Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Green Adhesives Using Tannin and Cashew Nut Shell Liquid For Environment-Friendly Furniture Materials
Green Adhesives Using Tannin and Cashew Nut Shell Liquid For Environment-Friendly Furniture Materials
Green Adhesives Using Tannin and Cashew Nut Shell Liquid for
Environment-friendly Furniture Materials
Jeong-Hun Lee, Jisoo Jeon, Sumin Kim†
Abstract: Sick building syndrome symptoms that are experienced by building occupants may be
caused by toxic substances such as formaldehyde and VOCs, which are known to be emitted
from building materials and wood composite products such as wood-based panel, furniture, en-
gineered flooring and construction adhesive. In Korea, the use of wood composite products for
indoor environments has increased over the last decade. Recently, wood composite products
have been installed in approximately 95% of newly constructed residential buildings. The use of
these products has resulted in problems related to human health, and consequently a realization
about the importance of indoor air quality. In addition, consumer demand is increasing for nat-
ural materials because conventional building materials and wood composite products are made
by adding urea-formaldehyde resin or they contain formaldehyde-based resin. More recently,
many efforts have been made to reduce formaldehyde emission from building materials that laid
in the indoor environment. Especially, if conventional formaldehyde-based adhesives are re-
placed with green adhesives for residential spaces, it is possible to reduce most of the emission
amounts of formaldehyde in indoor environments. In line with this expectation, many re-
searches are being conducted using natural materials such as tannin and cashew nut shell liquid
(CNSL). This study discussed the affects and possibilities of green adhesives to reduce form-
aldehyde emission in indoor environments.
219
220 Jeong-Hun Lee, Jisoo Jeon, Sumin Kim
R = H : procyanidin : R = OH : prodelphinidin
Fig. 2. Chemical structure of wattle tannin (Acacia Fig. 3. Chemical structure of proanthocyanidins and re-
mearnsil) flavonoids (Bisanda et al. 2003). action with formaldehyde (Ping et al. 2011).
Chemically, tannins are made up of complex name of Nox Primer for the treatment of rusted
phenolic compounds of high molecular weight, steel surfaces prior to painting.
ranging from 500 to 20,000. There are two main ∙Rust converter to transform oxidized steel in-
categories of tannins: (a) hydrolysable tannins to a smooth sealed surface.
(HT) and (b) condensed tannins (CT). Generally, ∙Wood adhesives for bonding wood chips in
tannins are soluble in water, with the exception producing particle board building materials.
of some very high molecular weight compounds. ∙Rust inhibitor where tannin is added to min-
HTs are readily soluble in water, making it possi- eral oil to protect cold rolled steel from corrosion
ble for them to react with other substances to during transportation or storage.
yield a wide range of water-soluble chemicals
such as gallic acid (-gallotannins) or ellagic acid 2.2. Preparation of Tannin Based-adhesive
(-ellagitannins). Fig. 1 shows the chemical struc- Wood adhesive condensed tannins with for-
tures of simple phenols obtained in HT. CTs laldehyde, have been used industrially since the
(Proanthocyanidis) have a condensed chemical 1970s for the interior and exterior wood bonding
nature, even though they are still capable of un- of products such as particleboard and plywood.
dergoing further condensation reactions. They They are obtained by the hardening of polymeric
have complex chemical structures made of fla- flavonoids by polycondensation with form-
vonoid units, with variations on the sites at which aldehyde, involving their more reactive A-ring
the flavan bonds are created. In general, CTs according to Fig. 3. Thus, it was demonstrated
have rigid carbon–carbon bonds that cannot be that condensed tannins are both chemically and
broken easily by hydrolysis. Fig. 2 shows the economically interesting for the preparation of
chemical structure of wattle tannin (Acacia adhesives and that they could be successfully
mearnsii) flavonoids according to Pizzi (Pizzi used as substitutes for phenol in the production of
1983, 2006). resins (Pinga et al. 2011).
