Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Training in Interpersonal Skills
Training in Interpersonal Skills
Training in Interpersonal Skills
40,4
Training in Interpersonal Skills
for Librarians and Information
Workers
6 Cephas Odini
Moi University, Kenya
Introduction
Interpersonal skills is a term used to describe a wide range of social and
communicative skills, the most important of which involve:
• Two-way communication skills, for example oral and written, listening
and questioning (particularly important in enquiry work, reference
interviews, etc.).
• Styles of behaviour, particularly emphasising the importance of a positive
response and a confident professional manner, while remaining
approachable and helpful, i.e. personal presentation.
• Leadership and team work.
• General understanding of human behaviour and interpersonal relationships
in terms of interaction with, for example, other staff, internal and external
enquiries within the firm, clients, the general public, suppliers, publishers
and external information sources.
Most human experiences involve interaction or relationships with other persons.
When people interact they are affected by their goals, conflicts, psychological
mechanisms and environment. No one has ever fully explained human interaction
because of its great richness and variety. Indeed, in many ways the more that
is known, the deeper the mystery seems to become.
Nevertheless, when dealing with a whole host of local groups, societies and
individuals of different backgrounds there needs to be a flexible but informed
approach to and treatment of human interaction, which can only be possible
when one possesses good social skills.
"Social skills" is thus a shorthand term for those behaviours which facilitate
human social interaction — both generated responses (e.g. appearing welcoming
and friendly) and perceptions of others (e.g. perceiving that another is anxious,
embarrassed, etc.).
Interpersonal skills are also based on the use of good communication skills,
which involve listening, giving the other person time to consider the question
and the best way to reply, among other things. In fact communication, whether
written or spoken, requires preparation. However experienced one might be,
careful thought is still required for each presentation; for example, what sort
Library Review, Vol. 40 No. 4, of people make up the audience, what information do they require and what
1991, pp. 6-20, © MCB University
Press, 0024-2535 response is sought by the presenter?
It is a truism that some people are naturally better able to practise social Interpersonal
and communicative skills than others. In fact some psychologists define people Skills for
as primarilyfield-dependentorfield-independent.Field-dependent people are Librarians
naturally more attentive to social cues than are field-independent people. They
have an interpersonal orientation. Field-independent people have greater skill
in cognitive analysis and structuring but have an impersonal orientation. Field-
dependent people are more likely to avoid expressions of hostility in their
relationships with others. 7
Why Librarians and Information Workers Need Interpersonal Skills
Training
Librarianship, or information work in general, is a social and communicative
profession; a librarian deals with library users, many need to convince authorities,
or to convince or control staff.
His or her role therefore, is based on relationships and continuous communication
with individuals at all levels throughout the organisation, and s/he will be required
to interpret information and pass it on intelligibly to his or her customers through
face-to-face contact. These social and communicative factors cannot be understood
in a vacuum; a theoretical appreciation must be enhanced by real experience,
through a continuous on-the-job training process in interpersonal skills.
Individual librarians need to be able to communicate effectively, not only with
one another, but more specifically with their various client groups.
Communication involves breaking down barriers, one of which may be that caused
by "the image" of a librarian in the user's mind. This may be of an
unapproachable, unhelpful character, surrounded by so many inflexible rules
and regulations as to make the user feel excluded from, and an intruder upon,
the library. The development of good communicative skills through interpersonal
skills training is therefore a long-term investment for anyone involved in library
or information work.
Pleasant, courteous and well-groomed staff members, perceptive of the user's
needs lend an air of assurance which will be reflected not only in the initial
approach of the clientele to the library but also in the continuous use of its
services and facilities.
The case for interpersonal skills training in librarianship, as with any people-
directed profession, seems self-evident, especially in the light of the not
infrequently expressed concern about the quality of entrants to the profession
in many countries. Any employer who expects the library or information studies
schools to produce an expert in dealing with people is likely to be disappointed.
