Trevor Quirk, tmq@qlflaw.

com
1
Aletheia Gooden
2 877 S Victoria Ave., Ste. 111
Ventura, CA 93003
3 Telephone: (805) 650-7778
4 Facsimile: (866) 728-7221

5 Trevor Quirk, Trustees of the Quirk/Gooden Family Trust, Roe 199;

Aletheia Gooden, Trustee of the Quirk/Gooden Family Trust, Roe 95
6
7 SUPERIOR COURT OF THE STATE OF CALIFORNIA

8 FOR THE COUNTY OF LOS ANGELES

9 SANTA BARBARA CHANNELKEEPER, a Case No.: 19STCP01176
10 California non-profit corporation,
CROSS-DEFENDANTS TREVOR QUIRK
11 Petitioner, & ALETHEIA GOODEN’S REQUEST
v. FOR JUDICIAL NOTICE
12
13 STATE WATER RESOURCES CONTROL Trial Date: 03/16/2022
BOARD, et al., Time: 8:30 AM
14 Place: Dept. SS10
15 Respondents.
______________________________________
16 CITY OF SAN BUENAVENTURA, et al.,
17 Cross-Complainant,
18 v.
DUNCAN ABBOTT, an individual, et al.,
19
Cross-Defendants.
20
21 TO ALL PARTIES AND THEIR ATTORNEYS OF RECORD HEREIN:
22 PLEASE TAKE NOTICE that on March 16, 2022, at 8:30 a.m. in Dept. SS10 of this Court,
23 located at 312 N Spring Street, Los Angeles, California, Cross-Defendants Trevor Quirk and
24 Aletheia Gooden (“Cross-Defendants”), will move this Court for an Order taking judicial notice
25 of:
26 • Code of Federal Regulations § 328.3;
27 • City of Ventura Legal Report, Agenda Item No. 8E dated November 20, 2018;
28 • City of Ventura Response to Public Records Act Request dated February 22, 2022;
______________________________________________________________________________
REQUEST FOR JUDICIAL NOTICE
1
 1 • United States Department of Commerce letter dated August 29, 2007 and
2 accompanying draft biological opinion; and
3 • The definition of material provided in Black’s Law Dictionary, Seventh Addition
4 • The definition of material provided in Merriam Webster’s Collegiate Dictionary,
5 Tenth Edition.
6
Memorandum of Points & Authorities
7
8 The Court is required to take judicial notice of Code of Federal Regulations § 328.3 as
9 Evidence Code § 451(a) provides [j]udicial notice shall be taken of the statutory law of the United
10 States.
11 Similary, the Court is required to take judicial notice of the definitions of substantial and
12 material as Evidence Code § 451(e) provides [j]udicial notice shall be taken of all English words
13 and phrases and of all legal expressions.
14 Pursuant to Evidence Code 452, the Court may take judicial notice of the City of Ventura’s
15 Legal Report, Response to Public Records Act Request and the United States Department of
16 Commerce letter and draft biological opinion.
17 Based on the foregoing, Cross-Defendants request the Court take judicial notice of the
18 above-mentioned items.
19
DATED: March 2, 2022.
20
21
By: ________________________
22 Trevor Quirk
23 Cross Defendant

24
25
26
27
28

______________________________________________________________________________
REQUEST FOR JUDICIAL NOTICE
2
1 PROOF OF SERVICE

2 Santa Barbara Channelkeeper vs. State Water Resources Control, et al.

Los Angeles County Superior Court, Case No. 19STCP01176
3
I declare that I am over the age of 18 and not a party to this action. My business address is 877 S. Victoria
4 Ave., Suite 111, Ventura, California 93003.

5 1. CROSS-DEFENDANTS TREVOR QUIRK AND ALETHEIA GOODEN’S

MOTION IN LIMINE
6 2. CROSS-DEFENDANTS TREVOR QUIRK AND ALETHEIA GOODEN’S
7
REQUEST FOR JUDICIAL NOTICE
3. CROSS-DEFENDANTS TREVOR QUIRK AND ALETHEIA GOODEN’S
8 DECLARATION IN SUPPORT OF JUDICIAL NOTICE
4. CROSS-DEFENDANTS TREVOR QUIRK AND ALETHEIA GOODEN’S PRE-
9 TRIAL STATEMENT
10 5. NOTICE TO APPEAR [CUSTODIAN OF RECORDS CITY OF VENTURA]

