Download as pdf or txt
Download as pdf or txt
You are on page 1of 10

1

CHALLENGES AND PROSPECTS OF NOMADIC EDUCATION


IN NIGERIA

Mbayuav Slyvester Terna


College of Education,
Kastina-Ala.

Abstract
Nations across the globe are painstakingly fighting hard to
educate their citizens. This is because education presents the
best opportunity for the development and prosperity of any
nation on earth. To this end, this research work sets out to
critically analyze nomadic education in Nigeria. Analyzing
the data collected from secondary sources, the work
discovers that poor funding, corruption, unsuitable curricula,
sectarian and cultural issues among others, some of the
challenges confronting nomadic education in Nigeria. The
work notes however that the prospects of nomadic education
in Nigeria overwhelm the challenges. The research
recommends among others, that policy making on nomadic
education should be bottom to top not top to bottom as has
always been the case.

It is an existential truism that Education is both a human right in itself


education serves as the spring board for and an indispensable means of realizing
social and economic change. No wonder other human rights. As an empowering
Wennergreen, A ntholt and right, education is the primary vehicle by
Whitaker (1984) affirmed that “all who which economically and socially
have mediated on the art of governing marginalized adults and children can lift
mankind have been convinced that the fate themselves out of poverty and obtain the
of an empire depends on the education of means to participate fully in their
the youth”. To remove the chronic communities. According to (UNESCO,
illiteracy among the mobile population of 2003), education has a vital role in
Nigeria, the government introduces the empowering women, street working
nomadic education program. The children from exploitative and hazardous
programme has three broad goals; to raise labour and sexual exploitation, promoting
the living standard of the rural community; human rights and democracy, protecting
to harness the potentials of the Fulani; and the environment, and controlling
to bridge the literacy gap between the population growth.
Fulani and the rest of the society.
2
Journal of Teacher Perspective
Clearly, achieving the right to The last group, ‘The fishermen’, is
education for all is one of the biggest concentrated in Rivers, Ondo, Edo, Delta,
challenges of our times. Educating Cross River, and Akwa-Ibom States. The
Nigeria’s nomadic population via distance first five nomadic groups listed are
education ( and using mobile learning considered pastoralist nomads. Delivering
methods), can be viewed as a positive step of educational services to the children of
towards effective implementation of the all nomadic groups has tended to follow
provision of Nigeria’s National Policy on the lines of the formal school system.
Education (NPE) on equal access and Special attention was paid to these groups
brighter opportunities for all its citizens by the Nigerian government when it set-up
regardless of where they live. the National Commission for Nomadic
Education by Decree 41 of 12 December
We shall therefore execute this 1989.
work in phases beginning with nomadic
education in Nigeria followed by Of the estimated 9.3million people
approaches to nomadic education, benefits that currently comprise Nigeria’s nomadic
of nomadic education, challenges and groups, approximately one third, that is 3.1
prospects of nomadic education in Nigeria. million are of school and pre-school age.
We shall then draw a conclusion and make The pastoral nomads are more
some recommendations. highly disadvantaged than the migrant
fishermen, in terms of access to education
Nomadic Education in Nigeria primarily because they are more itinerant.
According to Akinpelu (1993), the As a result, the literacy rate of pastoral
contemporary definition of ‘nomadic’ nomads is only 0.28 percent, while that of
refers to any type of existence the migrant fishermen is about 20 percent.
characterized by the absence of a fixed
domicile. He identifies three categories of The basic responsibility of the
nomadic groups as; hunters/food gatherers, commission for Nomadic Education
itinerant fishermen, and pastoralists (a.k.a, among others is to provide primary
herdsmen). In Nigeria, there are six education to the children of pastoralist
nomadic groups as identified by Akinpelu nomads- a responsibility shared with the
(1993), which are; states and local governments. To provide
1. the Fulani education to its nomads, a multifaceted
2. The Shuwa strategy has been adopted by the
3. The Buduman commission, which includes on –site
4. The Kwayan schools, the “shift system”, schools with
5. The Badawi alternative intake, and Islamiyya (Islamic)
6. The Fishermen schools. The current mobile school system
in the strictest sense remains sparingly
Challenges and Prospects of Nomadic…… 3

