Chapter 4
Board of Directors’ Roles
and Responsibilities
INTRODUCTION
ROLE OF THE BOARD OF DIRECTORS
FIDUCIARY DUTIES OF THE BOARD OF DIRECTORS
BOARD COMMITTE
BOARD MODELS
BOARD CHARACTERISTICS
BOARD SELECTION
DIRECTOR EDUCATION AND EVALUATION
BOARD ACCOUNTABILITY
EFFECTIVE CORPORATE BOARDS
DIRECTOR LIABILITY
SUMMARY
KEY TERMS
REVIEW QUESTIONS
DISCUSSION QUESTIONS
NOTES
INTRODUCTION
Boards of directors are elected by shareholders to oversee the managerial function, The-
oretically, boards of directors exist to resolve the agency problems associated with the
separation of a company’s ownership controls from decision controls, Intuitively, although
directors are elected to align management's interests with those of shareholders, their close
association with the company’s senior executives can create conflicts of interest within the
boardroom. Senior executives, particularly CEOs, are motivated to take over the board by
influencing the election of directors and controlling their compensation, whereas directors,
8990
Chapter 4 Board of Directors’ Roles and Responsibilities
have the fiduciary duty to maintain their independence, monitor the CEO, and discipline the
CEO for poor performance. This chapter discusses the roles and responsibilities of the board
of directors in advising management on its strategic decisions without micromanaging and
overseeing its actions and performan
Primary Objectives
‘The primary objectives of this chapter are to
+ Identify the difference between decision management and decision control.
+ Understand the role of the board of directors with regard to decision control and
fiduciary duties.
‘+ Understand that the board of directors is ul
its affairs,
imately responsible for the business and
+ Provide an overview of what the oversight function entails.
+ Identify and explain the fiduciary duties of the board of directors.
+ Gain awareness of the variety of board models recommended in global corporate
governance reforms.
+ Idemtify the board attributes that affect the quality of monitoring and oversight func-
tions performed by the company's board,
+ Illustrate the importance of an independent board of directors.
‘+ Become familiar with the best practices of determining directors’ compensation.
+ Idemtify and describe the determinants of an effective board of directors.
+ Become familiar with board accountability, evaluation, and the legal obligations and
liabilities fa
ing outside directors of public companies.
ROLE OF THE BOARD OF DIRECTORS
Separation of ownership and control in public companies and resulting agency problems
ead to the division of decision management and decision control. Decision management,
which consists of initiation and implementation of strategies, is viewed as the manage-
‘ment’s responsibility, whereas decision control, which entails the ratification and monitor-
ing of strategies, is viewed as the board of directors’ fiduciary duty performed on behalf
Of the shareholders. In performing their oversight function, boards of directors should not
involve themselves in managerial and operational decisions through micromanaging. They
should oversee managerial strategies but not implement them. In today's ever-changing and
challenging business environment, the traditional model of the board of directors in just
overseeing financial activities and reporting may not be adequate as directors get involved
more in corporate governance functions of ensuring their company is prepared to meet,
future challenges
‘The board of directors is ultimately responsible for the company’s business affairs and
governance on, the
bylaws, and shareholder agreements, Many state laws require corporations to form a board
stated in its governing documents, including the articles of incorporatRole of the Board of Directors. 91
of directors to represent shareholders and make decisions on their behalf. The Delaware
General Corporation Law Code states
The business and affairs of every corporation organized under this chapter shall be managed
by or under the direction of a board of ditectors, except as may be otherwise provided in this
chapter or in its certificate of incorporation. (Emphasis added.)
Almost all states have a similar statute authorizing and empowering the board of directors
to direct, oversee, and control a company’s business affairs, and to govern its activities.