I agree with Argyle[1] when he suggests that "social behaviour" could be
introduced as a subject into the librarianship curriculum. Many professional
training programmes (e.g. for teachers, bank employees, social workers)
incorporate social skills training exercises to better equip trainees to deal with
their client groups, and there is every reason to suppose that librarianship would
benefit from such an approach. However, employers would also still have their
own indispensable contribution to make to the graduate's professional preparation
by providing appropriate training in interpersonal skills in an open-ended training
process which should go on throughout a person's working life.
Library Review Many librarians and information workers do not admit that they require training
40,4 in interpersonal skills. There is also a feeling in some library and information
organisations that interpersonal skills are essentially a matter of an individual's
personality, and beyond the scope of teaching. I think this is unfortunate since
I believe that, whilst it is possible that most librarians are fairly competent in
this respect, it does not necessarily follow that they are conscious of "practising
8 social skills". By increasing an individual's awareness of the dynamics of
interpersonal behaviour it may be possible to improve social performance.
Moreover, in many libraries and information departments, the types of behaviour
problems that result from interpersonal difficulties are various, although in some
cases it may be difficult to recognise their connection with interpersonal relations
in the work situation. All libraries and information workers, therefore, need
to be competent in interpersonal functioning, and their organisations must design
or organise training programmes which respond to real learning needs in
interpersonal skills training.
Job Rotation
To improve the interpersonal skills of librarians and information workers in my
organisation I use job rotation in an attempt to broaden employees' experience,
knowledge and skills. Job rotation enables trainees to work with different groups
and individuals, making it possible for their social interpersonal skills in particular
to be enriched and widened by virtue of the breadth of first-hand experience.
Where the range of tasks to be undertaken includes much that is boring and
repetitious, job rotation can also introduce more variety and interest in
interpersonal skills training, and in the work situation in general.
Job rotation as a method of training in interpersonal skills, however, suffers Interpersonal
from certain limitations. In practical terms, movement around a widely dispersed Skills for
system can create problems of travel and good time-keeping. In Kenya for Librarians
example, the University of Nairobi Librarian encounters a lot of problems when
arranging this kind of training for his library staff. Trainees are asked to move
to Kabete or Kikuyu Campus Libraries which are more than 20 kilometres away
from the main University Campus Library and from their residential areas. This
creates many problems for staff involved in job rotation training, especially as 11
public transport in and around Nairobi is not very reliable.
Interviews
The interview exists as a mechanism through which formal structured
communication concerning a particular problem can take place, with the objective
of solving that problem. Communication in interviews is two-way, with information
being given and sought by both parties — one party assuming the role of
interviewer, the other the role of interviewee.
Interviews are conducted according to various social rules, depending on the
type of interview. However, there are two underlying principles which apply
in all types of interview. The first relates to preparation and the second to good
manners. Participants need to be able to listen to each other patiently and
objectively to exercise tact and discretion, and make decisions based on fact
rather than opinion.
Role-playing interviews in particular may enable individuals to acquire the
appropriate interpersonal skills required in their everyday work. The appraisal
interview is also very important as it provides a vehicle for two-way feedback
which could contribute as much as to the development of the information service
as to that of the individual whose performance is being reviewed. The appraisal
interview also forms the basis for constructive staff relationships. A broad range
of interpersonal, communication and organisational skills (in other words, those
skills which make up the ability to manage people) are needed in interviews,
and these are also the key skills in successful and effective interpersonal
interaction throughout the organisation.
Coverdale Training
This is an approach which, built upon group training, was developed by Ralph
Coverdale[7], an industrial psychologist who devised his own methods of planned
behaviour improvement.
The method is essentially a form of personal self-development through
concentrating on teamwork. For five days at a stretch, the participants spend
most of their time in syndicates. They are encouraged to discipline themselves
to achieve a set task within a set time, with a "coach" feeding in the tuition,
for instance about the expediency of adopting a systematic approach. Being
systematic in setting objectives, gathering information, planning action and review
is the cornerstone of the approach.
The techniques are designed to provide a system whereby people can learn
from actual experience rather than listening to lectures, and thus develop skills
in putting their knowledge to practical use, particularly those social skills which
are relevant to co-operation with other people. This training method is quite
suitable in library and information departments where there is a well qualified
trainer who is capable of devising a systematic approach to setting objectives
and establishing an overall purpose; without such a person there would be
problems in administering it.
