Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Yoga Older People 2011
Yoga Older People 2011
net/publication/221684983
The Impact of a Short-Term Iyengar Yoga Program on the Health and Well-
Being of Physically Inactive Older Adults
CITATIONS READS
32 1,614
4 authors, including:
Fiona Burnell
Hinterland Medical Centre, Gold Coast, Australia
8 PUBLICATIONS 76 CITATIONS
SEE PROFILE
Some of the authors of this publication are also working on these related projects:
All content following this page was uploaded by Fiona Burnell on 23 March 2019.
Research
The Impact of a Short-Term Iyengar Yoga Program on the
Health and Well-Being of Physically Inactive Older Adults
Juliane Vogler, MSc, Lily O’Hara, MPH, Jane Gregg, MHP,
Fiona Burnell, PhD
University of the Sunshine Coast, QLD, Australia
Abstract: Background: With the current challenge of rapidly aging populations, practices such as yoga may help older
adults stay physically active, healthy, and fulfilled. Methods: The impact of an 8-week Iyengar yoga program on the
holistic health and well-being of physically inactive people aged 55 years and over was assessed. Thirty-eight older
adults (mean age 73.21 ± 8.38 years; 19 intervention, 19 control) engaged in either twice-weekly yoga classes or con-
tinued their usual daily routines. Physical health measures were muscle strength, active range of motion, respiratory
function (FEV1), resting blood pressure, and immune function (salivary IgA and lysozyme). Self-perceived general,
physical, mental, spiritual, and social health and well-being were assessed with the Life’s Odyssey Questionnaire and
the SF12v2™ Health Survey. Results: Muscle strength, active range of motion, physical well-being, and aspects of
mental well-being (emotional well-being and self-care) improved significantly in the yoga group (p < .05). Median
changes in most of these variables were also significantly different from those in the control group. Conclusions:
Participation in Iyengar yoga programs by older people is beneficial for health and well-being, and greater availability
of such programs could improve quality of life.
Key words: yoga, older adults, aging, well-being, health, fitness, physical activity, mind-body therapy
Correspondence: Lily O’Hara, Health Authority Abu Dhabi, PO Box 5674, Abu Dhabi, United Arab Emirates.
Tel: +971 2 4193 251. lohara@haad.ae.
Background physical level as people age: muscle strength and joint flex-
ibility decrease, and the function of the endocrine, nervous,
As the populations in Western countries rapidly age,1 pulmonary, cardiovascular, and immune systems declines.2-6
attention is being focused on practices and lifestyle changes Vaillant’s7 Model of Aging Well offers additional indicators
that allow people to live extended physically active, healthy, of health and well-being among older adults: nondisability at
and fulfilled lives. Significant physical changes occur on a the age of 75 years, good subjective physical health, positive
Acknowledgments: This study was funded by the University of the Sunshine Coast, QLD, Australia. The authors ac-
knowledge Dr. Leigh Findlay for editorial assistance with the manuscript. The authors also acknowledge the support of
the management and residents at the retirement village in which the study was conducted. Thank you to the anonymous
reviewers of the paper; their comments and suggestions have strengthened it considerably.
62 INTERNATIONAL JOURNAL OF YOGA THERAPY – No. 21 (2011)
that they perceived as beneficial. Participants in the control the tests in the same sequence before and after the inter-
group were asked to continue with their usual lifestyles and vention. Each testing session took approximately one hour.