used, primarily due to the enormity of Radio and Television Education:- the
problems associated with this model. pastoral Fulani as a captive audience for
No doubt, nomadic education in radio television programme have radios
Nigeria draws its strength from section 10 which they carry along during herding.
subsection 94(ii) of the National Policy on
Education (2004). This section states that The literate world can, thus, reach
“the children of nomadic pastorals, migrant itinerants Fulani without disrupting their
fisher folks, migrant farmers, hunters etc nomadic life or livelihood. To improve
who, due to their lifestyles and means of literacy, especially in the rural areas, the
livelihood, are unable to have access to the Nigerian Government has introduced
conventional educational provision and radio, television, and electric generators,
therefore require special education to cater and built viewing rooms for public use.
for their particular /peculiar needs and
circumstances”. We shall now look at Although the Nigerian government
some of the approaches used in actualizing has spent millions of naira to support its
this section 10 subsection 94 (ii). nomadic education programme, education
attainment among the Fulani remains low
Approaches to Nomadic Education in and the quality of education among them is
Nigeria mediocre at best. The current form of
To improve the literacy rate of nomadic education, therefore, has truly yet
Nigeria’s nomads, the National to lift the literacy and living standards of
Commission for Nomadic Education the Fulani people as children of farmers
employed various approaches such as on – rather than Fulani’s constitute up to 80
site schools, the ‘shift system’ schools with percent of the pupils in nomadic schools.
alternative intake, and Islamiyya (Islamic) In Plateau state, for example, only six of
schools to provide literacy education to the 100 children in the Mozaropp nomadic
nomads. It is interesting to note that, the school are Fulani (Iro, 2006).
Nigerian government has set up different
agencies to implement education for the Mobile Schools/Mobile Learning
nomads. These agencies include the federal The government is also using this
ministry of Education, school Management approach in order to bring education to the
Board, National Commission for Nomadic door step of nomads in Nigeria. Mobile
Education, Agency for mass Literacy and schools use collapsible classrooms that can
the scholarship Board. Together, all these be assembled or disassembled within
agencies offer mobile school system minutes and carried conveniently by pack
wherein the schools and the teachers move animals. While a whole classroom and its
with the Fulani children. The following are furniture can be hauled by only four pack
some of the approaches; animals, motor caravans are gradually
replacing pack animals to move the
classrooms. A typical mobile unit consists
4
Journal of Teacher Perspective
of three classrooms, each with spaces In recent years, there has been a
equipped with audio-visual teaching aids steady growth in Nigeria’s mobile
to serve 15 to 20 children. telephone infrastructure and a concomitant
Mobile learning is the use of any acquisition and hence, use of mobile
mobile or wireless device for learning on telephones amongst Nigerians. Increasing
the move. It is any service or facility that rates of accessibility through Nigeria is
supplies a learner with general electronic encouraging more and more people to have
information and educational content that access to, or purchase, a mobile phone.
aids their acquisition of knowledge, Service providers in Nigeria are also on the
regardless of location and time (Lehner increase to meet this growing demand, and
and Nosekabel 2002). Kinshuk (2003) over time interconnectivity is projected to
cited in Sharples (2002) suggests that there be both easier and more affordable,
are three ways in which learning can be especially for Nigeria’s nomadic
considered mobile; (i) Learning is mobile population.
in terms of space; (ii) In different areas of
life; and (3) with respect to time. These On the strength of the above, there
definitions, according to Kinshuk (2003) are many benefits that Nigeria’s nomadic
suggest that mobile learning systems population can draw upon when mobile
should be capable of delivering learning would have been properly
educational content to learners anytime integrated into Nigeria’s current nomadic
and anywhere they need it. education programme. Such projected
benefits are;
Mobile learning, as a novel 1. Mobile learning will afford Nigeria’s
educational approach, encourages nomadic people the opportunity to
flexibility; students do not need to be a acquire literacy skills with little
specific age, gender, or member of a disruption to their nomadic lifestyles
specific group or geography to participate and livelihood.
in learning opportunities as restriction of
time, space and place have been lifted. 2. The establishment of nomadic schools,
in fixed locations, appears to be a
Educating Nigeria’s nomadic misguided educational policy. Indeed,
population via distance education/ and the inherent nature of Nigeria’s
using mobile learning methods), can be nomads as groups of wandering people
viewed as a positive step towards effective was not taken into consideration
implementation of the provision of during the formulation of this policy.
Nigeria’s National Policy on Education Therefore, one viable option available
(NPE) on equal access and brighter for these wandering people is to learn
opportunities for all its citizens regardless through a mobile learning system.
of where they live.
Challenges and Prospects of Nomadic……
5

