Professional Documents
Culture Documents
The Key Role of Apolipoprotein E in Atherosclerosis: Review
The Key Role of Apolipoprotein E in Atherosclerosis: Review
The Key Role of Apolipoprotein E in Atherosclerosis: Review
DOI 10.1007/s00109-004-0631-3
REVIEW
Received: 20 July 2004 / Accepted: 8 November 2004 / Published online: 13 April 2005
# Springer-Verlag 2005
Abstract Apolipoprotein E is a multifunctional protein volved in the efficient hepatic uptake of lipoprotein par-
that is synthesized by the liver and several peripheral tissues ticles, stimulation of cholesterol efflux from macrophage
and cell types, including macrophages. The protein is in- foam cells in the atherosclerotic lesion, and the regulation
of immune and inflammatory responses. Apolipoprotein E
deficiency in mice leads to the development of atheroscle-
rosis and re-expression of the protein reduces the extent of
the disease. This review presents evidence for the potent
anti-atherogenic action of apolipoprotein E and describes
our current understanding of its multiple functions and regu-
lation by factors implicated in the pathogenesis of cardio-
vascular disease.
intima of the arterial wall [1]. Once monocytes enter the is degraded prior to secretion [6, 7]. In addition, newly
intima, they differentiate into macrophages and begin to secreted apoE may remain tightly bound to proteoglycans
accumulate cell debris and oxidatively modified lipopro- on the cell surface, and this source of the protein can either
teins, resulting in the development of lipid-laden foam cells serve as a precursor for the secreted protein or be internal-
[1]. This early vascular lesion, called a fatty streak, prog- ized and then degraded or recycled back to the cell surface/
resses further with the migration and proliferation of smooth extracellular medium [8–12]. Furthermore, the secretion of
muscle cells (SMC) from the media into the intima. The apoE can be regulated by a number of factors such as
most advanced and unstable lesions within the intima con- cholesterol loading of the cells [7, 13, 14] (see below).
sist of a lipid-rich necrotic core surrounded by an extracel- ApoE is produced by various tissues including the liver,
lular matrix and covered by a fibrous cap containing smooth brain, spleen, lung, ovary, adrenal gland, kidney and mus-
muscle cells [1]. The major clinical complications, such as cles [15]. In general, most of the apoE found in the plasma is
myocardial infarction and stroke, arise due to plaque rup- synthesized by the liver with about 20–40% derived from
ture and thrombosis. extra-hepatic sources, such as macrophages [15, 16]. The
A major focus of recent research on cardiovascular dis- expression of apoE is also known to be modulated during
ease has been to understand the molecular basis of ath- physiological and pathophysiological changes by a number
erosclerosis in detail and has resulted in the identification of of factors at the transcriptional and post-transcriptional
a key, but complex, role for apolipoprotein (apo) E in the levels (see below).
process. ApoE was first described by Shore and Shore [2] as
a lipoprotein constituent of triglyceride-rich very low den-
sity lipoproteins (VLDL). It has since been found to be a Structure of apoE
major component of several classes of plasma lipoproteins
and has been implicated in the maintenance of overall plas- ApoE contains two independently folded domains that are
ma cholesterol homeostasis by facilitating the hepatic uptake linked by a protease-sensitive loop [17]. The amino-ter-
of lipoproteins by binding to their receptors. The protein minal domain (residues 1–191) has an ordered structure
also carries out additional functions such as stimulation of consisting of four amphipathic α helix bundle (residues 24–
cholesterol efflux from macrophages, prevention of platelet 42, 54–81, 87–122 and 130–164, respectively) arranged in
aggregation, and inhibition of proliferation of T-lympho- an anti-parallel fashion with the hydrophobic faces orien-
cytes and endothelial cells. ApoE therefore plays a key pro- tated towards the interior of the bundle [18]. A short addi-
tective role in atherosclerosis. A number of polymorphisms tional helix (residues 44–53) connects helices 1 and 2. This
in the apoE gene have been identified, and the functional amino-terminal region contains the recognition sites for low-
consequences of these changes along with their association density lipoprotein (LDL) receptor (LDL-R) and LDL-R
with cardiovascular disease have been investigated. This related protein (LRP), with an arginine- and lysine-rich seg-
review describes the molecular and cell biology of apoE, the ment of helix 4 (residues 136–150) being essential for the
polymorphisms that have been identified and their con- interaction with the acidic residues of the receptors [17].
sequences, the multiple functions of the protein, and evi- The importance of these lysine or arginine residues for re-
dence supporting its key role in atherosclerosis. In addition, ceptor binding activity has been demonstrated by muta-
the regulation of apoE expression by factors implicated in genesis and chemical modification [17]. A region spanning
atherosclerosis is addressed. residues 171–183 also contains essential elements for sta-
bilization or alignment of the receptor binding domain [19].
