Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Blood of The Martyrs BW
Blood of The Martyrs BW
Blood of The Martyrs BW
3
The Blood of the Martyrs
After the brutal butchering of our them. This is a very material truth,
queer siblings in Orlando, we are all not a magical fairy tale. Martyrs who
mourning. Their lives were ended have been killed on their path to
because a homophobic fascist, who Allah, remain for ever there in our
claimed to be Muslim, decided that memory, as eternal witnesses against
they had no right to live. The the crimes that were committed
families of these martyrs will miss against them, against humanity and
them. Nobody had expected them to be against Allah.
slaughtered, when they were only out Hussayn(pbuh), the grandson of our
looking for love, joy and a bit of beloved prophet Muhammed(pbuh), was
fun. This senseless attack once again murdered by the army of the oppressor
reminds us how violent this world has Yazid. He had refused to pledge
become. We mourn even more when we allegiance to this new self declared
realise that these attacks are daily the new ruler of the Muslim world.
business in many countries in the The ruler understood that this
Muslim World. refusal was a strong sign. Hussayn's
Allah subhanahu wa ta’ala understands acts showed that a true Muslim should
our mourning and wants to console us. never accept the authorities of
He tells us that the martyrs are not unjust rulers. He preferred serving
really dead, they live on for ever. Allah and striving for righteousness
The murderers can only kill our than serving a ruler and striving for
bodies, but our souls live on for power and wealth. He would rather
ever. live free on the difficult path of
Martyrdom Allah than rot on the shiny path of
the hypocrites and the rulers. He
What is a martyr? Why do we call our fully understand what this choice
siblings who were butchered by that implied in a world that is governed
name? What does the word mean? The by a brutal dictatorial regime:
Greek word μάρτυρός (martyros) choosing a life of struggle for
literally means 'witness'. It has the freedom means choosing to be killed
same range of meanings as the Arabic on the path of Allah rather than
word ( شهيدshahid). A martyr is living to obey a human ruler.
someone who is willing to make his
Martyrdom is one of the miracles of
whole life a testimony of his faith.
religion. It shows the paradox that
Every thing they say and do becomes a
in order to have a full life, we may
sign of their love for Allah. A
one day loose our lives in the
martyr remains a witness of Allah,
process. Martyrdom shows us that the
even in face of persecution, torture
death of our bodies does not have to
and death.
mean the death of everything. Today,
Martyrdom is not some kind of fourteen centuries after the murder
military strategy, it has nothing to of Hussayn, his martyrdom is still
do with suicide attacks against remembered by millions. By killing
innocent people. Martyrdom is not his body, the army of the oppressor
born from a perverted desire to kill has freed his spirit and made him a
and die. It is not born from a love source of inspiration for us, the
for death, suffering and destruction. ones who are still here.
Martyrdom arises from the will to
We often forget how important the
live to the fullest and to engage
living martyrs are, those who are
that life in the struggle for justice
witnesses but have not been
and peace. Martyrdom is the fruit of
slaughtered. Martyrdom means living
our desire to live and let others
on the path of Allah, that is the
live, even if that desire kills us.
essence of it. It means making your
The Holy Quran explains that the whole life a testimony of your
martyrs who were killed on the path devotion. We don't need dictators,
of Allah are not really dead. They terrorists or fascist butchers to
live on for ever and Allah cares for become martyrs. All we need is to be
4
Muslims, to surrender our selves to no The blood of the Martyrs
other than Allah and engage ourselves Archbishop Oscar Romero of San
in a struggle to do good and stop Salvador was a strong supporter of the
evil. dictatorial regime that ruled his
When Hussayn was murdered, part of his country. He was blind to the suffering
family was spared. His sister of the poor and the oppressed, didn’t
Zaynab(pbuh) had been a witness to the see their poverty and their suffering.
whole massacre, but she survived. Because he couldn’t see the misery of
After being captured by the army and his people, he was also unable to
brought to the capital Damascus, she understand their struggle against
started telling the story of how her poverty and exploitation, injustice
brother was killed, how the army of and oppression. He was especially
the oppressors had murdered the annoyed when priests, monks or nuns
grandson of the prophet of Islam. Her joined this uprising of the poor.
testimony, told and retold time after All that changed when the killing
time, destroyed the Islamic mask of squads murdered two of these
the tyrant and his regime. rebellious priests in front of him.
In every generation there are rebels, This cruel act of the barbarians, the
people who transcend the lives of senseless butchering of two men who
their contemporaries and who inspire tried to testify of God’s Love for
them to struggle for a better world. humanity, opened his eyes. The blood
In every generation there are of the martyrs had healed his eyes. He
oppressors who find no other answer to could no longer remain blind for the
this struggle than power, violence, crimes of the rulers. The death of
torture and murder. In every these innocents had stirred a new life
generation there are those who escape in him.
the massacres and who live to be From then on Oscar Romero became a
witnesses. voice for the voiceless. He became one
In our generation we have social of the strongest and most stubborn
media. Never before have so many of champions of the poor and the
our sisters and brothers had access to oppressed.
a global stage to speak their own Today, just a few days after the
mind. This means that today, for every fascist attack in Orlando, we see that
modern day Hussayn who is killed by a the blood of the fifty queer martyrs
modern day Yazid, there are thousands seems to have the same healing powers
of modern day Zaynabs. For every to the eyes of thousands of our Muslim
brutal slaughtering of the innocents, sisters and brothers. They find it
there are thousands who condemn it, hard to remain blind for the
who live to testify and tell and homophobia that still exists in our
retell the story. Ummah. They start to understand how
5
homophobic thoughts and words spread Our so called leaders
through the Ummah as a pandemic It has been a tradition for centuries
disease, how these hateful words and that certain people appoint themselves
thoughts produce hateful actions. as religious leaders of the Muslim
Some of our sisters and brothers have community. It is not always clear in
been our allies for years. They have what way they are leading the
fought with us for queer rights under community, or what part of that
all possible circumstances. Some have community they are speaking about.
supported us as friends, but were There is also no clear reason why
afraid to speak out against the these brothers (usually they are
oppression we were facing. Today i see brothers, hardly any of them are
many of them breaking their silence sisters and I have no knowledge of
and saying out-loud what they have transgendered siblings claiming this
been whispering all those years. Still leadership over the community) would
others have always had the idea that have the right to appoint themselves
we exaggerate. They may have found as leaders. No matter how many
some truth in the homophobic words of arguments we may find to be sceptical
the haters and they were doubting if about their leadership, it is clear
we were sinners and if the homophobes that through this claim, they have a
weren't correct in their actions. The strong influence on many Muslims.
bullets from the gun of the homophobic In the last few days we have seen many
fascist in Orlando have shattered that of them reacting to the Orlando
doubt for some of them. Seeing the massacre in one of the ways that we
bloody consequences of homophobia has described above. Some have always been
given them a deeper understanding of allies and now try to find ways to
the hatred they had doubts about. strengthen our alliance. Some were
Not all the eyes in the Ummah will be silent but had sympathy, but now speak
healed by this blood. Some of our out in support of us. Some were
brothers and sisters are blind and homophobes, but the attack opened
they will remain blind. Some of the their eyes. Others now plainly deny
homophobes will be intimidated by what that they ever were homophobes,
happened. They will not change their joining the ranks of the hypocrites.
