Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Chinmun 2022 - Unsc Background Guide The Situation in Yemen Freeze Date - June 23, 2019
Chinmun 2022 - Unsc Background Guide The Situation in Yemen Freeze Date - June 23, 2019
Chinmun 2022 - Unsc Background Guide The Situation in Yemen Freeze Date - June 23, 2019
Background Guide
The Charter of the United Nations also known as the UN Charter is the Founding
document of the United Nations, an inter-governmental body which is
responsible For maintaining the international peace and security across the
globe. The United Nations Conference on International Organization was held in
San Francisco California, 25 April - 26 June 1945, to draft the Charter of the
1
United Nations. The text was based on earlier proposals, negotiated in various
subsidiary bodies, and Finally adopted unanimously in a plenary meeting of the
Conference on 25 June 1945. Representatives of 50 countries participated in the
San Francisco Conference.
Chapter VI: Pacific Settlement of Disputes
Chapter VI of the United Nations Charter encompasses pacific settlement of
disputes. The Resolutions made under Chapter VI are not legally enforceable,
although the legally binding nature is not precluded/ ignored completely. The
various schools of thoughts include Chapter VI not having enforcement
mechanisms but relying on state provided constitutional enforcement methods
in issues not related directly to the member nation/ state in question.
Chapter VI warrants member nations to look out for peaceful solutions including
but not limited to "negotiation, enquiry, mediation, conciliation, arbitration, judicial
settlement, resort to regional agencies or arrangements, or other peaceful
means of their own choice." Even after implementation or the lack of it, if the
dispute resolution methods professed under Chapter VI Fail, then under article
35 of the United Nations Charter, any country can refer the question to the
Security Council or the General Assembly.
Chapter VI provisions include arbitration and submission of matters not under
arbitration to the Security Council and specifically recommendations to be
provided by the Security Council and not the power to adopt binding resolutions,
in which case, the Security Council acts under Chapter VII of the United Nations
Charter.
Introduction to Yemen
The Republic of Yemen is a country at the southern end of the Arabian Peninsula
in Western Asia. It is bordered by Saudi Arabia to the north, the Red Sea to the
west the Gulf of Aden and Guardafui Channel to the south, and the Arabian Sea
1
and Oman to the east. Yemen's territory includes more than 200 islands. Yemen
is a member of the Arab League, United Nations Non-Aligned Movement and
1
under Houthi rebel control since February 2015. Yemen is a developing country
and the poorest country in the Middle East. It is also the most corrupt. In 2016,
the United Nations reported that Yemen is the country with the most people in
need of humanitarian aid in the world with 21.2 mlllion.
The Yemeni Civil War began with the overthrow of Yemen's President Abdrabuh
Mansour Hadi in March 2015 by Ansar Allah (Partisans of God) also known as
1
the Houthis. However, roots of the civil war can be found in instability in Yemen
resulting from the end of former President Ali Abdullah Saleh's 22-year reign
following 2011 Arab Spring protests, and in armed conflict between the Hussein
Badreddin al Houthi's followers and the Yemeni government has furthermore
been ongoing 2004. The conflicts and relationships between the Hadi
government, Houthi rebels and pro-Saleh forces is only further complicated by
1
the role of regional powers and other groups in the Middle East. Saudi Arabia
and Iran have both been heavily involved in supporting the Hadi government and
Houthi rebels, respectively. Additionally, both Al-Qaeda and ISIS have been
attracted to the instability of Yemen and established a presence in the country.
The conflict in Yemen has escalated to a humanitarian disaster, leaving 80% of
its population
in need of aid.
Southern Yemen was an important colony for the British because its location
allowed them to maintain control of Bab al-Mandab, the narrow strait between
Africa and the Middle East, which was vital to British trading interests. After
establishing the protectorate of Aden in 1937, the British sought to consolidate
their power through agreements they established with the small tribes and
communities that surrounded the Protectorate of Aden. By 1967, the Marxist
National Liberation Front (NLF) was in control of much of the area and the British
withdrew their last troops in November. On November 30, 1967, the People's
Republic of Yemen was Formed as an independent nation outside the influence
of the British Empire.
who would fight with him, lead to his government making alliances with
extremists Sunni groups. This alliance in particular, embroiled the nation in
the sectarian struggle between Sunni and Shiite Islam which had engulfed
much of the Middle East.