Association with lipids is essential for apoE to recognize
Molecular and cell biology of apoE the LDL-R [17]. It has been proposed that upon binding to
lipids the amino-terminal helix bundle opens, thereby in-
Gene organization, synthesis and expression profile creasing exposure of lysines 143 and 146 to the aqueous
phase and triggering helix formation by amino acids 165–
The human apoE gene has been mapped to chromosome 19, 169 [20, 21]. In this confirmation the positive electrostatic
where it is located at the 5′ end of a 50-kb gene cluster with potential in the receptor-binding region of apoE is enhanced,
apoCI, an apo-CI pseudogene, apoCII and apoCIV [3]. The thus allowing its high affinity binding to the LDL-R [22].
apoE gene contains four exons separated by three introns The segment containing helix 4 also has a high-affinity
and specifies for a secretory protein that follows the classi- binding site for heparan-sulphate proteoglycans (HSPG)
cal pathway for secretory protein synthesis and release [4]. with the lysine- and arginine-rich residues interacting with
The primary translation product is 317 amino acids long and the negatively charged carboxylate and sulfate groups of
contains an 18 amino acid extension at the amino-terminus, proteoglycans [23, 24]. More recently the amino-terminal
which acts as a signal peptide that directs the nascent poly- region of apoE has been shown to contain the binding site
peptide chain to the endoplasmic reticulum [4]. The protein for scavenger receptor class B type and, as with LDL-R,
is then transported to the Golgi, where it undergoes O- lipidation enhances the interaction [25, 26].
linked glycosylation with the addition of carbohydrate The carboxyl-terminal region (residues 216–299) con-
chains containing sialic acid, prior to secretion [5]. The tains high-affinity lipid-binding sites and is also responsible
secretion of apoE is, however, a complex process. For ex- for the self-association of apoE in the absence of lipids [17].
ample, a significant proportion of newly synthesized apoE The structure of the carboxyl-terminus is currently poorly
331
understood but is believed to adopt an amphipathic α-helical gene frequencies in different populations see [48]). A
conformation, with a segment that coincides with the puta- second, non-genetically determined form of apoE polymor-
tive lipoprotein binding site having a high propensity to phism arises due to differential glycosylation [28]. Indeed,
form a coiled-coil [27]. Residues 243–272 are also thought several glycosylated isoforms of apoE exist mainly because
to bear a heparin-binding site [23]. of the different extent of sialization on the carbohydrate
chain added to threonine 194 [49]. Although sialated iso-
forms account for about 10–20% of plasma apoE, the func-
ApoE polymorphisms tional relevance of this modification remains currently
unclear. Whilst most apoE is secreted from hepatic cells in
Nature of polymorphisms the glycosylated form, glycolysation is not essential for the
synthesis or the secretion of the protein [50].
ApoE is a polymorphic protein with three common iso-
forms and more than 20 rare variants (Table 1) [28]. The
three most common polymorphisms are E2, E3 and E4, Functional consequences of genetically determined
which are the products of three alleles (ε2, ε3 and ε4) at a apoE polymorphisms
single gene locus [28]. ApoE3 (Cys112, Arg158) is consid-
ered to be the parent form and apoE4 (Arg112, Arg158) and Although the three common apoE isoforms differ from one
apoE2 (Cys112, Cys158) are variants [28]. Overall, six phe- another by only a single amino acid substitution, the changes
notypes are possible with their ranking from most to least have profound effects at the structural and functional level
common being E3/3, E4/3, E3/2, E4/4, E4/2 and E2/2 (for [28]. For example, the three isoforms exhibit different ther-
mal and chemical stabilities (apoE4<apoE3<apoE2) [51,
52]. In addition, the binding affinity of apoE2 for LDL-R is
Table 1 Rare variants of apoE
less than 2% of the affinity of apoE3 and apoE4 [53]. Such
Variant References reduced binding capability of apoE2 is because of the ab-
sence of a positive charge at position 158, which drastically
ApoE1 (Gly127→Asp, Arg158→Cys) 29 changes salt bridges within helix 4 and between helices 3
ApoE1Harrisburg (LyS146→Glu) 28 and 4 that are required to maintain the receptor binding
ApoE1Hammersmith (LyS146→Asn, Arg147→Trp) 30 region of the protein in a conformation that can interact ef-
ApoE1Baden (Arg180→Cys) 31 fectively with the receptor and, additionally, lowers the pos-
ApoE1 (Leu252→Glu) 32 itive ion potential of the receptor binding domain [53, 54].