views, but will be more afraid to We should not dismiss the slight shift
voice them. Not so long ago they that was caused by the attacks. All
believed that the Ummah was united in over the world, Muslim leaders have
it's homophobia, now they start to made small steps that brought them a
perceive the diversity that exists. little bit closer to openness,
They have lost their false sense of acceptance, solidarity and equality.
security. Others will even turn to Many of our so called leaders are less
hypocrisy and pretend to be our homophobic today than they were before
allies. Even though, in their heart, the shooting. Especially in the West
they still despise us, they no longer we have seen several declarations,
feel safe to express this. joint statements and fatawa by central
Some of our extremist sisters and Muslim organisations and their
(mostly) brothers will react by even representatives, condemning the
strengthening their homophobic attacks and the homophobia that caused
behaviour. They will feast in the it.
blood of the martyrs, praise the However, we queer Muslims should also
fascist who killed them and call upon know that these declarations will
the Ummah to copy this attack. Their remain dead words if there is no real
hatred against queers is so deep, that change within the communities. We
they have lost touch with that which accept the sympathy, the condolences,
makes them human. We must learn to the messages of support from our
search for the root causes of their religious leaders, but it is far from
hatred and find ways to heal them, but enough.
in the mean time we must do all we can
to protect ourselves and our Some scholars have condemned the
communities against the harm these murder of innocent people in a bar in
extremists may cause. Orlando, but they forget to mention
that this was a queer bar and the
people who were killed were queer people.
6
The vast majority of Muslims would never
accept the lawfulness of an active
homosexual lifestyle.(...) But there is also no
authority in the tradition for any individual to
take things into his own hands and impose
their version of the religion on someone else.
They don't forget to mention that the Some of our leaders point out that the
killer was probably not a good Muslim, homophobe killer seems to have been
that drank alcohol, frequented bars gay himself. They say that this murder
and didn't pray at regular times. was a deliberate act by a gay man in
Others don't forget to mention the order to create more sympathy for
innocent victims were queer and they queers in the Ummah. They claim that
offer their sincere condolences to the this attack is an attack by Western
queer community, but they stress the secret forces, together with the queer
fact that these queers were (in their community, to further the so called
head) not Muslim. They tolerate queer homosexual agenda and to undermine
lifestyles for unbelievers, but repeat Islam.
the lie that it is a sin for Muslim It is a disgrace that the Ummah still
queers to live the way Allah has accepts bigots like these to represent
created them. us and claim the leadership over our
Some so called leaders condemn the community. They claim that they are
attacks in Orlando, not so much defending the Islam, but they are
because queers were killed, but really trying to strangle and destroy
because they believe that an Islamic it. They want Islam to change from a
State should kill us, not some living religion of diversity and
vigilante. They believe themselves to creativity into a dead regime of
be morally superior to the fascist conformism. How could anybody claim to
vigilante homophobe killer, because defend Islam while attacking the lives
their homophobe murders would be of millions of queer Muslims?
carried out by a fascist state, not an
individual.
7
Creation = transformation
It is important to understand that
the fascist killer was not doing
the work of Allah. Allah is the
Most Merciful, the Most
Compassionate. Allah is the God of
Creation and Peace, Love and
Understanding. The prophets of the
ancient times used the name
“Moloch” for the false god of
violence and destruction. Moloch
the god who was worshipped by the
fascist who killed our queer
siblings in Orlando. Murdering
innocent people who are only May Allah
looking for joy, love and subhanahu wa ta’ala
companionship is a ceremony for bless the blood
this false idol. It was the work of of the martyrs of Orlando
Iblis, the Satan, the eternal and make it a healing potion
deceiver. Satan, this dark force, for the eyes of so many
that lives in all of us and tries
brothers and sisters
to seduce us to leave the path of
Allah, makes destruction, hatred, who were still blind yesterday
violence and murder seem good and for the injustice
holy in the eyes of his victims. and the crimes
It is important for us as believers committed against queers
to understand that this horror was all over this planet
not wat Allah ordered. If we fall
in Satan's trap of believing that May their death
these crimes were holy, good, stir a new life
wanted by Allah, we are on the road in millions of Muslims
to become his slaves as well.
on this planet
Having faith in the wake of this
a living urge to speak out
brutal fascist attack, means
refusing to believe that Allah against homophobia
wants this violence, this and all other kinds of hatred
bloodshed, this absurd orgy of
destruction. It means knowing May the slaugtered bodies
wholeheartedly that Allah was not of all the martyrs
in the storm of the homophobic of all times
rage, the fire of the guns, the become seeds
earthquake of violence. Allah is
in the fertile sole
present in the silent whispering of
hope, love, solidarity that grows of our souls
stronger after each new meaningless and may these seeds grow
massacre. and produce the sweetest fruits
Faith is our potential to see a we could ever imagine
blooming garden in a handful of
wrinkly seeds, scattered around in
the dirt. Faith is the certainty
that Allah's promise is true: the
martyrs are not really dead, they
live on to testify. Allah cares for
them. Faith is the deep will to
believe that the tiny changes in
the Ummah that have arisen after
the slaughtering of queer bodies in
Florida.
8
Janazah Prayer for Eid
Dear Lord, provide for us through Your Yet, each time such events occur,
signs and symbols of life in Your Muslims ask: “Why do bad things happen
Creation, so that we may continue to to good people?” Of course, the
bring into reality the greatness of question really asks us why do good
Qur’anic ethics that keeps us from people die? In reality, death is
destruction and doom. inevitable – but so often it is how we
die and from what causes. We can look
Ramadan began on June 6, 2016, a month to other events such as natural causes
of collective prayers, reflection in or those that end a person’s life due
communion with family, friends and to old age or disease, or the results
community. At the close of Ramadan of natural catastrophes or the
this year, July 5, the world has verisimilitudes of modern life, i.e.,
experienced over 300 lives that were slips and falls, traffic accidents,
deliberately taken during this “holy collapse of infrastructure, and the
month” of Ramadan. Ending this last list goes on. However, none of these
week of Ramadan, we have hundreds of are deliberate acts of violence.
families mourning the deaths of loved
ones rather than celebrating the end In one news report, a photograph of a
of Ramadan. teenager attacker – maybe 17 or 18
years old – brought a great shock to
As we think about the various my mind and pain to my heart. I
geographic locales, the numbers of question how could such a depraved
innocent lives taken, can we really mind teach a child to kill
get out of our minds the children, the indiscriminately based on an ideology
young people, the parents and that this is “Islam.” What we need to
grandparents, that were targeted by understand – as Muslims collectively –
Islamists in their acts of war. We this is not how Islam works. Our
take the two most recent events – Qur’an teaches us that life is
Baghdad and Medina – these attacks valuable, and that the future is
were not against “the state” or valuable, and participation in society
“military group” or a particular in a positive way is valuable, and
“governmental authority” but a these are our Islamic values.
deliberate attack on human beings who
identify as Muslim, killed during the In conclusion, I have frequently said
holiest month of the year. that our understanding of Islam –
inculcating the histories of Islams –
Just a week into Ramadan and we saw requires a rethinking, and revival and
the awful attack on Orlando, with many reform for today’s world, but it also
young and innocent LGBT lives requires enlightenment. My Eid prayer
perishing simply because one young is that Muslims find greater
man. We saw another event this past enlightenment in their reflections on
week, in Baghdad, as people shopped the Qur’anic message and ethics. Dear
for the celebrations of the coming Lord, your love and mercy is our only
Eid, senseless act of killing that reality, amen.
left many young children and young
people see their lives cut short.
