Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Alergic
Alergic
Alergic
allergic rhinitis, Introduction Massive consumption of dietary supplements, including vitamins and minerals, has
allergy, asthma, recently become a serious health issue in Europe. Their use may negatively affect the pharmacological
calcium, skin prick activity of various medications, including antiallergic drugs. Calcium preparations are commonly used
test in some European countries as a popular remedy for allergy‑related skin reactions, such as itching,
erythema, and wheals, as well as insect bites. However, so far there have been no reliable studies to
prove their action.
Objectives The aim of this randomized, double‑blind, placebo‑controlled study was to investigate
the efficacy of calcium salts in allergic reactions, using an allergen‑induced skin prick test (SPT).
Patients and methods Forty adult volunteers with allergic rhinoconjunctivitis or asthma (or both)
were recruited to receive oral calcium carbonate (1000 mg) or placebo 3 times a day for 3 days. SPTs
were performed with 11 aeroallergen extracts at baseline and at 4 and 72 hours after drug administra‑
tion. The wheal diameter was measured. We also used the visual analog scale to evaluate the intensity
of pruritus.
Results There was no difference in the wheal size or pruritus between patients receiving calcium or
placebo at any of the time points (P >0.05). Calcium preparations were well tolerated.
Conclusion We found no evidence to support the efficacy of calcium preparations in allergy‑related
skin reactions associated with itching and wheals. Calcium preparations do not suppress SPT responses;
moreover, their use in allergic patients should be discouraged due to their possible interference with
the absorption of antiallergic drugs.
V0 4 hours V1 3 days V2
wheal diameter – wheal diameter time t) / wheal Discussion The use of calcium in allergic dis
diameter baseline] × 100) for each test group for eases is controversial. Despite the lack of evi
all time periods and compared with one another. dence, its application in allergy‑related skin reac
The same method was used to calculate the per tions is relatively common in Central and Eastern
centage change of itching. Europe, especially in Poland, Czech Republic, Ger
Statistical comparisons between the groups many, Hungary, Bulgaria, Slovenia, and Ukraine
were performed using 1‑way analysis of vari (a social‑media based survey prior to the study
ance. A P value of less than 0.05 was considered initiation; data not shown). On the other hand,
statistically significant. The data were present calcium salts were found to interact with many
ed as the means and standard error (all comput drugs, both by alterations in gastric pH and by
ed with Statistica Version 13.2, Statistica, Tulsa, formation of nonabsorbable complexes.8,18 These
Oklahoma, United States). compounds were found to impair the absorp
The study was conducted in accordance with tion of prednisone and probably other cortico
the Declaration of Helsinki, good clinical prac steroids used to treat symptoms of allergic reac
tice guidelines, and the requirements of nation tions; therefore, their extensive use may signifi
al laws. All study documents were approved by cantly decrease corticosteroid activity.5,6 In this
an independent ethical committee (the primary study, we addressed the question of the useful
responsible ethics committee: Medical Universi ness of calcium preparations in allergy‑related
ty of Warsaw; number, 205/2014). All patients skin reactions by using objective and restric
gave their written informed consent to partici tive principles of a randomized controlled tri
pate in the study. al in a reliable research model.19 We found that
calcium supplements given at a single dose or
Results In total, 78 volunteers were screened as a 3‑day treatment did not reduce the size of
for this study. Of these, 40 individuals (12 men the wheal or pruritus compared with placebo in
and 28 women; mean age, 25 years; range, 19–32 a human SPT model.
years) who met all the inclusion criteria were Of note, the levels of calcium in intracellular
enrolled and randomized, and all of them com compartments are 20 000 times lower than those
pleted the study. No dropouts were recorded. At in extracellular compartments.20 Therefore, in vi
baseline, there was no significant difference be tro experiments showing calcium‑mediated inhi
tween the groups in mean wheal responses and bition of histamine release are not reproducible
itching sensations in SPTs. in vivo, since very high intracellular concentra
Neither the mean wheal diameter nor itching tions are unlikely to be obtained, even following
sensation changed in any of the groups through an intravenous administration.10
out the study compared with the baseline values Our results are inconsistent with those of pre
(FIGURE 2A and 2b , FIGURE 3 , TABLES 1 and 2 ). There vious studies conducted in the 1970s and 1980s,
was no difference between the calcium and pla in which the authors observed the efficacy of cal
cebo groups in the percentage change in wheal cium in inhibiting type I allergic reactions. In
response at any time point (V1, V2), compared the first report, Debelic21 evaluated the effects
with the baseline values (TABLE 1). Moreover, there of oral calcium gluconate and calcium lactate