11 on the interested parties in this action by placing a true and correct copy of each document thereof, enclosed

12 in a sealed envelope, addressed as follows:

SEE SERVICE LIST
13

14 [X] By E-mail or Electronic Transmission. Based on an agreement of the parties to accept service by
15 e-mail or electronic transmission, I caused the documents to be sent to the persons at the e-
mail address(es) listed above. I did not receive, within a reasonable time after the
16
transmission, any indication that the transmission was unsuccessful.
17

18 [X] (State) I declare under penalty of perjury under the laws of California that the above is true and
correct.
19
Executed on March 2, 2022 at Ventura, California.
20 _______________________________
21 Esteban Minero

22

23

24

25

26

27

28
1 SERVICE LIST
2

3 Shawn D. Hagerty, Esq. Matthew Bullock

shawn.hagerty@bbklaw.com Deputy Attorney General
4 BEST BEST & KRIEGER LLP California Department of Justice
655 West Broadway Natural Resources Law Section
5
15th Floor 455 Golden Gate Ave., Suite 11000
6 San Diego, California 92101 San Francisco, CA 94102-7004
Telephone: (619) 525-1300 Tel: (415) 510-3376
7 Facsimile: (619) 233-6118 matthew.bullock@doj.ca.gov
Attorneys for Respondent and Defendant
8
CHRISTOPHER MARK PISANO, Bar No. State
9 192831 Water Resources Control Board
christopher.pisano@bbklaw.com
10 SARAH CHRISTOPHER FOLEY, Bar No. Robert N. Kwong
277223 Dennis O. La Rochelle
11
sarah.foley@bbklaw.com Arnold Larochelle Mathews Vanconas &
12 PATRICK D. SKAHAN, Bar No. 286140 Zirbel, LLP
Patrick.Skahan@bbklaw.com 300 Esplanade Dr Ste 2100
13 BEST BEST & KRIEGER LLP Oxnard, CA 93036
14
300 South Grand Avenue Tel: (805) 988-9886
25th Floor rkwong@atozlaw.com
15 Los Angeles, California 90071 Attorneys for Cross-Defendant Casitas
Telephone: (213) 617-8100 Municipal Water District
16 Facsimile: (213) 617-7480
Patrick Loughman
17 Attorneys for Respondent and Cross
Cristian Arrieta
Complainant, City of San Buena Ventura
Lowthorp, Richards, McMillan, Miller &
18
Templeman
Daniel Cooper
19 300 Esplande Drive, Suite 850
Sycamore Law
Oxnard, CA 93036
20 1004 O'Reilly Ave.
Tel: 805.804.3848
San Francisco CA 94129
Ploughman@lrmmt.com
21 Tel: (415) 360-2962
Carrieta@lrmmt.com
daniel@sycamore.law
22 Attorneys for Cross-Defendants Ernest Ford,
Attorneys for Petitioner and Plaintiff
Tico Mutual Water Company, and Betty
23 Santa Barbara Channelkeeper
Withers and Betty Bow Withers Trust
24

25

26

27

28
1 Marc N. Melnick Gregory J. Patterson
Deputy Attorney General William W. Carter
2
Attorney General's Office Musick, Peeler & Garrett LLP
3 1515 Clay Street, 20th Floor 2801 Townsgate Road, Suite 200
P.O. Box 70550 Westlake Village, CA 91361
4 Oakland, CA 94612-0550 Tel: (805) 418-3103
5
Tel: 510-879-0750 Fax: (805) 418-3101
Marc.melnick@doj.ca.gov g.patterson@musickpeeler.com
6 Attorneys for Respondent and Defendant w.carter@musickpeeler.com
State Attorneys for Cross-Defendants Robert C.
7 Water Resources Control Board Davis, Jr.; James Finch; Topa Topa Ranch &
8 Nursery, LLC; The Thacher School; Thacher
Eric M. Katz Creek Citrus, LLC; Ojai Oil Company; Ojai
9 Supervising Deputy Attorney General Valley School; Sharon Hamm-Booth and
Noah Golden – Krasner David Robert Hamm, Co-Trustees of The
10
Deputy Attorney General Hamm 2004 Family Trust Dated April 29,
11 Carol Boyd 2004; Reeves Orchard, LLC; and Ojai Valley
Deputy Attorney General Inn, Edward J. Conner, Edward J. Conner,
12 300 South Spring Street, Suite 1702 Trustee of the Edward J. Conner Trust, Roe
Los Angeles, CA 90013 56; Friend’s Ranches, Inc.; Finch Farms,
13
Tel. (213) 269-6343 LLC; Red Mountain Land & Farming, LLC;
14 Fax (213) 897-2802 James Finch, Trustee of the Finch Family
Eric.Katz@doj.ca.gov Trust
15 Noah.goldenrasner@doj.ca.gov
Carol.boyd@doj.ca.gov
16
Attorneys for Proposed Intervenor California Jeanne Zolezzi
17 Department of Fish & Wildlife Herum Crabtree Suntag
5757 Pacific Avenue, Suite 222
18 Edward J. Casey Stockton, CA 95207
19
Gina Angiolollo Tel: (209) 472-7700
Ha Chung Fax: (209) 472.7986
20 Alston & Bird LLP jzolezzi@herumcrabtree.com
333 South Hope Street, 16th Floor Attorneys for Cross-Defendants Meiners Oaks
21 Los Angeles, CA 90071 Water District and Ventura River Water
22 Tel: 213.576.1000 District
ed.casey@alston.com
23 gina.angiolillo@alston.com
Ha.Chung@alston.com
24
Attorneys for Cross-Defendants AGR
25 Breeding, Inc.; Bentley Family Limited
Partnership; and Southern California Edison
26 Company
27

