Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Efficiency of Cement Plant - A Research Paper
Efficiency of Cement Plant - A Research Paper
Efficiency of Cement Plant - A Research Paper
www.elsevier.com/locate/omega
PII: S0305-0483(15)00015-8
DOI: http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.omega.2015.01.013
Reference: OME1483
Cite this article as: Yaseen Ghulam, Shabbar Jaffry, Efficiency and productivity
of the cement industry: Pakistani experience of deregulation and privatisa-
tion, Omega, http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.omega.2015.01.013
This is a PDF file of an unedited manuscript that has been accepted for
publication. As a service to our customers we are providing this early version of
the manuscript. The manuscript will undergo copyediting, typesetting, and
review of the resulting galley proof before it is published in its final citable form.
Please note that during the production process errors may be discovered which
could affect the content, and all legal disclaimers that apply to the journal
pertain.
!
*+#,+ + -
.
-
/ /
012
3
-
3
43
- (+ + 3
+ 3+ 5667 81
2
/
"
$
/
-
+
!=
&>5&='5
)/
012
?.
1
1 /+
+.
A
-
+
.
&+.1
/ B 4&97C 56&&;+
/
/ D
/
B+
-
E +
* <
F::G H
F77G @ F>>G - F&CG - F>9G 3 F79G
1
3
5666
2
- F&IG (D
A F'5G - F&7G F5>G <
F>CG @ 3 F>IG K F9IG5+ .
1 2
+
'+!
E 11
*
-FC7G$FCIG
/F5CG.A@F7:G
F'&G/F5&G%-FC&G
$F:G
FI&G
1%F>GFIG+(
/
/ D
>+
./ 1M1
"
4
";
5
*
E
N
+.
/
/
/ -
+
/ 2
4
3
-3
47779; 1 +
3
1 ( !
4(!;+
4
B
:;+ O (!
B
/
+
+
( (!
-@/F>7G
$FCCG
/
-+
5
<
-
1 -
+O
4
&996
B
012
+.
012
3
+3
1 (! " (
@
4"(@;
1
?
- 4 ;+ < &99C 566I
/ 566I 56&&
+ H
+ %
+ " / B
. B / -
6
'
/ +
5
+ (
/
1
- :+:N
&+>N ( '6
-
$
-D
/ / >>:664;+.
/
&9>I+ / /
4
;//
>76666+(
- O
(
4O(;+ .
/ 9+IN &9C6+ &9I&
/:7N
/
O
< 4%O<; 2
-4 ;+
.
A
/
<
%&9I7
BB
-
A
-
&9II+
6
/
/
&'+5N2 --.
=4.=;+
.
+O&995
//
+./
/
&99C
/ 1/ &999 566'+ 566'
/- / 561'6N /- + .
&99& / / 2
+
7
- 7+ .
4" &;+.
B
/
B
+
" #
$%
./&976
"
&976&996 / +.
/ 4
B;+.
F&'G H F&:G - F56G
/
+ F5G
+!
7. /
&:6666/-
+" B
<
!
+
8
)F&>G<F::G
F&9G
F>5G9
FI>G
FC5G+
O B -
-
/ &6+ 8
) F&G /
1 1 /
+ .
/
+ 82 )
F:9G
Q
/ /-
/
R+ @/
/
/
/ +
-FC7C9G
)+
=
$ " FC>G
9
F>5G
- 1
/
+
10
.
-
/
&:+
9
+ = L F:&G
F.
& G
/
+! F'7G +
F'&G
/
+
<
/ 1/ / &9I619I+
.A FI'G . -
1/ + / F5CG
.
/
+
$F:G
'156N+ FIG
10
/ /
+
O
B
1
/*
&+
-
&
1
/
+
5+
-
G/F5CGF/G
@F&&GFG%-
B4-//
D
B;
'6
$ 8
!B 2 +
F5&G F G %- FC&G F G $ F:G
11
F G+
/
+
+ -
4
O
/ / / / /
& '
O
/
/3
-
3
F7996G
1
&&+3/
/
"(@(!
