Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Macroeconomics 2 Essay - Group 5
Macroeconomics 2 Essay - Group 5
ESSAY
Subject: MACROECONOMICS 2
CLASS: ML55
TOPIC: HYPERINFLATION OF ZIMBABWE
GROUP: 5
2011156060 Nguyễn Minh Duy (Leader)
2011156063 Bùi Hoàng Gia Hân
2011155161 Nguyễn Thục Hiền
2011155083 Lã Nguyễn Quang Công
2011156064 Đoàn Thị Ngọc Hân
2011155088 Trần Nguyễn Linh Đan
2011155094 Nguyễn Vĩnh Đạt
2011156145 Nguyễn Phạm Hoài Anh
2011155122 Phạm Công Duy
TABLE OF CONTENTS
INTRODUCTION .......................................................................................................... 4
1. Research context: .................................................................................................... 4
2. Research purposes: .................................................................................................. 5
3. Research target and scope: ...................................................................................... 5
4. Research method: .................................................................................................... 5
5. Research structure: .................................................................................................. 5
CHAPTER 1: THEORETICAL BASIS ......................................................................... 6
1. Definition of inflation ............................................................................................. 6
2. Types of inflation .................................................................................................... 6
2.1 Creeping Inflation .............................................................................................. 6
3. Developments: ....................................................................................................... 11
3.1 Before hyperinflation: ...................................................................................... 11
2
4. Consequences ........................................................................................................ 15
4.1 Decreasing the value of savings and retirement money .................................. 16
5. Measures the government can and should carry out in order to help the country
abstain from the current state of hyperinflation ........................................................ 17
5.1 Dollarization of the economy .......................................................................... 17
1. Dollarization .......................................................................................................... 20
CONCLUSION ............................................................................................................ 23
REFERENCES ............................................................................................................. 24
3
INTRODUCTION
1. Research context:
-Unlike a stable inflation rate, hyperinflation is defined to be an economic situation
where prices of goods and services skyrocket in a short period of time, thereby the
amount of G&S sold is declining while its value is climbing at an accelerating pace.
-Hyperinflation is totally capable of destroying a whole nation’s economy. Along with
the macro negative influences, it also impacts many political, social and humane
principles.
-Reported in 2008, Zimbabwe was named the second worst country to ever suffer from
hyperinflation, just behind Hungary the postwar period. After every 25 hours, prices
were automatically doubled. The government issued the most valuable cash papers
which were valued at 100 thousand billion to cope up with the dire situation but it was
just enough for a weekly bus ticket. Besides, the monthly inflation rate of Zimbabwe
was calculated to rise to 3,5 million %. 50 million Zimbabwe dollars was merely
affordable for an egg. A loaf of bread was priced equal to buying 12 cars but 10 years
ago.
-In addition, the infamous global economic crisis in 2008 created a ripple of effects to
almost every economy and Zimbabwe’s was not an exception. Combined with the
inefficient domestic economy and accumulated debts, Zimbabwe was announced to be
the first country in the 21st century to endure hyperinflation. Despite efforts from the
government to reduce expenditure, pay off public debts by raising taxes, they still failed
to save the economy due to extended worker’s strikes. Urgent national problems led the
government to issue more and more cash to pay off debts for laborers, which made the
hyperinflation status quo an irreversible crisis.
-Acknowledge the urgency and adverse consequences caused by hyperinflation to a
macro economic scenario and Zimbabwe’s in particular, our group has come to a
consensus that this would be the topic for our course’s report. Our work will examine
the root causes of hyperinflation, disastrous repercussions and therefore withdraw some
of the lessons and experiences to illustrate how to avoid hyperinflation in an in depth
manner.
4
2. Research purposes:
-Our team will scrutinize the topic with 3 specific purposes:
Analyze the root causes and hyperinflation’s impacts to Zimbabwe’s economy
Examine how the government of Zimbabwe dealt with the situation.
Lessons learned to avoid hyperinflation and suggested solutions.
4. Research method:
-Our team incorporates both the quantitative and qualitative approach into the study to
look into the crisis:
The qualitative approach: analyze, compare, sum up several opinions coming
from the citizens of Zimbabwe at the time examined to gain better knowledge of
how it impacts activities of the economy.
The quantitative approach: utilize the model AS-AD to analyze the theoretical
causes of hyperinflation and gather information throughout the period studied to
learn the crisis’s repercussions. Secondary data is our team’s main source of
information. We look for sources, data, information from websites, magazines,
channels, scientific research regarding the same issue domestically and
internationally to approach the crisis in Zimbabwe
5. Research structure:
-The study comprises of 3 chapters as follows:
Chapter 1: Theoretical base of knowledge with regards to inflation, thereby
hyperinflation’s causes, impacts and solution to curb the dire situation.