28
1 Ryan Blatz Lindsay F. Nielson
Blatz Law Firm Law Office of Lindsay F. Nielson
2
206 N. Signal St. Suite G 845 E Santa Clara Street
3 Ojai, CA 93023 Ventura, CA 93001
Tel: (805) 646-3110 Tel: 805-658-0977
4 ryan@ryanblatzlaw.com nielsonlaw@aol.com
5
Attorneys for Cross-Defendants Troy Becker Attorneys for Cross-Defendant Meiners Oaks
and Jeri Becker; Janet Boulton; Michael Water District, Ventura River Water District,
6 Boulton; Michael Caldwell; Joseph Peter and Jean Marie Webster, Trustee of The
Clark, successor in interest to the Joseph Roger E. and Jean Marie Webster Trust
7 Clark and Linda Epstein Family Trust; Linda
8 Louise Epstein, successor in interest to the
Joseph Clark and Linda Epstein Family Trust;
9 Michael I. Cromer and Jody D. Cromer;
Neal P. Maguire
Michel A. Etchart, Trustee of the Michel A.
10 Ferguson Case Orr Patterson LLP
Etchart Separate Property Trust, and Mark W.
1050 South Kimball Road
11 Etchart, Trustee of the Mark W. Etchart
Ventura, CA 93004
Sepertate Property Trust; Lawrence
Tel: (805) 659-6800
12 Hartmann; Ole Konig; Krotona Institute of
nmaguire@fcoplaw.com
Theosophy; Stephen Michtell and Kathleen
13 Attorneys for Cross-Defendants Rancho
Reid Mitchell, Trustees of the Stephen
Matilija Mutual Water Company; Bettina
14 Mitchell and Byron Katie Trust; North Fork
Chandler, Trustee of the Bettina Chandler
Springs Mutual Water Company; Stephen
15 Trust; Martin Gramckow and Linda
Robert Smith, Trustee of the Charles R. Rudd
Gramckow individually; Martin Gramckow,
and Lola L. Rudd Trust, dated May 20, 2976;
16 Trustee of the Monika G. Huss Irrevocable
Shlomo Raz; Sylvia Raz; Senior Canyon
Trust, Trustee of the Karin W. Gramckow
17 Mutual Water Company; Siete Robles Mutual
Irrevocable Trust, and Trustee of the Kurt J.
Water Company; Soule Park Golf Course,
18 Gramckow Irrevocable Trust
Ltd.; Telos, LLC; Victor C. Timar, Jr. Trustee
19
of the Timar Family Trust; John Town;
Trudie
Thomas S. Bunn III
20 Town; Asquith Family Limited Partnership,
Elsa Sham
Ltd.; Burgess Ranch; Cary Cheldin; Cynthia
21 Lagerlof Senecal Gosney & Kruse LLP
Daniels; Wayne Francis; David Friend; The
301 N. Lake Avenue, 10th Floor
22 Larry & Pat Hartmann Family Trust; The
Pasadena, CA 91101-5123
John
Tel.: (626) 793-9400
23 N. Hartmann Trust; Gary Hirschkron; Cheryl
Fax: (626) 793-5900
Jensen; Lutheran Church of the Holy Cross of
24 tombunn@lagerlof.com
Ojai, California; Janice Sattler (Mineo); Eitan
esham@lagerlof.com
25 Sloustcher; Rogers-Cooper Memorial
Attorneys for Cross-Defendant St. Joseph’s
Foundation; Robert Norris (not yet appeared);
Associates of Ojai, California, Inc. and St.
26 Patricia Norris; Old Creek Road Mutual
Joseph's Health and Retirement Center, Janis
Water Company (not yet appeared); Margaret
27 Long Nicholas, John Jay Nicholas, Jess Earl
Vanderfin; Telos Ojai, LLC (not yet
Long (aka Jess E. Long), Johana Rae Long,
28 appeared); Jennifer Ware; The Walker Jr.
and Mary Margaret Long, Janis Long
1 Living Trust; David Altman, Trustee of the Nicholas and Jess E. Long as Trustees of the
1190 El Toro Trust ; Babtiste Foundation; Long Family Trust
2
Sean A. Bennett and Leslie Bennett, Trustees
3 of the Bennett Family Trust; Dwayne A.
Bower and Marilyn E. Bower Trustees of the Michael J. Van Zandt
4 Bower Family Trust; Mark Terry Cline and Nathan A. Metcalf
5
Bonnie Burreson Cline, Trustees of the Mark Sean G. Herman
Terry Cline and Connie Burreson Cline Hanson Bridgett LLP
6 Revocable Trust; Robert R. Daddi and 425 Market Street, 26 Floor
Darlene J. Daddi; Lucille A. Elrod, Trustee of San Francisco, CA 94105
7 the John and Lucille Elrod Family Trust; Tel: 415-777-3200
8 Friend's Stable & Orchard Inc. Daniel Fax: 415-541-9366