not to change their physical activity pattern or to engage Various dimensions of holistic health and well-being were
in new exercises or physical activity over the intervention assessed with a combination of noninvasive tests for physical
period. After the completion of the intervention period and health indicators and two questionnaires to assess self-per-
outcome measurement, a similar 8-week Iyengar yoga pro- ceived general, physical, mental, spiritual, and social health
gram was provided for control group participants. and well-being: the Medical Outcomes Study Short Form
12 Health Survey Version 2 (SF-12v2™)26 and Life’s Odyssey
Outcome Measures Questionnaire.27 The SF-12 is a widely used health-related
Both the yoga program and all assessments took place questionnaire and has been validated for use in an older
at the retirement resort where the participants lived. An ex- population.28 It assesses 8 domains of functional health sta-
ercise physiologist administered all the tests to both groups tus: physical functioning; role limitations because of physi-
before and after the intervention. All participants completed cal health problems; bodily pain; general health perceptions;
vitality (energy/fatigue); social functioning; role limitations Active range of motion (aROM) was measured for the
because of emotional problems; and general mental health upper extremity, hip flexion, hip extension, hip abduction,
(psychological distress and psychological well-being). The and trunk rotation. A general scan for the range of motion
Life’s Odyssey Questionnaire, a commercially developed in joints of the upper extremity was undertaken by the
self-report instrument, assesses 7 domains: physical well- technique of “placing hands behind the back.”29 The tech-
being; life, health and attitude; emotional well-being; self- nique assesses scapular, shoulder, and elbow movements in
care; purpose and meaning; social connectedness; and rest, a complex way and reveals the flexibility of the entire shoul-
pleasure, and play. Validation studies for the Life’s Odyssey der girdle. Hip flexion, hip extension, hip abduction, and
Questionnaire have not been published, but it has been used trunk rotation were measured with a universal goniometer.
in many thousands of participants over a 10-year period.27 In order to determine an active range of motion, the in-
General Health and Well-Being. General health and well- dividual performs each movement unassisted, within their
being were assessed with the first question of the SF-12v2, personal range of ability. For measurements of hip flexion,
“In general, how would you rate your health?” Responses to hip extension, and hip abduction, the neutral zero method
the question are scored on a 5-point scale from “Excellent” was used, in which the goniometer is placed lateral to the
to “Poor.” joint. The stationary arm of the goniometer lies parallel to
Physical Health and Well-Being. Self-perceived physi- the longitudinal axis of the proximal joint segment, and the
cal health and well-being was assessed with the Physical moveable arm lies, and then moves, parallel to the moving
Component Summary of the SF-12v2™26 and the Physical distal segment of the joint.29,30 Trunk rotation was measured
Well-Being subscale of the Life’s Odyssey Questionnaire.27 from the top in degrees from zero position. The pivot point
The Physical Component Summary (PCS) was computed of the goniometer was placed over the top of the center
from the eight domains of general health status assessed by of the skull and the stationary arm of the goniometer was
the SF-12v2. The PCS was transformed for comparison, held in zero position, while the moveable arm was moved
with a mean score of 50 and a standard deviation of 10 in the with the shoulder to the side in the direction that the indi-
general U.S. population.25 The Physical Well-Being subscale vidual was turning; the acromion was used as the reference
score was computed from the Life’s Odyssey questionnaire: point. Participants’ measurements for the aROM for the left
the scores for the 10 items in the subscale were summed and right sides of the body were summed to generate five
to create a subscale summary raw score; the subscale sum- variables: aROM upper extremity, aROM trunk rotation,
mary raw score was then transformed to a scale of 0 to 100 aROM hip flexion, aROM hip abduction, and aROM hip
using the formula [(actual value – minimum possible value) extension.
/ range] x 100.27 Physiological Measurements. Resting systolic and dia-
Physical Function. Muscle strength of major muscle stolic blood pressures were measured in all participants on
groups was assessed using manual muscle testing.29 Muscle the left upper arm by the auscultation method.31 The mea-
strength tests were conducted for the groups of muscles surement was taken once at the start of each testing session.
responsible for hip flexion and abduction, knee extension, Respiratory function was assessed via forced expiratory
shoulder flexion and abduction, and trunk rotation and ex- volume in one second (FEV1) using a Spiro II spirometer
tension, with possible scores from Grade 3- to Grade 5. The (Medical International Research, Waukesha, WI, USA).
scores equate to: Grade 3-, movement through the complete Three successive measurements of FEV1 were taken with
test range in a gravity-eliminated position; Grade 3, move- participants in the standing position. Between each mea-
ment through the complete test range against gravity; Grade surement, participants were asked to take several normal
3+, movement through the complete test range against grav- breaths at a resting pace.31,32 Mean FEV1 was calculated from
ity and additional minimum resistance; Grade 4, movement the three measurements. Immune function was assessed
through the complete test range against gravity and addi- by testing for secretory IgA (SIgA) and lysozyme in saliva.