B 1012
10 2
+ O 2
/
3
-3
F7996G+
12
<
2 B
+
= 2 4; 2 42;
/
/ 2
4 -; + "
-+ .
4 4 E ; B
!
#
"
. 4&; , !
45;
+
%
%
% %
&
. -/ '( $
&5=A
-
+
13
-/
/
4"(@;
-, *
. -,
$ / 0 1
1 9 1) 0 : )
;
23
4H$
;(!
< /
. =<>< *
B
F F F
?<@AB -,
$ C0 1 D
1
23
9 E N) 1)
0 : E N) 0 ) E N) $ N) :
G) $ H
I
)+ )+ )+
(! "(@
# (! B+ .
+
(!
"(@ + @/
/ -
+ O
LM M
"(@ /
(!"(@
+@
14
(! "(@ // /&'+ 3
- 3
F95G
/ /
-
+@
/
+
$
/
A
F5'G
12 B
/3
-3
F9&G//
13
. B
F:>G+.
B
4B
<
F59G-F9G3
-3
F96G3
F9:G+ 3
- 3
F95G B
+
14
"
A
F5'G Q1R( F''G FCG
3
F9'G
102
+
15
<
-A
F5'G+
15
/ # + .
45;
/*
N
OP QRS
M OP
T
/S4 $ S MS
P
MWXN
OP Y
3
-3
F9&G
P
P
/
B
F5'G
B
+(
/ *
16
F
+
-,
$ C) ) Z)+
4;
/
`
% % a
% ^
+ O f t
2
A +
"
/ 3
- 3
F9'G +':I S
*
- / 4
3
- 3
F9'G+':I;+
%
$ ijk%
b% %
.
α12
*
.
α12
*
2 49;*
17
,
t , U U
-F`
s `
$
R E u* 9 U *
: U
* * -F`
`
&
*+
/V4W; +8/n<o p q
X4WW;
/*
/v
%{l,
t ,
% %
-F`
$
ijkC% Ds `
" m Z
;
3
-3
F95G |{`}F` 0 1
/
t F |
ws ` t
U | 1U D-F` z "
wsF | U | 1U D-F` z "
`
%{l, U U + 3
- 3
F9'G
0
2
0U6+9
+3 3
F9>G"!$
1 +
3
-3
F9'G /
4&; 45;
01
2
& 5+
18
%l *L *L
,
l L $
I
%l * *
* ,
3l L /&5
012
& 5+ 3 4& 5;
<
2 B B"S
(! "(@ %$(!$<
012
+<
2 B&C*
8 8 L , 8 8
458
658
. 458
658
.
Yl L $ * ,
8
8
T
458 658
. 458 658
.
.B 4 ; &5
- / B 012
(
3
&97C56&&+.
/
#
16
"
3
-3
F9'G'C&+
19
1
E + %
/-
B&I+.
&7 B
&9
B 56
(
B/
B+
&97C &99C+ " /
4
;
- F>'G+ "
/
/
/
/+ " &9951C
.
/ B
5:N/-/
17
%
2
F&6G. -
-
F7CG+
18
1 /-+3 +"
/ --+
B/
+%
$ FC:G+
19
8B
+%
F&6G+
20
"
:6N +3
/
20
- /
+ (
/ /
/-+ " / * &97C &99& &99C+ .
* &97C ± N
&97C19&
&99&1C
+(
&99I//
.
5/ +
-
/
+.
/
B
>6I /
B + O
4 ; + 3
012
/
/
/
+
F.
5 G
)
3
F9>G55+3
D + 3
55 3
3
2
2
"!$
+
21
/
B 1
4
4&97C19&; CN 4&995156&&; E
4&995197;+ .
4566I1&&; / &995197
/
F.
' G
B +=-.
'
B + ( ?
22
Q%$(!$<R
+ "
B B +.
56N
A
/
/ B / (! /
α1
2
+ .
+ .
B
'N &99517+ .
