Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Food As Medicine
Food As Medicine
MEDICINE
HOW FOOD AND
DIET IMPACT
THE TREATMENT
OF DISEASE
AND DISEASE
MANAGEMENT
Table of Contents
Acknowledgements
This report is the result of four years of research, literature review, meetings, and
iterations. It would not have been possible without the expertise and support of INTRODUCTION ......................................................................................................... 8
everyone who participated over these past years, including research assistants, Impact of Poor Diet on Health, Disease, and Health Care Costs ...............................9
consultants, and reviewers. Thank you to those who participated in and helped Food for Preventive Health, Disease Treatment & Public Health.............................10
with the many beginning attempts. We would especially like to thank early
readers of this report, including Judy Kern, Katrina Mateo, and Representative
Synthesizing the Evidence to Drive Change..............................................................12
Jim McGovern, and as well as our graphic designer Yvonne Chow. We also
appreciate all the efforts of all of our researchers, including Regan Elyse Murray, PART I
Giulia Panter, and Evan Watkins. FOOD AS MEDICINE: A BRIEF HISTORY................................................................ 16
Food as Medicine in Ancient Cultures .......................................................................19
Suggested Citation: Traditional Chinese Medicine............................................................................................19
Platkin, C., Cather, A., Butz, L., Garcia, I., Gallanter, M., Leung, MM.,
Food as Medicine in Ancient Greece ...............................................................................20
Food As Medicine: Overview and Report: How Food and Diet Impact the
Spotlight: Hippocrates and the Quote Representing of Food as Medicine ......................21
Treatment of Disease and Disease Management. Center for Food As Medicine
and Hunter College NYC Food Policy Center; March 30, 2022, available at Ayurvedic Medicine in India ..............................................................................................23
foodmedcenter.org and nycfoodpolicy.org. Food as Medicine in the New World (Western Hemisphere)..........................................29
Additional Cultures Practicing Food as Medicine ..........................................................30
Spotlight: Garlic Throughout History and Cultures ..........................................................32
Food as Medicine Resources and Research Guides Spotlight: Mushrooms as Medicine, from Ancient Times to Present Day ........................34
An Anthropological and Historical Lens into Food as Medicine .............................37
The Center for Food as Medicine (foodmedcenter.org) is a not-for-profit Food as Medicine in Modern Society .........................................................................39
organization working to uncover the mysteries and myths surrounding food, The HIV/AIDS Pandemic and the Rise of Medically-Tailored Meal Programs ..............39
nutrition, fitness and medicine with the goal of educating, engaging, inspiring and
creating a catalyst for meaningful change in personal and community health and Advancing Food as Medicine from a Policy and Practice Perspective ........................39
wellness. The Center combines journalism, scientific research and health literacy Distinct Dietary Patterns in the Blue Zones of Health ....................................................40
to synthesize complex health and medical information surrounding food and Spotlight: Interview with T. Colin Campbell ....................................................................44
disease, and translates this information to readers searching for reliable, Food as Medicine in Popular Culture .........................................................................48
scientific information. The Center was founded by Charles Platkin, PhD, JD, MPH Documentaries Bring Food as Medicine into Public Discourse....................................48
in 2021. Spotlight: Significant Food As Medicine Documentaries .................................................49
The Impact of Food as Medicine Online ..........................................................................50
The Hunter College New York City Food Policy Center (nycfoodpolicy.org)
develops intersectoral, innovative and evidence-based solutions to prevent Spotlight: Deciphering Health Information Online ............................................................52
diet-related diseases and promote food security in New York City and other Food as Medicine on Social Media...................................................................................56
urban centers. The Center works with policy makers, community organizations, Spotlight: What are Dietary Supplements? ......................................................................58
advocates and the public to create healthier, more sustainable food environments Rising Popularity of Plant-Based and Plant- Forward Diets ..........................................59
and to use food to promote community and economic development. Through Spotlight: NYC Mayor Eric Adams’ Reversal of Type 2 Diabetes Through Diet ..............60
interdisciplinary research, policy analysis, evaluation and education, we leverage Spotlight: Plant-Based Lifestyle Medicine Program,
the expertise and passion of the students, faculty and staff of Hunter College. NYC Health + Hospitals/Bellevue ....................................................................................62
The Center aims to make New York City a model for smart, fair food policy.
2 3
PART II Dietary Supplements, Nutraceuticals and Functional Foods ......................................134
FOOD AS MEDICINE CHALLENGES ...................................................................... 69 Dietary Supplements ........................................................................................................135
The Impact and Influences of the Dietary Guidelines ...............................................69 Spotlight: National Institutes of Health Office of Dietary Supplements
(NIH ODS) recommendations for taking dietary supplements .......................................136
The Dietary Guidelines for Americans .............................................................................69
Supplement Use Among Athletes .....................................................................................137
Spotlight: Dietary Guidelines for Americans 2020-2025 (USDA) .....................................72
Nutraceuticals ...................................................................................................................139
Spotlight: The “Cheeseburger Bill”...................................................................................74
Spotlight: Food for Specified Health Uses in Japan ......................................................142
Dietary Guidelines from the World Health Organization ................................................76
Functional Foods .............................................................................................................143
Dietary Guidelines Around the World ..............................................................................79
Additional Examples of Dietary Supplements,
Spotlight: Traffic Light Food Labeling ..............................................................................83 Nutraceuticals, and Functional Foods ..............................................................................144
An Attempt to Define the Terms “Healthy” and “Unhealthy” ..................................86 Regulation of Dietary Supplements, Nutraceuticals and Functional Foods ......................148
Spotlight: Healthy Eating Defined and Deconstructed ....................................................87 Medical Foods ..................................................................................................................152
Food Insecurity, Food Justice, and Health Equity ...................................................89 Food Interventions, Reimbursement, and Health Insurance..................................153
Food Insecurity and Food as Medicine Interventions ....................................................92 Conflicts of Interest: Health Insurance Companies and the Fast Food Industry.......154
Spotlight: New York City “Health Bucks” ..........................................................................95
Health Insurance Plans Adopting Food as Medicine Programs ..................................155
Nutrition Incentive Programs Increase Vegetable
and Fruit Consumption Improving Health Outcomes .........................................................96
Government Support for Food as Medicine.............................................................158
Supporting Access to Food Resources ..............................................................................99
Primary Care Physicians and Food ..........................................................................101 PART IV
How Marketing and Legalized Health Claims Obfuscate FOOD AS MEDICINE: TREATING AND MANAGING DISEASE ............................ 162
the Impact of Food on Disease ................................................................................103 Alzheimer’s .................................................................................................................162
Health Claims ...................................................................................................................103 Arthritis, Non-Rheumatoid.........................................................................................171
Spotlight: Qualified Health Claims .................................................................................104 Arthritis, Rheumatoid.................................................................................................174
Spotlight: Authorized Health Claims ..............................................................................105 Autism .........................................................................................................................175
Nutrient Content Claims ..................................................................................................106 Cancer .........................................................................................................................178
Structure/Function Claims ..............................................................................................106 Chronic Kidney Disease ............................................................................................181
Use of Unregulated and Misleading Health-Related Terms .........................................107 Cirrhosis and Ascites.................................................................................................183
“Healthy” Beverages .......................................................................................................110 Diabetes.......................................................................................................................184
Food Industry-Funded Research .............................................................................. 112 Inflammatory Bowel Diseases...................................................................................189
HIV/AIDS ......................................................................................................................192
PART III Hypertension (High Blood Pressure)........................................................................193
FOOD AS MEDICINE: INTERVENTIONS, Mental Health Conditions and Illnesses...................................................................196
PROGRAMS, POLICIES AND PRACTICES ........................................................... 118 Multiple Sclerosis .......................................................................................................200
Food as Medicine Interventions ............................................................................... 119 Sleep ............................................................................................................................201
Medically Tailored Meals (MTMs)....................................................................................119
Fruit and Vegetable Prescription Programs ..................................................................120 PART V
Identifying Targeted Patient Populations ..........................................................................124 RECOMMENDATIONS ........................................................................................... 206
Examples of Produce Prescription Programs Targeting Patients With Diet-Related Chronic
Diseases ..........................................................................................................................124
REFERENCES & METHODOLOGY ........................................................................ 213
Examples of Produce Prescription Programs Utilizing Various Eligibility Criteria ............125
Issuing Produce Prescriptions ..........................................................................................127 Methodology ...............................................................................................................214
Partners in Produce Prescription Programs .....................................................................128 References ..................................................................................................................215
Outcomes and Opportunities ............................................................................................129
Culinary Medicine ...........................................................................................................130
Culinary Medicine in Medical School ................................................................................132
Culinary Nutrition ..............................................................................................................134
4 5
Introduction
6 7
Impact of Poor Diet on Health, Disease, and
Health Care Costs
Introduction
There is overwhelming evidence These diet-related diseases consume a
demonstrating the impact of food and diet significant portion of medical costs. In 2017,
on health, specifically among food-related the total estimated cost of diagnosed diabetes
diseases.16,17,18,19,20 Whether or not a poor diet alone was $327 billion in medical costs and lost
can cause damage to the body should no productivity.37,38 Obesity costs the United States
longer be debated, as evidence supports the roughly $147 billion a year,39 and heart disease
potential causal relationships between dietary and stroke together cost the health care
factors and diet-related diseases such as system $214 billion per year and $138 billion in
ischemic heart disease, diabetes, and certain lost productivity in the workforce.40 Estimates
In July of 2021, famed chef Tom Colicchio Using food for prevention and treatment of cancers.21,22,23,24,25,26,27 For example, researchers project that chronic diseases will cost more
made a decision to open a healthy restaurant disease has a long history and documented reporting in the journal PLOS Medicine found than $47 trillion in lost output between the
in a children’s hospital. According to the efficacy.2,3 In fact, evidence indicates that that a “[s]uboptimal diet of 10 dietary factors years 2011 and 2030.41 Additionally there is a
Washington Post, “Root & Sprig, [is] a new sustained dietary changes can be as effective accounts for 18.2 percent of all ischemic heart significant socioeconomic disparity in health.42
fast-casual concept that aims to give patients, as pharmacological interventions in treating disease, stroke, and type 2 diabetes costs in Studies have shown that lower socioeconomic
families, doctors and other healthcare workers certain diseases, especially in the early stages the US.”28 The ten factors these researchers status has been linked to disproportionate
a better meal when they’re at a hospital, of the disease.4,5 In some instances, a long- studied were fruits, vegetables, nuts/seeds, access to adequate health care among a
whether working or recovering.”1 Colicchio’s term, specific diet may be more effective whole grains, red meat, sugar-sweetened variety of diseases.43 Individuals of lower
restaurant is one of the latest developments than medication at mitigating, stabilizing, and beverages, processed meat, polyunsaturated socioeconomic status have higher rates of
in the increasingly popular “food as medicine” reversing disease.6,7,8,9,10 Additionally, using fatty acids, seafood omega-3, and sodium.29 cardiovascular disease, hypertension, arthritis,
movement, a philosophy arguing that the food drug treatments in combination with a healthy Unbalanced consumption habits of the diabetes, and cancer.44 With this increased
we eat impacts our health by preventing and/ tailored diet may be more impactful than drugs aforementioned ten factors are estimated to rate of disease comes an increase in mortality,
or fighting disease. alone; there are a plethora of studies which cost Americans $50.4 billion in diet-related especially beginning at middle age.45
demonstrate the extensive health benefits of cardiometabolic disease expenses annually.30
There are a variety of key terms and phrases food as medicine and indicate that the focus Poor diet has also been linked to increased
used to describe and discuss food as should not be on diet or medicine alone, but There is also evidence showing that the morbidity and mortality across many diet-
medicine, including but not limited to: food is rather on diet and medicine.11,12,13,14 chemical structures and composition of food related diseases.46 According to the Global
medicine, culinary medicine, culinary nutrition, can have a significant impact on individual and Burden of Disease study published by the
medically tailored meals, medically tailored In an interview in the Harvard Health Policy population health - sugar, oils, saturated fats, Journal of the American Medical Association,
groceries, medically tailored food packages, Review about her research, Lisa Haushofer, pesticides, and processed foods are known poor diet is the number-one risk factor
food for health, nutritious food referrals, MD, PhD, a senior research associate at the to pose a wide variety of health risks and associated with morbidity and mortality in the
prescription fruit and vegetable programs, Institute for Biomedical Ethics and History of diseases.31 Further, the increasing availability United States.47 A comparative risk assessment
using food for disease management, and Medicine at the University of Zurich, discussed of ultra-processed foods coincides with the published in The Lancet looked at the global
community-level healthy food programs. There the boundaries between food and medicine, rise of obesity, chronic illness, and other diet- burden of disease across 195 countries and
are a variety of definitions and phrases to stating “one of the things I try to understand related diseases.32 According to data from the found that in the year 2017, 11 million deaths
describe the integration of food to prevent and in my research is how nutrition came to be so CDC in 2018, 42.8 percent of American adults and 255 million disability-adjusted life-years
or treat disease. marginalized in contemporary biomedicine and over 60, nearly 45 percent of adults aged 44- (DALYs) were attributable to dietary risk
how instead it was absorbed increasingly by a 59 years, and 40 percent of young adults (age factors.48 In fact, according to the researchers,
nutritional consumer industry.”15 20-39) are obese.33 Additionally, 60 percent of high intake of sodium accounted for 3 million
Americans have an underlying health condition: deaths and 70 million DALYs, low intake of
121.5 million adults have cardiovascular whole grains accounted for 3 million deaths
disease and over 34 million have diagnosed and 82 million DALYs, and low intake of fruits
type 2 diabetes. As of 2020, an additional 88 accounted for 2 million deaths and 65 million
million American adults have prediabetes.34,35,36 DALYs.49
8 Introduction Introduction 9
Food for Preventive Health, Disease Treatment prescriptions,126 as methods of achieving
improved health outcomes in patients with
Furthermore, various state governments have
begun investing in food-related movements to
& Public Health diet-related chronic diseases.127,128,129,130,131
For example, at NYU Langone’s Perlmutter
improve the social and economic conditions
that contribute to health.137 For example, New
While diet has the potential to cause disease, means of improving and equalizing health Cancer Center in New York City, cancer York State passed a bill in 2019 that requires
it is also capable of building, maintaining, care outcomes.62 Research conducted on patients are receiving individually-tailored hospitals to provide plant-based meals at no
and restoring health.,50,51,52,53 Unprocessed behalf of the American Heart Association nutritious meals to help them tackle loss of extra cost to patients.138 Jay Inslee, Governor
whole foods, for example, provide nutrients and published in August 2021 suggests that appetite.132 Addressing this issue is critical of Washington State, signed an executive
the body needs to prevent and combat achieving the packaged food and beverage as malnourishment from not eating can order in 2013 that requires state agencies
diseases and disorders that respond favorably sugar content targets set by the US National lead to greater complications during cancer provide “healthful food and beverages”
to nutritional intervention.54 A systematic Salt and Sugar Reduction Initiative in 2018 treatment.133 in cafeterias, vending machines, catered
review of existing research on U.S. dietary could prevent almost half a million deaths from meetings, and retail establishments.139 On the
patterns published in the the Journal of the cardiovascular disease and around 750,000 Additionally, related evidence is growing to federal level, the Agriculture Improvement Act
American Medical Association found evidence diabetes cases.63 These reductions in chronic support the impact of food-based government (known as the Farm Bill) includes support and
that nutrient-dense diets reduced patients’ disease would likely translate to a $160 billion policies to improve public health. Researchers funding for produce prescription programs
risk of dying from chronic disease. 55 The reduction in health care costs over a 28.33 from a study published in the journal Health by way of the Gus Schumacher Nutrition
review, which assessed one randomized trial year period.64 Achieving the targets is also Affairs found that patients dually eligible Incentive Program.140
and 152 observational studies, concluded anticipated to have the greatest impact on the for Medicare and Medicaid in a medically-
that diets rich in vegetables, fruits, lean health of individuals with lower income, as well tailored meal program had fewer emergency
proteins, nuts, legumes, and whole grains as Black and Hispanic Americans, helping to department visits and lower health-related
decreased mortality rates associated with reduce health disparities.65 costs.134 Covering healthy meals under
cardiovascular disease, obesity, diabetes, Medicare and Medicaid therefore could be
and some cancers.56 This decline in patient Diet may also provide a solution when disease an effective way to improve the health of
mortality was observed across the studies is present.66 In fact, food interventions are those enrolled. (Approximately 80 million
despite differences in approach and effectively being used to prevent, manage, individuals in the United States have health
assessment methods.57 treat, and co-treat, a variety of disease coverage through Medicaid and the Children’s
states (e.g. Alzheimer’s,67,68,69 arthritis,70,71 Health Insurance Program [CHIP] in 2021
Recent research has also suggested that autism,72,73,74,75,76 cancer,77,78 cardiovascular and approximately 61 million individuals have
even relatively small dietary adjustments can disease,79,80,81 celiac disease,82 chronic health coverage through Medicare.)135,136
help to reverse the increased mortality rates kidney disease,83,84 cirrhosis/ascites,85,86,87,88
attributable to food-related diseases.58,59 In Crohn’s,89,90,91 depression,92,93 diabetes,94,95
an August 2021 study published by Nature digestive disorders,96,97 eating disorders,98,99
Food, researchers reported that substituting epilepsy,100 food allergies/intolerances,101,102,103
10 percent of the beef and processed meats in gastroesophageal reflux disease,104,105,106 HIV/
patients’ diets for fruits, vegetables, legumes, AIDS,107,108 hypertension,109,110,111 multiple
nuts, and select seafood could increase sclerosis,112,113,114,115 osteoporosis,116,117,118,119
their lifespans by 48 minutes per person per overweight/obesity,120,121 and skin
day.60 Researchers arrived at this estimate diseases122,123,124). [Note: Treatment of disease,
by scoring foods according to 15 dietary risk using food, alone or in combination with
factors for chronic disease and translating other treatments, will be discussed in Part IV
these scores into an assessment of the net more extensively.]
minutes of healthy life gained or lost through
consuming them.61 Health care systems are increasingly
being encouraged to use food as medicine
Reductions to the amount of added sugar interventions, such as medically-tailored
in the American diet also show promise as meals125 and food (i.e., fruit and vegetable)
10 Introduction Introduction 11
Synthesizing the Evidence to Drive Change
For change to occur in our food and health The first section, “Part I: Food as Medicine - A
systems, and for food as medicine to be Brief History,” highlights how food as medicine
incorporated in our health care system was practiced across ancient cultures, and
and policies, diverse stakeholders must be its rise in popularity in modern society and
engaged, including farmers, chefs, physicians popular culture. The second section, “Part
and physician extenders, nutritionists, II: Food as Medicine Challenges,” discusses
policymakers, elected officials, government critical challenges in the food ecosystem
staffers, community based organizations, that limit the reach and impact of the food
public health advocates, academics, insurance as medicine movement. The third section,
companies, food companies, media, and “Part III: Food as Medicine - Interventions,
patients.141 However, meaningful progress Programs, Policies and Practices,” describes
towards impactful interventions and policies food as medicine interventions and
is limited by the accessibility of evidence- spotlights successful programs and policies
based information about the prevention and leveraging food as medicine philosophy.
treatment of disease using food and or a Lastly, the fourth section, “Part IV: Food as
combination of food and other treatments. Medicine - Treating and Managing Disease,”
summarizes the evidence of food as medicine
The focus of this report is to synthesize to treat and manage specific diseases and
existing scholarship on food as medicine conditions. This report concludes with a
into a single, interdisciplinary resource. This list of recommendations for readers who
report will serve as the basis for a shared currently are or aim to be advocates for and
understanding among scientists, medical key stakeholders in the food as medicine
professionals, policymakers, and other key movement.
stakeholders of how food can be used in the
management and treatment of chronic disease
and can lay the foundation for future study of
food as a therapeutic.
12 Introduction Introduction 13
Part I
Food as Medicine:
A Brief History
14 Introduction Introduction 15
PA RT I
Food as Medicine:
A Brief History
As early as 300 BCE, humans were cultivating a shift away from nutrition-based medicine
food crops for medicinal purposes.142 Since towards allopathic medicine.150 Allopathic
that time, food as medicine and food as medicine is defined by the National Cancer
preventive medicine remained an integral Institute as: “A system in which medical
component of many Eastern healing practices. doctors and other healthcare professionals
Practitioners advised people how to live so (such as nurses, pharmacists, and therapists)
that they would not become ill, although it treat symptoms and diseases using drugs,
was generally acknowledged that diet was radiation, or surgery. Also called biomedicine,
powerless against epidemic diseases.143,144 conventional medicine, mainstream medicine,
orthodox medicine, and Western medicine.”151
Western cultures, however, have slowly
broken away from using food as medicine.145 However, the use of food as medicine is
In the 18th and 19th centuries, scientific rooted in science and has been adopted and
investigation and innovation dominated practiced by numerous cultures despite the
Western understanding of medicine.146 fact that the history of food as medicine was
During that time, American medical education largely ignored by academics until the 21st
underwent notable advancements.147 In 1745, century.152,153,154 Now, largely because of its
the first formal course in human anatomy was increasing social media presence and online
established at the University of Pennsylvania, attention,155,156 academic study of the history
and in 1829, the first American textbook and use of food as medicine has begun to
on pathology was published.148,149 These gain momentum, finding its place in journals,
innovations, among others, ultimately inspired conferences, and programs of study.157,158,159,160
16 Part I Food as Medicine: A Brief History Part I Food as Medicine: A Brief History 17
Food as Medicine in Ancient Cultures
Many ancient cultures shared a holistic belief One of the main ways Chinese physicians
that disease was caused by the improper used herbs was to balance qi (CHē). A
flow of the body’s vital energies.161 Because fundamental concept in Chinese medicine,
ancient healers and physicians lacked qi refers to a vital life energy that circulates
much of the knowledge and technologies through people and their environment.175
we use in medical practice today, their According to practitioners of Traditional
treatments were often reliant on food.162,163 Chinese Medicine, qi flowed according to the
Most treatments used rituals, elixirs, herbs, complementary and opposed dynamics of
and dietary practices to eliminate blockages yin and yang. People’s health depended on
and restore balance to the body,164 while having the right balance of yin and yang so
the risks and dangers of emerging, curative that their qi would flow properly.176,177 Among
medicine were frequently as harmful the “Recipes for Nurturing Life” were dietary
as the illness itself (e.g., bloodletting, methods for people to achieve the proper
trepanation, tracheostomies).165,166,167 circulation of qi in their bodies.178 Foods were
categorized as promoting yin or yang and
prescribed to the sick to reset this balance
Traditional Chinese Medicine and eliminate disease. If patients showed
The use of food as medicine in China may symptoms of “greater yang disease,” for
date back as far as the Neolithic period, example, including trouble breathing, fever,
when people sacrificed ale and meat to their chills, and vomiting, they were prescribed a
ancestors in the hope of securing the spirits’ tea made with cinnamon, ginger, and various
protection from death and disease.168 By flowers, fruits, and spices.179 The cinnamon
was said to cure chills, and ginger calmed the
the Qin dynasty (221-206 BCE), dieticians
vomiting, while peony and licorice reset the yin
had emerged as one of the six categories
and boosted the body’s defenses against the
of Chinese physicians.169 Around this time,
Chinese shamans and physicians began to disease.180 When looking at this prescription
through a modern lens, it becomes clear why
record “Recipes For Nurturing Life” (Yang
it was used. Cinnamon has anti-inflammatory
sheng fang), which, according to Stanford
properties to treat fever,181 and studies have
University’s Encyclopedia of Philosophy,
shown ginger to be effective against nausea.182
“consists of eighty-seven recipes, including
In addition, both peony root and licorice have
food, drugs, and beverages, along with several
antioxidant properties.183,184,185
sexual cultivation exercises.”170,171 Alongside
the standard information on symptoms,
diagnostics, and treatments, Chinese medical
textbooks contained botanical field guides that
gave extensive information about medicinal
herbs.172 Certain principles of Traditional
Chinese Medicine are evident in many
current views concerning diet and disease
among Chinese people today,173 such as the
importance of a consistent, balanced diet
composed of grains, vegetables, and fruit.174
18 Part I Food as Medicine: A Brief History Part I Food as Medicine: A Brief History 19
In addition to using food to treat individual angina pectoris,194 endometriosis,195 high
patients, Traditional Chinese Medicine turned cholesterol,196 irritable bowel syndrome,197
food into a tool for improving public health. menstrual cramps,198 and more. However, Spotlight: Hippocrates and the Quote
When an epidemic swept through China
during the Song dynasty (960-1279 CE) and
almost 50 percent of Traditional Chinese
Medicine reviews in the Cochrane Database
Representing of Food as Medicine
had a particularly devastating impact on its were conducted without the involvement of
poor,186 Emperor Huizong (1082-1135 CE) a Traditional Chinese Medicine practitioner, It is important to note that Ancient Greek physicians, including Hippocrates, did not
responded by creating “Peace and Relief the inclusion of whom likely would have confuse food and medicine.211 Rather, food and diet were understood to contribute to a
Hospitals” in rural provinces.187 Each hospital improved the researchers’ understanding person’s health, and the importance of nutritional intervention was well established.212
had a kitchen and a pharmacy and treated of how practitioners determine individual Hippocrates is also often credited with the following impactful quote: “Let food be thy
patients with easy-to-consume prescriptions treatment plans.199 Additionally, the authors medicine and medicine be thy food,” which is perhaps the most well-known quote
created from medicinal foods.188 The noted that the reviews related to Traditional attributed to the food as medicine movement.213,214,215 While Hippocrates was a pioneer
success of these treatments prompted many Chinese Medicine “were not up-to-date in developing evidence-based medicine (which included studying the effect of diet on
physicians to found private pharmacies,189 according to Cochrane criteria, some health),216 according to Diana Cárdenas, MD, PhD, associate editor of the journal Clinical
and as the number of pharmacies grew reviews pooled the results of different herbal Nutrition ESPEN and professor in the faculty of medicine at the Universidad El Bosque,
Colombia, there is no evidence that Hippocrates made this statement.217,218
and the techniques they used to create medicines and ignored the searching of
medicine became more precise, food-based Chinese databases.”200
“[Hippocrates’] work was compiled either directly or indirectly through his disciples, so
prescriptions grew to be among the most that the existing knowledge on Hippocrates’ medicine consists of more than 60 texts
accessible and well-regarded forms of treating While there have been a plethora of clinical known as The Hippocratic Corpus (Corpus Hippocraticum). This important text in the
disease and solving public health crises in studies of the effectiveness of various history of medicine expounds on the theory of diet.”219,220,221 In these texts, disease is
premodern China.190 Traditional Chinese Medicine practices, there attributed to natural causes, physiological imbalances, and poor diet.222
is a lack of good quality evidence with high
Traditional Chinese Medicine is still practiced credibility.201,202 Since Traditional Chinese While Dr. Cárdenas believes the statement has had tremendous impact, she argues “the
extensively today, and the National Institutes Medicine is so popular today in China and phrase ‘let food be thy medicine and medicine be thy food,’ a widespread phrase quoted
of Health’s National Center for Complementary beyond, effective integration of its therapeutic by today’s scientists, is nowhere to be seen [in the 60 medical texts know as Hippocratic
and Integrative Health (NCCIH) keeps practices with evidence-based medicine could Corpus (Corpus Hippocraticum)]. This literary creation is not only a misquotation but it
information about the safety of various help patients find the most effective treatment also leads to an essential misconception: in the Hippocratic medicine, even if food was
remedies available for people interested plan for their lives and conditions.203 closely linked to health and disease, the concept of food was not confused with that of
medicine.”223 Dietary intervention was considered one of the most important medical
in using this method of addressing health
interventions that Hippocratic physicians could use to treat disease, but it was separate
problems.191 Worldwide, an estimated 1.5
Food as Medicine in from medicine and surgical procedures.224
billion people use Chinese herbal medicine
today, and the value of the Traditional Chinese Ancient Greece Nevertheless the quotation has appeared in numerous scholarly publications225 and
Medicine industry is estimated to be about according to Dr. Cárdenas in the quote has been used:
The Greek physician Hippocrates (460-
a third of the total pharmaceutical industry
375BCE)204 and the physician and philosopher
in China.192 Furthermore, according to the • To explore the association between diet and health
Galen (129-216 CE)205 are often described
WHO’s 2019 Global Report on Traditional • To highlight the medicinal properties of foods
as the forefathers of modern Western • To emphasize the skeptical attitude of doctors towards nutrition
and Complementary Medicine, 100 member
medicine.206,207 There is little known about the • To emphasize the antiquity of the “widely accepted for generations philosophy of
states formally acknowledged that Traditional
life of Hippocrates beyond his status as one medicinal power of foods”
Chinese Medicine was used by people in
of the first medical researchers to attribute the • To highlight the lack of nutrition care in hospitals226
their country.193
body’s health to diet and medicine rather than
divinity and the gods.208,209 There are about 60 While the quote “Let food be thy medicine and medicine be thy food,” may not have been
The Cochrane Database of Systematic
surviving medical texts that bear his name, but directly mentioned in Hippocrates’ 60 medical texts, there is the possibility that it was
Reviews has compiled research on Traditional
scholars think that most of these works were stated rather than written, nevertheless, the impact and meaning has been far reaching.
Chinese Medicine treatments for numerous
not actually written by him.210 Hundreds of
diseases and conditions, and has found
years after Hippocrates came Galen, a Greek-
evidence that it might be effective in treating
born expatriate living in Rome who
20 Part I Food as Medicine: A Brief History Part I Food as Medicine: A Brief History 21
served as physician to the Roman emperor Ancient Greek medicine has left a lasting
Marcus Aurelius.227 Galen’s works, which were legacy: physicians and health care
built upon those of Hippocrates, supported professionals still must follow the principles of
physiological experimentation and a thorough the Hippocratic Oath248 and the caduceus (a
understanding of anatomy.228 rod with two intertwined snakes that was the
symbol of the Greek god Hermes) has become
Hippocrates considered bodily factors known a symbol for modern medicine.249 English
as “humors” in his treatment of patients.229 speakers still use humoral
The humors are four fluids—phlegm, blood, words like “melancholic”
yellow bile, and black bile—that, according (black bile) and “sanguine”
to Hippocrates, needed to be kept in balance (blood) to describe people
in order to maintain health.230 For example, of different temperaments
an excess of black bile was thought to cause and characteristics.250,251
cancer.231 Humoral theory remained popular
well into the Elizabethan era of England and
beyond.232,233,234,235,236 Shakespeare used Ayurvedic Medicine in India
humoral theory in some of his plays, including Ayurveda is an ancient form of medicine that
The Taming of the Shrew237 and The Merchant has been practiced in India for more than
of Venice.238 The balance (or imbalance)
3,000 years.252 According to the National
of the four humors was said to influence Institutes of Health’s National Center for
people’s dispositions and characteristics,239 Complementary and Integrative Health
and the attitudes of different characters in
(NCCIH) overview of Ayurvedic medicine:
Shakespeare’s plays were frequently attributed
to their humors.240,241 Only once people began The ancient Indian medical system,
to understand bacteria and viruses as major also known as Ayurveda, is based on
causes of disease did humoral medicine fall ancient writings that rely on a ‘natural’ and
out of favor in the West.242 holistic approach to physical and mental
health. Ayurvedic medicine is one of the
Dietetics was largely viewed as synonymous world’s oldest medical systems and is
with internal medicine in ancient Greek still practiced today. Ayurvedic treatment
medical practice.243 It is important to note that combines products that are mainly derived
to many ancient Greek scholars of medicine, from plants but may also include animal,
the phrase diaita (roughly translated to metal, and mineral, along with diet,
“dietetics”) refers to food, drink, and physical exercise, and lifestyle.253
exercise.244 In some cases, diaita also
The NCCIH also describes a few well
encompasses bathing and sexual activity.245
designed studies and systematic research
In one of the Hippocratic texts, On Diet,
reviews demonstrating the effectiveness of
dietetics is seen as directly influencing the
Ayurvedic Medicine for conditions including
body’s internal temperature and moisture
knee osteoarthritis,254 rheumatoid arthritis,255,256
balance.246 Certain foods were written about in
Hippocrates’s body of work as being heating, type 2 diabetes,257 and ulcerative colitis.258
[See Ayurvedic Medicine - Systematic
cooling, drying, or moistening. For example,
Reviews/Reviews/Meta-analyses (PubMed)
if a Greek physician determined that a patient
and Ayurvedic Medicine - Randomized
needed to “cool down,” he might prescribe a
Controlled Trials (PubMed)]
regimen of specific “foodstuffs” and types of
exercise to achieve this effect.247
22 Part I Food as Medicine: A Brief History Part I Food as Medicine: A Brief History 23
Ayurvedic practice has roots in two ancient Ayurvedic practitioners use food to impact
Hindu schools of thought: Vaisheshika, the health of the mind and the body,259 and
a school of philosophy, and Nyaya, a recognize the different effects of various
school of logic.283 Vaisheshika describes foods.260 Foods are classified as satvika
the observations that must be made about (promoting thought and intelligence), rajsika
a patient’s condition, and Nyaya teaches (good for physical labor), or tamasika
that practitioners of medicine should have (encouraging laziness).261 Practitioners
extensive knowledge of a disease before prescribe foods and diets based on their
treating a patient.284 The healing practices patients’ individual doshas,262 occupations,263
taught by these Hindu schools of thought were and pre-existing medical conditions.264 The
later compiled into two texts, the Charaka goal of Ayurvedic dietary practices is to
Samhita and the Sushruta Samhita,285 which ensure a well-rounded diet that “contains
are most frequently referred to by historians different types of foods in such quantities
when studying Ayurvedic theory.286 and proportions that the need of the body is
adequately met,” wrote Das Banamali, a writer
Ayurvedic practitioners attribute the body’s and researcher, in the Journal of Homeopathy
basic physiological functions to three doshas & Ayurvedic Medicine.265 It is important for
or energies (sometimes spelled dosa287): Vata, practitioners to remember, however, that
Pitta, and Kapha.288 These doshas regulate body needs vary from person-to-person;
different aspects of the human body: there is no one-size-fits-all approach to an
Ayurvedic diet.266,267
Vata dosha maintains the cellular transport,
electrolyte balance, elimination of waste In rural India, about 70 percent of the
products and its effect is increased by population still relies on Ayurvedic
dryness. Pitta dosha regulates body medicine,268,269 and the NCCIH estimates
temperature, optic nerve coordination that about 240,000 American adults also use
and hunger and thirst management. Heat
Ayurvedic medicine.270 There is, however,
conditions of the body aggravate Pitta.
some concern that with the popularity of
Kapha dosha is increased due to sweet
and fatty food and it provides lubrication to Ayurveda has come a deterioration in the
the joints for proper functioning.289 standards of education for its practitioners.271
In a study looking at knowledge and attitudes
Practitioners believe that disequilibrium of the towards Ayurvedic medicine use among
doshas leads to poor health and disease.290 In allopathic resident doctors, researchers
addition to the doshas, Ayurvedic practitioners found that:
consider the body’s seven dhatus, or tissues—
Rasa (tissue fluids), Meda (fat and connective [a]llopathic residents had little knowledge
about basic concepts of Ayurveda, that
tissue), Rakta (blood), Asthi (bones), Majja
is, ‘panchakarma’ and ‘tridosha.’ Majority
(marrow), Mamsa (muscle) and Shukra
residents (99 percent) had no opportunity
(semen)—and the three malas, or wastes— to learn the basics of Ayurveda, but 67
Purisha (feces), Mutra (urine) and Sweda percent residents prescribed Ayurvedic
(sweat).291 These three constituents (dosha, medicines to patients. However, many
dhatu, and mala) are said to be largely formed residents (76 percent) mentioned that
by nutrition and diet.292 Finally, each patient cross practice should not be allowed due
falls into a different genetically-determined to lack of knowledge.272
prakriti category, which helps the Ayurvedic
practitioner determine a patient’s susceptibility In 2014, the Government of India established
to particular diseases and conditions.293 the Ministry of Ayush to oversee the
24 Part I Food as Medicine: A Brief History Part I Food as Medicine: A Brief History 25
development of traditional medical practices We need to interpret logic of Ayurveda
in India, including Ayurveda.273 Within this when, adopting modern science tools
Ministry is the National Institute of Ayurveda, in drug development and validation and
committed to improving the quality of Ayurveda much research is required. Validation
education and training.274 of Ayurvedic medicines using the latter
approach may lead to an evidence based
Ayurveda – Modern Medicine interface.
Research suggests that Ayurveda might
Also, in pursuit of finding better treatment
have the potential to treat numerous chronic
solutions, we ought to step beyond the
illnesses, including cancer, diabetes, and realm of only drugs and attempt validation
asthma.275,276,277 However, the NCCIH’s in- of comprehensive specific treatment
depth overview on Ayurvedic medicine, package as per classical Ayurveda. Finally,
concluded the following with regards to its validation of a combined (Ayurveda and
effectiveness: “A few studies suggest that modern medicine) therapeutic approach
Ayurvedic preparations may reduce pain and with superior efficacy and safety is
increase function in people with osteoarthritis likely to be a major leap in overcoming
and help manage symptoms in people with some of the current frustrations to treat
type 2 diabetes, but most of these trials are difficult disorders like arthritis using only
small or not well-designed. There is little modern medicines.282
scientific evidence on Ayurveda’s value for
other health issues.”278 Researchers have
noted that in order to better serve the needs
of patients, modern healthcare providers and
Ayurvedic practitioners must find ways to
integrate their treatment models and clinical
drug trials.279,280,281 Arvind Chopra, MD, a
physician at the Arthritis Research and Care
Foundation Center for Rheumatic Diseases,
has been an advocate for integrating
Ayurvedic treatment and Western medicine.
