Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Week 4 &5 - Exchange Rate Determination
Week 4 &5 - Exchange Rate Determination
Group Assignment
GROUP MEMBERS
Seline
TABLE OF CONTENT
Measuring Currency Movement..................................................................................................1
Exchange Rate on currency movement........................................................................................1
Conversion Spreads......................................................................................................................1
Effects of currencies movement...................................................................................................2
The Fixed Exchange Rate System...............................................................................................2
Conclusion...................................................................................................................................3
Foreign Currency Supply and demand relation...........................................................................3
Exchange Rate Determination.....................................................................................................3
Measuring exchange rates............................................................................................................3
Key Factors that Affect Foreign Exchange Rates........................................................................4
1. Inflation Rates......................................................................................................................4
2. Interest Rates........................................................................................................................4
3. Country’s Current Account / Balance of Payments.............................................................5
4. Government Debt.................................................................................................................5
5. Terms of Trade.....................................................................................................................5
6. Political Stability & Performance........................................................................................5
7. Recession..............................................................................................................................6
8. Speculation...........................................................................................................................6
Conclusion:..................................................................................................................................6
Interest Parity and Purchasing Power..........................................................................................6
Purchasing Power.........................................................................................................................7
The Downfalls of Purchasing Power .........................................................................................8
Parity Conditions and Fischer Effect...........................................................................................8
How to calculate Interest Rate Parity.........................................................................................10
KEY TAKEAWAYS.................................................................................................................12
Covered interest rate............................................................................................................13
KEY TAKEWAYS....................................................................................................................14
Example of How to u Use Covered Interest Rate Parity.....................................................15
Components of the Formula................................................................................................18
Calculating the Formula......................................................................................................18
Short-term Applications......................................................................................................18
Long-term Significance.......................................................................................................19
Reference...................................................................................................................................20
Measuring Currency Movement
An exchange rate is how much it costs to exchange one currency for another in the currency
movement. Exchange rates fluctuate constantly throughout the week as currencies are actively
traded. This pushes the price up and down, similar to other assets such as gold or stocks. The
market price of a currency – how many U.S. dollars it takes to buy a Canadian dollar for example
– is different than the rate you will receive from your bank when you exchange currency. Traders
and institutions buy and sell currencies 24 hours a day during the week. For a trade to occur, one
currency must be exchanged for another. To buy British Pounds (GBP), another currency must
be used to buy it. Whatever currency is used will create a currency pair. If U.S. dollars (USD) are
used to buy GBP, the exchange rate is for the GBP/USD pair. Access to these forex markets can
be found through any of the major forex brokers. Live rates for several major currencies are
available on the Investopedia Forex page.
Conversion Spreads
When you go to the bank to convert currencies, you most likely won't get the market price that
traders get. The bank or currency exchange house will markup the price so they make a profit, as
will credit cards and payment services providers such as PayPal, when a currency conversion
occurs.If the USD/CAD price is 1.0950, the market is saying it costs 1.0950 Canadian dollars to
buy 1 U.S. dollar. At the bank though, it may cost 1.12 Canadian dollars. The difference between
the market exchange rate and the exchange rate they charge is their profit. To calculate the
percentage discrepancy, take the difference between the two exchange rates, and divide it by the
market exchange rate: 1.12 - 1.0950 = 0.025/1.0950 = 0.023. Multiply by 100 to get the
percentage markup: 0.023 x 100 = 2.23%.
A markup will also be present if converting U.S. dollars to Canadian dollars. If the CAD/USD
exchange rate is 0.9132 (see section above), then the bank may charge 0.9382. They are charging
you more U.S. dollars than the market rate. 0.9382 - 0.9132 = 0.025/0.9132 = 0.027 x 100 =
2.7% markup.
Banks and currency movement compensate themselves for this service. The bank gives you cash,
whereas traders in the market do not deal in cash. In order to get cash, wire fees and processing
or withdrawal fees would be applied to a forex account in case the investor needs the money
physically. For most people looking for currency conversion, getting cash instantly and without
fees, but paying a markup, is a worthwhile compromise.
