Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Ashvamedha: Aśvamedha)
Ashvamedha: Aśvamedha)
Ashvamedha: Aśvamedha)
Contents
The sacrifice
On Gupta coins
Similar sacrifices elsewhere
List of performers
In Hindu revivalism
Reception
See also
Footnotes
References
The sacrifice
The Ashvamedha could only be conducted by a powerful victorious king (rājā).[6][7] Its object was the
acquisition of power and glory, the sovereignty over neighbouring provinces, seeking progeny and general
prosperity of the kingdom.[8] It was enormously expensive, requiring the participation of hundreds of
individuals, many with specialized skills, and hundreds of
animals, and involving many precisely prescribed rituals at
every stage.[9]
After the return of the horse, more ceremonies were performed for a
month before the main sacrifice. Twelve days of dīkṣā rites took
place, and then twelve days of upasad.[18] The dīkṣā rite was a
preparatory consecration rite performed before sacrifices.[19] It
consisted of a preliminary oblation, and then the king would bathe,
dress in black antelope skin, and sit on another skin in a hut in front
of a fire, fasting in silence with a covered head and sleeping on the
ground. The upasad was a multiday ceremony that precedes Soma
sacrifices.[20] It consisted of the acquisition and welcoming of Soma
and the construction of various structures needed for the sacrifice, Depiction of the Asvamedha in
along with the sacrifice of a goat.[21] History of India (1906)
On the twenty-sixth day,[22] the king was ritually purified, and the horse was yoked to a gilded chariot,
together with three other horses, and Rigveda (RV) 1.6.1,2 (YajurVeda (YV) VSM 23.5,6) was recited. The
horse was then driven into water and bathed. After this, it was anointed with ghee by the chief queen and
two other royal consorts. The chief queen (mahiṣī) anointed the fore-quarters, the favorite wife (vāvātā) the
middle, and the discarded wife (parvṛktī) the hindquarters.[28][29] They also embellished the horse's head,
neck, and tail with golden ornaments and 101 or 109 pearls.[18][30] After this, the horse, a hornless black-
necked he-goat, and a Gomṛga were bound to sacrificial stakes near the fire, and seventeen other animals
were attached with ropes to the horse. The he-goat dedicated to Agni was attached to the horse's chest. A
ewe dedicated to Sarasvatī was attached under the horse's mouth. Two black-bellied he-goats dedicated to
the Aśvins were tied to the horse's front legs. A dark grey he-goat dedicated to Soma-Pūṣan was attached
underneath the horse. On the two sides of the horse were attached a black goat to Sūrya and a white goat to
Yama. Two goats with shaggy thighs were dedicated to Tvaṣṭar. A white goat dedicated to Vāyu was
attached to the tail. A cow about to give birth was dedicated to Indra, and a dwarfish cow was dedicated to
Viṣṇu.[31] A great number of animals, both tame and wild, were tied to other stakes, according to one
commentator, 609 in total. The sacrificer offered the horse the remains of the night's oblation of grain. The
horse was then suffocated to death.[12]
The chief queen ritually called on the king's fellow wives for pity.
The queens walked around the dead horse reciting mantras and
obscene dialogue with the priests.[18] The chief queen then had to
spend the night beside the dead horse in a position mimicking sexual
intercourse and was covered with a blanket.[32][18][33][34]
On the next morning, the priests raised the queen from the place.
One priest cut the horse along the "knife-paths" while other priests
started reciting the verses of Vedas, seeking healing and
regeneration for the horse.[35] The horse's epiploon along with soma
are offered in an oblation, and the priests dismember the horse and
other animal victims with an oblation of their blood. On the third
day an Atirātra was performed.[18] The Atirātra was a Soma
sacrifice in which there was a nocturnal session where soma was
drunk.[36] Afterwards an Avabhṛtha takes place.[18] However, in
the Ashvamedha sinners and criminals also take part in the Ashvamedha of Pandavas
purificatory bathing. Afterwards twenty-one sterile cows are
sacrificed, and the dakshina was distributed to the priests. The main
dakshina forms either the four wives of the king or their four hundred attendants.[18]
The Laws of Manu refer to the Ashvamedha (V.53): "The man who offers a horse-sacrifice every day for a
hundred years, and the man who does not eat meat, the two of them reap the same fruit of good deeds."[37]
On Gupta coins
One type of the gold coins of the Gupta Empire kings Samudragupta (reigned c. 350-370 CE) and
Kumaragupta (reigned c. 415-455 CE) commemorates their Ashvamedha sacrifices. The obverse shows the
horse anointed and decorated for sacrifice, standing in front of a Yūpa sacrificial post, and is inscribed "The
king of kings who has performed the Vajimedha sacrifice wins heaven after protecting the earth". The
reverse shows a standing figure of the queen, holding a fan and a towel, and is inscribed "Powerful enough
to perform the Ashvamedha sacrifice".[38]
A similar ritual is found in Celtic tradition in which the king in Ireland conducted a rite of symbolic marriage
with a sacrificed horse.[32] The Roman October Horse sacrifice was an annual event, and apparently the
only time horses were sacrificed, rather than cattle or smaller animals.[39]
Horse sacrifices were performed among the ancient Germans, Armenians, Iranians,[40] Chinese, Greeks,[41]
among others.