Daayiee Abdullah
9
Janazah Prayer for All Who Have Perished
During This Holy Month of Ramadan*
Exalted and great, we should know that these innocents shall not bear the
burden of those who committed such violence. May these innocents have peace and
thrive in the highest ranks, oh dear Lord.
We know that life is sacred and that being slain wrongfully is not the goal of our
faith. May our heavy hearts contemplate the Ramadan, its pure fast and celebration,
and carry the message that hatred is not an example of sacred love and mercy. May
our memories forever remind us that evil is hateful in the eyes of God.
Though those who committed these acts of violence may think of themselves as
angels, we know that their words are promises of deceit. We know, dear Lord, you
are the remover of our troubles and agents of harm. We shall not give up in despair
for in You we seek guidance. We acknowledge that it is through reflection and
movement to action, we find greater truth and spiritual growth, which only comes
from our Lord.
Dear Lord, provide for us through Your signs and symbols of life in Your Creation,
so that we may continue to bring into reality the greatness of Qur’anic ethics that
keeps us from destruction and doom.
Amen
Daayiee Abdullah
* Inspiration for this prayer was taken, generally, from Surah Isra (17).
10
We stand with the families and loved ones of the massacre at the Pulse
nightclub in Orlando, with the LGBTQ community, the Latinx community, the
Muslim community and all who are joining together in solidarity to oppose
homophobia, transphobia, Islamophobia, racism and xenophobia.
12
I've spent the last two nights with
community members at vigils and
shared meals. We've each spoken
about how surreal and shocking all
of this is.
Why did it take the killing of 49
predominantly brown and black queer
people by a man who professed his
Never before have allegiance to ISIS for straight
Muslims to wake up and see that
we as LGBT Muslims their own children could have been
at that club.
Basil Arshad
14
15
Statement from the MASGD
on the shooting in Orlando
(Washington, DC - June 12, 2016) The Muslim Alliance for Sexual and Gender Diversity
(MASGD) is devastated by the massacre at the Pulse gay nightclub in Orlando on June
12, 2016. Our thoughts and prayers are with the victims and their loved ones.
Although the facts are still emerging, as LGBTQ Muslims, we feel compelled to speak
out to appeal for solidarity and to ask that we resist assigning blame to any
individual or group beyond the shooter.
This senseless loss of life is a reminder of the violence that LGBTQ people continue
to experience, despite many recent legal gains for our communities:it is not lost on
us that this horrific tragedy occurred during LGBTQ Pride month and the Muslim holy
month of Ramadan, typically a period of peace and self-reflection. It pains us that
these periods of joy, celebration, and peace have been violently marred with horror.
This tragedy cannot be neatly categorized as a fight between the LGBTQ community and
the Muslim community. As LGBTQ Muslims, we know that there are many of us who are
living at the intersections of different communities and identities, and we
recognize the complexity of these experiences. No community is a monolith - not
LatinX, Muslim, queer or trans*. We honor the lives lost and those impacted by this
tragedy, the vast majority of whom are LatinX, a fact being widely ignored. We stand
in solidarity with communities of color and all who fight for the collective right
to pursue lives of dignity and self-determination, without fear of harm.
We reject attempts to perpetuate hatred against our LGBTQ communities as well as our
Muslim communities. We ask all people to resist forces of division and hatred, and
to stand against homophobia and transphobia, as well as against Islamophobia and
anti-Muslim bigotry. Tragedies often lead people to seek someone or something to
blame, but we ask our friends to resist this temptation. Let us instead recommit
ourselves to working toward a world without hatred and prejudice. We ask our
straight Muslim allies, many of whom have stood in solidarity with us, to build
support for LGBTQ people and in opposing homophobia and transphobia in whatever
guise it presents itself,. We ask our non-Muslim allies, especially within the LGBTQ
community, to stand with us against Islamophobia and anti-Muslim bigotry, while we
work to end homophobia and transphobia. And to all peace-loving people everywhere,
we ask for your compassion and your support at this very difficult time for our
communities.
The Muslim Alliance for Sexual and Gender Diversity (MASGD) works to support, empower
and connect LGBTQ Muslims. We seek to challenge root causes of oppression, including
misogyny and xenophobia. We aim to increase the acceptance of gender and sexual
diversity within Muslim communities, and to promote a progressive understanding of
Islam that is centered on inclusion, justice, and equality.
http://www.muslimalliance.org/
16
Statement on the Orlando Shooting
Universalist Muslims and El Tawhid Juma Circle Unity Mosques
are shocked and saddened to learn of the senseless mass
shooting at a gay nightclub in Florida this morning that
tragically injured and ended the lives of so many innocent
people. Our hearts go out to the victims, and families and
loved ones of the victims and to all our American neighbors who
are grieving this morning.
We wholeheartedly condemn all acts of violence whether in the name of religion or for
any other reason and stand shoulder to shoulder with the victims and their loved ones,
conveying our most sincere condolences to our American neighbors of all sexual
orientations, gender expressions and gender identities.
El-Farouk Khaki
17
TIC Media Release on Orlando Shooting
(Cape Town, South Africa – June 13, 2016) – It is with the great
heartache and sorrow that The Inner Circle extends our deepest
condolences to the families of victims of the massacre in
Orlando on June 12, 2016. Although this is a national tragedy
directly affecting American citizens, it resonates with all
peace-loving people around the world.
It is even more disheartening that this tragedy occurs during the Holy Month of
Ramadan, which for Muslims is a month dedicated to reflection, love, compassion and
mercy.
There is no religious justification for senseless killing in the name of Islam targeted
at any population regardless of nationality, ethnicity, cultural, gender or sexual
identity. We stand in solidarity with all Queer Muslim organizations in condemning
these attacks. We particularly stand, shoulder to shoulder, with our partner
organization in the United States, MASGD and other partners in the Global Queer Muslim
Network GQMN, including Maruf (Netherlands) and LiberalIslamischeBund (Germany) who
have also expressed their condolences about this tragic event; as well as leaders from
Eltawhid Juma Circle and Salaam Canada who have taken to media to share their
condolences and represent the struggle of living at the intersection faith and
sexuality. We appeal to all Muslims to challenge their assumptions and rhetoric on
issues of sexual orientation and gender identity, which played a part in the motivation
for this massacre.