Fighting continued for the next three years until Operation Scorched Earth
began in August 2009. It sought to destroy the Houthi rebel movement once
and for all, which would in turn give the central government more legitimacy
as well as make an example out of the rebels opposing the current regime.
The government deployed 40,000 troops, which is much more than it has in
the past, and even deployed a Popular Army of local tribesmen and other
citizen fighters. This led to a significant escalation of the conflict as President
Saleh told his men to quash the rebellion with an "iron fist." The indiscriminate
bombing of non-combatants as well as up tick in tribal conflict due to the arming
and weaponization of various tribal groups, has led to an unprecedented
number of casualties. The intensification of the violence also led to an
escalation in the numbers of displaced individuals which numbered about
250,000 by this point..
Internationally, the conflict in Yemen also attracted various global players.
Saudi Arabia, a bastion of Sunni fundamentalism, does not want the Hou this
getting power and establishing a Shi'ite nation right at their border.
Furthermore, this became the newest theatre of the ideological conflict taking
place between Saudi Arabia which is Sunni and Iran which is Shia. The two
nations, seeking to establish their sect of Islam have been in various
confrontations over the years, but none as bloody as the proxy war currently
being waged in Yemen.
Although Iran officially supports the Saleh regime and the current government
of Yemen, American warships have intercepted various Iranian arms cargos
which were believed to be enroute to Houthi rebel groups.
In 2014, Houthi rebels, allied with troops who were loyal to former President
Saleh, captured most of the country. The ground captured included even the
capital at Sanaa. An international coalition, led by Saudi Arabia and supported
by the United States, quickly began a campaign by air against the rebels in
support of President Hadi. Ultimately, the air campaign has been
unsuccessful in actually regaining lost ground from the rebels, although it has
been successful in destroying major weapons caches and rebel outposts.
In June 2018, the coalition attempted to break the deadlock on the battlefield
by launching a major offensive on the rebel-held Red Sea city of Hudaydah,
whose port is the principal lifeline for almost two thirds of Yemen's population.
UN officials warned that the toll in lives might be catastrophic if the port was
damaged or blocked. But months passed before the warring parties could be
persuaded to attend talks in Sweden to avert an all-out battle in Hudaydah.
Sporadic exchanges of fire and other ceasefire violations had been reported
between Houthi forces and coalition troops around Hudaydah in January 2019
Envoy of the United Nations Secretary-General for Yemen Martin Griffiths brokered
a cease fire centred on the besieged Red Sea port city of Hudaydah Yemen's 1
largest port. As part of the deal, the coalition and the Hou this agreed to redeploy
their forces outside Hudaydah city and port. The United Nations agreed to chair a
Redeployment Coordination Committee (RCC) to monitor the cease-fire and
redeployment.
On February 17, the United Nations announced that the Houthis would withdraw
from Hudaydah port and the Saudi-led coalition would move out of the eastern
outskirts of Hudaydah city. Still, the warring parties have yet to agree on the
identities of local police forces to take over security in Hudaydah. As of March 2019,
the parties had made "significant progress towards an agreement to implement
phase one of the redeployments of the Hudaydah agreement."
with barricades, trenches and roadblocks still present throughout the city. The
Houthis want local coast guard units to assume control. The coalition claims 1
however, that the leaders of the local coast guards are loyal to the Houthis, and U.N.
observers may have difficulty in verifying the neutrality of security personnel in
Hudaydah. U.N. officials have reported to the Security Council that the Houthis fear
that a withdrawal from Hudaydah will make their forces vulnerable to attack by the
coalitior1.
Overall, many observers remain sceptical that the cease-fire reflects a broader
impulse to end the war, seeing it instead as a means of easing international pressure
on the coalition. Since the signing of the Stockholm Agreement the Saudi-led
1
coalition has conducted airstrikes in Sanaa in retaliation for a Houthi drone attack
against a Yemeni military parade. In late January, artillery fire struck a camp for
internally displaced people in Yemen's north western Hajjah province, killing eight
civilians and wounding 30 others. According to reporting by the United Nations,
implementation of the Stockholm Agreement has been hindered by an overall lack
of trust and a reluctance to make operational concessions outside of a
comprehensive political agreement.