Hultgen, Trustee of the Hultgen Living Trust; mvanzandt@hansonbridgett.com
9 Ojai Golf, LLC; Three Oaks, LLC, Erica J. nmetcalf@hansonbridgett.com
Abrams, Trustee of the Erica J. Abrams Trust; sherman@hansonbridgett.com
10
Raul E. Alvarado and Hildegard M. Alvarado, Attorneys for Cross-Defendant Ventura
11 Trustees of the Alvarado Family Trust; County Watershed Protection District and
William Armstrong and April Nardini; Joseph County of Ventura
12 Lynn Barthelemy and Elvira Lilly
Barthelemy, Trustees of the Joseph Lynn
13
Barthelemy and Elvira Lilly Barthelemy 2002 Jeffrey E. Barnes
14 Family Trust; James S. Bennett and Carolyn Chief Assistant County Counsel
D. Bennett, Trustees of the Bennett Family Jason Canger
15 Trust; Sumeet Bhatia and Michael McDonald; Assistant County Counsel
John Joseph Broesamle and Katharine Sue Office of Ventura County Counsel
16
Broesamle, Trustees of the Broesamle Family 800 South Victoria Avenue, L/C #1830
17 Trust; Richard Aaron Carlson, Trustee of the Ventura, CA 93009
Richard Aaron Carlson Trust and Michelle Tel.: (805) 654-2879
18 Larson, Trustee of the Michelle Larson Fax: (805) 654-2185
19
Family Trust; Thomas D. Carver and Cynthia jason.canger@ventura.org
L. Carver; Dana Ceniceros, Trustee of the Attorneys for Cross-Defendants
20 Dana and Dawn Ceniceros Revocable Living Ventura County Watershed Protection District
Trust; Deborah Lys Martin Crawford; Frank and County of Ventura
21 Clay Creasey Jr.; Debra Joy Reed, Trustee of
22 The Debra Joy Reed Revocable Trust Dated
November 3, 1994; Frederic Devault; Diana Scott Slater
23 Syvertson, Trustee of the Diana Syvertson Bradley Herrema
Living Trust; Dive Deep L.L.C.; Douglas Roy Christopher Guillen
24
Parent and Ann Marie Parent; William Brownstein Hyatt Farber Schreck LLP
25 Erickson; Gelb Enterprises, L.P.; Jan Stephen 1021 Anacapa Street, 2nd Floor
Granade and Priscilla K. Granade, Trustees of Santa Barbara, CA 93101
26 the Granade Family Revocable Living Trust; Tel: (805) 963-7000
Margot J. Griswold; Brian C. Haase and Fax: (805) 965-4333
27
Marie Haase, Trustees of the B&M Haase sslater@bhfs.com
28 Trust Dated October 8, 2019; Thomas Lann bherrema@bhfs.com
1 Harper and Jadona Collier-Harper; Ojai- cguillen@bhfs.com
Jackman L.L.C.; Kevin Rainwater and Attorneys for Cross-Defendant The Wood-
2
Marianne Ratcliff; Keith M. Nightingale and Claeyssens Foundation
3 Victoria V. Nightingale, Trustees of The
Nightingale Family Trust; Heide C. Kurtz,
4 Trustee of The Kurtz Family Trust Dated Joseph C. Chrisman
5
January 19, 2019; Randall Leavitt, Trustee of Hathaway, Perrett, Webster, Powers,
The Randall B. Leavitt 2010 Trust; Edward C. Chrisman & Gutierrez
6 Leicht and Jacqueline M. Leicht, Trustees of 5450 Telegraph Road
The Leicht Family 2013 Revocable Trust Ventura, CA 93003
7 Dated March 1, 2013; Paul Lepiane and (805) 644-7111
8 Bengtson Bo; Robert Levin and Lisa Solinas, jchrisman@hathawaylawfirm.com
Trustees of The Levin Family Living Trust; Attorneys for Cross-Defendant Wood-
9 Francis Longstaff and Shauna Longstaff, Claeyssens Foundation
Trustees of The Longstaff Trust Dated
10 Jeffrey M. Oderman
October 11, 2018; Mandy Macaluso, Trustee
Douglas J. Dennington
11 of The Living Trust of Mandy Macaluso;
Jeremy N. Jungreis
Marilyn Wallace, Trustee of The Marilyn
Rutan & Tucker, LLP
12 Wallace Separate Property Trust; Daniel J.
611 Anton Boulevard, Suite 1400
McSweeney and Yoko McSweeney; Wendell
13 Costa Mesa, CA 92626-1931
M. Mortensen and Laura L. Mortensen,
Tel: 714-641-5100
14 Trustees of The Mortensen Family Revocable
Fax: 714-546-9035
Trust; Timothy Jerome Murch and Jody
15 joderman@rutan.com
Caren
ddennington@rutan.com