According to Dr. Chopra:
26 Part I Food as Medicine: A Brief History Part I Food as Medicine: A Brief History 27
Food as Medicine in the New lead much more sedentary lives.294 American
World (Western Hemisphere) settlers have pushed the native people off
their lands, leaving them with little choice but
Various Native American tribes have also to adopt a Westernized way of life, including
practiced food as medicine from ancient higher-fat diets and less physical labor.295
times until today.306,307 Medicinal food and According to social science writer Malcolm
beverage plants were gathered and utilized by Gladwell, writing for The New Yorker in 1998,
indigenous populations of eastern Canada to the high rates of diet-related disease among
treat numerous physical ailments,308 including the Pima have led to a sense of resignation,
gastrointestinal issues and musculoskeletal “that nothing can be done, that the way things
disorders.309 Salal, a shrub native to the Pacific are is the way things have to be.”296
Northwest, is used by Native American people
near the Puget Sound to treat heartburn, fever, Food as medicine principles were also
sinus inflammation, and more.310,311,312 Many of practiced by the native peoples of the region
the medicinal plants used by Native American, now known as Latin America. For example,
Native Hawaiian, and Alaska Native tribes many of the ancient Mesoamerican people
have also been documented by the National of Mexico used chile peppers from the genus
Library of Medicine, such as yucca, purple Capsicum for a variety of purposes, including
coneflower, and dandelion.313 as medicine.297 The Maya peoples in particular
used the fruits, leaves, seeds, and even roots
A number of traditional Native diets are of the Capiscum to treat numerous ailments,
largely plant-based and have been found to including respiratory problems, gastrointestinal
help fight the chronic diet-related diseases issues, earaches, and sores.298 Researchers
that are prevalent in indigenous communities have also found Capsicum to have
today, such as obesity and type 2 diabetes.314 antimicrobial properties that can be used to
Native American diets consisted of corn, bean, fight off bacterial diseases such as tetanus.299
squash, root crops, native berries, wild rice,
fruits, nuts, seeds, and game—diets that are Medicinal plants, used extensively by many of
presently considered balanced and composed these cultures, are still relied upon by many
of whole foods.315,316 communities in Latin America and demonstrate
potential to be used in modern medicinal
Of note, however, the Westernization of many treatments.300,301 One such example is yac”n,
Native American diets and lifestyles has been a perennial flower with tuberous roots,
associated with the increase in diet-related traditionally grown in the Andes.302 Nearly all of
diseases that are prevalent among these the plant is used in both the culinary traditions
populations.317,318 Perhaps the most striking of the region and the medicinal practice – the
example of this is among the Pima people plant is regarded by many as a functional
of central Arizona, who have historically had food.303 It is reported to prevent fatigue and
one of the highest rates of obesity and type cramps, relieve constipation, lower high blood
2 diabetes in the world.319,320,321,322 During pressure, and more.304
the twentieth century, the Pima lifestyle
changed from primarily hunting and gathering Animal products and foods have also had
nutrient-dense foods to subsisting on high-fat a long history of use in traditional medicine
processed foods provided by the United States practices of Latin America; at least 584 animal
government.323 Furthermore, the Pima of species have been recorded as used in
Arizona used to work the land but today traditional medicine.305 These species
28 Part I Food as Medicine: A Brief History Part I Food as Medicine: A Brief History 29
range from reptiles to shellfish, insects to wild Additional Cultures Practicing
birds.324 According to researchers Rômulo Food as Medicine
Alves and Humberto Alves writing in the
Journal of Ethnobiology and Ethnomedicine: Similar to China and India, some parts of
the Mediterranean, as well as many Islamic
Hard parts, such as teeth, nails, shells, countries, still practice a form of ancient
rattles from snakes, fish scales, bone medicine known as Arab-Islamic herbal
and cartilage generally are sun-dried, medicine or Traditional Arabic and Islamic
grated and crushed to powder, being then Medicine, which is descended from Greco-
administered as tea or taken during meals, Arab and Islamic medical practices.333 Having
while fat, body secretion and oil are either inspired early European medical education,334
ingested or used as an ointment.325
these practices are used today to treat
diseases such as cancer,335 diabetes,336 and
The significance of medicinal plants in
liver disease.337,338 While there is very little
Latin America has led to a clear trend
information reported on early Greco-Arab and
within the West of people seeking “exotic”
Islamic medicine, there are a few sources
remedies.326 Traditional foods, such as
which demonstrate the use of diet as the first
açai and Peruvian root maca, are regularly
line of defense against disease; only if food
marketed as “superfoods” that come from a
did not work would a physician turn to drugs.339
primitive “nutritional utopia,” write researchers
According to Dr. Bashar Saad, professor of cell
Jessica Loyer and Christine Knight in Food,
biology and immunology at the Arab American
Culture & Society.327 This “superfood” label
University in Jenin, Palestine, the modern use
is problematic for a variety of reasons
of Arab-Islamic medicine still relies on the use
(superfoods are discussed in further detail in
of medicinal plants and herbal remedies, many
Part II),328 not the least of which due to the
of which have been used in the development
“commodity racism” they promote. Loyer and
of modern pharmaceuticals.340
Knight write that these primitive superfoods
“reinforc[e] neocolonial social relations by
The Yoruba people of western Africa also have
temporally distancing ‘primitive’ producers
a history of traditional herbal medicine that
from modern Western consumers.”329
has left an impact on their medicinal practices
An example of this can be found in quinoa,
today.341 The majority of rural Nigerians, for
a grain native to the Andean region of South
example, rely on traditional healers for their
America.330 The crop has been used by the
health care needs due to a lack of Western-
native peoples of the Andes as both food and
trained healthcare professionals in the
medicine for thousands of years, but since the
country.342 Yorubic medicine uses a variety of
late nineties it has been used to create various
medicinal plants and herbs native to western
nutraceuticals and functional food products
Africa, and herbalists are considered among
sold across the globe.331 The marketing of
the specialists in the traditional medicine
quinoa often relies on its history and status
discipline.343,344 Many of these herbs have
as an “ancient grain,” but companies selling
been used to develop modern medicinal
quinoa often obfuscate the “social, economic,
treatments for disease.345
and ecological complexities surrounding the
quinoa industries in Peru and Bolivia.”332
30 Part I Food as Medicine: A Brief History Part I Food as Medicine: A Brief History 31
Spotlight: Garlic Throughout History and Studies have also shown that garlic has antimicrobial effects against bacteria, fungi,
Cultures and parasites.370,371,372,373 These antimicrobial properties led to the use of garlic as a mild
antibiotic in the mid-nineteenth century, and as an antiseptic during World Wars I and
II.374 Finally, it has been used as a treatment for various bacterial diseases throughout
Garlic has been used for its medicinal properties by numerous cultures throughout history, including typhus, cholera, diphtheria, and tuberculosis.375
history.346 Native to Central Asia, it is an integral component of Traditional Chinese
Medicine,347 Ayurveda348 and other traditional forms of medicine around the globe. The Consumption of garlic and other allium vegetables (e.g., onions, leeks, chives) have
ancient people of Sumer used garlic for its healing attributes,349 while ancient Egyptians been linked to decreased risk of stomach and colon cancer.376 The organosulfur
used it to stimulate laborers and slaves.350 In ancient India, it was used to cure a variety compounds, in addition to potentially being antiviral,377,378 are known to give it anti-tumor
of ailments, including hemorrhoids, cough, skin diseases and general weakness.351 properties; some of these compounds can suppress tumor development and slow down
Richard S. Rivlin, MD, writing in the Journal of Nutriton’s “Recent Advances on the the growth of tumors.379
Nutritional Benefits Accompanying the Use of Garlic as a Supplement,” said of garlic
that “cultures that never came into contact with one another came to many of the same Incorporating garlic into everyday foods is incredibly easy, as it can be added to nearly
conclusions about the role of garlic in the treatment of disease.”352 any savory dish to add aroma and flavor. For the best effects, crush or cut garlic before
cooking, which releases the allicin.380 Furthermore, overcooking garlic can destroy the
Among the earliest recorded uses of garlic as medicine is in the ancient Egyptian Codex enzyme that activates its disease-fighting compounds, so garlic should always be added
Ebers, a medical papyrus from 1550 BCE.353 The Egyptians were accomplished healers toward the end of the cooking process.381
and were familiar with many medicinal plants, but garlic was the one used most often.354
In the Codex Ebers, it is mentioned as a therapeutic remedy for headaches, bites, and
tumors.355 Artistic renderings of garlic have been found in ancient Egyptian tombs that
date as far back as 3700 BCE, indicating the plant’s importance in Egyptian culture.356
From Egypt, garlic as a medicinal food made its way to ancient Greece, Rome, Israel
and beyond.357
What properties does garlic have that makes it so popular as a remedy? Michael Netzel,
PhD, a senior research fellow in the Centre for Nutrition and Food Sciences at the
University of Queensland, wrote of it in a 2020 article from the peer-reviewed journal
Foods:
However, Netzel notes that few of the reported features of garlic have been fully studied
in humans, and more research is needed to understand its potential as a nutraceutical or
functional food.359
32 Part I Food as Medicine: A Brief History Part I Food as Medicine: A Brief History 33
Spotlight: Mushrooms as Medicine, from Many of the bioactive compounds found in certain edible mushrooms have been
Ancient Times to Present Day associated with lowered risks for anxiety and depression among adults.392,393 One
mushroom in particular, Hericium erinaceus (known colloquially as lion’s mane), has
been associated with improved sleep quality and overall mood.394,395
The terms used in the marketing of mushrooms, however, are not always accurate.396
“Wild mushrooms,” for example, is an unregulated phrase, so products marketed as
containing “wild mushrooms” do not always contain the wild mushrooms, such as
porcinis and truffles that consumers may expect.397 A 2021 study of food products using
the label “wild mushrooms” found that cultivated mushrooms, such as shiitake and
portobello, are frequently passed off as “wild.”398 Furthermore, a few food products were
found to contain mushrooms that were potentially toxic.399
Mushrooms are also known for the psychedelic properties of certain species, a use
that is receiving renewed interest.400 The state of Oregon was the first to legalize the
use of psilocybin-containing mushrooms (colloquially known as “magic mushrooms”)
for therapeutic purposes in 2020.401 This move was the culmination of mounting media
attention paid to psilocybin and “magic mushrooms,” including from notable food writer
Michael Pollan.402,403 From a historical perspective, decriminalizing (and even legalizing)
psilocybin is unsurprising to many, as it has been used by cultures around the world
since ancient times to heal.404
Studies have shown that psychedelic therapies using psilocybin might have potential to
treat psychiatric distress and addiction.405 The Johns Hopkins Center for Psychedelic
and Consciousness Research at Johns Hopkins University has done extensive research
into the medicinal potential of psilocybin.406,407 Researchers from this center have found
psilocybin to be an effective tool in treating major depressive disorder,408 alcohol use
disorder,409 and anxiety in cancer patients.410 Furthermore, it has been found to facilitate
smoking cessation.411 It should be noted that in these studies, psilocybin was used
Mushrooms have been used as medicine for millennia, and their use is seeing renewed as a part of a structured therapy regimen, including preparation and monitoring by a
interest in recent years.382,383 However, “[u]sing these medicines require[s] both a healthcare professional.412
working knowledge of toxic versus safe mushrooms and the ability to physiologically
respond to the chemicals they produce,” write researchers Paul Stamets, DSc and
Heather Zwickey, PhD in the scientific journal Integrative Medicine.384 Some mushrooms
can heal, some can kill, and some can just be dinner; this diverse range of potential
applications of mushrooms can make them particularly fascinating to study.385
Mushrooms are a good low-fat source of protein, dietary fiber, vitamin C, and B
vitamins.386 They also supply a good source of selenium,387 which is needed for proper
functioning of the thyroid gland.388 In addition, research suggests that selenium may
reduce the risk of lung, liver and prostate cancers.389
34 Part I Food as Medicine: A Brief History Part I Food as Medicine: A Brief History 35
An Anthropological and Historical Lens into
Food as Medicine
In a Journal of the History of Medicine and An example of the second way is the work of
Allied Sciences special issue, historians anthropologist and ethnopharmacologist Nina
and researchers Juliana Adelman, PhD and Etkin. In her book Edible Medicines, she states
Lisa Haushofer, MD, PhD explored food as that “until the recent and rapidly escalating
medicine in relation to cultural norms and interest in functional foods and supplements...,
science.413 The connection between food foods were regarded as virtually chemically
and medicine can often be categorized in inert, thus of no salience to disease
one of two ways.414 One approach is based processes.” These two approaches to food as
on how food and medicine developed medicine are not mutually exclusive, of course;
into distinct cultural practices, with fluid in fact, many accounts combine nostalgia for
boundaries between the two, as is evident the past with enthusiasm for current nutritional
in Chinese, Ancient Greek, and Ayurvedic science. The continued appearance of the
medicine.415,416,417 The other focuses on famous misquotation falsely attributed to
recent scientific advances and how they Hippocrates, “Let thy food be thy medicine, let
have increased awareness of the medicinal thy medicine be thy food,” in current works on
potential of various foods.418 Adelman and medicinal foods… illustrates the desire to view
Haushofer write: recent nutritional science as a confirmation of
past wisdom, and past dietetic practices as
Nancy Chen’s Food, Medicine, and the intuitive anticipations of modern knowledge.419
Quest for Good Health is a good example
of the first way. Chen combined a historical One suggested reason for the dichotomy
and anthropological perspective on the between food and medicine is power
development of eating and medicating as dynamics, the intentional separation of
distinct cultural practices. While the book medicine from food and agriculture in order
emphasizes the ways in which food and to fit notions of the superiority of “civilized”
dietary prescriptions are shaped by culture, as opposed to non-civilized intelligence.420
it also at times upholds a false dichotomy of Historians analyze food and medicine by
science and culture. Science and medicine exploring the balance of power between the
are seen as impacts on the cultural practices two—the “professional” versus “layperson,”
of eating, but the development of nutritional “theoretical” versus “tacit” knowledge,
knowledge and scientifically informed dietary and “experimental” versus “experiential”
prescriptions are of course inseparable from knowledge.421
particular or historically specific cultural forces.
Through a historical survey of dietetic ideas
in Ancient Greek, Chinese and Ayurvedic
medicine, Chen argues that the boundary
between science and medicine used to be
much less blurred than it is at present. She
adds that “[w]e may have something to learn
from cultures that blur the boundaries between
these categories.”
36 Part I Food as Medicine: A Brief History Part I Food as Medicine: A Brief History 37
Food as Medicine in Modern Society
The HIV/AIDS Pandemic and is Dean Ornish, MD, who helped popularize
the Rise of Medically-Tailored the idea that you can treat and even reverse
disease—particularly cardiovascular disease—
Meal Programs
by eating a diet rich in whole foods, among
Additional interest in and advancement of other lifestyle changes.430,431 He founded the
food’s impact on disease occurred during the Preventive Medicine Research Institute in
HIV/AIDS pandemic of the 1980s and 1990s, 1984 with the mission of researching how
which led to the emergence of numerous lifestyle medicine, including diet, can reverse,
nonprofit organizations that used food to help treat and prevent chronic diseases,432 and
people living with HIV/AIDS, including Project since the 1990s has published numerous
Open Hand in San Francisco (founded in articles in medical journals.433,434,435,436 The
1985),422 God’s Love We Deliver in New York Preventive Medicine Research Institute has
City (founded in 1986),423 and Community performed numerous trials and studies on
Servings in Boston (founded in 1990).424 the effect different food programs can have
These organizations were among the first to in managing diet-related diseases, including
provide medically tailored meals to individuals heart disease437,438 and prostate cancer439
managing disease and have yielded positive among others. Currently, the Preventive
results with improved HIV health.425 Medicine Research Institute is conducting
a trial to determine the effect of lifestyle
In 1990, the United States Congress passed changes (including diet) on the progression of
the Ryan White Comprehensive AIDS Alzheimer’s disease.440
Resources Emergency (CARE) Act, creating
the Ryan White HIV/AIDS Program.426 This In 1995, another notable physician, Caldwell
program funds grants to state and local Esselstyn, MD, published a benchmark,
governments as well as community-based longitudinal nutritional study in the Journal
organizations to provide services (including of Family Practice demonstrating that a
medically-tailored meals) to people managing nutritious, low-fat diet could halt and even
HIV or AIDS.427 This program has been reverse coronary artery disease in severely
described as a “model” of food and nutrition ill patients.441 Throughout Esselstyn’s career,
services for people living with chronic he published numerous studies on the
illness428 that policymakers and healthcare impact of plant-based nutrition on diet-related
professionals can look to when designing and chronic diseases such as coronary artery
implementing nutrition-focused health care disease,442,443,444 hypertension,445 diabetes,446
intervention plans.429 and retinopathy.447 His work has influenced
some notable politicians, including former
President Bill Clinton448,449 and New York City
Advancing Food as Medicine from Mayor Eric Adams.450
a Policy and Practice Perspective
There are many examples of other modern-
In the 1980s, physicians and researchers
day physician researchers, politicians, and
began paying more attention to the
advocates who have continued to build and
relationship between nutrition and physical
expand on this work examining the
health. Among these healthcare professionals
38 Part I Food as Medicine: A Brief History Part I Food as Medicine: A Brief History 39
relationship between food and health, including Dr. Hyman emerged as a leader in the
David Katz, MD, PhD, Dariush Mozaffarian, functional medicine movement and is one of
MD, DrPH, Congressman Jim McGovern the more prominent social media influencers to
(D-MA), and Mark Hyman, MD. post about food as medicine. He has published
numerous bestselling books about nutrition451
Dr. Katz is a physician who has worked to and hosted a PBS special in 2018 about
advance the principles of food’s impact on nutrition and health.452 However, his work
the prevention and treatment of disease. is not without controversy; he sells dietary
His experience includes work with various supplements to accompany a 10-day “detox”
preventive and lifestyle medicine groups,461 diet,453 despite there being little evidence that
and he founded the Yale-Griffin Prevention detox diets work.454 He also has received
Research Center,462 the True Health criticism for his cooperation with Robert
Initiative,463 and DietID.464 He has more F. Kennedy Jr. in writing a book about the
than 200 peer-reviewed publications about debunked link between vaccines and autism.455
nutrition,465 and in 2020 co-authored a book
with notable food journalist Mark Bittman, The increasing support of food as medicine
How to Eat: All Your Food and Diet Questions among these notable figures has given the
Answered.466 movement traction among even some of the
oldest nutrition organizations, including the
Dr. Mozaffarian is a cardiologist, dean and Academy of Nutrition and Dietetics (AND).
Jean Mayer Professor at the Tufts Friedman The AND describes food as medicine as “a
School of Nutrition Science and Policy, and philosophy where food and nutrition aids
professor of medicine at Tufts Medical School. individuals through interventions that support
He is the Principal Investigator of Food- health and wellness.”456
PRICE, a group of American researchers
who investigate how to improve the diets
of Americans and combat diet-related Distinct Dietary Patterns in the
diseases such as heart disease, obesity, and Blue Zones of Health
diabetes.467 He has published extensively
One of the most fascinating studies of the
about the connections between nutrition and
connection between food and its impact on
health, including about the burden that diet-
health was performed in 2000 by Giovanni
related disease places on the modern health
Pes, MD, PhD and Michel Poulain, PhD and
care system.468
published in 2004 in the journal Experimental
Gerontology. The study identified Sardinia
Congressman McGovern, a long-time hunger
as the region of the world with the highest
and agriculture advocate, launched the
concentration of male centenarians.457 In
bipartisan Food as Medicine Working Group
2000, prior to beginning the study, National
within the House Hunger Caucus in 2018.
Geographic Fellow and author Dan Buettner
The group focuses on the impact hunger has
launched a program with the goal of identifying
on health and health care costs, as well as
the world’s longest-lived people and their
the importance of creating agricultural and
common attributes.458 Pes, Poulain, and
nutrition policies guided by evidence-based
Buettner developed the Blue Zone certification
health research that demonstrates access
in order to mark regions of the world where
to affordable and nutritious foods like fresh
a higher than average number of people live
produce leads to healthier communities.469,470
longer than others.459,460
40 Part I Food as Medicine: A Brief History Part I Food as Medicine: A Brief History 41
There are five Blue Zones identified around low among all people living in the five Blue
the world where people live significantly Zones, has been linked to higher rates of
longer than people in other parts of the prostate cancer for men and aggravated
world.471 Okinawa, Japan; Sardinia, Italy; kidney problems for women.480 The research
Nicoya, Costa Rica; Ikaria, Greece; and demonstrates the strong impact food has on
Loma Linda, California are home to some overall health, and the link between physical
of the longest living people in the world.472 health with quality of life.
Longevity has traditionally been regarded as
a marker of overall health, and Pes, Poulain, The China Study: Connecting Diet
and Buettner’s work illustrates how lifestyle & Chronic Disease
choices and cultural practices factor into
leading a long and healthy life.473 In their groundbreaking 2005 book, The
China Study: The Most Comprehensive
Pes, Poulain, and Buettner studied these Study of Nutrition Ever Conducted, T. Colin
zones to see what habits and lifestyle choices Campbell, PhD, a long-time Cornell University
overlapped among such physically distant researcher, and his son, Thomas M. Campbell
locations. Along with important choices such II, MD, offer some of the most comprehensive
as exercise, quality time with friends and research connecting diet and chronic disease
family, and having a sense of purpose, one of in China.481
the greatest overlaps they found was diet.474
They found that individuals living in Blue The Campbells found that genes on their own
Zones ate primarily a plant-based diet heavy do not always determine diseases; but rather,
in beans and lentils and light in meats and nutrition plays a key role in which genes are
dairy (just five 3-4 ounce servings of meat actually expressed.482 They also found that the
per month).475 same nutrition that prevents disease in early
stages can be used to halt or reverse disease
In total, nine common lifestyle habits, including later on in life, and that nutrition that benefits
dietary patterns, were identified among people one chronic disease tends to address a variety
living in the Blue Zones. According to their of disease states.483 Their research even
research, people that live the longest have demonstrated that nutrition can help control
a diet composed mostly of plants.476 Leafy the adverse effects of noxious chemicals.484
greens like spinach and kale, seasonal fruits
and vegetables, and beans are the most The Campbells also noted that nutrition is
common foods eaten by people in the Blue a matter of the combined activities of food
Zones.477 And other foods consumed by substances and not the result of individual
these same people have also been identified parts—in other words, vitamin supplements,
as effective in treating specific diseases. either in pill form or added to food, are not an
For example, olive oil consumption, which adequate replacement for nutritious whole
is prominent among middle-aged people in foods.485 For this reason nutrients will act
Ikaria, has been shown to increase good differently from medicine, which tends to have
cholesterol and lower bad cholesterol.478 quicker and more obvious “wins” when it
People with high levels of High-Density comes to health.486
Lipoprotein (HDL) or good cholesterol
have been shown to be at lower risk for
heart disease and stroke.479 Additionally,
egg consumption, which was found to be
42 Part I Food as Medicine: A Brief History Part I Food as Medicine: A Brief History 43
Charles Platkin: In your book you state that, “Among the many associations that are
Spotlight: Interview with T. Colin Campbell by relevant to diet and disease, so many pointed to the same finding: People who ate the
Charles Platkin, PhD, JD, MPH (2012)487 most animal-based foods got the most chronic disease. Even relatively small intakes of
animal-based food were associated with adverse effects. People who ate the most plant-
based foods were the healthiest and tended to avoid chronic disease.” There are some
T.Colin Campbell is a retired professor of nutritional biochemistry at Cornell University who disagree with this nutritional philosophy.
who started his career doing research on how to make animals grow faster. His goal was
to promote better health by advocating the consumption of more meat, milk and eggs. Dr. T. Colin Campbell: I don’t like to respond to the assertion that people make decisions
Then, more than 40 years ago, while he was a young researcher working on a project to on the basis of “philosophy,” which suggests that people are motivated by personalized
help stamp out malnutrition in the Philippines, he came to a turning point that shifted the agendas in making their decisions. Although I know this to be true for most people,
direction of his life’s work. Now he’s on a mission to share his compelling research on this is not what motivated me. I simply did the research with my many students
nutrition and diet with the world. He co-wrote a book called The China Study, (BenBella and colleagues and produced experimental findings that were peer-reviewed and
Books, 2005), based on his years of research showing the connection between nutrition published in the very best scientific journals. I then made my conclusions on the basis
and heart disease, diabetes and cancer. The study was the culmination of a 20-year of actual empirical data. There was no philosophy involved. If I had a personal bias or
partnership among Cornell University, Oxford University and the Chinese Academy of philosophy in drawing my conclusions, it would have been exactly the opposite of these
Preventive Medicine. conclusions, given my many years on the farm milking cows.
Here are a few answers to the Diet Detective’s questions from the man whose research My observation that “even relatively small intakes of animal-based food were associated
could be responsible for saving our lives by changing our diet. with adverse effects” comes from the data showing that there is a high statistical
significance between blood total cholesterol and aggregate chronic disease rates (i.e.,
Charles Platkin: Do we really need to be so worried about exactly what we’re eating? “Western” diseases). This is especially interesting because dietary animal-based protein
Have we blown our “unhealthy” eating habits out of proportion? in this survey ranged only from 0 percent to 10 percent of total protein. Moreover, to
observe such statistical significance within this very low range of animal-based protein
Dr. T. Colin Campbell: Yes, and no. We obsess about details (which nutrients, which and within such a low range of blood cholesterol is striking, especially when the blood
supplements, which specific ailments and diseases are candidates for therapy) but do cholesterol was so highly correlated with animal-source foods.
not pay enough attention to the big picture (whole foods versus processed foods, plant
versus animal source foods). Understanding the big picture has the most to offer – Charles Platkin: Are you suggesting that we all become vegetarians or vegans??
by far.
Dr. T. Colin Campbell: I have never suggested that we should all be vegetarians,
Charles Platkin: Could you tell us briefly about the genesis of The China Study? because about 90 percent of vegetarians are still consuming food (i.e., dairy, eggs) with
nutrient compositions that actually account for the adverse health effects of animal-
Dr. T. Colin Campbell: In 1981, the Chinese government announced the results of a based foods. Although consuming foods that trend in the direction of better health,
massive nationwide survey of cancer mortality for 2,400 counties, which showed that vegetarians do not do what they could do. This suggests that vegans should do better,
cancer was far more common in some areas than in others. Geographic localization was but they, too, compromise their potential benefits because they consume food that is
far more intense than in the U.S. because the vast majority of people in China resided in highly processed. My recommendation is to consume a whole-food, plant-based diet
the same place all their lives and consumed locally produced food, at least in rural parts without supplementing with added fat, salt, sugar and processed foods.
of the country. Americans move around and consume food from places far and wide,
making it virtually impossible to do such a study. Whether people should eat this way is, of course, their choice. Besides, we know that
a few people (5 percent) can deviate from this practice and still enjoy good health
Also, dietary lifestyle characteristics of people in rural China were substantially different until advanced ages. But this may be analogous to the small number of smokers who
from people in Western societies. These conditions presented an unparalleled and live to their 90s and believe that it was their smoking that got them there. If we want
unique opportunity to compare diet, lifestyle and disease mortality rates with Western to maximize our health, I believe that it would be prudent to go the whole way to an
societies. It also allowed us to compare our results with our extensive and provocative all-plant-based diet and allow ourselves the opportunity to discover some hidden and
laboratory animal findings obtained during the previous 15 years. I especially wanted delicious tastes that are masked because of our addictions to high fat, salt and sugar.
to record as many different kinds of diet and lifestyle factors as possible in order to get Who can calculate the 1 in 20 chance that they might escape the hazards of eating the
information on “big picture” questions that seemed to be so contentious in the scientific wrong food? The real question is whether 100 percent plant-based diets are healthier
and public communities. than, say, 90 to 95 percent plant-based diets. This will undoubtedly depend on the
differing responses of each individual, although I know of no scientifically valid
44 Part I Food as Medicine: A Brief History Part I Food as Medicine: A Brief History 45
data showing that people consuming a plant-based diet suffer more and die earlier. If I were to put my finger on one explanation of the extraordinary confusion in nutrition
Indeed, the findings are clearly to the contrary. research, I would say that it is the way that nutrition is defined. Nutrition should not,
for example, be defined as the biological effects of single, isolated nutrients but as the
Charles Platkin: You also claim that your research showed that the protein casein, which collective, highly integrated effects of all active substances in plant-source foods. The
makes up 87 percent of cow’s milk protein, promoted all stages of the cancer process. practice of medicine is the antithesis of nutrition. It relies on the biological effects of
Are you saying that animal protein promotes cancer? individual chemicals (e.g., drugs or nutrient supplements) acting independently and, to
make matters much worse, on chemicals not in their natural form but in a synthetic form.
Dr. T. Colin Campbell: In our experimental animal studies, casein as an animal protein
promotes cancer, in spades. Of all the experimental research my laboratory did, this Aside from this scientific argument, there also are highly socio-historical, economic and
may be the most convincing. In fact, our findings, done in so many ways, show that political factors wherein special interests from the food and drug industries exert their
casein is the most relevant chemical carcinogen ever discovered. I have presented this enormous power to influence science agencies, regulatory authorities, politicians and
information in seminars to virtually all the relevant agencies and research groups who the media in order to sway public opinion in favor of their products and profits. I spent
do these kinds of studies, and have published the results in the very best peer-reviewed about 20 successive years almost continuously involved in some aspect of food and
scientific journals. These findings also are consistent with similar promoting effects of health policy development and witnessed first hand a devastating effect of corporate
casein on the development of experimental atherogenesis (the lesion leading to heart interests on public nutrition information. Our system is about creating wealth for the few
disease) and rising blood cholesterol levels, among other toxic events. at the expense of health for the many – and using public taxpayer dollars to do this dirty
work! The media merely carry the message of the food and health cartels and mostly
Charles Platkin: What is the healthiest diet to prevent disease and live our best life? know not what they are doing. Trust what you read in the media at your own peril.
Dr. T. Colin Campbell: The closer we get to a whole foods plant-based diet with minimal Charles Platkin: Do we really need to be buying organic foods? If so, why? What’s the
or no use of added oil, sugar, salt or processed foods, the healthier we will be. On compelling argument for or against?
interpreting the scientific evidence, I mostly rely on statistical odds and biological
plausibility, which overwhelmingly point in the direction of a plant-based diet. But I Dr. T. Colin Campbell: I prefer using organic food but must confess that convincing and
become substantially convinced when I see the clinical evidence achieved by my direct scientific evidence for its health benefits is lacking, although there is certainly
physician colleagues. some reasonable indirect evidence to support health benefits from these foods.
Charles Platkin: What about all the white rice the Chinese eat? We’ve been taught that Charles Platkin: If we don’t eat well, should we be taking a multivitamin
rice should always be brown – that is, 100 percent whole grain? and/or supplements?
Dr. T. Colin Campbell: Yes, white rice is not the most desirable. It likely would be better Dr. T. Colin Campbell: No. There now is ample evidence that (except perhaps for B12
for the Chinese to eat whole-grain rice. and maybe vitamin D) taking vitamin supplements is, at a minimum, a waste of money
and at worst, may actually cause harm.
Charles Platkin: You say that the real science about “food and nutrition has been
buried beneath a clutter of irrelevant or even harmful information.” Can you please Charles Platkin: What’s your favorite breakfast?
explain more specifically what you mean, and why this has occurred? What’s wrong
with nutrition research today? Is it tainted by corporate research dollars and National Dr. T. Colin Campbell: A bowl of either cold or hot cereal (whole grain) with fresh or
Institutes of Health mandates? Can we trust what we read in the media? frozen fruit, various dried fruits (raisins, figs) and a sprinkle of nuts. A breakfast of whole-
grain pancakes with a large dollop of fruit puree, maybe some maple syrup, with no
Dr. T. Colin Campbell: This is a very big, important and complex story. We do the wrong added oil to the pancake mix, also is delicious. My wife does it exactly right.
thing in nutrition research, not just because we misunderstand nutrition but even more
because we misunderstand what the words “health” and “medicine” mean. Charles Platkin: What’s your favorite “junk food”?
Dr. T. Colin Campbell: When my wife is not looking, a piece of strongly flavored cheese.
But it has to be someplace else because it is not to be found in our house.
46 Part I Food as Medicine: A Brief History Part I Food as Medicine: A Brief History 47
Food as Medicine in Popular Culture
Spotlight: Significant Food As Medicine
Documentaries
Documentaries Bring Food as explores the role that big business plays in
Medicine into Public Discourse public health and the epidemic of diet-related
disease.498 Joaquin Phoenix, acclaimed actor Super Size Me (2004), dir. Morgan Spurlock
One of the earliest documentaries chronicling and vegan activist, acted as an executive
the relationship between food and health was producer on the film.499 The film was criticized Food Matters (2008), dir. James Colquhoun and Carlo Ledesma
the 2004 Super Size Me. Filmmaker Morgan by reviewers for cherry-picking science studies Killer at Large (2008), dir Steven Greenstreet
Spurlock ate exclusively McDonald’s fast food and distorting scientific data.500,501,502,503
for thirty straight days, and the documentary Fat, Sick and Nearly Dead (2010), dir. Joe Cross and Kurt Engfehr
follows the changes to his physical and mental The cultural impact of this popularization can Forks Over Knives (2011), dir. Lee Fulkerson
health that occur as a result of this drastic still be seen today. Numerous professional
shift.488 Shortly after the film was released, athletes have publicly extolled the benefits Vegucated (2011), dir. Marisa Miller Wolfson
McDonald’s discontinued the “supersize” of plant-based diets in particular; former Hungry for Change (2012), dir. James Colquhoun and Laurentine ten Bosch
option;489 however, the company alleged NFL lineman David Carter switched to a
that the decision to stop selling “supersize” vegan diet in 2014 after watching Forks Over A Place at the Table (2012), dir. Kristi Jacobson and Lori Silverbush
portions was entirely unrelated to the film.490 Knives.504 The popularity of veganism among Bite Size (2014), dir. Corbin Billings
athletes is the primary focus of Netflix’s 2019
The food as medicine movement gained documentary, titled The Game Changers, Fed Up (2014),
dir. Stephanie Soechtig
further attention with the release of the 2011 which strongly promotes a plant-based diet.505
documentary, Forks Over Knives.491 The film It featured many of the major figures in the That Sugar Film (2014),
was the culmination of more than ten years of Food as Medicine movement, including Dean dir. Damon Gameau
research by executive producer Brian Wendel Ornish, Caldwell Esselstyn, and David Katz, PlantPure Nation (2015),
into the health effects of a plant-based diet.492 alongside very well-known celebrities such as dir. Nelson Campbell
In the film, he interviews major figures in the Arnold Schwarzenegger.506 This documentary
plant-based food as medicine movement, highlighted athletes (especially men) who Food as Medicine (2016),
including T. Colin Campbell and Caldwell dir. Lenore Eklund
follow vegan diets, using the term “plant-
Esselstyn.493 After the documentary’s release, based” in an attempt to broaden the appeal.507 Food Choices (2016),
the Forks Over Knives brand has expanded to However, the film was criticized for citing very dir. Michal Siewierski
include multiple cookbooks, a cooking course, little reputable research and relying heavily on
The Magic Pill (2017),
and a meal planning service.494 It has been anecdotal evidence instead.508 dir. Robert Tate
described by many media outlets as a film
that, even if it does not convince the audience What the Health (2017),
to turn to completely plant-based diets, will dir. Kip Andersen and Keegan Kuhn
force viewers to think more critically about the H.O.P.E. What You Eat Matters (2018),
food they eat.495,496 dir. Nina Messinger
Meat Me Halfway (2021),
In 2017, director Robert Tate released The
dir. Brian Kateman and
Magic Pill, which diverted from the plant-based Journey Wade-Hak
focus of Forks Over Knives. In The Magic
Pill, the health benefits to high-fat, meat- They’re Trying to Kill Us (2021),
heavy diets (such as the ketogenic diet) are dir. Keegan Kuhn and John Lewis
explored.497 That same year, documentarian
Kip Andersen released What the Health, which
48 Part I Food as Medicine: A Brief History Part I Food as Medicine: A Brief History 49
The Impact of Food as advanced health degrees,517 which causes
Medicine Online readers of these sites to be more likely to trust
the information they find.518,519 However, online
According to the National Telecommunications health information may still be misleading and
and Information Administration (NTIA) in the have inaccurate claims.520 In fact, baseless
United States Department of Commerce, more trends and sensationalist news reports create
than half of American households used the opportunities for misinformation to proliferate,
internet for health-related activities in 2019.509 In providing information that may sometimes be
its survey, NTIA reported that dangerous.521,522 While some individuals may
be skeptical of government websites (such as
The proportion of households that accessed the FDA,523 USDA,524 and the U.S. National
health or health insurance records online Library of Medicine’s MedlinePlus525,526,527) it
grew from 30 percent in 2017 to 34 percent can be valuable in offering a baseline level of
in 2019. Households communicating information or a starting point, that along with
with a doctor or other health professional
original research from scholarly search engines
online grew by two percentage points,
such as PubMed or Google Scholar, can provide
and households that researched health
information online grew by one percentage a starting point for individual health information
point between 2017 and 2019.510 research.528
50 Part I Food as Medicine: A Brief History Part I Food as Medicine: A Brief History 51
Spotlight: Deciphering Health Information Facts? Opinion? Bias?
Online ● Check to see if the information on the site is based on the latest scientific research –
the “state of the science.” You can always look on pubmed.gov or search in Google
Scholar using key words and seeing what research articles show up. You can filter
By Charles Platkin, PhD, JD, MPH results by year too.
You wake up one morning and see that you have an unidentified rash on your hand. ● Information should be presented in a clear manner. It should be based on fact and
What’s one of the first things you do? Probably, if you’re like most Americans, you go verifiable from primary sources such as professional / scientific literature, peer-
to your smartphone or computer and start searching for what disease you have. The reviewed journal articles, and other scholarly researched, university backed sources.
statistics are staggering – nearly 75 percent of Americans are looking online for health
information. As Mark Twain said: “Be careful about reading health books.” The reality is ● Is the information showing only one point of view? Check multiple websites,
you can’t always trust what you read. Here are a few tips from a variety of sources (e.g. especially university and government research organizations (such as CDC.gov
the Medical Library Association, NIH’s US National Library of Medicine, Medline Plus and NIH).
and a few other reliable sources) to help make sure your future health searches yield
● Information that is opinion should be clearly stated on the website and the source or
more accurate results.
sources of the information should be identified.
Who Owns or Is Responsible for the Website and Its Content? ● Are there advertisers or sponsors on the site? Who are they? What type of ads?
Ask yourself the following questions: Keep in mind, most government websites, hospitals, universities and other non-
profits don’t take ads or have sponsors.
● Who or what entity created the website or is responsible for the information?
● Is advertising clearly marked as a sponsored? Many sites create advertorials
● Does the site have an email address, or is the only way to contact the organization
– advertisements disguised as editorial content or information from reliable
through a web or contact form? Make sure their contact information is accurate
health sources.
and detailed.
● Who owns the site? Is there an “About” or “About Us” section? Is it a not-for-profit, ● Look carefully to see if the site is a front for a corporation, pharmaceutical company,
and, if so, who is funding? There are some nonprofits that are funded by specific or another biased organization.
interest groups or corporations. Is it a corporation? If so, what kind—hospital, ● Check the style and display of the site information including the graphics, colors,
university, etc.? fonts, and size of text. Watch out for all capital letters, exclamation points, and
● Does it explain the mission and purpose of the website? Is there an address? If you anything out of the ordinary.
look it up on a search engine “street image,” what does it show?
● Has the material been reviewed or vetted by an expert, such as an MD or PhD in
● Why was the website created? What is its purpose and what do they gain? Is it
the field?
educational? Corporate? Trying to sell a product or service?
● Does the “About Us” section list names of individuals associated with the site? If Is the Information Accurate and Timely?
there is an individual identified, what are their credentials (PhD, Masters – and from
● Are the sources cited reliable?
what university? Is it accredited?)?
● Is it clear who they are and what they do for the site? You might even do a search for ● Is there a date on the page?
that person’s name – see what comes up. ● When was the last page updated? The site should be updated frequently. Health
● Are the individuals involved with the site backed by a known nonprofit organization information changes constantly as new information about diseases and treatments is
(e.g., government, university, or research center)? discovered through research and patient care. What was published a year ago may
● What is the domain name? This is not always the best indicator; however, typically a be outdated now.
“.edu” or a “.gov” is a good start, while “.org” is not necessarily a guarantee that it’s a ● Do the links work?
legitimate organization.
● Is there an advisory board? If so, who is on the advisory board?
52 Part I Food as Medicine: A Brief History Part I Food as Medicine: A Brief History 53
● Are there grammatical and spelling errors?