Conclusion
When you go to the bank to convert currencies, you most likely won't get the market price that
traders get. The bank or currency exchange house will markup the price so they make a profit, as
will credit cards and payment services providers such as PayPal, when a currency conversion
occurs.
Cross rates –Is an exchange rate calculated by reference to the third party.
Trade weighted index-It provides a broader measure of general trend in currency ;as it shows
price of domestic currency in terms of weighted average group of currencies. The weights of
each currency in the basket are generally based on the share of trade conducted with the trading
countries. It shows if currency is appreciating or depreciating relatively to its trading partners. It
fluctuates less than bilateral as movements in bilateral exchange often offset each other.
Key Factors that Affect Foreign Exchange Rates
Electronic funds transfer document
Foreign Exchange rate (Forex rate) is one of the most important means through which a
country’s relative level of economic health is determined. A country's foreign exchange rate
provides a window to its economic stability, which is why it is constantly watched and analyzed.
If you are thinking of sending or receiving money from overseas, you need to keep a keen eye on
the currency exchange rates.
The exchange rate is defined as "the rate at which one country's currency may be converted into
another." It may fluctuate daily with the changing market forces of supply and demand of
currencies from one country to another. For these reasons; when sending or receiving money
internationally, it is important to understand what determines exchange rates.
This article examines some of the leading factors that influence the variations and fluctuations in
exchange rates and explains the reasons behind their volatility, helping you learn the best time to
send money abroad.
1. Inflation Rates
Changes in market inflation cause changes in currency exchange rates. A country with a lower
inflation rate than another's will see an appreciation in the value of its currency. The prices of
goods and services increase at a slower rate where the inflation is low. A country with a
consistently lower inflation rate exhibits a rising currency value while a country with higher
inflation typically sees depreciation in its currency and is usually accompanied by higher interest
rates
2. Interest Rates
Changes in interest rate affect currency value and dollar exchange rate. Forex rates, interest rates,
and inflation are all correlated. Increases in interest rates cause a country's currency to appreciate
because higher interest rates provide higher rates to lenders, thereby attracting more foreign
capital, which causes a rise in exchange rates
3. Country’s Current Account / Balance of Payments
A country’s current account reflects balance of trade and earnings on foreign investment. It
consists of total number of transactions including its exports, imports, debt, etc. A deficit in
current account due to spending more of its currency on importing products than it is earning
through sale of exports causes depreciation. Balance of payments fluctuates exchange rate of its
domestic currency.
4. Government Debt
Government debt is public debt or national debt owned by the central government. A country
with government debt is less likely to acquire foreign capital, leading to inflation. Foreign
investors will sell their bonds in the open market if the market predicts government debt within a
certain country. As a result, a decrease in the value of its exchange rate will follow.
5. Terms of Trade
Related to current accounts and balance of payments, the terms of trade is the ratio of export
prices to import prices. A country's terms of trade improves if its exports prices rise at a greater
rate than its imports prices. This results in higher revenue, which causes a higher demand for the
country's currency and an increase in its currency's value. This results in an appreciation of
exchange rate.
6. Political Stability & Performance
A country's political state and economic performance can affect its currency strength. A country
with less risk for political turmoil is more attractive to foreign investors, as a result, drawing
investment away from other countries with more political and economic stability. Increase in
foreign capital, in turn, leads to an appreciation in the value of its domestic currency. A country
with sound financial and trade policy does not give any room for uncertainty in value of its
currency. But, a country prone to political confusions may see a depreciation in exchange rates.
7. Recession
When a country experiences a recession, its interest rates are likely to fall, decreasing its chances
to acquire foreign capital. As a result, its currency weakens in comparison to that of other
countries, therefore lowering the exchange rate.
8. Speculation
If a country's currency value is expected to rise, investors will demand more of that currency in
order to make a profit in the near future. As a result, the value of the currency will rise due to the
increase in demand. With this increase in currency value comes a rise in the exchange rate as
well.