Shareholders have statutory rights to elect directors, to replace them, and in many states to
approve major decisions or transactions such as mergers and acquisitions, the sale of major
assets, or dissolution of the company. A vigilant board of directors proactively participates
in strategic decisions; asks management tough questions; oversees management's plan:
decisions, and actions; and monitors management's ethical conduct, financial reporting,
and legal compliance. The primary oversight function of the board is the appointment of the
CEO and concurrence with the CEO's selection of other senior executives to run the com-
pany. Corporationsare legally required to have a board of directors, and many not-for-profit
organizations (¢.g., churches, universities) have a similar governing board. The success
of the board of directors depends on the composition, structure, resources, diligence, and
authority of the entire board, as well as their working relationships with other participants
of corporate governance, including management, external auditors, intemal auditors, legal
counsel, professional advisors, regulators, standard-setting bodies, and investors. Tradition-
ally, many companies” boardrooms are viewed as “gentleman's clubs” characterized by a
tendency and desire to please the CEO and rubber-stamp the CEO's decisions rather than
being the place for challenge and inquiry that adds value to corporate governance. ‘The
board, in overseeing management, should be able to influence the company’s vision, mis-
sion, strategies, and goals as well as management's plans, decisions, and actions to achieve
these goals without micromanaging.
‘The board may delegate its decision-making authority to the company’s top man-
agement team, but it is still responsible and accountable for running the company.
Boards of directors must realize that they not only are representing shareholders, but
also all stakeholders who have direct or indirect human or physical capital interests
in their corporations. ‘This does not necessarily mean that all major stakeholders (in-
vestors, employers, suppliers, govemment, customers, creditors) must have representa-
tive or so-called constituency directors on the boards. Instead, both inside (executive)
and outside (nonexecutive) directors must represent all stakeholders and protect their
interests,
‘The board of directors is the comerstone of the company’s corporate governance struc~
ture with the primary role of safeguarding interests of shareholders and other stakeholders.
In summary, roles and responsibilities of boards of directors are to
1, Represent shareholders and create shareholder value,
2. Align the interests of management with those of shareholders while protecting the
interests of other stakeholders (customers, creditors, suppliers).
3. Define the company’s mission and goals.
4, Establish or approve strai
plans and decisions to achieve these goals.92 Chapter4 Board of Directors’ Roles and Responsibilities
5. Appoint senior executives to manage the company in accordance with the estab-
lished strategies, plans, policies, and procedures.
6. Oversee the company’s performance by setting objectives, establishing short-term
‘and Long-term strategies to achieve these objectives, and assessing the performance
of senior executives in fulfilling their responsibilities without micromanaging
7. Approve major business transactions and corporate plans, decisions, and actions
according to the bylaws.
8. Develop and approve executive compensation, pension, postretirement benefits
plan, and other long-term benefits, including stock ownership and stock options.
9. Review financial reports, including audited annual financial statements, quarterly
reviewed financial statements, and other important financial disclosures such as
‘management discussion and analysis (MD&A) eamings releases and reports filed
with regulators (SEC) or disseminated to the public
10, Review management's report on the effectiveness of internal control over financial
reporting,
11, Provide counsel to the company’s senior executives, especially the CEO, on ma-
terial strategic decisions and risk management.
12, Ensure the company's compliance with applicable laws, rules, and regulations,
13. Approve the company's major operating, investing, and financial activities.
14, Set the tone at the top by promoting legal and ethical conduct throughout the
company.
15. Evaluate the performance of the board, its committees (¢.g., audit, compensation,
and nominating), and the members of each committee.
16. Hold the board, its committees, and directors accountable for the fulfillment of the
assigned fiduciary duties and oversight functions.
17. Approve dividends, financing, capital changes, and other extraordinary corporate
matters.
18. Oversee the sustainability of the company in ere:
and protecting interests of other stakeholders,
1g long-term shareholder value
‘Table 4.1 compares roles and responsibilities of directors before and after corporate
governance reforms. Boards of directors have experienced unprecedented challenges in
the post-SOX era, and some still struggle to find the right balance between engaging in
strategic decisions of directors advising management and monitoring its managerial deci-
sions and actions. This is particularly important in light of landmark settlements by former
directors of Enron and WorldCom agreeing to pay damages ($31 million) from their own
pockets for their company’s failures. Corporate boards are now undet extensive scrutiny,
and directors are concerned about their personal liability for questionable governance prac-
tices. One way to influence directors’ ethical conduct is to hold them accountable and
liable for poor performance and business misconduct. It is expected that boards of direc-
tors will engage more proactively in the oversight function in facing increasing business
challenges.Fiduciary Duties of the Board of Directors 93
Table 4.1 Compatiéon of Destine (Pit and Postcorpotnte Gavemanés Refit)
Prerefonms Postreforms
+ Personal ties to company + Oversight ofthe sustainability ofthe company in
management