Address: 501, Pujit Plaza, Palm Beach Date

Road, Sector-11, Near CBD Station, Opp 7/19/2022

K-Star Hotel, CBD Belapur, Navi Mumbai, By
Maharashtra 400614 MS
Name of Project-Rehabilitation and upgradation of existing road to two lane with paved shoulder configuration from Design chainage Km. 36/400 to Km.
107/224 of NH-167BG from Duttaluru (at NH-565 junction) to Kavali (joining on NH-16) in the state of Andhra Pradesh on EPC mode.
two lane with paved shoulder in the State of Andhra Pradesh on EPC mode
Comments on MJB_CH 41+498 (1x10x4m)

Sr.
Comments from DCSL Compliance from Design Director Remarks
No.

1 Slope of stone pitching shall be 2:1 in width direction as per SP GAD, DRG No. HELP-STR-MNB-
13:2004 according to Plate. GAD-03 (SH 01 OF 02)

In drawing, Bore log mentioned as VUP @Ch 27+030 at A1 site, GAD, DRG No. HELP-STR-MNB-
Please verify and correct. GAD-03 (SH 01 OF 02)
2 Kindly add the calculation for braking force as per IRC 6:2017 Cl. Design note MNB(1x10x4m)
211.2
3 Kindly apply the impact factor for Vehicular loading as per IRC Design note MNB(1x10x4m)
6:2017 Cl. 208
4 In design, Maximum stresses in steel at Top of Bottom Slab is Design, Page No. 26
338.2Mpa which is exceeding permissible stresses as 300Mpa
(taken to avoid fatigue check for rare combination as per IRC 112-
2011 Ammendment Oct 13, A-8). Kindly redesign and resubmit.

5 In design, Maximum crack width at Top of Bottom Slab is Design, Page No. 27
0.618mm which is exceeding permissible crack width as 0.3mm
for severe condition as per IRC 112, Table12.1. Kindly redesign
and resubmit.
6 In design, Maximum crack width at Side Wall Bottom Corner is Design, Page No. 41
0.496mm which is exceeding permissible crack width as 0.3mm
for severe condition as per IRC 112, Table12.1. Kindly redesign
and resubmit.

7 Please provide Hydrology report

8 Mention the name of Design consultant and Authority engineer in GAD, DRG No. HELP-STR-MNB-
Drawings. GAD-03 (SH 01 OF 02)
9 Please provide Geotech report
 Horizontal Vertical Horizontal Moment
Node L/C Fx Mton Fy Mton Fz Mton Mx kN-m My kN-m Mz kN-m
201 101 -5.696 105.808 3.514 298.852 -0.119 502.131
102 -5.902 105.628 3.806 322.559 -0.119 519.122
103 -18.398 48.361 8.052 687.720 -0.357 1612.228
104 -9.851 97.242 21.751 1766.704 -0.392 851.109
105 -30.339 -27.689 7.300 590.522 -0.827 2588.419
202 101 -6.037 143.582 3.509 299.436 -0.084 522.256
102 -6.244 144.549 3.801 323.144 -0.084 539.287
103 -18.584 209.200 8.003 687.990 -0.276 1629.906
104 -10.180 184.382 21.654 1765.774 -0.104 871.830
105 -30.106 242.745 7.218 590.778 -0.728 2597.602
203 101 -5.761 111.136 3.466 296.096 -0.011 506.159
102 -5.967 110.582 3.762 320.033 -0.011 523.167
103 -18.496 40.700 8.143 692.620 -0.033 1617.535
104 -9.956 60.210 22.208 1790.031 -0.051 856.109
105 -30.452 -34.850 7.392 595.541 -0.310 2594.158
204 101 -6.017 149.265 3.477 297.572 -0.010 521.527
102 -6.224 149.859 3.773 321.508 -0.010 538.553
103 -18.584 202.332 8.105 693.420 -0.032 1629.756
104 -10.161 147.641 22.109 1788.972 -0.145 869.851
105 -30.135 236.549 7.298 594.988 -0.337 2598.711
205 101 -5.767 104.059 3.360 290.017 0.011 506.682
102 -5.974 103.465 3.656 313.954 0.011 523.709
103 -18.512 32.227 8.046 687.071 0.034 1618.491
104 -9.997 55.197 22.197 1789.184 0.146 858.313
105 -30.466 -36.447 7.373 594.649 0.339 2594.812
206 101 -5.996 145.264 3.378 291.852 0.009 520.608
102 -6.203 145.818 3.674 315.789 0.009 537.616
103 -18.554 196.935 8.010 687.935 0.031 1628.162
104 -10.124 143.089 22.094 1787.770 0.052 867.639
105 -30.124 235.525 7.264 592.786 0.309 2597.951
207 101 -5.740 67.529 3.140 277.308 0.085 504.842
102 -5.947 66.562 3.432 301.016 0.085 521.874
103 -18.494 -14.477 7.718 668.129 0.280 1616.471
104 -9.996 0.315 21.668 1757.097 0.101 856.933
105 -30.414 -61.480 7.128 580.726 0.735 2590.339
208 101 -5.988 113.767 3.156 279.045 0.117 519.944
102 -6.195 113.947 3.448 302.751 0.117 536.935
103 -18.533 154.832 7.676 668.519 0.353 1626.083
104 -10.128 89.838 21.579 1756.431 0.393 866.604
105 -30.126 210.864 7.011 578.127 0.819 2596.490

Maximum Axial Load -5.696 242.745 22.208 1790.031 0.819 2598.711

Minimum Axial Load -30.466 -61.480 3.140 277.308 -0.827 502.131