Conclusion:
All of these factors determine the foreign exchange rate fluctuations. If you send or receive
money frequently, being up-to-date on these factors will help you better evaluate the optimal
time for international money transfer. To avoid any potential falls in currency exchange rates, opt
for a locked-in exchange rate service, which will guarantee that your currency is exchanged at
the same rate despite any factors that influence an unfavorable fluctuation.
When IRP exists there are no options for profit as the difference between spot and exchange rate
are equivalent to the difference in the two countries interest rates. Hence investing money in a
local bank while signing forward exchange agreement yields same amount of money as buying
currency at spot rate and invest it in a foreign account.
–Interest rate parity is the fundamental equation governing relationship between interest rates
and currency exchange rate
-It is used by forex traders to find arbitrage opportunities
-Its basic promise is that hedged returns from investing in different currencies is similar
regardless levels of interest rates
Covered IRP is when no arbitrage condition could be satisfied through the use of forward
contracts in an attempt to hedge against foreign exchange risk.
Uncovered IRP is when no arbitrage condition could be satisfied without the use of forward
contracts to hedge against foreign exchange risk.
Real Interest Rate Parity it is where both UIRP and purchasing power parity hold ,the two
conditions reveal a relationship among expected real interest rate ;wherein changes in expected
real interest rates reflect expected changes in the real exchange rate.
Purchasing Power
Purchasing power parity is an economic theory that compares different countries’ currencies
through a (basket of goods). Is measured by finding values (in USD) of a basket of goods that are
present in each country eg, pineapple juice, pencils etc. .If that basket costs $100 in the us and
$200 in the UK, then the purchasing power parity exchange rate is $ 1.2 .
Two currencies are in equilibrium or at per when a basket of goods (taking into account the
exchange rate) is priced the same in both countries .Low of one price (LPO) an economic theory
that predicts that after accounting for different in interest rates and exchange rates, the cost of
something country X should be same as that in country Y in real terms.
S= P1/P2. Where S is the exchange rate in currency 1 to currency 2. P1 is the cost of goods X in
currency 1 and P2 is the cost of goods X in currency 2.
(iv) https://www.youtube.com/redirect?q=http%3A%2F%2Feconclassroom.com%2F
%3Fpage_id
%3D5870&event=video_description&v=1Gs1KrTBIBM&redir_token=-
_EHxPMoCLo1UffFyHHXy8LjQNF8MTU1MTM4MzY4NUAxNTUxMjk3Mjg1
Note: Bank One will notice a book imbalance (all the activity involves selling USD for JPY,
selling
JPY for GBP, selling GBP for USD.) and will adjust quotes. Say:
SJPY/USD,t ↓ (say, SJPY/USD,t = 93 JPY/USD).
SUSD/GBP,t ↓ (say, SUSD/GBP,t = 1.56 USD/GBP).
SJPY/GBP,t ↑ (say, SJPY/GBP,t = 145 JPY/GBP).
There is convergence between SI
JPY,GBP,t & SJPY,GBP,t:
SI
JPY,GBP,t ↓ (= SJPY,USD,t ↓ x SUSD/GBP,t ↓ ) ⇔ SJPY,GBP,t ↑ ¶
Again, all the steps in the triangular arbitrage strategy should be done at the same time.
Otherwise,
we’ll be facing risk and what we are doing should be considered pseudo-arbitrage.
It does not matter which currency you borrow (USD, GBP, JPY) in step (1). As long as the
strategy
involves the step Sell JPY/Buy GBP (following the direction of the arrows in the triangle
above!),
you should get the same profit as a %.
3. Covered Interest Arbitrage (Four instruments -two goods per market-, two markets)
Open the third section of the WSJ: Brazilian bonds yield 10% and Japanese bonds 1%.
Q: Why wouldn't capital flow to Brazil from Japan?
A: FX risk: Once JPY are exchanged for BRL (Brazilian reals), there is no guarantee that the
BRL
will not depreciate against the JPY. The only way to avoid this FX risk is to be covered with a
forward
FX contract.
