Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Acute Effects of Hypoxemia, Hyperoxemia and Hypercapnea On RRI SHARKEY Et Al ERS 1988
Acute Effects of Hypoxemia, Hyperoxemia and Hypercapnea On RRI SHARKEY Et Al ERS 1988
aa
Acute effects of hypoxaemia, hyperoxaemia and hypercapnia on renal blood flow in normal Dept of Respiratory Medicine, Beaumont
and renal transplant subjects. R.A. Sharkey, E.M.T. Mulloy, S.J. O'Neill. ERS Journals Hospital, Dublin, Ireland.
Ltd 1998.
ABSTRACT: The aim of this investigation was to study noninvasively the effects of Correspondence: S.J. O'Neill
Dept of Respiratory Medicine
hypoxaemia, hyperoxaemia and hypercapnia on renal blood flow in normal subjects Beaumont Hospital
and renal allograft recipients, i.e. with denervated kidneys. By comparing these two Dublin 9
groups, the influence of renal innervation on any resulting changes in renal blood Ireland
flow could be ascertained. Fax: 353 1 8376982
Nine normal and eight renal allograft recipients were studied. Each subject inhaled
the following gas mixtures in order: room air, 10% O2 (hypoxaemia), 10% O2+base- Keywords: Hypercapnia
line CO2 (isocapnic hypoxaemia), 10% O2 + high CO2 (hypercapnic hypoxaemia), 100% hyperoxaemia
O2 (hyperoxaemia), 100% O2 + baseline CO2 (isocapnic hyperoxaemia) and 100% O2 hypoxaemia
renal blood flow
+ high CO2 (hypercapnia hyperoxaemia). Using Doppler ultrasonography, the pulsa- renal denervation
tility index (PI), an index of renovascular resistance, was measured at the various gas
inhalation levels. Received: October 29 1997
In normal subjects, the renovascular resistance increased in response to hypox- Accepted after revision May 12 1998
aemia, with a greater increase in response to hypercapnic hypoxaemia. Hyperoxae-
mia caused a decrease in renovascular resistance but this was abolished with the addi-
tion of CO2. There was a similar pattern in the PI response to the different gas
inhalations in the renal transplant subjects, but these responses were attenuated in
comparison with those of the normals.
In conclusion, renal denervation does not completely abolish the renovascular
responses to inhaled oxygen and carbon dioxide.
Eur Respir J 1998; 12: 653–657.
Changes in arterial oxygen and carbon dioxide levels the rapid, accurate, reproducible and noninvasive investiga-
cause alterations in the renal blood flow. Studies have tion of renal blood flow and is ideally suited for human
shown variable effects of hypoxaemia and increasing oxy- studies.
genation on renal blood flow, although it is generally
accepted that severe hypoxaemia reduces renal blood flow Methods
[1, 2]. There is more general agreement on the effect of
hypercapnia, which reduces renal blood flow in subjects Subjects
with chronic obstructive pulmonary disease (COPD). Hy-
percapnia has also been shown to prevent improvement in Nine normal and eight renal allograft recipients were
renal blood flow with the administration of oxygen [1, 3]. studied. All participants were male. Each subject gave in-
There are very few published studies looking at the acute formed consent and the hospital ethics committee approv-
effects of changes in inspired oxygen and carbon dioxide ed the study protocol. The normal subjects were recruited
on renal blood flow in normal subjects [4, 5]. from the hospital medical staff. They were all in good
The mechanisms whereby alterations in oxygen and health and none was taking medication.
carbon dioxide levels influence renal blood flow are not The renal transplant subjects were recruited from the
fully understood. It is thought that the renal nerves and nephrology outpatient department. They were at least 18
various hormones and neuropeptides including catecho- months post-renal transplantation (mean 30 months), and
lamines, dopamine and endothelin are the main factors in- had no history of cardiac or respiratory disease. Renal
fluencing the changes in renal blood flow [3, 6, 7]. In this function was stable in each subject, with serum creatinine
study, the effect of different levels of inspired oxygen and level <250 µmol·L-1 and no recent episodes of rejection.
carbon dioxide on renal blood flow was compared in nor- All subjects were receiving immunosuppressive therapy
mal subjects and in subjects postrenal transplantation, i.e. which included prednisolone, azothioprine and cyclosporin.
subjects with denervated kidneys. By comparing these two Seven of the subjects were taking antihypertensive medi-
groups, it could be ascertained whether renal denervation cation, consisting of a β-blocker in five cases and nitrates
abolished the renovascular responses to the gas inhalations. in two, and this medication was omitted for 24 h before
The development of Doppler ultrasonography has allowed the study.