Murch, Trustees of The Jodim Family 2007
16 jjungreis@rutan.com
Trust Dated July 31, 2007; Chris E. Platt and
Attorneys for Cross-Defendant Casitas
17 Hanh H. Platt; Robert Erickson, Trustee and
Municipal Water District
Ronald Wilson; Michael D. Robertson and
18 Kimberly A. Robertson, Trustees of The
19
Robertson Family Trust; James P. Robie, Thomas E. Jeffry
Trustee of the Robie Family Trust; Petter Debra J. Albin-Riley
20 Romming and Kimi Romming, Trustees; Arent Fox LLP
Marc Saleh, Trustee of The Saleh Family 555 West Fifth Avenue, 48th Floor
21 Trust; Konrad Stefan Sonnenfeld, Trustee of Los Angeles, CA 90013-1065
22 The Konrad Stefan Sonnenfeld Living Trust; (213) 629-7400
Mark Sutherland, Trustee of The Sutherland (213) 629-7401
23 Marital Trust; John H. Thacher and Caroline Thomas.jeffry@arentfox.com
H. Thacher, Trustees of The Thacher Family Attorneys for Cross-Defendant Community
24
Trust Dated January 2004; Gilbert G. Memorial Health System
25 Vondriska and Carolyn J. Vondriska, Trustees
of The Vondriska Living Trust; William D.
26 Rusin, Sr., Trustee of the William D. Rusin Andrew Brady
Sr. Revocable Trust; Oscar D. Acosta, Trustee DLA Piper LLP (US)
27
of the Acosta Trust; Chris E. Platt and Hanh 550 South Hope Street, Suite 2400
28 H. Plat; Deborah Lys Martin Crawford; Diane Los Angeles, CA 90071-2618
1 Syvertson, Trustee of the Diana Syvertson Tel. (213) 330-7700
Living Trust; Erica J. Abrams, Trustee of the Fax: (213) 330-7701
2
Erica J. Abrams Trust; Frank Clay Creasey andrew.brady@us.dlapiper.com
3 Jr.; Frederic DeVault; Gilbert G. Vondriska Attorneys for Cross-Defendant Integritas
and Carolyn J. Vondriska, Trustees of the Ojai,
4 Vondriska Living Trust; James P. Robie, LLC
5
Trustee of the Robie Family Trust; John H.
Thacher and Caroline H. Thacher, Trustees of
6 the Thacher Family Trust dated January 2004; Jennifer T. Buckman
Mandy Macaluso, Trustee of the Living Trust Andrew J. Ramos
7 of Mandy Macaluso; Margot J. Griswold; Holly Jacobson
8 Mark Sutherland, Trustee of the Sutherland Bartkiewicz Kronick & Shanahan, PC
Marital Trust; Randall Leavitt, Trustee of the 1011 Twenty-Second Street
9 Randall B. Leavitt 2010 Trust; Raul E. Sacramento, CA 95816-4907
Alvarado and Hildegard M. Alvarado, trustees Tel. (916) 446-4254
10 Fax (916) 446-4018
of the Alvarado Family Trust; Sumeet Bhatia
11 and Michael McDonald; Timothy Jerome jtb@bkslawfirm.com
Murch and Jody Caren Murch, Trustees of the hjj@bkslawfirm.com
12 Jodim Family 2007 Trust dated July 31, 2007; Attorneys for Cross-Defendant City of Ojai
Wendell M. Mortensen and Laura L.
13
Mortensen, Trustees of the Mortensen Family
14 Revocable Trust; Petter Romming and Kimi David R. Krause-Leemon
Romming, Trustees; William Armstrong and BEAUDOIN & KRAUSE-LEEMON LLP
15 April Nardini; William Erickson; Rancho 15165 Ventura Blvd., Suite 400
Sueño, LLC Sherman Oaks, CA 91403
16 Tel. (818) 205-2809
17 William G. Short, Esq. Fax (818) 788-8104
Law Offices of William G. Short david@bk-llaw.com
18 Post Office Box 1313 Attorneys for Cross-Defendant RDK Land,
Ojai, California 93024-1313 LLC
19
Tel: (805) 490-6399
20 Fax: (805) 640-1940
billshortesq@me.com Brian A. Osborne
21 Attorney for Cross-Defendant Robin Bernhoft Osborne Law Firm
Anthony Lee Francois 674 County Square Drive, Suite 308
22 Ventura, CA 93003
Briscoe Ivester & Bazel LLP
23 235 Montgomery Street, Suite 935 Tel. (805) 642-9283
San Francisco, CA 94104 Fax (805) 642-7054
24
Tel: (415) 402-2707 osbornelawyer@gmail.com
Fax (415) 398-5630 Attorney for Cross-Defendants Brian A.
25
tfrancois@briscoelaw.net Osborne; Ronald W. Rood and Susan B.
26 Attorney for Cross-Defendant Robin Bernhoft Rood, Trustees of the Rood Family Trust