ApoE2 (Arg136→Cys) 33 The binding properties of these apoE variants to lipoproteins
ApoE2Christchurch (Arg136→Ser) 34 also differ, with apoE3 and apoE2 preferentially binding to
ApoE2Heidelberg (Arg136→Cys) 35 high-density lipoprotein (HDL) and apoE4 to VLDL. Do-
ApoE2 (Arg142→Leu) 36 main interaction between the amino- and the carboxyl-ter-
ApoE2 (Arg142→Cys) 28 minal regions of apoE is responsible for such a difference
ApoE2 (Arg145→Cys) 28 [55, 56]. The substitution of cysteine 112 by arginine in
ApoE2Sendai (Arg145→Pro) 37 apoE4 causes a reorientation in the side chain of arginine
ApoE2 (Lys146→GIn) 28 61, allowing it to interact with glutamate 255 within the
ApoE2Dunedin (Arg228→Cys) 28 critical lipoprotein-binding region of the carboxyl terminus,
ApoE2 (Val236→Glu) 32 thereby leading to an alteration in conformation [55]. In
ApoE3 (Ala99→Thr, Ala152→Pro) 28 addition, the carboxyl-terminal domain becomes less or-
ApoE3-Leiden (Cys112→Arg; residues 121–127a) 28 ganized, which results in a significantly higher affinity for
ApoE3 (Cys112→Arg, Arg142→Cys) 28 lipids and therefore the preferential association with VLDL
ApoE3 (Cys112→Arg, Arg142→Gly) 29 [56].
ApoE3 (Arg136→Ser) 38 A number of studies investigating the role of apoE on the
ApoE3 (Arg145→His) 39 normal variation of its own expression and that of plasma
ApoE3 (Arg251→Gly) 32 lipids have also revealed isoform-specific differences. Thus,
ApoE3′(Arg136→His) 40 compared to apoE3, apoE2 tends to be associated with de-
ApoE4Philadelphia (Glu13→Lys, Arg145→Cys) 41
creased levels of apoB and cholesterol and increased levels
ApoE4Freiburg (Leu28→Pro) 42
of apoE and triglycerides [57]. On the other hand, apoE4 is
ApoE5 (Glu3→Lys) 43
associated with increased apoB and cholesterol levels and
decreased apoE levels [57]. The mechanisms that are re-
ApoE5 (Glu13→Lys) 44
sponsible for such changes are currently poorly understood
ApoE5 (Pro84→Arg, Cys112→Arg) 43
except for the variation in cholesterol levels, where an ac-
ApoE5 (GIn204→Lys, Cys112→Arg) 45
tion on hepatic LDL-R levels is likely to make a major
ApoE5 (Glu212→Lys) 46
contribution [57]. ApoE4 preferentially distributes to triglyc-
ApoE7 Suita (Glu244, 245→Lys) 47
eride-rich lipoproteins and accelerates its uptake, thereby
a
Seven amino acid insertionthat is a tandem repeat of residues leading to down-regulation of hepatic LDL-R expression
121–127 and increased levels of LDL [57–59]. On the other hand, the
332
lower affinity of apoE2 for LDL-R would decrease cellular heart disease whereas the ε2 allele had no significant asso-
cholesterol influx and lead to lower intracellular levels of ciation [61]. Several other studies have demonstrated a
the sterol and up regulation of LDL-R [57–59]. context dependency of apoE genotype on cardiovascular
disease risk. An emerging pattern is that the association of
the ε4 allele with risk is present in individuals who smoke
ApoE polymorphisms and pathophysiological [67–69].
conditions In addition to cardiovascular disease, apoE polymor-
phisms have been investigated as a risk factor for other
The association between homozygous ε2 phenotype, in pathophysiological conditions, including Alzheimer’s dis-
which the protein is defective in binding to lipoprotein re- ease (AD), Parkinson’s disease, diabetes, renal disease, stroke,
ceptors, and type III hyperlipoproteinaemia is well docu- schizophrenia, and cancer [48, 57, 61, 62, 70, 71]. From
mented [57]. This disorder is characterized by increased these, the action of apoE and its polymorphisms on neuro-
triglyceride and cholesterol levels, presence of β-VLDL, nal function and AD has been the subject of intense research
cholesterol-rich remnants of chylomicrons and VLDL, in a number of laboratories. A detailed description of the
xanthomas and premature cardiovascular disease [57]. How- current literature on this topic is beyond the scope of this
ever, more than 90% of homozygous E2 individuals have review, where the focus is on the role of apoE in athero-
either normal or low cholesterol levels [57]. Thus the action sclerosis. The readers are therefore directed to recent re-
of other secondary hormonal, environmental and/or genetic views [70, 71]. Briefly, apoE is expressed at high levels in
factors is required for overt type III hyperlipoproteinae- the brain, where it acts as a principal lipid transport protein
mia [57, 60]. It is interesting that some of the rare apoE in the cerebrospinal fluid [57, 70, 71]. Furthermore, the
variants (see Table 1) are associated either with dominant expression of apoE is induced during peripheral nerve in-
type III hyperlipoproteinaemia or hypertriglyceridaemia jury, where it is involved in the repair process by redis-
[57, 60]. Such dominant variants of apoE include apoE3- tributing lipids to regenerating neurons and Schwann cells,
Leiden, apoE2 (Lys146→Gln), apoE3 (Cys112→Arg, and additionally it modulates neurite extension and cy-
Arg142→Cys), apoE4 (Glu13→Lys, Arg145→Cys), apoE2 toskeletal function [57, 70, 71]. Both clinical and epide-
(Arg145→Cys), apoE1 (Lys146→Glu) and apoE1 (Lys146→ miological studies have uncovered a strong correlation
Asn, Arg147→Trp) [28, 30, 41]. In most cases the mutations between apoE variants and the development of AD, with
involve substitution of lysine or arginine in the cluster of the ε4 allele accounting for over one-half of AD cases in
basic amino acids in the receptor/heparin-binding region of the United States and the rarity of the disease in carriers
the protein (residues 136–150) by a neutral or acidic amino of the ε2 allele [57, 70, 71]. Such an isoform-specific ac-
acid. tion has also been shown in a mouse model of AD [72].