tional moderate resistance; Grade 5, movement through the Saliva samples were collected using Salivette® cotton swabs
complete test range against gravity and additional maximum (Salimetrics, State College, USA). Participants were asked
resistance.29 Participants’ scores for the set of strength tests not to eat or drink for one hour before the saliva collection.
were summed and then transformed using the formula [(ac- For collection, participants were asked to chew the cotton
tual value – minimum possible value) / range] x 100. This swab for at least one minute. The samples were kept cool
transformation provided a value for overall muscle strength after collection, then centrifuged at 1000 x g for 2 minutes,
on a scale of 0 to 100, allowing comparison of results. and stored at -20 ºC. The SIgA concentration was measured
YOGA FOR INACTIVE OLDER ADULTS 65
Life & Health Attitudes (scale 0-100) 75.0 (55.0-100.0) 77.5 (37.5-95.0)
Rest, Pleasure & Play (scale 0-100) 77.5 (55.0-95.0) 80.0 (52.5-100)
Table 2. Baseline characteristics of participants before the yoga intervention. (continued on page 66.)
66 INTERNATIONAL JOURNAL OF YOGA THERAPY – No. 21 (2011)
* = Active range of motion; † = Sum of both sides, smaller value indicates greater flexibility; ‡ = Forced Expiratory
Volume in one second; § = significantly different from control value by Mann-Whitney test (p < 0.05).
Variable
Median Median Median Median
Median Median
before after in- before after in-
change change
intervention tervention intervention tervention
(Min-Max) (Min-Max)
(Min-Max) (Min-Max) (Min-Max) (Min-Max)
Overall Muscle 53.9 (34.6- 67.3* (50.0- 11.5† (0- 59.6 55.8 (38.5- -1.9 (-11.5-
Strength (%) 71.25) 76.9) 34.6) (36.5- 80.8) 75.0) 3.9)
aROM‡ Upper 28 (0-90) 14.00* (0-59) -7† (-33-0) 20 (0-77) 20 (0-46) 0 (-32-8)
Extremities (cm)§
aROM Trunk 20 (0-42) 42* (4-80) 16† (0-60) 24 (4-80) 12* (4-60) -4 (-36-10)
Rotation (0)
aROM Hip Flexion 198 (128- 212* (180- 10 (-18-72) 210 (158- 208 (178- 0 (-34-60)
(0) 226) 248) 280) 296)
aROM Hip 56 (32-80) 70* (40-92) 16† (-8-36) 58 (28-100) 56 (20-100) -2 (-36-18)
Abduction (0)
aROM Hip 11 (0-20) 20* (0-20) 4† (-4-12) 16 (0-28) 16 (0-20) 0 (-16-8)
Extension (0)
Systolic Blood 140 (110- 138 (110- -2 (-34-20) 130 (98-160) 128 (102- -2 (-42-28)
Pressure (mm Hg) 164) 160) 150)
Diastolic Blood 76 (60-85) 78 (60-94) 0 (-8-14) 78 (60-96) 78 (60-86) 0 (-20-18)
Pressure (mm Hg)
FEV1II (L) 1.57 (0.66- 1.59 (0.85- 0.11 (-0.25- 1.87 (0.78- 2.01* (0.79- 0.13 (-0.16-
2.40) 2.55) 0.50) 3.74) 3.81) 0.84)
Salivary IgA 894 (182- 1174 (283- -194 (-4177- 843 (147- 857 (75- -99 (-7511-
(μg/mL) 6351) 3022) 1852) 0130) 3324) 2481)
Salivary lysozyme 1078 1214 (575- -26 (-25978- 2028 (424- 1570 (448- 111 (-48110
(ng/mL) (194- 33500) 10926) 4440) 5926) 7816) -3771)
Physical Well-Being 62.5 (30- 72.5* (35-85) 8.75 (-10-25) 65 (32.5- 70 (22.5- 2.5 (-32.5-
82.5) 87.5) 92.5) 27.5)
Physical 40.1 (20.8- 42.5 (27.5- 0.2 (-14.6- 43.6 (25.8- 45.1 (17.4- 1.8 (-8.41-
Component 63.9) 59.2) 17.5) 53.8) 58.9) 10.66)
Summary
* = Significant difference within groups before and after intervention by Wilcoxon signed rank test (p < 0.05); † =
Significantly different from control value by Mann-Whitney test (p < 0.05); ‡ = Active range of motion; § = Sum of
both sides, smaller value indicates greater flexibility; II = Forced Expiratory Volume in one second.
