Common Pleas Court

Rank Judge Total Cases Disposed Appealed Cases Reversed Cases

1 Winkler 3089 88 6
2 Nurre 3000 121 6
3 Kraft 3138 127 7
4 Crush 3372 119 10
5 Hogan 1954 60 7
6 Cartolano 3037 137 12
7 O'Connor 2969 129 12
8 Tracey 3141 127 13
9 Ney, Jr. 3219 125 14
10 Niehaus 3353 137 16
11 Ruehlman 3205 145 18
12 Dinkelacker 1258 44 8
13 Nadel 2959 131 20
14 Morrissey 3032 121 22
15 Mathews 2264 91 18
16 Sundermann 955 60 10

Total 43945 1762 199

eas Court
Appeal Rate Reversal Rate Success Rate Rank Judge
0.02848818387828 0.00194237617352 99.81% 1 Panioto
0.04033333333333 0.002 99.80% 2 Cunningham
0.04047163798598 0.00223072020395 99.78% 3 Dinkelacker
0.035290628707 0.00296559905101 99.70% 4 Gaines
0.03070624360287 0.003582395087 99.64%
0.04511030622325 0.00395126769839 99.60% Total
0.04344897271809 0.00404176490401 99.60%
0.04043298312639 0.0041388092964 99.59%
0.03883193538366 0.00434917676297 99.57%
0.04085893229943 0.00477184610796 99.52%
0.04524180967239 0.00561622464899 99.44%
0.03497615262321 0.00635930047695 99.36%
0.04427171341669 0.00675904021629 99.32%
0.03990765171504 0.00725593667546 99.27%
0.04019434628975 0.00795053003534 99.20%
0.06282722513089 0.01047120418848 98.95%

0.04009557401297 0.00452838775742 99.55%

 Domestic Relations Court
Total Cases Disposed Appealed Cases Reversed Cases Appeal Rate Reversal Rate
12970 32 3 0.002467232074 0.00023130300694
2729 7 1 0.00256504214 0.00036643459143
6001 19 4 0.003166138977 0.00066655557407
8799 48 9 0.00545516536 0.00102284350494

30499 106 17 0.003475523788 0.00055739532444

 Municipal Court
Success Rate Rank Judge Total Cases Disposed Appealed Cases
99.98% 1 Grady 5253 6
99.96% 2 Hair 2532 5
99.93% 3 Mattingly 2971 13
99.90% 4 Kenney 2798 6
5 Helmick 7900 29
99.94% 6 Davis 7736 43
7 Mike Allen 6149 43
8 West 2797 4
9 Stockdale 5371 22
10 Black 7954 41
11 Nadine Allen 7812 34
12 Marsh 8219 34
13 Hogan 2308 13
14 Mallory 8277 38
15 Schweikert 5403 33
16 Painter 2239 7
17 Rosen 7790 41
18 Luebbers 4698 25
19 Mestemaker 4975 28
20 Isaiah Gaines 5282 35

Total 108464 500

Municipal Court
Reversed Cases Appeal Rate Reversal Rate Success Rate
0 0.0011422044546 0 100.00%
0 0.0019747235387 0 100.00%
1 0.0043756311006 0.00033658700774 99.97%
1 0.0021443888492 0.00035739814153 99.96%
5 0.0036708860759 0.00063291139241 99.94%
5 0.0055584281282 0.00064632885212 99.94%
4 0.006993006993 0.00065051227842 99.93%
2 0.0014301036825 0.00071505184126 99.93%
4 0.0040960714951 0.00074474027183 99.93%
6 0.0051546391753 0.00075433744028 99.92%
6 0.0043522785458 0.00076804915515 99.92%
7 0.0041367562964 0.00085168511984 99.91%
2 0.0056325823224 0.00086655112652 99.91%
9 0.0045910353993 0.00108735048931 99.89%
6 0.0061077179345 0.00111049416991 99.89%
3 0.0031263957124 0.00133988387673 99.87%
13 0.0052631578947 0.00166880616175 99.83%
8 0.0053214133674 0.00170285227756 99.83%
9 0.0056281407035 0.00180904522613 99.82%
13 0.006626277925 0.00246118894358 99.75%