List of performers
Sanskrit epics and Puranas mention numerous legendary performances of the horse sacrifice.[42] For
example, according to the Mahabharata, Emperor Bharata performed a hundred Ashvamedha ceremonies
on the banks of Yamuna, three hundred on the banks of Sarasvati and four hundred on the banks of the
Ganga. He again performed a thousand Ashvamedha on different locations and a hundred Rajasuya.[43]
Following the vast empires ruled by the Gupta and Chalukya dynasties, the practice of the sacrifice
diminished remarkably.[6]
The Udayendiram inscription of the 8th-century Pallava king Nandivarman II (alias Pallavamalla) states that
his general Udayachandra defeated the Nishada ruler Prithvivyaghra, who, "desiring to become very
powerful, was running after the horse of the Ashvamedha". The inscription does not clarify which king
initiated this Ashvamedha campaign. Historian N. Venkataramanayya theorized that Prithvivyaghra was a
feudatory ruler, who unsuccessfully tried to challenge Nandivarman's Ashvamedha campaign. However,
historian Dineshchandra Sircar notes that no other inscriptions of Nandivarman or his descendants mention
his performance of Ashvamedha; therefore, it is more likely that the Ashvamedha campaign was initiated by
Prithvivyaghra (or his overlord), and Nandivarman's general foiled it.[68]
In Hindu revivalism
In the Arya Samaj reform movement of Dayananda Sarasvati, the
Ashvamedha is considered an allegory or a ritual to get connected to
the "inner Sun" (Prana)[13][69] According to Dayananda, no horse
was actually to be slaughtered in the ritual as per the Yajurveda.
Following Dayananda, the Arya Samaj disputes the very existence
of the pre-Vedantic ritual; thus Swami Satya Prakash Saraswati
claims that
The horse Shyamakarna on the bank
of Lake Dudumbhi, illustrating
the word in the sense of the Horse Sacrifice does not
Jaimini's commentary on
occur in the Samhitas [...] In the terms of cosmic
Ashvamedha, 19th century,
analogy, ashva s the Sun. In respect to the adhyatma
Maharashtra
paksha, the Prajapati-Agni, or the Purusha, the
Creator, is the Ashva; He is the same as the Varuna, the
Most Supreme. The word medha stands for homage; it
later on became synonymous with oblations in
rituology, since oblations are offered, dedicated to the
one whom we pay homage. The word deteriorated
further when it came to mean 'slaughter' or
'sacrifice'.[70]
He argues that the animals listed as sacrificial victims are just as symbolic as the list of human victims listed
in the Purushamedha[70] (which is generally accepted as a purely symbolic sacrifice already in Rigvedic
times).
Gayatri Pariwar since 1991 has organized performances of a "modern version" of the Ashvamedha where a
statue is used in place of a real horse, according to Hinduism Today with a million participants in
Chitrakoot, Madhya Pradesh on April 16 to 20, 1994.[71] Such modern performances are sattvika Yajnas
where the animal is worshipped without killing it,[72] the religious motivation being prayer for overcoming
enemies, the facilitation of child welfare and development, and clearance of debt,[73] entirely within the
allegorical interpretation of the ritual, and with no actual sacrifice of any animal.