654 R.A. SHARKEY ET AL.
Circuit Results
Two 100 L Douglas bags were filled with a mixture of The mean age of the normal subjects was 27±2.6 yrs
10% O2 and 90% N2. These were connected to a breathing and that of the transplant subjects was 35.2±5.36 yrs (p<
circuit, to which room air, 100% O2 and 100% CO2 at var- 0.005). In the normals, the PI changed significantly in res-
ying flow rates could be added. The subjects breathed via
a facemask which occluded the nose, and had one-way
inspiratory and expiratory valves. End-tidal CO2 tension Table 1. – Arterial oxygen saturation (Sa,O2), end-tidal car-
bon dioxide tension (Pet,CO2) and changes in pulsatility in-
(Pet,CO2) was monitored by means of a CO2 sensor att- dex (PI) in normal subjects (n=9)
ached to the expiratory port. A Hewlett-Packard capno-
meter was used, which was calibrated before each study Sa,O2 Pet,CO2 PI
(Hewlett Packard, Waltham, MA, USA). Arterial oxygen % kPa
saturation (Sa,O2) was monitored by means of a Sensor- Baseline Sa,O2 96.6±0.7 5.1±0.6 0.86±0.11
Medics (Anaheim, CA, USA) pulse oximeter with a finger Hypocapnic 83.3±2.2** 4.4±0.4** 0.96±0.13
probe. The subjects held the facemask tightly in place, so hypoxaemia
that they could remove it quickly if they became dis- Isocapnic 84.2±3.3** 5.1±0.5 1.03±0.14
hypoxaemia
tressed. The presence of air leaks was excluded by a stable Hypercapnic 87.8±4.4** 6.8±0.6** 1.14±0.14*
Pet,CO2 reading. Pet,CO2 is the CO2 tension at the peak of hypoxaemia
exhalation [11], and in healthy humans, is approximately Hypocapnic 98.6±0.4** 4.0±0.6** 0.77±0.1
0.13 kPa (1 mmHg) lower than the alveolar CO2 tension. hyperoxaemia
Therefore, Pet,CO2 can be used as an indirect way of re- Isocapnic 98.4±0.7** 5.1±0.5 0.88±0.09
cording arterial CO2 tension (Pa,CO2) [12]. hyperoxaemia
The effect of hypoxaemia and hyperoxaemia alone and Hypercapnic 98.4±0.9** 6.8±0.5** 1.01±0.12
then with CO2 added was studied. To study the effects of hyperoxaemia
changing oxygenation independently of changes in arte- Data are shown as mean±SD. **: p<0.01; *: p<0.05, change in
rial CO2 levels, the Pet,CO2 was continuously monitored variable from room air.
RENAL BLOOD FLOW 655
0.6
Isocapnic hyperoxaemia- 0.05±0.06 -0.007±0.09 NS
baseline PI 5.8% -0.7%
0.4 Hypercapnic hyperoxaemia- 0.15±0.09 0.09±0.13 NS
baseline PI 17.4% 8.7%
0.2 Data are shown as mean±SD. NS: nonsignificant.
Isocapnic
hyperoxaemia
Isocapnic
hypoxaemia
Room air
lating catecholamines and neuropeptides, also contribute 28]. A possible criticism of these studies was a failure to
to these renovascular responses in humans. control for CO2 levels, which usually increase with O2
Hypercapnia caused a rapid and marked rise in renovas- therapy. Two recent studies in COPD patients, also using
cular resistance, suggesting a decrease in renal blood flow, Doppler methodology, showed improved renal blood flow
and this occurred even in the presence of hyperoxaemia. when oxygenation was improved [2, 3]. In the study by
The effect of hypercapnia on renal blood flow is well doc- HOWES et al. [3], the patients with hypercapnia failed to
umented in animal studies [15–17] and in subjects with improve their renal blood flow in response to O2 adminis-
respiratory failure [1, 3, 18] but, to our knowledge, no tration, supporting the present findings. A preliminary
recent studies have been conducted on normal subjects. study from our department of subjects with respiratory
The most recent study, using methodology similar to the failure showed that renal blood flow increased acutely in
present study, showed that subjects with COPD and hy- res-ponse to inhaled O2 and this improvement was also
percapnic respiratory failure had a lower baseline renal rev-ersed by inducing hypercapnia [29].