+ . 5+:N>N &&+CN
+31
4
;
0U6+9 2
+ O
I&N &E6+I&U&+>
0U6+92
+@
/
5C+
/ /
2
# / +@ /
+
26
% 0
2
6+9+ 3
B/ 0
6+76+7: 6+7I+
. B + !
23
" 5
012
+ 3
+
- / &97C19: /
+ H
/-
+ H /
;+ 8B / /
+ .
B
/ 41 ;+ . B
/ / 1
^D;+. 4
^
D;
" '
/&995/
1 B &97C+ 3
&99' 566I 566I /
719N
24
/ &995 56&&+ B
+%
+
/ +
.
> <
2
5I+3
& &
+ =- B
45N; 1
>56/
5+&N /
/-+O/B
566I
4
5+9N &995156&&>+>N/
&99956&&;+
27
3
2
/
B/0U6+7+.B+B /
25
57 4
5N
6+CN /
/
+.
/
/ /
4 ;+ "
2
+
2
&996
5666B
&97C19&+
F.
> G
" / B
57 %
1
/$F:G/&N
+
$FCIG$" FC>G
.AFI'G
O
- FI6G /
!
3
// 2
# ."
26
45+5N;'&+.
6+IN;+ . /
2
&996
5666 I+:N
5+:N+ .
/ /
+
.
/ 1
56&&+ %
&99517
/ +.
+
+.
+ @
27
/ 4
;
+ .
4/; +
F.
: G
/4
;B4
B;
4 /@
OB;+@
B /
4
_; '5+ .
4
(4;; /4 ;; ''+
. 4 B
4 ;
'5
@@O/
-
/
+ 8 -
B /
//
+%
/ +
'' %
/
.AFI'G+
28
.B
B 4B ;
4;
+ ( - $ 4-+ $+;
&995 /; &995 1
+
4
;
*
&976 &996+ .
B
+@/
+"2
/
Q
-
R+.
B
/+$
/ B (!
-
+ .
/
A 1 (!+
- + .
1
+.
29
+%
/+ @
E +
3
- B
+ . /
/+. &999566I/
# /
B
+3
30
+
/+O
-*
(
O 4
(O;?&99:+
?&97C+
F>G
1% <+ ! A
+
! 5665?'>4&;*&&&1&&I+
F:G )+ $ <+ . A+ O
$/
"
566I?&C4>;*':>`'CC+
FCG + ( + .1 + 8 *
2
1 +! .566:?5&45;*':7`'79+
+
! 5667?'C4';*>971:69+
F7G-
!+@
$+
+
+
/+O
! $/&97>?5:4';*C>I1CC5+
F9G-+
$+=/
+] !
+$/
O +
%
$
56&&?C549;*&C5&1&C'I+
F&&G
+ @ !+ %/ *
1 +$/!
566:?7I4&;*&':1&>I+
F&5G
)+
-+O
= %A
4O=%;
/A
?&997+
+
&9I9?'>4&;*::1C>+
31
F&>G<$+)+)*
B +3
(
&979?&I4:;*C>'1C:I+
F&:G !+ H $+ %/ *
! &979?'54&;*&1''+
&>6+
*1
+ 1"
566>?&54&;*C:196+
'99+
F&9G <
+ - (+ .
)
A+
! &99I?594';*59I1'&6+
?&99'+
&&>4&;*C&199+
F55G + ( $ - + ( + .
F5'G A
+ "
+
=+ 8 * +
! 5665?&6C4&;*&`5:+
F5>G+"<+$ %+@D
%!a!<-$/566C?I751&69+
<
/+ (
$/566&?&'45;*5IC1'6I+
32
F5CG / !3+ O A <
/
+.
O
! 566>?:545;*5II1579+
F5IG
+%56&>?>5&&:I1&C:+
F57G - + + .
+
(
5667?>>49;*&'>5`&':'+
F59G $+ < = )$+ 2
+.$/!
&99C?I745;*':91C>+
F'6G
+
! 566'?':4';*5:&15CI+
F'&G
)++3.+.
/A(!
>C5+
F'5G (D
A + < 3+ $ 8+ !