Library Review Role Playing and Role Negotiation
40,4 Role playing, as a training method, was developed in the 1930s. Participants
act out a particular role, which is structured to a certain extent but which allows
for the spontaneous development of responses. The technique is often used
to examine interpersonal relationships or change attitudes. The success or
otherwise of role-playing exercises will depend on the willingness of participants
to live through the role and to act in a convincing fashion. Traditionally, it is
14 expected that role playing in interviewing will involve someone playing a hard
uncomprising personality — a role which perhaps does not come easily to the
typical librarian of popular imagination.
Harrison[8] has indicated that it is possible to improve interpersonal
relationships through structured negotiations. His approach is to encourage
people to bring out into the open the things they feel the other person should
do more of, do less of, or keep doing. Though the approach is structured, it
nevertheless deals with real issues. Harrison[8] calls the approach "Role
Negotiation" and it is designed so that people can begin to openly negotiate
the behaviour they would like to see from others. It is a two-way exchange
and provides a basis for improving problem solving within relationships. As
Harrison says, resolving conflict successfully at the interpersonal level can only
be done by first tackling the ever-present issue of power and influence among
members. Role negotiation does this and provides a sound and effective base
upon which to build more satisfying relationships.
Role negotiation is an interesting approach, but more research is needed to
identify what effect it does have and how such a method can be used. However,
it again represents a way in which training can be used as a practical tool to
help solve organisation differences and problems.
Confrontation Meeting
One of the most widely known approaches is Beckhard's "confrontation
meeting"[9]. He developed this approach to enable a large number of people
in an organisation to meet for a period of about one day to discuss major areas
for improvement and to work on a strategy for action. A typical approach is
to start at 9 o'clock in the morning and the stages identified by Beckhard[9]
are as follows:
• Climate setting — where the top manager outlines the purpose of the
meeting, and sets the scene so that people can participate.
• Gathering information — participants are asked to work in groups and
identify the key issues which need to be tackled if organisational
improvement is to occur.
• Information sharing — information is then shared, usually by placing the
data on wall charts.
• Priority setting and planning — the action required to improve the areas
identified to be considered.
• Organisation planning — top management indicates how they feel
priorities should be put into action in the executive system.
• Follow up — top management indicates how the ideas developed will Interpersonal
in fact be implemented. Skills for
This is a very quick way to enable a number of people to understand the problems Librarians
of the organisation, particularly those related to social behaviour, and to become
committed to doing something about it.
Value Clarification 15
Our characteristics as human beings influence our values, which represent our
own personal morality. Values may often be based on how we generally regard
the human person. Values do affect our interpersonal dealings and professional
efforts and sometimes they are a rival to logic, for decisions may be based on
values rather than on strictly objective data.
Training sessions where staff have values clarified may help change their
negative views about racial minorities, the economically deprived, the
handicapped, and those from different cultural and ethnic backgrounds. However,
the problem with this training method is that it is very difficult to change people's
values, just as it is difficult to change their attitudes and habits.
Sessional Observations and Self-Instruction
In many cases we learn a new skill from a combination of instruction and
observation. Eventually, we are instructed by someone else, then we repeat
the process giving instructions to ourselves, and finally we complete the activity
"automatically" without consciously thinking of the instructions. We can apply
a similar process of observation, instruction, self-instruction, and automatic
ability to the learning of interpersonal skills as well.
Observation plays a very important role in all learning situations. Any learner
meeting a new situation opens her/himself up to it, tries to take in and senses
everything s/he can about it, thinks about it, grapples with it boldly, imaginatively
and resourcefully, and if s/he fails to master it, looks without shame or fear
at the mistake and learns what s/he can from it.
However, the training manager should not just remain passive and expect
staff to observe and learn good interpersonal skills. S/he has to bear in mind
the fact that people learn best when they are interested in what they are learning.
Where there is no satisfaction to reward performance there is little interest;
where there is little interest both learning and performance are poor. The learner
should be involved in the learning process and should be shown how learning
objectives are related — how one thing leads to another. S/he should be able
to build on what is already known, in such a way that the next step becomes
a challenge rather than a threat.