blood flow than normocapnic hypoxaemic COPD subjects The mechanisms whereby changes in oxygenation af-
[3]. The hypercapnic subjects also failed to improve their fect renal blood flow are not fully understood. In an ani-
renal blood flow with added oxygen, in contrast to the mal study, the changes in renal blood flow induced by
nor-macapnic subjects [3]. hypoxaemia were prevented by denervation of the peri-
Hypercapnia can reduce renal blood flow by several pheral chemoreceptors and markedly attenuated by renal
potential mechanisms. Hypercapnia causes noradrenaline denervation, but not influenced by adrenalectomy [32].
release via chemoreceptor stimulation and peripheral vaso- This suggests that changes in renal blood flow are caused
dilation, leading to renal vasoconstriction [6, 7, 19]. In by a reflex mechanism, dependent on the sympathetic
addition to circulating noradrenaline, there is local release nerves and chemoreceptor stimulation. The present results
of noradrenaline in the kidneys via the efferent sympa- would be consistent with this finding, as attenuation of the
thetic nervous system [20]. In animal studies, the renal changes in renovascular resistance in response to changes
blood flow response to hypercapnia is abolished by renal in O2 was seen in the subjects with denervated kidneys.
denervation, suggesting that local neurogenic mechanisms The mechanism whereby hyperoxaemia increases renal
play a dominant role in renovascular control in animals blood flow is unknown but may be due to inhibition of the
[17, 21, 22]. In the present study, in post-renal transplant chemoreceptors by hyperoxaemia (the opposite effect to
subjects, i.e. those with denervated kidney, the renovas- hypoxaemia). Hormones and neuropeptides such as
cular response to hypercapnia was not totally abolished noradrenaline, endothelin and the renin-angiotensin acti-
(tables 2, 3), being 50–55% of the change observed in nor- vating system may also play a role, together with a direct
mals. The lack of a significant difference between the two effect of hyperoxaemia on the renal vessels.
groups may be due to the small numbers in the study. Thus, Possible explanations (other than denervation) for the
while renal innervation plays some role in renovascular attenuated renovascular responses in the transplant sub-
responses to hypercapnia, other factors such as circulating jects include their greater age, their impaired renal func-
catecholamines and neuropeptides may also play a role. tion, the effect of medication and possible narrowing of
Severe hypoxaemia is generally agreed to cause red- the renal artery anastamosis. However, there was no overt
uced renal blood flow in both humans and animals [1, 22– Doppler evidence of renal artery stenosis in the subjects
24]; however, there are conflicting reports on the renal and there was only a 20% difference in the baseline renal
effects of moderate hypoxaemia [1–3, 25–29]. FISHMAN et interlobar artery PI between the two groups. Ideally, the
al. [27] found that renal plasma flow increased with hy- two groups should have been matched for age and serum
poxaemia and decreased during oxygen therapy. MANNIX et creatinine, however, this does not detract from the finding
al. [25] and REIHMAN et al. [28] found no change in ren-al that the transplant subjects still had a partial response to
blood flow with changing levels of oxygenation. These changes in O2 and CO2 despite renal denervation.
investigators studied COPD patients using para-aminohip- The Pet,CO2 rose in response to hyperoxaemia in all
purate or radioisotope clearance techniques to measure subjects apart from three of the transplant subjects. A pos-
renal plasma flow, which may be inaccurate in the pres- sible explanation for this may be the roll-off effect. During
ence of the impaired renal tubular function that frequently the first few seconds of hypoxaemia, there is a rapid
occurs in severe COPD [30, 31]. Invasive devices and gen- increase in respiratory frequency owing to stimulation of
eral anaesthesia, such as in the study of FISHMAN et al. [26], the carotid body. However, this increase falls to a plateau
may also have interfered with the results obtained. A (hypoxic roll-off) which is between one-quarter and one-
recent study using similar methodology to the present third of the peak value in adults [32]. It is thought that the
study showed that renal blood flow was reduced in subjects respiratory frequency is inhibited from a central source,
with hypoxaemic COPD (mean Pa,O2 6.9 kPa) compared with possibly the brainstem. The present subjects were made
normal controls [2]. The present study is comparable to hypoxaemic, resulting in an increase in respiratory fre-
this, as the normal subjects reached an Sa,O2 of 80–90%, quency, and 100% inspiratory oxygen fraction (FI,O2) was
i.e. Pa,O2 approximately 6.4–8.0 kPa. Few studies have applied soon afterwards. This hyperoxaemia could have
been carried out on normals, however, a recent altitude inhibited the central inhibition on the respiratory fre-
study (Sa,O2 79–83%) showed that renal blood flow fell by quency, leading to an increase, not the expected decrease,
10% [4]. Almitrine bismesylate, a chemoreceptor stimu- in respiratory frequency and a fall in Pet,CO2. Unfortu-
lant that simulates the effect of hypoxaemia, increased nately, the respiratory frequency was not recorded during
renal blood flow in the first hour postadministration in the study.