104 0.0046098244579 0.00095884348724 99.90%

Rank Judge Court Total Cases Disposed Appealed Cases Reversed Cases
1 Grady Municipal 5253 6 0
2 Hair Municipal 2532 5 0
3 Panioto Domestic Relations 12970 32 3
4 Mattingly Municipal 2971 13 1
5 Kenney Municipal 2798 6 1
6 Cunningham Domestic Relations 2729 7 1
7 Helmick Municipal 7900 29 5
8 Davis Municipal 7736 43 5
9 Mike Allen Municipal 6149 43 4
10 West Municipal 2797 4 2
11 Stockdale Municipal 5371 22 4
12 Black Municipal 7954 41 6
13 Nadine Allen Municipal 7812 34 6
14 Marsh Municipal 8219 34 7
15 Gaines Domestic Relations 8799 48 9
16 Mallory Municipal 8277 38 9
17 Schweikert Municipal 5403 33 6
18 Painter Municipal 2239 7 3
19 Dinkelacker Common Pleas and Domestic Relations 7259 63 12
20 Rosen Municipal 7790 41 13
21 Luebbers Municipal 4698 25 8
22 Mestemaker Municipal 4975 28 9
23 Winkler Common Pleas 3089 88 6
24 Nurre Common Pleas 3000 121 6
25 Hogan Common Pleas and Municipal 4262 73 9
26 Kraft Common Pleas 3138 127 7
27 Isaiah Gaines Municipal 5282 35 13
28 Crush Common Pleas 3372 119 10
29 Cartolano Common Pleas 3037 137 12
30 O'Connor Common Pleas 2969 129 12
31 Tracey Common Pleas 3141 127 13
32 Ney, Jr. Common Pleas 3219 125 14
33 Niehaus Common Pleas 3353 137 16
34 Ruehlman Common Pleas 3205 145 18
35 Nadel Common Pleas 2959 131 20
36 Morrissey Common Pleas 3032 121 22
37 Mathews Common Pleas 2264 91 18
38 Sundermann Common Pleas 955 60 10
Success Rate Appeal Rate Reversal Rate Reversal/Appeal
100.00% 0.001142204455 0 0
100.00% 0.001974723539 0 0
99.98% 0.002467232074 0.0002313030069 0.09375
99.97% 0.004375631101 0.0003365870077 0.0769230769230769
99.96% 0.002144388849 0.0003573981415 0.166666666666667
99.96% 0.00256504214 0.0003664345914 0.142857142857143
99.94% 0.003670886076 0.0006329113924 0.172413793103448
99.94% 0.005558428128 0.0006463288521 0.116279069767442
99.93% 0.006993006993 0.0006505122784 0.0930232558139535
99.93% 0.001430103683 0.0007150518413 0.5
99.93% 0.004096071495 0.0007447402718 0.181818181818182
99.92% 0.005154639175 0.0007543374403 0.146341463414634
99.92% 0.004352278546 0.0007680491551 0.176470588235294
99.91% 0.004136756296 0.0008516851198 0.205882352941176
99.90% 0.00545516536 0.0010228435049 0.1875
99.89% 0.004591035399 0.0010873504893 0.236842105263158
99.89% 0.006107717934 0.0011104941699 0.181818181818182
99.87% 0.003126395712 0.0013398838767 0.428571428571429
99.83% 0.008678881389 0.0016531202645 0.19047619047619
99.83% 0.005263157895 0.0016688061617 0.317073170731707
99.83% 0.005321413367 0.0017028522776 0.32
99.82% 0.005628140704 0.0018090452261 0.321428571428571
99.81% 0.028488183878 0.0019423761735 0.0681818181818182
99.80% 0.040333333333 0.002 0.0495867768595041
99.79% 0.017128108869 0.0021116846551 0.123287671232877
99.78% 0.040471637986 0.002230720204 0.0551181102362205
99.75% 0.006626277925 0.0024611889436 0.371428571428571
99.70% 0.035290628707 0.002965599051 0.0840336134453782
99.60% 0.045110306223 0.0039512676984 0.0875912408759124
99.60% 0.043448972718 0.004041764904 0.0930232558139535
99.59% 0.040432983126 0.0041388092964 0.102362204724409
99.57% 0.038831935384 0.004349176763 0.112
99.52% 0.040858932299 0.004771846108 0.116788321167883
99.44% 0.045241809672 0.005616224649 0.124137931034483
99.32% 0.044271713417 0.0067590402163 0.152671755725191
99.27% 0.039907651715 0.0072559366755 0.181818181818182
99.20% 0.04019434629 0.0079505300353 0.197802197802198
98.95% 0.062827225131 0.0104712041885 0.166666666666667