As statements from organizations and prominent individuals continue to be released, we
add our voice to honor and remember the innocent lives lost and renew our call for an
all-inclusive and compassion-centered Islam, an Islam, which embraces sexual and gender
diversity and which advocates social justice for all. #PrayForOrlando
To learn more about TIC and the work we do visit www.theinnercircle.org.za, or follow
TIC on Facebook https://www.facebook.com/TheInnerCircleSA and Twitter @TIC_SouthAfrica.
MARUF'S STATEMENT
ON THE ATTACK IN ORLANDO
The Maruf Foundation is deeply shocked and wants to express its
condolences on the fifty individuals that died during the Orlando
shooting Sunday night. Our first thoughts are with the bereaved and
our prayers are with you. Shortly after the tragedy deeply rooted
feelings of hate and intolerance were displayed on social media. This
included a variety of exclusion and blame. It saddens us to see that
the identity of the attacker is already widening the gap between
LGBTQI+ and Muslims. The Maruf Foundation tries time after time to close that gap by
showing that within the Queer community there are also Muslim members and we will do so
again this time. It disappoints to witness that certain individuals speak out their
support for the assassin. It shows that our efforts for equality are necessary, the
more so it shows that a strong Queer movement is indispensable.
Queer Muslims are part of that movement and we will not allow that certain types of
phobia will exclude us from grieving over this tragedy. By attributing this act of hate
to a religion, you are already excluding a part of the victims. We could be the ones
celebrating our liberty that night at Florida Pulse, we could be the ones that lost a
friend or a lover to an assassin that was only driven by blind hate. Let us commemorate
collectively without excluding anyone, because this act of violence is not only hurting
LGBTQI+ people, it is also hurting queers who consider themselves Muslims.
Maruf and the Dutch ministry of Education, Culture and Sciences are joining hands to
establish a European Muslim LGBT Network. The Dutch minister Bussenmaker of Education,
Culture and Sciences announced her support for a European Queer Muslim Network (EQMN)
during the IDAHO FORUM 2016 in Copenhagen. The Dutch government will fund the project
for two years. Stichting Maruf, a Dutch knowledge center on Islam and sexual diversity,
is the initiator of the network. The network consists of eight Queer Muslim
Organizations that will collaborate to address the issue of sexual diversity within the
Muslim communities. The formation of the network is a unique first step in the pursuit
of the European empowerment of Muslim LGBT.
18
Statement: Orlando Shooting
19
JE SUIS
OMAR MATEEN
For those who are unfamiliar let
me introduce you to the concept
of Toxic Gay Shame.
When you grow up being told that
as a gay Allah condemns your
existence, that via prophet Lot
MATEEN
he threw a mountain upon the
gays to wipe them out, that
Mohammed said gays should be
thrown off roof tops in hadith,
that in a caliphate gays should
be executed, that hell fire is
waiting for you and that your
flesh shall be burnt repeatedly
from your bones and you will be
forced to drink pus.
When you try to fight the urge to have sex with
men and yet it resurfaces, when you go to mosque
for the whole weekend on retreat and your friends
are going to parties and playing football in the
park but you want to be in mosque and pray that
god will take this curse away from you.
When the sex you have is sordid, swiftly
organised with men whose names you don’t know in
public toilets and the back of cars and when its
over you vow again to never do this because you
ARE NOT gay. And then you do it again.
When you can’t have eye contact with your wife
because you are not attracted to her and while
you close your eyes and lay naked upon her you
can fantasise that she is the man you love who
you regularly attend mosque with. That you
haven’t used another human being to fulfil a
hollow model of a relationship that your family
and mullah said you should have.
When you have all this and more, you are angry.
You are angry and you are sad, you are in pain
and you hurt. You want other to hurt as you see
them laugh with their wives that they love and
know this is something you can never have. You
hate the world for the cards you have been dealt.
You drink. You drink to forget and to be numb.
You metal health is fractured with excessive
sadness and anger and this plays out in a myriad
of ways. Including violence.
Sometimes you just want to shoot the world.
Jimmy Bangash
20
My people want me dead
My people want me dead My people note my ardour
Because I love another man Embrace my Islamic fervour
And as I reach out for his hand Though they note my wife’s demeanour
I must remember its Shaytan Still I pray in the front row.
And that this lifestyle is Haraam Although they do not know
The self-loathing that’s within
My people prize their honour That’s layered on this sin
Above sister, mother, brother As I gaze across the floor
Above any illicit lover I see his shoes besides the door
Fake sham marriages instead. And know he prays within these walls
My people want me dead Our lives are ever within walls
Or they want me celibate I no longer catch his eye
As they discuss my cock in mosque No exchange of smile or grin
And muse upon my use of tool His life equally as grim
Which orifice, with whom? Our lives now devoid of candour
So I internalise this shame Yet my people note my ardour
Because my people prize their honour
My people want me dead
My loved ones want me slain Sometime it’s been I want the same
Because I go against the grain But no sin: no execution
Although it’s effortless; innate Suicide results in hell
And loving women is inane Though death is our consensus
And as I see this man in mosque Endurance is dictated
I know he feels the same In this life that I have hated
“As-salamu alaykum”. Our hands clasp. In this life, that I have hated
The world recedes within this grasp. Because I loved another man
We both strain to make it last, And they love just as they can
Before our brothers ever notice And they love just as they feel
Before our worlds consumed by shame And they love just as they want
Because my loved ones want me slain And love is all I want
But there is none of that ahead
My people want me dead When your people want you dead
Or to take a wife instead
And as I take her to my bed My sons they hate their father
I mount her carcass full of dread Culturally they couldn’t sit further
Lack lustre thrusts to end this task My wife seated by my side
Dupe some woman to a farce; As I lay within this hospice
Devoid of love and laugher I am overwrought with guilt
All in the name of Allah And I reach to take her hand
And I wonder at this test She recoils, unfamiliar.
And who my people value less: And as I’m fading from this land
Is it women, is it gays? I watch my sons gaze, wistful, linger
We use our girls as a resource On the male staff attending
And for gays there’s no recourse And my last breaths are distraught
Arrange marriages ahead With the doom that gaze has wrought.
When your people want you dead
it answered
everywhere
everywhere
everywhere.”