1
" 566:?&&4:;*I>I`ICC+
! <b2 ] b
.
O
F'>G ( +
=+ 8
*
2
+
566:?5>4&;*9'`&5&+
* +<+ < +
@+.
-*81@
?&97>*5>'`5CI+
33
F'IG( <+
+
F'7G! +<
+= .+3 A a!
F'9G"S$+- +=
)
/18#
?&97:+
F>6G "S $+ -
+ = + $ +
/
* <
2 R ( !
*
+ + 3+ 3+ ++ =/ =+ <+
( *
)
/ &99>+
F>&G "J !+ c + OdeA <+ % - - 1
566I?&C4>;*'CI1'79+
F>5G
=+ . + H
O+ 3
2
+3(++*.3
-?&99>+
"
$ 566&?5>4&;*&&9`'&+
F>:G @ 3+ @ "8+ @+ <
ʾ
%56&>?>7>91:9+
F>IG@ K+3)+
A *
34
F>7G @/
8+ + + = @
+
(+
/
*"
+%56&'?>&'::'1::7+
+
O
(
566'?&:4C;*I5I1I>:+
F:6G (+ < 8+ %/ * !+
$/(
! 5665?C45;*57>`'6&+
F:&G = 3+ L =+ . A
/
+
=/! 566>?>I45;*'9:1>'6+
F:5G < O+ # 3+ . A /
+O
! $/&9II?&745;*>':1>>>+
/
*
+.
" &99>?L=OL
45;*>6'1>:5+
F:CG <
O
$/"
566I?&C4>;*''51':'+
F:7G828@)
$+.
-+.-
(
$/&99&?'645;*&6:1&>>+
F:9G828@)
$+
-+OQ@/
$
?&99I+
35
FC6G8 -
&6>4>;*I5>1I>C+
3
(
566C?'>49;*&:'I1&::C+
FC5G
+A
/
2 *
fO!
4O!;+3
(
&999?5I45;*'>'1'C6+
+%56&>?>>:71C9+
FC>G $ <+ " =+ A A
*
+
! =5665?94&5;*75'175C+
+!
56&5?>>*&>6`&:5+
/
FC7G
(
+-(+.
//
! 5666?5&4C;*5:'15C7+
FC9G
(
+-(+ g 3g
/
O 5666?59*'7+
FI6G
(
+-(+ A//
!
3
+
$
! 566&?564&;*C&196+
FI&G
(
+- (+31 .+ (
36
FI5G
++% #
`(
(!
a%56&>?>I&1&C+
FI'G
+.A!+A/
. -
+
! 566&?I54>;*:7&1C6:+
FI>G
&999?&&45;*&''1&>I+
FI:G $3+ . + *
?&9I6+
FIIG
=+3
3+
/"E@ +
FI7G
=+3
3+% / (! h a
FI9G
=+3
3+
+
5666?5I4C;*II9`765+
F76G
=+3
3+
*
+
!
5666?&'4&;*>9`I7+
< i
!
+ i
A <* i 566&+
.
Q (!!O
R
18
+566&+
%
$ 5665?&'94&;&&:1&'5+
37
F7>G . )+ . <+ ( (! / /- *
-1
F7:G .A + @ 3+ A *
566:?'94:;*>6:1>5>+
F7IG .P
@+
- $$+
+ ./
/
/
#
-`
+%56&:?:&&&15'+
F77G H
+ A * /
A
+
! g%A5666?>54&;*
>'1I>+
D/
+"
<566'?'545;*&6I1&5C+
F96G3
-(+3
3+8/
B+
+
-+
<! 566&?>I4';*C:'1CI>+
F9&G 3
- (+ 3
3+ $ 1
+
+
-+3-+"
$-
+= +
566'8+
F95G 3
- (+ 3
3+ 81
2
F9'G 3
- (+ 3
3+ $ 2
5669?5I4';*':>1'C7+
F9>G 3
3+ "!$* / -
+
1!
