Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Potential of Using Cemented Soil-Tire Chips Mixture As Construction Fill: A Laboratory Study
Potential of Using Cemented Soil-Tire Chips Mixture As Construction Fill: A Laboratory Study
† ‡
College of Ocean Science and Engineering School of Civil and Environmental Engineering
Shanghai Maritime University Nanyang Technological University
Shanghai 201306, China 639798, Singapore www.cerf-jcr.org
§
College of Civil Engineering ††
College of Civil and Transportation Engineering
Chongqing University Hohai University
Chongqing 400045, China Nanjing 210098, China
ABSTRACT
Xin, L.; He, J.; Liu, H., and Shen, Y., 2015. Potential of using cemented soil-tire chips mixture as construction fill: A
laboratory study. In: Mi, W.; Lee, L.H.; Hirasawa, K., and Li, W. (eds.), Recent Developments on Port and Ocean
Engineering. Journal of Coastal Research, Special Issue, No. 73, pp. 564-571. Coconut Creek (Florida), ISSN 0749-
0208.
www.JCRonline.org Waste materials that are generated in large quantities, such as waste rubbers, plastics, and dredged soils, can
potentially be reused as fill materials in construction projects. It will bring both economical and environmental
benefits. This paper firstly presents a review on different methods of reusing scrap tires and waste soils in
constructions. Then, a new method of using these two wastes as a fill material is proposed and experimentally
evaluated. The material is formed by mixing waste soils, scrap tire chips, Portland cement, and water together in
varying proportions. Isotropic compression and triaxial consolidated undrained compression tests were carried out.
The geotechnical properties of the material with varying additions of different components are investigated. It is
found that adding more tire chips in the material leads to an evident improvement in the undrained strength; while the
compressibility of the specimens with 0-60% tire chips content (to dry soil by weight) does not change very much.
The test results also manifest that increasing cement content is an effective way to reduce the compressibility and
improve the undrained strength, indicating that the mechanical behavior of the material can be well controlled by
adjusting the cement addition. Thanks to its advantageous features such as small compressibility and adjustable
strength, the material is suitable for quaywall backfill and embankment fill in port or transportation constructions.
ADDITIONAL INDEX WORDS: Tire chips, waste soils, fill material, isotropic compression test, triaxial test.
_______________________________________________________________________________________
INTRODUCTION water content and low strength. The tire chips used are
Construction projects, such as port, highway, and railway processed from scrap tires. Portland cement is used to stabilize
developments, require large amount of fill materials. The supply the mixture. A similar fill material that has gained extensive
of conventional fills, including sand, rock, and good earth, is research efforts is EPS lightweight fill (Gao et al., 2012; Gao,
becoming more difficult, because of their increasing prices and Liu, and Liu, 2011; Liu, Deng, and Chu, 2006). However,
exploitation restrictions. For this reason, the development of expandable polystyrene (EPS) beads used for EPS lightweight
alternative fill materials has been gaining increasing interests in fill are commercial products. Using scrap tire chips as a
recent years. The sources of these alternative fill materials are replacement of EPS beads will bring more economical and
often from wastes. For example, large volumes of waste soils are environmental benefits. Tire chips also have the lightweight
generated through the dredging of harbors and fairways and feature, although they are heavier than EPS beads. The specific
other constructions works. Instead of dumping them into land or gravity of tire chips used in this study is 1.25, which is much
sea as usual, these waste soils can be used as fill materials if smaller than those of common soil minerals.
they can be properly treated. Some other waste materials, such The use of waste materials as construction fill not only has
as scrap tires, waste plastics, and sewage sludge etc., can also be environmental and economical benefits, but also brings many
used as fill materials in constructions projects after suitable technical advantages to the construction projects. In port and
treatments. transportation constructions, tire chips alone or in combination
In this paper, a laboratory study is presented on the potential with other materials has lightweight, high strength, and small
of using cemented soil-tire chips mixture as a fill material in deformation features. When using it in quay wall backfills and
construction projects. The soil used is a waste soil with high road embankments in lieu of conventional fills, the ground
____________________ settlement and lateral earth pressure acting on the wall can be
DOI: 10.2112/SI73-098.1 received 6 August 2014; accepted in revision much reduced. Projects can thus be safer and cheaper.