Additional Help
● The Medical Library Association’s Consumer and Patient Health Information
Section regularly reviews websites for inclusion on their “Top Health Websites”
page: http://www.mlanet.org/p/cm/ld/fid=397
54 Part I Food as Medicine: A Brief History Part I Food as Medicine: A Brief History 55
Others who use online sources as their Food as Medicine on Social Media
primary tools for making sense of their health
are driven by the desire to receive a quick In the age of social media, platforms including
and more However, consulting online sources Facebook, Twitter, Instagram, and TikTok are
(often referred to as “Dr. Google”), can lead also increasingly popular sources of health
people toward treatment approaches that lack information.554,555,556,557 Many users turn to
scientific evidence.543,544 Additionally, excessive these sites looking for food-based ways
searching for online health information has to prevent, manage, and treat disease.558
been linked to increased anxiety and distress, The extensive number of pages devoted to
a phenomenon known as “cyberchondria.”545 using food as medicine attest to this interest
There are also issues that health information among users.559,560,561 Unfortunately, the
seekers are often frustrated when searching accessibility of evidence-based information
for the medical and health information they about food as medicine has not kept pace
want. Approximately 60 percent of health with its booming popularity.562,563,564,565,566
seekers found the process of finding health Information circulated on social media and
information frustrating.546 Furthermore: the internet can often be unsound and
inaccurate, especially information about food
[i]n studies published during the last and diet.567,568,569 Misinformation is extremely
decade, persons who reported greater prevalent in online discourse,570,571 and even
difficulty in seeking health information young, tech-savvy users fall for inaccurate
online were more likely to be from socially claims on the internet and through social
disadvantaged groups, including racial/ media.572,573,574,575 Many Americans struggle to
ethnic minority groups, older adults, those understand medical information, leaving them
with lower incomes, and persons living in susceptible to misinformation spread through
rural areas; more likely to report negative social media.576,577 Research by the Institute
perceptions about health care; and more
of Medicine indicates that approximately half
likely to be misinformed about cancer
the adults in the United States lack the ability
prevention than those from relatively
advantaged groups.547 to make informed decisions regarding their
health, a phenomenon that has been called
As internet literacy improves across the board, a “health literacy epidemic.”578,579 “Health
more and more people will turn to it to answer literacy” refers to an individual’s ability to
their health questions without seeking the take responsibility for his or her health and
advice of their healthcare professionals.548 understand the factors that impact it.580,581
Patients want to feel more in control of their
health decision making,549 altering their rela- Often health claims come from social media
tionship with their physicians.550 Researchers influencers who profess food-based solutions
Sharon Swee-Lin Tan and Nadee Goonawar- to common health conditions.582,583 These
dene wrote in the Journal of Medical Internet accounts attract large, eager fan bases with
Research in 2017 that healthcare profession- some influencers and have been shown to
als need to consider ways to adapt their ser- have a significant impact on the food and
vices in the internet world in order to improve health practices of social media users.584,585,586
the patient-physician relationship.551 Key to A 2017 survey appearing in Proceedings of
rebuilding trust among patients in their health- the Nutrition Society conducted across all
care professionals is transparency; people age groups found that a majority of users, 59
want to know what doctors and other health- percent, followed influencers on social media,
care providers are doing and why they are
doing it.552,553
56 Part I Food as Medicine: A Brief History Part I Food as Medicine: A Brief History 57
and 16 percent of users considered the their marketing strategy.609,610 Many of their
opinions of these influencers to have a notable followers are teenagers and young adults—41
Spotlight: What are Dietary Supplements? impact on their food choices. 597 percent of TikTok users are between the ages
of 16 and 24611—who are highly responsive to
Claims spread via social media platforms messaging that they perceive to come from
The U.S. Food and Drug Administration (FDA) maintains that dietary supplements in- such as TikTok are often not only false their peers.612 As a result, an estimated 60
clude vitamins, minerals, amino acids, and herbs or botanicals, as well as other sub-
but potentially dangerous. For example, in percent of food and beverage promotions are
stances that can be used to supplement the diet but are not intended to treat, diagnose,
the spring of 2021, influencers on TikTok now endorsed by social media influencers.613
cure, or alleviate the effects of diseases.587 According to the 2012 National Health Inter-
view Survey, 89 percent of American adults who took dietary supplements other than encouraged the use of liquid chlorophyll
vitamins and minerals were interested in general wellness or disease prevention and as a cure for acne.598 However, some
improved immune function, memory, or energy.588 As the FDA treats dietary supplements dermatologists caution against taking liquid Rising Popularity of Plant-Based
differently from conventional pharmaceuticals (does not have the authority to review di- chlorophyll for acne without the guidance and Plant- Forward Diets
etary supplement products for safety and effectiveness before they are marketed), man- of a medical professional because a
Plant-based diets are eating patterns that
ufacturers can make certain kinds of health claims without submitting their product for photosensitizing agent such as chlorophyll can
review by the agency.589 Companies can promote their products by using statements that emphasize the consumption of foods derived
be very damaging to skin as it accumulates
describe the documented impact of their nutrient ingredients on improving or maintaining from plants, including fruits, vegetables,
and can cause rashes, burning, and
the “structure/function” of the human body.590 “Structure/function” claims are differentiat- nuts, seeds, oils, whole grains, legumes,
stinging.599,600 The key issue is that this has
and beans.614,615 Roughly a century ago,
ed from disease claims because they reference the health of an organ or mechanism of not been tested or scientifically tested and
the body rather than purporting to impact the signs and symptoms of disease.591 Some most people ate predominantly plant-based
proven to be impactful or safe. There is a high
dietary supplements have not been proven to work, and studies of some supplements foodstuffs.616 Industrialization, which increased
demand for misinformation, and validation of
have not supported claims made about them.592 Although dietary supplements that fea- standards of living while decreasing the costs
alternative scientific and medical information.
ture structure/function statements are required to include disclaimers stating that their of meat, fish, and fowl, contributed to animal
products have not been evaluated by the FDA, their claims still entice consumers to buy This information has a high believability and
products to become staples of the American
these products in the hope, often false, of mitigating disease.593 [See: National Center for low skepticism by the recipients.
diet.617,618 Federal subsidies for dairy and
Complementary and Integrative Health’s Herbs at a Glance and Health Topics A-Z] livestock, in part via subsidies on feed grains,
Researchers have used social contagion
contribute to artificially low meat prices in the
The NCCIH supports research into dietary supplements and how they affect the body, models, which study how people influence
United States, making animal-based foods
and provides information to consumers interested in taking supplements for their one another in belief, affect, and behavior, to
health.594 Some dietary supplements are well-researched and known to be generally much more affordable and accessible.619,620
demonstrate the important role these popular
beneficial for certain conditions, such as melatonin;595 others have little evidence sup- figures have played in the rise of veganism
The government in the United States spends
porting their use, such as echinacea in the treatment of the common cold.596 more than $38 billion annually on crop
over the past decade.601 For many platform
insurance and commodity programs for farms
users, influencers are trusted sources of food
(most of which go to the production of corn,
information as well as aspirational figures.602
soybeans, and other field crops that can be
Followers are eager to emulate their attractive
used as feed for livestock);621,622 however, less
physiques and glamorous lifestyles by
than one percent of that amount is allocated
following their health advice;603,604 which, in
to fruit and vegetable production due to their
recent years, this advice has attracted many
status as “specialty crops.”623,624
increasingly pushed Americans towards
certain diets.605
The shift towards plant-based eating reflects
a variety of changes to how Americans
Some health claims on social media
understand and approach their food. Today,
are funded by companies selling dietary
some of the most popular plant-based diets,
supplements, weight loss products, and
including vegetarianism and veganism,
other food-based health solutions.606,607,608
exclude many or all animal products.625 Other
According to a 2017 estimate, at least 75
plant-based diets emphasize flexitarianism
percent of advertisers in the United States
and reducetarianism rather than eliminating all
employ social media influencers as part of
fish, meat, and dairy.626,627
58 Part I Food as Medicine: A Brief History Part I Food as Medicine: A Brief History 59
Some pursue these diets out of ethical and fruits, and whole grains—foods that serve
60 Part I Food as Medicine: A Brief History Part I Food as Medicine: A Brief History 61
Many snack and convenience foods, including modern “food as medicine” model, nutrition
Fritos, Sour Patch Kids, and Oreos, are and medications can be applied together as
Spotlight: Plant-Based Lifestyle Medicine technically plant-based demonstrating that appropriate to greatly enhance outcomes.715,716
Program, NYC Health + Hospitals/Bellevue plant-based doesn’t necessarily mean a food
item is healthy.697 These items are increasingly Evidence-based approaches to food as
joined in the marketplace by other ultra- medicine recognize that a fully plant-based
Bellevue Hospital, in the Kips Bay neighborhood of Manhattan, launched a plant- processed foods specifically designed as diet may not be accessible/feasible for
based diet program in January of 2019 with the support of then-Brooklyn Borough vegetarian and vegan alternatives to animal all patients.717 Some individuals may lack
President Eric Adams.691 Called the Plant-Based Lifestyle Medicine Program, this products.698,699,700,701,702 Vegans and non- the nutritional knowledge, access to fresh
resource is designed for patients with chronic diseases and conditions, such as type vegans alike can now reach for produce and plant-based foods,
2 diabetes, prediabetes, high blood pressure, heart disease, and health concerns oat milk ice cream,703 pea and/or cooking skills required to
related to obesity.692 Adams was able to get the city to fund $400,000 into launching the protein “eggs,”704 and plant- implement and maintain such a
program,693 and it began with more than 260 patients.694 based meat analogues or diet.718,719 Others may face social
“fake” meats.705,706 These and cultural barriers, including
Participants in the program receive the attention of doctors, a registered dietitian, and alternatives often contain harsh criticism from friends and
a health coach, and each individual’s program is designed to meet their specific goals
the same high levels of family members, that make
and health needs.695 As a lifestyle program, it focuses on more than just diet. There are
added sugar, saturated fat, going plant-based untenable for
six areas of lifestyle change that participants are supported through: “plant-based diet,
physical activity, stress reduction, sleep health, social connections, and avoidance of and sodium as the animal- them.720
risky substances such as tobacco.”696 based foods they mimic
and are also implicated The perceived high cost of
in rising rates of obesity a plant-based diet may also
and other diet-related be a deterrent, though recent
diseases.707,708,709,710 As a research shows that many
result of the proliferation and plant-based foods are less
popularity of these products, expensive per serving than
the term “junk food vegan” red meats, poultry, eggs,
has been coined to refer to and seafood.721 Legumes, for
plant-based eaters who rarely example, are rich in protein and
consume whole vegetables, fiber and are among the most
fruits, and grains.711,712 economical foods available. To
address these and other barriers
Food and lifestyle choices, to adopting a plant-based diet,
specifically nutritious plant- culturally sensitive education
based diets, can be effective and support should be made
in the management and readily available (e.g., to patients
treatment of disease. This in health care settings) to increase
does not discount or eliminate the use of their consumption of healthful plant-based
medications or conventional therapeutics, foods, including fruits, vegetables, whole
which may also play a powerful role in grains, legumes, nuts, and seeds. Changes
managing disease and reducing the risk of in local and national food policies are also
disease-related complications. Additionally, warranted to increase access to these foods in
when plant-based diets are used in all communities. In the end, plant-based diets
conjunction with conventional therapeutics are tools that many people can implement to
under the guidance and oversight of qualified enhance their health outcomes, however, they
healthcare professionals, it could lead to a are not necessarily a universal panacea.
powerful response to all disease.713,714 In the
62 Part I Food as Medicine: A Brief History Part I Food as Medicine: A Brief History 63
64 Part I Food as Medicine: A Brief History Part I Food as Medicine: A Brief History 65
Part II
Food as Medicine
Challenges
66 Part I Food as Medicine: A Brief History Part I Food as Medicine: A Brief History 67
PA RT I I
Food as Medicine
Challenges
Despite the long history of food as medicine by discussions of efforts to define the term
across history and cultures, as well as its “healthy;” food insecurity, food justice and
rise in popularity in our modern culture, there health equity; insufficient nutrition counseling
remain critical challenges throughout the food from clinicians; food marketing; and food
ecosystem that may limit the ability for “food industry-funded research. It is important
as medicine” to be actualized in practice. This to acknowledge and understand these
section highlights several of these challenges challenges in order to develop, implement,
starting with controversies and inconsistencies and evaluate effective, long-term strategies
surrounding dietary guidelines, followed and solutions.
The 2020-2025 Dietary Guidelines for The Dietary Guidelines are intended to
Americans promote nutrient-dense foods such “provide food-based recommendations to
● Limiting sodium intake to less than 2,300mg per day (or even less if younger
than 14);
● Limiting alcoholic beverages* (if consumed) to 2 drinks or less a day for men and 1
drink or less a day for women.
To learn more about the Dietary Guidelines for Americans, see here.
* The Dietary Guidelines for Americans, 2020-2025 recommend limiting intake of added sugars
and alcoholic beverages, but do not include changes to quantitative recommendations from the
2015-2020 Dietary Guidelines for these two topics, because the new evidence reviewed since the
2015-2020 edition is not substantial enough to support changes to the quantitative recommenda-
tions for either added sugars or alcohol.
In 2002, an overweight man from New York filed a lawsuit against McDonald’s,
alleging that the fast food chain was at fault for his obesity and diabetes. After this
suit, many similar ones were filed across the country,745 including a lawsuit filed by two
Bronx teenagers against the McDonald’s Corporation alleging the fast-food giant was
responsible for their obesity (the case was dismissed).746,747
Obesity lawsuits gained national media attention, and the executives at the fast-food
and big-food industries took notice. One possible result of this attention is the Personal
Responsibility in Food Consumption Act in 2004, colloquially known as the “Cheese-
burger Bill.”748 The bill was introduced by former Representative Ric Keller (R-FL). The
law would have protected the food industry, particularly fast-food companies, from law-
suits brought by the public based on diet-related disease claims.749 (It is worth noting
that Representative Keller received nearly $60,000 from the Food & Beverage industry
during his 2004 Congressional campaign.)750 Former Representative Phil Gingrey (R-
GA), a co-sponsor of the bill, said to Congress, “allowing an individual to sue a restau-
rant because the consumer chose to eat there often or chose to eat too much is simply
ridiculous and, frankly, it is a dangerous waste of the court’s time. For every frivolous
case that takes up a spot on the docket, a legitimate case where an individual is truly
harmed and truly needs expeditious judicial review gets pushed farther and farther down
the line.”751
The Personal Responsibility in Food Consumption Act was passed by the United States
House of Representatives in 2004 and again in 2005, although was never brought to a
vote in the Senate and thus never became law.752 In 2009, a similar bill was introduced
to the House, called the Commonsense Consumption Act.753 This bill, similar in nature to
the Cheeseburger Bill, “Prohibits new, and requires dismissal of pending, civil actions by
any person against a manufacturer, marketer, distributor, advertiser, or seller of food, or
a trade association, for any injury related to a person’s accumulated acts of consumption
of food and weight gain, obesity, or any associated health condition.”754 The Common-
sense Consumption Act never made it to a vote on the House floor.755
● Read and compare food labels ● Perform moderate physical exercise for at
while shopping. least 150 minutes each week.
● Be aware that food marketing can ● Prioritize fresh lean meats, such as fish
influence your choices. and poultry, over fatty meats and smoked
or cured meats.
● To learn more about the Canadian
guidelines, see here. ● Limit table salt, cooking oil, added sugar,
and alcohol.
ο Recommended sugar intake of less than
50g per day.
● Drink 7-8 cups of water daily.
● Avoid food waste wherever possible.
● To learn more about the Chinese
guidelines, see here.
David L. Katz, MD, MPH, author of The Truth about Food. and founder of True Health Initiative
“To me, ‘healthy’ does NOT mean changing weight as fast as possible. It means fostering vitality and
An Attempt to Define the Terms longevity; adding years to life and life to years. And since there can be no truly healthy people on a
sick and ravaged planet, it also means sustainable – friendly to the planet, the climate, to biodiversity,
“Healthy” and “Unhealthy” to the permafrost and the rain forests. Aggregate the massive available information we have on these
topics from diverse sources- from science, sense, and the global consensus of expert – and you get
Common advice given to individuals seeking are “healthy foods”? “Healthy” or related terms a very clear articulation of the theme: a diet made up MOSTLY of minimally processed vegetables,
fruits, whole grains, beans/legumes, nuts and seeds, with plain water the go-to answer for thirst. Get
to improve their health is to “eat healthy” or (such as “health,” “healthful,” “healthfulness,” those fundamentals right – wholesome foods in a balanced, sensible assembly – and you simply can’t
to keep up a “healthy diet.” But what, exactly, “healthfully,” “healthier,” “healthiest,” go too far wrong!”
Marion Nestle, PhD, Professor, of Nutrition, Food Studies, and Public Health Emerita at New
York University and author of How Food Companies Skew the Science of What We Eat
“What ‘healthy eating’ is turns out to be so simple that the journalist Michael Pollan can do it in seven
words: “Eat food. Not too much. Mostly plants.” Really, that’s all there is to it. Those seven words re-
flect plenty of evidence that diets that follow these principles–a wide variety of relatively unprocessed
foods (including many of plant origin) in amounts that balance calorie intake with expenditure–are
associated with prevention of weight gain and the chronic diseases for which it is a risk factor. What I
like so much about these principles is that they provide plenty of room for enjoying food as one of life’s
greatest pleasures.”
Urvashi Rangan, PhD, Chief Science Advisor, GRACE Communications Foundation and Found-
er of FoodPrint.org
“How ingredients are produced and processed and packaged all impact the health of our eating.
Pesticides, chemicals, drugs, heavy metals, many food additives and aids won’t be found on the la-
bel when they are used. Supporting food choices from progressive, biodynamic, regenerative, pas-
ture-based or real organic food producers is a powerful way to support real sustainable and healthy
food choices.”
...food apartheid looks at the whole food Food Insecurity and Food as
system, along with race, geography, faith,
Medicine Interventions
and economics. You say ‘food apartheid’
and you get to the root cause of some of Food as medicine interventions, such as
the problems around the food system. It medically tailored meals, medically tailored
brings in hunger and poverty. It brings us groceries, and produce prescription programs,
to the more important question: What are
have demonstrated positive outcomes in
some of the social inequalities that you
reducing food insecurity and improving
see, and what are you doing to erase some
of the injustices?901 health.898 According to an analysis in the
journal BMJ:
Using the term “food apartheid” to address
Referring patients to food is medicine
food justice disparities calls for an approach
interventions can change their ability
to the food system that acknowledges the role
to follow dietary recommendations,
of race and class as well as geography and tackling several barriers to healthy eating,
economics.902 including the inability to afford or access
recommended foods. Providing food or
Access to nutritious food is a critical food focused financial assistance can also
component of food justice,903 as well as the alleviate budget constraints that prevent
emerging field of health equity.904 According to patients from affording medications and
the CDC, health equity is achieved: paying bills. Some food is medicine
100 PART II Food as Medicine Challenges PART II Food as Medicine Challenges 101
from physicians will also help patients interpret faculty and medical schools that have any educators at both the undergraduate and ● Include nutrition in state continuing medical
all of the nutritional information they are likely knowledge about nutrition and diet. To build graduate levels in order to best improve education requirements.
to find online and on social media, improving it into schools now requires real investment the quality of nutrition education medical
● Include nutrition in continuing
their overall nutrition literacy.1025 in hiring and training.”1038 In her analysis of professionals receive, thus improving the
education requirements for
food as medicine in medical programs, Sarah quality of nutrition counseling they provide to
federally-employed doctors.1042
Some physicians and medical schools have Downer, a clinical instructor at Harvard’s their patients. Recommendations include:
begun incorporating “culinary medicine” Center for Health Law and Policy Innovation,
into their practice.1026,1027 Culinary medicine Executing these changes will empower future
writes: ● Amend the American Council of Graduate
is a field that combines nutrition education, Medical Education (ACGME) accreditation
and practicing physicians to recognize the
individual medical needs, and practical Theories for the lack of progress include relationships between food, diet, and health
requirements to include nutrition education.
education about food preparation and lack of leadership or faculty level nutrition and provide up-to-date evidence-based
cooking.1028,1029 Culinary medicine programs champions at many medical schools, ● Tie government funds for residency advice on eating habits, preventive health and
have been proven effective at improving lack of compelling training opportunities programs to the inclusion of disease management, all of which will help
the knowledge and confidence of medical (such as fellowships) focused on nutrition, nutrition education. optimize health outcomes for patients.
and rapidly advancing nutrition science
students as they become doctors.1030,1031,1032
coupled with rampant public nutrition
[More information about culinary medicine
misinformation might have minimised the
can be found in Part 3]. However, since not all
How Marketing and Legalized Health Claims
perceived credibility of nutrition science
medical schools incorporate culinary medicine among physicians.1039
into their curriculums as elaborated above,
many patients are still left with little in the
way of nutrition education from their primary
In a Harvard Law School Food Law and Policy Obfuscate the Impact of Food on Disease
Clinic report, “Doctoring Our Diet: Policy
care providers.1033 Tools to Include Nutrition in U.S. Medical Front-of-package (FOP) food claims and Health Claims
Training,” the authors note that “[t]he lack descriptive key words and phrases are
Furthermore, while many patients will attempt frequently used in food marketing and often A health claim is defined by the FDA as
of comprehensive nutrition education for
to improve their diets when counseled by a create confusion among consumers.1043,1044 having two components: “(1) a substance
physicians represents a missed opportunity
physician,1034 doctors need to be cautious not for doctors to promote good health, illness These claims influence consumer decision (whether a food, food component, or dietary
to stigmatize their patients and make them making for both consumers with high ingredient) and (2) a disease or health-related
prevention, and treatment of chronic
feel “fat shamed.”1035 As medical student nutritional knowledge and health motivation condition.”1048 If a statement does not have
diseases.”1040
Triya Chakravorty wrote in the BMJ, “[i]n a and those without.1045 Consumers’ these two things, then it is not considered
health care setting, negative attitudes held by understanding of these types of claims is a health claim, and is therefore not subject
Additionally, requiring comprehensive nutrition
healthcare professionals will make patients relevant to food as medicine because it sheds to premarket review and authorization from
training as a component of healthcare
feel stigmatised and reluctant to access health light on some of the most accessible health the FDA.1049 There are two different types of
clinician education will ensure equitable
care services, further damaging their long term and nutrition information consumers receive: health claims: authorized and qualified (see
patient access to nutrition expertise no
health.”1036 To better serve patients of all sizes, marketing. Furthermore, FDA-approved health related Spotlights).
matter their geographic location or the type
healthcare professionals should be trained in of doctor they are seeing. Ways to ensure claims in particular demonstrate what the
techniques to talk about weight with patients average consumer is likely to believe about Many players in the food industry have
the incorporation of nutrition into medical
without shame or judgment.1037 the relationship between diet and disease,1046 attached health claims to their products
education curricula include legislative
because these claims are so pervasive in for decades. In 1886, Coca-Cola was sold
mandates, making government funding for
Medical school curricula have been developed everyday life.1047 as a patented medicine and “brain tonic”;
schools contingent upon inclusion of nutrition
historically, focusing on biology, behavior, and Dr. Pepper was also advertised as a “brain
courses; integration of nutrition coursework
disease rather than more inclusive approaches There are three types of claims that tonic” in drugstores.1050,1051 As recently as
into accreditation standards; and the inclusion
that include nutrition education. Emily M. can be used by food companies: health 2013, Coca-Cola released advertisements
of nutrition questions on board and other
Broad Leib, the Director of the Food Law and claims, nutrient content claims, and promoting Coke products as part of a healthy
qualifying examinations.1041
Policy Clinic of the Center for Health Law structure/function claims. lifestyle working to combat obesity.1052 Other
“Doctoring Our Diet: Policy Tools to Include
and Policy Innovation at Harvard University, advertisements from Coca-Cola promised
Nutrition in U.S. Medical Training” also
told The Counter, “because [nutrition] wasn’t includes numerous recommendations for
to cure headaches and relieve mental and
prioritized for so long, there aren’t a lot of physical exhaustion.1053 Kellogg’s is another
102 PART II Food as Medicine Challenges PART II Food as Medicine Challenges 103
Spotlight: Qualified Health Claims Spotlight: Authorized Health Claims
Qualified health claims, which are supported by scientific evidence but do not meet the Also called “significant scientific agreement” health claims, authorized health claims
significant scientific agreement standard required for the FDA to approve an authorized connect specific molecules and nutrients with specific diseases and disease states.
claim, are also a frequently used marketing strategy.1054,1055 In order to ensure that these They require a rigorous standard of agreement among qualified experts in order to
claims are not false or misleading to consumers, they must be accompanied by be used.1068 This “significant scientific agreement” is determined by the FDA, which
disclaimers or additional language to accurately communicate the level of scientific considers “the totality of the publicly available scientific evidence (including evidence
evidence supporting them.1056 These disclaimers include phrases such as “supportive from well-designed studies conducted in a manner that is consistent with generally
but not conclusive,” “very limited and preliminary scientific research,” “scientific evidence recognized scientific procedures and principles).”1069 Since 1990, when the Nutrition
suggests but does not prove” or “limited scientific evidence.”1057 Including these phrases Labeling and Education Act was passed and the FDA was made to regulate health
that are not accepted by the FDA as an authorized claim can confuse consumers, as claims, 12 health claims have been authorized for use.1070
they are left not knowing what to believe about how their diet will affect their health.1058
While none of these claims have been revoked by the FDA yet, one claim has been
An example of a qualified health challenged: the claim that soy protein reduces risk of heart disease.1071 A rule has been
claim that has been approved by the proposed to revoke this authorization, as it no longer meets the substantial scientific
FDA: “Supportive but not conclusive agreement requirement.1072 There have been calls for more research into soy protein to
research shows that eating 1.5 have evidence upon which to base a soy protein food health claim.1073
ounces per day of walnuts, as
part of a low saturated fat and low Health claims of this type can also be made as an “authoritative statement” of a scientific
cholesterol diet and not resulting body.1074 The scientific bodies that can make these authoritative statements include
in increased caloric intake, may the National Institutes of Health (NIH), the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention
reduce the risk of coronary heart (CDC), and the National Academy of Sciences.1075 There are currently two authorized
disease.”1059 There are dozens of health claims based on authoritative statements.1076,1077
similar qualified health claims that
have been approved by the FDA.1060 Some examples of a model authorized health claim, according to the Code of Federal
These include statements about Regulations:
tomatoes and cancer,1061,1062 nuts and
coronary heart disease,1063,1064,1065
● “Adequate calcium throughout life, as part of a well-balanced diet, may reduce the
psyllium husk and diabetes,1066
risk of osteoporosis.”1078
cranberries and urinary tract
infections,1067 and more. ● “Eating a healthful diet low in fat may help reduce the risk of some types
of cancers.”1079
● “Diets low in sodium may reduce the risk of high blood pressure, a disease
associated with many factors.”1080
● “Diets low in saturated fat, cholesterol, and total fat may reduce the risk of
heart disease. Heart disease is dependent upon many factors, including diet,
a family history of the disease, elevated blood LDL-cholesterol levels, and
physical inactivity.”1081
● “Low fat diets rich in fiber-containing grain products, fruits, and vegetables may
reduce the risk of some types of cancer, a disease associated with many factors.”1082
Note that these types of health claims include the word “may” or “might.”1083
104 PART II Food as Medicine Challenges PART II Food as Medicine Challenges 105
company with a history of making medicinal is plenty of room for the FDA to better regulate However, this policy was not intended to
claims about its products; in fact, the founder, the use of these claims in foods; as researcher address food production methods, such as
John Kellogg, MD, started by serving John C. Wallingford wrote in Advances in the use of pesticides, nor did it explicitly
medicinal cereals and granolas to a health Nutrition in 2018, “Consistent standards can address food processing or manufacturing
institution.1084,1085 Most recently, through its ensure that [structure/function] claims across methods, such as thermal technologies,
acquired brand, Insurgent Brands, makers of food types are truthful and not misleading, and pasteurization, or irradiation. The FDA also
did not consider whether the term “natural”
famed RXBar, it introduced RX Cereal as an protect consumers’ access to new scientific
should describe any nutritional or other
attempt to rebrand itself under the “clean” and learnings about the functions of substances
health benefit.1114
“healthy” food labels.1086 The cereals are made in foods.”1109
with “plant-based protein” using “a mix of pea
Meanwhile, the USDA defines the term
protein, almonds and brown rice to provide its
Use of Unregulated and “natural” as products “containing no artificial
protein.”1087
ingredients or added colors” and “is only
Misleading Health-Related Terms
minimally processed,” meaning it is “processed
Nutrient Content Claims Terms such as “natural” can be found all over in a manner that does not fundamentally alter
products on supermarket shelves. However, the product.”1115 The lack of guidelines and
Another strategy commonly used by food these labels are not regulated and consumers loose definitions mean that animals raised with
marketers is nutrient content claims, which are often unaware of what they actually hormones and antibiotics can still be labeled
tell consumers about certain nutrients that are mean.1110 The FDA has not established a “natural,” as can Cheetos, lemon-flavored
in the food.1088 Any claims about the levels of Structure/Function Claims formal definition for the term “natural.”1111,1112,1113 Oreos, and Skippy peanut butter.1116
nutrients in food that are not on the nutrition Addressing the term, the FDA wrote:
Structure/function claims are statements that
information panel are considered nutrient There’s ample evidence to demonstrate that
describe how a given nutrient or ingredient
content claims, and most are regulated by The FDA has considered the term “natural” big food companies profit from confusion
in the food affects or maintains the structure
the FDA.1089,1090,1091 to mean that nothing artificial or synthetic among consumers. A Consumer Reports
or function of the human body.1099 “Calcium
(including all color additives regardless survey found that 73 percent of respondents
builds strong bones” is a prime example of a
There are two types of nutrient content claims: of source) has been included in, or has purchased products labeled “natural”—a
structure/function claim.1100 These are perhaps been added to, a food that would not
express and implied.1092 Express nutrient greater number than those who purchased
better known for being used on dietary normally be expected to be in that food.
content claims are direct statements about foods with the stricter “organic” label.1117 And
supplements, but are used on conventional
the nutrient levels in food.1093,1094 This includes
foods as well.1101 Structure/function claims on
terms and phrases such as “high in...,” “light/
food must relate to the food’s nutritive effects,
lite,” and calorie counts, among others.1095
whereas on dietary supplements they can
Implied nutrient content claims, however, only
relate to non-nutritive effects as well.1102,1103
suggest the presence or absence of certain
These claims must be truthful and not
nutrients.1096 This includes claims such as
misleading; however, they are not subject to
“high in oat bran” (oat bran is not a nutrient,
premarket approval from the FDA before they
but the presence of this ingredient suggests
are used.1104
the presence of dietary fiber to the consumer)
and “contains the same amount of [the
These types of claims received scrutiny in
nutrient] as [other food].”1097
2016, particularly the use of them on infant
formula packaging.1105 This led the FDA to
These are particularly powerful at influencing
issue draft guidance on how marketers can
consumers’ beliefs about the “healthiness”
use structure/function claims on infant formula
of foods. In a 2018 study of nutrient content
labels in September 2016.1106 While this
claims on snack foods, researchers found
guidance does not have the force of law, it was
that consumers perceived foods with nutrient
the first time that the FDA shared its thinking
content claims to have healthful attributes, and
about structure/function claims for a food
consumers were more likely to purchase those
product specifically.1107,1108 Clearly there
foods.1098
106 PART II Food as Medicine Challenges PART II Food as Medicine Challenges 107
another survey performed by Technomic, a any specific information about the nutritional or any product of roasting, heating or
foodservice consulting company, found that content of foods, perceived health terms enzymolysis, which contains the flavoring
one in five consumers are willing to pay more on package labeling improves consumers’ constituents derived from a spice, fruit
for products labeled “natural” and “organic.”1118 perceptions of the quality and healthiness or fruit juice, vegetable or vegetable
of the product.1127 Given the previously juice, edible yeast, herb, bark, bud,
A study published in the journal Nutrients in mentioned Consumer Reports survey,1128 it is root, leaf or similar plant material, meat,
seafood, poultry, eggs, dairy products,
2021 found that many consumers feel that possible that the unregulated word “natural”
or fermentation products thereof, whose
food products containing the claim “natural” or might have a similar health halo effect.1129 In
significant function in food is flavoring
the “organic” label are superior to food without fact, the health halo effect has been found rather than nutritional.1133
these claims or labels, even if the product even for products made by companies with
is a chip or cookie.1119 These feelings could reputations as being socially responsible—a However, many of these natural flavors
arise from the manner the food was grown characteristic that seemingly has nothing to do undergo intensive chemical processing
or produced, or the health benefits of food with the nutritional quality of the food.1130 before they are used, making the distinction
that may not be man-made.1120 This effect is between which flavors are “natural” or
commonly called a “health halo.”1121,1122,1123 Using “natural flavors” also has proved “artificial” murky and difficult for consumers to
In one 2015 study published in Psychology to be a lucrative marketing tool for many understand.1134,1135 As with artificial flavorings,
& Marketing, researchers found that the food manufacturers.1131,1132 Unlike “natural,” “natural” flavorings are created in a lab,
presence of a health halo (in this case, the however, the FDA does have a definition for often with the addition of preservatives and Dr. Marion Nestle, PhD, Paulette Goddard
word “organic”) reduced negative consumer the phrase “natural flavor”: emulsifiers; once a team of professional Professor of Nutrition, Food Studies, and
perceptions of food products that otherwise “flavorists” is done extracting and distilling a Public Health, Emerita, at New York University,
had no nutritional information1124 (note that the The term natural flavor or natural flavoring has done extensive research on food labeling
natural flavor from a plant or animal, it has
USDA has strict requirements for use of the means the essential oil, oleoresin, essence practices and the way food marketers use
the same chemical composition as a synthetic
word “organic” on food labels).1125,1126 Absent or extractive, protein hydrolysate, distillate, labels to mislead consumers. On her website,
artificial flavor.1136,1137
Food Politics, Dr. Nestle frequently writes
The lack of strict regulation concerning the about the efforts made by these marketers
use of the term “all natural” by the FDA has to advertise their products as “natural” or
kept litigation between consumers and food “healthy.”1148,1149,1150,1151 While “healthy” does,
companies prevalent,1138 as consumers are technically, have a definition according to the
often left feeling misled.1139,1140 Lawsuits such FDA, it is a broad definition: the term can be
as these often have a secondary purpose, used when food products “(1) Are not low
which is to put pressure on the FDA to in total fat, but have a fat profile makeup of
regulate “natural,” either by creating guidelines predominantly mono and polyunsaturated fats;
for when the word can be used or by banning or (2) contain at least ten percent of the Daily
use of it altogether.1141,1142,1143 For example, a Value (DV) per reference amount customarily
2016 class-action lawsuit against Kind LLC consumed (RACC) of potassium or vitamin
(ie, Kind Bars) accused the brand of using D.”1152 According to Dr. Nestle, “natural” and
the phrases “all natural” and “non-GMO” “healthy” are “about marketing, not health.”1153
despite the snack foods containing genetically-
modified and highly processed ingredients.1144 The “natural” label is not the only one
The lawsuit was put on hold in 2018 pending to go largely unregulated.1154 Terms like
guidance from the USDA or FDA regarding “lightly sweetened,” “made with real...,” and
the definition of “natural,” but was allowed to “multigrain” also lack official definitions, leaving
proceed once again in early 2019 due to a lack customers vulnerable to overinterpreting the
of movement on the part of the government.1145 nutritional value of products carrying these
The case was certified in 2021,1146,1147 but has labels.1155 Additionally, the terms “superfood”
yet to be decided as of publication. and “miracle food” can misinform the public
108 PART II Food as Medicine Challenges PART II Food as Medicine Challenges 109
by implying to consumers that one specific have shifted away from sugar-sweetened
“superfood” is able to provide all the nutrients beverages.1168 The marketplace is now filled
they need for health,1156 these are also with probiotic drinks, mushroom-infused teas
unregulated terms.1157 Studies used to back and beers, and beverages containing trendy
“superfood” claims are often sponsored by the wellness ingredients such as nootropics and
companies and organizations representing adaptogens.1169
the foods they wish to promote.1158 The term
“superfood” influences consumer behaviors One of the most popular types of functional
and their value judgements when making food beverages is those which are fermented, such
choices at the grocery store, as it convinces as kombucha and kefir,1170,1171,1172 many of
consumers that certain foods have more value which have been produced and consumed by
than others.1159 This marketing tactic does cultures around the globe for centuries.1173,1174
not have to even be directly used by the food These types of beverages are popular in part
company selling the product; media coverage due to the presence of pre- and probiotics,
and informal marketing communication which can be beneficial for gut health.1175
usage of the term also influences consumer Kombucha in particular has seen immense
behavior.1160 In fact, scientists researching growth in popularity.1176 The kombucha market
the health benefits of these so-called was worth more than $1.5 billion in 2019,
“superfoods” frequently use the term in their and is expected to grow to at least triple
academic publications.1161,1162 that by 2027.1177,1178 International beverage
companies, such as PepsiCo and Coca-
Another way food marketers imply that a Cola, have purchased commercial kombucha
product may improve consumers’ health is companies to capitalize off this consumer
by drawing attention to recipe changes.1163 interest.1179,1180
Companies often advertise foods as “reduced
sodium” or “reduced calorie” in hopes of Sports and energy drinks, designed to
attracting diet-conscious customers; however, help athletes hydrate and recover after
the “reduced” claim is only a comparison to physical exertion, are also popular among
the product’s original formulation.1164 These the non-athlete population, particularly
claims do not specify the nutrient content of adolescents.1181,1182 The beneficial attributes
the original item, meaning that a manufacturer of these beverages for athletic performance
could label a food product as “reduced is well-established, but it is unclear how
sodium” even if its salt levels far exceed the beneficial they are for people not performing
recommended daily allowance.1165 strenuous physical exercise.1183 Companies
producing these drinks can be expected to
continue selling them to a larger audience, as
“Healthy” Beverages the sports drink market is projected to continue
The past twenty years have seen a surge growing in the coming years.1184
in the production and sales of functional
beverages that promise health benefits to
consumers.1166 These include beverages
such as kombucha, kefir, energy drinks,
and vegetable juices.1167 Food companies
capitalize off the perceived health benefits of
these drinks in order to target marketing more
effectively toward people whose health values
110 PART II Food as Medicine Challenges PART II Food as Medicine Challenges 111
Food Industry-Funded Research
Food industry leaders, including both consumption on wrinkles.1204,1205 I n both
corporations and agricultural boards, have studies, researchers compared before-and-
long provided funding to scholars and after photographs to analyze changes to
organizations researching the nutritional wrinkle severity among groups of menopausal
benefits of various foods.1185,1186, This funding women who replaced 20 percent of their daily
might, of course, contribute to bias in the caloric intake with almonds over a 16 week
results of nutrition studies,1187,1188 which then period.1206,1207 Despite the small sample size
can skew dietary guidelines and the foods and brief study period, researchers concluded
that consumers choose based on perceived that regular almond consumption may
healthfulness.1189 Furthermore, the money reduce signs of photoaging.1208,1209 Dr. Nestle
invested into research by these industry featured the articles, and the media coverage
players shapes the research agenda and surrounding them, on her Food Politics blog in
determines which nutritional topics are September 2021.1210
investigated.1190 There are many groups
funding research, including large corporations In 2021, Dr. Nestle wrote about another study
(such as Coca-Cola1191), trade associations funded by an agricultural board: a study
(such as the National Confectioners from The Journal of Nutrition partially funded
Association1192) and agricultural boards (such by the Hass Avocado Board.1211 The study
as the Hass Avocado Board1193). determined that daily avocado consumption
may lead to an improved gut microbiome.1212
On her website, Food Politics,1194 Dr. However, Dr. Nestle noted that the positive
Marion Nestle has long advised consumers effects attributed to avocados in this study
to be skeptical of industry-funded could apply to other foods.1213 She writes:
research.1195,1196,1197,1198,1199 Every week she
highlights a recent food study that is either fully All fruits and vegetables provide nutritional
or partially funded by a figure or organization value, and the best way to get the nutrients
with a stake in the food item being researched. you need is by eating a variety of them.
For example, Dr. Nestle highlighted the If you like avocados, include them in that
funding of a 2018 study between breakfast variety. If not, don’t.
consumption and body weight funded by
The Haas marketers want you to think that
a leading global breakfast cereal company
avocados are a superfood. Alas, there is
Cereal Partners Worldwide, a partnership with
no such thing. All fruits and vegetables
Nestlé and General Mills.1200 Dr. Nestle wrote provide nutritional value. By that criterion,
of the study’s “predictable results,” which all fruits and vegetables are superfoods.1214
concluded that regular breakfast consumption
(such as a bowl of cereal) was associated with “Big Soda” (a term used by many activists
healthier body weight.1201 to describe the soda industry), notably
Coca-Cola, is a known funder of health
In addition to “Big Food,” agricultural boards organizations and nutrition research around
are frequent funders of food research.1202,1203 In the globe.1215,1216,1217,1218,1219,1220 In 2015, AP
recent years, the Almond Board of California reported on leaked emails that revealed Coca-
has funded two studies, one in Phytotherapy Cola had input in the research and strategy
Research in 2019 and another in Nutrients development of the Global Energy Balance
in 2021, assessing the impact of almond Network (GEBN), a nonprofit dedicated to
112 PART II Food as Medicine Challenges PART II Food as Medicine Challenges 113
fighting obesity.1221,1222,1223 The GEBN’s major journals featured involvement from the food And according to Dr. Sacks and colleagues, increase perceived industry credibility,
arguments included claims that consumption industry, either through funding, affiliation, writing in PLoS One in 2020: reduce industry criticism, and encourage
of sugar-sweetened beverages is not linked to or other connections.1234 Furthermore, the increased dependency on the food
obesity.1224 Coca-Cola was also found to have study revealed that more than 55 percent There are many reasons why food industry;1245,1246 3) industry influence
some influence over researchers studying of research findings from articles with food companies might be involved in nutrition- over research agendas to preferentially
childhood obesity by funding their work,1225 and industry involvement reported food industry- related research. These reasons may focus on topics likely to benefit industry
include unobjectionable motives such as interests, rather than topics of public health
from 2011 until 2015, the company attempted favorable results as compared to articles not
a willingness to develop new knowledge, importance;1247 4) industry influence on
to convince the CDC and the World Health backed by the food industry.1235
assist in research translation and the methods, conclusions and impact
Organization to promote exercise (rather than of research in ways that are likely to
contribute expertise and resources.1243
diet) as a solution to obesity.1226,1227 Coca-Cola Of note, some question whether peer- favour industry interests over and above
However, from a public health perspective,
is not the only major beverage group to use reviewed journals should deny publications several concerns have been identified other factors;1248,1249,1250,1251 and 5) use
funding as an attempt to sway research; soda funded by industry. For example, thirty percent regarding food industry involvement in of research for political purposes.1252,1253
giant PepsiCo and the American Beverage of the studies published in The Journal of research. These include: 1) the creation An increased dependence on food
Association, a lobbying group, have also Nutrition (JN) in 2018 had industry funding.1236 of increased marketing opportunities industry funding by academics has been
funded studies that did not find a correlation When asked by Scientific American about this, for industry products, many of which documented,1254,1255,1256,1257 with food
between consumption of sugar-sweetened JN’s editor-in-chief, Teresa Davis, said, “I think are harmful to population health;1244 industry funding sometimes acknowledged
beverages and obesity.1228,1229,1230 it’s not appropriate for us to discriminate based 2) the establishment and nurturing of as a strategically important funding source
on the institution the manuscript is submitted relationships between the food industry for the university sector.1258,1259
More broadly, the sugar industry’s funding from, or the funding source, or the country.”1237 and nutrition researchers that serves to
of nutrition research has a long history; She also added that, due to lack of financial
publications from as far back as the 1960s support from other sources (including the
that skewed evidence about the cause of government), researchers often have no other
coronary heart disease have had sugar options to fund their work.1238
industry funding.1231,1232 “[I]t was unfortunate
that these papers were published because Industry influence over research agendas
they influenced the public discussion about causes a narrowing of the topics that are
the health impact of sugar,” said Michael studied in peer-reviewed journals.1239,1240 “The
Jacobson, PhD, co-founder and former long- influence on the research agenda might allow
term Executive Director of the Center for the food industry to narrowly frame public
Science in the Public Interest, in an interview health problems and policy solutions as
on National Public Radio.1233 needing technological intervention rather than
behavioural or system-wide interventions,”
Gary Sacks, PhD, a fellow at the Global wrote researchers Alice Fabbri, Taylor J.