normals, but it fell 4 h later [5]. The Pet,CO2 fell in only two of the eight transplant sub-
Conflicting results were also found in early COPD stud- jects in response to hypoxaemia. The differing Pet,CO2 res-
ies of the effects of added O2 on renal blood flow [1, 25– ponse to changing oxygenation in both groups could possibly
RENAL BLOOD FLOW 657
be related to the effect of cyclosporin. Cyclosporin can affect 13. Gazdar AF, Dammin GJ. Neural degeneration and regen-
the distal renal tubule, causing a tendency towards renal eration in human renal transplant. N Engl J Med 1070;
tubular acidosis, which could affect the exchange of hydro- 283: 222–224.
gen ions and bicarbonate. 14. Hansen JM, Abildgaard U, Fogh-Andersen N, et al. The
It is well known that subjects with hypercapnic respira- transplanted human kidney does not achieve functional
reinnervation. Clin Sci 1994; 87: 13–20.
tory failure have a tendency to oedema, which is mediated 15. Daugherty RM Jr, Scott JB, Dabney JM, Haddy FJ. Local
in part via reduced renal blood flow [6–8]. Controlled effects of O2 and CO2 on limb, renal, and coronary vascu-
oxygen therapy can help to resolve this oedema [20]. The lar resistances. Am J Physiol 1967; 213: 1102–1110.
findings of the present study are consistent with these 16. Zillig B, Schuler G, Truniger B. Renal function and intra-
clinical observations and provide a possible mechanistic renal hemodynamics in acutely hypoxic and hypercapnic
ex-planation. However, the effects of acute changes in O2 rats. Kidney Int 1978; 14: 58–67.
and CO2 only were studied, and it is possible that more 17. Stone JE, Wells J, Draper WB, Whitehead RW. Changes
chronic changes in arterial blood gases may have a differ- in renal blood flow in dogs during the inhalation of 30%
ing effect on renal blood flow. carbon dioxide. Am J Physiol 1958; 194: 115–119.
In summary, in normal subjects, the pulsatility index 18. Farber MO, Roberts LR, Weinberger MH, Robertson GL,
Manfredi F. Abnormalities of sodium and H2O handling
increased with hypoxaemia, with a further increase with in chronic obstructive lung disease. Arch Intern Med 1982;
hypercapnic hypoxaemia. This suggests a fall in renal blood 142: 1326–1330.
flow. Hyperoxaemia caused a decrease in the pulsatility 19. Ganong WF. Review of Medical Physiology, 17th Edn.
index, which was abolished with the addition of CO2. These Norwalk, CJ, Appleton & Lange, 1995; pp. 615–624.
responses were attenuated, but not abolished in the renal 20. Anand IS, Chandrashekhar Y, Ferrari R, et al. Pathogene-
transplant subjects, suggesting that renal innervation plays sis of congestive state in chronic obstructive pulmonary
a role in the renal blood flow responses to acute altera- disease. Circulation 1992; 86: 12–21.
tions in inspired O2 and CO2. 21. Gomori P, Kovach AGB, Takacs L, et al. The control of
renal circulation in hypoxia. Acta Med Acad Sci Hung
1960; 16: 43–60.
22. Franklin KJ, McGee LE, Ullmann EA. Effects of severe
References
asphyxia on the kidney and urine flow. J Physiol 1951;
112: 43–53.
1. Kilburn KH, Dowell AR. Renal function in respiratory 23. Anderson RJ, Pluss RG, Berns AS, et al. Mechanism of
failure. Effects of hypoxia, hyperoxia and hypercapnia. effect of hypoxia on renal water excretion. J Clin Invest
Arch Intern Med 1982; 127: 754–762. 1978; 62: 769–777.