15 November 2014. This paper will firstly present a background on the reuse of
*Corresponding author: hejia@ntu.edu.sg scrap tires and waste soils in construction projects. Then, the
© Coastal Education & Research Foundation, Inc. 2015 laboratory work will be provided on the isotropic compression
Potential of Using Cemented Soil-Tire Chips Mixture 565
_________________________________________________________________________________________________
and undrained shear behavior of the material with various pure sand (Edil, 2005).
mixing ratios of different components. Another way to adopt tire rubber as a fill material is to use
cementation agents such as Portland cement or lime to cement
BACKGROUND tire rubber particles or mixtures of tire rubber and other
materials (Cheung, Jansen, and Hanson, 2008; Guleria and Dutta,
Scrap Tires and Their Reuse in Construction Projects 2011; Lee, Truong, and Lee, 2010; Pierce and Blackwell, 2003;
A large amount of scrap tires is generated in China every year. Shahin and Hong, 2010; Wang, Chen, and Wu, 2013; Yilmaz
Related pollution problems are acute. The number of scrap tires and Degirmenci, 2009). Some studies reported that tire rubber
increases from around 50 million in 2001 to 283 million in 2012 could be used in the controlled low strength material (CLSM) to
(Li et al., 2010). The rate of harmless utilization of scrap tires is replace part of sand as aggregates (Cheung, Jansen, and Hanson,
only about 60%, which is considerably lower than around 90% 2008; Pierce and Blackwell, 2003; Wang, Chen, and Wu, 2013).
in developed countries. The major utilization methods are Using cemented soil-tire rubber mixtures was another solution to
devulcanization and illegal tire oil extraction, which may cause adopt scrap tires as a fill material (Lee, Truong, and Lee, 2010;
high energy consumption and heavy pollution (Li et al., 2010). Shahin and Hong, 2010; this study). Shahin and Hong (2010)
Around 11% of scrap tires do not receive any treatments (Li et tested the unconfined compression strength of soft clay-cement
al., 2010). mixture with 0-7% tire rubber addition (by weight). This paper,
The use of scrap tires in civil and environmental projects has however, will provide a more comprehensive study on both
received great interests. Its common applications in this area compression and strength behavior of cemented soil-tire rubber
include lightweight fill materials (Eldin and Senouci, 1993; mixtures with a much larger range of tire rubber additions.
Pierce and Blackwell, 2003; Yoon et al., 2006), road pavement Despite the advantages of using scrap tires as fill materials,
materials (Huang, Bird, and Heidrich, 2007), and sorption awareness has been raised on its environmental impacts,
materials to reduce or eliminate contaminants from landfill especially groundwater pollution and self-combustion potential.
leachates (Park, Kim, and Edil, 1996). It can also be used for Hennebert et al. (2014) reported that tire rubber only had limited
insulation of frost penetration and vibration/earthquake consequences on the environment, and the water quality in the
attenuation. In China, one practical application is to use crumb eluates considering a wide range of parameters did not exceed
rubber mixed with asphalt as a road pavement material (Huang, the limits for road applications. Arroyo et al. (2011) reported
Bird, and Heidrich, 2007). Other applications have not been that the self-combustion potential was negligible as long as the
widely used in practice. amount of corrodible steel in the tire rubber is tightly controlled.
Tire rubber has some beneficial features when used as fill The use of tire rubber-soil mixture as embankment fill has
materials, such as lightweight and high strength. The unit weight almost no potential of self-combustion (Sienkiewicz et al., 2012).
of different compacted tire rubbers ranges from 2.4 to 7.0 kN/m3
(Edinçliler, Baykal, and Saygili, 2010), which is significantly Waste Soils and Their Reuse in Construction Projects
smaller than the typical unit weight of compacted soil fill (about Dredging of harbors and fairways produces large amount of
20 kN/m3). The unit weight of the soil-tire rubber mixtures is waste soils. Other sources of waste soils are from transportation
also smaller than that of pure soil. The lightweight feature can and building constructions. These soils often cannot be used as
help reduce the load acting grounds and earth retaining fill soil directly, because their engineering properties do not
structures. Scrap tires as fill materials can be used in several meet the requirement as fills. For example, soft soils from
forms. One common way is to use tire-sand mixtures (Eldin and dredging works usually have high water content, high void ratio,
Senouci, 1993; Hataf and Rahimi, 2006; Lee and Roh, 2007; and low strength. The usual way to deal with these soils is to
Yoon et al., 2006). The mechanical behavior of tire-sand mixture dispose them in land and in sea, which occupies large land and
is better than pure sand, especially in the shear strength. Most of water spaces and may cause negative impacts to the
the researches reported that the strength of tire-sand mixtures is environments.