A wide range of other industrial applications Generally, most tannin-based adhesives are
have been found for tannins, in addition to their fortified with a synthetic polymer system such as
widespread use in tanneries. These include an use commercial UF (Bisanda et al. 2003; Pizzi
in the manufacture of inks for dyeing of textiles, 2006), commercial PF (Vazquez et al. 2003), re-
and as a corrosion inhibitor. In Chile and Brazil, sorcinol-formaldehyde (Wen and Wei 2006) and
a variety of products have been developed from isocyanates (Batubenga 1995).
tannin (Bisanda et al. 1992): T. Tabarsa et al. studied four types of resins:
∙Anti-corrosive primer, sold under the brand PF, T10%PF, T20%PF, and T30%PF, which
were tannin-modified PF resins containing 0, 10, 2.3. Discussion of Tannin Based Adhesive
20%, and 30% tannin content, respectively. The The objective of T. Tabarsa’s work is to eval-
PF resin was supplied in liquid form, and before uate the mechanical and physical properties of
an use, a 2% by weight hardener zink acetate [Zn three-layer boards made with wheat straw and
(CH3COO)2] was added and the mixture was bonded with a tannin-based adhesive. The me-
thoroughly stirred. The tannin was extracted chanical properties of panels were evaluated by
from oak (Quercus castaneifolia) trees. The mod- static bending, modulus of rupture (MOR) and
ification of the PF resin was made through the modulus of elasticity (MOE), the internal bond
substitution of 10, 20% and 30% of a solution of (IB) tests. Physical properties such as water ab-
40% tannin extract (Tabarsa et al. 2011). sorption (WA) and thickness swelling (TS) in wa-
A. Moubaric et al. studied cornstarch-que- ter were determined. In general, all types of straw
bracho tannin-based resins designed as adhesive panels produced in this work met the MOR,
in plywood production. The resol type of phenol MOE, IB and TS requirements for general uses
formaldehyde with a solids content of 46% and a according to European standards. Although the
viscosity of about 450 cp was prepared using a wheat straw boards made with tannin-modified
2.2 : 1 formaldehyde: phenol ratio and 7.3% PF resins had slightly poorer mechanical proper-
(w/w) of NaOH. The resols were prepared in a ties compared to the boards made with pure PF,
two liter glass reactor with mechanical stirring the T10% PF resin showed higher bond ability
and temperature control. The necessary amount than other modified PF resins. The highest
of reactive according to the established for- MOR, MOE, IB and the lowest WA and TS were
mulation was fed into the reactor, and when the achieved at a 12 min press time and by using
operating temperature was reached 90°C, the ex- Type 10% PF resin. An increase in the press time
tension of reaction was monitored, measuring the positively affected the physical and mechanical
resol viscosity at 25°C. The adhesives were pre- properties of the panels produced. With respect
pared by copolymerisation at the room temper- to the findings of the study, it may be stated that
ature of cornstarch and quebracho bark tannins wheat straw can be used as a promising raw ma-
in variable quantities with the previously pre- terial for panel production with the use of a tan-
pared resols (Moubarika et al. 2009). nin-modified PF adhesive.
S. Kim studied PVAc/Tannin hybrid adhesives The aim of Amine A. Moubarik’s work was to
in accordance with the wt% of tannin. The pre- demonstrate the performances of cornstarch–
pared adhesives were used on the face of the dec- quebracho tannin-based resins designed as adhe-
orative veneer bonding of engineered flooring sives in plywood production. The cornstarch and
and the formaldehyde emission level and surface quebracho tannin was introduced in the classic
bond strength were evaluated. PVAc was added adhesive formulation in order to supply part of
to the natural tannin adhesive to increase the vis- the phenol–formaldehyde (PF). The physical
cosity of tannin adhesive for surface bonding. For properties of rheological characterization, ther-
tannin/PVAc hybrid adhesives, 5, 10, 20% and mogravimetric analysis and solid phase 13C
30% of PVAc were added to the natural tannin NMR analysis of the formulated resins were
adhesives (Kim 2009). measured. In order to evaluate the mechanical
performances of optimal cornstarch–quebracho
Table 1. Formaldehyde and TVOC emission of engineered flooring bonded with naturaladhesive and tannin/PVAc
hybrid adhesives by desiccator and FLEC methods (Kim 2009)
2
Equipment Dessicator (mg/L) FLEC (mg/m h)
Formaldehyde
Air pollutant a
Formaldehyde TVOC
Non-coated Coated
Natural tannin adhesive 1.19 0.34 0.2 0.32
Tannin90/PVAc10 1.32 0.44 0.21 0.39
Tannin80/PVAc20 1.33 0.47 0.21 0.4
a
UV curable urethane acrylate coating.
