Professional Documents
Culture Documents
A 7yg4n.5mm1p1r2ju
A 7yg4n.5mm1p1r2ju
A 7yg4n.5mm1p1r2ju
COLLECTION
OBJECTIVES
Evaluate a researcher’s decision to use existing data
or to collect new data
• THE MOST SALIENT ADVANTAGE OF RECORDS IS THAT THEY ARE ECONOMICAL; THE
COLLECTION OF ORIGINAL DATA IS OFTEN TIME-CONSUMING AND COSTLY . ON THE OTHER
HAND, WHEN RESEARCHERS ARE NOT RESPONSIBLE FOR COLLECTING DATA, THEY MAY BE
UNAWARE OF THE RECORDS’ BIASES.
THREE TYPES OF DATA COLLECTION
SELF- REPORTS
OBSERVATION
BIOPHYSIOLOGIC MEASURES
THREE TYPES OF DATA COLLECTION
• SELF- REPORTS
• SELF-REPORTS ARE PARTICIPANTS’ RESPONSES TO QUESTIONS POSED BY THE RESEARCHER, AS IN
AN INTERVIEW.
• OBSERVATION
• DIRECT OBSERVATION OF PEOPLE’S BEHAVIORS, CHARACTERISTICS, AND CIRCUMSTANCES IS
AN ALTERNATIVE TO SELF-REPORTS FOR CERTAIN RESEARCH QUESTIONS.
• BIOPHYSIOLOGIC MEASURES
• NURSES ALSO USE BIOPHYSIOLOGIC MEASURES TO ASSESS IMPORTANT CLINICAL VARIABLES.
KEY DIMENSIONS OF DATA COLLECTION METHODS
Structure
Quantifiability
Obtrusiveness
Objectivity
SELF
REPORT
QUALITATIVE
TECHNIQUES
UNSTRUCTURED INTERVIEWS
• SEMI-STRUCTURED (OR FOCUSED) INTERVIEWS ARE USED WHEN RESEARCHERS HAVE A LIST OF
TOPICS OR BROAD QUESTIONS THAT MUST BE ADDRESSED IN AN INTERVIEW.
• INTERVIEWERS USE A WRITTEN TOPIC GUIDE (OR INTERVIEW GUIDE) TO ENSURE THAT ALL
QUESTION AREAS ARE COVERED.
• THE INTERVIEWER’S FUNCTION IS TO ENCOURAGE PARTICIPANTS TO TALK FREELY ABOUT ALL THE
TOPICS ON THE GUIDE.
FOCUS GROUP INTERVIEWS
• FOCUS GROUP INTERVIEWS ARE INTERVIEWS WITH GROUPS OF ABOUT 5 TO 10 PEOPLE WHOSE
OPINIONS AND EXPERIENCES ARE SOLICITED SIMULTANEOUSLY.
• THE INTERVIEWER (OR MODERATOR) GUIDES THE DISCUSSION ACCORDING TO A TOPIC GUIDE.
DIARIES
• PERSONAL DIARIES HAVE LONG BEEN USED AS A SOURCE OF DATA IN HISTORICAL RESEARCH.
• THE THINK ALOUD METHOD HAS BEEN USED TO COLLECT DATA ABOUT COGNITIVE PROCESSES,
SUCH AS THINKING, PROBLEM-SOLVING, AND DECISION-MAKING.
• THIS METHOD INVOLVES HAVING PEOPLE USE AUDIO-RECORDING DEVICES TO TALK ABOUT
DECISIONS AS THEY ARE BEING MADE OR WHILE PROBLEMS ARE BEING SOLVED, OVER AN
EXTENDED PERIOD (E.G. THROUGHOUT A SHIFT).
• THE THINK ALOUD METHOD HAS BEEN USED TO COLLECT DATA ABOUT COGNITIVE PROCESSES,
SUCH AS THINKING, PROBLEM-SOLVING, AND DECISION-MAKING.
• THIS METHOD INVOLVES HAVING PEOPLE USE AUDIO-RECORDING DEVICES TO TALK ABOUT
DECISIONS AS THEY ARE BEING MADE OR WHILE PROBLEMS ARE BEING SOLVED, OVER AN
EXTENDED PERIOD (E.G. THROUGHOUT A SHIFT).
Open-ended question
Closed- ended question
Many structured instruments, however,
Closed-ended questions (or fixed- also include some open-ended
alternative questions) are ones in which questions, which allow participants to
the response alternatives are respond to questions in their own words.
prespecified by the researcher. The When open-ended questions are
alternatives may range from a simple included in questionnaires, respondents
yes or no to complex expressions of must write out their responses. In
opinion. The purpose of such questions is interviews, the interviewer writes down
to ensure comparability of responses responses verbatim or uses a tape-
and to facilitate analysis. recorder for later transcription.