Chapter 2: Analyze hyperinflation crisis in Zimbabwe in the span between 2007
to 2009
5
Chapter 3: Examine how the government solved the problem and withdraw
lessons and experiences on how to avoid hyperinflation.
2. Types of inflation
2.1 Creeping Inflation
When prices grow by 3% or less each year, this is referred to be creeping or mild
inflation. According to the Federal Reserve, price increases of 2% or less enhance
economic development. Mild inflation raises consumer expectations that prices will
continue to rise, which promotes demand. Consumers buy now to avoid higher future
pricing. Mild inflation fosters economic growth in this way. As a result, the Fed's target
inflation rate is set at 2%.
6
2.3 Galloping Inflation
When inflation reaches 10% or above, it has a devastating effect on the economy.
Money depreciates so swiftly that business and employee earnings can't keep up with
rising costs and prices. As a result, foreign investors shun the nation where this occurs,
depriving it of much-needed cash. The economy deteriorates, and government officials
lose credibility. Inflationary pressures must be avoided at all costs.
2.4 Hyperinflation
When prices rise by more than 50% each month, this is referred to be hyperinflation.
While hyperinflations are quite rare, once they start, they may quickly spiral out of
control. In reality, the majority of cases of hyperinflation occur when governments
inflate money to fund wars.
7
expenditure will rise in the same proportion as the money supply grows and the velocity
remains unchanged.
8
buy food such as loaves of bread or bags of milk. The inflation rate was so high that the
Reserve Bank of Zimbabwe issued banknotes with a denomination of hundreds of
trillions of dollars, which was the highest denomination in the world.
-In 2009, The Minister of Finance, Patrick Chinamasa, was forced to withdraw the order
of using the only local currency for transactions because people do not use local
currency in daily transactions. Also during this time, the government stopped reporting
the inflation indicators.
-Citizens are allowed to openly use USD, EUR and South African rand for transactions
and the US dollar was the most popular currency. According to banks, four-fifths of
transactions including transactions of domestically produced goods or payment of
wages to workers and securities transactions were in US dollars. Abandoning the
domestic currency was a brave decision of the Zimbabwe government because they
previously refused to.
2. Causes
-Hyperinflation is a difficult problem to deal with. By identifying possible causes of
hyperinflation, we can avoid it in the near future. In general, there are 3 main causes of
inflation. The first is demand-pull inflation when aggregate demand exceeds aggregate
supply. Second, cost-push inflation occurs when an increase in the cost of production
reduces aggregate supply, which increases prices. Finally, monetary inflation occurs
when the money supply increases continuously.
In this report, we will analyze deeply the causes of hyperinflation in Zimbabwe.
9
was managed by people with a little bit of knowledge of agriculture and related
activities. They struggled to maintain production on a large scale in the past.
-As a result, the Land Reform Program reduced agricultural output, especially tobacco,
which accounted for a third of foreign exchange earnings. Wheat production that used
to be 300,000 tons in 1990 has also decreased 50,000 tons left in 2007
10
- Common poverty and unemployment. In 2007, nearly 80% of the population was
below the poverty line. Unemployment was also high even before hyperinflation
occurred.
- Higher denominations. Although the Reserve Bank of Zimbabwe continuously issues
higher denominations, Zimbabwe does not believe that the new currency will be more
stable than the old.
- Wrong economic decisions. A mistake in a government's economic judgment can
make people ineffective as they must focus on correcting the mistake. While this harms
the economy, it does not necessarily reduce the value of the currency but can harm
confidence in the future.
3. Developments:
3.1 Before hyperinflation:
-The Republic of Zimbabwe gained independence on April 18th, 1980 and their official
currency was the Zimbabwean dollar. Economic growth was steady during the early
years of independence, so the Zimbabwean dollar was worth more than the US dollar
at the official exchange rate.
-In 1997, the government launched the Land Reform Program, which was the first move
to worsen the economic situation. Zimbabwe experienced a severe decline in food
production and all other sectors as a result of this policy. The banking industry also
11
collapsed, making farmers unable to borrow money. The International Monetary Fund
(IMF) refused to refinance and cancel debt because the IMF wanted to punish the
country because it disagreed with Zimbabwe's policy of taking land from white
landowners.