Obesity Centre, Institute for Health Holland, and Lisa A. Bero in an analysis for
Transformation, School of Health and Public Health Nutrition published in 2018.1241
Social Development, and faculty member This influences the kind of information
of Health at Deakin University, in Australia available to the public and to policymakers
and his colleagues reviewed the 10 most- seeking solutions to public health problems,
cited “nutrition and dietetics-related journals” and corporate interests are not always aligned
in 2018 for the journal PLoS ONE. The with the health needs of the people.1242
researchers found that 13.4 percent of studies
on nutrition published in the leading nutrition
114 PART II Food as Medicine Challenges PART II Food as Medicine Challenges 115
Part III
Food as Medicine:
Interventions, Programs,
Policies and Practices
116 PART II Food as Medicine Challenges PART II Food as Medicine Challenges 117
PA RT III Food as Medicine Interventions
Food as Medicine: Medically Tailored Meals (MTMs) in a MTM delivery program compared to
Interventions, Programs,
patients participating in a non-tailored meal
Many people living with chronic disease seek delivery program.1288
dietary changes to help them manage their
health,1273,1274,1275 but often these patients Other studies have found connections
118 PART III Food as Medicine: Interventions, Programs, Policies and Practices PART III Food as Medicine: Interventions, Programs, Policies and Practices 119
For uninsured individuals or those whose the organizations providing these services,
insurance does not cover MTM programs, such as Community Servings,1313,1314,1315,1316,1317
some MTM providers provide meals free of Project Open Hand in San Francisco,1318,1319
charge, such as Community Servings1305 and and Project Angel Heart in Denver.1320
God’s Love We Deliver.1306
While the financial support of these
Studies have shown MTMs to have organizations, might result in sponsorship bias
a particularly beneficial impact on in the research findings,1321 the importance
patients experiencing poverty and food of these studies is not to be underestimated.
insecurity.1307,1308 David Waters, CEO of Further research is needed to reinforce the
Community Servings, said of clients in an outcomes and findings already published.
interview with Tom Lee for the journal NEJM Additional studies supported by the National
Catalyst: “They are hungry, they are poor, and, Institutes of Health (NIH), health insurance
most importantly, they’re very isolated by their organizations, policy organizations, and
illness—unable to walk to the store, carry a third-party research departments—whether
bag of groceries, or stand at the stove.”1309 academic or clinical—are crucial to future
According to a 2018 clinical trial published understanding of the impact and thus
in the Journal of General Internal Medicine, widespread implementation of MTMs.1322
“A healthy diet is the cornerstone of diabetes The work and research done by community
management, but food insecurity incents based organizations (i.e. medically tailored
the consumption of inexpensive, calorie- meal programs) have laid the groundwork for
dense food of little nutritional value.”1310 All demonstrating the positive impact of treating
of the participants included in the study were and preventing chronic disease states with
experiencing food insecurity; by the end of the meals. In a 2021 food as medicine panel
trial, 62% of participants reported experiencing hosted by the University of Pennsylvania’s
food insecurity when not receiving MTMs, Leonard Davis Institute of Health Economics,
whereas only 42% reporting experiencing food panelist Sarah Downer, JD, Associate Director
insecurity while receiving MTMs.1311 of Harvard Law School’s Center for Health
Law and Policy Innovation, said, “We need
Another study appearing in the Journal the NIH to really get in the game with funding
of Urban Health that provided MTMs to research on this... and the government is best
individuals with diabetes or HIV in the San positioned to do the kind of big investment in
Francisco found that the intervention reduced preventive long-term studies that we would like
very low food security from 60 percent to 12 to see.”1323
pe rcent among participants.1312 Participants
in the study were given healthy meals and
snacks designed to provide 100 percent Fruit and Vegetable
of their daily nutritional needs and energy Prescription Programs
requirements. After 6 months, MTM recipients
Produce prescription programs are healthcare
ate less fat and sugar and more fruits and
interventions wherein doctors or other health
vegetables, they binge-drank less, and
care providers (e.g. registered dietitians,
felt less distressed and more in control of
pharmacists) “prescribe” certain foods (mostly
their diabetes.
fruits and vegetables) to help targeted patient
populations prevent or manage chronic
It is important to note, however, that much of
disease, much like they might prescribe a
the research regarding MTMs is funded by
pharmaceutical drug.1324,1325 Produce
120 PART III Food as Medicine: Interventions, Programs, Policies and Practices PART III Food as Medicine: Interventions, Programs, Policies and Practices 121
prescription programs go by a variety of programs that provided incentives to increase
names and are also known as “Pharmacy the purchase of fruits and vegetables by low-
to Farm,” “Food Prescriptions,” “Fresh Rx,” income consumers.1333 In the 2018 Farm Bill,
“ProduceRx,” “Fresh Food Farmacy,” “ FINI was expanded and renamed the Gus
Farmacy,” “Fruit and Vegetable Prescription Schumacher Nutrition Incentive Program
Programs,” “Harvest RX,” ”Veggies as (GusNIP),1334 after Gus Schumacher, a
Medicine,” “SuperSNAP,” or “VeggieRx.” longtime advocate for healthy food access for
low-income households.1335 The 2018
According to the National Produce Prescription expansion explicitly earmarks funding and
Collaborative, a produce prescription evaluation support for produce prescription
program is defined as “A medical treatment programs.1336 The 2018 Farm Bill authorized up
or preventative service for patients who are to $25 million in funding over five years for
eligible due to diet-related health risk or produce prescription programs.1337
condition, food insecurity or other documented
challenges in access to nutritious foods, In 2019, Wholesome Wave, a nonprofit
and are referred by a healthcare provider or organization, founded by Gus Schumacher and
health insurance plan. These prescriptions Chef Michel Nischan, that is often credited with
are fulfilled through food retail and enable pioneering one of the first produce prescription
patients to access healthy produce with no program,1338,1339 created the National Produce
added fats, sugars, or salt, at low or no cost to Prescription Collaborative. The goal of the
the patient.”1326 Collaborative is to catalyze the vital role of
food and nutrition in improving health and
Produce prescription programs provide a wellness by collectively leveraging the unique
financial incentive (e.g. discount, bonus, or opportunities for produce prescriptions to
credit) to increase access to and consumption achieve wellness through the healthcare
of fresh fruits in vegetables among targeted system, and embedding & institutionalizing
patient populations, which in turn may have Produce Prescriptions within the healthcare
an impact on diet-related health outcomes.1327 payment model.1340
Research has demonstrated that produce
prescription programs may also be an effective Produce prescription programs have rapidly
healthcare intervention to reduce food expanded across the United States over
insecurity among patients.1328,1329,1330,1331 In a the past decade. In 2020, Wholesome
2021 study published in the Archives of Public Wave commissioned consulting firm DAISA
Health, the authors highlight the important Enterprises to conduct a field scan report of
impact produce prescription interventions can produce prescription programs in the United
have on food insecurity and health: “Food States between 2010 and 2020.1341 The report
insecurity is associated with poor nutritional identified a total of 108 produce prescription
health outcomes. Prescribing fresh fruits and programs across 38 states with nearly a
vegetables in healthcare settings may be an quarter of all identified programs launched in
opportunity to link patients with community 2019 alone.
support to promote healthy diets and improve
food security.”1332 Key components of produce prescription
programs are discussed below and include:
Federal support for nutrition incentive i) the identification of targeted patient
programs was introduced in the 2014 Farm populations by health care providers,
Bill which authorized the Food Insecurity ii) the issuance of a “prescription” or referral for
Nutrition Incentive (FINI) program. This fruits and vegetables,
program provided $100 million to fund
122 PART III Food as Medicine: Interventions, Programs, Policies and Practices PART III Food as Medicine: Interventions, Programs, Policies and Practices 123
and ii) the redemption of produce prescriptions FreshRx.1348 The program is designed for Examples of Produce Prescription born underweight from 16.3 percent to 11.0
at food retail or other settings patients with type 2 diabetes and provides Programs Utilizing Various Eligibility percent, resulting in a savings of $189,000
participants with fresh fruits and vegetables Criteria in healthcare costs during the pilot.1361 The
Identifying Targeted Patient every two weeks for one year in addition to program estimates that if results similar to the
lifestyle, nutrition, and cooking classes. The While the majority of produce prescription pilot could be achieved for all mothers in the
Populations programs target patients with diet-related
program aims to reduce diabete patients A1C St. Louis’s Medicaid system, an additional 118
Produce prescription programs are distinct in conditions, the program model may have
levels (also known as the hemoglobin A1C babies would be born at a healthy weight and
that they partner with health care providers or utility for reaching broader populations of
or HbA1c test—is a simple blood test that Missouri Medicaid would save approximately
insurers to identify targeted patient populations low-income patients.1357 A review published
measures your average blood sugar levels $5.3 million annually .1362,1363 Trina Ragain,
who would benefit from increased access to in the AMA Journal of Ethics explored the
over the past 3 months1349) by 1 to 2 percent Director of Policy and Innovation at Operation
and consumption of fruits and vegetables.1342 policy implications of produce prescription
over the course of a year which would equate Food Search noted that “Those savings
Produce prescriptions are fulfilled through food programs and noted that “Produce Rx
to $16,000 to $24,000 in healthcare cost come from what we know of what it costs
retail and enable patients to access produce programs that seek to enroll participants with
savings per person per year.1350 when a low birth weight baby is born…they
with no added fats, sugars, or salt, at low or low socioeconomic status (SES) could make end up in neonatal intensive care, which is
no cost to the patient.1343 According to the greater use of existing public assistance
Another program in Syracuse New York aims expensive.”1364 In 2021, the program launched
National Produce Prescription Collaborative, systems through which incentives could be
to mitigate chronic diabetes among patients a three year randomized controlled trial with
“when appropriately dosed, produce disbursed, such as Supplemental Nutrition
who experience food insecurity. St. Joseph’s 750 women to formally evaluate the economic
prescription programs are designed to improve Assistance Program (SNAP) and Medicaid,
Health Food Pharmacy offers type 2 diabetics return on treating food insecurity among
healthcare outcomes, optimize medical thereby enlarging public data on the complex
enough fresh and healthy food for 2 meals pregnant women.1365
spending, and increase patient engagement intersections between healthcare, food access,
a day, 5 times a week, for the patient and
and satisfaction.”1344 and income.” 1358 The expansion of produce
members of the household in addition to Other produce prescription programs have
nutrition counseling and diabetes management prescription eligibility requirements may play focused on reaching SNAP participants, as
Health care providers who prescribe produce an important role in addressing broader social
group sessions.1351 In order to participate in the research suggests that SNAP benefits fall
prescriptions can include physicians, nurses, determinants of health that contribute to poor
program participants must have a diagnosis short of what households need to afford a
pharmacists, registered dietitians, social health outcomes in patients.1359 Below are
of diabetes with an A1C of 7.5 or higher and healthy diet.1366 Reinvestment Partners in
workers, community health workers, and examples of produce prescription programs
screen positive for food insecurity.1352 “Food North Carolina manages a statewide produce
midwives.1345 Patient eligibility for produce that utilize broader eligibility criteria in order
insecurity is a predictor of health and is prescription program called SuperSNAP
prescription programs is often based on to identify low-income populations who
linked to many chronic diseases,” explained where SNAP recipients are identified by health
the presence or risk of a diet-related health
St. Joseph’s Food Farmacy coordinator Deb may benefit from increased access to and care providers and receive $40 per month
condition (such as hypertension, diabetes consumption of fruits and vegetables.
Mendzef. “We are proud that we will be able to spend on fresh fruits and vegetables at
and obesity) and/or socioeconomic criteria
to ensure that these patients, and their family over 500 Food Lion store locations across
such as food insecurity, insurance status and/ Operation Food Search, a hunger relief
members, have the resources necessary to the state.1367 A 2021 study published in JAMA
or income.1346 A detailed report of current organization in St. Louis, Missouri, operates a
provide a quality and healthy diet.”1353 Network Open found that participation in the
produce prescription programs in the United program called Fresh RX: Nourishing Healthy
The Ohio-based produce prescription SuperSNAP program was associated with a
States commissioned by Wholesome Wave Starts, that aims to enhance birth outcomes
program, Health Improvement Partnership- significant increase in the purchase of fruits
found that 82 percent of programs use diet- for food-insecure mothers and their infants.
Cuyahoga, is a community healthcare and vegetables of $31.84 per month and a
related chronic disease as part of eligibility Fresh RX partners with Missouri Medicaid
partnership that provides low-income patients decrease in the monthly spending on sugar
criteria, with 31 percent specifically focused Health Plans to identify pregnant women who
managing hypertension with $40 in monthly sweetened beverages.1368
on diabetes.1347 are experiencing food insecurity and provides
farmers’ market produce vouchers and
nutrition counseling at clinical visits.1354,1355 In them with weekly produce shares from a The Washington State FVRx program partners
Examples of Produce Prescription a 2018 study on the impact of this program, Combined Supported Agriculture Program with public and private healthcare systems
Programs Targeting Patients With Diet- published in Preventing Chronic Disease, (CSA) in addition to cooking classes, nutrition to provide SNAP recipients with $10 grocery
Related Chronic Diseases participants reported an increase in fruit resources and supportive services during store vouchers that can be redeemed for
and vegetable consumption, a decrease pregnancy.1360 A 24 month pilot study with 75 fresh, canned, or frozen fruit or vegetables
In 2020, Crossover Health Services in North babies delivered in the St. Louis region found
Tulsa, Oklahoma, an under-resourced in fast food consumption, and improved at over 169 participating supermarkets
communication with their health care providers that a mother’s participation in the program across the state.1369 This statewide initiative
neighborhood lacking in places to buy improved food security by 44 percent and
fresh food, raised $180,000 to create Tulsa about diet.1356 strategically chose to implement the produce
reduced the likelihood that her child would be
124 PART III Food as Medicine: Interventions, Programs, Policies and Practices PART III Food as Medicine: Interventions, Programs, Policies and Practices 125
prescription program in counties where the of paper vouchers included ease of use across
prevalence of low fruit and vegetable intake settings, minimal technology requirements
and food insecurity are disproportionately and low costs. A limitation of paper vouchers
high. This approach allowed them to target the reported by participants is that they may carry
produce prescription program in counties of stigma or evoke self-consciousness that can
greatest need.1373 impact participation.1370
Another produce prescription program called Some produce prescription programs are
Fresh Rx Farm to Hospital, operating in South working directly with food retailers to leverage
Florida, focuses on identifying patients who existing loyalty card programs to distribute
receive Medicaid or Medicare and patients monetary funds to participants to purchase
who pay out of pocket.1374 Through Fresh produce, eliminating the need for vouchers.
Rx Farm to Hospital, oncology, cardiology, For example, Reinvestment Partners manages
stroke and pediatric patients are provided with a statewide produce prescription program in
a free 16-week produce box subscription if North Carolina and partners with healthcare
they are on Medicare, Medicaid, or pay out- centers and over 500 Food Lion stores to
of-pocket for medical expenses.1375 During provide SNAP recipients with $40 per month
the initial weeks of the COVID-19 pandemic, loaded onto the store’s MVP loyalty card for
FreshRx launched Farm to Family, an initiative the purchase of fruits and vegetables.1371 Here
that provided weekly produce and personal is how the SuperSNAP program works1372:
protective equipment to first responders and ● Step 1: The patient must enroll in the
families in need.1376 program at a participating healthcare
center and provide their health care
Issuing Produce Prescriptions provider with their name, phone number
Once eligible patients are identified by a and Food Lion MVP customer loyalty card
health care provider, they are provided with number. If the patient does not have a
a “prescription” or referral that can be fulfilled Food Lion MVP customer loyalty card, their
through food retail and enables them to health care provider can help them sign up
access free or discounted produce.1377,1378 The for one.
mechanism for distributing funds to purchase ● Step 2: In order to load $40 onto their Food
produce in retail settings can include paper Lion MVP card, the patient must make a
vouchers, scannable coupons, loyalty cards, purchase of any amount using both their
funds loaded onto electronic cards, and phone MVP loyalty card and their EBT card at a
applications.1379 participating Food Lion location.
A report of produce prescription programs ● Step 3: The patient can then use their MVP
in the United States commissioned by card to access the $40 to purchase fresh
Wholesome Wave found that the majority fruits and vegetables at any participating
(67 percent) of programs issued funds for Food Lion location.
produce prescriptions in the form of vouchers Other programs are further leveraging
or coupons.1380 In a series of more than 60 technology to streamline the produce
interviews conducted by The Center for prescription process. Wholesome Wave has
Health Law and Policy Innovation at Harvard partnered with Tangelo to pilot an application
Law School, interviewees (including produce in California that allows patients to access their
prescription program participants, retailers, produce prescription digitally using their phone
and coordinators) reported that the advantages
126 PART III Food as Medicine: Interventions, Programs, Policies and Practices PART III Food as Medicine: Interventions, Programs, Policies and Practices 127
Boston Medical Center was the first hospital in the American Journal of Health Promotion
1387
number. Through this program, funds pharmaceutical prescription to treat high blood system to launch a therapeutic food pantry in 2019, the program reported “seeing a 20
for produce prescriptions are loaded to pressure and who are also enrolled in SNAP. in 2001 to address the nutritional needs of percent higher care gap compliance rate for
the Tangelo app as a restricted wallet that The produce prescription can be redeemed low-income patients with a variety of chronic those enrolled in the program. We have also
can only be used to purchase fruits and for $30 worth of fresh fruits and vegetables health conditions including cancer, HIV/AIDS, seen a 2-full point reduction in HbA1c among
vegetables.1388 HealthEBucksRX is another at more than fifteen farmers’ market locations hypertension, diabetes, obesity and heart program participants.”1408
technology application that has been piloted operated by GrowNYC. Cross-sector disease.1397 Through this program, patients
at community health centers and allows collaboration between healthcare institutions are identified by primary care providers who Outcomes and Opportunities
healthcare providers to create digital vouchers and farmers’ markets can benefit both write and issue produce prescriptions that are
Produce prescription programs represent
that can be distributed by email, text, or patients and local farmers. Marcel Van Ooyen, then redeemed at the on-site Preventative
a promising healthcare intervention to
hardcopy to patients and redeemed directly President and CEO of GrowNYC, stated Food Pantry for perishable food items such as
improve food security among targeted
with food retailers by scanning the barcode.1389 “This initiative has successfully introduced fruits, vegetables and meats. The on-site food
patient populations.1409 Research has
Electronic reporting with HealthEBucksRx community members to their neighborhood pantry is open five days a week and patients
demonstrated that produce prescription
allows providers to track patient compliance farmers’ market, connecting them to this can redeem their prescriptions up to two times
programs can improve fruit and vegetable
and sponsors to reimburse retailers. important resource for fresh food and simple, per month.1398
consumption,1410,1411,1412,1413,1414 nutrition
healthy recipes. We want to see small family
knowledge,1415,1416,1417,1418 and food purchasing
Partners in Produce Prescription farms thrive, and all residents, regardless of In 2018, the Children’s Hospital of
practices1419,1420 among a variety of patient
income, have affordable access to the foods Pennsylvania launched the first pediatric,
Programs populations. The benefits of produce
they need to be healthy.”1381 hospital-based Food Pharmacy program to
Partnerships are critical to the successful prescription programs are multifaceted
promote nutrition and address food insecurity
implementation of produce prescription as they can reduce barriers to dietary
Collaboration between health care providers among families in primary care and specialty
programs.1390,1391 A wide variety of partners changes by improving affordability and
and community food retailers may also serve care sites.1399 Through this program patients
have been used to redeem prescriptions accessibility of fruits and vegetables and
to increase patient awareness of local food are screened for food insecurity at clinical
for fruits and vegetables including farmers’ increasing knowledge related to diet-related
resources available to support healthy diets. visits and referred to the on-site Food
markets, grocery and retail stores, mobile health conditions.1421,1422,1423,1424.
In addition to providing farmers’ market Pharmacy where they receive a three-day
markets, farm stands, food pantries, as well
vouchers, The Food Rx program in Chicago supply of nutritious food for the household.
as on-site distribution where the prescription While produce prescription programs have
also provided diabetic patients with coupons Food insecure families are able to access the
was administered.1392 A national report been shown to improve the consumption of
to Walgreens to increase awareness about the Food Pharmacy at follow up clinical visits.1400
commissioned by Wholesome Wave found fruits and vegetables among targeted patient
recent expansion of fresh produce available
that 48 percent of programs utilized farmers’ populations, evidence of the effectiveness
at this retailer.1382 A 2019 qualitative study Geisinger, a regional health care provider
markets and 29 percent utilized grocery retail of these programs on health outcomes
published in the Journal of General Internal that serves parts of Pennsylvania and New
locations to redeem produce prescriptions, are less clear.1425,1426,1427 Findings from a
Medicine found that a produce prescription Jersey,1401 began an initiative called Fresh
while 20 percent of programs reported on-site systematic scoping review published in the
program in Cleveland Ohio increased Food Farmacy in 2016.1402 The program
produce distribution where participants receive American Journal of Health Promotion in 2021
participant awareness of farmers’ markets that serves patients diagnosed with type 2 diabetes
their prescribed amount of produce directly at reviewed 23 studies published on produce
operate in the community as well as how to who have experienced food insecurity in the
their healthcare institution.1393 prescription programs and concluded that
use local produce.1383 past year.1403 Enrollees in the program receive
“studies incorporating health metrics reported
a prescription of diabetes-appropriate food,
The most common type of redemption partner mixed effectiveness, with little consensus on
A growing number of hospitals have also and are then able to pick up the ingredients
used in produce prescription programs is the impacts of food prescriptions on blood
implemented produce prescription programs needed on-site to cook ten nutritious meals
farmers’ markets.1394,1395 Pharmacy to Farm is a pressure, BMI, or glucose homeostasis.”1428
that integrate both the referral and redemption each week.1404 In addition, patients receive
produce prescription program administered by Authors attribute inconsistent findings to poor
processes on-site at a location within the more than 20 hours of diabetes education
the New York City Department of Health and study designs and limited time frames in a
healthcare system, eliminating the need for and access to free nutrition and wellness
Mental Hygiene that partners with GrowNYC, nascent body of funded programs.1429
participants to visit a community partner to classes.1405,1406 Early stages of data collection
a farmers’ market operator, and local
redeem their prescriptions. This approach for the program have shown that providing
pharmacies to provide patients with fresh fruits Produce prescription programs represent
can potentially address challenges such as food to diabetic patients is much less
and vegetables.1396 Through this program, a burgeoning field in the Food as Medicine
transportation and limited food retail hours that expensive than providing them with medical
pharmacists provide monthly produce landscape and will require more rigorous
may limit participation in community-based care.1407 According to an editorial published
prescriptions to patients filling a research in order to demonstrate their impact
redemption models.1384,1385,1386
128 PART III Food as Medicine: Interventions, Programs, Policies and Practices PART III Food as Medicine: Interventions, Programs, Policies and Practices 129
on longitudinal health outcomes and support is as meaningful and culturally appropriate as
their integration into national policy.1437 In it is nutritious.”1430
2022, The Aspen Institute recently released
the Food is Medicine Research Action Plan
which provides the following recommendations Culinary Medicine
for future research designs of Food as Food science, nutrition, and cooking come
Medicine interventions:1438 together in the science of culinary medicine,
● Research should be appropriately powered which aims to improve patients’ conditions
to meaningfully evaluate primary outcomes by analyzing how food can play a role in
● Researchers should prioritize rigorous preventing or treating a particular disease.
research designs with a combination of According to John La Puma, MD, the Clinical
quantitative and qualitative approaches Director and Founder of Chef Clinic, “culinary
medicine is a new evidence-based field in
● Research should always report process medicine that blends the art of food and
and engagement metrics cooking with the science of medicine.”1431
Culinary medicine takes into account an
● Researchers should carefully consider
individual’s conditions and dietary needs when
whether the intensity and duration of the
designing home-cooked meals and meal
intervention is likely to influence outcomes
plans.1432 As physician Irl B. Hirsch (et al.)
of interest
wrote in Clinical Therapeutics in 2019:
● Metrics for specific health conditions
should be developed in collaboration with Specifically, culinary medicine adds
primary care and specialist conditions to existing nutrition interventions by
integrating the concept of “food pleasure”
(ie, both the sensory-based experience of
Produce prescription programs may also
food in terms of taste, smell, texture, and
have the potential to promote health equity in appearance, and the emotions surrounding
communities underserved by supermarkets food) with the scientific knowledge
and healthy food retailers. Produce Rx, of how food and dietary choices may
a produce prescription program run by influence human metabolism, immunity,
the Washington DC-based nonprofit DC and pathophysiology.1433
Greens, helps residents of Ward 8, one of
D.C.’s predominantly Black neighborhoods, It is important to note that culinary medicine
afford fresh fruits and vegetables from the is not focused on prescribing specific foods
neighborhood’s only full-service grocery to patients, nor does it attempt to replace
store.1439 In April 2021, Wholesome Wave’s prescription medications.1434 In fact, culinary
CEO, Benjamin Perkins, MA, MDiv, medicine can be used in conjunction with
participated in a panel about promoting health prescription medications and other nutritional
equity through food as medicine hosted by the and dietary interventions.1435,1436 Dr. La Puma
University of Pennsylvania’s Leonard Davis wrote of culinary medicine in the journal
Institute of Health Economics.1440 Regarding Population Health Management:
the operation of a successful food prescription
program, Perkins said: “It’s about listening to Culinary medicine is not nutrition, dietetics,
that community and using their input to inform or preventive, integrative, or internal
the way programs are designed and operated. medicine, nor is it the culinary arts or food
And it’s not just about giving them any kind of science... Culinary medicine is aimed
food, but rather providing them with food that at helping people reach good personal
medical decisions about
130 PART III Food as Medicine: Interventions, Programs, Policies and Practices PART III Food as Medicine: Interventions, Programs, Policies and Practices 131
accessing and eating high-quality meals and Health Sciences assisting with its culinary
that help prevent and treat disease and medicine programming.
restore well-being.1441
Dr. Harlan is also a senior advisor and former
Culinary Medicine in Medical School executive director of The Goldring Center
Culinary medicine, as an emerging field for Culinary Medicine at Tulane University’s
that incorporates the principles of food as School of Medicine in New Orleans,
medicine, has started to gain traction among Louisiana.1449 Founded in 2012, The Goldring
physicians and medical schools.1442,1443 In Center is the nation’s first culinary medicine
the United States, United Kingdom, and center at a medical school. The teaching
Spain, “culinary medicine” movements are kitchen provides hands-on training for medical
blending clinical medicine with individual students and residents through elective
nutrition education that is focused on the culinary medicine classes and mandatory
practical aspects of food preparation and interdisciplinary seminars. The Goldring
cooking.1444 These programs support a health Center also provides Community Classes to
care professional’s willingness and ability the local community interested in learning
to recognize nutrition needs and provide about nutrition.1450
appropriate and practical advice to patients.1445
The first medical school to offer a cooking and Some culinary medicine programs have a
nutrition elective in the United States was the dual focus: to teach participating medical
State University of New York - Upstate Medical students how to better manage their own
University, in Syracuse, in 2003.1446 health as well as that of their patients.1451
The courses emphasize cooking with fresh
One of the most prolific culinary medicine fruits and vegetables and teach participants
projects is the Health Meets Food culinary how to select, store, prepare, and even grow
medicine curriculum, which was developed their own produce in order to maximize its
by Timothy S. Harlan, MD, FACP, a world nutritional value.1452 Dr. Jaclyn Albin, the
renowned doctor, chef, teacher and author, Associate Program Director for the University
while at Tulane University. Dr. Harlan who of Texas Southwestern’s Internal Medicine and
spent his pre-medical career working in, and Pediatrics Residency program, has pioneered
eventually owning a restaurant, is also known culinary medicine courses for her students.1453
as Dr. Gourmet.1447 Currently, the Health She hopes that culinary medicine will foster
Meets Food culinary curriculum consists lifestyle changes that place students in a
of more than 30 content-specific modules better position to manage their health, deal
designed for health care professionals. “Each with stress, and reap the benefits of any other
of the educational modules presents basic medical care they are undergoing, including
and clinical science related to evidence- therapy and dietary consultation.1454
based nutritional and dietary goals for
specific topics, case presentations, recipes, The inclusion of culinary medicine within
cooking instructions, discussion questions, medical training has shown evidence-based
and quizzes.”1448 The Health Meets Food efficacy in improving the nutrition knowledge
culinary curriculum is used by medical and confidence of medical students as
students, residents, and clinicians at more they graduate and become board-certified
than 55 academic medical centers across the physicians.1455,1456 One study published in
world. Currently, Dr. Harlan is at the George Advances in Preventive Medicine compared
Washington University School of Medicine medical students who participated in a cooking
and nutrition elective in a medical school-
132 PART III Food as Medicine: Interventions, Programs, Policies and Practices PART III Food as Medicine: Interventions, Programs, Policies and Practices 133
based teaching kitchen versus traditional Culinary Nutrition Dietary Supplements a household income of ≥ 350% of the
clinical education. The cooking and nutrition poverty level, those who were food
Culinary nutrition is a term used to describe The National Institutes of Health Office of
elective resulted in a 72 percent increase in secure, and SNAP income-ineligible
the practice of incorporating nutrition and Dietary Supplements (NIH ODS) defines a
the reporting of total proficiency in providing food science knowledge into individual dietary supplement as “[a] product (other
nonparticipants across all sex, age, and
nutrition counseling to patients.1466 According race/ethnic groups. Among women,
preparation of food,1457 resulting in “an than tobacco) that is intended to supplement prevalence of use significantly differed
to a survey of medical students published in interdisciplinary approach to food, ranging the diet; contains one or more dietary between SNAP participants (39%) and
the American Journal of Lifestyle Medicine, from nutrition and dietetics to culinary arts and ingredients (including vitamins, minerals, SNAP income-eligible nonparticipants
during the 2019-2020 academic year, a gastronomic sciences,” wrote researchers in herbs or other botanicals, amino acids, and (54%). Older adults (71+ years) remained
3-hour culinary medicine training was found the International Journal of Gastronomy and other substances) or their components; is the highest consumers of DS, specifically
to have positive effects on the students’ Food Science in 2021.1458 This interdisciplinary intended to be taken by mouth as a pill, among the highest income group (82%),
“nutrition knowledge, skills, and attitudes and approach is proving effective; culinary nutrition capsule, tablet, or liquid; and is identified while younger adults (19–30 years),
confidence in patient nutrition counseling.”1467education programs are gaining traction as on the front label of the product as being predominantly in the lowest income group
motivators for behavior change in patients a dietary supplement.”1474 Products of this (28%), were the lowest consumers.1487
Various schools and organizations provide managing chronic disease.1459 According to type are not called “dietary supplements” in
continuing medical education (CME) to a 2020 article in Health Promotion Practice, every jurisdiction; for example, the United Among children, the difference in supplement
physicians and other health care providers “Evidence of the benefits of culinary nutrition Kingdom’s Food Standards Agency calls use by socioeconomic characteristics
about nutrition and food as medicine:1468 education is growing in the literature. them “food supplements,” defined as “any was similar:
The American College of Preventive Medicine Culinary nutrition education programs are food the purpose of which is to supplement
now offers an Introduction to Culinary Medicine naturally experiential, social, skills-based, the normal diet and which is a concentrated DS and MVM use were associated with
course focusing on “provider education that higher family income and higher household
and effective in improving nutrition-related source of a vitamin or mineral or other
seeks to incorporate self-care while counseling beliefs, knowledge, and behaviors.”1460 While food security level. DS use was lowest
substance with a nutritional or physiological
and empowering patients to make and sustain the term “culinary nutrition” is often used among children in households participating
effect, alone or in combination and is sold in in the Supplemental Nutrition Assistance
healthier food choices through shopping and interchangeably with culinary medicine, the dose form.”1475 The European Commission
meal preparation,” and provides continuing Program (SNAP; 20%) and those
latter is primarily associated with educating defines food supplements as “concentrated participating in the Special Supplemental
medical education credits and maintenance of physicians and health care workers as well sources of nutrients (or other substances) Nutrition Assistance Program for Women,
certification credits.1469,1470 as physician extenders.1461,1462 Jacqueline B. with a nutritional or physiological effect. Such Infants, and Children (WIC; 26%)
The American College of Lifestyle Medicine Marcus, MS, RDN, author of Culinary Nutrition: food supplements can be marketed in “dose” compared to both income-eligible and
offers an online CME program called Lifestyle The Science and Practice of Healthy Cooking, form, such as pills, tablets, capsules, liquids in income-ineligible nonparticipants. Most
Medicine Core Competencies, which includes writes, “People have integrated nutrition, food measured doses, etc.”1476 children who used DS took only one (83%)
nutrition education alongside other lifestyle science and cooking since the beginning of or two (12%) products; although children
practices such as sleep health, weight time—without even knowing it.” According to the National Health and in low-income families took fewer products
management, and alcohol use.1471 The CME’s Nutrition Examination Survey (NHANES), than those in higher income families.
are offered through a collaboration with Rush The most common motivations for DS
which is conducted annually, about
University Medical Center, American College Dietary Supplements, and MVM use were to “improve (42% or
half of American adults use dietary
of Preventive Medicine and the American 46%)” or “maintain (34 or 38%)” health,
Nutraceuticals and supplements.1477,1478,1479,1480,1481 And that number followed by “to supplement the diet (23
College of Lifestyle Medicine. Functional Foods is on the rise, particularly among athletes and
The Health meets Food Culinary Medicine or 24%)” for DS or MVM, respectively.
those with chronic illnesses.1482,1483,1484 Rates High-income children were more likely to
Program offers a Certified Culinary Medicine Dietary supplements, nutraceuticals of supplement use also tend to vary based use DS and MVM “to supplement the diet”
Specialist program for clinicians to learn (sometimes called “bioceuticals”), and on factors such as income, food security, and than middle- or low-income children. Only
how to “[e]xplore the implications of diet on functional foods are foods, or supplements participation in food assistance programs 18% of child DS users took DS based on
overall health; Enhance the quality of patient to food, that are ingested with the intention (such as SNAP).1485,1486 Based on 2011-2014 a health practitioner’s recommendation.
counseling; [and] Improve the management of providing a physiological or medicinal data from NHANES: In conclusion, DS use was lower among
1472
of diet-related chronic diseases.” This effect.1463,1464,1465 children who were in low-income or food-
is a hybrid program, with some virtual [Dietary supplement (DS)] and insecure families, or families participating
(both live and asynchronous) and some [multivitamin-mineral (MVM)] use was in nutrition assistance programs.1488
in-person components.1473 significantly higher among those with
134 PART III Food as Medicine: Interventions, Programs, Policies and Practices PART III Food as Medicine: Interventions, Programs, Policies and Practices 135
A study appearing in JAMA Internal Medicine by many supplementation programme
analyzing three years (2007-2010) of managers as being the main barriers
Spotlight: National Institutes of Health NHANES data submitted by nearly 12,000 to success.1492
Office of Dietary Supplements (NIH ODS) patients reported that some individuals were
able to articulate specific reasons for taking Despite the prevalence of dietary supplements
recommendations for taking dietary supplements, including the use of calcium (which are often food extracts), studies have
products to promote “bone health.”1511 Most found that most users are not knowledgeable
supplements individuals surveyed, however, could only about the active ingredients, possible side
explain their use of dietary supplements effects, or recommended dosages of what
in general terms, reporting that they used they were taking.1493,1494,1495,1496 Patients’ lack
The NIH ODS recommends that people who are interested in taking dietary supplements
supplements to “improve” or “maintain” of knowledge seems partially attributable
to treat their health conditions keep the following in mind:
overall health.1512 Individuals of all ages use to their lack of communication with medical
supplements. NHANES data from 2006- professionals regarding the potential benefits
● If you are scheduled to have any type of surgical procedure, talk with your health and risks of supplement use.1497,1498,1499 Of
2014 showed that during that time period,
care provider about any supplements you take. those who responded to the NHANES surveys
33.2 percent of children and adolescents in
● Keep in mind the term ‘natural’ doesn’t always mean safe. Some all-natural the United States used dietary supplements between 2007 and 2010, 77 percent had
botanical products, for example, like comfrey and kava, can harm the liver. A dietary (particularly multivitamins, supplements for self-prescribed dietary supplements without
supplement’s safety depends on many things, such as its chemical makeup, how it immunity, omega-3 fatty acids, and sleep consulting a healthcare provider.1500,1501 Many
works in the body, how it is prepared, and the amount you take. aids).1513 However, according to data from the of these individuals further reported that they
2017-2018 NHANES, rates of supplement use avoided discussing the use of supplements
● Before taking any dietary supplement, talk to your health care providers to answer with their physicians because they felt that
tend to increase with age.1514
these questions: their doctors lacked knowledge or were biased
ο What are its potential benefits for me? Supplement use has also been proposed as against the practice.1502,1503
ο Does it have any safety risks? a method to combat nutritional insecurity.1515
ο What is the proper dose to take? The Food and Agricultural Organization of Many patients, physicians, and researchers
ο How, when, and for how long should I take it?1489 the United Nations and the World Health have questioned the safety of taking dietary
Organization released a report back in 2006 supplements.1504,1505,1506 As mentioned above,
The NIH ODS acknowledges the potential health benefits of certain supplements: outlining methods for improving nutritional the NIH ODS warns patients about the
● Calcium and vitamin D help keep bones strong and reduce bone loss. security globally, and included information potential negative effects of supplements’
about dietary supplements.1516 The report interaction with other medicines.1507 Some
● Folic acid decreases the risk of certain birth defects. researchers argue that there is little benefit at
notes that supplementation programs have
● Omega-3 fatty acids from fish oils might help some people with heart disease. been used to improve iron and folic acid all to taking supplements, and are therefore
levels among children, pregnant women, and not worth the potential risk of taking something
● A combination of vitamins C and E, zinc, copper, lutein, and zeaxanthin may slow postpartum women in developing countries.1517 unknown and potentially harmful.1508,1509
down further vision loss in people with age-related macular degeneration (AMD).1490 However, there are some obstacles facing However, in an 11-year study from 1999
these dietary supplementation programs as to 2010, published in Annals of Internal
Furthermore, the NIH ODS notes that consumers should be aware of potential negative noted in this joint report: Medicine in 2019, of 30,899 adults taking
interactions between dietary supplements and pharmaceutical medicines: supplements, researchers found that use of
● Vitamin K can reduce the ability of the blood thinner warfarin to prevent blood Supplementation usually requires dietary supplements was not connected to
from clotting. the procurement and purchase of increased mortality.1510
micronutrients in a relatively expensive
● St. John’s wort can speed the breakdown of many medicines and reduce their pre-packaged form, an effective distribution Supplement Use Among Athletes
effectiveness (including some antidepressants, birth control pills, heart medications, system and a high degree of consumer
anti-HIV medications, and transplant drugs). compliance (especially if supplements The trend of self-prescription also holds
need to be consumed on a long-term among elite athletes, among whom dietary
● Antioxidant supplements, such as vitamins C and E, might reduce the effectiveness basis). A lack of supplies and poor supplement use is significantly more prevalent
of some types of cancer chemotherapy.1491 compliance are consistently reported
136 PART III Food as Medicine: Interventions, Programs, Policies and Practices PART III Food as Medicine: Interventions, Programs, Policies and Practices 137
than it is among average Americans.1518 International Journal of Preventive Medicine,
This heightened frequency of use, defines nutraceuticals as “products, which
however, does not seem to correspond to other than nutrition are also used as
increased scientific knowledge of how these medicine.”1537 According to two research
supplements may impact the body.1519,1520 scientists in a 2020 editorial in the journal
In multiple studies conducted from 2003 Nutrients, “Nutraceuticals and nutrition
to 2021, athletes have reported taking supplements are collectively referred to
supplements to achieve a broad range of as ‘dietary supplements,’ intended to be
health goals, including improved performance, taken orally.”1538
enhanced muscle recovery, and disease
prevention1521,1522,1523,1524,1525,1526,1527 However, there is no official definition of
nutraceutical yet accepted by government
In a 2019 survey of elite athletes in Spain agencies, health care professionals, and
published in the Journal of the International nutrition researchers.1539,1540 “Currently,
Society of Sports Nutrition, more than nutraceuticals do not have a specific definition
60 percent of respondents stated that distinct from those of other food‐derived
they used dietary supplements, including categories, such as food supplements, herbal
supplements that had little evidence products, pre‐ and probiotics, functional foods,
backing their efficacy.1528 Nearly half of the and fortified foods,” write researchers in a
respondents said that they relied primarily 2018 review in the British Journal of Clinical
on themselves as sources of information, Pharmacology.1541 This lack of consensus
rather than a physician, nutritionist, or might lead to confusion about the purpose and
other health care professional.1529 “This efficacy of different products for consumers.1542
information points towards the necessity of According to the researchers:
increasing the knowledge of the benefits and
risks of supplementation in the elite athlete Many studies have led to an understanding
population,” the authors wrote.1530 In addition, of the potential mechanisms of action
a 2010 study published in JAMA Internal of pharmaceutically active components
Medicine showed that the majority of athletes contained in food that may improve
surveyed did not know the active ingredients health and reduce the risk of pathological
conditions while enhancing overall well‐
or mechanisms of action of the supplements
being. Nevertheless, there is a lack of clear
they were taking, and only half of the
information and, often, the claimed health
athletes knew the recommended supplement benefits may not be properly substantiated
dosages.1531 Less than half of these athletes by safety and efficacy information or in
said they consulted their medical providers vitro and in vivo data, which can induce
before starting supplementation.1532 false expectations and miss the target for a
product to be effective, as claimed.1543
Nutraceuticals
The term “nutraceutical” was coined by According to two research scientists in
founder and chairman of the Foundation a 2020 editorial in the journal Nutrients,
for Innovation in Medicine, Stephen “Nutraceuticals and nutrition supplements
DeFelice, in 1989 to describe a food or are collectively referred to as ‘dietary
part of a food with therapeutic benefits, supplements,’ intended to be taken
particularly in the prevention or treatment orally.”1544Well-known nutraceuticals include
of disease.1533,1534,1535,1536 A 2014 review of echinacea, green tea, ginseng, glucosamine,
studies on nutraceuticals, published in the omega-3, folic acid, and cod liver oil.1545
138 PART III Food as Medicine: Interventions, Programs, Policies and Practices PART III Food as Medicine: Interventions, Programs, Policies and Practices 139
The majority of nutraceuticals have multiple based on the assumption that supplement
therapeutic properties and “may be used to products may offer health benefits or ‘immune-
improve health, delay the aging process, boosting’ effects if consumed.”1546,1547,1548,1549,1550
prevent chronic diseases, increase life The increased attention paid to these products
expectancy, or support the structure or raised questions about their safety and efficacy
function of the body.”1558 However, not all in the treatment and prevention of COVID-
nutraceuticals provide the health effects 19.1551 As noted above in dietary supplements,
they purport to: in a 2018 systematic review the NIH ODS cautions patients to be aware
of randomized controlled trials published of potential harmful side effects from the use
in the British Journal of Nutrition studying of supplements, including nutraceuticals.1552
the impact of nutraceutical use on cognition As researchers wrote in a 2021 review in the
among older adults, the researchers “failed to journal mSystems:
locate sufficient evidence to justify long-term
use to improve cognitive function.”1559 The Consumers need to be aware of
researchers also note that further studies are misinformation and false promises
needed to understand the efficacy of certain surrounding some supplements, which
nutraceuticals such as folic acid, curcumin, may be subject to limited regulation by
and Yamabushitake mushroom. Furthermore, authorities. However, considerably more
research is required to determine whether
they write that “the combination of dietary and
dietary supplements and nutraceuticals
nutraceutical interventions may be a promising
exhibit prophylactic and therapeutic
strategy to improve cognitive function.”1560 value against SARS-CoV-2 infection
and COVID-19.1553
Despite the lack of evidence about the
impact of certain nutraceuticals on health, For example, elderberry (which is often
the market for these products is growing.1561 hypothesized to have antiviral properties1554)
While investigating the commercialization has been a nutraceutical of interest in the
of food and medicine, Lisa Haushofer, MD, treatment and prevention of COVID-19.1555
PhD, a senior research associate at the However, there is little conclusive evidence
Institute for Biomedical Ethics and History of about its efficacy;1556 furthermore, elderberry
Medicine at the University of Zurich, noted that has potentially dangerous side effects
“the nutraceutical and health foods markets (including nausea, vomiting, diarrhea, and
are among the fastest growing and most others) and cannot be consumed raw or
promising markets worldwide.”1562 According undercooked, so patients should be very
to Precedence Research, a worldwide market cautious with this nutraceutical.1557
research and consulting organization, in 2020
the global nutraceuticals market size was
valued at $160.3 billion and is expected to rise
to $314.2 billion by 2030.1563
140 PART III Food as Medicine: Interventions, Programs, Policies and Practices PART III Food as Medicine: Interventions, Programs, Policies and Practices 141
In addition to increased use of nutraceuticals ● Processed foods containing ingredients
that aid specific bodily functions in addition
Spotlight: Food for Specified Health Uses
from the COVID-19 pandemic, several other
factors have contributed to the popularity to being nutritious.1583
in Japan of nutraceuticals as an area of research
and treatment. Research has demonstrated Christiani Jeyakumar Henry, PhD, MSc, the
that nutraceuticals may have a lower risk of director of the Clinical Nutrition Research
Japan was one of the first governments to regulate functional foods and explore the addiction and serious side effects than many Centre at the Agency for Science, Technology
health benefits of foods through robust research and testing.1565,1566,1567 The Japanese current pharmaceutical treatments for pain and Research (A*STAR) in Singapore and the
Ministry of Health, Labor, and Welfare oversees the approval process for these foods, and serious disease.1586,1587,1588 (Note that more Deputy Executive Director at the Singapore
which are called Food for Specified Health Uses (FOSHU).1568,1569 To be approved for a clinical research is needed to understand the Institute of Food Biotechnology and Innovation
FOSHU label, a food must meet the following requirements: potential use of nutraceuticals in managing (SIFBI), wrote about the start of the functional
pain.)1589,1590 Given that nutraceuticals are food movement in the European Journal of
● “Effectiveness on the human body is clearly proven derived from food, they may also be less Clinical Nutrition:
expensive to produce than most conventional
● Absence of any safety issues (animal toxicity tests, confirmation of effects in the pharmaceuticals.1591 Finally, the rising The conviction to develop functional foods
cases of excess intake, etc.) interest in nutraceuticals may follow the rising first emerged in Japan in the 1980s when
● Use of nutritionally appropriate ingredients (e.g. no excessive use of salt, etc.) consumer demand in the intersection of food faced with escalating health-care costs.
and health.1592 The Ministry of Health and Welfare initiated
● Guarantee of compatibility with product specifications by the time of consumption a regulatory system to approve certain
foods with documented health benefits.