Intuition: Suppose we have the following data:
iJPY = 1% for 1 year (T=1 year)
iBRL = 10% for 1 year (T=1 year)
St = .025 BRL/JPY
We construct the following strategy, called carry trade, to “profit” from the interest rate
differential:
Today, at time t=0, we do the following (1)-(3) transactions:
(1) Borrow JPY 1,000 at 1% for 1 year. (At T=1 year, we will need to repay JPY 1,010.)
(2) Convert to BRL at St = .025 BRL/JPY. Get BRL 25.
(3) Deposit BRL 25 at 10% for 1 year. (At T=1 year, we will receive BRL 27.50.)
Now, we wait 1 year. At time T=1 year, we do the final step:
(4) Exchange BRL 27.50 for JPY at ST.
Problem with this carry trade: Today, we do not know ST=1-year. Note:
- If ST= .022 JPY/BRL, we will receive JPY 1250, for a profit of JPY 240.
- If ST= .025 JPY/BRL, we will receive JPY 1100, for a profit of JPY 90.
- If ST= .027 JPY/BRL, we will receive JPY 1019, for a profit of JPY 9.
- If ST= .030 JPY/BRL, we will receive JPY 916, for a profit of JPY -74.
Weare facing FX risk. That is, (1)-(4) is not an arbitrage strategy
Now, at time t=0, we can use the FX forward market to insure a certain exchange rate for the
JPY/BRL.
Suppose we get a quote of Ft,1-yr =.026 JPY.BRL. At time t=0, we re-do step (4):
(4’) Sell BRL forward at .026 JPY/BRL. (We will receive JPY 1058, for a sure profit of JPY 48.)
=> We are facing no FX risk. That is, (1)-(4’) is an arbitrage strategy (covered arbitrage).
Now, instead of borrowing JPY 1,000, we will try to borrow JPY 1 billion (and make a JPY 48M
profit) or more. Obviously, no bank will offer a .026 JPY/BRL forward contract!
Interest Rate Parity Theorem
Q: How do banks price FX forward contracts?
A: In such a way that arbitrageurs cannot take advantage of their quotes.
To price a forward contract, banks consider covered arbitrage strategies.
Review of Notation:
id = domestic nominal T days interest rate.
if = foreign nominal T days interest rate.
St = time t spot rate (direct quote, for example USD/GBP).
Ft,T = forward rate for delivery at date T, at time t.
Note: In developed markets (like the USA), all interest rates are quoted on annualized basis. We
will
use annualized interest rates (The textbook is completely mistaken when it quotes periodic
rates!!)
Now, consider the following (covered) strategy:
(1) At time 0, we borrow from a foreign bank 1 unit of a foreign currency (FC) for T days.
At time=T, We pay the foreign bank (1 + if x T/360) units of the FC.
(2) At time 0, we exchange FC 1 at St for 1 unit of FC we get St.
(3) We deposit St in a domestic bank for T days.
At time T, we receive St (1 + id x T/360) (in DC).
(4) At time 0, we buy a T days forward contract to exchange domestic currency (DC) for FC at a
Ft,T.
At time T, we exchange the DC St(1 + id x T/360) for FC, using Ft,T.
We get St(1 + id x T/360)/Ft,T units of FC.
This strategy will not be profitable if, at time T, what we receive in FC is less or equal to what
we
have to pay in FC. That is, arbitrage will ensure that
The IRP theory, also called covered IRPT, as presented above was first clearly exposed by John
Maynard Keynes (1923).
It is common to use the following linear IRPT approximation:
Ft,T St [1 + (id - if) x T/360].
This linear approximation is quite accurate for small id & if (say, less than 10%).
Notes:
⋄ Steps (2) and (4) simultaneously done produce a FX swap transaction! In this case, we buy the
FC
forward at Ft,T and go sell the FC at St. We can think of (Ft,T - St) as a profit from the FX swap.