27
Peter A. Goldenring
28 Mark R. Pachowicz
1 Eric J. Schindler Pachowicz | Goldenring A Professional Law
Michelle J. Berner Corporation
2
Kroesche Schindler LLP 6050 Seahawk Street
3 2603 Main Street, Suite 200 Ventura, CA 93003-6622
Irvine, CA 92614 Tel. (805) 642-6702
4 Tel. (949) 387-0495 Fax (805) 642-3145
5
Fax (888) 588-0034 Fax attorneys@gopro-law.com
eschindler@kslaw.legal peter@gopro-law.com
6 mberner@kslaw.legal mark@pglaw.law
Attorneys for Cross-Defendant Oak Haven, Attorneys for Cross-Defendant The Manfred
7 LLC Krankl and Elaine V. Krankl Living Trust
8
Adam D. Wieder
9 Barry C. Groveman Karen A. Feld
Ryan Hiete Daniel S. Roberts
10 Groveman Hiete LLP Cole Huber LLP
11 35 East Union Street, Suite B 3401 Centrelake Drive, Suite 670
Pasadena, CA 91103 Ontario, CA 91761
12 Tel (626) 747-9383 Tel: (909) 230-4209
Fax (626) 747-9370 Fax: (909) 937-2034
13 kfeld@colehuber.com
awieder@grovemanhiete.com
14 bgroveman@grovemanhiete.com droberts@colehuber.com
rhiete@grovemanhiete.com Attorneys for Cross-Defendant Ventura
15 Attorneys for Cross-Defendant Michael Unified School District
Bradbury; Heidi Bradbury; and The Heidi
16
Gramkow Trust
17 T&D Nevada Trust
Ernest J. Guadiana Dennis and Antoinette Mitchell
18 Elkins Kalt Weintraub Reuben Gartside LLP Mitchell Homes Inc.
10345 W. Olympic Boulevard P.O. Box 360
19
Los Angeles, CA 90064 Ojai, CA 93024
20 Tel. (310) 746-4425 (805) 340-2890
eguadiana@elkinskalt.com amitc74383@aol.com
21 Attorneys for Michael Lombardo and Charles
L. Ward III, as Co-Trustees of the Ward-
22 12293 topa Lane
Lombardo Living Trust
23 Santa Paula, CA 93060
David A. Ossentjuk Tel. (323) 493-3737
24 Ossentjuk & Botti micboehm@me.com
2815 Townsgate Road, Suite 320
25
Westlake Villge, CA 91361
26 Tel: (805) 557-8081 Dennis and Nadine Corte
Fax: (805) 456-7884 12812 MacDonald Drive
27 DOssentjuk@oandblawyers.com Ojai, CA 93023
Attorney for Cross-Defendant Robert Martin Tel. (805) 701-1950
28
1 Hermitage Mutual Water Company, and dwcorte@outlook.com
Santa
2