Reception
The earliest recorded criticism of the ritual comes from the Cārvāka, an atheistic school of Indian philosophy
that assumed various forms of philosophical skepticism and religious indifference. A quotation of the
Cārvāka from Madhavacharya's Sarva-Darsana-Sangraha states: "The three authors of the Vedas were
buffoons, knaves, and demons. All the well-known formulae of the pandits, jarphari, turphari, etc. and all
the obscene rites for the queen commanded in Ashvamedha, these were invented by buffoons, and so all the
various kinds of presents to the priests, while the eating of flesh was similarly commanded by night-
prowling demons."[74]
According to some writers, ashvamedha is a forbidden rite for Kali Yuga, the current age.[75][76]
This part of the ritual offended the Dalit reformer and framer of the Indian constitution B. R. Ambedkar and
is frequently mentioned in his writings as an example of the perceived degradation of Brahmanical
culture.[77]
Scholar Manohar L. Varadpande, praised the ritual as "social occasions of great magnitude".[78] Rick F.
Talbott writes that "Mircea Eliade treated the Ashvamedha as a rite having a cosmogonic structure which
both regenerated the entire cosmos and reestablished every social order during its performance."[79]
See also
Ashva – Horses in Hinduism
October Horse – Animal sacrifice to Mars
Cruelty to animals – Negligent or abusive action against non-human animal by humans
Footnotes
1. Monier-Williams, Monier; Leumann, E.; 4. van Buitenen, J.A.B. (1973) The
Cappeller, C. (2005). A Sanskrit-English Mahabharata: Book 1: The Book of the
Dictionary: Etymologically and Beginning. Chicago, IL: University of
Philologically Arranged with Special Chicago Press, p 478
Reference to Cognate Indo-European 5. Debroy, B. (2010) The Mahabharata,
Languages. Asian Educational Services. Volume 1. Gurgaon: Penguin Books India,
p. 115. pp xxiii - xxvi
2. Ganguli, K.M. (1883-1896) "Aswamedha 6. Mansingh, Surjit. Historical Dictionary of
Parva (http://www.sacred-texts.com/hin/m1 India. Rowman & Littlefield. p. 68.
4/index.htm)" in The Mahabharata of
7. Rick F. Talbott 2005, p. 111.
Krishna-Dwaipayana Vyasa (12 Volumes).
Calcutta 8. Gopal, Madan (1990). K.S. Gautam (ed.).
India through the ages (https://archive.org/d
3. Dutt, M.N. (1905) The Mahabharata
etails/indiathroughages00mada).
(Volume 14): Ashwamedha Parva. Publication Division, Ministry of Information
Calcutta: Elysium Press and Broadcasting, Government of India.
p. 72 (https://archive.org/details/indiathroug
hages00mada/page/72).
9. Glucklich, 111-114
10. Glucklich, 111-112 32. Thomas V. Gamkrelidze; Vjaceslav V.
11. Stutley 1969, p. 257. Ivanov (1995). Indo-European and the
12. Glucklich, 112 Indo-Europeans: A Reconstruction and
Historical Analysis of a Proto-Language
13. Roshen Dalal 2010, p. 399. and Proto-Culture. Part I: The Text. Part II:
14. Stutley, Margaret (1969). "The Aśvamedha Bibliography, Indexes (https://books.googl
or Indian Horse Sacrifice" (https://www.jsto e.com/books?id=M2aqp2n2mKkC&q=Ashv
r.org/stable/1258749). Folklore. Taylor & amedha). Walter de Gruyter. pp. 402–403.
Francis. 80 (4): 257. ISBN 9783110815030.
doi:10.1080/0015587X.1969.9716646 (http 33. Bose 2020, p. 4-5.
s://doi.org/10.1080%2F0015587X.1969.97
16646). JSTOR 1258749 (https://www.jstor. 34. Dalal, Roshen (2014). Hinduism: An
Alphabetical Guide (https://www.google.co
org/stable/1258749) – via JSTOR.
m/books/edition/Hinduism/zrk0AwAAQBA
15. Bose, Saikat (2020). "The Aśvamedha: in J?hl=en&gbpv=1&dq=hinduism+dalal+spe
the context of early South Asian socio- nding+one+night&pg=PT223&printsec=fro
political development" (https://crossasia-jou ntcover). Penguin Books Limited.
rnals.ub.uni-heidelberg.de/index.php/ejvs/a ISBN 9788184752779.
rticle/view/11333/11118). Electronic
Journal of Vedic Studies. 25 (2): 3–4. 35. Rick F. Talbott 2005, p. 123.
36. Renou 1957, p. 104-105.
16. Bose 2020, p. 16.
37. The Laws of Manu, translated by Wendy
17. Bose 2020, p. 18,20.
Doniger with Brian K. Smith, p.104.
