Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Pulp Reactions To Different Preparation Techniques On Teeth Exhibiting Periodontal Disease
Pulp Reactions To Different Preparation Techniques On Teeth Exhibiting Periodontal Disease
Pulp reactions to preparation techniques are still a Eleven teeth with positive reactions to sensitivity test-
major concern in restorative and prosthodontic den- ing, no or minimal carious lesions, advanced periodon-
tistry. According to many longitudinal investigations tal destruction, and therefore scheduled for extraction,
there is a high rate of primarily vital teeth exhibiting were prepared for full veneer crowns with the pa-
typical signs of endodontal complications following tient’s consent using two different preparation tech-
dental restorations. According to Bergenholtz and Ny- niques. The featheredge preparation, limited to the
man (1984), up to 15% of teeth showed negative enamel/dentin junction, was used in experimental
results to sensitivity testing, including periapical infl- group 1, including 13 sites. The shoulder preparation,
ammatory lesions, 4 – 13 years after crown preparation. extended deep into the dentin, was used in experi-
Different factors may accumulate and lead to these mental group 2, including nine sites. Either one or
dramatic changes of the endodontium, including age, both preparation techniques were applied. The control
abrasion/attrition, periodontal disease, carious lesions group 3 with no experimental preparations consisted
as natural occurring phenomena and pulp damage of four teeth of the same patient with the same level
caused by dental procedures and materials. Therefore, of periodontal destruction. Detailed information con-
it was the aim of the present investigation to compare cerning the results of the clinical investigation and the
the influence of different preparation techniques, like type of preparation is summarized in Table 1. Labora-
shoulder preparation and featheredge preparation, to tory made crowns (Visio Gem®*) were fixed with zinc
investigate further the reactions to bacterial invasion, phosphate cement (Harvard®†). The frequent clinical
to characterize the reactions of the pulp in correlation control included sensitivity testing, percussion testing
to the remaining dentin thickness, taking into account
the already predamaged pulp, and finally to conclude
* Espe, Am Griesberg 2, 82229 Seefeld, Germany.
clinical recommendations concerning pulp †
Richter & Hoffmann Harvard Dental, Johannisberger Str. 24,
degeneration. 14197 Berlin, Germany.
and pain history. The teeth were carefully extracted shoulder (Fig. 1) and the thickness of the remaining
after 90 days under local anesthesia and the roots dentin (Fig. 2) at three different levels: D1—inner part
were cut off under permanent water cooling for rapid of the margin, shortest distance to the pulp; D2—in-
penetration of 5% buffered, neutral formalin. The ner margin, following the direction of the dentin
specimens were then decalcified in HNO3, embedded tubules to the pulp and D3—end of the preparation,
in paraffin, serially sectioned at 5 mm and stained with following the direction of the dentin tubules to the
haematoxilin – eosin, azan and according to J. Hopkins pulp.
for the detection of bacteria. Adjacent pulpal areas of
each section were histopathologically rated (micro-
scope: DMRM‡) according to the BRD criteria (Table 2)
Results
comprising the parameters (i) Bacterial invasion, (ii)
Regenerative parameters, (iii) Degenerative parame- The mean extension of the shoulder preparation into
ters. The endodontal reactions localized in the crown, the dentin was 0.8 mm. Table 3 demonstrates the corre-
in the root or adjacent to the prepared margin were lation of bacteria in dentin tubules and the type of
separately rated. The quantitative measurement of preparation. Bacterial invasion occurs in both types:
video-based pictures of each section (screen: KX- featheredge preparation and shoulder preparation (Fig.
14P1§; camera: CF11/1¶) included the width of the 3). The correlation of grade of bacterial invasion to
‡
irritation dentin (Table 4) as an example for the en-
Leica, Lilienthalstr. 39–45, 64625 Bensheim, Germany.