higher than that of pure sand (Edil, 2005; Edinçliler, Baykal, and To reuse waste soils as fill materials in construction projects is
Saygili, 2010; Foose, Benson, and Bosscher, 1996; Lok and Yu, an effective solution to solve abovementioned problems (Parson
2006; Marto et al., 2013; Singh and Vinot, 2011; Zornberg, and Swafford, 2012). One way is to use waste soils for land
Cabral, and Viratjandr, 2004). However, a few experimental reclamation projects. The in-situ treatment of soils using vacuum
studies on small size tire chips reported that the strength preloading techniques is a cost-effective method in land
decreased with increasing amount of rubber (Neaz et al., 2013; reclamation (Chu, Yan, and Lam, 2012). Another way is to add
Youwai and Bergado, 2003). The disagreement between these cementation agents like Portland cement or lime to stabilize
previous studies could be due to the influences of other factors, soils. In this method, EPS beads and tire chips can be added into
such as sizes and shapes of tire rubber resulted from different cemented soils to amend physical or mechanical properties of
processing conditions, and confining stress used in the strength the material. The use of waste soils and tire chips in such a way
tests (Edinçliler, Baykal, and Saygili, 2010). Excessive is the method that will be investigated in this study. Some other
compression may occur in the tire-sand mixtures. However, test methods can also be adopted for the treatment of soft clay soil so
results showed that most of the compression was plastic and as to use the soil as a construction material. These methods
could be eliminated by preloading or surcharging during include the use of mechanical measures such as centrifuges and
construction (Edil, 2005; Neaz et al., 2013; Wartman, Natale, geotextile tubes, and the use of chemicals such as flocculants
and Strenk, 2007). And then the mixtures behaved like an elastic and coagulants (Howard et al., 2010). However, after the
material and the elastic modulus was at a level comparable to treatment by these methods, the water content of soil sometimes
is still very high and further treatments are needed. specially-designed machine developed by the company. Fibers
and steel wires in the scrap tires were removed and only rubber
Benefits of Using Cemented Soil-tire Chips Mixture as part was left to be used. Some basic properties of the tire chips
Construction Fill used here are summarized in Table 1. A picture of tire chips is
The use of cemented soil-tire chips mixture has advantages shown in Figure 1.
when compared with previous methods of reusing waste soils or Soil used here was from a highway construction site at
scrap tires in constructions. As mentioned earlier, a conventional Ningbo, Zhejiang Province, China. The basic soil properties are
method is to use tire chips or chips-sand mixtures as a fill given in Table 2. The soil was classified into clay of low
material. In this way, tire chips may cause contamination to the plasticity (CL) according to Chinese soil classification standard
groundwater, although this impact is not significant. When (GB/T 50145-2007). This soil has high water content, high
adding cement into tire chips, this negative impact can be further compressibility, and low strength. Such a soil cannot be used as
reduced or eliminated, as cement has an effect to fix the fill material without any proper treatment.
contaminants. The use of sand can eliminate the potential of Tap water and Portland cement were used for the preparation
self-combustion. However, the sand is a relatively expensive of the specimens.
construction material. The replacement of sand with waste soils
when mixed with tire chips is a cheaper and more Table 1. Properties of tire chips.
environmentally-friendly solution.
Vacuum preloading method is an economical way for large- Specific Range of sizeAverage sizeParticle
scale land reclamation using soft dredged materials. The gravity (mm) (mm) shape
downsides of this method are that it is not economically feasible 1.25 4.3-4.8 4.5 Angular
for small-scale filling projects, and it takes a considerably long
time to complete the treatment process. In contrast, the use of
cemented soil-tire chip mixtures is more suitable for projects
which require relatively small amount of filling materials or
have limited construction periods, such as quaywall backfills
and road embankment constructions.
Materials
The material tested in this study is made from four
components: tire chips, soil, Portland cement, and tap water. The
sources and basic properties are provided here.
Tire chips used here were processed from scrap tires of Figure 1. Tire chips.
automobiles. The material processing was done by a waste
material cycling company. Tire chips with a certain range of Test Arrangement and Specimen Preparation
sizes were obtained thought cutting and sieving using a There are four components in the material. The content of a
specific component (tire chips, cement, or water) here is defined
(b)
(a)
(c)
(a)
(a)
(b)
(b) CONCLUSIONS
This paper presents an experimental study on the mechanical
Figure 5. Triaxial undrained behaviour of the material of varying behavior of cemented soil-tire chips mixture. Isotropic
cement contents: (a) Stress-strain curves; (b) pore water pressure curves. compression tests and triaxial consolidated undrained tests were
conducted. The following conclusions can be made:
Figure 6 shows the undrained shear behavior of the material (i) The compression curves of the material in the semi-log
with varying water content. The undrained strength gently scale show a bilinear pattern that is similar to the compression
reduces as water content increases in the tested range of water curves of overly-consolidated clay. The compressibility before
content. The undrained peak strength for the specimens with 75, 200 kPa is relatively small except for the specimens with 5%
80, 85, and 90% water contents are 197.7, 197.0, 137.7, and cement content.
131.0, respectively. (ii) The addition of tire chips in the material up to 60% does