18. Renou, Louis (1957). Vedic India. Penguin Books, London, 1991
Translated by Spratt, Philip. Susil Gupta.
pp. 108–109. 38. Glucklich, 111
39. Thomas V. Gamkrelidze; Vjaceslav V.
19. Apte & 1957-1959, p. 816.
Ivanov (1995). Indo-European and the
20. Monier-Williams, Leumann & Cappeller Indo-Europeans: A Reconstruction and
2005, p. 206. Historical Analysis of a Proto-Language
21. Renou 1957, p. 105. and Proto-Culture. Part I: The Text. Part II:
22. Bose 2020, p. 4. Bibliography, Indexes (https://books.googl
23. Apte, Vaman Shivaram (1957–1959). e.com/books?id=M2aqp2n2mKkC). Walter
Revised and enlarged edition of Prin. V. S. de Gruyter. p. 70. ISBN 9783110815030.
Apte's: The practical Sanskrit-English 40. Rick F. Talbott 2005, p. 142.
dictionary. Vol. 3. Poona: Prasad 41. Roshen Dalal 2010, p. 44.
Prakashan. p. 251. 42. David M. Knipe 2015, p. 234.
24. Renou 1957, p. 100, 105-106, 108-109. 43. K M Ganguly 1896, pp. 130–131.
25. Monier-Williams, Leumann & Cappeller 44. Jamison, Stephanie; Brereton, Joel (2014).
2005, p. 178. The Rigveda: The Earliest Religious
26. Goldstücker, Theodor (1856). A Dictionary, Poetry of India. Oxford University Press.
Sanskrit and English. A. Asher and Co. pp. 619–626, 699. ISBN 9780199370184.
p. 137. 45. Erdosy, George; Witzel, Michael (1995).
27. Apte & 1957-1959, p. 1363. Language, Material Culture and Ethnicity.
28. Stutley 1969, p. 259. The Indo-Aryans of Ancient South Asia:
29. Bose 2020, p. 40. Rgvedic history: poets, chieftains and
politics. De Gruyter. pp. 237–242.
30. Karmakar, R. D. (1949). "The Aśvamedha:
Its Original Signification" (https://www.jstor. 46. Erdosy, George; Witzel, Michael (1995).
org/stable/41784542). Annals of the Language, Material Culture and Ethnicity.
Bhandarkar Oriental Research Institute. 30 The Indo-Aryans of Ancient South Asia:
(3/4): 333. JSTOR 41784542 (https://www.j Rgvedic history: poets, chieftains and
stor.org/stable/41784542) – via JSTOR. politics. De Gruyter. pp. 237–242.
31. Stutley 1969, p. 258.
47. Witzel, Michael (1995). "4. Early Indian 63. Snigdha Tripathy 1997, pp. 74–75.
history: Linguistic and textual parametres" 64. Rama Shankar Tripathi (1942). History of
(https://www.degruyter.com/document/doi/1 Ancient India (https://books.google.com/bo
0.1515/9783110816433-009/html). In oks?id=rOVpOG6MPMcC&pg=PA466).
Erdosy, George (ed.). The Indo-Aryans of Motilal Banarsidass. p. 466. ISBN 978-81-
Ancient South Asia: Language, Material 208-0018-2.
Culture and Ethnicity. Indian Philology and
65. P. K. Gode (1953). "Some contemporary
South Asian Studies. De Gruyter. pp. 85–
Evidence regarding the aśvamedha
125. doi:10.1515/9783110816433-009 (http
Sacrifice performed by Sevai Jayasing of
s://doi.org/10.1515%2F9783110816433-00
Amber (1699-1744 A. D.)". Studies in
9). ISBN 978-3-11-081643-3. Indian Literary History (https://books.googl
S2CID 238465491 (https://api.semanticsch
e.com/books?id=oXZHtgEACAAJ). Vol. 2.
olar.org/CorpusID:238465491).
Singhi Jain Shastra Sikshapith. pp. 288–
48. Raychaudhuri, Hemchandra (2006), 291. OCLC 2499291 (https://www.worldcat.
Political History of Ancient India (https://boo org/oclc/2499291).
ks.google.com/books?