A number of studies have investigated the impact of apoE A number of potential mechanisms have been proposed
polymorphisms on cardiovascular disease, often yielding for the contribution of apoE4 to the pathogenesis of AD,
conflicting results (for recent reviews see [48, 61, 62]). including the regulation of deposition and clearance of
Differences in study design, geographic and ethnic back- amyloid β peptides and formation of plaques, altered phos-
ground, allele frequency, sex, and potential gene-gene and phorylation of the microtubule-associated protein tau and
gene-environment interactions are likely to have contrib- the formation of neurofibrillary tangles, modulation of neu-
uted to such conflicting results [61]. In addition, apoE ronal signalling pathways, disruption of cytoskeletal struc-
genotypes have also been found to potentially affect life ture and function, and impairment of the anti-oxidative
expectancy [62]. Although several, but not all, studies link defence system [57, 70–73].
the ε4 allele with greater risk for cardiovascular disease, the
relationship with respect to the ε2 allele remains in com-
plete [48, 57, 61, 62]. For example, a study of middle-aged Interaction of apoE polymorphisms with other genes
men from nine populations estimated a 40% greater risk for and environmental factors
mortality from coronary heart disease for carriers of the ε4
allele than ε2 carriers or individuals with the ε3/ε3 geno- Several studies have also investigated the interaction be-
type [63]. In addition, populations with higher cholesterol tween apoE polymorphisms and diet, smoking, gender, al-
levels and higher coronary heart disease mortality rates cohol consumption, obesity, weight gain, physical inactivity,
have a greater risk of the ε4 allele [48, 57, 63–65]. A meta- cholesterol lowering drugs and other genetic factors [48, 61,
analysis of 14 published studies in 1996 reported that 62, 67–69, 74–84]. A large number of such association
compared with carriers of the ε3/3 genotype those with ε4/4 studies have also often produced conflicting findings [48,
had a higher risk for developing coronary heart disease, and 57, 61, 62]. For example, in relation to lipid-lowering drugs
that the ε2 allele was not associated with such a risk [66]. Gerdes et al. [78] reported that ε4 carriers had a greater
However, numerous other studies have been performed reduction in mortality in response to simvastatin than non-ε4
thereafter with conflicting results (see [61] and references carriers. On the other hand, a meta-analysis study in 1995
therein). A comprehensive recent meta-analysis of 48 pub- [79] showed that apoE genetic variations had a significant
lished studies comprising 15,492 case patients and 32,965 impact on the lowering of LDL cholesterol by 3-hydroxy-3-
controls concluded that compared to the ε3/3 genotype methylgluaryl coenzyme A reductase inhibitors, with ε2
carriers of the ε4 allele had a 42% higher risk for coronary carriers being more responsive than ε4 carriers or ε3/ε3
333
subjects. A number of other studies, however, have failed to apoE-deficient mice using a retroviral transduction system
find such an association between apoE genotype and lipid- leads to reduced early foam cell lesion formation [100]. It
lowering agents [80–82]. should, however, be noted that there are studies which have
seen normalization of cholesterol levels by expression of
macrophage-derived apoE [102, 103]. In conclusion, both
Role of apoE in atherosclerosis hepatic- and macrophage-derived apoE can have anti-ath-
erogenic effects through beneficial changes in plasma lipids
Several lines of evidence have implicated a potent anti- and direct action on and from within the artery wall.