Warsan Shire
22
23
the winding path that brought me to this place
As happens, friends, I take you on the Larry, I know, what was I thinking? That's
winding path that brought me to this place what the first caller said. He was an
where i share with you this piece I've English professor and he yelled into the
written for the Washington Post, inspired phone to me, "Do you know how unsafe it is
by the #Pulse of humanity that survives in Morgantown for gay men?"
from those souls whose lives were lost on a I didn't. In DC, wondering about what safe
Saturday night in Orlando.... looked like for me too in my straight
Dear Friends, In the summer of 1993, as a identity, challenging the traditional rules
young Wall Street Journal reporter, I moved in my culture, I started to ponder that
to an apartment on 17th Street in the professor's question more deeply.
neighborhood of Washington, D.C., called In the late 1990s Manhattan, as I worked in
Dupont Circle, known for being a popular the WSJ's New York bureau, a dashing pair
place for lesbian, gay, bisexual and of twins, Dan and Sean, did me the honor of
transgender to live, dance and hang out. being my friend, and with them I traversed
There, I was confronting the anguish of a into clubs that I had never entered before
marriage that lasted a little longer than where I was able to absorb the powerful
Kim Kardashian's. As I heard the ex-wife of energy of knowing what it feels like to
Omar Mateen talk about her short-lived have a safe space for an identity that also
marriage to the man who would later was once a crime in America.
extinguish so many lives, I remembered my Well, friends, we may not agree always with
own union, not because it was similar in the decisions that others make in their
the level of horror for Mateen's ex-wife, lives. I don't think we can ever expect
but because it was parallel in the struggle that of others. But what I came to know
of a person to find peace, safety, security deeply, with the most unexpected gift of
and love, navigating so many landmines of life within me, years later in the early
culture, identity, religion, being and winter of 2002, without a wedding ring on
shame. my finger, was that we are best served by
Like the family for Mateen's ex-wife, my celebrating our lives and embracing our
parents rescued me when they saw I was in destinies. I struggled with shame. This
despair, feeling too as if I had failed in time, what did my father write to me, as I
a culture where divorce has been a thing of sat in Pakistan? My friends know: "I love
such shame. What did my father tell me: "I you." And my mother? She rubbed oil in my
want to save you, not your marriage." And hair when I returned home and lay in dear
my mother? She rubbed oil in my hair. Safiyyah's bed, getting oil on her pillows.
That summer, I learned to have fun in this My mother told me: "Do not live in shame."
world when this fun guy, Danny Pearl, came Koula told me: celebrate life.
to the WSJ bureau, and I started to try to I had an anecdote that didn't make the
live my psychologist's advice: "Do what you edit: When Shibli was six months old in my
want to do. Not what you should." belly, I stood at the steps of Sacre Couer,
As the sun came up on a few nights, I met the Sacred Heart cathedral, in Paris, and i
the lovely transgender waitresses at that saw a double rainbow, a symbol of divine
diner on 17th. What's its name, Lynn? blessing in my vulnerable heart. Jill,
I contemplated living a self-determined, remember the double rainbow?
self-expressed life, not in a narcissistic, And you might know, when I saw Shibli,
self-absorbed way, but on a healthy path beautiful and perfect, I chose not to live
that was loving and accepting of others, in shame.
starting with the person who stared back at I share all of this because I have been
me from the mirror. thinking of all of this these past few
I thought back to years earlier in days, as I absorb the story of a man,
Morgantown, when in the early 1980s, I had unhealthy, radicalized, dangerous, violent,
slipped into the men's bathroom in the deadly, and I ponder the people slain, all
basement of West Virginia University's main on each of their journeys of identity.
library to do reporting for an expose on We have to help each other navigate this
"glory holes," as they were called, in world with truth, love, honesty, commission
between bathroom stalls, very much an -- RADICAL ACCEPTANCE, as Buddhist teacher,
unsafe space for the men who struggled with Tara Brach, preaches.
their gay identities in a time and place And whatever mechanisms are in place
where it was dangerous to be honest about crushing the spirits of others,
identity. My friend and editor, Eric, stood endangering their lives, we have to
outside, guard. Do you remember this story, remove, friends, so I penned this piece
Paul?
24
I share with you now on the need for segregation in mosques and other parts
us to repeal the scarlet-letter sex of traditional Muslim society. Please
laws in Muslim countries (and those support all of them and the important
that aren't Muslim as well). This work of Ani Zonneveld, Usama Hasan,
isn't to make any demands on what Maajid Nawaz, Raheel Raza, Debra Corso,
others may believe morally because M Zuhdi Jasser, Courtney Lonergan, the
that is for each one of us to ponder, Muslim Reform Movement and so many
but it is to remove from society the others. Politics, styles, words will be
state-sponsored mechanisms that try to different but intention I believe is
control our bodies, our hearts, our the same for a better world.
minds. I honor all of you, and wish for
Who do I think about as my everyone a life in which there is
inspirations? Faisal Alam who invited congruence between our inner beings and
me to the Al-Fatiha retreat that I our lives in the world.
write about in the piece. Imam Daayiee My apologies for the reflections, so
Abdullah who spoke back to the woman long and windy, but I wanted to share
who dared to condemn others to hell. with you the ways that each one of you
It was there at the retreat that I met have helped me come to a place of the
the brave Parvez Hussein Sharma whose spirit where I could pen 716 words so
documentaries Jihad for LOVE and all people can feel safe in the most
Sinner in Mecca open eyes to the lives intimate place in our lives: our
of gay Muslims. Raquel Evita Saraswati hearts.
lives with style. Andy Ngo moves Much love,
forward in this world with purpose.
Pamela K. Taylor & Ify Okoye prayed Asra Nomani
shoulder to shoulder with me and
helped me realize the absurdity of the
heterosexual assumption of gender
25
SOME TERRORISTS ARE MORE
EQUAL THAN OTHERS
26
"Three weeks after the drone murder of Pakistani taxi driver Mohammad Azam,
there was a massacre of 49 people in the US city of Orlando. It was horrible.
Much of the world was aghast, and there was emotion displayed in Europe and
North America, with candle-lit vigils, solemn silences of respect in
parliaments and other demonstrations of sympathy and solidarity.
And when a British female Member of Parliament was killed by a lunatic on June
16 there was an amazing outpouring of grief in the country. Her husband said
after her murder that “the two things that I’ve been very focused on is how do
we support and protect the children.”
Quite right. And understandable and most admirable. But who is going to support
and protect the children of the US drone-killed taxi driver Azam?
https://www.facebook.com/Muslims4Ferguson
27
Interview with
Shaykh Hamza Yusuf
Q: There have been many statements from Q: What about the gay community and gay
Muslims condemning terrorism. Why issue Muslims who may feel ostracized from
another one? mainstream Islam?