● Established quality control methods, such as specifications of products and Functional Foods
Its primary objective was to improve the
ingredients, processes, and methods of analysis”1570 Functional foods, defined by researcher health of the nation’s ageing population.
Marcello Nicoletti, a professor of In 1984, the Ministry of Education,
Furthermore, there are three other types of FOSHU: Qualified (scientific evidence Environmental Biology at Sapienza University Science and Culture, an ad hoc group
is minimal and has not met the standard for an approved FOSHU), Standardized of Rome, are “foods or food ingredients that in Japan commenced a national project
(functional attributes of ingredients in a product have already been approved as have additional health or physiological benefits to explore the link between food and
individual FOSHU, and the foods therefore do not always require clinical trials), and over and above the normal nutritional value medical sciences. The term ‘functional
reduction of disease risk (there is sufficient clinical evidence that a certain food or they provide.”1593 Typically, the distinction food’ first appeared in 1993 in the Nature
ingredient is connected to lowered risk of a certain disease).1571
between nutraceuticals and functional foods news magazine under the heading ‘Japan
lies in how they are ingested: “nutraceuticals” explores the boundary between food
Since 2012, more than 1,000 products have consistently held an approved FOSHU
are supplements that are not consumed as and medicine’.1584
label. 1572,1573 FOSHUs can be approved for certain specified uses: changing
gastrointestinal health, lowering blood cholesterol, regulating blood sugar levels, conventional food or drink, whereas “functional
foods” are consumed as conventional food Dr. Henry, a world renowned expert on
impacting blood pressure, assisting in dental hygiene, aiding in mineral absorption, and functional foods, also described functional
encouraging bone growth. 1574, 1575, 1576 or drink.1594
foods as the following:
Japan has one of the lowest rates of obesity and highest average lifespans in the world, While there is no universal and unanimous
1577, 1578
and some researchers have argued that diet play a role in these statistics. 1579, definition of a functional food, several options ● Conventional food containing naturally
1580,1581
“We need to increase the evidence base of the impact of the whole Japanese in various languages have been proposed to occurring bioactive substance. An example
dietary lifestyle on health as well as having specific studies on the functionality and the Food and Agriculture Organization of the could be β-glucan in oat bran to lower
health benefits of individual food items,” said Eriko Komiya, Director of Food Cultures United Nations, including: blood cholesterol; [Note: β-glucan is a
Office in the Japanese Ministry of Agriculture Forestry and Fisheries, in an article for water-soluble dietary fiber found in the cell
Nature. 1582 walls of plants]1585
● A foodstuff that provides a health benefit
beyond basic nutrition, demonstrating ● Foods that have been modified, by
specific health or medical benefits, enrichment or other means, with bioactive
including the prevention and treatment substances. An example could be
of disease. margarine that contains added phytosterol
that is known to lower serum cholesterol;
142 PART III Food as Medicine: Interventions, Programs, Policies and Practices PART III Food as Medicine: Interventions, Programs, Policies and Practices 143
● Synthesized food ingredients, such as Additional Examples of Dietary Many dietary supplements, nutraceuticals, ● Green Tea: The NCCIH writes, “Green tea
some specialized carbohydrates intended Supplements, Nutraceuticals, and and functional foods are used by consumers as a beverage or dietary supplement is
to have probiotic effects. Functional Foods across the world to help manage their promoted for improving mental alertness,
health. The National Institutes of Health has relieving digestive symptoms and
● A functional food can be (1) a natural food, Certain foods have been proven to support numerous resources that provide current, headaches, and promoting weight loss.”1645
(2) a food to which a component has been general health in addition to being effective in evidence-based information for consumers However, there is insufficient evidence
added, (3) a food from which a component the treatment, co-treatment, and prevention and health care providers about many different to definitely conclude that green tea is
has been removed, (4) a food where one of specific disease states.1610,1611,1612 Research foods and supplements. Below is information effective for these purposes.
or more components has been modified, has demonstrated that functional dietary from the National Institutes of Health, including
(5) a food in which the bioavailability has changes can impact an individual’s heart, ● Niacin: Niacin, also called vitamin B3,
the Office of Dietary Supplements (NIH ODS),
been modified or (6) any combination brain, and bone health: is a nutrient with many uses, including
the National Center of Complementary and
of these.1595 ● Heart Health: Nuts and seeds have been assisting the body to turn food into
Integrative Health (NCCIH), and the National
shown to help lower cholesterol.1613,1614,1615 energy, maintenance of genome integrity,
Library of Medicine, about some popular
Functional foods are often used by consumers Fish oil and olive oil can help reduce control of gene expression, and cellular
supplements and functional foods:
seeking optimal health and prevention or inflammation, which is associated with communication.1646 It is found in a variety of
● Capsicum: Also known as red pepper or foods (including animal foods and certain
treatment of disease, and do not need to heart disease.1616,1617 More specifically, fish chili pepper, the capsicum plant contains
be used under the supervision of a health contains omega-3 fatty acids, which can types of nuts, legumes, and grains), but it
a chemical called capsaicin, which is can also be added to some food products
care professional.1596,1597,1598,1599 For example, lower blood fats (triglycerides).1618,16191620 commonly used to reduce pain from a or purchased as a supplement.1647
probiotics, commonly found in fermented dairy Whole grains consumption has also
products, are often considered to be functional been associated with reduced levels
variety of chronic conditions, including Insufficient niacin can lead to a skin
diabetic neuropathy, arthritis, and
foods for their benefits to the gastrointestinal of homocysteine,1621 an amino acid condition called pellagra, characterized by
others.1639 The National Library of Medicine a roughened, sunburned-like appearance
tract by balancing the gut microbiome associated with heart disease.1622 notes that while capsaicin has also been and pigmented rash.1648 However, the NIH
to potentially relieve gastrointestinal
discomfort.1600,1601 Many health care ● Brain Health: Peanuts, eggs, fish, meat, used for issues such as indigestion ODS warns that taking too much niacin
and other foods that are high in choline problems, “but there is no good scientific can lead to negative side effects such as
professionals and scientists consider all fruits
elevate acetylcholine, a neurotransmitter evidence for many of these uses.”1640 headaches, rashes, and dizziness.1649
and vegetables to be functional foods due to
responsible for healthy mental ● Cranberry: According to the NCCIH,
their rich amounts of important compounds
function.1623,1624,1625 Vitamin E is a fat- ● Omega-3 Fatty Acids: Found in foods
such as fiber and antioxidants.1602,1603 “Historically, cranberry fruits or leaves such as fish and flaxseed, as well as
soluble antioxidant that helps protect the
Functional foods can also be foods that
fatty environment of the brain.1626,1627,1628
were used for bladder, stomach, and liver supplements such as fish oil, omega-3
are fortified or otherwise enhanced with disorders, as well as diabetes, wounds, fatty acids are a collection of three
vitamins, nutrients, phytochemicals, or other And whole grains rich in vitamin B, such and other conditions.”1641 Today, cranberry
as brown rice or barley, help reduce levels fatty acids that partially make up cell
components that have health benefits.1604 is most often associated with treatment membranes.1650 One of these three acids
These are often called “fortified foods,” and of homocysteine, which is associated with of UTIs, and generally studies show that
dementia.1629,1630,1631 Migraines can be cannot be produced by the body, so it
include milk with added vitamin D, iodized salt, cranberry products reduce the risk of UTIs; must come from food; the other two can
or cereals with added folic acid.1605,1606 attributed to a diet lacking in folate (found however, there have been inconsistent
in leafy greens).1632 be produced by the body in very small
results among various populations.1642 amounts, so getting them from foods is
The FDA has no official definition for ● Bone Health: Calcium fortifies bones, ● Garlic: Garlic, a popular cooking much more practical.1651
“functional food,”1607 so the phrase often and vitamin D plays an essential role
ends up as a marketing term for various in calcium absorption.1633 Milk, salmon,
ingredient, is also commonly available as ● Potassium: Potassium is found in a
a dietary supplement. It is most commonly variety of foods: bananas, potatoes,
food products.1608 Interest in and demand and dark green vegetables all contain associated with treating heart and blood spinach, kidney beans, and much more.1652
for functional foods is growing in the United calcium. Almost all milk sold in the United conditions, such as high blood cholesterol According to the NIH ODS, “Your body
States and globally,1609 so consumers should States is fortified with vitamin D,1634 and and high blood pressure.1643 However,
be encouraged to inform themselves about sunlight helps your body create vitamin needs potassium for almost everything it
the NCCIH notes that there is conflicting
the functions and benefits that different foods D.1635 Magnesium (found in almonds, does, including proper kidney and heart
evidence about the impact of garlic on function, muscle contraction, and nerve
claim to have. lentils, seeds, and spinach) works in cholesterol and blood pressure.1644 To read transmission.”1653 However, abnormally
conjunction with calcium to promote more about garlic as medicine, see the
bone health.1636,1637,1638 high levels of potassium, a condition
Spotlight on page 32.
144 PART III Food as Medicine: Interventions, Programs, Policies and Practices PART III Food as Medicine: Interventions, Programs, Policies and Practices 145
● called hyperkalemia (most common in ● Lowering Cholesterol: Some studies have
people with chronic kidney disease), can reported that phytosterols, a component
cause muscle weakness, numbness, of plant cell membranes commonly used
tingling, nausea, and other symptoms in as additives in food products, reduce
some patients.1693 “bad” low-density lipoprotein (LDL)
cholesterol by decreasing the amount
● Probiotics: Probiotics are defined by the
the body produces and absorbs into the
NIH ODS as “live microorganisms (such
gastrointestinal tract.1654,1655,1656,1657,1658
as bacteria and yeasts) that provide
Other nutraceuticals in a few studies
health benefits when you consume
have demonstrated potential in reducing
them.”1694 Probiotic food products include
cholesterol and include the polyphenols
dairy products such as yogurt as well as
in durian (an edible fruit),1659,1660 certain
certain non-dairy fermented foods.1695
kinds of green tea,1661,1662 Annurca apple
As noted above in Functional Foods,
polyphenolic extract,1663,1664,1665,1666 and
probiotics are often considered to be
a formulation that includes berberine
functional foods for their benefits to the
(“a chemical found in some plants
gastrointestinal tract.1696,1697
like European barberry, goldenseal,
● Vitamin D: Vitamin D is used by the goldthread, Oregon grape, phellodendron,
human body for many functions, including and tree turmeric,” according to the
calcium absorption, muscle movement, National Library of Medicine1667) and red
and maintaining the immune system.1698 yeast rice.1668,1669,1670,1671
According to the NIH ODS, “Very few
● Cancer: Cancer researchers are interested
foods naturally contain vitamin D. ” They
in the potential for nutraceuticals to
note, however, that fatty fish, such as
provide lower-cost, reduced-risk ways
trout, salmon, tuna, and mackerel, is a
of managing and treating the disease.
good natural source of vitamin D.1699 Many
For example, butein is a polyphenol, are
foods are thus fortified with vitamin D,
“common antioxidants present in a large
such as cow’s milk, plant-based milk, and
number of foods and beverages of plant
breakfast cereals.1700
origin,” 1672 with a history of use in many
East Asian traditional medical practices
Note: See Office of Dietary Supplements’ for its anticancer effects.1673,1674 In a few
Dietary Supplement Fact Sheets, the National studies, butein has been shown to have
Center of Complementary and Integrative the ability to induce death in cancer
Health’s Health Topics, and the National cells.1675,1676,1677,1678,1679,1680 In addition,
Library of Medicine’s Medline Plus to learn phytosterols (plant-derived sterols
more about specific foods and supplements. similar in structure to cholesterol1681,1682)
in three types of algae have shown
Although extensive research into the anticancer effects in a small group of
various kinds of nutraceuticals and dietary studies.1683,1684,1685,1686 There is also interest
supplements, their medical applications, and in finding applications for the management
the potential risks associated with their use and treatment of cancer in lactic acid
remains to be done, early studies have shown bacteria (LAB),1687,1688,1689,1690,1691 which
certain supplements may have potential for is prevalent in cultured and fermented
managing and treating disease. These include: foods.1692
146 PART III Food as Medicine: Interventions, Programs, Policies and Practices PART III Food as Medicine: Interventions, Programs, Policies and Practices 147
● Neurological Disorders: Neurological of a wide range of diseases;1732,1733 and
disorders have a variety of causes curcumin, a polyphenol found in turmeric,
and risk factors, including stressful life has also been found to have capabilities
events, psychological comorbidities, in both the prevention and treatment of
advanced age, and smoking .1701,1702,1703 inflammatory conditions.1734,1735,1736
Over time, the brain undergoes
oxidative stress, which plays a key role
Regulation of Dietary Supplements,
in numerous neurological disorders,
Nutraceuticals and Functional Foods
including Alzheimer’s disease (AD).1704,1705
Antioxidants can be found in many food Unlike pharmaceuticals, which are significantly
products, including curcumin, which is regulated by the FDA, dietary supplements
an antioxidant found in turmeric1706,1707,1708 do not require FDA approval.1737,1738 Marketers
and the flavonoids in wine and tea, are allowed to make statements about the
may, according to some studies, help potential health benefits of the supplement,
to slow the progress of AD and similar however, the following qualifier is required:
conditions.1709,1710,1711,1712 In addition, many “This statement has not been evaluated
neurological disorders, such as Multiple by the Food and Drug Administration. This
Sclerosis (MS), are caused by improper product is not intended to diagnose, treat,
folding of proteins in the brain, a process cure, or prevent any disease.”1739 (According
that vitamin A,1713,1714 β-carotene,1715,1716 to a 2019 review of labeling impacts on
and coenzyme Q10 (CoQ10)1717,1718,1719 consumer behavior in The Journal of Alternative
all may help to combat.1720 The decline and Complementary Medicine, “Many consumers
in function associated with Parkinson’s did not regularly read product labels, nor
disease (PD) results from a drastic drop in understand the information they read on those
the brain’s dopamine levels, and lycopene, labels.”1740) The lack of regulation has led
an antioxidant found in tomatoes, to the production and sale of supplements
papayas, and other red fruits and that do not always contain the ingredients
vegetables, has been shown to increase and quantities that the labels say they
dopamine in mice, suggesting it may do.1741,1742 Third party groups, such as United
have potential for managing the disease States Pharmacopeia (USP) and NSF
in humans.1721,1722,1723 International,1743,1744 have thus stepped in to
test various dietary supplements (including
● Inflammation: Certain nutraceuticals have vitamins, minerals, herbal supplements,
proven effective as anti-inflammatories, and others) and verify what exactly is in
showing potential on diseases such them.1745,1746 Consumers therefore are
as cancer, neurological disorders, encouraged to take special caution when
and arthritis.1724,1725,1726 For example, choosing to take dietary supplements.1747
ergosterol from edible mushrooms has
been shown to reduce inflammatory Furthermore, as mentioned earlier in
responses,1727,1728,1729 as have lactic this report, the terms “nutraceutical” and
acid bacteria1730 and some chemical “functional food” have no formal definitions
compounds such as tocopherols and from the FDA.1748,1749 Instead, these products
tocotrienols in the vitamin E family, found are regulated as drugs, dietary supplements,
in seeds, nuts, and many vegetables.1731 or foods, depending on their ingredients and
Polyphenols, found in olive oil, cocoa, and intended use.1750 As researchers for the the
berries, have been found to have anti- British Journal of Pharmacology wrote in 2016:
inflammatory properties in the treatment
148 PART III Food as Medicine: Interventions, Programs, Policies and Practices PART III Food as Medicine: Interventions, Programs, Policies and Practices 149
The terms “nutraceutical” and “functional more informed decisions about the treatments guidelines define vitamin and mineral food Clear definitions and regulation of functional
food” are often used interchangeably and they pursue for their specific condition,1751 but supplements as products that: foods and nutraceuticals will help improve
have no legal definition in most countries. the regulations have received criticism from consumer understanding of the effects of
These products are intended to have Canada’s food industry for potentially stifling …derive their nutritional relevance their food choices on their health while
health benefits in addition to their basic innovation.1752 primarily from the minerals and/or vitamins simultaneously promoting the expansion of
nutritional value and usually contain they contain. Vitamin and mineral food evidence-based food as medicine practices
ingredients which are referred to as supplements are sources in concentrated
In the European Union, discussions are and programs.1776
generally recognized as safe (GRAS) in forms of those nutrients alone or in
ongoing in the European Parliament (EP)
the United States and elsewhere and as combinations, marketed in forms such as
as to whether nutraceuticals are medicinal Furthermore, there are three other types
qualified presumption of safety (QPS) in capsules, tablets, powders, solutions, etc.,
products, defined by the legislative body as of FOSHU: Qualified (scientific evidence is
the European Union (EU).1760 that are designed to be taken in measured
“any substance or combination of substances minimal and has not met the standard for an
small-unit quantities but are not in a
The lack of standards and regulations has presented as having properties for treating or approved FOSHU), Standardized (functional
conventional food form and whose purpose
led to the dissemination of misinformation by preventing disease in human beings.”1753 The is to supplement the intake of vitamins attributes of ingredients in a product have
supplement companies and confusion among debate is not regarding whether food products and/or minerals from the normal diet.1771 already been approved as individual FOSHU,
consumers.1761,1762 In 2019, the FDA issued a can have beneficial impacts on human health and the foods therefore do not always require
warning to 12 dietary supplement companies, or not, but whether they have sufficient These Guidelines were developed to clinical trials), and reduction of disease risk
telling them to stop making claims that their medical properties for that to be considered establish international agreement about the (there is sufficient clinical evidence that a
products could cure various diseases, most their primary function.1754 Lex Mundi, a composition, packaging, and labeling of certain food or ingredient is connected to
notably Alzheimer’s.1763 Scott Gottlieb, MD, worldwide network of independent law firms, vitamin and mineral supplements.1772 However, lowered risk of a certain disease).1777
former commissioner of the FDA, said about released a report in 2012 outlining policy the Codex Alimentarius has no regulatory
the warning, “[U]nproven supplements that regulations of food supplements in various power, and therefore countries are not Since 2012, more than 1,000 products have
claim to treat the disease but offer no benefits countries around the world.1755 obligated to enforce any guidelines included consistently held an approved FOSHU
can prevent patients from seeking otherwise in it.1773 Still, at the time, American consumers label.1778,1779 FOSHUs can be approved
effective care.”1764 In 2005, the Codex Alimentarius Commission were concerned, as a result of these concerns, for certain specified uses: changing
(CAC), established by the Food and the FDA gave assurances that the adoption of gastrointestinal health, lowering blood
Warnings such as these shed light on the Agriculture Organization of the United Nations the Guidelines for Vitamin and Mineral Food cholesterol, regulating blood sugar levels,
need for stricter regulation in this industry.1765 (FAO) and the World Health Organization Supplements “will not restrict U.S. consumers’ impacting blood pressure, assisting in dental
Establishing standards for testing and (WHO), developed the “Guidelines for Vitamin access to vitamin and mineral supplements or hygiene, aiding in mineral absorption, and
proving the safety and efficacy of dietary and Mineral Food Supplements” and adopted impose any restrictions that go beyond those encouraging bone growth.1780,1781,1782
supplements, nutraceuticals and functional them into the Codex Alimentarius,1756,1757 an established by U.S. law.”1774
foods is critical to advancing the research international collection of standards, guidelines In a review of nutraceutical regulation for the Japan has one of the lowest rates of
into their potential as treatments for disease and codes of practice about food and food British Journal of Pharmacology, researchers obesity and highest average lifespans in
alongside conventional pharmaceuticals.1766,1767 safety.1758 (See Part 2 to learn more about the from the University of Napoli Federico II, the the world,1783,1784 and some researchers
Such peer-reviewed scientific research and Codex Alimentarius.) Italian Medicine Agency, and the University of have argued that diet play a role in these
governmental regulation would also help to Miami write: statistics.1785,1786,1787 “We need to increase the
distinguish legitimate claims made for the According to a 2018 review in the Annual evidence base of the impact of the whole
efficacy of these types of treatments from Review of Public Health, the “Guidelines ...a restructuring of the entire regulatory Japanese dietary lifestyle on health as well
unsubstantiated claims made on behalf of for Vitamin and Mineral Food Supplements” framework of dietary supplements in view as having specific studies on the functionality
dietary supplements.1768 “apply only to supplements that contain of the role of nutraceuticals is deemed and health benefits of individual food
Conversations about the regulation of vitamins and/or minerals where these products necessary to first give credit to their items,” said Eriko Komiya, Director of Food
functional foods and nutraceuticals are not are regulated as foods, and they address the different purposes and definition, and Cultures Office in the Japanese Ministry of
limited to the United States.1769 In Canada, composition of supplements, including their second, to assess their specific role in the Agriculture Forestry and Fisheries, in an article
functional foods and nutraceuticals such as safety, purity, and bioavailability.”1759 Note that prevention and treatment of pathological for Nature.1788
probiotics or herbal supplements are regulated conditions, supporting their potential
these guidelines do not include regulations
medical use in prevention and therapy
as “natural health products.”1770 These for products such as functional foods, herbal
only when proven by sound scientific and
regulations exist to help consumers make supplements, fatty acids, or amino acids. The clinical data.1775
150 PART III Food as Medicine: Interventions, Programs, Policies and Practices PART III Food as Medicine: Interventions, Programs, Policies and Practices 151
Medical Foods [The] FDA narrowly defines the conditions regulations; (2) a color additive used ● products with a full complement of
under which a medical food may be marketed: in accordance with the color additive nutrients except the offending nutrient
Medical foods are defined by the FDA as foods regulations; (3) a substance that is (eg, phenylalanine or tyrosine), including
“formulated to be consumed or administered generally recognized, by qualified experts, Lofenalac, Ketonex-2, or Propimex;
enterally under the supervision of a physician 1. It must be a specially formulated and to be safe under the conditions of its
and which [are] intended for the specific processed product (as opposed to intended use (GRAS); or (4) a substance ● modular products, such as ready-to-
dietary management of a disease or condition a naturally occurring foodstuff used that is authorized by a prior sanction drink beverages, tablets, and amino acid
for which distinctive nutritional requirements, in its natural state) for the partial issued by FDA.1793 mixtures, including GlutarAde and Foltx.1796
based on recognized scientific principles, are or exclusive feeding of a patient
by means of oral intake or enteral Some examples of medical foods include
established by medical evaluation.”1789 These
feeding by tube; formulas for enteral administration (feeding
foods are exempt from usual health claim
tubes)1794 and infant formula.1795 Today’s
regulation for foods, and the FDA does not
2. It must be intended for the dietary Dietitian provides further examples:
maintain a comprehensive list of approved
medical foods.1790 management of a patient who,
because of therapeutic or chronic
medical needs, has limited or
Food Interventions, Reimbursement, and
Medical foods are meant to be consumed
under the supervision of a physician by impaired capacity to ingest, digest,
Health Insurance
patients who have “limited or impaired absorb, or metabolize ordinary
capacity to ingest, digest, absorb, or foodstuffs or certain nutrients, or
metabolize ordinary foodstuffs or certain who has other special medically
determined nutrient requirements, the Some insurance plans, well aware of the
nutrients, or who has other special medically
dietary management of which cannot From the late 2000s to the early 2010s, healthcare costs associated with poor diet,
determined nutrient requirements, the dietary
be achieved by the modification of health insurers have come under scrutiny for have started to include financial coverage
management of which cannot be achieved by
spending less on care and more on lobbying for food interventions, including meals and
the modification of the normal diet alone.”1791 the normal diet alone;
and marketing costs in order to increase groceries.1809,1810,1811 “[I]nsurers... have to
Generally, though, medical foods do not
3. It must provide nutritional support profits.1797,1798,1799,1800 The Affordable Care accurately predict how much the people
require a prescription to be purchased;
instead, health insurance companies might specifically modified for the Act, passed in 2010, attempted to curtail this they insure will cost. That way they can
management of the unique nutrient trend by requiring that companies spend 80 set premiums to cover those costs,” wrote
require a physician’s order or issuance in order
to cover the cost of the product.1792 According needs that result from the specific percent of premiums they receive on patient journalist Marshall Allan for NPR.1812 Since the
disease or condition, as determined claims.1801,1802,1803,1804,1805 Many companies have Affordable Care Act requires health insurance
to the book Developing New Functional Food
by medical evaluation; responded by simply raising their premiums, companies to spend at least 80 percent of
and Nutraceutical Products:
thus increasing the amount of money they premiums on care (rather than administrative
4. It must be intended to be used under get to keep for administrative uses and as costs),1813 higher healthcare costs (resulting
medical supervision; and profit.1806 Health insurers have also been from rising rates of diet-related disease)
implicated in agreements with client hospitals could complicate these calculations for some
5. It must be intended only for a that set inflated rates for medical care, insurance companies and cut into their
patient receiving active and ongoing causing the United States to spend more profits.1814
medical supervision wherein the on health care per person than any other
patient requires medical care on developed nation, according to statistics from Numerous health insurers across the
a recurring basis for, among other the Organisation for Economic Co-operation country have begun coverage for food
things, instructions on the use of the and Development, an international economic interventions, such as home-delivered
medical food. organization with 35 member states.1807 And, meals, healthy grocery stipends, and
in another alarming trend, the COVID-19 nutrition education.1815,1816 Food interventions
In terms of ingredients that may be used in pandemic has seen many of the nation’s provided through the healthcare system can
medical foods, the ingredients should
largest insurance companies, including help patients manage their chronic disease
be either (1) a food additive used in
Humana, Anthem, and UnitedHealth Group, while simultaneously addressing food
accordance with FDA’s food additive
double their earnings.1808 insecurity.1817,1818 “[F]inancial support for food is
medicine interventions in the healthcare
152 PART III Food as Medicine: Interventions, Programs, Policies and Practices PART III Food as Medicine: Interventions, Programs, Policies and Practices 153
system might be effective and expedient ways Conflicts of Interest: Health Medicine, and one of the co-authors of the Medicaid: Numerous state Medicaid programs
to improve both food insecurity and health, Insurance Companies and the aforementioned American Journal of Public have incorporated food interventions in
even if they do not comprehensively tackle the Health study, said, “If the insurance industry their coverage, including Virginia, Michigan,
Fast Food Industry
root structural causes of suboptimal diet,” write is willing to invest in products known to be and North Carolina.1845 In Virginia, various
researchers led by Sarah Downer, Clinical It is also important to note the significant harmful and/or kill people then, prima facie, Medicaid Managed Care programs include
Instructor at the Center for Health Law and financial investments that some health and this is not an industry that actually cares about benefits such as home-delivered meals and
Policy Innovation of Harvard Law School and life insurers have in the fast food industry.1826 health and well-being.”1842 Spokespeople for free transportation to farmers’ markets and
Director of the Center’s Whole Person Care A 2010 study in the American Journal of some of the companies mentioned in the grocery stores.1846 Michigan has a policy that
Initiative, for the BMJ.1819 The authors note that Public Health found that insurers such as article disputed the claims.1843 requires their Medicaid contractors to measure
this financial support can come from health Metlife (life, dental, disability, and critical and report on food access for clients, as well
insurers: illness insurance), Prudential (life insurance), The authors concluded that there are two as provide resources to clients to help them
New York Life (life insurance), Northwestern ethical options for insurers to consider access food.1847 North Carolina’s Medicaid
In the U.S., government and private health Mutual (life, disability, and long-term care regarding their investments: program includes an initiative called “Healthy
insurers are adopting food and nutrition insurance), among others, have millions of Opportunities,” which provides funding to
interventions in the hope of a return on dollars in holdings in fast food companies such The first is to divest themselves of holdings various non-medical pilot programs to improve
their investment due to reductions in high as McDonald’s, Jack in the Box, and Burger in fast food companies as well as other health, including food interventions such
expenditure healthcare claims. In light industries that have a clearly negative as healthy food boxes, fruit and vegetable
King.1827 Frequent fast food consumption has
of emerging evidence, policy makers public health impact. Socially responsible
been linked to poor health and increased prescriptions, healthy meals, and medically
are experimenting with loosening the investment funds have shown that profits tailored meals.1848,1849
parameters of value based or capitated risk of diet-related disease such as diabetes
are not incompatible with social good.
payment structures to allow public and obesity.1828,1829,1830 In the journal Nutrition
insurance money to be spent on food Reviews in 2013, researchers wrote: Medicare Advantage: As of 2019, more
A second option is that insurers could
is medicine interventions. This flexibility mitigate the harms of fast food by
than 20 million people were enrolled in a
can be expanded, administratively or Consumption of takeaway and fast leveraging their positions as owners of fast Medicare Advantage program (sometimes
through legislation, to all public health food has been shown to have adverse food companies to force the adoption of called “Part C” or “MA Plans”), a type of health
insurance programmes. However, large health effects, and while the majority practices consistent with widely accepted insurance that provides Medicare benefits
scale uptake of newly created flexibility to of studies on this subject have focused public health principles. Such moves through contracting a private health insurance
pay for food depends on confidence that on the relationship between fast food could include encouraging companies company.1850 According to the Kaiser Family
food is medicine interventions are clinically consumption and weight gain,1831,1832,1833 to improve the nutritional quality of their Foundation, almost half (46 percent) of
effective and cost effective compared with more frequent consumption of meals products, reduce calorie density, serve Medicare Advantage plans offer some type of
other aspects of medical care.1820 prepared outside of the home has also smaller portions, and change marketing meal benefits,1851 such as nutrition education,
been observed to correspond with practices. To maximize their impact,
increased risk of insulin resistance, type cooking classes, or meal delivery.1852 These
Access to nutritious food is considered a social insurers might turn over their proxy votes nutrition related programs are part of Medicare
determinant of health by the U.S. Department 2 diabetes, elevated total cholesterol, to an independent nonprofit organization
and low-density lipoprotein cholesterol Advantage’s attempt to increase their available
of Health and Human Services’ Healthy that could pool votes in a way that effects
“health-related benefits” in order to improve
(LDL-C) levels as well as decreased high- meaningful change.1844
People 2030.1821 (According to the U.S. patient health and lifestyle before they even
density lipoprotein cholesterol (HDL-C)
Department of Health and Human Services: concentrations.1834,1835,1836 Takeaway or go to the doctor.1853 One study of these
“Social determinants of health [SDOH] are the fast food consumers are characterized programs in the journal Health Affairs found
conditions in the environments where people by higher intakes of energy, fat, saturated that participants in a meal delivery program
are born, live, learn, work, play, worship,
Health Insurance Plans Adopting
fatty acids (SFAs), trans fatty acids required fewer emergency health services.1854
and age that affect a wide range of health, (TFAs), added sugar and sodium, and Food as Medicine Programs
functioning, and quality-of-life outcomes lower intakes of fiber, macronutrients, Several health insurers, both public and Oscar Health: At the outset of the COVID-19
and risks.”1822) Therefore, covering the cost and vitamins in comparison to those
private, have incorporated food as medicine pandemic, Oscar Health reported that
of nutritious food may be a way for health who do not eat food prepared outside
coverage in their plans. See below for a 30 percent of their Medicare Advantage
insurance companies to reduce clients’ health the home.1837,1838,1839,1840,1841
customers had food supply problems, and
list of programs and plans that include
care costs by improving their food security they responded to this obstacle by arranging
food interventions.
and, ultimately, their health.1823,1824,1825 Wes Boyd, MD, PhD, a professor of Medical
complimentary grocery deliveries from local
Ethics and Psychiatry at Baylor College of
154 PART III Food as Medicine: Interventions, Programs, Policies and Practices PART III Food as Medicine: Interventions, Programs, Policies and Practices 155
grocery stores.1855 The insurer acknowledges Humana: Health insurance company and beverages) from specific retailers.1867 The fee to avoid delivery charges.1871 The program
the steep costs of hospital visits and believes Humana has a few programs that integrate card acts like a debit card loaded with $25 or ran for six months in 2019; however, at the
that training people to eat a more nutritious food and medicine. In an interview with the $50 per month.1868 This benefit is available to time of publication (February 2022) the FoodQ
diet is a cheaper alternative to costly medical Associated Press, Andrew Renda, MD, MPH, enrollees in Humana’s Medicare Advantage website is not operational.1872
care.1856 Ananth Lalithakumar, an executive at Vice President of Bold Goal and Population plans.
Oscar Health, stated that, “We’ve seen time Health Strategy at Humana, said that there Blue Shield of California: In 2021, health
and again, the lack of food and nutritional is research demonstrating that diabetes Blue Cross Blue Shield: Health Care insurance company Blue Shield of California
food causes members to get readmitted” patients make visits to the emergency room Service Corporation, the parent company of (an independent member of the Blue Shield
to hospitals.1857 when access to food is difficult: “It may be Blue Cross Blue Shield in Texas, Oklahoma, Association) expanded its Wellvolution lifestyle
because they’re still taking their medications New Mexico, Montana, and Illinois, launched program (a platform that connects participants
Health Partner Plans: In 2015, Health but don’t have enough food, so that their blood a prepared meal delivery pilot program, with curated programs to manage a “healthy
Partners Plans (HPP), a Philadelphia-based sugar goes crazy and then they end up in the called FoodQ, for residents of 25 Illinois zip lifestyle,” such as weight loss, mental health,
insurance company, piloted a medically hospital.”1865 One of the programs offered by codes and 15 Dallas zip codes.1869 Many of and smoking)1873 to include nutrition support for
tailored meal program among 30 people Humana to address this problem is called the the residents of the chosen zip codes have members living with type 2 diabetes.1874 Low-
who were living with diabetes.1858 The 30 Well Dine program: difficulty accessing nutritious food because of income members of Blue Shield are eligible
enrollees received three meals per day and transportation barriers or a lack of availability to receive six months of free diabetes-friendly
were supported by phone by case managers. Well Dine delivers fully prepared, nutritious of nutritious foods in their communities.1870 meals provided by health care company Betr
The results were so successful that HPP meals to eligible Humana Medicare- Recipients could purchase meals for $5-$10 Health.1875,1876
transformed the pilot into an established covered patients recovering at home from each, and pay a $10 per month subscription
program.1859 As of July 2018, the program had an inpatient stay in a hospital or skilled
delivered 610,500 meals to more than 2,400 nursing facility (SNF) or enrolled in a
members, more than 13 percent of whom were qualified chronic-condition special needs
plan (SNP), dual-eligible SNP or Illinois
people with diabetes. Tracking outcomes, they
Medicare-Medicaid plan. Patients also
found that hospital admissions dropped nearly
receive a guide to nutrition and eating well.
28 percent, emergency room visits nearly 7
percent, primary care visits nearly 16 percent, Meals are provided by a Humana vendor
and visits to specialists over 7 percent.1860 As and delivered by FedEx or UPS. Post-
of November 17, 2021, Health Partners Plans discharge meals must be ordered within 30
and Metropolitan Area Neighborhood Nutrition days of the patient’s post-discharge date.
Alliance delivered one million medically The number of meals provided depends on
tailored meals to its Medicaid members.1861 the patient’s plan benefits. There may be a
limit to how many times the benefit can be
Healthfirst and MetroPlus: In early 2021, used each year.
Healthfirst, one of the nation’s largest not-
for-profit health insurers, partnered with the Patients who are eligible for the chronic-
NYC-based nonprofit GrowNYC to allow condition meals program receive 20 meals
members of certain Medicare Advantage designed to support their special dietary
dual-eligible plans to purchase fresh fruits needs. Patients with multiple conditions can
and vegetables at farmers’ markets run by receive 20 meals per eligible condition during
GrowNYC.1862,1863 Members can use cards the plan year. Eligible conditions may include
provided by Healthfirst to purchase coupons congestive heart failure, coronary artery
that can then be used for the purchase disease, and diabetes.1866
of any fruits and vegetables at GrowNYC
markets. The nonprofit has also made Another program offered by Humana is the
these coupons available to members of Healthy Foods Card, which allows members to
MetroPlus Medicare.1864 purchase approved foods (including perishable
foods, nonperishable foods, frozen foods,
156 PART III Food as Medicine: Interventions, Programs, Policies and Practices PART III Food as Medicine: Interventions, Programs, Policies and Practices 157
Government Support for Food as Medicine
In addition to health care organizations, some medically tailored meals made with fresh
policymakers and legislators have introduced fruits and vegetables for more chronically-
and supported food as medicine programs on ill Americans. “We simply cannot address
local, state, and federal levels. In 2019, the hunger and health as two separate issues,”
Center for Health Law & Policy Innovation at said McGovern at an event celebrating the
Harvard Law School and medically-tailored program’s launch, “They’re two sides of the
meal nonprofit Community Servings released same coin.”1883 Over the few years since its
the Massachusetts Food is Medicine State launch, the group has made notable progress.
Plan.1877 Sponsored by State Senator Julian In 2020, it introduced the Medically Tailored
Cyr (D-MA) and State Representative Denise Home-Delivered Meal Demonstration Pilot Act,
Garlick (D-MA), the plan advocated for the which, if passed, would establish a 3-year pilot
Office of Medicaid (MassHealth) to create program assessing the impact of providing
a food and health pilot program that would MTMs to vulnerable older adults through
connect Medicaid enrollees with diet-related Medicare.1884,1885
diseases to community-based nutrition
organizations.1878 The authors of the plan As the momentum behind using nutrition
estimate that food insecurity, hunger, mental as a tool for improving public health builds,
health and the physical health conditions to universities have begun working with
which they contribute currently cost the state policymakers to devise healthier federal
of Massachusetts approximately $1.9 billion food programs.1886 Tufts University’s Food is
annually.1879 The goal of the program would Medicine Public Impact Initiative is a notable
be to reduce those costs while also achieving example of this type of collaboration.1887 Led
better health outcomes for patients.1880,1881 by faculty at the Gerald J. and Dorothy R.