5667?>54>;*5>I15:>+
38
F9:G3
3+)+8
B
+
+
+
! 566>?&94>;*:6:`:5>+
F9CG 3
-+
A # + O
-*
$?&97C+
F9IGKL+K.+ @+O 1
39
# ,
,
-%
.
!///
-FI6G
!" # !
% &''
$
()*" !+ ! ,' , - .))''
+ ,' /1
-)''
/
0!#"
&) 2 /
%3 - 5
#" 40
6 # ! ,' & &''
,
+"
40 - -''
7) 2"
( ! / 0
#+" ''
89" +
: 5'
*++
()* " !+ ! ,' , .))''
0;
4 ,' 5 $')
." )
/0 *++2 / :
." ''
( * / : -
#" ''
4 2 ,' ; '''0
*" *++* .
;
1;
<1 # ,' /1
5$
% "
% # ,' 5
$"
!"
&) -
*+++ :)
%' ,' ='
$)
!" *++# $
40
!"
#
$
!
%
&
'
< ,> 2+! *>2 #*+># > *2+#> #
( ,> 2+! *#> *+2>2 2># 2+>2
8$ -$ 2+! ! > 2*>+ + *+
, ,> 2+! *#>*2 !> *>2 2*>*
7 ,> 2+! !# *>* >2 2 >
( )
!!*""!
!*
? 7=. 7=. =&% =&% =&%) <=&, <=&, @ @ @
A
%-/ A
%-/ A
%-/)
'
>+++! +> >+## +> ! >+ ! +>! * >2** +>!+ +> +>
'
* >++ # +>*! >+ * +># >+#* +>! >**+ +>!2! >+*2 +>!+
* >++# +># >+ +># >+2 +>!!2 >* +>!*! +> +> #!
>++ +> ! >+2 +>2# >+* 2 +>! >*# +>##2 >+2# +>!*
+ >++ +>2 >+22 +># >+* +>! >+#+ +>*# >++ +>!!
*++! >+++ +> >+# +>++ >+** +>!2 >#** +>+2 > + +>!+
41
+,! !*
#-
./
!01
2034567
8668
!
! >+!* >+2 >+*# > >*! +>* >+ +> > >+2 >+ +>2
+> +> +>! +># +>2* +>* +>+ >++2 +> +>2 +>2 >+++
>+* >+* >++2 >+2# >++ >+## >+ >+*2 +> >+#* >+* >++
+ >+2 >+# >+ >++! +> >+*+ >* * >* +>! +>2 +>! >+*+
>++* +> >+# >+2 +> >+*# >+ 2 +>*! >2 +> +>+ >++
* +>! >+ +> # >+!+ >*! +>+ +>! +>** +>!* +>* +>2! +>!#
# >+! >+# +>* >+#! >+ +>!+ >+ >** +> +> +>2 +>
2 +>! >+* +>2 >+#* >+# +> +>!+ >+ +>2 +>2 +> +>
>+ +>!* >+2 >+*+ +>! >+ +> +> +> >#! +> >+
+> +>2 >+* >+# +> >+#2 >+* +>+ >* +>* +>2 +>+
! >++ >+ +> >+2# +># >+ >+* >+# +> +> +> +>*!
+> >++* +> >+22 >+* +> >+ >++ >+2 +>*# +>2 +>!
+># >+++ +># +>** >+ +># +> +>!2 +> >++ >+ +>2
*+++ +>* >+2 +>2+ +> +> +> >+* >++ +># +>#! +>*# +>+!
*++ +>!+ +>2 +> +>#+ +>2 >+2 >+#* >+ +>! +>!!2 +>+ +> +
*++* +> >+2! +>2 >++ >+!# +># +> >++! +> >+2 >*++ +>!
*++# +>2+ +>2! +># >+* >+# +>! +>2! +>*# >+*
*++2 +>! >+#2 +>22 >+# >+! +> * +>#! >++ +>*
*++ >+## +>!2 >+ >+*+ +>! >+ >+# +> * >+!