-In addition, Zimbabwe was involved in the Second Congo War, so Robert Mugabe,
President of Zimbabwe needed cash to spend on his army and pay his soldiers. So, when
a government needs money, it will often try to generate income for the country through
a variety of economic strategies such as increasing exports to other countries and
attracting foreign investors. But Robert Mugabe had another idea that would shock the
world. The idea is that the government will print more money to pay off foreign debts
and public servants like soldiers and policy.
-Unfortunately, things have turned worse, an increase in the money supply does not
equate to an increase in the productivity of the Zimbabwean economy, and only some
new investments are real to create new goods. In other words, citizens now need more
dollars to buy the same amount of goods as before.
12
-From the Table above, the estimated inflation rate for November 14, 2008 is
79,600,000,000%.
-Prices doubled every 24 hours. When prices started to rise, the government
responded by printing more money. So the cycle continues and commodity prices
continue to rise. Because the price was so high, the government had to print money with
a higher denomination. At first they printed 1 million Zimbabwe dollars, then they
printed higher denominations of 100 million. Then it was 10 billion and then 100 billion
dollars.
-In 2008, prices started to increase by thousands of percent per month, so the
government started printing 100 trillion dollars. Zimbabweans became billionaires but
that money was worthless because basic goods were still worth billions of dollars.
-In late 2008, a large bank's ATM had a data overflow error, preventing people from
withdrawing money with too many zeros. Despite some efforts to control inflation, the
Zimbabwe dollar was officially phased out on April 12, 2009 and in 2014 the Central
13
Bank of Zimbabwe recognized the US dollar and several other currencies as legal
tender.
-During hyperinflation, goods and services in Zimbabwe witnessed record high prices,
reflection with some of the following items.
14
-According to the National Bureau of Statistics, in 2020, Zimbabwe's inflation rate
increased to more than 800%, but it started to trend downward compared to the same
period last year officially at 106.64%, and the inflation rate dropped to 50.24%.
4. Consequences
-As we all know, hyperinflation can bring many bad effects to any country that is
experiencing it. This can be seen throughout the history of hyperinflation in the world.
Professor Steve H. Hanke, an American applied economist at Johns Hopkins University
published a journal with the Cato Institute listing the worst episodes of hyperinflation
of all time:
-From the table above, we can see that even the German hyperinflation of 1923 could
not match Zimbabwe's hyperinflation, as this is the second worst inflation rate in
15
history. All of the countries in this table experienced severe economic problems during
peak inflation. In addition to the problems that arose during the hyperinflation in
Zimbabwe, there were many long-term effects that could only be seen after 2009, which
is several years after the country reached its peak of inflation. Some of the problems
include:
16
2000s reduced food production, adding to the fire. Millions of people depend on food
aid. In 2013, Zimbabwe had 1.6 million people starving and had to receive aid from
Europe and America.
17
July 2008, hyperinflation reached 23 million percent (23,100,000%) in this country,
leaving 80% of workers unemployed.
-It is hard to believe that after only 2 years, Zimbabwe has successfully controlled
hyperinflation and we can delve deeper into this in Chapter 3, in which the application
of the policy of dollarization of the economy will be exploited thoroughly.
-According to Steve Hanke, the dollarization of the economy has various advantages
such as cutting hyperinflation immediately, quickly reducing deposit interest rates, and
stabilizing the national budget. However, this is only a short-term policy and does not
guarantee national competitiveness. Therefore, in the long term, the Zimbabwean state
needs policies that can guide the country's economy to become more stable and
sustainable. And through careful findings and research, there have been proposed
policies that the Zimbabwean government should implement so that the economy can
improve in a sustainable way. More specifically, these are the policies:
18
5.4 Foreign investors attraction by eliminating corruption
Mugabe's government is plagued by corruption scandals in the country. The United
States and the European Union have imposed economic sanctions targeting 200 of
Mugabe's family and close friends. Their foreign assets have been frozen in Europe.
Much of the farmland taken from white farmers ended up in the hands of politically-
connected people. Some army generals also receive it as a reward. Policy can be
successful if it is not given to people who have no knowledge of agribusiness. When a
government is transparent, it will create trust from the people and foreign investors.
This will attract Foreign Direct Investment (FDI). Therefore, it is considered beneficial
for the economy of the country because the money inflow can create jobs to reduce the
unemployment rate.
19
CHAPTER 3: ZIMBABWE’S RESPONSE TO ITS
HYPERINFLATION
1. Dollarization
- Zimbabwe's hyperinflation skyrocketed in 2008. The average GDP per capita fell to
US$136, the lowest level in 53 years (at 2005 constant price). The Zimbabwean
government's first attempt to manage inflation was to impose price controls on essential
commodities by compelling merchants to sell goods at set rates. In June 2001, the Grain
Marketing Board was monopolized, primarily to control wheat and maize prices. The
government gradually began to regulate the wholesale and retail prices of other
commodities.