Table 3. Outcome measure scores for physical health and well-being within and between intervention (yoga) and control groups.
68 INTERNATIONAL JOURNAL OF YOGA THERAPY – No. 21 (2011)
Variable
Median Median Median Median
Median Median
before after in- before after in-
change change
intervention tervention intervention tervention
(Min-Max) (Min-Max)
(Min-Max) (Min-Max) (Min-Max) (Min-Max)
Life & Health 75 (62.5- 77.5 (37.5- 87.5 (52.5-
75 (55-100) 2.5 (-20-20) 5 (-15-22.5)
Attitudes 100) 95) 95)
Mental Component 49.1 (31- 53.7 (41.7- 1.3 (-12.7- 53.4 (45.9- 54.8 (34.8- 0.5 (-18.9-
Summary 62.2) 65.6) 20.3) 68.5) 63.8) 10.1)
* = Significant difference within group before and after intervention by Wilcoxon signed rank test (p < 0.05)
Table 4. Outcome measure scores for mental, spiritual, and social health and well-being within and between intervention (yoga)
and control groups.
with mild to moderate asthma. Although performing the in the yoga group had minor surgery during the program.
postures facilitates breathing, in the Iyengar yoga tradition, Stress and daily events may influence IgA concentration and
most breathing techniques are introduced at a later stage. secretion rate, in addition to high individual variability in
Therefore, further long-term studies are suggested to inves- these measures.5
tigate the possible effect of Iyengar yoga on FEV1 or other Participants in the yoga program also showed a signifi-
respiratory functions once advanced breathing techniques cant improvement in self-perceived physical health and well-
have been appropriately introduced. being, consistent with the improvements evident in many of
In addition, there were no significant effects of the yoga the objective measures of physical function. However, this
program on immune function in this study. High variability improvement was not consistent with results of the Physical
was observed in salivary lysozyme and SIgA measurements, Component Summary of the SF12v2, which did not show
which may have been partly due to the confounding factor an improvement in the yoga group. This inconsistency may
of concomitant medications taken by the participants. Many be due to the fact that the reference group used for the stan-
participants were on multiple medications, which may have dardization of the SF12v2 consisted of North American
influenced their mucosal immunity. Also, a few participants adults, and older Australians may differ significantly from
70 INTERNATIONAL JOURNAL OF YOGA THERAPY – No. 21 (2011)
this standard population. In this study, the Life’s Odyssey program: “I feel a return of inner peace and quiet; I believe I
Questionnaire appeared more sensitive than the SF12v2 to am thinking clearly, can hold a pen, walk without staggering
detect changes in physical health and well-being. Participant and a walking stick; now at the end of my road, I am content
comments about the physical health benefits they were expe- and at peace with my life, both as it was and is now.”
riencing during the yoga program included improvements in In terms of limitations, the study was conducted in a
body awareness, balance and walking, posture, body shape, retirement resort and therefore the results should not be
and ability to undertake daily activities. generalized to the population of older people as a whole. It
Participation in the Iyengar yoga program resulted in was beyond the scope of this study to determine if the resort
improvements in two of the measures used to assess mental residents were more or less healthy or frail than older people
health and well-being: the Emotional Well-Being and Self- generally. A larger sample size would have increased the
Care subscales of the Life’s Odyssey Questionnaire. This is power of the statistical analyses and reduced the potential for
consistent with the findings of a study on the impact of yoga Type II errors. For example, Physical Well-Being and Self-
on depression in older people.24 The improvement in self- Care scores showed significant differences within the yoga
care could be due to the participants in the Iyengar yoga group, but the median change between groups fell outside
program being encouraged to explore and reflect during and the (0.05) significance level. A larger sample size may have
after the classes on whether and how they experienced any resulted in these changes reaching significance. Results from
effect of the yoga practice on their well-being. The effects of the questionnaires may have been inflated because statistical
restorative postures were explained, and participants were analyses did not protect against the potential for error that
encouraged to incorporate postures that they perceived as can arise when two instruments measure similar constructs.