Conclusion
It is most unfortunate that interpersonal skills training does not receive the
attention it deserves, both in library and information schools and in libraries
and information service organisations. Perhaps the reason for this is that social Interpersonal
skills training programmes are sometimes mistakenly equated with group therapy Skills for
and viewed with suspicion. Librarians
It is, however, important for the parties concerned to realise that social skills
training is not an attempt to change or shape an individual's personality, nor
is it an attempt to take away the individuality of the professionals; rather, it
is a straightforward behaviour strategy designed to make individuals better able
to function socially. 19
I therefore strongly recommend that all library and information studies schools
should include interpersonal skills in their curriculum, and that every employer
should provide open-ended training in interpersonal skills for his or her staff,
using some of the several training methods discussed in this article.
References
1. Argyle, M., The Psychology of Interpersonal Behaviour, Penguin, 1978.
2. Cowley, J., Personnel Management in Libraries, Clive Bingley, London, 1982.
3. Cronin, B. and Martin, I., "Social Skills Training in Librarianship'', Journal ofLibrarianship,
Vol. 15 No. 2, 1983.
4. Webb, S.P., Personnel Development in Information Work, Aslib, London, 1986.
5. Prytherch, R.(Ed.), Staff Training in Libraries, Gower, Hants, 1986.
6. Rackham, N. and Morgan, T., Behaviour Analysis in Training, McGraw-Hill, New York,
1976.
7. Coverdale, R., Thought — A Frame for Teamwork Training Partnerships, London, 1968.
8. Harrison, R., "Where Power Conflicts Trigger Team Spirit", European Business, 1972.
9. Beckhard, R., "The Confrontation Meeting", Harvard Business Review, Vol. 45 No. 2, 1967.
10. Vandenput, M., "The Transfer of Training", Journal of European Training, Vol. 3 No.
3, 1973.
11. Beckhard, R., Organisation Development: Strategies and Models, Addison Wesley, 1969.
Bibliography
Bennis, W.G., Organisation Development: Its Nature, Origins and Prospects, Addison Wesley, 1969.
Clewis, J.E. and Panting, J.I., Performance Appraisal — An Investment in Human Capital, College
and University Personnel Association, Washington DC, 1985.
Conroy, B., Library Staff Development and Continuing Education, Libraries Unlimited Inc,
Colorado, 1978.
Cooper, C.L.(Ed.), Behaviour Problems in Organisations, Prentice-Hall, Englewood Cliffs, NJ,
1979.
Creth, J., Personnel Management in Libraries, Neal Schuman, New York, 1981.
Dettart, F.E., The Librarian's Psychological Commitments, Greenwood Press, Connecticut, 1979.
Edward, R.J., In Service Training in British Libraries, Library Association, London, 1977.
Filley, A.C., House, R.J. and Kerr, S., Managerial Process and Organisational Behaviour, Scott
Foresman and Co., Glenview, 1976.
Frank, E. and Margenson, C., Training Methods and Organisation Development, Vol. 2 No. 4, 1978.
Jinks, M., "Training", Blandford Management Series, 1979.
Library Review Library Association, Training in Libraries: Report of the Working Party, Library Association, 1977.
40,4 Martin, A., "Practical Problems and Principles of In-Service Training", Aslib Proceedings, 1970.
Roche, S., "Coverdale Training — A Method for Developing Managers and the Organisation",
Manpower and Applied Psychology, Vol. 1 No. 1, Ergon Press, Ireland, 1967.
Savage, A.W., Personnel Management, Library Association Management Pamphlet No. 1, 1977.
Schuster, M., The Library Centred Approach to Learning, ETC Publications, Palm Springs, 1977.
20 Spence, S. and Shepherd, G.(Ed.), Developments in Social Skills Training, Academic Press,
London, 1983.
Walton, R.E., Interpersonal Peace Making: Confronations and Third Party Consultation, Addison
Wesley, London, 1979.
Williams, J.G., Simulation Activities in Library, Communication and Information Science, Marcel
Dekker, New York, 1976.
Wilson, B.J., "Library Theory and Practical Vocational Training", Aslib Forum, Aslib Proceedings,
Vol. 23, 1971.