
several editions. This book was used as a the right perspective”. We create a mental
prime source for more than three hundred view of the relative importance of
years by experts when they interpreted relationships or aspects of a matter or
classical art. Art historians have learned, problem.
and know the language of art. This is,
however, not true for people in general.
They lack this necessary frame of reference.

Imaginary Perspective
During the Baroque era, a special
perspective was used in European
pictorial art and architecture for the
purpose of creating illusionistic effects –
the imaginary perspective. The artists
10 (12)

In Visual Communication. Images with


Producer/
Messages Lester (1995) emphasized six
publisher perspectives for analysing images in the
Supplier of Network media through which we see. These
hardware operator
perspectives are: personal, historical,
Electronic Producer/
technical, ethical, cultural, and critical.
Writer Publishing publisher

Aural Perspectives
Supplier of Library
software The ear is efficient in receiving and
Society localizing sound within our environment.
Our ears bring us a world of sound that has
depth and distance. Schwartz (1973) noted
Views. Depending on their frames of references, that any “soundscape” has three layers, or
different people can interpret the same
phenomenon in different ways. Pettersson (1993) planes, of acoustical information. There
demonstrated a number of approaches and views are foreground sounds, context sounds,
to the field of electronic publishing (here EP) with and background sounds.
the above illustration (page 34).
According to Wenzel (1992) people
The concept also applies to the manner have a natural ability to isolate sounds in
in which we survey an area, a field of relationship to their approximate positions;
interest. We may, for example, “get the behind, above, below, to the sides, or in
supply and demand of a product into front of the head.
perspective” (general view). In the Ferrington (1994) defined aural
programme for the “6th European perspective with respect to distant sounds,
Conference for Research on Learning and intimate sounds, and moving sounds.
Instruction” (EARLI, 1995) it is noted that Distant sounds are far away from us.
(page 20-21): Iintimate sounds are close-up. Moving
sounds move in juxtaposition to the
Symposia should provide an opportunity listener. Although sound is three
to examine specific problems or topics dimensional it is the sound generated by
from a variety of perspectives. moving objects, or the movement of the
... listener in relationship to a sound, that
Thus, individuals with diverse views can strengthens the perception of three
interact on a topic of sufficient scope and dimensionalality.
importance.

Critics throughout the history of art and A Conceptual Model


literature have used many methods to
analyse works created by others. Lodge There are several different types of
(1984) gave the following fourteen perspectives, several of them related to
examples of analytical perspectives: each other in various ways. When we try
allegorical, archetypal, biographical, to systematically group the different
Christian, ethical, existentialist, Freudian, meanings of the concept perspective as a
historical, Jungian, Marxist, mythical, hierarchy, it becomes evident that some
phenomenological, rhetorical, and perspective-concepts are missing in our
structural. daily verbal language. In the
hierarchically ordered list below I have
11 (12)

created some suggestions for new References


perception concepts. This is one of several Dondis, D. A. (1973). A Primer of Visual Li-
possible ways to organize the various teracy. Cambridge, MA: Massachusetts
perspectives. Institute of Technology.
As is evident from the hierarchy below, EARLI (1995). Programme 6th European
most perspectives are pictorial spatial Conference for Research on Learning and
Instruction. European Association for Re-
perspectives related to our perception of search on Learning and Instruction. Au-
depth. However, the term “perspective” gust 26 - 31. University of Nijmegen, De-
also carries other meanings, not related to partment of Educational Sciences.
depth. Conceptual perspectives are Holland.
visualisation of psychological and social, Ferrington, G. (1994). Keep your Ear-Lids
subjective values. Verbal-linguistic Open. Journal of Visual Literacy, 14,
perspectives are used figuratively and in 2, 51–61.
Freeman, M. (1988). Collins Photography
transferred senses. An aural perspective is
Workshop. The Image. London: William
an apparent spatial distribution in perceived Collins Sons & Ltd. .
sounds. Lester, P, M. (1995). Visual Communication.
Images with Messages. Belmont, CA:
Wadsworth Publishing Company. A Divi-
sion of International Thomson Publishing
Perspectives Inc.
Lodge, D. (1984). Small World. New York:
Pictorial perspectives
Warner Books.
Spatial perspectives
Realistic linear perspectives
One-point perspective
Two-point perspective
Bird's-eye perspective
Military perspective
Gentleman’s perspective
Eye-level perspective
Worm's-eye perspective
Parallel perspective
Reversed linear perspective
Intuitive perspectives
Overlapping perspective
Aerial perspective
Tonal perspective
Color perspective
Geometrical perspective
Conceptual perspectives
Multi-view perspective
Value perspective
Simultaneous perspective
Imaginary perspective
Time perspective
Verbal-linguistic perspectives
Aural perspectives
12 (12)

Longman (1990). The Longman Dictionary of


Contemporary English. Essex: Longman
Group UK Limited.
Ottenheimer Publishers Inc. (1991). The New
Websters Dictionary and Thesaurus. New
York, New York: Book Essentials, Inc.
Pettersson, R. (1993). Visual Information.
Englewood Cliffs, NJ: Educational
Technology Publications.
Schwartz, T. (1973). The responsive
chord. Garden City, New York:
Anchor Books.
Tulloch, S. (1995). The Oxford Dictionary
and Thesaurus. Oxford, Melbourne:
Oxford University Press.
Zimmer, A., & Zimmer, F. (1978). Visual
Literacy in Communication: Designing
for Development. Hulton Educational
Publications Ltd., in cooperation with the
International Institute for Adult Literacy
Methods, Teheran.
Wenzel, E. (1992). Launching sounds into
space. In L. Jacobson (Ed.) Cyberarts:
exploring art and technology. San
Francisco: Miller Freeman, Inc., pp.
87–92.

You might also like