beneficial into their daily lives. Thus, the improvement in Participants in the control group were not asked to record
self-care might reflect an empowering effect of the yoga their physical activity during the intervention period. As a
program on the participants. Participant comments about result, it is not known if their activity levels changed, and if
the mental health benefits of the yoga program included so, how this may have influenced their results. The 8-week
improvements in emotional well-being, cognitive function, program was successful in producing changes in some mea-
capacity to relax, and enjoyment. sures of physical and mental health and well-being; however,
The short-term nature of the study may account for the a longer yoga program may have produced further changes
lack of effects on spiritual health and well-being measures. In in mental, spiritual, and social health and well-being, as is
contrast, a longer-term study reported a significant strength- suggested by Iyengar yoga philosophy. Further research is re-
ening of seniors’ sense of coherence after a 14-week yoga quired to determine the long-term effects and sustainability
program.23 Both of these results are consistent with Iyengar of such a program in older people.
yoga philosophy, in which the practice is believed to have The study assessed yoga versus no activity and did not
progressive effects on practitioners, starting with the physi- include a second control group of a non-yoga exercise pro-
cal body and only gradually affecting the deeper mental and gram or a social interaction program. Exercise has an impact
then spiritual levels.11 A few participants commented about on older adult well-being,36 so it is not clear how much of
the spiritual health benefits of the yoga program, including the impact of this study is truly from the Iyengar yoga pro-
an increased sense of calm and peace. gram in particular, and how much is from exercise. Likewise,
social interaction has a positive impact on older adult health
Strengths, Limitations, and Future Directions outcomes,37 and, again, it is unknown what contribution the
The study had a number of strengths. The absence of ex- social interaction in the Iyengar yoga program made to the
clusion criteria meant the program was open to a broad range health and well-being outcomes recorded. However, life in
of people residing in the retirement resort. The measures the retirement resort is very sociable, with many opportuni-
used to assess physical, mental, spiritual, and social health ties for social interaction between residents. This may be one
and well-being allowed exploration of effects across a range reason why there was no significant change in social connect-
of health indicators. The extremely low attrition rate (5%) edness in either yoga or control group, suggesting that the
indicates that the program met participants’ needs and expec- health improvements in the yoga group were not related to
tations. Participant comments reflected the range of benefits the social interaction experienced in the group. In addition,
experienced and addressed physical, mental, spiritual, and almost all of the participant comments referred to benefits
social aspects of health and well-being. For example, one par- that are likely to have resulted from the yoga program itself,
ticipant made the following comment at the end of the yoga rather than exercise in general or social interaction.
YOGA FOR INACTIVE OLDER ADULTS 71
30. Clarkson HM. Musculoskeletal Assessment. 2nd ed. USA: Lippincott Activity and Successful Ageing, Xth International European Group on
Williams & Wilkins; 2000. Research into Elderly and Physical Activity Conference, Cologne, Germany.
31. Perloff D, Grim C, Flack, J, Frohlich ED, Hill HM, McDonald M, Cologne, Germany: German Sport University; 2006.
Morgenstern BZ. Human blood pressure determination by sphygmoma- 35. Sabina AB, Williams, Wall HK, Bansal S, Chupp G, Katz DL. Yoga
nometry. Circulation. 1993;88(5 Part 1), 2460-2470. intervention for adults with mild-to-moderate asthma: a pilot study.
32. American College of Sports Medicine. American College of Sports Annals of Allergy, Asthma and Immunology. 2005;94(5):543-548.
Medicine’s Guidelines for Exercise Testing and Prescription. USA: 36. Netz Y, Wu MJ, Becker BJ, Tenenbaum G. Physical Activity
Lippincott Williams & Wilkins; 2006. and Psychological Well-Being in Advanced Age: A Meta-Analysis of
33. Field AP. Discovering Statistics Using SPSS. 2nd ed. London, UK: Intervention Studies. Psychology and Aging. 2005; 20(2):272-284.
Sage Publications; 2005. 37. Fiori KL, Antonucci TC, Cortina KS. Social Network Typologies
34. Sacks Campos F, de Souza JL. Influence of the joint movement in and Mental Health among Older Adults. The Journals of Gerontology.
the intervertebral disc nutrition and the ageing process. In: Physical Series B, Psychological Sciences and Social Sciences. 2006;61(1):25-32.