- This finally resulted in market shortages, and there were moments when supermarkets
were completely out of stock. (2001 IMF Staff Report).
- In 2006, 2008, and 2009, the currency was redenominated several times. By December
2008, the use of foreign currency as a medium of exchange had nearly reached
saturation, albeit unofficially, and the central bank had licensed around 1,000 shops to
sell goods in foreign currency, ostensibly to help businesses suffering from chronic
foreign currency shortages import goods and spare parts. This was Zimbabwe's first
conscious recognition of unofficial dollarization; yet, the central bank's action was
purely political in nature. When it was realized that the country had de facto dollarized
and that the government was still collecting taxes in the worthless local currency, the
decision was made to support the ruling regime by increasing the amount of foreign
currency flowing into its coffers by collecting hard currency taxes from 1,000 shops
while criminalizing the use of foreign currency in the informal sector, where it could
not collect taxes. This revealed to all that the government was self-serving; on the one
hand, it was still paying civil workers’ salaries in the worthless Zimbabwean currency,
while at the same time expecting them to be able to buy needs in shops with foreign
cash. The minister of finance conferred legal tender status to the South African Rand
and the US dollar in January 2009, a month after the licensing of 1,000 shops,
completing official dollarization. Local currency was confined to being used in small
transactions and for change, similar to how local coinage are used in other officially
20
dollarized economies. In this context, the opposition leader was sworn in as Prime
Minister as part of the September 2008 power-sharing deal, following a compromise on
cabinet post allotment. The establishment of official dollarization, bolstered by political
accommodation, had the obvious immediate effect of halting hyperinflation, and the
country actually entered deflation, with consumer price inflation at -2.34 percent and -
3.26 percent, respectively, at the end of January and February. Bilateral donor aid began
to flow into the country, and the country predicted positive growth for the first time in
almost ten years (Ministry of Finance, 2009). Though the IMF approved targeted
technical assistance in the areas of tax policy and administration, payments systems,
lender-of-last-resort operations and banking supervision, central banking governance
and accounting to Zimbabwe in May 2009, the country's relations with the Bretton
Woods financial institutions have yet to normalize. The resumption of collaboration
was based on the observation of a significant improvement in the Zimbabwean
government's cooperation on economic policies to solve the country's debt challenges
(IMF, 2009). On the other hand, the bank has yet to resume any type of engagement
with Zimbabwe, citing the lack of conditions suitable to a full-fledged economic
development program with the country (World Bank, 2009).
- However, high denominations such as Z$100 trillion were still utilized (making it the
world's largest note), eventually leading to the introduction of the fourth Zimbabwean
dollar (2009), which made 1 trillion dollars equal to one new dollar.
- Both of these efforts, however, had little impact. In February 2009, the authorities
ultimately established a multicurrency system, in which five foreign currencies were
designated as official, and the US dollar was designated as one of the principal
currencies for government-related transactions. In 2009 and 2010, the budget
expenditure allocation was done in USD, and the native currency was eliminated until
2012.
22
also become extremely difficult and this has greatly affected the competitiveness of
Zimbabwe with countries around the world. Another major disadvantage of
dollarization is the loss of seigniorage money (the income earned from the issuance of
money) - a huge contributor to the government's revenue in times of hyperinflation.
broadcast.
-Zimbabwean politicians and senior officials are also very concerned that dollarization
could bring unwanted erosion of sovereignty and monetary independence. For them,
dollarizing and abandoning the country's currency is also claiming that they will lose
the country's sovereignty and pride.
-However, with the economy gradually recovering and economic systems adjusting to
dollarization, banks are forced to adopt competitive and transparent practices, hence
leading to stability in the banking system. By the end of 2009, the total bank deposits
increased by 750% from the December 2007 level. The stable exchange rate, lack of
monetization of the budget deficit and absence of black markets compensated for the
disadvantages of dollarization and lack of control over the monetary policy
CONCLUSION
According to the essay, hyperinflation in Zimbabwe exhibits nearly all the hallmarks of
classic hyperinflation that a country suffering a growing fiscal deficit would be sensitive
to both internal and external fiscal shock. When inflation hit, financial authorities tried
to manage and rectify an inefficient tax system, while continuing to print additional
money in the meanwhile, which caused the inflation to get worse. As inflation
worsened, the financial authorities were forced to print ever-increasing amounts of
money. To sustain tax revenue at the time, the government implemented measures such
as price control and suppressing the black market. Thus, the government's constant
printing of money to meet its needs is the primary cause of hyperinflation, undermining
the value of the Zimbabwean dollar and driving up the prices of imported products.