INSTRUMENT CONSTRUCTION
• IN DRAFTING (OR BORROWING) QUESTIONS FOR A STRUCTURED INSTRUMENT, RESEARCHERS
MUST CAREFULLY MONITOR THE WORDING OF EACH QUESTION FOR CLARITY , SENSITIVITY TO
RESPONDENTS’ PSYCHOLOGICAL STATE, ABSENCE OF BIAS, AND (IN QUESTIONNAIRES)
READING LEVEL.
• DRAFT INSTRUMENTS ARE USUALLY CRITICALLY REVIEWED BY PEERS OR COLLEAGUES AND THEN
PRETESTED WITH A SMALL SAMPLE OF RESPONDENTS.
• THE DEVELOPMENT AND PRETESTING OF SELF-REPORT INSTRUMENTS CAN TAKE MANY MONTHS
TO COMPLETE.
SCALE AND OTHER FORMS OF STRUCTURED SELF-
REPORT
SCALE
VIGNETTES
Q-SORTS
1. SCALE
LIKERT SCALE
• THE MOST COMMON SCALING TECHNIQUE IS THE LIKERT SCALE, WHICH CONSISTS OF SEVERAL
DECLARATIVE STATEMENTS (ITEMS) THAT EXPRESS A VIEWPOINT ON A TOPIC. RESPONDENTS ARE
ASKED TO INDICATE HOW MUCH THEY AGREE OR DISAGREE WITH THE STATEMENT.
SEMANTIC DIFFERENTIAL
• ANOTHER TECHNIQUE FOR MEASURING ATTITUDES IS THE SEMANTIC DIFFERENTIAL (SD).
• WITH THE SD, RESPONDENTS ARE ASKED TO RATE CONCEPTS (E.G., DIETING, EXERCISE) ON A SERIES
OF BIPOLAR ADJECTIVES, SUCH AS GOOD/BAD, EFFECTIVE/INEFFECTIVE, IMPORTANT/UNIMPORTANT.
• RESPONDENTS PLACE A CHECK AT THE APPROPRIATE POINT ON A SEVEN-POINT SCALE THAT
EXTENDS FROM ONE EXTREME OF THE DIMENSION TO THE OTHER.
• SDS ARE FLEXIBLE AND EASY TO CONSTRUCT, AND THE CONCEPT BEING RATED CAN BE VIRTUALLY
ANYTHING— A PERSON, CONCEPT, CONTROVERSIAL ISSUE, AND SO ON.
• THE SCORING PROCEDURE FOR SD RESPONSES IS SIMILAR TO THAT FOR LIKERT SCALES. SCORES
FROM 1 TO 7 ARE ASSIGNED TO EACH BIPOLAR SCALE RESPONSE, WITH HIGHER SCORES GENERALLY
ASSOCIATED WITH THE POSITIVELY WORDED ADJECTIVE.
• RESPONSES ARE THEN SUMMED ACROSS THE BIPOLAR SCALES TO YIELD A TOTAL SCORE.
VISUAL ANALOG SCALE (VAS)
• ANOTHER TYPE OF PSYCHOSOCIAL MEASURE IS THE VISUAL ANALOG SCALE (VAS), WHICH
CAN BE USED TO MEASURE SUBJECTIVE EXPERIENCES, SUCH AS PAIN, FATIGUE, AND DYSPNEA.
• THE VAS IS A STRAIGHT LINE, THE END ANCHORS OF WHICH ARE LABELED AS THE EXTREME
LIMITS OF THE SENSATION OR FEELING BEING MEASURED.
• PARTICIPANTS AREASKED TO SORT THE CARDS ALONG A SPECIFIED BIPOLAR DIMENSION, SUCH
AS AGREE OR DISAGREE.
• TYPICALLY, THERE ARE BETWEEN 50 AND 100 CARDS TO BE SORTED INTO 9 OR 11 PILES, WITH
THE NUMBER OF CARDS TO BE PLACED IN EACH PILE PREDETERMINED BY THE RESEARCHER.
• SELF-REPORT METHODS HAVE SOME WEAKNESSES. THE MOST SERIOUS ISSUE CONCERNS THE
VALIDITY AND ACCURACY OF SELF-REPORTS
• YOU SHOULD ALSO BE AWARE OF THE MERITS OF UNSTRUCTURED AND STRUCTURED SELF-
REPORTS.
QUALITATIVE
TECHNIQUES
IMPORTANT DIMENSIONS IN OBSERVATIONAL
STUDIES
Concealment.
Duration.
• 2. THE PARTICIPANTS—“WHO” QUESTIONS. WHO IS PRESENT? WHAT ARE THEIR CHARACTERISTICS AND
ROLES? WHO IS GIVEN ACCESS TO THE SETTING?
• 3. ACTIVITIES—“WHAT” QUESTIONS. WHAT IS GOING ON? WHAT ARE PARTICIPANTS DOING? WHAT
METHODS DO THEY USE TO COMMUNICATE, AND HOW FREQUENTLY DO THEY DO SO?