A: Muslims are constantly being accused A: As we say in the Orlando statement, we are
of not condemning these types of attacks, committed to Abrahamic morality, but it
even though I don’t have any control over should not to be imposed on others. America
what other people do, and they don’t is about choices, including those to live
represent me or my faith. Nobody certain lifestyles. There’s a statement in
associates all Seventh-day Adventists the Quran: There should be “absolutely no
with David Koresh, who belonged to a compulsion in religion.”
splinter sect, or all of Judaism with
Meir Kahane. But when these things Q: What about gay Muslims, though?
happen, the whole religion of Islam is A: Look, I don’t have the power to issue
besmirched. We’re trapped in this papal decrees. We don’t have that type of
constant cycle of: events, condemnation; structure in our tradition. But I have
events, condemnation. And then people studied the tradition, and the vast majority
still say, “Why don’t Muslims condemn of Muslims would never accept the lawfulness
these things?” of an active homosexual lifestyle. I don’t
see that happening. But there is also no
Q: What do you make of Donald Trump’s authority in the tradition for any individual
speech about Islam and terrorism on to take things into his own hands and impose
Monday? their version of the religion on someone
A: He’s playing a dangerous game, and a else.
lot of lives are threatened by that type
of saber-rattling. We’re in an extremely Q: Why can’t Muslim teachings on
volatile situation and social media has homosexuality change? Is it because the
introduced an unprecedented element that Quran, which is considered the inerrant word
we don’t fully understand. of God, condemns it?
A: The Quran is pretty explicit in its
Q: Trump and President Obama are arguing condemnation of the act, and we have a long
over whether to label attacks like the tradition of jurisprudence that defines it as
Orlando shooting “radical Islam.” unlawful. But there were also fatwas
A: When a man wrote a political screed permitting people who had those attractions
against the IRS and flew into its to relieve themselves so they wouldn’t fall
building, he was deemed mentally ill, into active engagement. There’s an awareness
even though it was clearly a political that this is a real human urge. I definitely
act. There’s a double standard, which is: have sympathy for people who are struggling.
If his name is Muhammad, it’s I’ve met with young Muslims who have told me
automatically terrorism. This man (Omar about their struggles. But I’m not sure they
Mateen) wasn’t a radical Islamist. To want our sympathies; they want full
drink or go to gay bars, or any kind of recognition of their lifestyle, and my
bar, is prohibited in Islam. He seemed to religion tells me that I can’t accept that.
be a nominal Muslim. He went to mosques But I can’t — and won’t — impose my beliefs
on occasion but I don’t see a lot of on others, either verbally or otherwise. I’m
devotion there. not going to judge people.
28
Q: What do you say when gay Muslims tell Q: A lot of Muslims have lamented that the
you about their struggles? feelings of goodwill after Muhammad Ali’s
A: I say that I’m not going to deny your funeral quickly dissipated after the
experience but my recommendation is not to Orlando shooting. You were at Ali’s
actively engage in behavior outside of memorial. What was that like?
what is permitted in the religion. I know A: Dr. Sherman Jackson said it best:
that people can live celibate lives, I did Muhammad Ali put an end to the idea that
it myself for many years. you can’t be an American and a Muslim. We
were all feeling that last week. The
Q: The punishment for homosexuality in memorial was all planned by Muhammad Ali
some schools of Islamic jurisprudence can himself, and I was impressed by how much
be quite harsh. his faith was highlighted, even by people
A: There’s no specific punishment in the of other traditions. The spirit of love
books of fiqh (Islamic laws) that relate that embodied the city of Louisville for
to homosexuality per se. They apply to any two days was overwhelming. Everyone was
illicit sexual relations, including smiling and hugging. It felt like such a
prohibited heterosexual acts like breakthrough for our community … and then,
adultery. And the punishments are strong, Orlando. We went from the incredible
but they are legal fictions because they pathos of joy to the bathos of despair.
are impossible to prove. You need four It’s one step forward, two steps back.
witnesses to say they witnessed (sexual)
penetration. In what circumstances are you
going to find someone to testify to that?
Sheikh Hamza
Yusuf quoted in
Scott Korb,
“Light Without
Fire: the Making
of America's
First Muslim
College”
29
A Joint Muslim Statement
On the Carnage in Orlando
(The Orlando Declaration was signed by more than 450 Muslim leaders and community
organisers in the United States http://orlandostatement.com)
30
ASSOCIATION oF BRITISH MUSLIMS
Statement on the Orlando Attack
The Creator does not tell us to hate, let alone harm,
anyone because of their differences to us. We have all
been created by the same Merciful and Gracious Creator.
We cannot but condemn this attack on the innocent people
of Orlando, Florida.
LGBTQ people are too often targets of violence. Our
deepest condolences to the loved ones and families of
the victims of this attack. We stand in solidarity with
them and pray the Most High eases their suffering.
Our Creator didn’t create us to hate or to cause friction between people,
therefore we at the Association of British Muslims (AoBM) will redouble our
efforts to oppose all forms of violence and bigotry in the name of religion and
we ask that people of all religions and the wider society challenge homophobia
alongside anti-Muslim hate, rascism, anti-Semitism, in fact all forms of
extremism and bigotry.
We will not let hate and violence succeed. We will stand together united and
those who wish to cause division will know they cannot succeed.
31
Belgian Muslim Executive
The
condemns the attacks in Orlando
During the night from saturday june 11 til sunday june 12 the horror and hatred have
struck again, this time in Orlando.
The Belgian Muslim Executive (EMB) unconditionally condemns these terrorist attacks,
aggravated by homophic hatred.
The EMB will never ceise to repeat that in Islam the value of a human life is sacred and
that everybody who kills a human being is equal to one who has killed all of humanity.
Everybody is free in the choices they want to make. No form of intimidation, aggrssion
or assault in the name of ethnic, sexual or philosophic differences can be tollerated.
In these difficult times, our thoughts go out to the families and loved ones of the many
victims. We want to offer them our condoleances. To the many wounded who survived the
attack, we want to offer our solidarity and support.
The EMB will continue to fight all forms of extremism and we continue to plead for a
peaceful and tolerant society so that muslims and their fellow citisens of all creeds
and lifestyles can live together in peace.
Salah ECHALLAOUI
chairman
The Muslim Executive of Belgium is the official Muslim interlocutor of the Belgian federal
government for the implementation of the July 19, 1974 law recognizing Islam as one of the
subsidized religious or secular communities in Belgium according to the law of March 4, 1870.
It was set up by a royal decree on July 3, 1996.
The Ahmadiyya Muslim Community believe that the long-awaited messiah has come in the person of
Mirza Ghulam Ahmad (1835-1908) of Qadian. Mirza Ghulam Ahmad claimed to be the metaphorical
second coming of Jesus(as) of Nazareth and the divine guide, whose advent was foretold by the
Prophet of Islam. The Ahmadiyya Muslim Community believes that God sent Mirza Ghulam Ahmad, like
Jesus, to end religious wars, condemn bloodshed and reinstitute morality, justice and peace. Most
Muslim scholars reject this claim and on this ground some scholars believe that members of the
Ahmadiyya community are not real Muslims.