were no significant differences in itching sensa combined with vitamin D2 on SPT results in 20
tion assessed using the VAS between the calcium pollen‑allergic volunteers in a double‑blind ran
preparation and placebo groups (TABLE 2 ). domized controlled study, indicating a signifi
Calcium carbonate was well tolerated when cant wheal reduction (20%). A double-blind ran
used at high doses, and no drug‑induced adverse domized study by Haas22 revealed that the same
effects were observed. mixture of ingredients fortified with ascorbic
acid was effective in reducing the wheal area and
0
V0 V1 V2
B 8
6 Calcium carbonate
Wheal diameter for histamine, mm
Placebo
5
NS
4 NS
0
V0 V1 V2
itching intensity. However, the methodology of calcium levels occur 2 to 6 hours after calcium in
both studies raises some concerns. The authors gestion,24,25 while in the above reports, calcium
of both papers did not adequately address SPT re ‑induced responses were recorded 10 and 30 min
producibility in their reports. There are many fac utes after administration.21,22 Based on the anti
tors known to modulate the SPT readout, which histamine model, even when the maximum plas
are required to obtain reproducible results, and ma level of the drug is reached by 30 minutes, it
in our study, we strictly conformed to those cri takes another 1.5 hours for the drug to diffuse
teria.23 Moreover, considering calcium pharmaco into the extravascular space to observe clinical
kinetics and bioavailability, the maximum serum effect.26
Calcium carbonate
2
Placebo
0
V0 V1 V2
TABLE 1 Percentage change in wheal responses 4 hours after the first dose (V1) and after 72 hours of treatment
(V2) versus baseline (V0) in patients treated with calcium carbonate or placebo
TABLE 2 Percentage change in itching sensation 4 hours after the first dose (V1) and after 72 hours of treatment (V2)
versus baseline (V0) in patients treated with calcium carbonate or placebo
Time Mean % change in itching sensation (vs V0) P value (calcium carbonate
Calcium carbonate Placebo vs placebo)
Our results are also in contrast to 2 studies con an effect resulting from the inhibition of hista
ducted by Bachert et al,27,28 who analyzed the ef mine release from mast cells.29-31
fects of intravenous and oral calcium on nasal al In the 3 studies discussed above, calcium prep
lergen provocation tests. The authors observed aration was administered in a single oral dose,
decreased swelling of the nasal mucosa and im much higher than that used in our study or than
proved nasal flow after calcium application, but doses commonly administered to patients in or
interestingly, those effects were associated with der to mitigate the symptoms of allergy. It is
only a minimum (4.5%) increase in serum calci worth noting that calcium absorption is a satu
um levels. The discrepancy between these studies rable process, which means that a dose of about
and our findings is probably related to the study 500 mg of elemental calcium results in a signifi
model. It may be speculated that calcium activity cantly reduced absorption.32 Furthermore, dur
in allergic rhinitis most probably relies on the re ing our 3‑day study, the total dose administered
duction in the permeability of blood vessel walls, in participants was 3.6‑fold higher than the dose
in allergic diseases such as allergic rhinitis, ur 3 Navarro VJ, Khan I, Bjornsson E, et al. Liver injury from herbal and di‑
etary supplements. Hepatology. 2017; 65: 363-373.
ticaria, and allergic bronchial asthma; however,
4 Hamishehkar H, Ranjdoost F, Asgharian P, et al. Vitamins, are they safe?
their results are inconsistent.33-35 Adv Pharm Bull. 2016; 6: 467-477.
Our study has several limitations. Firstly, this 5 Sadowski DC. Drug interactions with antacids. Mechanisms and clini‑
was not a clinical trial, but rather a human‑model cal significance. Drug Saf. 1994; 11: 395-407.
study. The suppression of histamine‑induced 6 Uribe M, Casian C, Rojas S, et al. Decreased bioavailability of predni‑
sone due to antacids in patients with chronic active liver disease and in
skin wheals has been well established as an ob healthy volunteers. Gastroenterology. 1981; 80: 661-665.
jective in vivo model for evaluating peripheral 7 Krela‑Kazmierczak I, Szymczak A, Tomczak M, et al. Calcium and phos‑
H1‑blockade19 ; however, it does not necessarily phate metabolism in patients with inflammatory bowel diseases. Pol Arch
Med Wewn. 2015; 125: 588-590.
reflect the overall antiallergic activity. Mediators 8 Sweetman SC. Calcium. In: Sweetman SC, ed. Martindale The Com‑
other than histamine also play an important role plete Drug Reference. London, United Kingdom: Pharmaceutical Press;
in allergic cutaneous responses, including medi 2009: 1675-1678.
9 Unger R. [Experience with parenteral Calcium preparations]. Ther Ggw.
ators involved in cellular late‑phase responses.36 1935; 76: 69. German.
Therefore, SPT findings should be interpreted 10 Sozanski T, Magdalan J, Sozanska B, et al. Is there any hope for calci‑
with caution and with consideration of the clini um use in allergic diseases? Adv Clin Exp Med. 2009; 18: 507-512.
cal situation since they may not necessarily cor 11 Nittner‑Marszalska M, Cichocka‑Jarosz E. Insect sting allergy in
adults: key messages for clinicians. Pol Arch Med Wewn. 2015; 125:
relate with clinical responses.37 929-937.