⋄ We get the same IRPT equation if we start the covered strategy by (1) borrowing DC at id; (2)
exchanging DC for FC at St; (3) depositing the FC at if; and (4) selling the FC forward at Ft,T.
Check Steps (1)-(3) in Example 1: Foreign (U.S.) capital flows to Japan (capital inflows to
Japan).
A - Go back to Example 2
p = [(Ft,T-St)/St] x 360/T = [(110 – 106)/106] x 360/360 = 0.0377 => USD trades at a premium.
p = 0.0377 > (id - if) = - 0.016 Arbitrage possible (pricing mistake!) capital flows!
Check Steps (1)-(3) in Example 2: Domestic (Japanese) capital flows to USA (capital outflows).
¶
Consider a point under the IRPT line, say A (like in Example 2): p > id -if (or p + if > id) a
long
spot/short forward position has a higher yield than borrowing abroad at if and investing at home
at id
Arbitrage is possible! (There is a pricing mistake).
Covered Arbitrage Strategy:
(1) Borrow DC at id for T days
(2) Convert DC to FC (the long position in FC)
(3) Deposit FC at if for T days
(4) Sell forward FC at Ft,T (the short forward position in FC)
That is, today, at a point like A, domestic capital fly to the foreign country: What an investor
pays in
domestic interest rate, id, is more than compensated by the high forward premium, p, and the
foreign
interest rate, if.
• IRPT: Evidence
Starting from Frenkel and Levich (1975), there is a lot of evidence that supports IRPT. For
example,
Figure 7.3 plots the daily interest rate differential against the annualized forward premium. They
plot
very much along the 45° line. Moreover, the correlation coefficient between these two series is
0.995, highly correlated series!
Using intra-daily data (10’ intervals), Taylor (1989) also find strong support for IRPT. At the
tickby-tick data, Akram, Rice and Sarno (2008, 2009) show that there are short-lived (from 30
secondsup to 4 minutes) departures from IRP, with a potential profit range of 0.0002-0.0006 per
unit. Theshort-lived nature and small profit range point out to a fairly efficient market, with the
data close tothe IRPT line.
There are situations, however, where we observe significant and more persistent deviations from
the IRPT line. These situations are usually attributed to monetary policy, credit risk, funding
conditions,risk aversion of investors, lack of capital mobility, default risk, country risk, and
marketmicrostructure effects.
For example, during the 2008-2009 financial crisis there were several violations of IRPT (in
Graph7.2, the point well over the line (-.0154,-.0005) is from May 2009). These violations are
attributed tofunding constraints –i.e., difficulties to do step (1): borrow. See Baba and Parker
(2009) and Griffoliand Ranaldo (2011).
Baldwin, R., & Krugman, P. (1989). Persistent trade effects of large exchange rate shocks. The
Quarterly Journal of Economics, 104(4), 635-654
Boudoukh, J., Richardson, M., & Whitelaw, R. F. (2004). Industry returns and the Fisher effect.
the Journal of Finance, 49(5), 1595-1615.
Chadwick, M. G., Fazilet, F., & Tekatli, N. (2012). Common movement of the emerging market
currencies (No. 1207).
Frankel, J., & Poonawala, J. (2010). The forward market in emerging currencies: Less biased
than in major currencies. Journal of International Money and Finance, 29(3), 585-598.
Ho, C., Ma, G., & McCauley, R. N. (2005). Trading Asian currencies.
Huang, Q. H. (2011). Discovery of time-inconsecutive co-movement patterns of foreign
currencies using an evolutionary biclustering method. Applied Mathematics and
Computation, 218(8), 4353-4364.
Miller, K. D., Jeffrey, F. J., & Mandelker, G. (2006). The “Fisher effect” for risky assets: An
empirical investigation. The Journal of finance, 31(2), 447-458.
Mishkin, F. S. (2002). Is the Fisher effect for real?: A reexamination of the relationship between
inflation and interest rates. Journal of Monetary economics, 30(2), 195-215.
International money market (in money market: the international money market)