Friedman School of Nutrition Science and
Interest and action surrounding the use Policy, the oldest and largest graduate school
of food as medicine has also reached the of nutrition in North America, the initiative
federal level. In January 2018, the House aims to “raise awareness of the tremendous
of Representatives created a bipartisan impact of food on national well-being... and
Food is Medicine Working Group led by provide trusted science on actionable and
Representatives Jim McGovern (D-MA), impactful solutions.”1888 In conjunction with
Chellie Pingree (D-ME), Roger Marshall Congressional leaders, community advocates,
(R-KS), and Jackie Walorski (R-IN) whose and industry stakeholders, the researchers
purpose is to draw attention to hunger and hope to create policy solutions that improve
address its impacts on health.1882 One of nutrition for all Americans, reduce the cost of
the Food is Medicine Working Group’s key their care, and mitigate health inequities by
goals is to shape policy that would secure using food as medicine.1889
158 PART III Food as Medicine: Interventions, Programs, Policies and Practices PART III Food as Medicine: Interventions, Programs, Policies and Practices 159
Part IV
Food as Medicine
Treating and Managing
Disease
160 PART III Food as Medicine: Interventions, Programs, Policies and Practices PART III Food as Medicine: Interventions, Programs, Policies and Practices 161
PA RT IV
Food as Medicine:
Common Dietary Interventions
Disease
The ketogenic diet was first introduced in the early 1920s as a treatment for epilepsy
and has also been examined in the treatment of a variety of diet-related health
conditions.1905 The ketogenic diet is a low carbohydrate, high fat diet that focuses on
replacing carbohydrates and sugars your body can break down easily (such as white
bread and soda) with a moderate amount of proteins (e.g grass-fed beef and free-range
poultry) and a high amount of healthy fats (e.g. avocado).19061907,1908,1909 While there is
not a standard macronutrient profile for the ketogenic diet, “The dietary macronutrients
are divided into approximately 55% to 60% fat, 30% to 35% protein, and 5% to 10%
carbohydrates. Specifically, in a 2000 kcal per day diet, carbohydrates amount up to 20
Research has demonstrated that a The conditions and diseases included in this to 50 g per day.”1910 This mix of macronutrients aims to induce ketosis, a metabolic state
nutritious diet can have a significant section are: in which your body uses fat for fuel instead of carbohydrates.
impact on the prevention, treatment,
The Mediterranean diet consists of foods that are consumed in regions surrounding
and outcome of many disease ● Alzheimer’s
the Mediterranean Sea, including local, fresh produce; extra virgin olive oil; small
states.1890,1891,1892,1893,1894,1895,1896,1897,1898,1899 ● Arthritis, Non-Rheumatoid
amounts of cheese, yogurt and red meat; fish and poultry; desserts made up of fresh
This section provides an overview of dietary ● Arthritis, Rheumatoid fruit; and moderate amounts of wine consumed with meals.1911,1912 The Mediterranean
interventions that have been studied in the ● Autism diet is included on the United Nations Education, Scientific and Cultural Organization
treatment, co-treatment, and management of ● Cancer (UNESCO)’s list of Intangible Cultural Heritage of Humanity.1913 According to The
specific conditions and diseases. ● Chronic Kidney Disease Mediterranean Diet, the website charged with “safeguard[ing] and promot[ing] the
● Cirrhosis and Ascites Mediterranean Diet at the regional, national and international level,”1914 followers of the
● Diabetes diet should use the official diet pyramid, which “places at the base foods of plant origin
● Inflammatory Bowel Diseases that provide key nutrients and other protective substances that contribute to general
● HIV/AIDS well-being and to maintain a balanced diet.”1915
● Hypertension
● Mental Health Conditions and Illnesses
● Multiple Sclerosis
● Sleep
Alzheimer’s
According to the National Institutes of Health symptoms first appear in their mid-60s.
National Institute on Aging (NIA): Early-onset Alzheimer’s occurs between a
person’s 30s and mid-60s and is very rare.
Alzheimer’s disease is a brain disorder that Alzheimer’s disease is the most common
slowly destroys memory and thinking skills cause of dementia among older adults.1900
and, eventually, the ability to carry out the
simplest tasks. In most people with the
disease—those with the late-onset type
162 PART IV Food as Medicine: Treating and Managing Disease PART IV Food as Medicine: Treating and Managing Disease 163
Estimates from experts suggest that more than Mediterranean diet could act as a protective
6 million Americans over the age of 65 might measure against memory decline in older
have Alzheimer’s,1916 and the Alzheimer’s adults at high risk of developing Alzheimer’s
Association projects this number to grow to (researchers cited the following risk factors
nearly 14 million by 2050.1917 Alzheimer’s for Alzheimer’s: relatives with Alzheimer’s,
disease is characterized by a “loss of cognitive subjective cognitive decline, and mild cognitive
functioning — thinking, remembering, and impairment).1920 In a 2020 study appearing
reasoning — to such an extent that it interferes in Alzheimer’s & Dementia, older individuals
with a person’s daily life and activities.”1918 (age 50-85) were given cognition tests and
food frequency questionnaires to determine
The NIA states that the Mediterranean diet the connections between dietary intake and
(high in fish, whole grains, vegetables, and cognitive function.1921 In the study, researchers
olive oil while low in red meat consumption) found that participants whose diets were most
has been associated with cognitive benefits in similar to the Mediterranean diet scored higher
reducing the risk and effects of Alzheimer’s.1919 on cognition tests.1922
A 2021 study in Neurology showed that the
164 PART IV Food as Medicine: Treating and Managing Disease PART IV Food as Medicine: Treating and Managing Disease 165
The DASH (Dietary Approaches to Stop According to the NIA, the MIND diet
Hypertension) diet has been shown to emphasizes eating from 10 healthy food
lower high blood pressure, a risk factor for groups as follows:
Alzheimer’s disease.1923 The DASH diet ● Leafy green vegetables, at least
includes: “Eating vegetables, fruits, and 6 servings/week
whole grains; including fat-free or low-fat
dairy products, fish, poultry, beans, nuts, and ● Other vegetables, at least 1 serving/day
vegetable oils; limiting foods that are high in ● Berries, at least 2 servings/week
saturated fat, such as fatty meats, full-fat dairy
products, and tropical oils such as coconut, ● Whole grains, at least 3 servings/day
palm kernel, and palm oils; and limiting sugar- ● Fish, 1 serving/week
sweetened beverages and sweets.”1924
● Poultry, 2 servings/week
The MIND (Mediterranean–DASH Intervention ● Beans, 3 servings/week
for Neurodegenerative Delay) diet combines
elements of both the DASH diet and the ● Nuts, 5 servings/week
Mediterranean diet. Similarly to those diets, ● Wine, 1 glass/day
the MIND diet emphasizes fruits, vegetables,
whole grains, nuts, beans and certain fish.1925 ● Olive oil
The diet focuses on plant-based foods linked
● [Set limits for] red meat, sweets, cheese,
to dementia prevention.
butter/margarine and fast/fried food.1926
166 PART IV Food as Medicine: Treating and Managing Disease PART IV Food as Medicine: Treating and Managing Disease 167
According to the NIA, “Evidence supporting Alzheimer’s .1945 Specifically, memory retention
the MIND diet comes from observational rates, adherence, and safety were all more
studies of more than 900 dementia-free older achievable in Alzheimer’s patients who were
adults, which found that closely following the on the ketogenic diet.1946
MIND diet was associated with a reduced risk When designing dietary changes for
of Alzheimer’s disease and a slower rate of patients managing Alzheimer’s, there are
cognitive decline.”1927 A forthcoming 3-year other variables that need to be considered
study will examine the impact of these diets to ensure that food is both appealing
on brain health and cognitive decline among and easy to eat.1947 Cognitive decline in
older adults with a family history of dementia patients with Alzheimer’s has been linked
or Alzheimer’s.1928 The study is supported by to masticatory function decline,1948 which
the MIND Diet Intervention, a collaboration means that they often have difficulty chewing.
between Rush University, Harvard T.H. Chan Loss of appetite is also common among
School of Public Health, Brigham & Women’s Alzheimer’s patients.1949 Furthermore, many
Hospital, and the National Institute on medications prescribed to treat Alzheimer’s
Aging.1929 have side effects that adversely affect the
gastrointestinal system.1950 While the triggers
There is a plethora of research demonstrating for gastrointestinal pain and discomfort vary
that oily fish (e.g., salmon) is associated widely among different people,1951 some
with lower cognitive decline and higher brain studies have shown that intake of dietary
function.1930,1931,1932,1933,1934,1935,1936,1937 This could fiber (often from fruits and vegetables)
be due to the omega-3 fatty acids in fish, might help patients who are experiencing
nutrients present in high quantities in the gastrointestinal discomfort.1952,1953,1954
brain.1938 In a 2018 study of patients diagnosed
with Alzheimer’s at varying levels of severity Current evidence about the connection
appearing in the Journal of Alzheimer’s between diet and Alzheimer’s risk is not as
Disease, dietary intervention in the form of strong as evidence for other types of lifestyle
fish oil intake was associated with slower interventions, such as physical activity and
progression of the disease, including improved cognitive testing.1955 However, research
memory, sight, and mood.1939 In 2019, another into the effects of various types of foods
study appearing in PLoS One concluded and dietary interventions on brain health is
that fish oil supplementation might have still ongoing,1956 as well as the risk factors
neuroprotective effects when taken during the associated with obesity, alcohol consumption,
presymptomatic stage of Alzheimer’s.1940 and smoking.1957
168 PART IV Food as Medicine: Treating and Managing Disease PART IV Food as Medicine: Treating and Managing Disease 169
Arthritis, Non-Rheumatoid
According to the National Institutes of as well as pomegranates are among the
Health National Institute of Arthritis and commonly available fruits that may offer
Musculoskeletal and Skin Diseases (NIAMS), some protection against arthritis.”1969 In one
“‘Arthritis’ literally means joint inflammation. 2015 study published in the journal Arthritis,
Although joint inflammation is a symptom or a whole-food, plant-based (WFPB) diet was
sign rather than a specific diagnosis, the term found to reduce pain for osteoarthritis patients:
arthritis is often used to refer to any disorder
that affects the joints. Joints are located in The primary mechanism by which diet
-places where two bones meet, such as your reduces subjective pain may be a result
elbow or knee.”1958 Arthritis refers to more of normalization of the fatty acid profile
than 100 different diseases characterized by and reduction in exposure to inflammatory
joint pain, swelling, and stiffness; this includes protein precursors. Western diets are high
in arachidonic acid, which are modified
osteoarthritis, gout, psoriatic arthritis, and
into proinflammatory prostaglandins
rheumatoid arthritis, among others.1959,1960
and leukotrienes. Nonsteroidal anti-
Arthritis can affect people of any age, sex, and inflammatory drugs work to reduce pain
race, but is most prevalent among women and by limiting the metabolism of arachidonic
older people.1961 acid. Arachidonic acid is found in
animal foods and some vegetable oils.
Osteoarthritis Therefore, the adoption of a WFPB will
dramatically reduce the availability of
According to the Centers for Disease Control
precursors necessary to produce painful
and Prevention (CDC), osteoarthritis is
prostaglandins.1970
the most common type of arthritis caused
by damage or breakdown of joint cartilage
To treat osteoarthritis, some patients turn to
between bones.1962 In some studies, the
dietary supplements, including glucosamine
Mediterranean diet has been shown to help
and chondroitin, which are described by
alleviate pain for people with osteoarthritis due
the National Institutes of Health National
to its anti-inflammatory effects.1963,1964,1965,1966,1967
Center for Complementary and Integrative
Eating a diet that is high in fiber such as
Health (NCCIH) as “structural components
vegetables, beans, whole grains and fruit has
of cartilage, the tissue that cushions the
been associated with decreased inflammation.
joints.”1971 While these components are
In two long-term observational studies of
found naturally in the body, they are also
individuals with knee osteoarthritis published
available as over-the-counter dietary
in Annals of the Rheumatic Diseases,
supplements.1972 Glucosamine in particular
researchers found that higher total fiber
has received attention as being able to
intake correlates with lower prevalence of
reduce the symptoms of osteoarthritis of
the disease.1968
the knee;1973 however, most major studies
of the supplement’s effects (on knees as
Consumption of various fruits and fruit
well as other joints) have had conflicting
extracts, especially berries high in antioxidants
results.1974,1975,1976,1977,1978,1979,1980,1981,1982 In
(such as blueberries, raspberries, and
2008, the National Institutes of Health (NIH)
strawberries), may reduce pain and
conducted a large-scale, multicenter clinical
inflammation; according to a 2019 review in
trial published in Journal of Pain & Palliative
Food & Function, “on the basis of emerging
Care Pharmacotherapy testing the efficacy of
pre-clinical, epidemiological and clinical data,
glucosamine and chondroitin supplements in
blueberries, raspberries and strawberries,
treating knee osteoarthritis and found:
170 PART IV Food as Medicine: Treating and Managing Disease PART IV Food as Medicine: Treating and Managing Disease 171
For a subset of participants with Ankylosing spondylitis
moderate-to-severe pain, glucosamine
Ankylosing spondylitis is an arthritis
combined with chondroitin sulfate
of the spine that can cause back pain
provided statistically significant pain
relief compared with placebo—about and stiffness,1997 and for some people
79 percent had a 20 percent or greater gastrointestinal problems.1998,1999,2000,2001 A
reduction in pain versus about 54 percent 2010 study of 165 adults in Sweden with
for placebo... For participants in the mild ankylosing spondylitis, published in Clinical
pain subset, glucosamine and chondroitin Rheumatology, found that gastrointestinal pain
sulfate together or alone did not provide was more prevalent in those who reported
statistically significant pain relief.1983 high consumption of vegetables and less
prevalent among those who consumed milk
The NCCIH notes that some European and soured milk.2002 The authors note that
studies of glucosamine have reported positive certain vegetables are high in a collection
effects of the supplement on knee pain of short-chain carbohydrates that are not
and function.1984 properly absorbed in the gut and hypothesize
that “an inappropriate absorption may allow
Gout these foodstuffs to reach the distal ileum
Osteoarthritis can predispose the depositing and colon where they affect the bowel flora,
of monosodium urate crystals into joint thereby creating the symptoms of an irritable
sites, leading to gout, which is another type bowel.”2003 Overall, there are not enough
of arthritis.1985,1986 Gout is characterized by studies investigating the relationship between
sudden and severe pain localized to one or diet and dietary supplements and ankylosing
more joints, but is most commonly found in the spondylitis.2004,2005 Despite the lack of published
big toe.1987,1988 Consumption of high-fructose research, dietary modifications and vitamin
corn syrup (which is prominent in Western supplementation are still common among
diets) can lead to a buildup of uric acid, which ankylosing spondylitis patients.2006,2007
causes gout.1989 Other dietary risk factors for
gout include a high consumption of meat and Psoriatic Arthritis
alcohol.1990,1991,1992 The management of gout Psoriatic arthritis is a chronic type of
focuses primarily on medical treatment, but inflammatory arthritis that is linked with
diet can also play a significant role.1993 The psoriasis, an autoimmune condition that
body makes uric acid when it breaks down causes red and scaly patches on the skin.2008
purines; therefore the intake of foods high Dietary interventions have been found to be
in purine, such as meat, beer, bread, and an effective supplemental therapy to reduce
certain legumes, might increase the frequency the severity of psoriatic arthritis.2009 A 2018
of gout flares.1994 Research has also shown study published in JAMA Dermatology of
that increased intake of fruits, especially 158,361 psoriatic arthritis patients suggested
cherries, can help prevent gout flares.1995 that adherence to the Mediterranean diet
Clerodendranthus spicatus, often referred to might result in lower disease activity.2010 In
as “Kidney tea,” an herbal remedy used in a 2020 study in the Journal of the American
Traditional Chinese Medicine, may have the Academy of Dermatology, researchers wrote,
potential to reduce pain and swelling when “[p]atients often ask about the potential for
taken during a gout flare-up.1996 dietary factors, and gluten intake in particular,
to modify risk of other inflammatory skin
diseases, including psoriasis and atopic
dermatitis.”2011 However, adopting a gluten-free
diet has yet to be shown effective at treating
psoriatic arthritis.2012,2013,2014
172 PART IV Food as Medicine: Treating and Managing Disease PART IV Food as Medicine: Treating and Managing Disease 173
Arthritis, Rheumatoid Autism
Rheumatoid arthritis is an autoimmune [C]arbohydrates should be consumed Autism spectrum disorder (ASD) is a group of after the diagnosis of an intolerance or
disease in which the immune system every day (3 portions of whole grains, neurodevelopmental disorders characterized allergy to allergens in the foods that would
attacks healthy cells, causing painful preferably gluten free), together with by difficulty communicating and socializing be eliminated in such a diet.2060
inflammation.2015,2016 It is characterized by pain, fruits and vegetables (5 portions; among with others, as well as repetitive behaviors
stiffness, and swelling in the joints (such as which fruit, berries and citrus fruit are to and narrow interests.2046,2047 An estimated 1 in Limited research has been conducted to
be preferred, and among the vegetables, 110 children have ASD, presenting a range of evaluate the impact of a ketogenic diet in the
the wrist, hands, feet, spine, knees, and jaw),
green leafy ones.), light yogurt (125 ml),
which can flare up and worsen from time to symptoms varying from mild to severe.2048 It is management and treatment of symptoms for
skim milk (200 ml), 1 glass (125 ml) of ASD.2061,2062,2063,2064 Studies in which mice were
time.2017,2018 According to the National Institute four times more common in boys than girls.2049
wine and extra virgin olive oil; weekly, fed a ketogenic diet have shown promise
of Arthritis and Musculoskeletal and Skin fish (3 portions), white meat (3 portions), The impact of the disorder on children as they
Diseases (NIAMS), risk factors for rheumatoid age varies with the severity of their case, the in reducing seizures and anxiety, but initial
legumes (2 portions) eggs (2 portions),
arthritis include advanced age, smoking, symptoms they present, and the promptness research has yet to rule out other variables
seasoned cheeses (2 portions), and red or
obesity, and gum disease.2019 processed meats (once a week).2033 of their diagnosis.2050 Although the cause of such as lower caloric intake resulting from the
ASD remains unknown, early treatment is dietary change as the cause of the reduction
Research has demonstrated that eating While food certainly has an impact, some associated with milder symptoms long-term in core symptoms.2065,2066,2067,2068 This reduction
higher amounts of fish and/or taking fish oil researchers argue that more studies and and overall improvements in quality of life.2051 in anxiety could potentially play a role in
is associated with lower rates of pain and observation are needed before a concrete normalizing social interactions, which many
other negative symptoms of rheumatoid dietary recommendation can be made Given that few treatments have shown to individuals with ASD struggle with.2069
arthritis.2020,2021,2022,2023 The Mediterranean diet about the relationship between food and be effective at mitigating the core symptoms
has been shown to help patients manage rheumatoid arthritis.2034,2035,2036 of autism, many patients and their families Existing studies of the impact of a ketogenic
rheumatoid pain.2024 A 2018 study in Clinical seek alternative and food-based medicine.2052 diet on humans with ASD have used small
Nutrition showed that monounsaturated fatty Around 25 percent of people with ASD follow sample sizes, but have demonstrated
Juvenile Idiopathic Arthritis
acids (found in olive oil and avocado oil) might a specialized diet or use dietary supplements behavioral improvements in some children
Juvenile idiopathic arthritis (JIA) is another with ASD.2070,2071 The Childhood Autism Rating
be the key nutrients that suppress disease to manage their condition.2053 Gluten-free
type of autoimmune arthritis that begins in scale is a diagnostic tool used by trained
activity.2025 Some research has also found that (aims to eliminate wheat, barley, and rye) and
childhood.2037 The word “idiopathic,” which clinicians to rate items indicative of ASD
low-fat plant-based diets reduce rheumatoid casein-free (aims to eliminate milk and dairy
means unknown, refers to researchers’ lack after direct observation.2072 In a 2018 study
arthritis symptoms by eliminating many of the products) diets are most common, although
of understanding about what causes JIA.2038 appearing in the journal Physiology & Behavior
most common triggers.2026,2027 In a 2020 journal clinical studies have been unable to provide
article in BMC Rheumatology, researchers
Like rheumatoid arthritis, JIA is a form of
sufficient evidence to support the diet as a monitoring the impact of a modified ketogenic
inflammatory arthritis; however, according and gluten-free diet on children with autism
advised that dietary intervention should not be treatment for ASD.2054,2055,2056,2057,2058,2059 Due
to the Arthritis Foundation, “it is not a kid
the sole treatment plan for rheumatoid arthritis, to the lack of sufficient clinical studies about aged 2 to 17 years, researchers found that
version of the adult disease.”2039 About 5 “50 percent of subjects showed improvement
but also noted that dietary choices play a role these diets, some researchers have explicitly
percent of children with JIA have a subtype of on [the Childhood Autism Rating Scale, 2nd
in disease management, writing, “Adherence advised against it; in the Journal of Child
the disease whose observable physical and Edition] scores in the areas of imitation,
to the Mediterranean diet is generally Neurology in 2014, researchers wrote:
biochemical characteristics resemble those of body use, and fear or nervousness.”2073 The
recommended, with a plant-based regimen
adult rheumatoid arthritis.2040
abundant in wholegrains, legumes, five or [T]he evidence to support gluten-free, researchers conclude that the ketogenic
While research has not supported a standard casein-free diets is limited and weak, such diet warrants further investigation with larger
more fruit and vegetables per day, preferably
diet for the treatment of JIA, parents and sample sizes.2074
seasonal.”2028 Anti-inflammatory foods have dietary restrictions being associated with
potential in the treatment of rheumatoid
families of people with JIA often consider social rejection, stigmatization, deficits in
diet a factor contributing to disease socialization and integration, and a misuse Some clinical evidence has shown that
arthritis.2029,2030,2031,2032
activity.2041,2042,2043,2044 In a 2014 survey of 50 of resources, as well as potential adverse children with autism may have abnormally
Finnish children with JIA published in BMC biomedical effects. Hence, we advise low levels of fatty acids relative to non-autistic
A 2021 review in the journal Clinical Nutrition against resorting to elimination diets in an
outlined the ideal “food pyramid” for a person
Complementary Medicine and Therapies, children,2075,2076,2077,2078 and these findings
28 percent of respondents reported using attempt to treat autism spectrum disorders.
have spurred research into omega-3 and
living with rheumatoid arthritis, which included
dietary restrictions to help manage their Specifically, until there is conclusive
omega-6 supplements as treatments.2079,2080,2081
the following:
condition, although the effects of these dietary evidence of the benefits of gluten-free,
casein-free diets in autism spectrum However, these studies have not produced
changes on the children’s disease activity are sufficient evidence associating fatty
disorders, they should only be introduced
unclear.2045
174 PART IV Food as Medicine: Treating and Managing Disease PART IV Food as Medicine: Treating and Managing Disease 175
acid supplements with improved ASD treating children suffering from autism.” A 2012
symptoms.2082,2083,2084,2085,2086 Another dietary randomized controlled trial in Child Psychiatry
supplement, sulforaphane (a phytochemical & Human Development testing the effects of
derived from broccoli sprouts), might have a Ginkgo biloba on children with autism also
positive impact on irritability among those with did not result in significant improvement
ASD.2087,2088 Clinical trials investigating other in autism symptoms.2115 However, one
potential applications of sulforaphane in the 2012 study published in Evidence-Based
treatment of ASD are currently inconclusive Complementary and Alternative Medicine
but remain ongoing.2089,2090,2091,2092,2093 showed that a Traditional Chinese Medicine
Dietary supplements, such as omega-3 dietary intervention that emphasized grains,
fatty acids, zinc, melatonin, and vegetables, fruits, beans, mushrooms, nuts,
others, have also received significant and root vegetables (while reducing ginger,
attention as possible treatments for ASD garlic, green onion, spicy foods, eggs, meat,
symptoms.2094,2095,2096,2097,2098,2099,2100 Some and fish) resulted in improved executive
clinical studies have resulted in minor function among children with ASD.2116
behavioral and functional improvements for
participants receiving these supplements, Children on the autism spectrum are more
but researchers acknowledge that not all likely to exhibit nutritional deficiencies than
people with ASD will respond similarly to children who do not have ASD.2117 Selective
dietary supplements.2101,2102,2103,2104,2105,2106,2107 eating, tantrums, inattention at mealtime,
Other researchers have argued that dietary and aversion to new foods are all commonly
supplementation is unnecessary for children reported in autistic children.2118,2119 These
with ASD because it might lead to excessive restrictive feeding behaviors are thought
intake of certain nutrients, particularly to contribute to deficiencies in Vitamin A,
vitamin A, folate and zinc.2108 This can have Vitamin B6, Vitamin B12, Vitamin C, Vitamin
negative outcomes; for example, excessive D, calcium, zinc, and fatty acids in autistic
intake of vitamin A can lead to side effects youth.2120,2121,2122,2123,2124,2125,2126 A 2011 study
such as nausea, headache, fatigue, loss of appearing in Nutrition & Metabolism has
appetite, psychiatric changes, osteoporosis, suggested that the levels of necessary
and irritability.2109 vitamins, minerals, and plasma amino
acids in children with ASD are inversely
Studies analyzing the impacts of herbs correlated with the severity of their symptoms,
used in Traditional Chinese Medicine on the with those managing more serious cases
core symptoms of autism have found mixed exhibiting more significant malnutrition.2127
results.2110,2111,2112,2113 One very small study Malnutrition negatively affects cognitive and
(n = 3) conducted in 2009 appearing in the social development, making it imperative
Journal of Dietary Supplements measured that pediatricians and families find ways to
the effects of Panax ginseng on children with improve the nutrient intake of children with
autism and revealed very slight improvement ASD.2128 Furthermore, malnutrition and vitamin
in measures of irritability, hyperactivity, deficiencies among children with ASD has
inadequate eye contact, and inappropriate been linked to scurvy, bone-thinning, and
speech.2114 However, the author of the study vision loss.2129,2130,2131,2132,2133,2134,2135
concluded: “Since there does not seem
to be any significant improvement caused Food selectivity also leads to an increased
by Panax ginseng, its effect as an add-on prevalence of diet-related diseases among
therapy... requires further investigation. autistic children2136 who tend to restrict their
Before knowing its efficacy for adults, Panax consumption to foods that are high in calories
ginseng should not be recommended for and refined carbohydrates that provide little
176 PART IV Food as Medicine: Treating and Managing Disease PART IV Food as Medicine: Treating and Managing Disease 177
nutritional diversity and lead to weight gain microbiota and may create gastrointestinal high intake of vegetables and some fruits pathology reports in the patient’s medical
and obesity.2137,2138,2139,2140,2141,2142 As a result, issues.2149,2150,2151 Ongoing studies of the gut- may improve overall survival. High post- record.2183 The researchers concluded:
dietary evaluations and feeding interventions brain axis—the physiological connections diagnostic fruit juice intake may also be
to mitigate food selectivity are recommended between the microbiome in the gut and the associated with increased risk of death Sugary foods were not associated with the
for all children diagnosed with ASD in order brain—have begun to indicate a possible due to breast cancer and all causes, and risk of any cancer. However, in exploratory
to improve the variety of foods and nutrients link between the makeup of an individual’s this finding needs further evaluation.2173 stratified analyses, total consumption of
consumed among these children.2143,2144,2145,2146 gut flora and the severity of their ASD sugary beverages was associated with
symptoms.2152,2153,2154,2155,2156 If such a Additional research supports the role of 59 percent higher risk of adiposity-related
individualized nutrition education in cancer cancers [cancers related to higher body
Children with ASD frequently exhibit connection is firmly established, there may, in
care. One 2018 study published in Annals weight, such as breast, prostate, and
gastrointestinal problems, including fact, be a role for food-based interventions that
of Behavioral Medicine demonstrated colorectal] in participants with excessive
constipation, gas, and diarrhea.2147,2148 alter patients’ gut microbiomes as a means of central adiposity [excess body fat resulting
Research has shown evidence that children managing and treating ASD.2157,2158 that participation in a 12-week exercise
and dietary intervention consisting of in a weight circumference greater than
with ASD may have alterations of gut 40 inches for men and 35 inches for
individualized nutritional counseling with an
women].2184
emphasis on adopting a plant-based diet
resulted in “significant, clinically meaningful
Cancer improvements in mobility performance,
This is consistent with other studies of the
relationship between sugar-sweetened
muscular strength, and body composition”
Cancer is an umbrella term for more than a appearing in the British Journal of Nutrition beverage consumption and cancer
among prostate cancer patients.2174 Another
hundred diseases caused by abnormal cell showed that “[a] higher intake of fruit and occurrence.2185,2186 However, researcher
2019 study appearing in Nutrition and
growth in any part of the body.2159 The National vegetables was associated with significantly Cancer showed that individualized nutritional
Mingyang Song, ScD, Assistant Professor of
Institutes of Health National Cancer Institute better physical functioning.”2171 Furthermore, Clinical Epidemiology and Nutrition at Harvard
education and dietary intervention led to a
(NCI) emphasizes, “it’s important to know in a 2020 review published in the journal reduction in negative gastrointestinal side
School of Public Health, noted the need for
there isn’t just one food or special diet that has Advances in Nutrition, researchers wrote: effects from chemotherapy.2175 Some of the
additional research into the sugar-cancer
proved to control cancer.”2160 connection in the American Journal of Clinical
recommendations provided to participants
…the consumption of ~300 g/d of Nutrition in 2020. He wrote:
included eating frequent small meals
The NCI recommends that all cancer vegetables by head and neck cancer
and avoiding spicy, fried, sugary or very
patients maintain “healthy eating habits” and patients and ~300 g/d of vegetables and Like many questions in nutrition, strong
aromatic foods.2176 biological plausibility does not necessarily
incorporate all their needed nutrients into ~300 g/d fruit separately by ovarian cancer
patients decreased overall mortality. lead to positive findings in epidemiology.
their diets, which can be difficult for patients Research has also suggested that the
Moreover, it is important to bear in mind This is particularly true when it comes to
experiencing loss of appetite, changes in ketogenic diet might be an effective dietary
that none of the studies have detected a the sugar–cancer relation. The reasons
taste, trouble swallowing, and other side intervention for cancer patients to starve are multifaceted and related to the
harmful relation with the consumption of
effects of cancer treatment.2161 To help fruit and vegetables in cancer patients.2172 cancerous cells of energy from carbohydrates challenges of accurate dietary assessment
patients manage their diet throughout cancer while normal cells adapt to use ketone bodies over a long period of time, adequate
treatment, the NCI compiled a list of dietary In a study of 8,927 women with breast cancer (compounds produced during the metabolism control for confounding by other dietary/
changes that can be made to treat various appearing in Cancer Research in 2020, of fats) to survive.2177 lifestyle exposures, identification of the
side effects and symptoms of cancer and researchers wrote: most relevant time window for exposure
cancer treatment.2162 For example, cancer Sugar consumption has been connected assessment, consideration of potential
patients with changes to their sense of taste effect modifications by population
…we observed better overall survival after to cancer occurrence and recurrence in
characteristics, and heterogeneity between
are advised to avoid red meat and try high- breast cancer diagnosis among women numerous studies,2178,2179,2180, although findings
protein vegetarian recipes instead.2163 and within cancer types.2187
with higher vegetable consumption; are inconsistent.2181,2182 In one long-term study
specifically, green leafy vegetables as appearing in Cancer Prevention Research
Fruit and vegetable intake is frequently well as cruciferous vegetables, fruits In conjunction with medical treatment, a
of more than 3,000 adults aged 26-84 years,
and vegetables high in vitamin C, and tailored nutritious diet can help to counter side
studied for its impact on the prevention, study participants were asked to fill out food
treatment, and recurrence rate of various vegetables rich in β-carotene. Although effects, repair damaged tissue, and maintain
frequency questionnaires from 1991 until
cancers.2164,2165,2166,2167,2168,2169,2170 One 2020 eating higher amounts of vegetables may energy levels.2188 The American Cancer
1995, and were followed up with until 2013
not affect breast cancer-specific mortality, Society recommends that patients going
analysis of 150 colorectal cancer survivors regarding cancer incidence as confirmed from
through treatment consume more calories and
178 PART IV Food as Medicine: Treating and Managing Disease PART IV Food as Medicine: Treating and Managing Disease 179
protein, and snack often.2189 This can include a
variety of protein-rich snacks such as yogurt,
An example of a highly individualized dietary
intervention for cancer treatment can be found Chronic Kidney Disease
cereal and milk, and cheese and crackers.2190 at NYU Langone’s Perlmutter Cancer Center Chronic kidney disease (CKD) is the gradual ● “Choose and prepare foods with less
Different cancer treatments can have very in New York City.2198 The hospital launched a loss of kidney function due to damage, usually salt and sodium.” To do this, the NIDDK
different side effects; however, loss of appetite program in 2016 to provide patients with indi- from high blood pressure and high blood advises patients to cook from scratch
is one of the most common side effects of vidualized home-delivered customized meals sugar.2204,2205 Because kidneys act as filters for more, and use spices and herbs to flavor
cancer treatment (including chemotherapy, that take into account the reasons for their loss wastes, kidney damage can result in a buildup food rather than salt.
radiation therapy, and surgery) and is the of appetite (which might include nausea, de- of wastes in the body.2206 The kidneys balance
most common cause of malnutrition in cancer pression, or difficulty swallowing).2199 ● “Eat the right amount and the right types
out nutrients in the body, such as sodium,
patients.2191 Furthermore, chemotherapy According to the NCI, many cancer patients of protein.” Protein-rich foods should be
phosphorus, potassium, so people suffering
treatment often causes alterations in taste might seek out complementary medicines, eaten in small portions so that the kidneys
from CKD have to closely monitor their intake
and smell, which can lead to changes in food including dietary intervention, to pursue do not have to filter too much waste
of these nutrients.2207,2208 The CDC estimates
behavior.2192 A systematic review published in alongside regular treatment for a variety of produced by the body’s use of protein.
that more than 1 in 7 US adults have CKD,
Supportive Care Cancer in 2020 found that the reasons, including: however, 90 percent of people living with the ● “Choose foods that are healthy for your
use of oral nutrition supplements and dietary disease do not know they have it.2209 Certain heart.” Cooking with olive oil instead of
counseling and increases in EPA (a fatty acid) ● Help coping with the side effects of diet-related diseases, including diabetes and butter, trimming fat and skin from meat,
from fish oil supplementation improved the cancer treatments, such as nausea, pain, hypertension, are risk factors for CKD.2210 and avoiding deep-fried foods are some
appetite and nutrition outcomes of patients and fatigue Furthermore, high intake of meats and refined ways to ensure food is heart-healthy.
with cancer undergoing cancer treatments.2193 carbohydrates increases individuals’ risk
● Comforting themselves and ease ● “Choose foods and drinks with less
of CKD.2211,2212,2213,2214
Cancer treatment plans are highly the worries of cancer treatment and phosphorus.” Fresh fruits, vegetables,
individualized to meet the needs of patients, related stress breads, pasta, and rice are examples of
For those living with CKD, low-protein, and
foods low in phosphorus.
so food as medicine interventions for cancer ● Feeling that they are doing something to vegetarian diets have been shown to delay
patients should be equally tailored to specific help with their own care progression of the disease and the onset of ● “Choose foods with the right amount
needs and conditions.2194,2195,2196 Researchers renal failure.2215,2216 Since plant-based foods of potassium.” People with CKD need
Itziar Tueros, PhD and Matxalen Uriarte, ● Trying to treat or cure their cancer2200
tend to be higher in fiber than meat, higher to make sure their blood potassium
PhD wrote about the need to accommodate intake of vegetables and grains can result levels do not build up. Apples and
changing food preferences among cancer However, the NCI warns that patients in more frequent bowel movements and, peaches are among the fruits low
patients in the Journal of the Science of Food and caregivers should be aware of any therefore, less retention of uremic toxins in the in potassium, and white breads and
and Agriculture in 2018: potentially negative interactions between blood.2217 However, patients with advanced pastas have less potassium than their
cancer treatment drugs and the foods CKD should attempt to limit their intake of whole-wheat counterparts.2220
Taking into account that reduced food patients eat. For example, St. John’s wort, potassium-rich fruits and vegetables, such as
enjoyment during cancer treatment can which is sometimes taken by patients as a bananas and carrots, because potassium has Beyond the aforementioned dietary changes
give rise to negative physical, emotional complementary treatment for depression,2201
and social consequences, taste and been associated with faster progression of the that people living with CKD can make,
has been shown to reduce the efficacy of disease.2218
smell alterations, food preferences and researchers have found that the incorporation
certain cancer drugs such as imatinib2202
specific nutritional requirements should of bioactive nutrients, such as microbiota that
and docetaxel.2203 The National Institutes of Health National
be combined and considered by the live in the gut, into the diet can help prevent
food industry when designing innovative Institute of Diabetes and Digestive and and treat CKD.2221 Gut microbes play
formulae for cancer patients. The Kidney Diseases (NIDDK) recommends a
development of new food products or the five-step system for CKD patients interested
revision of existing ones is necessary to in changing what they eat to manage their
prevent or tackle malnutrition, being the condition.2219 The five steps are:
main challenge in oncological nutrition,
as it is a determinant factor for adverse
outcomes, including increased morbidity
and mortality, and decreased quality
of life.2197
180 PART IV Food as Medicine: Treating and Managing Disease PART IV Food as Medicine: Treating and Managing Disease 181
an important role in the body’s metabolism has been applied to some existing food as
and immune responses, and diet directly medicine interventions that target patients with
influences the microbial microbiome of the the disease.2228 Many medically-tailored meal
gut.2222,2223,2224,2225,2226 programs, including Community Servings in
Boston,2229 Mama’s Kitchen in San Diego2230
Dietary interventions that manage the and God’s Love We Deliver in New York
microbiome can also help control the City,2231 serve nutritious and appropriate food
production and absorption of some uremic to patients with CKD that have been shown to
toxins, which are toxic compounds which improve health outcomes by slowing disease
cannot be eliminated from the body and progression, especially for those patients who
accumulate in the bloodstream.2227 Research are also experiencing food insecurity.2232 See
into the role of diet in the treatment of CKD more on medically tailored meals in Part 3 .