3 Ana Ranch, Inc. Jacob Slujter

Attn: J. Roger Essick Rabindra Singh
4 2955 Hermitage Road 1070 McAndrew Road.
Ojai, CA 93023 Ojai CA 93023; Tel.
5
Tel. (805) 320-1406 (805) 646-2726
6 rogeressick@gmail.com ED@KFA.ORG
In Propria Persona for Krishnamurti
7 Julie A. Baker Foundation of America
8
2193 Maricopa Hwy
Ojai, CA 93023
9 (805) 646-8700
Jandjbaker2@gmail.com
10
The Joseph Fedele 1995 Living Trust, Kelton Lee Gibson
11 878 Oak Grove Court
Oriana Marie Fedele, Trustee
12 Attn. Oriana Fedele Ojai, CA 93023
P.O. Box 298 Tel. (805) 701-9318
13 Lahaina, HI 96767 kgibson@mwgjlaw.com
Tel. (818) 601-3161 kgibson878@gmail.com
14
orianafedele@gmail.com Kelton Lee Gibson, Trustee of the Gibson
15 Family Trust, dated June 6, 2006
Anthonie M. Voogd
16 918 Palomar Road
17 Ojai, CA93023 Rebecca C. Collins
Tel. (805) 646-1512 Thomas M. Collins, Jr.
18 avoogd@stanfordalumni.org 241 Longhorn Lane
Ojai, CA 93023
19
Lawrence S. Mihalas Tel. 805-312-5894
20 Trustees of the Mihalas Family Trust tominojai@gmail.com
419 21st Place collinst3@sbcglobal.net
21 Santa Monica, CA 90402
Tel. (310) 739-0700
22
lmihalas@gmail.com Claude R. and Patricia E. Baggerly
23 lmihalas@ucla.edu 119 S. Poli Avenue
Ojai, CA 93023-2144
24 Heather Blair Tel. (805) 646-0767
556 So. Fair Oaks Ave., Ste 101 Tel. (805) 766-7317
25
Box 356 russ.baggerly65@gmail.com
26 Pasadena, CA 91105
Tel. (626) 755-6566
27 Hblair1946@gmail.com David R. Greifinger
Law Offices of David R. Greifinger
28
15515 West Sunset Blvd., No. 214
1 Martin Hartmann Pacific Palisades, CA 90272
Whitney Hartmann Tel. (424) 330-0193
2
430 S. Carrillo Road tracklaw@me.com
3 Ojai, CA 93023 Attorney for Cross-Defendants Danny Everett
Tel. (805) 798-2253 and Tiarzha Talyor
4 earthbuilding@gmail.com
5
Robert K. Cartin George and Sigrid Bressler
6 Cartin Family LLC 340 Longhorn Lane
505 Estremoz Ct. Ojai, CA 93023
7 Oceanside, CA 92057 Tel. (805) 646-1221
8 Tel. (760) 429-4738 andybsail@gmail.com
bob.cartin@dvm.com
9
Loa E. Bliss
10
Loa E. Bliss 2006 Revocable Trust
Peter Duchesneau
11 9030 Ojai Santa Paula Road
Sigrid R Waggener
Ojai, CA 93023
Mannat, Phelps & Phillips, LLP
12 Tel: (617) 750-8500
One Embarcadero Center, 30th Floor
loabliss@hotmail.com
13 San Francisco, CA 94111
Te.l (415) 291-7400
14 Del Cielo LLC
Fax (415) 291-7474
Attn. Tim Carey, Managing Member
15 pduchesneau@manatt.com
22410 Hawthorne Boulevard, Suite 5
swaggener@manatt.com
Torrance, CA 90505
16 Attorneys for Cross-Defendant Aera Energy,
Tel. (310) 787-6569
LLC
17 tim@calvoterguide.com
18 Joyce Syme, and
Judith L. Mercer
The Joyce A. Syme Living Trust
19 c/o of Jason Goldman
1760 Ocean Avenue