*++ +> +>2 >+22 +> +>* >+# >++ >++* >++2
*++! >2 >+ 2 >+!! >++ +>! >+# >+!+ +>2# >#
*++ +>!+ >++ +> +>2 >+ +>## +>2+ +>#2 +>
*++ +>22 +>#! >++! +>#2 +>* >++ +>2# +> +>!#
*++ +># +># >+2! +>2! +>!+ >+! >+## >++ >+*#
*+ +>+ >+#+ +>! +># >+! +> +>* >+!* +> *
>+*+ >++ >+2 >+## >+# +> >+ >+# >+ >++* +>! >++
* *+ +>! +> +>2 +>2 >++ +>! +> +># +># +>* +>! +>2
* *+ +>! +>* +>! +># >++! +>! +> +> +>
* +> >++ +>! >+2+ >+# >++* >++* +>+ >+ +>## +> + +>!*
*+ +> +> +> +> +>+ +> +>!+ +> +>!
8*+B
566I+
42
# (
B ))C ' '' $ B B) *
>+++
+>+2# >+++
B +>+# +>+ >+++
))C +>++* +>+ +>2 >+++
+>+!* +>### +>* +>!# >+++
' +>+*! +>## +>2 +> 2! +>** >+++
'' +>+2+ +>#2 +>+ +>!* +> +>* >+++
$ +>+# +>## +>* +>! +>!2 +>2! +># >+++
B +>+* +>##* +> +>!# +> +> +> +>+ >+++
+>+ +># # +>2+ +>22 +> +>#+ +>+ +> +> >+++
B) +>++ +>#2 +>2# +>2!* +>* +># +> +>! +># +>! >+++
+>+2 +>#+ +>#+ +>+! +>2! +>+ +>* +>*2 +>2# +>!! +>! >+++
* +>+ +>*2 +>22 +>+# +>2#+ +>+ +>22 +>2 ! +>## +> +> #! +>*2 >+++
+>+* +> +>+ +>+ +>2 +>2* +>2+# +>#* +>#* +>+ +>2! +>2+ +># >+++
-D$B
,E
B
7F
G
B&BF1F>GG
))C.')5BFB
'$')'G
D'F>$G
','BF$H++G
''I'B'F1>>,G
$$F1>>,G
BIBF1>>,G
F,G
B)&B)F1>>JKG
7F
KG
*=
$H'JF*G;+)
$
$$'
>,$
43
.,
+> +
+>2+
+>*+
+>++
+>++
+>+ +
+>+2+
+>+*+
+>+++
!
+
*
#
2
!
*+++
*++
*++*
*++#
*++2
*++
*++!
*++
*++
*++
*+
*++
))C ))C ))C
8*
_*.
@
OB
_*.
@
OB
_ *
@
OB
.!0
1
2$3
4
>+++ +>++
+>++ +>++
+>++ +>+!+
+>!++
+>+ +
+> ++
&''
D
+>++
+>++
+>+2+
+>2++
+>+#+
+>#++
+>*++ +>+*+
+>++ +>++
+>+++ +>+++
!
+
*
#
2
!
*+++
*++
*++*
*++#
*++2
*++
*++!
*++
*++
*++
*+
*++
?
I&<,%/5( ,&=5%- %5/.,&/5( D%5%-(&
44
."0
1
2$3 -%
+>++
+>++
+>!++
+> ++
&''
+>++
+>2++
+>#++
+>*++
+>++
+>+++
!
+
*
#
2
!
*+++
*++
*++*
*++#
*++2
*++
*++!
*++
*++
*++
*+
*++
?
0 $
45
'
"
!!*""!
!*
@ A
%-/) @ A
%-/) @ A
%-/) <=&, <=&,
@H+>+ @H+> @H+>! H2 H2
+>2# +>* +>* +> * > *
! +> +> +> +>!*+ >!!