182 PART IV Food as Medicine: Treating and Managing Disease PART IV Food as Medicine: Treating and Managing Disease 183
Diabetes and permanent damage to the kidneys,
nerves, and eyes.2254,2255
a meal plan. Each person with diabetes
should be actively engaged in developing
an individualized eating plan. All individuals
Diabetes is a disease that compromises administration of insulin.2250 Type 2 diabetes is
Diabetes affects 34.2 million people in the with diabetes should be offered a referral
the body’s ability to produce or respond to the most common form of diabetes and results for individualized MNT provided by a
the hormone insulin, resulting in abnormal from the body’s ineffective use of insulin.2251 US and 422 million worldwide.2256,2257 It is
estimated that 88 million American adults RD who is knowledgeable and skilled in
metabolism of carbohydrates and elevated Symptoms of diabetes can include: excessive providing diabetes-specific MNT.2267
levels of glucose in the blood and urine.2248,2249 thirst and/or hunger, frequent urination, have prediabetes, which is categorized
Type 1 diabetes (previously called insulin- unexplained weight loss, fainting, numbness by slightly higher than normal blood sugar
Individual nutrition therapy is recommended
dependent or juvenile diabetes) refers in hands or feet, slow wound healing, and levels indicative of increased risk of type 2
for all people with type 1 and type 2 diabetes
to a condition where the pancreas either blurred vision.2252,2253 If left untreated, or diabetes.2258,2259 There is strong evidence
and has shown to be effective for improving
doesn’t produce any insulin or doesn’t not treated properly, diabetes can lead to that various health and behavioral factors
glycemic control (target blood glucose levels)
produce sufficient insulin and requires daily complications including heart attack, stroke, put individuals at increased risk for diabetes
and various markers of cardiovascular and
and related complications including obesity
hypertension risk.2268
and overweight, high blood pressure, high
cholesterol, physical inactivity and tobacco
Overall, research has shown that diets rich
use.2260
in fruits and vegetables, whole grains, nuts
and legumes and lower in red and processed
Among US adults aged 18 years or older
meats, refined grains, and sugar-sweetened
diagnosed with diabetes, 89 percent were
beverages are consistently associated with a
overweight or had obesity, defined as a body
decreased risk of diabetes2269,2270,2271,2272 as well
mass index (BMI) of 25 kg/m2 or higher.2261
as maintenance of target blood glucose levels
As overweight and obesity is the most
for people living with type 2 diabetes.2273,2274,2275
strongly associated risk factor connected
However, clinical guidelines suggests that
with developing Type 2 diabetes and related
there is not an ideal macronutrient profile
complications, there has been great interest
(carbohydrates, protein, and fat) for all people
in the scientific and lay communities regarding
with diabetes.2276
the impact of diet on both preventing and
treating diabetes.2262 Change in diet, along
There is extensive evidence to suggest that
with exercise and medication, are standard
the Mediterranean diet is associated with
recommendations as part of treatment plans
improved outcomes of glycemic control,
for individuals with diabetes.2263
body weight, and cardiovascular risk factors
in patients with type 2 diabetes.2277,2278,2279
Research on a variety of dietary patterns have
A meta-analysis published in the European
shown positive results in the treatment and
Journal of Clinical Nutrition in 2015 included
management of diabetes.2264,2265 The American
data from nine randomized controlled trials
Diabetes Association (ADA) 2019 guidelines
comparing the effects of the Mediterranean
of care state that nutrition and diet should
diet with control diets in patients with type
be individually tailored to meet the goals of
2 diabetes.2280 The study concluded that
blood glucose and weight management of a
adherence to a Mediterranean diet seems to
patient.2266 The ADA states that individualized
have a protective role in glycemic control as
medical nutrition therapy (MNT) is a core
reflected by reduced HbA1c (average blood
component of diabetes management:
glucose levels over the past three months) and
For many individuals with diabetes, the lower fasting levels in addition to decreased
most challenging part of the treatment plan insulin resistance and mortality.2281
is determining what to eat and following
184 PART IV Food as Medicine: Treating and Managing Disease PART IV Food as Medicine: Treating and Managing Disease 185
A systematic review of eight meta-analyses 2025 Dietary Guidelines for Americans, which Research has also explored the potential improve and be sustained,” write researchers
and five randomized controlled trials recommends that adults eat 22 to 34 grams benefits of components of specific foods in in the Journal of Clinical Nursing in 2016.2332
published in BMJ Open in 2015 compared the of fiber each day, the specific amount varying the management of diabetes. For example, Several dietary patterns have demonstrated
Mediterranean diet with a control diet in the depending on age and sex.2297 researchers have demonstrated that omega- benefits for diabetes management, including
treatment of type 2 diabetes.2282 The study 3s from foods such as walnuts may help to low-carbohydrate, low-GI, Mediterranean, and
concluded that “The Mediterranean diet was Other diets that have been studied for their reduce overall inflammation and oxidation high-protein diets,2333 and should be selected
associated with better glycemic control and effect on diabetes management include low- as well as improving vascular function in based on individuals personal and cultural
cardiovascular risk factors than control diets, carbohydrate, low-glycemic index (GI), and patients with diabetes.2314,2315,2316,2317 Studies food preferences and metabolic goals.2334
including a lower fat diet, suggesting that it is high-protein.2298 In low-carbohydrate diets, also suggest that probiotics may have a However, a better understanding of food habits
suitable for the overall management of type 2 carbohydrates can be reduced to different role in diabetes management by reducing among cultures around the world is needed
diabetes.”2283 levels; according to a 2011 review appearing autoimmune responses, decreasing in order for physicians, dietitians, and other
in Nutrition in Clinical Practice, the typical inflammatory reactions and increasing insulin health care providers to make appropriate
Research has also demonstrated that a definitions for types of low-carbohydrate diets sensitivity.2318,2319,2320 A systematic review and effective recommendations; according
vegetarian diet may also improve glycemic are: and meta-analysis published in Nutrition & to researchers writing in The Lancet in 2014,
control in patients with diabetes.2284,2285 A Diabetes in 2017 stated that olive oil could “High quality, large sample size intervention
2019 systematic review and meta-analysis of 1. Reduced-carbohydrate diet: >130 g be beneficial in the treatment of diabetes and and observational studies and region-specific
nine randomized controlled trials published of carbohydrate per day, up to 45% of reported that olive oil supplementation resulted recommendations are lacking from diverse
in Clinical Nutrition showed that vegetarian total calories in significantly more pronounced reduction populations and cultures.”2335
dietary patterns improved glycemic control and in HbA1c and fasting plasma glucose as
other established cardiometabolic risk factors 2. LC diet: 30-130 g of carbohydrate per day compared with the control groups.2321 Food insecure adults are at a higher risk for
in individuals with diabetes over a median diabetes and experience increased challenges
follow-up of 12 weeks.2286 While research 3. Very low-carbohydrate ketogenic (VLCK) Ensuring that dietary interventions for with diabetes management.2336,2337,2338 Often,
suggests the potential benefits of a vegetarian diet: <30 g of carbohydrate per day; will diabetes patients are appropriate for their the most affordable foods are calorie dense
diet, further information is needed to explore usually permit ketosis to occur.2299 cultural and religious needs is important and high in sugar, sodium, and fat, which
the long term effects of this dietary approach for health care providers and dietitians contribute to disease progression and activ-
on the management of diabetes.2287 Multiple studies, including randomized designing these programs to keep in ity.2339,2340 Additionally, food insecurity may
controlled trials, have shown that reducing mind.2322,2323,2324,2325,2326,2327,2328,2329 In a 2020 alter food intake or establish binge-fast cycles
Fiber is recommended as part of a healthy carbohydrate intake might help patients article appearing in the journal Health based on food access and availability.2341 Pe-
diet for the management of type 2 diabetes.2288 manage their diabetes.2300,2301,2302,2303,2304 Low- Expectations, dietitians reported feeling riods of food scarcity may be followed by peri-
Fiber is able to slow down blood sugar GI diets include low-glycemic foods (such insecure about providing nutritional advice to ods of overconsumption and avoidance of food
spikes after meals2289,2290 and reduce HbA1c as oats or muesli), with white bread as the immigrant patients, citing language barriers waste that can lead to hyperglycemia.2342 Dia-
and plasma fasting glucose for people with reference point for the highest glycemic and differences in food habits as being major betes is also associated with a higher per-cap-
diabetes.2291,2292,2293,2294 A systematic review food.2305,2306 These diets might help people with obstacles to providing adequate care.2330 ita out-of-pocket health care expenditure than
and meta-analysis published in PLoS Med diabetes manage their body weight.2307,2308,2309 Obstacles such as these can lead to a lack any other disease (including heart disease and
in 2020 examined the effects of a higher In addition, high protein diets have been of adherence to doctor’s recommendations; cancer), which leads patients to purchasing
fiber intake in adults with prediabetes, type 1 used to manage body weight and glycemic in a 2019 study appearing in Public Health cheap, processed foods high in sugar, sodium,
diabetes, and type 2 diabetes and found that control among diabetic patients.2310,2311,2312 In Nutrition of Mayan communities in Mexico, and fat.2343,2344 Medically tailored meal pro-
higher-fiber diets resulted in improvements one 2021 study appearing in the European researchers wrote, “Non-adherence [to grams2345 and food prescription programs2346
in measures of glycemic control, blood lipids, Journal of Nutrition, participants who followed physician instructions] was influenced by lack are two common Food as Medicine interven-
body weight, and inflammation, as well as a a diet with meals provided that consisted of patient–provider shared knowledge and tions that often aim to improve food access in
reduction in premature mortality.2295 The study of 30 percent of energy from protein (as medical recommendations misaligned with diabetic populations. To learn more about pro-
findings concluded with the recommendation opposed to the control of 15 percent) saw local culture.”2331 grammatic interventions to address diabetes
that increasing daily fiber intake by 15 g or to improvements in body weight, liver fat content, and other diet-related chronic diseases, see
35 g might be a reasonable target that would and HbA1c concentrations throughout the “Clinicians must develop self-management Part 3.
be expected to reduce risk of premature 36-week intervention.2313 guidance within the sociocultural context
mortality in adults with diabetes.2296 This of the patient if diabetes outcomes are to
recommendation is consistent with 2020-
186 PART IV Food as Medicine: Treating and Managing Disease PART IV Food as Medicine: Treating and Managing Disease 187
Inflammatory Bowel Diseases
More than 1.8 million people in the United Additional research has suggested that IBD
States have an inflammatory bowel disease may be tied to the ratio of omega-3 versus
(IBD), which refers to a group of chronic omega-6 fatty acids an individual consumes
autoimmune inflammatory diseases of rather than overall intake.2365 A 2019 review
the gastrointestinal (GI) tract.2347 Clinical published in International Journal of Molecular
symptoms of IBDs include constipation, Science found omega-3 fats “may regulate
diarrhea, abdominal cramps, blood and mucus and attenuate the inflammatory processes
in the stool, and bowel obstruction.2348,2349,2350 and lead to remission of IBD and, thus, could
Ulcerative colitis (UC), a chronic disease in be considered as a new complementary
which abnormal reactions of the immune approach to the treatment of these
system cause inflammation and ulcers on inflammatory conditions.”2366
the inner lining of the large intestine, and
Crohn’s disease (CD), a chronic disease Some research has explored potential
that causes inflammation and irritation of connections between the consumption
the digestive tract, are the most common of animal products (including dairy and
IBDs.2351 Individuals with IBD go through animal proteins) and the development of
periods of active disease that, if left untreated, IBD.2367,2368,2369, In a 2010 study of more than
can progress to the point of requiring 60,000 middle-aged French women, published
hospitalization and surgery.2352,2353 Half of CD in The American Journal of Gastroenterology,
patients require surgical intervention in the researchers found:
ten years following their diagnosis and over
a third need more than one procedure.2354 …high protein intake was associated
Long term, persistent inflammatory responses, with an increased risk of IBD. The
including IBD, pose significant risk factors for positive association between high protein
chronic inflammatory conditions, cancer, and intake and IBD risk was restricted to
infectious disease.2355 animal protein intake. Among animal
protein sources, both fish and meat
were associated with risk, whereas egg
According to the National Institutes of Health
and dairy products were not, potentially
National Institute of Diabetes and Digestive because of insufficient power.2370
and Kidney Diseases (NIDDK), the exact
cause of IBDs such as UC and CD is still However, more research is required before
unclear.2356,2357 However, much research has a connection between protein or dairy
been conducted investigating the potential intake and the development of IBD can
role individual diet plays in the development be established.2371,2372,2373,2374,2375
of IBDs.2358,2359 Several studies conducted
between 2005 and 2011 determined that the Consumption of animal products (processed
omega-6 polyunsaturated fats found in red meat and red meat in particular) has also
meat, cooking oils, and margarine increased been studied for its potential effect on IBD
the risk of developing IBD.2360,2361,2362,2363 symptoms.2376,2377,2378,2379 One 2020 randomized
Furthermore, a 26-year longitudinal study of controlled trial appearing in the journal
more than 100,000 female nurses, appearing Gastroenterology showed that a diet low in
in the journal Gut in 2014, concluded that red and processed meats did not reduce the
“high intake of trans-unsaturated fats may be rate of CD flare ups.2380 However, the authors
associated with an increased risk of UC.”2364
188 PART IV Food as Medicine: Treating and Managing Disease PART IV Food as Medicine: Treating and Managing Disease 189
note that reducing red meat intake might be interventions, however, remains observational, Another diet that is recommended to IBD The IBD-AID has three phases based on the
beneficial for other health conditions.2381 and additional, randomized controlled studies patients is the Autoimmune Protocol (AIP) diet, level of symptoms a patient is experiencing,
are recommended.2408 which requires the elimination of grains, dairy, each phase building upon the dietary
To manage the symptoms of IBDs, patients refined sugars, legumes, eggs, nuts, seeds, allowances of the previous phase.2433,2434 In a
may try a variety of different diets and food Dietary Interventions for IBD nightshades (e.g., tomatoes, potatoes, and 2014 case series report published in Nutrition
treatments, because not all individuals have eggplant), and food additives and increases Journal, 100 percent of patients (n=11) placed
Among food-based interventions for IBD,
the same dietary triggers.2382,2383,2384 Patients the consumption of fermented foods.2421 One on the IBD-AID reported a decrease in bowel
low-FODMAP diets are the most studied,
managing IBDs therefore often follow diet 2017 prospective uncontrolled study appearing frequency and were able to discontinue at
and a plethora of evidence supports their
regimens that are highly individualized to in Inflammatory Bowel Diseases of 15 adult least one of their prior IBD medications.2435
use.2409 The acronym FODMAP refers to
their specific needs.2385 For example, IBD patients found that the AIP diet improved The authors conclude, “The study of the
fermentable oligosaccharides, disaccharides,
patients might try a variety of dietary changes symptoms in patients with UC and CD and 73 IBD-AID would benefit from the rigorous
monosaccharides, and polyols,2410 which
to reduce symptoms, including avoiding high- percent achieved clinical remission within six analysis provided by a randomized clinical
are short-chain carbohydrates (sugars)
fiber foods (such as vegetable skins and nuts), weeks of starting the diet.2422 trial, with evaluation of mucosal healing and
that the small intestine absorbs poorly.2411
eating a high-calorie diet, eliminating lactose assessment of change in gut flora to examine
Patients on a low-FODMAP diet refrain
from the diet, or reducing salt intake.2386 Another diet that is recommended for patients the exact mechanism(s) of benefit.”2436 A
from consuming foods that contain these
with IBD is the Specific Carbohydrate Diet 2021 review published in Intestinal Research
types of carbohydrates, including many
Furthermore, according to a 2020 survey (SCD), which removes grains, refined summarized available data from studies
fruits, vegetables, artificial sweeteners,
appearing in Frontline Gastroenterology, sugars, processed and packaged foods, that aimed to evaluate the effectiveness of
dairy products, starches, and plant-based
“Dietary advice [from healthcare providers some legumes and dairy, and starchy the AID and concluded, “Lack of consistent
proteins, for six to eight weeks.2412 Much
to patients] in IBD is inconsistent reflecting vegetables from one’s diet.2423 A 2016 data to support a practical recommendation
published research, including observational
uncertainty among healthcare professionals… comparative analysis of the SCD published of AID in managing IBD patients was noted
studies and literature reviews, points to the
With a striking lack of consistent dietary in Nutrition showed improvement in pediatric due to various limitations present in previous
efficacy of the low-FODMAP diet as part of
advice, it is not surprising that people with CD patients, as assessed by the Pediatric research. It is necessary for clinicians advising
a treatment plan for IBD, but researchers
IBD frequently follow their own dietary Crohn’s Disease Activity Index, a validated IBD patients to have in-depth knowledge about
agree that more clinical studies, including
rules.”2387 Advice from the National Institute instrument for measuring disease activity the strengths and limitations of the IBD-AID
randomized controlled trials, need to
of Diabetes and Digestive and Kidney in children and adolescents.2424 However, nutritional regime to ensure its effectiveness
be conducted.2413,2414,2415,2416
Diseases is unspecific; patients with CD are other retrospective surveys in both children as a therapeutic strategy.”2437
suggested to keep a food journal to track their and adults with CD and UC have shown
Research has suggested that the
food triggers,2388 and patients with UC are mixed results, with only a subset of patients Dietary Supplements and IBD
Mediterranean diet may be a useful
recommended to eat a “healthy diet.”2389 experiencing small improvements in
therapeutic tool for IBD due to its potential role Some IBD patients have turned to dietary
disease outcomes.2425,2426,2427,2428,2429
in modulating gut inflammation.2417,2418 A 2020 supplements as part of their treatment
“Guidelines for dietary recommendations
study of more than 100 adults with either UC or plans, and consume supplements such as
and nutritional therapy for patients with Derived from the SCD is the Inflammatory
CD appearing in Inflammatory Bowel Diseases curcumin.2438,2439 Curcumin has been shown
inflammatory bowel disease (IBD) are Bowel Disease Anti-Inflammatory Diet (IBD-
showed “improvement of disease activity and to inhibit the activation of transcription factors
lacking, and patients are moving toward AID), which was developed by researchers at
inflammatory markers” after adoption of the that lead to inflammation.2440 A subsequent
popular defined diets for relief of symptoms the University of Massachusetts Chan Medical
Mediterranean diet.2419 However, according double-blind, placebo-controlled trial published
and inflammation,” wrote researchers in School.2430,2431 According to the developers of
to a 2021 study appearing in Nutrition & in Current Pharmaceutical Design in 2009
Gastroenterology & Hepatology in 2019.2390 the diet writing in Nutrition Journal in 2014:
Dietetics, the typical diets of many IBD reported that patients given curcumin were
Many of these popular defined diets and
patients align poorly with Mediterranean less likely than controls to have a recurrence
food treatments have been studied for The IBD-AID consists of lean meats,
diet characteristics, suggesting that “dietary in UC symptoms in the six months after
their effects on symptoms of IBD, such poultry, fish, omega-3 eggs, particular
interventions focusing on improving the diet of sources of carbohydrate, select fruits and treatment.2441 Larger studies analyzing higher
as a low-FODMAP diet,2391,2392,2393,2394 an
individuals with inflammatory bowel disease to vegetables, nut and legume flours, limited doses of the supplement are recommended to
anti-inflammatory diet,2395,2396,2397,2398,2399,2400
align with Mediterranean diet characteristics aged cheeses (made with active cultures better understand its effect on IBD.2442
probiotic supplementation,2401,2402,2403,2404 and
are warranted.”2420 and enzymes), fresh cultured yogurt, kefir,
the Mediterranean diet.2405,2406,2407. Most of
miso and other cultured products (rich with Another supplement that has been studied
the research into the efficacy of these dietary
certain probiotics), and honey.2432 as a potential diet intervention for IBD is fiber,
190 PART IV Food as Medicine: Treating and Managing Disease PART IV Food as Medicine: Treating and Managing Disease 191
derived from a variety of plant sources.2443 for IBD.2448 The results do not appear as of several cell types.2478 Selenium has been HIV-1 viral replication.2490 However, certain
A randomized controlled trial appearing efficacious for patients with CD as they are shown to inhibit HIV replication pathways, forms of garlic can significantly decrease the
in Crohn’s & Colitis in 2020 reported the for those suffering from UC.2449 Three meta- and zinc is needed for T cell proliferation, levels of some antiviral medications.2491
prevention of gastrointestinal symptoms analyses, conducted between 2009 and 2015, helps with electrolyte absorption, and acts
among UC patients treated with 60 grams of reported that some strains, including E. coli as an anti-inflammatory agent. Early studies As a result of increased survival rates for
oat bran a day,2444 but additional studies are Nissle 1917 and Lactobacillus GG, were in PLWH found a high prevalence of zinc PLWH due to the advancements in treatment
required to determine the long-term benefits just as effective as mesalazine, a common deficiency in HIV patients.24792480 Selenium and increased accessibility of ART, the
of oat bran supplementation.2445 According medication for IBD, at preventing a relapse deficiency is common in PLWH, correlated population of people aging with HIV is
to a 2017 review in the journal Nutrients, two of UC symptoms.2450,2451,2452 Two additional with CD4 counts (a measure of white blood increasing.2492 Older adults with HIV are at
open-label trials (trials in which information is meta-analyses aimed at understanding cells that fight infection), viral load and disease even higher risk for age-related complications
not withheld from participants) have found that the impact of probiotics on CD, however, progression.2481 Foods high in selenium, like bone loss2493 and cardiovascular disease,
90 grams of germinated barley foodstuff a day concluded that supplementation with including brazil nuts, tuna, and sardines, compounded by their HIV status.2494 With
2482
reduced abdominal cramping and prolonged Lactobacillus GG and Lactobacillus johnsonii and foods high in zinc such as seafood, heightened risk of decreased muscle
remission in UC patients.2446 Germinated LA1 did not decrease the risk of relapse in CD namely oysters, and beans are recommended mass, memory loss associated with HIV
barley appears to be a safe maintenance patients.2453,2454 Further study of the varying for PLWH.2483 Additional micronutrients that and aging,2495 PLWH within the aging
therapy for adults with UC.2447 impacts of different strains and dosages on benefit PLWH include vitamin A, which can population have an even greater need for
both UC and CD are needed to determine the assist in increasing CD4 count,2484 and vitamin adequate nutrition.2496
Several clinical trials have investigated the patient populations that could benefit from D, which can address HIV-related bone
use of various species and strains of E. coli probiotic treatment.2455 problems associated with nutritional deficiency, Food insecurity adversely impacts the ability
and Lactobacillus bacteria as treatments HIV-infection, and ART interactions.2485 to manage HIV.2497,2498 For people living with
HIV (PLWH), food insecurity is associated
Alongside ART, medicinal plant extracts and with poor medication adherence, poor
192 PART IV Food as Medicine: Treating and Managing Disease PART IV Food as Medicine: Treating and Managing Disease 193
condition among patients hospitalized for (SNS), the amount of intra-abdominal and
COVID-19;2511 according to the CDC, “people intra-vascular fat, sodium retention leading
whose only underlying medical condition is to increase in renal reabsorption, and the
hypertension might be at increased risk for renin-angiotensin system, are considered to
severe illness from COVID-19.”2512 have important functions in the pathogenesis
of obesity-related hypertension.”2525 While
Although there are genetic influences on blood obesity is an increased risk factor for
pressure, diet also has a significant impact.2513 hypertension, weight loss of as little as ten
A 2018 study appearing in JAMA Cardiology pounds has shown to be effective in reducing
of the blood pressure levels of indigenous blood pressure.2526,2527
Yanomami and Yekwana individuals in
Venezuela demonstrated that increases in The National Institutes of Health National
blood pressure might not be a natural result Heart, Lung, and Blood Institute (NHLBI)
of aging, but rather a consequence of other recommends the DASH (Dietary Approaches
factors such as diet.2514 In societies where salt to Stop Hypertension) eating plan for people
intake is low, hypertension occurs at much managing hypertension.2528 This eating plan
lower rates.2515,2516 The recommended daily does not consist of specific foods, but rather
intake of salt is less than 2,300mg, or less provides broader nutritional guidelines:
than a teaspoon, but many processed foods
and fast foods can exceed that amount in just ● Consuming vegetables, fruits, and
one meal.2517,2518 whole grains
194 PART IV Food as Medicine: Treating and Managing Disease PART IV Food as Medicine: Treating and Managing Disease 195
pressure, overweight, and obesity among Available data seem to suggest that quality may be a modifiable risk factor for produce the neurotransmitters dopamine and
adolescents, 2532 [ketogenic diets] are able to provide mental illness.2542 norepinephrine, which are brain chemicals
a reduction in blood pressure values that play a role in mood, motivation, and
Several other dietary changes have been but do not induce significantly different Epidemiological studies have demonstrated concentration.2560 Refined sugar intake (e.g.
studied for their impact on treating and changes compared to non-ketogenic a consistent association between nutrition sugar-sweetened beverages) has been linked
managing hypertension. A 2018 study diets. These data suggest that the and mental health.2543 Several systematic to increased rates of depression, possibly
antihypertensive effects of [ketogenic reviews have shown healthy dietary
appearing in Clinical Cardiology showed that by altering endorphin levels and oxidative
diets] are not directly related to the precise
following a plant-based dietary intervention patterns (characterized by high intake of stress.2561,2562 Vegetable oil, which contains
metabolic consequences induced by
might be an effective approach to treatment for vegetables, fruit, wholegrains, nuts, seeds many types of dietary fat, has also been
ketosis but rather indirectly due mainly to
hypertension.2533 This dietary intervention used weight loss.2535 and fish, with limited processed food) to shown to activate endorphin neurons in the
a food classification system that emphasized be inversely associated with the risk of hypothalamus in rats.2563,2564
raw fruits and vegetables.2534One 2021 review Individuals with hypertension are frequently depression.2544,2545,2546 Conversely, diets
from the journal Nutrients assessed the link targeted by various food prescription programs consisting of processed, high-fat, high-sugar Fruit and vegetable consumption has
between hypertension and the ketogenic as a way to increase access to fruits and foods are associated with mental disorders also been shown to have an impact on
diet, concluding: vegetables.2536,2537 To learn more about such as depression and anxiety, as well as mood.2565,2566,2567 A 2021 study published in
produce prescription programs see Part 3. other neuropsychiatric conditions (conditions Clinical Nutrition found that fruit and vegetable
that have both neurological and psychiatric intake was inversely associated with perceived
features).2547,2548 Additionally, vitamin stress across the adult lifespan.2568 The study
deficiencies have also been shown to impair
Mental Health Conditions and Illnesses
indicated that “people who ate at least 470
mental health and cognition.2549,2550,2551 The grams of fruit and vegetables daily had 10
link is strongest for vitamin B12 deficiency per cent lower stress levels than those who
According to the National Institutes of Health Standard treatment for mental health which has been shown to affect cognition, consumed less than 230 grams.”2569 The
National Institute of Mental Health (NIMH), conditions can include the use of evidence- cause brain shrinkage, and can be associated WHO recommends a minimum daily intake
mental illnesses can include many different based medications, therapy and psychosocial with depression.2552,2553,2554,2555 Deficiency in of 400 grams of fruits and vegetables.2570 A
conditions that vary in degree of severity and services; however, it is estimated that in 2020 omega-3 fatty acids has also been linked to a 2016 study published in the American Journal
can be grouped into two broad categories less than half (46 percent) of those with mental higher risk of depression and suicide.2556 of Public Health found that increased fruit
described below: illness received mental health services.2541 and vegetable consumption was predictive
The emerging field of nutritional psychiatry Research has also demonstrated that food of increased happiness, life satisfaction, and
Any mental illness (AMI) is defined as a explores the adjunct role of food and nutrition can affect the chemical composition of the well-being and noted that improvements in
mental, behavioral, or emotional disorder. in the prevention and treatment of mental brain and impact mood.2557 In 1995, Richard happiness were seen long before any physical
AMI can vary in impact, ranging from no health conditions. In a review of the nutritional Wurtman, M.D. and Judith Wurtman, Ph.D., improvements.2571 Another study published in
impairment to mild, moderate, and even psychiatry literature published by Cambridge
severe impairment. Serious mental illness researchers at the Massachusetts Institute Frontiers of Psychology in 2018 demonstrated
University Press in 2017, the authors advocate
(SMI) is defined as a mental, behavioral, of Technology (MIT), published a review in that intake of raw fruits and vegetables was
for additional strategies to prevent and treat Obesity Research outlining how carbohydrate associated with better mental health than
or emotional disorder resulting in serious
mental health that integrate evidence on the foods boosted the production of serotonin, a intake of processed fruits and vegetables.2572
functional impairment, which substantially
interferes with or limits one or more major role of food and nutrition: neurotransmitter that controls mood, sleep, The gut-brain axis, which refers to the
life activities.2538 and appetite, and, when elevated, helps you to communication between the gut and the brain
Treatment is presently dominated feel more relaxed and calm.2558 This research via neural, endocrine, and immune pathways,
by pharmacotherapy, such as
It is estimated that mental illness affects 52.9 has shown that glucose in high carbohydrate has been shown to influence mood and mental
antidepressants, and psychotherapy,
million people (one in five adults) and serious food triggers the release of insulin which health.2573 The communication works both
such as cognitive behavioural therapy;
mental illness affects 14.2 million people however, such treatments avert less than in turn allows the amino acid tryptophan to ways, with the brain capable of influencing
(one in 20 adults) in the United States.2539 half of the disease burden, suggesting that reach the brain (by blocking other competing gut activity and the gut influencing mood,
Depression and anxiety are the most common additional strategies are needed to prevent amino acids), stimulating the production of mental health, and cognition.2574 Evidence
mental health conditions, making them a and treat mental disorders. There are now serotonin.2559 Other research has shown that shows that gut microbiota can profoundly
leading cause of disability worldwide.2540 consistent mechanistic, observational dietary protein raises the level of the amino affect the relationship between gut and
and interventional data to suggest diet acids tyrosine and phenylalanine, which brain, including influencing mental state and
196 PART IV Food as Medicine: Treating and Managing Disease PART IV Food as Medicine: Treating and Managing Disease 197
emotion regulation.2575 Other research shows insecurity cause poor mental health, or does understanding tryptophan availability and sweets, refined cereals, fried food, fast food,
that proper maintenance of gastrointestinal poor mental health lead to food insecurity? metabolism may be important.”2594 processed meats, and sugary drinks.
homeostasis results in improved cognitive The two issues have a “bidirectional A 2014 systematic review of randomized The dietary support group had significant
function and motivation.2576 Evidence also association whereby food insecurity increases controlled trials published in Public Health improvement in the consumption of the
shows that several mood disorders, including the risk of poor emotional health, and poor Nutrition reviewed dietary interventions that recommended food groups and significantly
anxiety and depression, are directly linked to emotional health increases the risk of food used depression or anxiety as an outcome and greater improvements in depressive symptoms
gastrointestinal problems.2577,2578 insecurity,” according to reviewers in a 2017 sought to identify characteristics of program compared to the control group.2601 Study
article appearing in Public Health Nutrition.2589 success.2595 The review found mixed results results provide preliminary evidence that
Research suggests that regulating gut activity Various factors have been theorized to with dietary interventions in clinically diagnosed
can result in improved mental health.2579,2580 A explain this relationship. People suffering from populations are feasible and may provide
study published in Scientific Reports in 2021 mental health disorders might have higher [A]pproximately half the studies reporting clinical benefit.2602,2603
looked at anxiety in women ages 18 to 25 and costs of living, leaving less money to spend improvements in outcomes, with
found that galacto-oligosaccharides (GOS) on food.2590 Researchers writing in BMC successful trials generally including at least The burgeoning field of nutritional psychiatry
prebiotics (taken as dietary supplements) was Public Health in 2021 have also proposed one of the following: single delivery mode is supported by epidemiological studies that
associated with a decrease in high trait anxiety that stigmas associated with food assistance (e.g. single or group face-to-face meetings have demonstrated a consistent association
only), employment of a dietitian, explicit
and an increase in bacterial abundance.2581 might lead to poor mental health during the between nutrition and mental health2604
recommendation of a diet high in fibre and/
GOS prebiotic supplements are commercially- COVID-19 pandemic: and emerging findings from clinical trials
or fruit and vegetables. These trials were
available and might be taken to improve also less likely to recommend weight loss, suggest that dietary interventions may play
anxiety symptoms.2582 These findings suggest The stigmatization of receiving food reduce red meat intake or follow a low- a beneficial role in the treatment of mental
that prebiotic supplementation may improve assistance might have increased anxiety cholesterol diet.2596 health conditions.2605 Drew Ramsey, M.D, an
indices of pre-clinical anxiety.2583 and depression for those who were not assistant clinical professor of Psychiatry at
food insecure before, which may help
The ketogenic diet has been proposed as a Columbia University and is one field’s leading
Additionally, mental health disorders have explain why food insecurity is more proponents of nutritional psychiatry.2606 Dr.
associated with anxiety and depression potential therapy for mood disorders such as
been linked to food insecurity. According bipolar,2597 but more robust trials and research Ramsey founded the Brain Food Clinic in New
than losing a job during the pandemic.2591
to the 2011-2014 National Health Interview is needed to determine the efficacy of the diet York City, an integrative mental health clinic
Survey, working-age adults (aged 25-61) living in treating mental health disorders.2598 which incorporates evidence-based nutrition
Additionally, people with mental health
with a mental health disability have a 11.3 and integrative psychiatry treatments with
disorders might have a more difficult time
percent chance of living in a food insecure The SMILES trial, which was published psychotherapy, coaching, and medication
“maintain[ing] (or resum[ing]) employment and
household.2584 A 2017 study published in the
adequate income supplements for…sufficient in BMC Medicine in 2017, was the first management in the treatment of depression,
American Journal of Preventive Medicine anxiety and emotional wellness concerns.2607
financial resources to maintain adequate randomized controlled trial intervention
analyzed cross sectional data from the study to test dietary improvement as a In a 2019 New York Times article Dr. Ramsey
nutrition,” write researchers in Public Health
2014 Gallup World Poll, a series of globally treatment approach for depression.2599 The stated, “We can’t control our genes, who our
in 2016.2592
implemented, nationally representative dietary intervention comprised personalized parents were, or if random acts of trauma or
surveys, and found that food insecurity was counseling from a clinical dietician in violence happen to us, but we can control
associated with poorer mental health and Dietary Interventions how we eat, and that gives people actionable
order to support optimal adherence to
specific psychosocial stressors across 149 In a review published in Molecular Psychiatry the recommended Mediterranean diet things that they can do to take care of their
countries.2585 A study published in Pediatrics in 2020, the researchers explored the and was compared to a control group brain health on a daily basis.”2608
found that household food insecurity underlying mechanisms of action by which that received social support. Those in the
was related to 27.9 percent higher rates diet may influence mental and brain health dietary intervention group learned about the Most studies to date looking at the relationship
of depressive symptoms in children.2586 and highlighted the importance of tryptophan Mediterranean diet and were encouraged between diet and mental illness have
Researchers recommend holistic approaches available for metabolism in the management of to consume more whole grains, vegetables, been observational and do not provide
to address these interconnected problems and mental health.2593 The authors also noted the fruit, legumes, low-fat and unsweetened dairy information about causality or underlying
protect children against food insecurity.2587 need for more research into the associations foods, raw and unsalted nuts, fish, lean red mechanisms.2609 Additional research is needed
between dietary tryptophan and mental health: meats, chicken, eggs, and olive oil.2600 They to elucidate on the underlying mechanisms
Some researchers have questioned where “In the context of using dietary interventions were also encouraged to reduce their intake of between nutrition and mental health and
the relationship between food insecurity for mental health prevention and treatment, explore the effectiveness of various dietary
and mental health originates:2588 Does food
198 PART IV Food as Medicine: Treating and Managing Disease PART IV Food as Medicine: Treating and Managing Disease 199
interventions.2610 However, emerging findings interventions may play a beneficial role in the per week.2639 A 2019 analysis of the Swank symptoms in MS patients.2645 Flavonoids
from clinical trials suggest that dietary treatment of mental health conditions.2611 diet in comparison to the Dietary Guidelines (organic compounds rich in antioxidants)
for Americans published in Nutrients found with phytopigments that are found in fruits
that the Swank diet meets nearly all of the and vegetables may be a protective agent
200 PART IV Food as Medicine: Treating and Managing Disease PART IV Food as Medicine: Treating and Managing Disease 201
individuals’ sleep patterns on their ability to supplementation are poorly understood, so the
maintain a diet high in foods perceived as NCCIH advises that people talk to their health
“healthy,” including a 2013 study appearing in care providers about use of supplements,
the International Journal of Obesity.2660 In this including melatonin.2674
study, participants who got only four hours of Another compound frequently associated with
sleep experienced greater brain rewards (such sleep is tryptophan, described by the National
as pleasure) when looking at unhealthy foods Library of Medicine’s PubChem as:
like pizza, doughnuts, and candy compared to
when they got nine hours of sleep.2661 These …the least plentiful of all 22 amino acids
results suggest sleep restriction alters the and an essential amino acid in humans
body’s response to foods.2662 The researchers (provided by food). Tryptophan is found in
noted, “Although we believe that all foods most proteins and a precursor of serotonin.
have a place as part of a healthy diet, foods Tryptophan is converted to 5-hydroxy-
tryptophan (5-HTP), converted in turn to
established as being unhealthy such as
serotonin, a neurotransmitter essential
candy and ice cream may produce feelings
in regulating appetite, sleep, mood, and
of guilt regardless of their calorie content.”2663 pain. Tryptophan is a natural sedative and
One’s ability to get a good night’s sleep is present in dairy products, meats, brown
positively correlated with maintaining a healthy rice, fish, and soybeans.2675
diet.2664,2665 According to Dr. Susan Redline,
a physician as well as a professor of sleep Some studies have shown that tryptophan
medicine at Harvard Medical School, “The might be effective as a sleep aid. According
takeaway is that diet and sleep are entwined. to a 2021 article published in Nature and
Improving one can help you improve the other Science of Sleep analyzing survey data from
and vice versa, creating a positive cycle where 7,890 Chinese adults, researchers found
they perpetuate one another.”2666 that higher intake of dietary tryptophan was
positively associated with sleep duration.2676
Some individuals turn to dietary supplements, A 2022 review appearing in Nutrition Reviews
notably melatonin, as sleep aids.2667,2668 showed that tryptophan supplementation might
According to the NCCIH, “Melatonin is a improve sleep quality.2677 About the potential
hormone that your brain produces in response uses for tryptophan, the National Library of
to darkness. It helps with the timing of your Medicine writes, “People use L-tryptophan for
circadian rhythms (24-hour internal clock) and severe PMS symptoms, depression, insomnia,
with sleep.”2669 Multiple Cochrane systematic and many other conditions, but there is no
reviews of the impact of melatonin on sleep good scientific evidence to support any of
quality, quantity, and duration have found these uses.”2678
little to no high-quality evidence supporting
its use.2670,2671,2672,2673 Side effects of melatonin
202 PART IV Food as Medicine: Treating and Managing Disease PART IV Food as Medicine: Treating and Managing Disease 203
Part V
Recommendations
204 PART IV Food as Medicine: Treating and Managing Disease PART IV Food as Medicine: Treating and Managing Disease 205
PA RT V • Food as medicine programs (such as medically tailored meals and produce
prescriptions) on health outcomes.
Recommendations
• Incorporate foods and dietary patterns from many different cultures into this research
to ensure food interventions are culturally appropriate for all participants.
ο Research should include robust clinical trials with large sample sizes necessary to
evaluate the efficacy of the above approaches.
ο Invest in research to identify and tailor effective implementation of food as medicine
programs for at-risk communities in a variety of settings.
● Create and maintain a central repository that identifies all current food as
Incorporating food as medicine practices into traditional healthcare is a strategy that medical medicine programs and interventions operating in the United States.
professionals, insurance companies, policymakers, community organizations, and other key ο The central repository will identify all existing food as medicine programs in the
stakeholders must explore to effectively prevent and treat chronic disease, lower health care United States (including nutrition incentive and voucher programs, medically-
costs, and improve patient quality of life. Food and dietary modifications can be included as a tailored meals programs, produce prescription programs, and culinary medicine and
part of treatment for a variety of diseases and conditions, in conjunction with modern medical education programs).
treatments. ο The repository should be developed to serve as a central access point for food as
medicine programs and interventions, where stakeholders can easily engage with
This report, with more than 2,500 citations and the curation of more than 650 studies, existing programs for referrals and obtain up to date information to disseminate to target
systematic reviews, meta-analyses, and other peer-reviewed journal articles, aims to serve audiences.
as a bridge between food-based treatment and traditional medicine, demonstrating that both ο The repository should also provide food as medicine program leaders with opportunities
should be considered to most effectively prevent and treat disease. There are still significant to connect and collaborate (e.g., creation of listservs and forums).
opportunities for further research, which have been outlined in this report.
● Disease-Specific Food as Medicine Research and Resource Guides: Create,
The goal of this report is to bridge the gap between traditional medicine and the use of food as curate, and update daily disease specific food as medicine research and
medicine in the prevention and treatment of disease. It is our hope that this report will serve as a resource portals / guides to translate and disseminate peer-reviewed,
foundation for understanding the potential uses of food and diet as a therapeutic mechanism. evidence-based research to academics, researchers, physicians, physician
extenders , individuals, caregivers, and family members of those diagnosed
The Center for Food as Medicine and the Hunter College NYC Food Policy Center have as well as the general public. These guides will use evidence-based research
compiled the following recommendations for healthcare professionals, insurance companies, to dispel myths and pseudoscience and bridge the gap between traditional
policymakers, community organizations, and other key stakeholders to consider when designing medicine and the impact of food on disease.
food as medicine interventions, programming, policies, and research. The two Centers make
ο The resource guides should be created and updated for specific health states such as
these recommendations to contribute to a healthier and more equitable future for all.
Multiple Sclerosis, Autism, Diabetes, Crohn’s, Alzheimer’s, and Depression.
ο Each resource guide will summarize the disease, how diet can positively or negatively
● Evaluate the impact of food on the prevention and treatment of disease. impact it, and specific foods to manage and treat the disease.
ο Congress must approve increased funding to the NIH to provide grants to researchers ο Each resource guide will be formed with evidence-based research that has undergone
specifically focused on the use of food in prevention and treatment of disease, potentially critical analysis by health professionals and scientists. The resource guides should be
reducing the dependency that many researchers currently have on funding from the food tailored for a variety of audiences and be available at no cost on the internet.
industry. ο See the Center for Food as Medicine’s Food as Medicine Resources and Research
ο Topic areas for funded research should include: Guides as an example.
208 U.S. National Library of Medicine. Hippocrates and 1977;21(3):235-260. doi:10.1017/S0025727300038242 233 Feerick J. Humoural Theory: Inside the Strange Pseu- 244 Jouanna J, Dietetics in Hippocratic Medicine: Defi-
the Rise of Rational Medicine. Greek Medicine. Sep- 221 National Library of Medicine. Hippocrates and the doscience That Dominated Western Medicine for 2,000 nition, Main Problems, Discussion. In: van der Eijk P, ed.
tember 16, 2002. Updated February 7, 2012. Accessed Rise of Rational Medicine. Greek Medicine. September Years. Discover. December 16, 2020. Accessed October Greek Medicine from Hippocrates to Galen: Selected Papers.
October 26, 2021. https://www.nlm.nih.gov/hmd/greek/ 16, 2002. Updated February 7, 2012. Accessed October 26, 2021. https://www.discovermagazine.com/the-sci- Boston, MA: Brill;2012:137-154.
greek_rationality.html. 26, 2021. https://www.nlm.nih.gov/hmd/greek/greek_ra- ences/humoural-theory-inside-the-strange-pseudosci- 245 Jouanna J, Dietetics in Hippocratic Medicine: Defi-
tionality.html. ence-that-dominated-western. nition, Main Problems, Discussion. In: van der Eijk P, ed.
209 Hanson A. Hippocrates the “Greek Miracle” in Med-
icine. Medicina Antiqua. Accessed August 23, 2021. 222 Lonie IM. A Structural Pattern in Greek Dietetics 234 Richet C. An Address on Ancient Humorism and Greek Medicine from Hippocrates to Galen: Selected Papers.
https://www.ucl.ac.uk/~ucgajpd/medicina%20antiqua/ and the Early History of Greek Medicine. Medical History. Modern Humorism: Delivered at the International Con- Boston, MA: Brill;2012:137-154.
sa_hippint.html. 1977;21(3):235-260. doi:10.1017/S0025727300038242 gress of Physiology Held in Vienna, September 27th to 246 Lonie IM. A Structural Pattern in Greek Dietetics
30th. Br Med J. 1910;2(2596):921-926. doi:10.1136/ and the Early History of Greek Medicine. Medical History.