66. Catherine B Asher (2008). "Rethinking a
id=h1KObc_qaXYC), Cosmo Publications,
Millennium: Perspectives on Indian History
p. 14,39, ISBN 81-307-0291-6
from the Eighth to the Eighteenth Century :
49. Pruthi, Raj (2004). Vedic Civilization (http Essays for Harbans Mukhia". In Rajat Datta
s://books.google.com/books?id=z3ksBrWo (ed.). Excavating Communalism:
Zm0C&q=Janamejaya+in+vedas&pg=PA8 Kachhwaha Rajadharma and Mughal
6). Discovery Publishing House. Sovereignty (https://books.google.com/boo
ISBN 9788171418756. ks?id=2H4PGhFB9ScC&pg=PA232).
50. Dineshchandra Sircar 1971, p. 175. Aakar Books. p. 232. ISBN 978-81-89833-
51. Dinesh Chandra Shukla (1978). Early 36-7.
history of Rajasthan (https://books.google.c 67. Ayodhya Revisited by Kunal Kishore p.24
om/books?id=RMoBAAAAMAAJ). (https://books.google.com/books?id=gKKa
Bharatiya Vidya Prakashan. p. 30. DAAAQBAJ&pg=PA24)
52. David M. Knipe 2015, p. 8. 68. Dineshchandra Sircar 1962, p. 263.
53. Jayantanuja Bandyopadhyaya 2007, 69. as a bahuvrihi, saptāśva "having seven
p. 203. horses" is another name of the Sun,
54. Dineshchandra Sircar 1971, p. 176. referring to the horses of his chariot.;
akhandjyoti.org (http://www.akhandjyoti.or
55. Upinder Singh 2008, p. 510.
g/marapr05/article12.html?Akhand-Jyoti/20
56. Tony Whitten; Greg S. Henderson; 05/Jul-Aug/Ashvamedha/) Archived (https://
Muslimin Mustafa (2012). The Ecology of web.archive.org/web/20070929080441/htt
Sulawesi (The Ecology of Indonesia p://www.akhandjyoti.org/marapr05/article1
Series, Volume IV) (https://www.google.co.i 2.html?Akhand-Jyoti%2F2005%2FJul-Au
d/books/edition/Ecology_of_Sulawesi/Q__ g%2FAshvamedha%2F) September 29,
PAgAAQBAJ?hl=en&gbpv=0). Tuttle 2007, at the Wayback Machine glosses
Publishing. p. 76. ISBN 9781462905072. 'ashva' as "the symbol of mobility, valour
57. David M. Knipe 2015, p. 9. and strength" and 'medha' as "the symbol
58. Ashvini Agrawal 1989, p. 139. of supreme wisdom and intelligence",
59. Dineshchandra Sircar 1971, p. 179. yielding a meaning of 'ashvamedha' of "the
combination of the valour and strength and
60. David M. Knipe 2015, p. 10.
illumined power of intellect"
61. Karl J. Schmidt (20 May 2015). An Atlas
70. The Critical and Cultural Study of the
and Survey of South Asian History (https://b
Shatapatha Brahmana by Swami Satya
ooks.google.com/books?id=vKZzCQAAQB
Prakash Saraswati, p. 415; 476
AJ&pg=PT77). Taylor & Francis. p. 77.
ISBN 978-1-317-47680-1.
62. Snigdha Tripathy 1997, p. 67.
71. Hinduism Today, June 1994 (http://www.hin 74. Madhavacarya, Sarvadarsana-sangraha,
duismtoday.com/archives/1994/6/1994-6-0 English translation by E. B. Cowell and A.
4.shtml) Archived (https://web.archive.org/w E. Gough, 1904 quoted in Debiprasad
eb/20061213233624/http://www.hinduismto Chattopadhyaya (ed.), Carvaka/Lokayata:
day.com/archives/1994/6/1994-6-04.shtml) An Anthology of Source Materials and
December 13, 2006, at the Wayback Some Recent Studies (New Delhi: Indian
Machine Council of Philosophical Research, 1990)
72. "Ashwamedha Yagam in city" (https://web.a 75. Rosen, Steven (2004). Holy Cow: The
rchive.org/web/20051214083253/http://ww Hare Krishna Contribution to
w.hindu.com/2005/10/13/stories/20051013 Vegetarianism and Animal Rights (https://b
16990400.htm). The Hindu. Hyderabad, ooks.google.com/books?id=Z-WKuYt0Mog
Andhra Pradesh. Oct 13, 2005. Archived C&pg=PA212). Lantern Books. p. 212.
from the original (http://www.hindu.com/200 ISBN 9781590560662.