32
Queer Muslims and allies call out
hypocricy
33
34
35
Negative comments about homosexuality
by Muslim groups and individuals
source:
36
British Muslim group Al- Ahmadiyyah Muslim Community
Muhajiroun
Ahmadiyyah Muslim Community was a Canadian
According to www.RainbowNetwork.com, the Muslim group. They published an essay
British Muslim group Al-Muhajiroun "Homosexuality & Islam" which views homosexual
issued a fatwa (religious decree) on behavior as a symptom of the decadence of
2001-JUL-16 against a Muslim homosexual society. "As this process continues, people
rights group Al-Fatiha. The alleged find and invent even more bizarre and
fatwa said: perverted means to satisfy natural urges, and
trends like child and adult pornography,
"The very existence of Al-Fatiha is bisexuality, homosexuality and bestiality
illegitimate and the members of this appear." They make a number of points:
organisation are apostates. Never will "....either the sexual license will cure
such an organisation be tolerated in itself through its own excesses (as it is
Islam and never will the disease that it doing now in the shape of numerous venereal
calls for be affiliated with a true diseases) or the wrath of God will fall in
Islamic society or individual. The shape of multitudes of Sodoms, Gomorrahs and
Islamic ruling for such acts is death. Ubars."
It is a duty of the Muslims to prevent Homosexuality has been considered deviant
such evil conceptions being voiced in behavior throughout human history.
the public or private arena." Homosexuals have redefined sexual abuse of
A spokesperson for Al-Fatiha said: children as "natural and acceptable."
Homosexuality cannot be caused by genes
"Al-Fatiha has concluded that the because:
statement from Al-Muhajiroun is only an there are essentially no gays and lesbians in
alleged fatwa. We believe that it was Russia, China and many other countries
only sent to press in the United Kingdom if there is a "gay gene" it would cause
in reaction to the Al-Fatiha conference homosexuality to die out quickly because
that was held in San Francisco, and Al- homosexuals typically do not have children.
Fatiha’s participation in the San Homosexuality "is utterly contrary to every
Francisco LGBT Pride Parade. But whether natural law of human and animal life, and
it is an official fatwa or not, the counter to the morals, purposes and
rhetoric used in the statement was institutions of a procreative society."
extreme, and cause for concern."
Mission Islam
"We as Muslims need to state unequivocally and unambiguously that homosexuality is a
deviant behavior and that there is not even an iota of doubt that Islam condemns the
behavior.
The most important thing for us as Muslims is that Islam is not our ethnicity, it is our
religion which regulates our lives and from which we derive our values.
ven though our religion allows us latitude, more than most, to ponder and reconsider some
issues, homosexuality is clearly and explicitly condemned by the Quran (7:80-83, 11:77-
79), the Prophet, and his progeny.
When we have a conflict with the Quran, which is the word of God verbatim, we do not ask
where the Quran went wrong but rather why are we, limited beings, in conflict with the
wisdom of the absolute, God Almighty.
As Muslims we do not make up our religion, but we receive it and we obey it.
Thus stated, we need to clarify, that it does not mean that we hate the homosexual person
but rather that we find the behavior abhorable. We want to help with sensitivity and care
whoever has these tendencies, or practices such behavior. We can further point out the
following:
God has created everything in pairs each endowed with physical and psychological
characteristics to complement and complete one another. The Quran (4:1) indicates that
human beings have been created from one living entity (nafs), which represents the origin
of both the male and the female. The human species though has included male and female
since its existence. The "mating" or "spousing" of male and female sexes is original in
human nature and out of this instinctive relationship the human race develops, continues
and spreads....."
"We, as Muslims, have benefit and blessings of divine guidance and wisdom. The Quran
reminds us that Allah (SWT) will change the condition of the people only if they
themselves put forth the effort (13:11). If the homosexuals can promote their wrong
values with vigor and succeed, we have a duty and a responsibility to not only make an
effort to arrest this trend, but also to invest our time, energy, and resources to
promote the divine values with as much zeal."
37
Even the Ahmadiyaa Muslim community
hate gays
Even the Ahmadiyaa Muslim community hate gays. You would think that
with the abject humiliation they suffer at the hands of other Muslims
they would be more tolerant and accepting. No.
This is from their official website. I have always been a supporter
of Ahmadiyaa. The treatment they face is Pakistan is akin to the
treatment gays face. I am getting bored of aligning with members of
society who will not stand for my rights.
The last sentence left me speechless.
38
I am
Qandeel
Baloch
I’m Qandeel Baloch. You just heard the wrong news that I have been murdered
today, it’s quite funny how the media uses the surprise news and gets my story
going to catch TRPs but I want to clarify that I’m still alive. I cannot be
murdered, I’m the rebel, you can see me on each and every page, line and verse
of history. I might have had different names, different features, but yes
you’ll see me with the same nature of being a fighter. Every form of me will
have the same story, the story of the underprivileged people who have big
dreams but are not ready to give up, who are the ones born to resist, who
refuse to die in the state in which they were born. For them, their dreams
stand above their soul, life and everything else in the world. They prefer
dying young over dying in misery. For them, rules are just intoxicants, they
are here to tell the world that they are a free soul.
You can kill me but can’t kill my ideology of going against the wind. You may
disagree with my actions; you may consider them wrong but what else do you
expect from a poor lady with a pathetic past. What other ways have you given
her to discover her talent, how much do you support her?
It is funny how nobody raised a single voice when I was married as a juvenile
at the age of 17, it is funny how nobody cared about me when I was divorced and
had to starve with my hunger, when I had to give up on my son as I could not
afford his medical treatment. Nobody cared. If you cannot acknowledge that
despite being so much under privileged and unknown, I stood out and became an
entertainer, then you have no right to mourn upon my death because I hate
cowards, I hate those who close women behind bars of their obsolete mentality.
Dreams don’t mean twerking on TV, it means to be free and taking decisions at
your own free will. I’m not being murdered by some man named Waseem, apparently
my brother, I’m being killed by the people who suffocated my dreams. Ladies and
gentlemen, if you wish to judge me, judge all you want but all I have to say is
each time a dream dies you’ll see a Qandeel Baloch being born.
http://ladiesofpakistan.com/i-am-qandeel-baloch/
39
The Intersections Between
Homophobia and Islamophobia
by Barry Kade
http://socialistunity.com/the-intersections-between-homophobia-and-islamophobia/
I would like to see a reasoned debate about At the heart of this ‘debate’ was a view
the complex intersections between prevalent amongst many gay rights and
homophobia and islamophobia, and the secular humanist activists. This view may be
challenges these pose for the left. I think described as simple enlightenment secular
discussions on the internet show how humanism. It takes the standpoint epitomised
theoretically impoverished we on the left by Voltaire’s polemics against the
are, which makes us unable to deal with eighteenth century religious establishment,
this complexity. Thus all we get is a ‘for’ but then deploys them against the racially
or ‘against’ gossip column about the merits oppressed migrant workers of Europe of
and demerits of a certain celebrity Muslim heritage.
activist under discussion.