210 Smith WD. Hippocrates Greek Physician. Encyclo- 223 Cardenas D. Let Not Thy Food Be Confused With bmj.2.2596.921
pedia Britannica. May 18, 2020. Accessed October 26, Thy Medicine: The Hippocratic Misquotation. Clin Nutr. 1977;21(3):235-260. doi:10.1017/S0025727300038242
235 In Our Time. BBC Sounds. December 20, 2007. Ac-
2021. 2013;8(6):e260-e263. doi:10.1016/j.clnme.2013.10.002 247 Lonie IM. A Structural Pattern in Greek Dietetics
cessed October 26, 2021. https://www.bbc.co.uk/sounds/ and the Early History of Greek Medicine. Medical History.
https://www.britannica.com/biography/Hippocrates. 224 Cardenas D. Let Not Thy Food Be Confused With play/b008h5dz.
Thy Medicine: The Hippocratic Misquotation. Clin Nutr. 1977;21(3):235-260. doi:10.1017/S0025727300038242
211 Cardenas D. Let Not Thy Food Be Confused With 236 Moreau, E. (2020). From Food to Elements and
Thy Medicine: The Hippocratic Misquotation. Clin Nutr. 2013;8(6):e260-e263. doi:10.1016/j.clnme.2013.10.002 248 Shmerling R. The Myth of the Hippocratic Oath.
Humors: Digestion in Late Renaissance Galenism. In G. Harvard Health Blog. November 25, 2015. Accessed Oc-
2013;8(6):e260-e263. doi:10.1016/j.clnme.2013.10.002 225 Cardenas D. Let Not Thy Food Be Confused With Korobili & R. Lo Presti (Ed.), Nutrition and Nutritive Soul in
Thy Medicine: The Hippocratic Misquotation. Clin Nutr. tober 26, 2021
212 Cardenas D. Let Not Thy Food Be Confused With Aristotle and Aristotelianism (pp. 319-338). Berlin, Boston:
Thy Medicine: The Hippocratic Misquotation. Clin Nutr. 2013;8(6):e260-e263. doi:10.1016/j.clnme.2013.10.002 De Gruyter. doi: 10.1515/9783110690552-016. https://www.health.harvard.edu/blog/the-myth-of-the-hip-
2013;8(6):e260-e263. doi:10.1016/j.clnme.2013.10.002 226 Cardenas D. Let Not Thy Food Be Confused With pocratic-oath-201511258447.
237 U.S. National Library of Medicine. The Unruly
213 Adelman J, Haushofer L. Introduction: Food as Thy Medicine: The Hippocratic Misquotation. Clin Nutr. Woman. History of Medicine. January 30, 2012. Updated 249 U.S. National Library of Medicine. Asclepius. Greek
Medicine, Medicine as Food. J Hist Med Allied Sci. 2013;8(6):e260-e263. doi:10.1016/j.clnme.2013.10.002 September 19, 2013. Accessed October 26, 2021. https:// Medicine. September 16, 2002. Accessed October 26,
2018;73(2):127-134. doi:10.1093/jhmas/jry010 227 U.S. National Library of Medicine. Galen. Greek www.nlm.nih.gov/exhibition/shakespeare/taming.html. 2021. https://www.nlm.nih.gov/hmd/greek/greek_as-
Medicine. September 16, 2002. Updated July 16, 2015. clepius.html.
214 Cardenas D. Let Not Thy Food Be Confused With 238 U.S. National Library of Medicine. Melancholy in Age.
Thy Medicine: The Hippocratic Misquotation. Clin Nutr. Accessed October 26, 2021. The Case of Shylock. History of Medicine. January 30, 250 BBC. In Our Time. BBC Sounds. December 20, 2007.
2013;8(6):e260-e263. doi:10.1016/j.clnme.2013.10.002 https://www.nlm.nih.gov/hmd/greek/greek_galen.html. 2012. Updated September 19, 2013. Accessed October https://www.bbc.co.uk/sounds/play/b008h5dz.
26, 2021. https://www.nlm.nih.gov/exhibition/shake- 251 Mirghazanfari SM. Sanguine Temperament: Spec-
215 Witkamp RF, van Norren K. Let Thy Food Be 228 U.S. National Library of Medicine. Galen. Greek Med-
speare/merchant.html. ifications and Lifestyle. Tehran Times. July 19, 2017.
Thy Medicine… When Possible. Eur J Pharmacol. icine. September 16, 2002. Updated July 16, 2015. Ac-
2018;836:102-114. doi:10.1016/j.ejphar.2018.06.026 cessed October 26, 2021. https://www.nlm.nih.gov/hmd/ 239 U.S. National Library of Medicine. The World of Accessed October 26, 2021. https://www.tehrantimes.
greek/greek_galen.html. Shakespeare’s Humors. History of Medicine. January 30, com/news/415195/Sanguine-temperament-Specifica-
2012. Updated September 19, 2013. Accessed October tions-and-lifestyle.
26, 2021. https://www.nlm.nih.gov/exhibition/shake- 252 Ayurveda. Johns Hopkins Medicine. November 5,
speare/fourhumors.html. 2020. Accessed October 26, 2021.
407 Academic Publications. Johns Hopkins Center for 419 Adelman J, Haushofer L. Introduction: Food as style Changes Reverse Coronary Heart Disease?: The 444 Esselstyn CB. A Plant-Based Diet and Coronary
Psychedelic and Consciousness Research. Accessed Sep- Medicine, Medicine as Food. J Hist Med Allied Sci. Lifestyle Heart Trial. Lancet. 1990;336(8708):129-133. Artery Disease: A Mandate for Effective Therapy. J Geriatr
tember 30, 2021. 2018;73(2)127-134. doi:10.1093/jhmas/jry010 doi:10.1016/0140-6736(90)91656-U Cardiol. 2017;14(5):317-320. doi:10.11909/j.issn.1671-
434 Daubenmier J.J., Weidner G., Sumner M.D. et al. 5411.2017.05.004
https://hopkinspsychedelic.org/publications. 420 Adelman J, Haushofer L. Introduction: Food as
Medicine, Medicine as Food. J Hist Med Allied Sci. The Contribution of Changes in Diet, Exercise, and Stress 445 McGoey-Smith K, Esselstyn C, McGoey-Smith A.
408 Davis AK, Barrett FS, May DG, Cosimano MP, Management to Changes in Coronary Risk in Women Reversal of Pulmonary Hypertension, Diabetes, and Reti-
Sepeda ND, Johnson MW, Finan PH, Griffiths RR. 2018;73(2)127-134. doi:10.1093/jhmas/jry010
and Men in the Multisite Cardiac Lifestyle Intervention nopathy After Adoption of a Whole Food Plant-Based Diet.
Effects of Psilocybin-Assisted Therapy on Major De- 421 Adelman J, Haushofer L. Introduction: Food as Program. Ann of Behav Med. 2007;22:57-68. doi:10.1207/ Int Jour Dis Reversal Prev. 2019;1(2):10. doi:10.22230/
pressive Disorder: A Randomized Clinical Trial. JAMA Medicine, Medicine as Food. J Hist Med Allied Sci. s15324796abm3301_7 ijdrp.2019v1n2a41
Psychiatry 2021;78(5):481-489. doi:10.1001/jamapsy- 2018;73(2)127-134. doi:10.1093/jhmas/jry010
435 Ornish D, Scherwitz L, Billings JH. Intensive Lifestyle 446 McGoey-Smith K, Esselstyn C, McGoey-Smith A.
chiatry.2020.3285 422 Project Open Hand. Accessed July 21, 2021. https:// Changes for Reversal of Coronary Heart Disease. JAMA. Reversal of Pulmonary Hypertension, Diabetes, and Reti-
409 Garcia-Romeu A, Davis AK, Erowid F, Erowid E, www.openhand.org/. 1998;280(23):2001-2007. doi:10.1001/jama.280.23.2001 nopathy After Adoption of a Whole Food Plant-Based Diet.
Griffiths RR, Johnson MW. Cessation and Reduction 423 God’s Love We Deliver. Accessed July 21, 2021. Int Jour Dis Reversal Prev. 2019;1(2):10. doi:10.22230/
436 Sumner M, Elliot-Eller M, Weidner G, et al. Effects of
in Alcohol Consumption and Misuse After Psyche- https://www.glwd.org/. ijdrp.2019v1n2a41
delic Use. J Psychopharmacol. 2019;33(9):1088-1101. Pomegranate Juice Consumption on Myocardial Perfusion
doi:10.1177/0269881119845793 424 Community Servings. Accessed July 21, 2021. in Patients With Coronary Heart Disease. J Am Coll Cardiol. 447 McGoey-Smith K, Esselstyn C, McGoey-Smith A.
https://www.servings.org/. 2005;96(6):810-814. doi:10.1016/j.amjcard.2005.05.026 Reversal of Pulmonary Hypertension, Diabetes, and Reti-
410 Griffiths RR, Johnson MW, Carducci MA, Umbricht nopathy After Adoption of a Whole Food Plant-Based Diet.
425 Palar K, Napoles T, Hufstedler LL, et al. Compre- 437 Ornish D, Brown SE, Billings JH, et al. Can Life-
A, Richards WA, Richards BD, Cosimano MP, Klinedinst Int Jour Dis Reversal Prev. 2019;1(2):10. doi:10.22230/
MA. Psilocybin Produces Substantial and Sustained hensive and Medically Appropriate Food Support Is As- style Changes Reverse Coronary Heart Disease?: The
Lifestyle Heart Trial. Lancet. 1990;336(8708):129-133. ijdrp.2019v1n2a41
Decreases in Depression and Anxiety in Patients With sociated With Improved HIV and Diabetes Health. J Urban
Life-Threatening Cancer: A Randomized Double-Blind Health. 2017;94:87-99. doi:10.1007/s11524-016-0129-7 doi:10.1016/0140-6736(90)91656-U 448 Conason J. Bill Clinton Explains Why He Became a
Trial. J Psychopharmacol. 2016;30(12):1181-1197. 438 Daubenmier JJ, Weidner G, Sumner MD, Mendell N, Vegan. AARP. August 2013. Accessed October 28, 2021.
426 The Ryan White HIV/AIDS Program: A Living History.
doi:10.1177/0269881116675513 Health Resources and Services Administration. Accessed Merritt-Worden T, Studley J, Ornish D. The Contribution https://www.aarp.org/health/healthy-living/info-08-2013/
411 Noorani T, Garcia-Romeu A, Swift TC, Griffiths September 27, 2021. of Changes in Diet, Exercise, and Stress Management bill-clinton-vegan.html.
RR, Johnson MW. Psychedelic Therapy for Smoking to Changes in Coronary Risk in Women and Men in 449 Esselstyn CB. President Bill Clinton Credits Dr.
https://hab.hrsa.gov/livinghistory/.
Cessation: Qualitative Analysis of Participant Ac- the Multisite Cardiac Lifestyle Intervention Program. Caldwell Esselstyn for Weight Loss and Heart Health Ben-
427 About the Ryan White HIV/Aids Program. Health Re- Ann Behav Med. 2007;33(1):57-68. doi:10.1207/
counts. J Psychopharmacol. 2018;32(7):756-769. efits. PRNewswire. October 4, 2010. Accessed October
sources and Services Administration. Updated December s15324796abm3301_7
doi:10.1177/0269881118780612 28, 2021. https://www.prnewswire.com/news-releases/
2020. Accessed October 26, 2021. https://hab.hrsa.gov/
439 Ornish D, Magbanua MJ, Weidner G, Weinberg V, president-bill-clinton-credits-dr-caldwell-esselstyn-for-
412 Johnson MW, Griffiths RR. Potential Therapeutic about-ryan-white-hivaids-program/about-ryan-white-
Effects of Psilocybin. Neurotherapeutics. 2017;14:734-740. Kemp C, Green C, Mattie MD, Marlin R, Simko J, Shi- weight-loss-and-heart-health-benefits-104272588.html.
hivaids-program.
doi:10.1007/s13311-017-0542-y nohara K, Haqq CM, Carroll PR. Changes in Prostate Gene 450 Adams E. How I Reversed My Diabetes and Became
428 Aidala A, Anema A, Pearl K, et al. Food Is Medicine: Expression in Men Undergoing an Intensive Nutrition and
413 Adelman J, Haushofer L. Introduction: Food as Healthy at Last. T. Colin Campbell Center for Nutrition
The Ryan White Food and Nutrition Services Program as Lifestyle Intervention. Proc Natl Acad Sci USA. 2008 Jun
Medicine, Medicine as Food. J Hist Med Allied Sci. Studies. September 21, 2020. Updated March 3, 2021.
a Model for Comprehensive Food and Nutrition Services 17;105(24):8369-74. doi:10.1073/pnas.0803080105
2018;73(2)127-134. doi:10.1093/jhmas/jry010 Accessed October 28, 2021. https://nutritionstudies.org/
in the United States. In: Health of HIV Infected People Food,
440 Ornish D. Can Lifestyle Changes Reverse Alzheimer’s how-i-reversed-my-diabetes-and-became-healthy-at-last/.
Nutrition and Lifestyle with Antiretroviral Drugs. 2015:213-
Disease? Preventative Medicine Research Institute. Ac-
242.
cessed on August 24, 2021.
462 The Yale-Griffin Prevention Research Center. Ac- recipes/food-guidelines/. CBS News. March 3, 2004. Accessed October 24, 2021. 504 Berger S. NFL Players’ Surprising New Performance
cessed October 1, 2021. https://yalegriffinprc.griffin- 477 Food Guidelines. Blue Zones. Updated 2020. Ac- https://www.cbsnews.com/news/mcdonalds-scrap- Hack—Going Vegan. CNBC. January 31, 2018. Accessed
health.org/. cessed November 5, 2020. https://www.bluezones.com/ ping-supersize/. October 26, 2021. https://www.cnbc.com/2018/01/31/
recipes/food-guidelines/. 491 Fulkerson L. Forks Over Knives. [online stream]. why-nfl-players-and-other-athletes-are-going-vegan.html.
463 True Health Initiative. Accessed October 1, 2021.
Newtown, PA: Virgil Films & Entertainment; 2011. 505 Psihoyos L. The Game Changers. [online stream] Los
https://www.truehealthinitiative.org/. 478 Food Guidelines. Blue Zones. Updated 2020. Ac-
cessed November 5, 2020. https://www.bluezones.com/ 492 Our Story. Forks Over Knives. Accessed August 26, Gatos, CA: Netflix. 2019.
464 DietID. Accessed October 1, 2021.https://www.dietid.
recipes/food-guidelines/. 2021. https://www.forksoverknives.com/our-story/. 506 Psihoyos L. The Game Changers. [online stream] Los
com/.
493 Fulkerson L. Forks Over Knives. [online stream]. Gatos, CA: Netflix. 2019.
Newtown, PA: Virgil Films & Entertainment; 2011.
1155 https://www.eater.com/2015/4/29/8504677/nutri- https://www.seattletimes.com/life/food-drink/its-not-nec- Report By Flavor (Original, Flavored), By Distribution 1186 Navarrete-Muñoz EM, Tard”n A, Romaguera D,
tion-claims-labels-processed-food-nutrition-facts. essarily-healthful-just-because-the-label-says-it-is/. Channel (Supermarkets, Health Stores, Online Stores), Martínez-González MÁ, Vioque J. La Financiaci”n de la
By Region, And Segment Forecasts, 2020 - 2027. Grand Industria Alimentaria Y la Investigaci”n Epidemiol”gica
1156 Inoue-Choi M, Oppeneer SJ, Robien K. Reality 1166 Fakuade M. How Big Beverage Poured Empty View Research. February 2020. Accessed October 19, Sobre Nutrici”n Y Salud [Food Industry Funding and
Check: There Is No Such Thing as a Miracle Food. Nutr Promises Down Our Throats. Vox. July 28, 2021. Ac- 2021. Epidemiologic Research in Public Health Nutrition].
Cancer. 2013;65(2):165-168. doi:10.1080/01635581.201 cessed August 20, 2021. Gac Sanit. 2018 Mar-Apr;32(2):168-171. Spanish.
3.748921 https://www.grandviewresearch.com/industry-analysis/
https://www.vox.com/the-goods/22589131/big-bever- kombucha-market. doi:10.1016/j.gaceta.2017.04.002.
1157 Litwin N, Clifford J, Johnson S. Functional Foods age-wellness-drinks. 1187 Fabbri A, Holland TJ, Bero LA. Food Industry
1178 Kombucha Market Size, Share & COVID-19 Impact
for Health - 9.391. Colorado State University Extension. 1167 Nazhand A, Souto EB, Lucarini M, Souto SB, Du- Sponsorship of Academic Research: Investigating
March 2018. Accessed August 20, 2021. https://ex- Analysis, By Type (Natural and Flavored), Distribution
razzo A, Santini A. Ready to Use Therapeutical Beverages: Channel (Supermarkets/Hypermarkets, Convenience Commercial Bias in the Research Agenda. Public
tension.colostate.edu/topic-areas/nutrition-food-safe- Focus on Functional Beverages Containing Probiotics, Health Nutr. 2018 Dec;21(18):3422-3430. doi:10.1017/
ty-health/functional-foods-for-health-9-391/. Stores, Health Stores, and Online Retail), and Regional
Prebiotics and Synbiotics. Beverages 2020; 6(2):26. Forecast, 2020-2027. Fortune Business Insights. De- S1368980018002100.
1158 Nestle M. Superfoods Are a Marketing Ploy. The doi:10.3390/beverages6020026 cember 2020. Accessed October 19, 2021. https://www. 1188 Rowe S, Alexander N, Clydesdale FM, Applebaum
Atlantic. October 23, 2018. Accessed August 20, 2021. 1168 Chang H-P, Ma C-C, Chen H-S. The Impacts of fortunebusinessinsights.com/industry-reports/kombu- RS, Atkinson S, Black RM, et al. Funding Food Science
https://www.theatlantic.com/health/archive/2018/10/su- Young Consumers’ Health Values on Functional Bev- cha-market-100230. and Nutrition Research: Financial Conflicts and Scien-
perfoods-marketing-ploy/573583/. erages Purchase Intentions. Int J Env Res Pub Health tific Integrity. Am J Clin Nutr. 2009 May;89(5):1285-91.
1179 Esterl M, Maloney J. Dr Pepper, Pepsi Snap Up
1159 Liu H, Meng-Lewis Y, Ibrahim F, Zhu X. Superfoods, 2020; 17(10):3479. doi:10.3390/ijerph17103479 Alternative Beverage Makers. The Wall Street Journal. doi:10.3945/ajcn.2009.27604.
Super Healthy: Myth or Reality? Examining Consumers’ 1169 Fakuade M. How Big Beverage Poured Empty November 22, 2016. Accessed August 20, 2021. https:// 1189 Chartres N, Fabbri A, Bero LA. Association of In-
Repurchase and Wom Intention Regarding Superfoods: Promises Down Our Throats. Vox. July 28, 2021. Ac- www.wsj.com/articles/dr-pepper-snapple-to-acquire-bai- dustry Sponsorship With Outcomes of Nutrition Studies:
A Theory of Consumption Values Perspective. J Bus Res cessed August 20, 2021. https://www.vox.com/the- beverages-for-1-7-billion-1479816988. A Systematic Review and Meta-analysis. JAMA Intern Med.
2021;137:69-88. doi:10.1016/j.jbusres.2021.08.018 goods/22589131/big-beverage-wellness-drinks. 2016 Dec 1;176(12):1769-1777. doi:10.1001/jamaint-
1180 Coca-Cola Buys Australia’s Kombucha Maker Mojo.
1160 Liu H, Meng-Lewis Y, Ibrahim F, Zhu X. Superfoods, Reuters. September 18, 2018. Accessed October 28, ernmed.2016.6721.
1170 Nazhand A, Souto EB, Lucarini M, Souto SB, Du-
Super Healthy: Myth or Reality? Examining Consumers’ razzo A, Santini A. Ready to Use Therapeutical Beverages: 2021. https://www.reuters.com/article/us-coca-cola- 1190 Fabbri A, Lai A, Grundy Q, Bero LA. The Influence of
Repurchase and Wom Intention Regarding Superfoods: Focus on Functional Beverages Containing Probiotics, deals/coca-cola-buys-australias-kombucha-maker-mo- Industry Sponsorship on the Research Agenda: A Scoping
A Theory of Consumption Values Perspective. J Bus Res Prebiotics and Synbiotics. Beverages 2020; 6(2):26. jo-idUSKCN1LY2KD Review. Am J Public Health. 2018 Nov;108(11):e9-e16.
2021;137:69-88. doi:10.1016/j.jbusres.2021.08.018 doi:10.3390/beverages6020026 doi:10.2105/AJPH.2018.304677.
1181 Orrù S, Imperlini E, Nigro E, Alfieri A, Cevenini A,
1161 Papadaki A, Kachrimanidou V, Lappa IK, Eriotou Polito R, Daniele A, Buono P, Mancini A. Role of Func- 1191 Rey-L”pez JP, Gonzalez CA. Research Partnerships
1171 Kim J, Adhikari K. Current Trends in Kombucha:
E, Sidirokastritis N, Kampioti A, Kopsahelis N. Medi- Marketing Perspectives and the Need for Improved tional Beverages on Sport Performance and Recovery. Between Coca-Cola and Health Organizations in Spain. Eur
terranean Raisins/Currants as Traditional Superfoods: Sensory Research. Beverages 2020; 6(1):15. doi:10.3390/ Nutrients 2018; 10(10):1470. doi:10.3390/nu10101470 J Public Health. 2019 Oct 1;29(5):810-815. doi:10.1093/
Processing, Health Benefits, Food Applications and beverages6010015 eurpub/cky175.
1182 Cordrey K, Keim SA, Milanaik R, Adesman A.
Future Trends within the Bio-Economy Era. Appl Sci 2021;
11(4):1605. doi:10.3390/app11041605 1172 Kapp JM, Sumner W. Kombucha: A Systematic Adolescent Consumption of Sports Drinks. Pediatrics 1192 Choi C. How Candy Makers Shape Nutrition
Review of the Empirical Evidence of Human Health 2018;141(6):e20172784. doi:10.1542/peds.2017-2784 Science. Associated Press. June 2, 2016. Accessed
1162 Štepec D, Tavčar G, Ponikvar-Svetab M. Sur- October 20, 2021. https://apnews.com/article/sci-
Benefit. Ann Epidem 2019;30:66-70. doi:10.1016/j.anne- 1183 Orrù S, Imperlini E, Nigro E, Alfieri A, Cevenini A,
prisingly High Fluorine Content in Some Exotic Super- pidem.2018.11.001 ence-nutrition-healthy-eating-archive-only-on-ap-f9483d-
foods. J Flu Chem 2020;234:109521. doi:10.1016/j. Polito R, Daniele A, Buono P, Mancini A. Role of Func-
tional Beverages on Sport Performance and Recovery. 554430445fa6566bb0aaa293d1.
jfluchem.2020.109521 1173 Rattray FP, O’Connell MJ. Encyclopedia of Dairy Sci-
ences. 2nd ed. Academic Press; 2011. Nutrients 2018; 10(10):1470. doi:10.3390/nu10101470 1193 Nestle M. Industry-Funded Study of the Week: Av-
1163 Platkin C. It’s Not Necessarily Healthful Just Be- ocados Again and Again. Food Politics. April 19, 2021.
1174 Kim J, Adhikari K. Current Trends in Kombucha: 1184 Sports Drink Size, Share & COVID-19 Impact
cause the Label Says It Is. The Seattle Times. October 18, Accessed October 27, 2021. https://www.foodpolitics.
2006. Accessed August 20, 2021. Marketing Perspectives and the Need for Improved Analysis, By Type (Isotonic, Hypotonic, and Hypertonic),
Brand (Gatorade, Powerade, and Others), Packaging Type com/2021/04/industry-funded-study-of-the-week-avoca-
Sensory Research. Beverages 2020; 6(1):15. doi:10.3390/
https://www.seattletimes.com/life/food-drink/its-not-nec- (Metal, PET/Plastic, and Glass), Distribution Channel (Of- dos-again-and-again/.
beverages6010015
essarily-healthful-just-because-the-label-says-it-is/. fline Channel and Online Channel), and Regional Forecast, 1194 Search results: Industry-funded study of the week.
1175 Nazhand A, Souto EB, Lucarini M, Souto SB, Du-
1164 Platkin C. It’s Not Necessarily Healthful Just Be- 2021-2028. Fortune Business Insights. May 2021. Ac- Food Politics by Marion Nestle. Accessed August 5, 2021.
razzo A, Santini A. Ready to Use Therapeutical Beverages:
cause the Label Says It Is. The Seattle Times. October 18, cessed October 19, 2021. https://www.fortunebusinessin- https://www.foodpolitics.com/?s=Industry-funded+-
Focus on Functional Beverages Containing Probiotics,
2006. Accessed August 20, 2021. sights.com/sports-drink-market-102083. study+of+the+week.
Prebiotics and Synbiotics. Beverages 2020; 6(2):26.
doi:10.3390/beverages6020026
1632 Gazerani P. Migraine and Diet. Nutrients 1645 Green Tea. National Institutes of Health National doi:10.1016/j.phrs.2017.04.008 1666 Sommella E, Badolati N, Riccio G, et al. A Boost in
2020;12(6):1658. Published 2020 Jun 3. doi:10.3390/ Center of Complementary and Integrative Health. Updated 1657 Yuan L, Zhang F, Jia S, Xie J, Shen M. Differences Mitochondrial Activity Underpins the Cholesterol-Low-
nu12061658 October 2020. Accessed January 27, 2022. https://www. Between Phytosterols with Different Structures in Regu- ering Effect of Annurca Apple Polyphenols on Hepatic
nccih.nih.gov/health/green-tea. lating Cells. Nutrients. 2019;11(1):163. doi:10.3390/nu11010163
1633 Calcium Fact Sheet. National Institutes of Health
1667 Berberine. MedlinePlus. Updated September 16,
Office of Dietary Supplements. Updated November 17, 1646 Niacin Fact Sheet. National Institutes of Health Cholesterol Synthesis, Transport and Metabolism in
2021. Accessed February 3, 2022. https://ods.od.nih.gov/ Office of Dietary Supplements. Updated March 22, 2021. Caco-2 Cells. J Func Food 2020;65:103715. doi:10.1016/j. 2021. Accessed February 3, 2022. https://medlineplus.
factsheets/Calcium-HealthProfessional/. Accessed February 4, 2022. https://ods.od.nih.gov/fact- jff.2019.103715 gov/druginfo/natural/1126.html.
1634 Vitamin D Fact Sheet. National Institutes of Health sheets/Niacin-HealthProfessional/. 1658 Ras RT, Geleijnse JM, Trautwein EA. LDL-choles- 1668 Spigoni V, Aldigeri R, Antonini M, et al. Effects of
Office of Dietary Supplements. Updated August 17, 2021. 1647 Niacin Fact Sheet. National Institutes of Health terol-lowering Effect of Plant Sterols and Stanols Across a New Nutraceutical Formulation (Berberine, Red Yeast
Accessed February 3, 2022. https://ods.od.nih.gov/fact- Office of Dietary Supplements. Updated March 22, 2021. Different Dose Ranges: A Meta-analysis of Randomised Rice and Chitosan) on Non-HDL Cholesterol Levels in In-
sheets/vitamind-healthprofessional/. Accessed February 4, 2022. https://ods.od.nih.gov/fact- Controlled Studies. Br J Nutr. 2014;112(2):214-219. dividuals with Dyslipidemia: Results from a Randomized,
sheets/Niacin-HealthProfessional/. doi:10.1017/S0007114514000750 Double Blind, Placebo-Controlled Study. Int J Mol Sci
1635 Nair R, Maseeh A. Vitamin D: The “Sunshine” Vi- 2017; 18(7):1498. doi:10.3390/ijms18071498
tamin. J Pharmacol Pharmacother 2012;3(2):118-126. 1648 Niacin Fact Sheet. National Institutes of Health 1659 Aziz NAA, Mhd Jalil AM. Bioactive Compounds,
1669 Barrios V, Escobar C, Cicero AF, et al. A Nutraceu-
doi:10.4103/0976-500X.95506 Office of Dietary Supplements. Updated March 22, 2021. Nutritional Value, and Potential Health Benefits of Indig-
Accessed February 4, 2022. https://ods.od.nih.gov/fact- enous Durian (Durio Zibethinus Murr.): A Review. Foods. tical Approach (Armolipid Plus) to Reduce Total and
1636 Castiglioni S, Cazzaniga A, Albisetti W, Maier LDL Cholesterol in Individuals With Mild to Moderate
JA. Magnesium and Osteoporosis: Current State sheets/Niacin-HealthProfessional/. 2019;8(3):96. Published 2019 Mar 13. doi:10.3390/
foods8030096 Dyslipidemia: Review of the Clinical Evidence. Athero-
of Knowledge and Future Research Directions. Nu- 1649 Niacin: Fach Sheet for Consumers. National Insti- scler Suppl 2017;24:1-15. doi:10.1016/j.atherosclero-
trients. 2013;5(8):3022-3033. Published 2013 Jul 31. tutes of Health Office of Dietary Supplements. Updated 1660 Haruenkit R, Poovarodom S, Leontowicz H, et sissup.2016.10.003
doi:10.3390/nu5083022 March 22, 2021. Accessed January 27, 2022. https://ods. al. Comparative Study of Health Properties and Nutri-
1670 Cicero AFG, Parini A, Rosticci M. Nutraceuticals and
1637 Palacios C. The Role of Nutrients in Bone Health, od.nih.gov/factsheets/Niacin-Consumer/. tional Value of Durian, Mangosteen, and Snake Fruit:
Experiments in Vitro and in Vivo. J Agric Food Chem. Cholesterol-lowering Action. IJC Metabolic & Endocrine.
from A to Z. Crit Rev Food Sci Nutr. 2006;46(8):621-628. 1650 Omega-3 Fatty Acids: Fact Sheet for Consumers. 2015;6:1-4. doi: doi:10.1016/j.ijcme.2014.10.009
doi:10.1080/10408390500466174 National Institutes of Health Office of Dietary Supple- 2007;55(14):5842-5849. doi:10.1021/jf070475a
1671 Santini A, Novellino E. Nutraceuticals in Hy-
1638 Rondanelli M, Faliva MA, Tartara A, et al. An ments. Updated August 4, 2021. Accessed January 27, 1661 Miyawaki M, Sano H, Imbe H, et al. “Benifuuki”
2022. https://ods.od.nih.gov/factsheets/Omega3FattyAc- Extract Reduces Serum Levels of Lectin-Like Oxidized percholesterolaemia: An Overview. Br J Pharmacol.
Update on Magnesium and Bone Health. Biometals. 2017;174(11):1450-1463. doi:10.1111/bph.13636
2021;34(4):715-736. doi:10.1007/s10534-021-00305-0 ids-Consumer/. Low-Density Lipoprotein Receptor-1 Ligands Containing
1651 Omega-3 Fatty Acids: Fact Sheet for Consumers. Apolipoprotein B: A Double-Blind Placebo-Controlled 1672 Pérez-Jiménez J, Neveu V, Vos F, Scalbert A.
1639 Capsicum. Medline Plus. Updated August 17, 2021. Randomized Trial. Nutrients. 2018;10(7):924. doi:10.3390/ Identification of the 100 richest dietary sources of poly-
Accessed January 27, 2022. https://medlineplus.gov/dru- National Institutes of Health Office of Dietary Supple-
ments. Updated August 4, 2021. Accessed January 27, nu10070924 phenols: an application of the Phenol-Explorer database.
ginfo/natural/945.html. Eur J Clin Nutr. 2010;64 Suppl 3:S112-20. doi:10.1038/
2022. https://ods.od.nih.gov/factsheets/Omega3FattyAc-
ids-Consumer/. ejcn.2010.221
1808 Abelson R. Major U.S. Health Insurers Report Big zaffarian D. Food Is Medicine: Actions to Integrate Food Food Consumption and Gestational Diabetes Incidence 1841 Jaworowska A, Blackham T, Davies I, et al.
Profits, Benefiting From the Pandemic. The New York and Nutrition Into Healthcare. BMJ. 2020;369:m2482. in the SUN Project. PLoS One. 2014;9(9):e106627. 2014 Nutritional Challenges and Health Implications of
Times. August 5, 2020. Accessed August 24, 2021. doi:10.1136/bmj.m2482 Sep 12. doi:10.1371/journal.pone.0106627 Takeaway and Fast Food. Nutr Rev 2013;71(5):310-318.
https://www.nytimes.com/2020/08/05/health/covid-insur- 1820 Downer S, Berkowitz SA, Harlan TS, Olstad DL, Mo- 1831 Pereira MA, Kartashov AI, Ebbeling CB, et al. doi:10.1111/nure.12031
ance-profits.html. zaffarian D. Food Is Medicine: Actions to Integrate Food Fast-Food Habits, Weight Gain, and Insulin Resistance 1842 Neale T. Health Insurers Hedge Bets With Fast Food
1809 Murphy T. Insurers Add Food to Coverage Menu as and Nutrition Into Healthcare. BMJ. 2020;369:m2482. (the CARDIA Study): 15-year Prospective Analysis. Lancet Stock. ABC News. April 16, 2010. Accessed October 28,
a Way to Improve Health. AP News. January 23, 2021. doi:10.1136/bmj.m2482 2005;365:36-42. doi:10.1016/s0140-6736(04)17663-0 2021. https://abcnews.go.com/Health/w_DietAndFitness/
Accessed October 29, 2021. https://apnews.com/article/ 1821 Social Determinants of Health. Office of Disease 1832 Bowman SA, Vinyard BT. Fast Food Consumption of health-insurance-companies-invest-billions-fast-food-
us-news-nutrition-coronavirus-pandemic-d1e17ef- Prevention and Health Promotion. Accessed August 24, U.S. Adults: Impact on Energy and Nutrient Intakes and stock/story?id=10392603.
502ab92bd41216c90ac60ba5f. 2021. Overweight Status. J Am Coll Nutr 2004;23:163-168. doi:1 1843 Neale T. Health Insurers Hedge Bets With Fast Food
1810 Tobin T. Health Insurance Coverage for Healthy Gro- https://health.gov/healthypeople/objectives-and-data/so- 0.1080/07315724.2004.10719357 Stock. ABC News. April 16, 2010. Accessed October 28,
ceries? More Food-Based Interventions May Be Coming. cial-determinants-health 1833 Duffey KJ, Gordon-Larsen P, Jacobs DR Jr, et al. 2021. https://abcnews.go.com/Health/w_DietAndFitness/
Forbes. May 24, 2018. Differential Associations of Fast Food and Restaurant health-insurance-companies-invest-billions-fast-food-
1822 Social Determinants of Health. Office of Disease stock/story?id=10392603.
Accessed October 29, 2021. https://www.forbes. Prevention and Health Promotion. Accessed August 24, Food Consumption with 3-Y Change in Body Mass Index.
com/sites/tommytobin/2018/05/24/health-insur- 2021. The Coronary Artery Risk Development in Young Adults 1844 Mohan AV, McCormick D, Woolhandler S, Him-
ance/?sh=3c960398459b. Study. Am J Clin Nutr 2007;85:201-208. doi:10.1093/ melstein DU, Boyd JW. Life and Health Insurance
1823 Berkowitz S, Terranova J, Hill C, et al. Meal Delivery ajcn/85.1.201 Industry Investments in Fast Food. Am J Public Health.
1811 Medical Foods Strive for Insurance Coverage. Programs Reduce the Use of Costly Health Care in Dually 2010;100(6):1029-1030. doi:10.2105/AJPH.2009.178020.
1834 Pereira MA, Kartashov AI, Ebbeling CB, et al.
Managed Healthcare Executive. Accessed April 11, 2021. Eligible Medicare and Medicaid Beneficiaries. Health Aff.
https://www.managedhealthcareexecutive.com/view/med- 2018;37(4). doi:10.1377/hlthaff.2017.0999 Fast-Food Habits, Weight Gain, and Insulin Resistance 1845 Clary A. States Are Advancing Healthy Food Pol-
ical-foods-strive-insurance-coverage (the CARDIA Study): 15-year Prospective Analysis. Lancet icies in 2020. National Academy for State Health Policy.
1824 Downer S, Berkowitz S, Harlan T, et al. Food Is 2005;365:36-42. doi:10.1016/s0140-6736(04)17663-0 February 18, 2020. Accessed October 29, 2021. https://
1812 Allen M. Why Your Health Insurer Doesn’t Care Medicine: Actions to Integrate Food and Nutrition Into www.nashp.org/states-are-advancing-healthy-food-poli-
1835 Krishnan S, Coogan PF, Boggs DA, et al. Con-
About Your Big Bill. NPR. May 25, 2018. Accessed Oc- Healthcare. BMJ. 2020;369:2482. doi:10.1136/bmj. cies-in-2020/.
tober 29, 2021. m2482 sumption of Restaurant Foods and Incidence of Type
2 Diabetes in African American Women. Am J Clin Nutr 1846 Virginia Medicaid Managed Care Operational Report.
https://www.npr.org/sections/health- 1825 Sonik RA. Health Insurance and Food Insecurity: 2010;91:465-471. doi:10.3945/ajcn.2009.28682 Virginia’s Medicaid Program. 2020. Accessed October
shots/2018/05/25/613685732/why-your-health-insurer- Sparking a Potential Virtuous Cycle. Am J Public 29, 2021. https://www.dmas.virginia.gov/media/3507/
1836 Duffey KJ, Gordon-Larsen P, Steffen LM, et al.
doesnt-care-about-your-big-bills. Health. 2019 Sep;109(9):1163-1165. doi:10.2105/ final-managed-care-operational-report-cms.pdf.
AJPH.2019.305252. Regular Consumption From Fast Food Establishments
1813 Patient Protection and Affordable Care Act. Public Relative to Other Restaurants is Differentially Asso- 1847 State of Michigan Contract No. Comprehensive
Law 111–148. 1826 Mohan AV, McCormick D, Woolhandler S, ciated with Metabolic Outcomes in Young Adults. J Nutr Health Care Program for the Michigan Department of
1814 Revels S, Kumar S, Ben-Assuli O. Predicting Obesity Himmelstein DU, Boyd JW. Life and Health In- 2009;139:2113-2118. doi:10.3945/jn.109.109520 Health and Human Services. Accessed October 29, 2021.
Rate and Obesity-Related Healthcare Costs Using Data surance Industry Investments in Fast Food. Am J https://www.michigan.gov/documents/contract_7696_7.
1837 Paeratakul S, Ferdinand DP, Champagne CM,
Analytics. Health Pol Tech 2017;6(2):198-207. Doi: Public Health. 2010;100(6):1029-1030. doi:10.2105/ pdf.
AJPH.2009.178020. et al. Fast-Food Consumption Among US Adults and
10.1016/j.hlpt.2017.02.002 Children: Dietary and Nutrient Intake Profile. J Am 1848 Healthy Opportunities Pilots. North Carolina De-
1827 Mohan AV, McCormick D, Woolhandler S, Diet Assoc 2003;103:1332-1338. doi:10.1016/S0002- partment of Health and Human Services. Accessed
1815 Humana Well Dine. Humana. Accessed August 24,
2021. https://www.humana.com/provider/medical-re- Himmelstein DU, Boyd JW. Life and Health In- 8223(03)01086-1 October 29, 2021. https://www.ncdhhs.gov/about/depart-
sources/clinical/health-programs/well-dine surance Industry Investments in Fast Food. Am J ment-initiatives/healthy-opportunities/healthy-opportuni-
1838 Bowman SA, Vinyard BT. Fast Food Consumption of
Public Health. 2010;100(6):1029-1030. doi:10.2105/ ties-pilots.
1816 Murphy T. Insurers Add Food to Coverage Menu as AJPH.2009.178020. U.S. Adults: Impact on Energy and Nutrient Intakes and
a Way to Improve Health. AP News. January 23, 2021. Overweight Status. J Am Coll Nutr 2004;23:163-168. doi:1 1849 Garner AD. Letter to Dave Richard, North Carolina
1828 Bowman S, Gortmaker S, Ebbeling C, et al. Effects 0.1080/07315724.2004.10719357 Department of Health and Human Services. April 25,
Accessed October 29, 2021. https://apnews.com/article/
us-news-nutrition-coronavirus-pandemic-d1e17ef- of Fast-Food Consumption on Energy Intake and Diet 2019. Accessed October 29, 2021. https://www.medicaid.
1839 Clemens LH, Slawson DL, Klesges RC. The EFfect of
502ab92bd41216c90ac60ba5f. Quality Among Children in a National Household Survey. gov/Medicaid-CHIP-Program-Information/By-Topics/
J Am Acad Pediatr. 2004;113(1):112-118. doi:10.1542/ Eating Out on Quality of Diet in Premenopausal Women.
J Am Diet Assoc 1999;99:442-444. doi:10.1016/s0002- Waivers/1115/downloads/nc/nc-medicaid-reform-ca.pdf.
1817 Downer S, Berkowitz SA, Harlan TS, Olstad DL, Mo- peds.113.1.112
zaffarian D. Food Is Medicine: Actions to Integrate Food 8223(99)00107-8
and Nutrition Into Healthcare. BMJ. 2020;369:m2482.
Published 2020 Jun 29. doi:10.1136/bmj.m2482.