§
Sony, 7-35 Kitashinagawa 6-chome, Shinagawa-ku, Tokyo 141,
dodontal reactions shows no significant results. The
Japan. histopathological changes of the endodontal areas adja-
¶
Kappa, Kleines Feld, 37130 Gleichen, Germany. cent to the rating points D1–D3 are summarized in
I Bacterial invasion
Grade 0: No signs of bacterial invasion
Grade 1: Moderate bacterial invasion along prepared margins
Grade 2: Moderate invasion in isolated dentin tubules
Grade 3: Severe invasion in most dentin tubules
Grade 4: Infection of necrotic pulp areas
II Regenerative paramenters of the endodontium
1. Regular irritation dentin
Grade 0: No signs of irritation dentin
Grade 1: Regular irritation dentin, localized in defined areas, no tendency to obliteration, well marked zone of uncalcified
dentin (predentin)
Grade 2: Regular irritation dentin, circumpulpal, no tendency to obliteration, well marked zone of uncalcified dentin (pre-
dentin)
Grade 3: Regular irritation dentin, tendency to obliteration, reduction or absence of uncalcified dentin (predentin)
2. Transient inflammation cells in pulpal tissue
Grade 0: No signs of inflammation cells
Grade 1: Isolated chronical and/or acute inflammation cells, fibroblast rich connective tissue (mesenchymal character)
Grade 2: Isolated chronical and/or acute inflammation cells, collagen rich connective tissue (loss of mesechymal character,
reduction of pulpoblasts and fibroblasts, isolated denticles)
III Degenerative parameters of the endodontium
1. Irregular irritation dentin
Grade 0: No signs of irregular irritation dentin
Grade 1: Irregular direction of dentin tubules, moderate numeric reduction of odontoblast processes, localized
Grade 2: Increase of irregular direction of dentin tubules, severe numeric reduction of odontoblast processes, localized
Grade 3: Severe irregularities in the direction of dentin tubules and/or loss of odontoblast processes, localized or circumpulpal
Grade 4: Mainly osteodentin, circumpulpal
Grade 5: Only osteodentin with inclusion of tissue, circumpulpal
Grade 6: Tendency to obliteration with areas of homogenous mineralisation, circumpulpal
2. Tissue necrosis
Grade 0: No signs of tissue necrosis
Grade 1: Isolated areas of tissue necrosis, localized and/or included by hard tissue
Grade 2: Extensive tissue necrosis (crown pulp)
Grade 3: Tissue necrosis reaching/including root pulp
3. Dentin resorption
Grade 0: No signs of dentin resorption
Grade 1: Isolated dentin resorption in crown dentin
Grade 2: Isolated dentin resorption in root dentin
Grade 3: Severe dentin resorption (internal granuloma)
4. Denticles
Grade 0: No signs of denticles
Grade 1: Fibrodenticles, isolated
Grade 2: Cellular fibrodenticles, isolated
Grade 3: Severe amount of denticles (free and/or attached), localised in crown pulp
Grade 4: Severe amount of denticles (free and/or attached), reaching the root pulp
5. Inflammation
Grade 0: No signs of inflammation cells
Grade 1: Isolated infiltration of chronical and/or acute inflammation cells
Grade 2: Infiltration of large areas of the pulp, tendency of demarcation
Grade 3: Severe infiltration without demarcation
Grade 4: Isolated abscesses
Grade 5: Large abcess (for example crown pulp)
BRD grading
Discussion
Mean Minimum Maximum
Earlier methodological prospective in vivo studies
Group 1 (featheredge 1.3 0 3
preparation) used graded classifications for the estimation of
Group 2 (shoulder prepa- 1.0 0 3 (pathological) pulpal changes, including the parame-
ration)
ters of inflammatory cell response, soft tissue organi-
zation, dentin bridge formation and bacterial staining,
as already suggested by Langeland et al. (1966),
slightly modified and confirmed for recent studies by
margin (D2) and root pulp. The most severe degener- Pameijer & Stanley (1995). Warfinge (1986) tried
ative reactions occurred in the crown pulp (irregular to introduce morphometric methods for the evalua-
irritation dentin, mean BRD grading 1.5) and in the tion of inflammatory responses. As a consequence,
area of the margin at point D2 (mean BRD grading pathological degenerative reactions are well defined
1.6). The results for the shoulder preparation (Table for teeth primarily exhibiting no pathological changes
9) document the same tendency with slightly different of the endodont, like in short-term biocompatibility
mean BRD gradings: irregular irritation dentin forma- testing for dental materials and methods defined in
(shoulder preparation)
Group 2
0.4/0/1
1.8/0/3
(featheredge preparation)
Group 1
Area D3
0.6/0/1
1.2/0/3
(shoulder preparation)
Group 2
0.4/0/1
1.8/0/3
(featheredge preparation)
Table 5. Irritation dentin formation at pulp areas adjacent to D1, D2, D3 (see Fig. 2)
Group 1
Area D2
0.5/0/1
1.6/0/3
Fig. 4. Azan stain ( × 1), featheredge preparation, overview. (shoulder preparation)
1.3/0/3
Group 1
0.5/0/1
1.3/0/3
(mean/min/max)
The regular irritation dentin formation is a (Brännström & Nyborg, 1971; Mjör, 1974). Tron-
natural phenomenon and a typical feature in early stad & Langeland (1971) proved that bacterial inva-
carious lesions (Gängler, 1996) and following mild sion into opened dentin tubules in omnivorous
physiological abrasion and attrition (Schwarz & Gän- teeth via abrasion is a natural occurring phe-
gler, 1998). In contrast to regular irritation dentin, nomenon. The results of both groups in this study
the irregular irritation dentin formation represents exploiting different preparation techniques con-
the numeric reduction or even loss of odondoblasts, firm experimental studies in pigs, where pulp reac-
and therefore fewer cells and their processes are re- tions correlate better with the material toxicity and
sponsible for dentin formation (Langeland et al., the remaining dentin thickness of dentin than
1975). This is the first sign of degeneration followed with the microbial invasion into dentin tubules
by the formation of fibrodenticles, osteodentin forma- (Schwarz & Gängler, 1998). Because of the non-
tion and/or dentin resorption by activation of odonto- correlation of presence and absence of bacteria with
clasts. Finally, the tissue necrosis of smaller or larger the pulp reactions in both groups, other factors
pulp areas is the degenerative result of crossing are responsible for the intensity of degenerative
the point of no return of cell reactivity. Without changes.