atherogenic role of apoE. Thus depressed expression of
apoE in humans has been found to be associated with a pro-
atherogenic lipoprotein profile and diffuse atherosclerotic Anti-atherogenic role of apoE through the regulation
disease [85, 86]. In addition, apoE knockout (apoE−/−) mice of lipoprotein metabolism and transport
are severely hypercholesterolaemic compared to the wild-
type counterparts, and the increase in cholesterol is largely Figure 1 summarizes the various anti-atherogenic actions of
distributed in lower density lipoproteins due to their im- apoE. Its central role in the regulation of overall lipoprotein
paired clearance [87–89]. The accumulation of remnant metabolism and transport is clearly a major contributor for
lipoproteins in such cases leads to the development of com- the anti-atherogenic function. Firstly, apoE mediates the
plex atherosclerotic lesions, which develop even when the uptake and degradation of lipoproteins through its ability to
mice are fed a low fat diet [87, 88, 89]. Atherosclerosis bind with high affinity to the LDL-R on parenchymal liver
in apoE-null mice has been shown to be prevented by in- cells [57]. As detailed above, the importance of such an
creasing circulating apoE levels through either recombinant interaction is underscored by the massive accumulation of
adenovirus-mediated gene transfer to the liver [90, 91], ex- lipoproteins and lipoprotein remnants in the plasma of pa-
pression of apoE transgenes [92], or injection of synthetic tients with type III hyperlipoproteinaemia, where apoE2
apoE peptide mimics [93]. which is defective in LDL-R binding, is present [28]. Sec-
ApoE expression is absent in normal vessels but high in ondly, apoE also binds to another hepatic receptor, LRP,
atherosclerotic plaques, and although the protein can enter and this has been implicated in the clearance of chylomicron
the artery wall from the periphery, it is believed to be mainly remnants [104, 105]. The clearance of chylomicron rem-
synthesized locally by resident macrophages [94]. As nants also involves the binding of apoE to HSPG, as demon-
monocytes/macrophages are the only haematopoietic cells strated by studies using heparinase treated cells and infusion
that express apoE, bone marrow transplantation has been of heparinase in mice [104]. Thirdly, apoE is able to directly
used largely to investigate the role of macrophage-derived stimulate hepatic VLDL and triglyceride production, and
apoE on atherosclerosis in vivo. Such studies have shown studies on apoE-deficient mouse hepatocytes have demon-
that macrophage-derived apoE exerts anti-atherogenic prop- strated impaired secretion of VLDL triglycerides [106].
erties largely independently of its effects on plasma lipid Consistent with this finding, increased VLDL production is
levels [95–97]. Approaches other than bone marrow trans- seen in hepatocytes stably transfected with human apoE or
plantation have also confirmed the anti-atherogenic role of in apoE3 transgenic mice [107]. Fourthly, apoE stimulates
apoE expressed in the vessel wall [98–101]. Thus, trans- reverse cholesterol transport, in which excess cholesterol
genic mice expressing human apoE in the vessel wall show in peripheral tissues is transported back to the liver, via a
reduced atherosclerotic lesions in the absence of any changes process involving HDL, for excretion through bile forma-
in plasma cholesterol and lipoprotein profile [98]. In ad- tion [57]. Finally, apoE activates enzymes involved in lipo-
dition, expression of low levels of apoE in the artery wall of protein metabolism such as hepatic lipase, cholesteryl ester
transfer protein and lecithin:cholesterol acyltransferase surrounding cells of the vessel wall, which then contribute
[108–110]. to its atheroprotective role. For example, apoE inhibits
The process of cholesterol efflux is particularly important platelet aggregation by interacting with a specific cell sur-
in maintaining cholesterol homeostasis in cells that are in- face receptor, the apoE receptor 2 (apoER2) [122, 123].
capable of limiting their uptake of lipids, such as macro- This interaction initiates a signalling cascade leading to the
phages, and is vital in the prevention of foam cell formation activation of nitric oxide synthase [123]. ApoE also inhibits
and atherogenesis [111]. A key role of apoE in stimulating the expression of vascular cell adhesion molecule 1 on en-
macrophage cholesterol efflux has emerged from a number dothelial cells [124] again via interaction with apoER2 and
of studies. For example, the capacity of apoE-depleted HDL stimulation of endothelial NO production [125]. It has been
from humans or mice to promote cholesterol efflux from proposed that tyrosine phosphorylation of apoER2 in this
mouse peritoneal macrophages is decreased and can be case initiates phosphoinositide-3-kinase signalling leading
restored to normal by the addition of exogenous apoE [112]. to activation of NO synthase [125]. ApoE can also suppress
In addition, the apoE genotype has a profound effect on the the activation and proliferation of T lymphocytes [126–
efficiency of cholesterol efflux [113]. The expression of en- 128]. Such an anti-proliferative effect of apoE is thought to
dogenous apoE also enhances cholesterol efflux [114, 115], be due to inhibition of critical signalling events such as
and the experimental characteristics of cholesterol efflux in intracellular calcium accumulation and phosphatidylinosi-
such cases can be distinguished from those produced by the tol turnover [127]. This inhibition of early signalling is
exogenous addition of lipid free apoE [116]. The precise manifested downstream by a reduction in interleukin 2 ex-