3. One major problem usually faced by 1. Mobile schools that can be


Nigeria’s nomads in their wandering dismantled and quickly moved have
activities, is that they lack proven their worth and appear to fit
“interactional and transactional” skills with Nigeria’s nomadic peoples’
with the people they come across peripatetic culture, lifestyle and
during their travels. The acquisition of livelihood.
literacy skills through the mobile
learning system will, to a large extent, 2. The National Commission for
equip them with valuable interactional Nomadic Education can enter into
and transactional skills needed to contractual agreement with the
enhance their relationships with the network providers to procure
people they meet. relatively inexpensive mobile
phones, which can then be
4. Lastly, the modern world is knocking distributed to the nomads in their
on their doors; nomads need to schools.
develop a sense of belonging to the
larger, modern world wherein learning 3. Designated learning centers can be
is a key commodity for survival. established at strategic locations
along the nomads traveling routes,
How Mobile Learning can be Used as a providing a place where a facilitator
Distance Learning Approach in can attend to the needs of the
Nomadic Education nomads. Other materials such as
Many scholars have wondered learning manuals and programme
how mobile learning can be used to syllabi, can also be distributed from
educate nomads who are always on the these strategic locations.
move in the remotes part of Nigeria. That
genuine worry has however been tackled. 4. Facilitators, via a simple call using
In a recent mobile Telecommunication their mobile telephones can call the
Nigeria (MTN) advertisement, a Fulani nomads to track their students’
pastoralist is depicted making a call and progress in their studies, and to
telling other Fulani friends that MTN determine and address any problems
network was now available, even in the that any learner whether they are
remotest regions. This advertisement stationary or mobile-typically face in
portrays the fact that pastoralists- like other mastering the course materials and
Nigerians- can also use mobile telephones learning objectives. Similarly, the
wherever and for whatever reason. Nomadic learners can also be
According to Ojokheta and Olojede regularly encouraged to call the
(2007), the processes of using mobile course facilitator on their mobile
phones for educational purposes can be phones, should they encounter any
illustrated as; problems or require clarification or
6
Journal of Teacher Perspective
help. Facilitators are also encouraged education is sometimes emotional,
to call and network with their fellow factless, and ill-intentioned. Planners
facilitators. Use of mobile phone in fail to take account of the
one’s native language, helps to government’s inability to provide
establish a cordial and hence, specialized services. For example,
sustainable learning atmosphere just to impress the public, the
based on trust and collegiality. government has rushed into policy
pronouncements for mobile school
Challenges of Nomadic Education in system without considering the
Nigeria difficulties in getting teachers,
Nomadic Education in Nigeria is monitoring students, and developing
affected by defective policy, inadequate suitable curricula.
finance, faulty school placement, incessant
migration of students, unreliable and 3. The nomadic education curricula are
obsolete data, and cultural and religious unsuitable, if not an impediment to
taboos. While some of these problems are learning. For example, the use of
solved by policy and infrastructure English for instruction at the
interventions, most of the problems are elementary school level is
complex and difficult to solve. The inappropriate. Learning in the English
persistence of these problems is causing language is difficult for the Fulani
the roaming Fulani to remain educationally children who are yet to master their
backward. Other challenges are; own language. The problem is that
1. A top-to-bottom planning of nomadic due to cost the government cannot
education programme, where the develop Fulfulde language to replace
Fulani are the recipients rather than English as a medium of instruction in
the planners of their education, schools.
dominates the nomadic education
policies. For instance, during the first 4. Instead of teaching pastoral
national workshop on nomadic procedures, formal schools spend too
education, only a few Fulani were much time on teaching history and
invited to attend. Ironically, it was at cultures of societies the pastoralists
that workshop that far-reaching least know or want to know about.
decisions that will affect the lives of Conventional education ignores the
the Fulani were taken. desirability of the apprenticeship
model, thereby closing a vital channel
2. It has been established that, because of skill transfer (Aleyidiewo 1985).
of the non-participation of the Fulani
in decision –making a simplistic 5. The shortage of funds limits
approach to educational planning is government efforts to provide formal
adopted. Advice on nomadic education in Nigeria. The under –
Challenges and Prospects of Nomadic……
7