• 4. FREQUENCY AND DURATION—“WHEN” QUESTIONS. WHEN DID THE ACTIVITY BEGIN AND END? IS THE
ACTIVITY A RECURRING ONE AND, IF SO, HOW REGULARLY DOES IT RECUR?
• 5. PROCESS—“HOW” QUESTIONS. HOW IS THE ACTIVITY ORGANIZED? HOW DOES THE EVENT UNFOLD?
• 6. OUTCOMES—“WHY” QUESTIONS. WHY IS THE ACTIVITY HAPPENING, OR WHY IS IT HAPPENING IN THIS
MANNER? WHAT DID NOT HAPPEN (ESPECIALLY IF IT OUGHT TO HAVE HAPPENED) AND WHY ?
2. GATHERING PARTICIPANT OBSERVATION DATA
• MULTIPLE POSITIONING INVOLVES MOVING AROUND THE SITE TO OBSERVE BEHAVIORS FROM
DIFFERENT LOCATIONS.
• FIELD NOTES REPRESENT THE OBSERVER’S EFFORTS TO RECORD INFORMATION AND TO SYNTHESIZE AND
UNDERSTAND THE DATA.
• DESCRIPTIVE NOTES (OR OBSERVATIONAL NOTES) ARE OBJECTIVE DESCRIPTIONS OF EVENTS AND
CONVERSATIONS, AND THE CONTEXTS WITHIN WHICH THEY OCCURRED.
• REFLECTIVE NOTES DOCUMENT RESEARCHERS’ PERSONAL EXPERIENCES, REFLECTIONS, AND PROGRESS IN THE
FIELD, AND CAN SERVE A NUMBER OF DIFFERENT PURPOSES.
• CATEGORY SYSTEMS ARE THE BASIS FOR CONSTRUCTING A CHECKLIST, WHICH IS THE
INSTRUMENT OBSERVERS USE TO RECORD OBSERVED PHENOMENA.
• THE CHECKLIST IS USUALLY FORMATTED WITH THE LIST OF BEHAVIORS OR EVENTS FROM THE
CATEGORY SYSTEM ON THE LEFT AND SPACE FOR TALLYING THE FREQUENCY OR DURATION OF
OCCURRENCE OF BEHAVIORS ON THE RIGHT
1. CATEGORIES AND CHECKLIST
NONEXHAUSTIVE SYSTEM
• NONEXHAUSTIVE SYSTEMS ARE ADEQUATE FOR MANY PURPOSES, BUT ONE RISK IS THAT
RESULTING DATA MIGHT BE DIFFICULT TO INTERPRET. WHEN A LARGE NUMBER OF BEHAVIORS
ARE NOT CATEGORIZED, THE INVESTIGATOR MAY HAVE DIFFICULTY PLACING CATEGORIZED
BEHAVIOR INTO PERSPECTIVE.
2. RATING SCALES
• IS A TOOL THAT REQUIRES OBSERVERS TO RATE SOME PHENOMENA IN TERMS OF POINTS ALONG
A DESCRIPTIVE CONTINUUM.
EVENT SAMPLING
• WITH EVENT SAMPLING, RESEARCHERS SELECT INTEGRAL BEHAVIORS OR EVENTS TO OBSERVE.
EVENT SAMPLING REQUIRES RESEARCHERS TO EITHER HAVE KNOWLEDGE ABOUT THE
OCCURRENCE OF EVENTS OR BE IN A POSITION TO WAIT FOR THEIR OCCURRENCE.
• EXAMPLES OF INTEGRAL EVENTS THAT MAY BE SUITABLE FOR EVENT SAMPLING INCLUDE SHIFT
CHANGES OF NURSES IN A HOSPITAL AND CARDIAC ARRESTS IN THE EMERGENCY ROOM.
EVALUATING THE OBSERVATIONAL METHODS
• POSSIBLE ETHICAL PROBLEMS AND REACTIVITY OF THE OBSERVED WHEN THE OBSERVER IS
CONSPICUOUS.
• BIOPHYSIOLOGIC MEASURES ARE RELATIVELY ACCURATE AND PRECISE, ESPECIALLY COMPARED WITH
PSYCHOLOGICAL MEASURES, SUCH AS SELF-REPORT MEASURES OF ANXIETY , PAIN, AND SO FORTH.
• BIOPHYSIOLOGIC MEASURES ARE OBJECTIVE. TWO NURSES READING FROM THE SAME SPIROMETER OUTPUT
ARE LIKELY TO RECORD IDENTICAL TIDAL VOLUME MEASUREMENTS, AND TWO SPIROMETERS ARE LIKELY TO
PRODUCE THE SAME READOUTS. PATIENTS CANNOT EASILY DISTORT MEASUREMENTS OF BIOPHYSIOLOGIC
FUNCTIONING.