Fig. 8. Bonding strength between the face of the deco- Fig. 9. Formaldehyde emission from engineered floor-
rative veneer and plywood substratein engineered floor- ing bonded with CNSL-formaldehyde (CF) resin and
ing: CNSL-formaldehyde (CF) resin and CF/PVAc CF/PVAc green adhesives as determined by thedesicca-
green adhesives (Kim 2010). tor method (Kim 2010).
erably less than phenol. P. A. Mahanwar ex- resin based on CNSL can be employed in adhe-
perimentally investigated the effect of replacing sive formulations. It improves the bonding
phenol with CNSL on the properties of novolak strength of Al-Al significantly. The addition of
and resole resins. The addition of CNSL into 3-aminopropyl triethoxy silane improves the
phenol seems to increase reaction times for the shear strength and peel strength of adhesives used
preparation of novolak as well as resole type in metal-to-metal bonding considerably. Although
resins. When CNSL with an acid value of more the copolymerization of crude CNSL and phenol
than 10 was used, no satisfactory resin could be has generally led to some deterioration of shear
formed. The resulting mass was only a viscous and peel performance compared to the case of
fluid with very low resin content. This suggests pure phenol- based resins, considering the low
that only CNSL with an acid value less than 10 cost of CNSL and its renewable nature, the parti-
was suitable for resin preparation. In conclusion, al use of CNSL for this adhesive application is an
the addition of CNSL leads to a decrease in ten- attractive proposal (Lubi and Thachil 2006).
sile strength but an improvement in the impact S. Kim carried out the reduction of form-
strength and electrical properties of the resole aldehyde and VOCs emission from wood-based
resins. CNSL with an acid value above 10 is un- flooring by green adhesive CNSL. In this study,
suitable for making resins (Mahanwar and Kale to discuss the reduction of formaldehyde and
1996). VOC emissions from engineered flooring, CNSL-
CNSL is a desirable starting material for adhe- formaldehyde (CF) resin and CF/PVAc resin
sive formulations due to its renewable nature, were applied for the maple face of the veneer
high polarity, inherent tackiness of phenolic ma- bonding on plywood. The bonding strengths of
terials, and ease with which liquid-to-solid con- the engineered flooring samples bonded with CF
versions can be accomplished. M. Lubi C. and resin and PVAc are shown in Fig. 8. The bonding
Eby Thomas Thachils’study aims to investigate strengths of the non-treated (before boiling), en-
the effect of the incorporation of CNSL-based gineered flooring samples made using CF/PVAc
resin in neoprene adhesive formulations. Phenolic hybrid adhesives were considerably higher than
those of the CF resin. With increasing PVAc con- to the overall properties of the resin (Papadopou-
tent, the bonding strength was increased until a lou and Chrissafis 2011).
PVAc content of 20% was obtained. Fig. 9 The understanding of the thermal character-
shows that the CF resin and CF/PVAc resin sys- istics of the CNSL resin curing is essential for the
tems with UV coating satisfied the E1 and E0 materials selection, design and manufacture of
grades of the Korean Standard. Before surface natural fiber reinforced composite material.
coating, the formaldehyde emissions from the Therefore, there is intense interest in under-
products glued with CF resin were already less standing the curing characteristics and properties
than the E1 grade of the formaldehyde emission of CNSL-based resins. In L. Y. Mwaikambo
level in the Korean Standard, even though the CF and M. P. Ansells’s work the DSC technique has
resin contained formaldehyde. Renewable phe- been applied to study the change in the glass tran-
nolic compounds from trees and plants such as sition temperature of the oven-cured resin with
tannin, lignin and CNSL were successfully ap- and without HMTA in order to monitor the ex-
plied as a thermosetting wood adhesive for wood tent of the cure. The glass transition temperature
panels to reduce formaldehyde emission. These was found to rise when the alkaline catalysed res-
renewable phenolic compounds give excellent in was subjected to higher curing temperatures re-
adhesive performance, good moisture resistance, gardless of the concentration of formaldehyde
and tend to give a lower formaldehyde emission used. The mode of cure of the NaOH-catalysed
than UF resin (Kim 2010). CNSL-formaldehyde resin has been found to be
In E. Papadopoulou and K. Chrissafisbs’ study, more regular with HMTA hardener. FT-IR spec-
an experimental phenol–formaldehyde resin troscopy has been used to study the neat CNSL
with 20% phenol replacement by CNSL was and polymerised CNSL-formaldehyde resin with
studied and compared with a conventional phe- and without HMTA. The use of the DSC and
nol–formaldehyde resin synthesized totally from FT-IR techniques to elucidate the extent of cure
petrochemical raw materials. The adhesion strength of CNSL resins is a valuable step towards the pro-
of these resins was investigated by their applica- duction of commercially successful CNSL-natu-
tion in plywood production. The plywood panels ral fiber composites.
were tested for their shear strength and wood fail-
ure performance while their free formaldehyde 4. Summary
emissions were determined with the desiccator
method. It was proved that although the neat Tannin is a renewable resource obtained from
CNSL modified PF resin (PCF) cures at a longer plants such as Acacia sp., Eucalyptus sp., Mirtus
time and higher temperature than a conventional sp., Acer sp., Betula sp., Salix Caprea, Pinus sp.