2. Baudouin SV, Bott J, Ward A, Deane C, Moxham J. Short 24. Bruns FJ. Decrease in renal perfusion, glomerular filtra-
term effect of oxygen on renal haemodynamics in pat- tion and sodium excretion by hypoxia in the dog. Proc
ients with hypoxaemic chronic obstructive airways dis- Soc Exp Biol Med 1978; 159: 468–472.
ease. Thorax 1992; 47: 550–554. 25. Mannix ET, Dowdeswell I, Carlone S, Palange P, Aronoff
3. Howes TQ, Deane CR, Levin GE, Baudouin SV, Mox- GR, Farber MO. The effect of oxygen on sodium excre-
ham J. The effects of oxygen and dopamine on renal and
tion in hypoxemic patients with chronic obstructive lung
aortic blood flow in chronic obstructive pulmonary dis-
disease. Chest 1990; 97: 840–844.
ease with hypoxemia and hypercapnia. Am J Respir Crit
26. Davies CE. The effect of treatment on the renal circula-
Care Med 1995; 151: 378–383.
4. Anand I, Chandrashekhar Y, Rao S, et al. Body fluid tion in heart failure. Lancet 1951; ii: 1052–1057.
compartments, renal blood flow, and hormones at 6000m 27. Fishman AP, Maxwell MH, Crowder CH, Morales P. Kid-
in normal subjects. J Appl Physiol 1993; 74: 1234–1239. ney function in cor pulmonale: particular consideration of
5. Ledderhos C, Quies W, Schuster R, Peters R. Renal hemo- changes in renal hemodynamics and sodium excretion dur-
dynamics and excretory function of healthy young men ing variation in level of oxygenation. Circulation 1951; 3:
during stimulation of their peripheral arterial chemo- 703–721.
receptors by almitrine bismesylate. Biomed Biochim Acta 28. Reihman DH, Farber MO, Weinberger MH, et al. Effect
1987; 12: 1035–1042. of hypoxemia on sodium and water excretion in chronic
6. MacNee W. Pathophysiology of cor pulmonale in chronic obstructive lung disease. Am J Med 1985; 78: 87–94.
obstructive pulmonary disease. Part I. Am J Respir Crit 29. Sharkey R, Mulloy E, O'Neill S. The acute effects of add-
Care Med 1994; 150: 833–852. ed oxygen and carbon dioxide on renal blood flow in res-
7. MacNee W. Pathophysiology of cor pulmonale in chronic piratory failure. Eur Respir J 1995; 8: Suppl 19, 389s.
obstructive pulmonary disease. Part II. Am J Respir Crit 30. Brenner BM, Zatz R, Ichikawa I. The renal circulations.
Care Med 1994; 150: 1158–1168. In: Brenner BM, Rector FC Jr, eds. The Kidney. Philadel-
8. Sharkey RA, Mulloy EMT, Kilgallen IA, O'Neill SJ. phia, PA, Saunders, 1986; pp. 93–123.
Renal functional reserve in patients with severe chronic 31. Farber MO, Weinberger MH, Robertson GL, Fineberg
obstructive pulmonary disease. Thorax 1997; 52: 411–415. NS. The effects of angiotensin-converting enzyme inhibi-
9. Gosling RG, Dunbar G, King DH, et al. The quantita- tion on sodium handling in patients with advanced chronic
tive analysis of occlusive peripheral arterial disease by a obstructive pulmonary disease. Am Rev Respir Dis 1987;
non-invasive ultrasonic technique. Angiology 1971; 22: 136: 862–866.
52–55. 32. Honig A, Wedler B, Zingler C, Ledderhos C, Schmidt M.
10. Evans DH, McDicken WM, Skidmore R, Woodcock JP. Kidney function during arterial chemoreceptor stimula-
Doppler ultrasound. Physics, instrumentation and clinical tion III. Long-lasting inhibition of renal tubular reabsorp-
applications. Chichester, Wiley, 1989; pp. 162–187. tion due to pharmacologic stimulation of the peripheral
11. Hess D. Capnometry and capnography: technical aspects, chemoreceptors with almitrine bismesylate. Biomed Bio-
physiologic aspects, and clinical applications. Respir Care chim Acta 1985; 44: 1659–1672.
1990; 35: 557–573. 33. Weil JV, Zwillich CW. Assessment of ventilatory res-
12. Tobin MJ. Respiratory monitoring in the intensive care ponse to hypoxia: methods and interpretation. Chest 1976;
unit. Am Rev Respir Dis 1988; 138: 1625–1642. 70: Suppl., 124–128.