mechanisms by which endogenous apoE stimulates cho- pression [128], which consequently arrests the lymphocytes
lesterol efflux currently remains unclear, although its reten- at the G1A/G1B boundary in the cell cycle [129]. ApoE also
tion at the cell surface via association with proteoglycans inhibits SMC migration and proliferation induced by agents
makes a contribution [117]. ApoE arrives at the cell surface such as serum, platelet-derived growth factor and oxidized
in a relatively lipid-poor state, and conformation changes LDL [130–132]. It was reported that the inhibition of SMC
attained during lipidation may cause its release [117]. In proliferation is mediated through the activation of NO
addition, apoE held in the proximity to the plasma mem- synthase triggered by the interaction of apoE with HSPG
brane by proteoglycan binding could facilitate passive de- [130, 131]. More recently, however, Kothapalli et al. [132]
sorption of lipid from the plasma membrane, a process that showed that the anti-mitogenic effect maps to the amino-
may involve scavenger receptor class B type I or ATP- terminal receptor-binding domain of the protein and in-
binding cassette transporter A1 (ABCA1) [118, 119]. In- volves stimulation of cyclooxygenase-2 expression leading
deed, it has been shown that apoE is an acceptor for free to prostacyclin synthesis and inhibition of cyclin A gene
cholesterol and phospholipid released from macrophages expression. The precise reason(s) for the different mecha-
by ABCA1, and that lipid-free apoE is able to interact with nisms identified remains unclear but may be related to the
ABCA1 in vitro [119]. nature of the mitogen employed [132]. In contrast to pro-
liferation, apoE inhibition of SMC migration appears to be
mediated by LRP-1, is independent of NO synthase, and
Other anti-atherogenic functions of apoE requires activation of the cAMP-dependent protein kinase
A [130–133]. ApoE is also able to inhibit lipid oxidation
As described above, a number of studies have shown that [134], which may thereby prevent the accumulation of
reduced expression of apoE in the vessel wall can accelerate oxidized LDL. Indeed, evidence of enhanced oxidative
atherosclerosis, whereas low expression of the protein in stress has been found in apoE-deficient mice along with
apoE knockout mice is able to limit the development of the LDL oxidation specific epitopes in the aortic lesions [135].
disease in the absence of any detectable changes in plasma In addition, Hayek et al. [112] have shown that circulating
cholesterol levels or lipoprotein profile [95–101]. This lipoproteins in apoE-deficient mice are more oxidized and
suggests an additional anti-atherogenic role of apoE that is more susceptible to oxidation in vitro than lipoproteins from
independent of its action on cholesterol metabolism and the wild-type animals. Although the mechanism is not com-
transport. More recently further support to this proposition pletely understood, it has been shown that apoE can bind
has been provided by the studies of Thorngate et al. [120] metal ions (copper and iron), possibly sequestering them
who demonstrated that low-level of apoE expression is able and preventing their participation in the oxidation process
to inhibit atherogenesis using a mechanism independent of [134]. Finally, a fraction of macrophage-secreted apoE be-
stimulation of cholesterol efflux. In addition, low levels of comes sequestered within the pericellular proteoglycan
extrahepatic, non-macrophage apoE was found to inhibit matrix where, in addition to influencing the uptake and
atherosclerosis in transgenic apoE-deficient mice without retention of atherogenic lipoproteins into the vessel wall,
correcting hypercholesterolaemia [121]. A number of anti- it can modulate the availability of cytokines and growth
atherogenic properties of apoE that are independent of factors retained within it [136]. Such an action of apoE is
direct involvement in lipid metabolism and transport have likely to make a major contribution to its ability to inhibit
been identified, and are discussed below in detail. endothelial cell proliferation [136].
The apoE expressed by macrophages has been found
to exhibit local cytokine- and hormonal-like effects on the
335
Regulation of apoE gene expression and factors that are involved in such regulation have been
the focus of research in a number of laboratories. The
The human apoE, apoCI, apoCIV and apoCII genes are proximal promoter region of apoE has been implicated
closely linked and are located on the long arm of chromo- in the induction of gene expression during macrophage
some 19, spanning a region of 45 kb. ApoE gene expression differentiation and regulation by cAMP [138, 158]. Thus
is extremely complex with regulation in a tissue-specific Basheeruddin et al. [158] showed that the −623 to −447
manner and in response to cellular changes and extracel- promoter region is necessary for transcriptional activation
lular/intracellular factors (Table 2). For example, the differ- during induced differentiation of human THP-1 monocytes
entiation of monocytes into macrophages is accompanied into macrophages. This study suggested that activator pro-
by increased apoE expression [145]. In addition, cholesterol tein 1-like transcription factors were involved, possibly due
loading of macrophages leads to a marked increase in apoE to 12-O-tetradecanoylphorbol-13-acetate activating the pro-
gene transcription [13, 143]. Oxidized forms of cholesterol tein kinase C pathway which is known to regulate these
such as those present in foam cells (e.g. oxysterol deriva- DNA binding proteins [158]. Andreani-Mangeney et al.