PF resin, wood affects it more significantly, re- (pine), etc. Also, CNSLs are a by-product of the
sulting in curing on the evening of their curing agriculture industry. They are naturally occuring
performance. This is a novel finding that mani- phenolic substances. Being an agricultural by-
fests the possibility of replacing a conventional product, they have the advantages of low cost
PF resin by a CNSL modified resin in the ply- and renewable supply. They can replace phenol
wood production, without changing any of the in many applications. Tannins and CNSL are
production conditions and with an improvement groups of natural resins that are receiving wide
exposed to concrete and hwangto building environ- Schmidt-Etkin, D. 1992. Office furnishings/equipment
ments. Environ. Toxicol. 22: 264-274. & IAQ health impacts, prevention & mitigation.
Lubi, C. and E. T. Thachil. 2006. Studies on Metal- Indoor Air Quality Update. Arlington, MA, USA:
to-Metal Adhesives Based on CNSL Resins, Polymer- Cutter Information Corporation.
Plastics Technology and Engineering, 45. Kim, S. 2009. Environment-friendly adhesives for sur-
Menzies, D. and J. Bourbeau. 1997. Building related face bonding of wood-based flooring using natural
illnesses. New Eng. J. Med. 337: 1524-1531. tannin to reduce formaldehyde and TVOC emis-
Otson, R. and P. Fellin. 1992. Characterization and sion, Bioresource Technology 100: 744-748.
cycling. In: Nriagu JO, editor. Gaseous pollutants. Kim, S. 2010. The reduction of formaldehyde and
New York: John Wiley and Sons. 335-421. VOCs emission from wood-based flooring by green
Mahanwar, P. A. and D. D. Kale. 1996. Effect of cash- adhesive using cashew nut shell liquid (CNSL),
ew nut shell liquid (CNSL) on properties of phenolic Journal of Hazardous Materials 182: 919-922.
resins, Journal of Applied Polymer Science 61: Tabarsa, T., S. Jahanshahi, and A. Ashori. 2011.
2107-2111. Mechanical and physical properties of wheat straw
Pickrell, J. A., L. C. Griffis, B. V. Mokler, C. H. boards bonded with a tannin modified phenol–
Hobbs, G. M. Kanapilly, and A. Bathija. 1986. formaldehyde adhesive. Composites: Part B. 42:
Formaldehyde release rate coefficients from selected 176-180.
consumer products. Washington, DC. In: Meyer B, Vazquez, G., J. Gonzalez-Alvarez, F. Lopez-Suevos,
Andrews B, Reinhardt RM, editors. Symposium ser- and G. Antorrena. 2003. Effect of veneer side wett-
ability on bonding quality of Eucalyptus globules
ies, formaldehyde release from wood products.
plywoods prepared using a tannin - phenol - form-
American Chemical Society Symposium Series,
aldehyde adhesive. Bioresour. Technol. 87: 349-353.
385: 40-51.
Wen, J. L. and C. L. Wei. 2006. Properties of re-
Pizzi, A., editor. 1983. Wood adhesives-chemistry and
sorcinol - tannin - formaldehyde copolymer resins
technology. Marcel Dekker Inc.
prepared from the bark extracts of Taiwan acacia
Pizzi, A. 2006. Recent developments in eco-efficient
and china fir. Biores. Technol. 97: 257-264.
bio-based adhesives for wood bonding: oppor-
Kim, Y. H., E. S. An, S. Y. Park, and B. K. Song.
tunities and issues. J. Adhesion Sci. Technol. 20:
2007. Enzymatic epoxidation and polymerization of
829-846.
cardanol obtained from a renewable resource and
Ikeda, R., H. Tanaka, H. Uyama, and S. Kobayashi.
curing of epoxide-containing polycardanol, J. Mol.
2000. A new crosslinkable polyphenol from a re-
Catal. B: Enzym. 45: 39-44.
newable resource, Macromol. Rapid Commun. 21:
Yu, C. and D. R. Crump. 1998. A review of the emis-
496-499.
sion of VOCs from polymeric materials used in
Park, S. Y., Y. H. Kim, and B. K. Song. 2005. Polymer
buildings, Building and Environment 33: 357-374.
synthesis by enzyme catalysis, Polym. Sci. Technol.
16: 342-353.