Professional Documents
Culture Documents
An Analysis of Grammatical Errors On Undergraduate Thesis Abstract
An Analysis of Grammatical Errors On Undergraduate Thesis Abstract
Abstract:
The academic genre of abstract has its own organizational framework and linguistic
characteristics. The abstract summarizes the most important aspects of the work or research
as succinctly as possible. The goal of this study is to find out what grammatical mistakes
undergraduate students make when writing their thesis abstract in English. As a result, this
is a descriptive qualitative study. The respondent in this study is a group of undergraduate
students from Universitas Lancang Kuning's Biology Department, Faculty of Education and
Teachers Training, in 2016. In the April 2016 timeframe, 10 abstracts from the biology
department were completed. Finally, the researcher believes that there are four types of
grammatical faults identified on biology students' theses abstracts at Universitas Lancang
Kuning in writing abstracts: omission, addition, and misformation.
sentences. Related to the above idea, the There are two sorts of abstracts that are
researcher is going to find out the students’ commonly used: In academic writing, there
grammar error on their thesis abstract are two types of descriptions: (1) descriptive
sentences. The term "abstract" is a loose and (2) informative (Davis, 2005, p. 112). A
term that refers to any concise summary of a descriptive abstract (a) educates readers
longer paper. It's not a review, and it's not an about the report, article, or paper's contents;
assessment of the work being abstracted. It's (b) covers the report, article, or paper's
a condensed version of a lengthier piece of purpose, methodology, and scope; and (c)
writing that highlights the most important summarizes the report, article, or paper. (c)
elements, intentionally describes the lacks any results, conclusions, or
writing's subject and scope, and briefly recommendations; and (d) is always brief,
summarizes the writing's contents. The usually under a page.
important points of the paper are To meet those goals, the abstract must
summarized in the abstract. be a short, basic, yet totally self-explanatory
Writing a research paper abstract can report on a scientific investigation. Just like
be done in two ways (Swales and Feak, the report itself, the abstract must include (1)
2004, p. 282). The results-drive-abstract is the study objectives and rationale for
one of them. This type of abstract focuses on conducting the inquiry, (2) the basic
the research findings and what conclusions methodology used, and (3) the results and
may be drawn from them. Another option is key conclusions that can be drawn. An
to provide a concise abstract for a research abstract can be condensed in order to
paper. The writer delivers a one- or two- establish boundaries that the writer cannot
sentence overview of the four sections in this cross. Some of the data in the above list can
type of abstract. be combined or eliminated.
There are two different types of There were some previous researchers
abstracts that are frequently used: There are who did the same topic with this research.
two types of descriptions in academic Firts (Siminto, 2009) with the research
writing: descriptive and informative (Davis, entitled “Grammatical Errors in the
2005, p. 112). A descriptive abstract (a) Students’ Thesis Abstract (A Study on the
educates readers about the report, article, or Students’ Enhancement in English
paper's contents; (b) covers the report, Grammar)”. Word order, plural-singular
article, or paper's purpose, methodology, and nouns, verb tense, missing and misapplying
scope; and (c) summarizes the report, article, article, ineffective sentence, punctuation,
or paper. (c) lacks any results, conclusions, unparalleled structure, misspelling, verb
or recommendations; and (d) is always brief, tense, punctuation, Indonesian terms used,
usually under a page. run-on sentence, article (missing and
Writing a research paper abstract can misusing), meaning not clear, ineffective
be done in two ways (Swales and Feak, sentence, redundant words, misspelling
2004, p. 282). The results-drive-abstract is words, word form, incomplete sentence,
one of them. This type of abstract focuses on misusing possessive nouns and adjectives.
the research findings and what conclusions Second (Luthfiyah et al, 2015) had
may be drawn from them. Another option is done a research entitled “An Investigation of
to provide a concise abstract for a research Cohesion and Rhetorical Moves in Thesis
paper. The writer delivers a one- or two- Abstract”. The purpose of this study was to
sentence overview of the four sections in this look at the cohesiveness and rhetorical
type of abstract. gestures in English Education students'
thesis abstracts. A qualitative research
| ELT-Lectura: Studies and Perspectives in English Language Teaching
Copyright© 2022 Syaifullah, Helen M Sukova
21
design was used in this study, with 10 does not leave the readers in doubt about
abstracts chosen as samples. The rhetorical what they aim to convey. Even if there are
moves are evaluated using Swales and some grammatical flaws, this does not cause
Feak's framework, while the cohesiveness is the reader to form their own opinion or guess
analyzed using Halliday and Hasan's notion. about the material. Those inaccuracies had
Except for substitution, all cohesive devices no effect on the abstract's overall
are used, according to the results. The understanding and meaning.