Voltaire and his comrades were resisting the
In a discussion on the original Green Left most powerful force in European society –
open email list, I think it was in 2008 or the church, which stood as a central bastion
2007. This had a long thread under the of feudal power. The overthrow of this power
heading ‘Salma Yaqoob’, which had started was a central task of the rising
with the helpful suggestion that someone enlightenment bourgeoisie. However, today we
should approach Salma and ask whether she have many wannabe petite-Voltaire’s whose
might like to join the Green Party. This central task is not to attack the most
was met with a hostile response from two or powerful, but the most powerless. This is
three persistent posters – over dozens of epitomised by the publication of the
emails. These emails were from white gay ‘Prophet-Cartoons’ by the right wing Danish
secular humanist comrades. (I also am gay newspaper the Jyllands-Posten. Framed in the
and an atheist, but as you will see, take enlightenment language of free expression
an opposite view). against religious obscurantism, these
cartoons were about degrading and
The central thrust of these emails were denigrating the belief systems of Muslim
that we should not work with Salma Yaqoob, people, who are racially oppressed in
as she was an ‘Islamicist’ and a homophobe. Europe.
The accusations became more wild, making
accusations of “Islamo-fascism’, and And this is the heart of the issue. Since
equating all Muslims with reactionary the end of the cold war against ‘communism’,
views. There was very little in the way of the west has had to invent another enemy.
refutation from others on the list. Orwell in 1984, had parodied this continual
Obviously the ‘anti-Salma’ posters had no construction of enemies to keep the
knowledge of Salma’s actual politics. I population docile and in control, with the
pointed out that Salma was not an seamless shift between enemies and allies,
‘Islamicist’, but a left-progressive Muslim Oceania and Eurasia – or in our time,
woman, with progressive views on women’s between ‘communism’ and an essentialised
liberation etc. Fortunately, this has now ‘global Islam’. This involves not only a
been understood by the Green Party and the series of imperialist wars and occupations
Green Left, but this was not always the to subjugate countries such as Iraq and
case. The posters against Salma on the Afghanistan – but also an increased
Green left list in 2008 were defamatory, oppression of Europe’s already oppressed
ignorant and often abusive. racial minorities of migrant workers and
their descendants, with an additional layer
I was particularly interested in this of Islamophobia. Thus ‘Islamophobia’ is now
discussion, being involved in both the an official of western power, uniting
fight against homophobia and Islamophobia. capitalists and workers, in both foreign
This is a central but highly difficult twin wars and domestic racism. It is also the
task, but none the less essential if we are most serious contemporary threat to the
to unite the working class against the socialist project of creating a united
coming capitalist attacks, and build a new working class resistance of all races and
left progressive counter-hegemonic alliance religions.
of all the different sections of the
exploited and oppressed. Yet this racism is veiled in the language of
40
enlightenment liberalism and secularism. aligning ourselves with the racist right
The rightwing thugs of the English Defence wing, and using homophobia as a stick to
League can claim that ‘Islam is not a race’ beat Muslims with. People retreat into their
and that they are not being racist, they religion as a form of comfort, as a defence
are merely standing up for secular against a hostile, racist and exploitative
humanism. This claim was also made on the world. As Marx said:
Green Left discussion list by my fellow gay
rights activists. However, this ignores the “Religious distress is at the same time the
dangers of the persecution of religious expression of real distress and the protest
minorities. Ethno-religious persecution has against real distress. Religion is the sigh
an ugly history, from the persecution of of the oppressed creature, the heart of a
Jews and Catholics, and other ethnic and heartless world, just as it is the spirit of
religious minorities. With Europes Muslims a spiritless situation. It is the opium of
this is combined with race. In Britain, the people. The abolition of religion as the
workers of Pakistani and Bangladeshi illusory happiness of the people is required
ancestry have long been on the bottom rung for their real happiness. The demand to give
of our society, at the receiving end of the up the illusion about its condition is the
lowest pay, worst housing and also the demand to give up a condition which needs
worst street violence and racial illusions”.
oppression. Now the new ideology of (Karl Marx, Critique of Hegel’s Philosophy of Right)
Islamophobia is added on, in a dangerous
and volatile mix. Thus Marx’s atheism was the opposite of
Voltairian secularism or bourgeois
Gender and sexuality have become frontlines enlightenment atheism. Marx did not believe
in this new battle. Our previous hard religion would disappear in a cloud of
fought battles against sexism and scientific logic, but that it has material
homophobia by the women’s and gay roots in social relations of alienation and
liberation movements are now being oppression. If religion is a painkiller,
appropriated by the establishment and other then bourgeois atheists ridicule the
oppressive forces. Thus the war in oppressed for needing painkillers, while
Afghanistan is sometimes justified with Marxist atheists seek to help the oppressed
reference to fighting sexism and remove the cause of the pain.
homophobia. And the BNP and the EDL in the
UK, and Dutch right wingers such as Geert And if homophobia amongst Muslims is to be
Wilders sometimes try to hijack our challenged, then we must first unite with
struggles against sexism and homophobia to Muslims in common struggles against war and
promote their racist and Islamophobic racism, and build alliances with progressive
agenda. Muslims. That this can be done is shown by
the recent courageous statements by Inayat
Leading figures in the feminist and gay Bunglawala of the Muslim Council of Britain
liberation movements need to speak out who recently spoke up for Muslim support for
against this hijacking and appropriation of gay rights, saying:
our struggles by the far right and the
warmongers. Yet all too often they “At its best, Islamic civilisation was more
collaborate with it, attending ‘freedom of than willing to learn from other surrounding
expression’ events, etc. countries and cultures and adopt the best
aspects as its own. Actively working to
And just because the right try to ensure that people are able to live free of
appropriate gay liberation and feminism in discrimination based on one’s ethnicity,
their Islamophobic crusade, this does not gender, religion or sexual orientation is a
mean that they are not also homophobic and worthy goal and should be viewed as an
sexist. I’ve just witnessed first hand the Islamic goal”.
rising anti-gay bigotry in the USA, around
an orchestrated backlash against gay I seem to have written a long and hasty
marriage proposals. The thugs of the EDL post. I will rework this further in my own
might try to use us as cover for their blog soon. I will also repost the ‘Gay
Islamophobic racism, but this all male Imperialism’ article from ‘out of place’ or
group of football hooligans are just as at least sections of it and a full exegesis
capable as going queer bashing as embarking and commentary.
on an Islamophobic pogrom.
However, given the tone of this blog thread
It is also just as important to challenge here, I expect to be quoted out of context
homophobia amongst the Muslim working and denounced by our influx of petite-
class. Racially and religiously oppressed voltaires and uncritical inheritors of the
minorities will not be able to defend or bourgoise enlightenment secularism. Enjoy!
liberate themselves if they remain in
thrall to backward and reactionary
prejudices. But this will not be done by
41
"Never before have
we as LGBT Muslims
received so much visibility"
(Faisal Alam)
42
A good note when our shuyukh offer nothing but PR moves and
apologetics for their criminalization of love, when they
fail to give care to wounded people IN their communities,
when they speak violence with a soft and polite voice…and
then their defenders tell YOU to watch your adab and insist
that you only gently nudge them towards treating you as
human. Watch how selective they are when it comes to using
adab as a weapon. Watch the wallahi bros with Malcolm X and
Muhammad Ali profile pics telling you to speak softly and
not push too hard.
43