Hyperinflation is harmful to all markets, including currencies, investors, labor markets,
materials, and fuels. Therefore, various steps were taken by the government to curb the
23
inflation: redenomination of the currency, a shift to the multicurrency system and then
finally, complete dollarization. Despite dollarization’s set of disadvantages, the
country's economy steadily rebounded, bringing stability with it. There were significant
economic improvements, with the real GDP growth rate climbing from -14.4 percent in
2008 to 3.7 percent by the end of 2009. By 2012, unemployment had decreased and
inflation had fallen to single digit levels. The government now is focusing on better
budget planning, restructuring of banking in the country, and paying off the huge debt
that the country bears.
REFERENCES
1. Amadeo, K. (2022) Types of Inflation: The Four Most Critical Plus Nine More.
Available at: https://www.thebalance.com/types-of-inflation-4-different-types-
plus-more-3306109
2. Coltart, D. (2008) ‘A decade of suffering in Zimbabwe: Economic collapse and
political repression under Robert Mugabe’, Development Policy Analysis, No. 5.
3. Coomer, J., & GsTraunThaler, T. (2011) ‘The hyperinflation in Zimbabwe’,
Quarterly Journal of Austrian economics, No. 14(3), pp. 311.
4. Cuevas, M. A. (2012) Zimbabwe: Staff Report for the 2012 Article IV
Consultation, International Monetary Fund.
5. Dem, A., Mihailovici, G. and Gao, H. (2001) Inflation and hyperinflation in the
20th century: Causes and patterns, Columbia University.
6. Engstrom, L., Verdier, G., Fernandez, G., Oppers, S. E., Hughes, R., McHugh,
J., & Coats, W. (2010) Zimbabwe: Challenges and policy options after
hyperinflation, International Monetary Fund.
7. IMF (2009) ‘Executive Board Approves Targeted Technical Assistance to
Zimbabwe’, IMF Press Release, No. 09(152). Available at:
http://www.imf.org/external/np/sec/pr/2009/pr09152.htm (Accessed 23 Feb
2022).
8. Islam, A. (2013) ‘Impact of Inflation on Import: An Empirical Study’,
International Journal of Economics, No 1(6), pp. 299-309.
24
9. Koech, J. ‘Hyperinflation in Zimbabwe’, Federal Reserve Bank of Dallas
Globalization and Monetary Policy Institute 2011 Annual Report, pp. 2-12.
Available at:
https://www.dallasfed.org/assets/documents/institute/annual/2011/annual11b.p
df.
10. Kwesa, I. (2009) ‘Banking in a Dollarized Environment’, Banks and Banking
Survey.
11. Ministry of Finance (2009) Mid-Year Fiscal Policy Review, Harare: Print Flow.
12. Noko, J. (2011) ‘Dollarization: the case of Zimbabwe’, Cato Journal, No. 31(2).
13. Pearce, D. W. (1981) The Macmillan dictionary of modern economics, London:
Macmillan Press.
14. Pettinger, T.(2019) Hyper Inflation in Zimbabwe. Available at:
https://www.economicshelp.org/blog/390/inflation/hyper-inflation-in-
zimbabwe/ (Accessed: 27 March 2022).
15. Reserve Bank of Zimbabwe (2021) Zimbabwe Inflation Rate, Trading
Economics. Available at:
https://tradingeconomics.com/zimbabwe/inflation-cpi (Accessed: 27 March
2022).
16. Sikwila, M. N. (2013) ‘Dollarization and the Zimbabwe’s Economy’, Journal of
Economics and Behavioral Studies, No. 5(6), pp. 398-405
17. Vy, T. (2008) Zimbabwe: 100 tỷ đôla = 1 ổ bánh mì!. Available at:
https://tuoitre.vn/zimbabwe-100-ty-dola-1-o-banh-mi-269771.htm (Accessed:
29 December 2021).
18. World Bank, (2009) World Bank Still Has Not Resumed Lending to Zimbabwe.
Available at
http://web.worldbank.org/WBSITE/EXTERNAL/NEWS/0,,contentMDK:2218
9250~menuPK:3325325~pagePK:34370~piPK:34424~theSitePK:4607,00.html
(Accessed 25 Feb 2022).
19. Zímtat, X. (2013) ‘Census 2012’, National Report.
25