reference device is the most commonly Fifth (Fitriya, 2014) has conducted a
utilized of these devices. The findings also research entitled “The Cohesion Devices of
reveal that some cohesive devices are being Thesis Abstracts Written by Students of
implemented inappropriately. Based on the Academic Year 2009 of Study Program of
results, seven abstracts (70%) are still in the English Universitas Brawijaya”. To address
medium cohesiveness group, while three the study's issues, this research employs a
abstracts (30%) are in the high cohesion descriptive qualitative approach and
category. In addition, seven abstracts are document analysis. The information was
grouped in diverse movement patterns that gathered from 12 abstract papers submitted
do not obey Swales' rules. by students in the 2009 academic year who
Third, with a study titled "The Lexical took linguistics, and the writer chose them at
Phrases Employed in the Thesis Abstracts of random. The writer used Renkema's theory
English Department Students" (Ngadiman, to analyze the data (1993). The findings of
2013). The current research focuses on this study revealed that the students' thesis
lexical phrases found in thesis abstracts abstracts had grammatical and lexical
written by English Department students. The cohesiveness. There are two forms of
data sources were randomly selected from grammatical cohesiveness that appeared in
abstracts of thesis papers written by English the students' thesis abstract. They're called
Department students for one of their conjunction and reference, respectively.
Bachelor's degree requirements. There are Conjunction takes up the most space (52
four types of lexical phrases used in students' percent), followed by reference (48 percent).
thesis abstracts: (a) verbal phrases, (b) noun There are three forms of lexical coherence
phrases, (c) prepositional phrases, and other that appeared in the students' abstract.
clausal structures, which are generally Repetition (61%) is the most important
longer. (a) relaying what others have said, factor, followed by reference (48%). For
(b) describing difficulties, (c) describing the lexical cohesion, there are three types that
situation, and (d) presenting results e) occurred in the students’ abstract. The
Research and study objectives (f) expressing biggest part is repetition (61%), then
points of view, (g) expressing degrees of followed by hyponymy (25%), and the last is
certainty, (h) presenting arguments, I antonyms (14%).
connectors, (j) comparing and contrasting, Budi Susanto conducted study on the
and (k) expressing degrees of certainty. sixth point (2014). He discovered that
Fourth, Hidayati (2010) published a students in class 3A, semester 5 of the
study named "English Grammatical Errors Accounting Department at the State
in the Abstract Section of Civil Engineering Polytechnic of Malang still struggled to
Students' Thesis, Diponegoro University." write English abstracts. External influences
According to the researcher's hypothesis, the have no bearing on students' inability to
substance of the abstracts written by write English abstracts. The DWA
Diponegoro University civil engineering implementation could help students enhance
students can be comprehended easily and their ability to write English abstracts.
| ELT-Lectura: Studies and Perspectives in English Language Teaching
Copyright© 2022 Syaifullah, Helen M Sukova
22
aspects: omission, misformation, addition, errors frequently take the form of inter-
and misordering, in order to learn more language, which is a mixture of two tenses,
about the description of grammatical a violation of numerical agreement, or the
problems in biology students' abstracts. use of the active-passive voice incorrectly.
Error nouns, on the other hand, frequently
There were 31 (37.3 percent)
take the form of singular-plural confusion
omission errors in total, with the omission of
and incorrect usage of word families. The
articles, verbs, and prepositions being the
examples and explanations of misformation
most common. The researcher discovered a
mistakes discovered in the thesis abstract are
fault in the student's grammar in this
listed below.
scenario, which omitted important elements
Example:
of the sentence. The most likely reason is
It can be concluded that
that the pupils wrote in English but
there were effect of
expressed their ideas in Bahasa Indonesia
cooperative learning type
style or word order. The following is an
example: Numbered Head
Togetherbased on Somatic,
The mean N-gain the
Auditory, Visual,
control class 0,48 with the
intellectual ….
medium category, while in
It might seem that the sentence does
the experimental class
not contain any errors, but the researcher
with a 0,71high category.
identified an error in the sentence which is
the bold words violating the generalization
In this case, it was not a sentence yet,
rule and number agreement of English
there was no “predicate” stated. However,
grammar. This study suggested the
the meaning of the words structure could still
following correction to the sentence:
be understood by the readers, even though it
Based on SAVI (Somatic
was not fulfilling the grammar criteria
Auditory, Visual, and
correctly. In fact, the sentence did not
employ some correct word choice. Intellectual), it can be
determined that
Therefore, the researcher proposed the
Cooperative Learning Type
following correction:
NHT (Numbered Head
The mean of N-gain of the
Together) had an effect....
control class is 0,48
So, “effect” should be in their plural
categorized as mid, while
form because in front of this noun, stated a
the experimental class is
plural predicate.
0,71 categorized as high.
Any usage of non-essential
The word “is” in the sentence is supposed to
components in sentences is referred to as
be a predicate which follows the subject in
addition. In the abstracts of the students'
front. Therefore, the predicate in the
theses, there are 18 (21.7 percent) faults that
sentence was missing.
show addition, and they are errors on
Any incorrect form of particular
articles, conjunctions, collocations, verbs,
morphemes or structures is referred to as
prepositions, pronouns, and nouns. The
misformation. In all, 19 (22.9 percent) errors
demonstrate misformation, with the majority most likely cause is that the students wrote
their abstracts in an Indonesian speaking
of the errors occurring on verbs and nouns.
manner.
In this situation, the researcher noticed that
certain pupils struggled to produce error-free
verbs and nouns. On the one hand, verb
| ELT-Lectura: Studies and Perspectives in English Language Teaching
Copyright© 2022 Syaifullah, Helen M Sukova
26