doubt, isolated or confluenting abcesses (grade 4/5) The results document that the remaining dentin
are signs of inflammation and they represent at least thickness is strictly correlated to the severity of
a sublethal trauma of the pulp tissue. In contrast
degenerative parameters while different preparation
to these undoubted degenerative features, isolated
techniques do not demonstrate clearly different
infiltration of chronic and/or acute inflammation cells
endodontal reactions. According to the conclusions
does not characterize per se a degenerative pro-
of Smulson & Sieraski (1989), it is confirmed that
cess. In general pathology, the reversibility of acute
the amount of 2 mm and more remaining dentin
and/or chronic inflammation is well described (Un-
seems to be the critical factor in determining the
derwood, 1982) and a prerequisite of a normal
degree of pulp response. However, in contradiction to
healing process. However, this regenerative poten-
their statement, that the shortest distance between
tial of connective tissue is limited in inflammatory
the prepared dentin margin and the pulp is decisive
pulp responses. This is why the appearance of inflam-
for the severity of inflammatory reactions (Smulson
matory cells to local irritants even in short-term
& Sieraski 1989), it is demonstrated in this study that
biocompatibility testing as defined in ISO/EN 7405
the critical remaining thickness of dentin follows the
(1997) is classified as a potentially degenerative
direction of dentin tubules. From the experi-
process.
Concerning the interpretation of the BRD gradings, mental and control results presented it is concluded
the results of the control group are in agreement that pulp changes due to periodontal disease are
with those of a previous investigation (Zoellner et superimposed by typical mainly degenerative re-
al., 1997) on incisors exhibiting periodontal disease sponses following crown preparation. Different pre-
and occlusal attrition. Pulp reactions due to severe paration techniques and various bacterial invasion
marginal periodontitis are mainly characterized by levels do not correlate with the severity of histo-
extensive regular irritation dentin formation with pathological changes. From a clinical point of view,
some tendency to reduced numbers of odonto- the remaining dentin thickness is the most important
blasts. Therefore, pulp responses to different prepara- factor of the cumulative effects including period-
tion techniques were clearly distinguished concerning ontal disease or type of preparation technique leading
the area as well as the intensity of degenerative to possible endodontal complications after crown
changes. preparation. The application of different preparation
These degenerative reactions my be caused by techniques on one tooth considering not only techni-
bacterial infection due to microleakage occurring un- cal requirements for the crown fabrication but pri-
der crowns fixed with zinc phosphate cement (Gold- marily general and individual morphological tooth
man et al., 1992). However, the influence of bacteria characteristics like enamel and dentin thickness is
as the main irritant is controversially disputed . recommended.
BRD grading
BRD grading
SMULSON, M.H. & SIERASKI, S.M. (1989) Histopathology and studies in human and monkey teeth. Swedish Dental Journal,
diseases of the pulp. In: Endodontic Therapy (ed. F.S. Weine), 39, 1.
4th edn, 134. Mosby Company, St. Louis. ZOELLNER, A., DIPPEL, C. & GAENGLER, P. (1997) Pulpal histo-
STANLEY, H.R. (1968) Design for a human pulp study. I. Oral pathology of incisors exhibiting periodontal disease and oc-
Surgery Oral Medicine Oral Pathology, 25, 633. clusal attrition. Journal Dental Research, 5, 1128.
TRONSTAD, L. & LANGELAND, K. (1971) Effect of attrition on
subjacent dentin and pulp. Journal Dental Research, 50, 17.
UNDERWOOD, J.C.E. (1982) General and Systemic Pathology, 43. Correspondence: Dr. Axel Zöllner, School of Dental Medicine,
Churchill Livingstone, New York. University of Witten/Herdecke, Alfred Herrhausen Str. 50,
WARFINGE, J. (1986) Dental pulp inflammation; experimental 58448 Witten, Germany. E-mail: dagmark@uni-wh.de