+>+ +>+ +> +>!+ >#*
+>*+ +>*+ +>! +>! >2+
+ +># +># +># +>!#! >+#
+>* +>* +>! +>!2 *>+
* +>22 +>+# +> # +>!*+ *>2
# +>2!! +>* +>* +>!#+ >!2
2 +> +>2 +>! +>!# >#2
+>2 +>2 +> +>!*+ >2*
+> +> 2 +> 2 +>!! >*#
! +>2 +> #* +> #* +>! >2*
+>!# +> *2 +> *2 +>!2 >*+2
+> +> # +> # +>!# >*+
*+++ +> * +> !# +> !# +>!# >22
*++ +> +> +> +>!* >*2
*++* +> * +>!+ +>!+ +>!2 >+
*++# +>2 +> +> +>!* >*
*++2 +> # +> # +> # +>! >
*++ +>! +> +> +>!2 >#
*++ +> + +> *+ +> *+ +>!#* >!*
*++! +>* +> * +> * +>!* >2!
*++ +>2* +>! +>! +> ! >*!
*++ +>! +>* +>* +> !! >2*
*++ +>2!2 +>#2 +>#2 +> >2*
*+ +> + +> + +>!! +>!2# >*
+>2 +> +> +>!* >2+
* +> +> + +> *! +>!* >#2
* +>* +> +> + +>!#! >!+
+>!2 +> #2 +> 2* +>!*# >*22
+ +> +* +> 2 +> 2 +>!# >2
*++! +>#* +> +> + +> >2*
46
'9
",! !*
#-
.0345:7
8668
!
! >2 > +> >** >#+ +>2* >2# >*# > * >+2 ># +> #
+> + +>! +>2 +>#! +> +> ! >+* >++! >+2 +>22 +> ! +>!
>+* >+* +># >+2 >+2 >++2 >+ >+2# +>!! >+** >+*2 +>
+ >+* +>! >+ >++2 +># >+!2 >*+ >*# >2 >++2 +># >+2
>++ +>! >++ +> +># +>* >+! >+ ! >+* +>* +>! >++2
* +>+ >+* +> + >+ >+ +> 2 +>+ +>+ +>2 +>* +>2 +>!
# >+*! >+ +>!! >+# >+! +> >+! >* +>! +> 2 +>!# +>+
2 >++ >+! +>2 >+ ># +> >+ >+* +>+ +># >+!! +>*
+> +>#+ >+!2 +> +>! >* +>* +> +>#* >2* +>2# >**
+> +> >+#* >+# >+ * +> >+!+ +>! >** +>#* +>!! +>2
! +>!* +> +>! +> 2 +>! +># +>* +>* >+#* +> + >+#2 +>*
>+++ +> >+# +> +>! >+* >+ >+*# >+## +>2 +>2* >+ *
+># >+** +>## +> >+ 2 +>! >+* >+#2 +>* >+ >+ +>*
*+++ +>! >+ 2 +>*+ +> +>2 +>! >+# >## +> +>+* +>* +>!2
*++ +># +> +># >++ +> >+* +> +>2# >+2 +>!!+ +>2 +>!*
*++* +>! +>+ +> +># +>2 >+ +># >+! +>*# >++ +>! + >#!
*++# +>* +>* >++2 +>! +>* +>! +># +>+! >+#*
*++2 +> # >+* +>* >+ ! >* +>* +> +>2+ +>!
*++ +>! +>2 >+# +> +> ! > +>2 +>! +>!
*++ +>! +> >+ +>* +>! +> +> 2 +>#! >+*
*++! >+!2 +> > +>2! +>## ># >++ +>2 >
*++ +> ! >+2 +>2 +> +># +> +>2 >++ +>2
*++ +>* +>*! >+ >+ +>!+ >** +> ! +> >++
*++ +># +>** >+! +>* +>*+ >++ +> >+++ +>
*+ +> >+* +>!# +> >+ +> +> >+ +>
>+#2 >+* >++ >+# >+2 +> >2 >+* >+! >++ >++ +>
* *+ +>!# +>2 +> +># +>! +>! +>! +> +># +>#* +>2 +>
* *+ +> +>! +>+ +> +> +>+ +>!! +>2 +>2
* +> +>! >+++ >+* >+* >++# >++ +> >+! +>2 +># +>!
*+ +> +> +> +> +>! +>* +> +>! +> 2
8*+B
566I
47