Humanitarian Situation
All sides of the civil war have been accused of human right violations, particularly
due to rampant targeting of civilian areas, including schools and hospitals. Both
the Houthi rebels and the Yemeni government have blatantly harmed civilians and
destroyed the economic, social and political wellbeing of Yemen. The coalition led
by Saudi Arabia and supported by the United States, Britain and France has been
accused of perpetrating war crimes. For instance, in a report that analysed attacks
from the coalition, only 2 out of 10 could be considered to have a legitimate
military objective.
Civilian casualties have only escalated since the collapse of UN-sponsored talks
in June 2016. By October 2016, over 4,125 civilians had been killed and 7,207
others had been injured in Yemen; children constituted a third of all civilian
deaths during the first year of conflict. Additionally, child soldiers have been used
in the conflict between the Houthi rebels and the Yemeni government since at
least 2010. As attacks on civilian infrastructure became a commonplace tactic in
the war1 21 million people have furthermore been deprived of life-sustaining
commodities and basic services; over 14 million people suffering from food
insecurity and no functioning healthcare facilities.
To make matters worse, an outbreak of cholera began in Yemen in October 2016
and is ongoing as of April 2019. UNICEF and WHO attributed the outbreak to
malnutritior11 collapsing sanitation and clean water systems due to the country's
ongoing conflict, and the approximately 30,000 local health care workers who had
not been paid for almost a year. A vaccination program was not started until more
than a million people were ill, and the Yemen conflict worsened the cholera
epidemic.
The Houthi originated from northern Yemeni followers of Zaydi Islam, the second
largest branch of Shiite Islam. Though followers of Zaydi Islam comprise a majority
of citizens in northern Yemen, they constitute just 40% of Yemen's total population;
the great majority of Yemen's remaining population follows Shafi'i Sunni Islam.
The Houthis began in the late 1980s as a northern Yemeni movement to protect
and revive Zaydi culture and became politicized in 2004. From 2004 to 20101 the
Hou this fought six rounds of armed conflict with the Saleh government.
Since taking control of Sanaa, however1 the Houthis' popularity has declined
dramatically in Southern Yemen. While their move into the capital to help install
a more competent government was popularly supported across the country1
their house arrest of Hadi, monopolization of control over Sanaa1 and territorial
expansion outwards all contributed to a rapid drop in public favour. Indeed, when
Houthi militias reached southern Yemen, local tribesmen perceived them as an
occupying force. This incited the southern resistance that has since solidified,
gained traction and formed the backbone of the domestic forces now opposing
the Houthis in civil war.
Northern Yemen, however, continues to support the Houthi movement.. As the
historic heartland and stronghold of the Houthis, the Houthis have maintained
military control and offer the only coherent leadership. Hadi has no connections
to the north, and the Houthis historic entrenchment in the northern tribes and
leadership will most likely continue to maintain their control and support in
northern Yemen, regardless of national politics.
Pro-Saleh Forces
Though former President Ali Abdullah Saleh was deposed in the popular 2011
Yemeni Revolution, the failures of Hadi's political transition have contributed to a
gain in Saleh's popularity. Furthermore, many of Yemen's security forces, tribal
networks, and members of the General People's Congress (GPC) political party
remain loyal to him and his son Ahmed Abdullah Saleh. Though the relationship
between Saleh's government and the Houthi movement was one of continual
tension and conflict throughout Saleh's presidency, many former Saleh
government members have no'N chosen to ally with the Houthi movement. When
the Houthis forced President Hadi to flee Sanaa and Saudi intervention in Yemen
began, Saleh offered to serves as a mediator between Saudi Arabia and the
Houthis. Saleh is also thought to have influenced the Yemeni military in standing
down to the Houthi's entrance into Sanaa in September 2015. However, in April
2015 he also offered the Saudi coalition help in retiring the Houthis to Northern
Yemen, which would leave Saleh at the centre of Yemen's political Future.
This offer to mediate with Saudi Arabia and growing influence with the Houthi thus
shows Saleh's primary motivation is to regain power within Yemen. While Houthi and
Saleh-controlled areas of Yemen are considered one side of the civil war (against the
side of Hadi's government), it is important to note Saleh's history of tension with the
Houthis and offers of support to both sides of the war. Thus, while Houthi Forces and
pro-Saleh Forces are allied for the time being, they should still be considered
separate groups, with separate loyalties, ideologies, and motivations.
DIRECTIVE - Covert/Overt