The advantage of these tests is that they are 12 Nowicki R. [Tratment of urticaria: general recommendations]. In:
easy to perform, fast, inexpensive, and safe. Kruszewski J, Śpiewak R, Nowicki R, eds. [Urticaria. Diagnosis and treat‑
ment. Statement of the Expert Group of the Polish Society of Allergology].
The SPT is used as an objective assessment of Warsaw, Poland: Medycyna Praktyczna; 2011: 65-68. Polish.
the efficacy and pharmacodynamics of antihis 13 Zuberbier T, Aberer W, Asero R, et al. The EAACI/GA(2)
taminic drugs; however, its readout is still prone LEN/EDF/WAO Guideline for the definition, classification, diagnosis, and
management of urticaria: the 2013 revision and update. Allergy. 2014; 69:
to errors.38 Therefore, another limitation of our 868-887.
study was the subjective and manual method 14 Schulz KF, Altman DG, Moher D. CONSORT 2010 Statement: updated
for SPT readouts, even though this part was guidelines for reporting parallel group randomised trials. BMC Med. 2010;
performed by investigators blinded to the study 8: 18.
15 Bousquet J, Heinzerling L, Bachert C, et al. Practical guide to skin
groups. An automatic wheal measurement might prick tests in allergy to aeroallergens. Allergy. 2012; 67: 18-24.
be more accurate, but it is not available yet.39 16 Levenson DI, Bockman RS. A review of calcium preparations. Nutr
Rev. 1994; 52: 221-232.
Conclusions To our knowledge, this is the only 17 Weisman SM. The calcium connection to bone health across a wom‑
an’s lifespan: a roundtable. J Reprod Med. 2005; 50: 879-884.
reliable report investigating the activity of calci
18 Palleria C, Di Paolo A, Giofrè C, et al. Pharmacokinetic drug‑drug inter‑
um preparations in allergic reactions. In this pa action and their implication in clinical management. J Res Med Sci. 2013;
per, we ultimately question any applicability of 18: 601-610.
calcium preparations in the treatment of allergy. 19 Simons FE, Simons KJ. Peripheral H1‑blockade effect of fexofenadine.
Ann Allergy Asthma Immunol. 1997; 79: 530-532.
Our results show that neither single doses nor
20 Clapham DE. Calcium signaling. Cell. 2007; 131: 1047-1058.
long‑term treatment with calcium supplements
21 Debelic M. [The anti‑allergic effect of an oral calcium prepara‑
reduces allergic cutaneous reactions (measured tion. Controlled double‑blind study]. Fortschr Med. 1979; 97: 1537-1540.
as the wheal response and symptoms of pruri German.
tus), as compared with placebo. 22 Haas PJ. [Drug modification of mechanically evoked itching and
the concomitant equivalents, erythema and wheals of the skin. Clinico
‑experimental studies]. Fortschr Med. 1983; 101: 1939-1943. German.
Acknowledgments We would like to thank 23 Nelson HS, Knoetzer J, Bucher B. Effect of distance between sites
the pharmacist Małgorzata Zając, who kindly pre and region of the body on results of skin prick tests. J Allergy Clin Immu‑
nol. 1996; 97: 596-601.
pared drug samples, and Marcin Dziekiewicz, who
24 Wang H, Bua P, Capodice J. A comparative study of calcium absorp‑
generated the random allocation sequence and as tion following a single serving administration of calcium carbonate pow‑
signed participants to interventions. The study der versus calcium citrate tablets in healthy premenopausal women. Food
Nutr Res. 2014; 58.
was funded by the Respira Foundation (to KM).
25 Chaturvedi P, Mukherjee R, McCorquodale M, et al. Comparison of
calcium absorption from various calcium‑containing products in healthy
Contribution statement KM and WF conceived human adults: a bioavailability study. FASEB J. 2006; 20: A1063‑A1064.
the idea for the study. KM and WF contributed 26 Church MK, Church DS. Pharmacology of antihistamines. Indian J Der‑
matol. 2013; 58: 219-224.
to the design of the research. KM and MM were
27 Bachert C, Drechsler S, Hauser U, et al. Influence of oral calcium med‑
involved in data collection. KM and WF analyzed ication on nasal resistance in the nasal allergen provocation test. J Allergy
the data. MD generated the random allocation Clin Immunol. 1993; 91: 599-604.
sequence and assigned participants to interven 28 Bachert C, Drechsler S, Keilmann A, et al. [Reduction of reactivi‑
ty to allergic rhinitis with intravenous administration of calcium. Clinical
tions. All authors enrolled participants. WF coor ‑experimental study on the effect of changes of local airway resistance af‑
dinated funding for the project. All authors edited ter nasal allergen provocation]. Arzneimittelforschung. 1990; 40: 984-987.
German.
and approved the final version of the manuscript.
29 West GB. Further thoughts on mast cells, calcium channels and hista‑
mine release. Int Arch Allergy Appl Immunol. 1990; 91: 214-216.