5/10/13/stories/2005101316990400.htm) 76. The Vedas: With Illustrative Extracts. Book
on December 14, 2005. Retrieved Tree. p. 62. "horse sacrifice was prohibited
30 September 2014. in the Kali Yuga"
73. Ashwamedhayagnam.org (http://www.ashw 77. Dr. Babasaheb Ambedkar, Writings and
amedhayaagam.org/whyamy.html) Speeches. p. 1376.
Archived (https://web.archive.org/web/2007
78. "History of Indian Theatre, Volume 1" by
0929082350/http://www.ashwamedhayaag
Manohar Laxman Varadpande, p.46
am.org/whyamy.html) September 29, 2007,
at the Wayback Machine 79. "Sacred Sacrifice: Ritual Paradigms in
Vedic Religion and Early Christianity" by
Rick F. Talbott, p. 133
References
Ashvini Agrawal (1989). Rise and Fall of the Imperial Guptas (https://books.google.com/book
s?id=hRjC5IaJ2zcC&pg=PA193). Motilal Banarsidass. ISBN 978-81-208-0592-7.
Charles Drekmeier (1962). Kingship and Community in Early India (https://archive.org/detail
s/kingshipcommunit0000drek). Stanford University Press. p. 46 (https://archive.org/details/kin
gshipcommunit0000drek/page/46). ISBN 978-0-8047-0114-3.
David M. Knipe (2015). Vedic Voices: Intimate Narratives of a Living Andhra Tradition (https://
books.google.com/books?id=6RxcBgAAQBAJ&pg=PA234). Oxford: Oxford University Press.
ISBN 9780199397709.
Dineshchandra Sircar (1962). Ramesh Chandra Majumdar (ed.). The History and Culture of
the Indian People: The classical age (https://books.google.com/books?id=2J0fAAAAIAAJ).
Bharatiya Vidya Bhavan.
Dineshchandra Sircar (1971). Studies in the Religious Life of Ancient and Medieval India (htt
ps://books.google.com/books?id=mh1y1eMgGBMC&pg=PA175). Motilal Banarsidass.
ISBN 978-81-208-2790-5.
Jayantanuja Bandyopadhyaya (2007). Class and Religion in Ancient India (https://books.goo
gle.com/books?id=gwUF11NRyT4C&pg=PA203). Anthem. ISBN 978-1-84331-332-8.
K M Ganguly (1896). The Mahabharata of Krishna Dwaipayana Vyasa (http://www.sacred-tex
ts.com/hin/m07/m07065.htm). Sacred Texts.
Glucklich, Ariel (2007). The Strides of Vishnu: Hindu Culture in Historical Perspective (https://
books.google.com/books?id=KtLScrjrWiAC&pg=PA112). Oxford University Press.
ISBN 9780195314052.
Rick F. Talbott (2005). Sacred Sacrifice: Ritual Paradigms in Vedic Religion and Early
Christianity (https://books.google.com/books?id=6XNLAwAAQBAJ). Wipf and Stock.
ISBN 978-1-59752-340-0.
Roshen Dalal (2010). Hinduism: An Alphabetical Guide (https://books.google.com/books?id=
DH0vmD8ghdMC&q=white+horse+hinduism&pg=PA399). Penguin Books India.
ISBN 9780143414216.
Snigdha Tripathy (1997). Inscriptions of Orissa (https://books.google.com/books?id=XUiYu3X
ByNgC&pg=PR3). Vol. I - Circa 5th-8th centuries A.D. Indian Council of Historical Research
and Motilal Banarsidass. ISBN 978-81-208-1077-8.
Stephanie Jamison (1996). Sacrificed Wife / Sacrificer's Wife (https://books.google.com/book
s?id=Hs6mFZqBnGYC). Oxford: Oxford University Press. ISBN 9780195096637.
Upinder Singh (2008). A History of Ancient and Early Medieval India (https://books.google.co
m/books?id=H3lUIIYxWkEC&pg=PA381). Pearson Education India. ISBN 9788131711200.
Tony Whitten; Greg S. Henderson; Muslimin Mustafa (2012). The Ecology of Sulawesi (The
Ecology of Indonesia Series, Volume IV) (https://www.google.co.id/books/edition/Ecology_of
_Sulawesi/Q__PAgAAQBAJ?hl=en&gbpv=0). Tuttle Publishing. ISBN 9781462905072.