tives) also modulate apoE expression [143, 153, 154]. The [138] have shown that cAMP inhibits apoE gene transcrip-
inflammatory response also has a profound effect on the tion in HepG2 cells, which is mediated via elements located
expression of apoE. For example, bacterial lipopolysac- between −614 to −804 in the promoter region. Interestingly,
charide decreases apoE expression in mouse macrophages this study also showed that a promoter region containing the
when added exogenously or injected in vivo [141]. ApoE −201/−1 region was activated only by cAMP, thereby in-
production by macrophages is also inhibited by interferon γ dicating a more complex regulation by this factor. Garcia
[144], interleukin 1 [146] and granulocyte colony-stimulat- et al. [140] have identified the transcription factor activator
ing factor [141, 142] and activated by tumour necrosis fac- protein 2, which interacts with the −48 to −74 and −107 to
tor α [157] and transforming growth factor β ([142] and −135 regions of human apoE, as a mediator of synergistic
our unpublished observations). Other agents that modulate activation by cAMP and retinoic acid. It was suggested that
apoE expression include cAMP [138–140], thyroid hor- protein kinase A mediated phosphorylation of activator
mone [156], insulin [148], and oestrogen [147]. protein 2 is likely to play an important role [140]. Trans-
Transcriptional regulation plays a key role in the mod- fection assays using manipulated promoter-reporter gene
ulation of apoE gene expression, and the sequence elements constructs, DNase I and in vivo footprinting, cell-free tran-
scription assays, and yeast one-hybrid system have iden-
Table 2 Regulators of apoE gene expression tified several other transcription factors that interact with
the proximal promoter region (SP1, HNF-3, HNF-4, TF-
Activators LF2, GATA-1, CCAAT/enhancer binding protein, BEF-1,
Apolipoprotein AI 137 Aa, B1b, B2b, Zic1 and Zic2) [159].
cAMP (macrophages, astrocytoma) 139, 140 Polymorphisms in the proximal promoter region of the
Cholesterol/stero loading 9, 13, 143 apoE gene have been described at positions −491 A/T, −427
Differentiation of monocytes to macrophages 145 T/C and −219 G/T [160]. A C/G polymorphism has also
Oestrogen 147 been identified at position +113, which corresponds to an
Expression of ATP-binding cassette transporters A1 139 enhancer element in intron 1 [161]. Such polymorphisms
and 8 are associated with variations in the transcriptional activity.
Glucocorticoids 150 For example, −219G allele shows higher transcriptional
High-density lipoprotein 111 activity than −219T, and the −491T allele shows lower
Oleic acid 152 transcriptional activity than −491A in transfected HepG2
Oxysterol ligands 153 cells and astrocytomas [160, 162]. It is believed that dif-
Oxidized low-density lipoprotein 154 ferential binding of nuclear proteins is responsible for the
Peroxisome proliferator activated receptor γ 155 altered transcriptional activity produced by these polymor-
activators phisms [160, 163]. Indeed, a European population study has
Retinoic acid 140 found an association between the −219G/T polymorphism
Transforming growth factor β 142 with differential plasma apoE levels [164]. The −219T allele
Thyroid hormone 156 was associated with an increased risk of myocardial in-
Tumour necrosis factor α 157 farction and premature coronary heart disease [164, 165]. In
Inhibitors addition, the −219G/T polymorphism has been found to
cAMP (hepatocytes) 138 influence triacylglycerol-rich lipoprotein metabolism dur-
Granulocyte-macrophage colony-stimulating factor 141, 142
ing the postprandial period, thereby prolonging postpran-
Interferon γ 144
dial lipaemia in individuals with the TT genotype [166].
Interleukin 1 146
The −491A/T polymorphism has also been shown to mod-
ulate the lipid-lowering efficiency of atorvastatin and beza-
Insulin 148
fibrate in combined hyperlipidaemia treatment [167]. Finally,
Lipoprotein lipase 149
a relationship between the polymorphisms and risk for AD
Lipopolysaccharide 141
has also been identified [71, 162, 163].
Statins 151
336
Despite the identification of the regulatory sequences and lesterol and activation of protein kinase A with the cAMP
the polymorphisms detailed above, it has been found that analogue 8-bromo-cAMP stimulates the secretion of apoE
the proximal promoter region of the apoE gene lacks the [113, 139]. ApoE secretion is also increased by acceptors of
ability to direct gene transcription in vivo in any cell of cholesterol in the efflux process (e.g. apoAI, HDL) at the
transgenic mice in the absence of the distal enhancers [168]. post-transcriptional level [111, 137]. On the other hand,
Hepatocyte expression of apoE is controlled by two cell- apoE secretion from macrophages is inhibited by interferon
specific enhancers, hepatic control regions (HCR) 1 and 2, γ due to increased intracellular degradation of newly syn-
which are located 15 kb (HCR.1) and 26 kb (HCR.2) 3′ to thesized protein [144]. ABCA1 and to a lesser extent ATP-
the apoE gene [168]. HCR.1 and HCR.2 share 87% se- binding cassette transporter 8, both of which are important
quence identity, thereby suggesting that they have probably regulators of cholesterol efflux, have also been shown to
arisen as a result of an evolutionary gene duplication that modulate apoE secretion from human monocyte-derived
yielded the apoCI and apoCI′ genes [168]. More recently, macrophages [139]. As cholesterol loading and cAMP treat-
downstream enhancer sequences have been identified that ment up-regulate ABCA1 expression in macrophages [139,
direct apoE expression in astrocytes, skin, macrophages and 175], it is likely that this plays a role in the intracellular
adipocytes [169–171]. In the case of adipocytes and macro- trafficking of apoE. Indeed, inhibition of ABCA1 leads to
phages, two homologous enhancers, designated multi-en- the disappearance of apoE-containing granular structures
hancer (ME) 1 and 2, are essential [171]. These are located from the plasma membrane [139]. More recently, oleic acid
3.3 kb (ME1) and 15.9 kb (ME2) downstream of the apoE has been shown to induce apoE secretion in macrophages
gene and contain 620 and 619 nucleotides, respectively [171]. by modulating the post-translational glycosylation of the
Several binding motifs for the glucocorticoid receptor and protein [152].