funding of nomadic education is and student monitoring difficult.


partly blamed on inaccurate Unscheduled out-migration due to
demographic data. The lack of environmental failures or conflicts
reliable statistics on the nomads leads between the farmers and the pastoral
to planning based on guessing. Fulani disrupts schools operations and
classroom composition.
6. Nomadic schools are stationed
inappropriately, few in densely 11. Nomadic educational program is
populated areas, and may in sparsely constrained by sectarian and cultural
populated areas. On the one hand, issues. The predominantly Muslim
having many schools in the pastoral Fulani reject the nomadic schools,
areas attracts non-Fulani children and fearing that their children will become
accentuates competition for other Christianized. On this assertion
resources. On the other hand, having Fafunwa (1974) agrees with the
few schools discourages the Fulani Fulani and states that “ since the
from participating in education. missionary schools were established
primarily to convert children and
7. The mismanagement of money by young adults to the Christian faith, the
officials of national commission for Muslims in the north and south saw
nomadic education (NCNE) and the this as a definite threat to their own
ministries of education in purchases, faith”.
contract awards and payments of
teachers has also hampered the 12. Nigeria’s nomads may not wish or be
progress of the nomadic educational willing to embrace mobile learning.
programme. On this note Rogers, (1995) avers
that, indeed, it is a well known fact
8. The progress of the mobile schools that innovations like mobile phones
has been curtailed by the shortage of and mobile learning, typically take
roads and Lorries in the rural areas. time to take root and take hold to
eventually become more widely
9. Lack of money has also forced accepted.
government to rely on volunteers or
unqualified teachers. The poor 13. The sheer cost of procuring enough
salaries paid to nomadic education mobile phones of distribution among
teachers cannot attract a caliber of Nigeria’s nomads and literacy
staff with the commitment to facilitators may be seen by some as
educational enrichment of the Fulani. too costly an endeavour to undertake.

10. The uncertainties of the movement of 14. Effective monitoring and evaluation
the Fulani make educational planning of mobile learning in Nigeria, remains
8
Journal of Teacher Perspective
a big challenge. Without effective the best way to fight for the rights denied
monitoring and evaluation, effective them for so long.
implementation of this new learning
mode might not be realized. Conclusion
Any nation that neglects the
Prospects of Nomadic Education in education of her people, presents a doomed
Nigeria future for such people. As we know,
In spite of the challenges outlined education plays a pivotal role in the socio-
above, there are good signs that economic development of every society
pastoralists are gradually embracing including the Nigerian society. It is in
education and improving their literacy. realization of the centrality of education in
Many pastoralists today, are interested in human existence that the Nigerian
formal education. Some Nigerian government has continued to do all it can
newspapers are reporting a growing to educate the nomads in Nigeria by way
interest in schools among the Fulani, as of establishing nomadic schools.
indicated by an increase in the demand for
such schools. In some places, the Fulani, These efforts of bringing education
have even built their own schools through to the door steps of every Nigerian,
community effort and have asked the especially the nomads have met with a
government to send teachers and teaching mountain of challenges which include but
materials. not restricted to poor funding, corruption,
Again, the Fulani have realized sectarian and cultural issues, unsuitable
that the herding sector cannot absorb all curricula etc. Overwhelming, as these
the children, and that not every child who challenges might be, the prospects of
would like to stay in herding will have the nomadic education flourishing in Nigeria
chance to do so. Considering the bleak are even more overwhelming.
future of nomadic pastoralism, many
Fulani are looking for an alternative to Recommendations
herding and school seems a good option. In order that nomadic education
The Fulani have also understood that part will stand the test of time in Nigeria, the
of their problems stem from the lack of following recommendations should be
educational men and women. And considered;
according to Wright (1988), “the absence 1. Non-governmental and community
of these men and women in governance based organizations should be
and policy making has put the Fulani at the involved in the monitoring and
mercy of their more educated counterparts evaluation of the nomadic mobile
in the society. learning programme
The pastoralists now believe that 2. Policy making on nomadic education
sending their children to school is the key should be bottom to top not top to
to active participation in governance and bottom as is always the case. When
Challenges and Prospects of Nomadic…… 9