CCAAT/enhancer binding proteins α and β has been lo- There is an optimal concentration of plasma apoE that is
cated in these enhancer regions although their precise roles required for lipoprotein clearance, and too little or too much
remain to be fully investigated [171]. Interestingly, the ME1 of the protein can be detrimental. For instance, over expres-
and ME2 enhancers along with the promoter also contain a sion of human apoE3 in apoE-deficient mice at concentra-
conserved liver–X receptor responsive elements that medi- tions greater than 30 mg/ml leads to hypertriglyceridaemia
ate activation of gene transcription in response to oxysterol because of elevation in hepatic VLDL triglyceride produc-
ligands in macrophages, but not monocytes [153]. Finally, tion and interference with VLDL lipolysis [176]. The body
Galetto et al. [155] has identified a peroxisome proliferator is able to regulate and maintain optimal levels of apoE, and
activated receptor γ response element within the apoE/ recent studies have provided novel insights into the recy-
apoCI intergenic sequence, the mutation of which abolishes cling of apoE. When radiolabelled triglyceride-rich lipopro-
the induction of expression by the activator ciglitazone. teins were employed to evaluate intracellular catabolism,
Overall, therefore, it is clear from all these studies that sub- more than one-half of the labelled apoE was released back
stantially more research needs to be carried out to precisely to the medium, where it again became part of lipoproteins
delineate the role of each of the sequence elements iden- [10]. Thus a substantial amount of the internalized lipo-
tified in the proximal and distal regions. In addition, the protein-associated apoE is retained inside the cell and then
signalling pathways associated with changes in apoE ex- reappears in the secretion medium. Such recycling has been
pression are poorly understood and need to be elucidated in seen in macrophages, hepatocytes and fibroblasts [10–12,
detail. 177]. Internalized apoE has been shown to escape the lyso-
Post-transcriptional mechanisms have also been found somal degradation pathway [177, 178], thereby suggest-
to be involved in the regulation of apoE expression. For ing the existence of an active cellular mechanism that
example, Basheeruddin et al. [172] have shown that apoE maintains apoE levels by dissociating the ligand from the
mRNA is degraded more slowly in macrophages than in lipoprotein particle and carry apoE back to the secretory
monocytes due to inhibition of a specific nuclease. In ad- apparatus. The precise molecular mechanisms responsible
dition, a substantial amount of newly synthesized apoE for apoE recycling remains to be deciphered, but the pres-
in macrophages is degraded prior to secretion due to either ence of internalized apoE has been demonstrated in Golgi
direct targetting of apoE to lysosomal pathways [173] or apparatus rich fractions isolated from mouse liver [178,
ubiquitinated-mediated proteasomal degradation [174]. Fur- 179]. More recently Farkas et al. [180] have investigated the
thermore, the segregation of cell-surface apoE between mechanism in detail and shown that apoE recycling can
secretion and degradation pathways is modulated by the occur in the absence of LDL-R or under conditions of dras-
presence of extracellular lipids, for example, phospholipid tically reduced LRP expression and also in the absence of an
vesicles or lipoproteins [6]. Duan et al. [13] have also dem- intact Golgi apparatus. Additionally, recycling occurs even
onstrated that pre-incubation of macrophages with sterol when apoE lacks its lipoprotein binding domain at the car-
increases secretion of apoE to the medium in part due to the boxyl terminus. It was therefore concluded that apoE recy-
suppression of apoE degradation, a process that requires the cling occurs through multiple redundant pathways [180].
carboxyl-terminal domain of the protein. A number of other Interestingly, HDL not only acts as an extracellular acceptor
agents have also been shown to stimulate apoE secretion, for recycled apoE but also stimulates the recycling of inter-
although the molecular mechanisms remain to be deci- nalized triglyceride-rich lipoprotein-derived apoE [12].
phered in detail. For example, enrichment of cells with cho-
337