the nomads propose these policies Aleyidiemo, S. (1985) Education and


themselves, such policies when Occupational Diversification
implemented would stand the test of Among Young Learners; The
time. Problem of Harmonizing Tradition
Practices with the Lessons of our
3. Adequate funding should be pumped Colonial Heritage. In Issues on
into nomadic education and adequate Development: Proceedings of a
mechanisms should be put in place Seminar held in Zaria, Nigeria:
to check mismanagement of such Ahmadu Bello University Press.
funds.
Fafunwa, B. (1974) History of Education
4. Mobile learning should be in Nigeria: A Study of Kano State.
encouraged by government. This London: George Allen Unwin
should be done through effective Limited
monitoring and evaluation of mobile
Iro, I. (2006). Nomadic Education and
learning in nomadic education
Education for Nomadic Fulani.
programme in Nigeria.
Retrieved May 20, 2012 from:
http://www.gamji.com/Fulani7.htm
5. Adequate enlightenment
programmes should be intensified. Kinshuk (2003). Adaptive Mobile Learning
This should be done so as to allay Technologies. Retrieved May 20,
the fear of the nomads that their 2012,from:http://www.whirligig.co
children will be Christianized. m.au/globaleducator/articles/kinshu
k2003.pdf
References
Aderinoye, R.A Ojokheta. K.O and Lehner, F. and Nose Label, H. (2002). The
Olojede A.A (2007) Integrating Role of Mobile Devices in E-
Mobile Learning into Nomadic learning-first experience with e-
Education Programmes in Nigeria: learning environment. In M. Milrad,
Issues and Perspectives. Ibadan: H.U. Hoppe and Kinshuk (eds)
IRRODL IEEE International Workshop on
Wireless and Mobile Technologies
Akinpelu, J.A (1993) Education for in Education. Los Alamitos: IEEE
Special Groups. In O.O. Akinkugbe Computer society.
(ed.) Nigeria and Education: The
Challenges ahead. Second Obafemi Federal Republic of Nigeria (2004)
Awolowo Foundation Dialogue. National Policy on Education. 4th
Ibadan: Spectrum Books. Edition Abuja: NERDC.
Journal of Teacher Perspective 10

Nkinyangi, J. (1980) Eduation for


Nomadic Pastoralists: Development
Planning by Trial and Error. In the
future of pastoral people:
Proceedings of a Conference Held
in Nairobi, by the Institute of
Development Studies. Nairobi:
Institute for Development Studies,
University of Nairobi.
Rogers, E.M. (1995) Diffusion of
Innovations. New York: free Press.
Sharples, M. (2000) The Decision of
Personal Mobile Technologies for
Lifelong. Computers and Education,
34 (3), 177-193.
UNESCO (2003). Right to Education:
Scope and Implementation. General
Comment 13 on the right to
education. UNESCO Economic and
Social Council. Retrieved May 20,
2012 from; http://portal.unesco.
org/education/en/file
Wilson, W. (1984) Resource management
in a Stratified Fulani Community.
Ph.D. dissertation. Howard
University, Washington, D.C
Wright, P. (1988) Ecology and Rural
Development in Sub-Saharan
Africa: Selected case studies.
Unpublished draft.

You might also like