Mercer Family Trust Agreement of 1992
20 Santa Monica, CA 90401
1175 Grand Avenue
Tel. (310) 403-1760
21 Ojai, CA 93023
seaviewmotel@hotmail.com
Tel. (310) 625-7795
22 jgoldman@begroup.com
Janice and Jesse Hillestad
23 9611 N. Ventura Ave.
Henry D. Finkelstein
Ventura, CA 93001
24 Brian Moskal
Tel. (310) 614-8438
Greenberg Glusker Fields Claman &
25 janicehillestad@icloud.com
Machtinger LLP
jessehillestad@gmail.com
26 2049 Century Park East, Suite 2600
Los Angeles, CA 90067
Dale and Patricia Givner
27 Tel. (310) 553-3610
12617 Koenigstein Rd.
Fax (310) 553.0687
28 Santa Paula, CA 93060
hfinkelstein@ggfirm.com
1 Tel. (805) 525-9524 bmoskal@greenbergglusker.com
dalegivner@gmail.com Attorneys for Ginnetti Living Trust, and
2
Baldwin Ranch, LLC
3 Carlos A Mejia
Kelley M. Rasmussen, Trustee
Sophie A Wenzlau
4 2420 Park Road
Department of Justice
Lake Oswego, OR 97034
1300 I Street, Suite 125
5 Tel. (805) 798-7125
P.O. Box 944255
kelleyras@gmail.com
6 Sacramento, CA 94244-2550
Tel. (916) 210-6379
7 Angela Small Booth, Attorney
Fax: (916) 327-2319
2175 Valley Meadow Drive
8 sophie.wenzlau@doj.ca.gov
Oak View, CA 93022
carlos.mejia@doj.ca.gov
Tel. (805) 765-5413
9 Attorneys for California Department of Parks
angie@angiesmall.org
and Recreation
10
William E. Colborn, Jr.
11 Harry D. Sims and Raymond P. Sims
13183 Ojai Road
P.O. Box 1870
Santa Paula, CA 93060
12 Ojai, CA 93024
Tel. (805) 795-1909
Tel. (805) 646-0167
13 jake@colbornandassociates.com
1978simsfamilytrust@gmail.com
14 Rebecca Tickell
Tiernan Dolan
15 350 Verano Drive
995 Riverside St.
Ojai, CA 93023
Ventura, CA 93001
16 Tel. (323) 559-5700
tdolan@hacityventura.org
rebecca@bigpictureranch.com
17 Attorney for Cross-Defendants Housing
Authority of the City of San Buenaventura,
18 Joshua Beckman
Triad Properties, Inc., Encanto Del Mar
913 Oso Road
Apartments, L.P., Villages at Westview I LP,
19 Ojai, CA 93023
Vista Del Mar Commons, LP, and Soho
Tel. (323) 404-0465
20 Associates, L.P.
joshbfbp@gmail.com
21
Gregg S. Garrison
22 Garrison Law Corporation
12986 MacDonald Drive
23 Andrew K. Whitman
Ojai, CA 93023
821 N. Signal Street
24 Tel. (650) 726-1111 / Fax: (805) 669-3168
Ojai, CA 93023
gsgarrison@garrisonlawcorp.com
25 Tel. (805) 444-5671
Attorney for Cross-Defendants Gregg S.
sfreberg@scr-legaliner.com
Garrison, Rosanna Garrison, Emily V. Brown,
26 In pro per and Atty for Cross-Defendants
Trustee of The Restated Emily V. Brown
Andrew K. Whitman and Heidi A. Whitman;
27 Intervivos Trust, Roe 37, and Denise
Nancy L. Whitman; John R. Whitman and
Wizman, as Trustee of the Denise Wizman
28 Nancy L. Whitman Family Trust
Revocable
1 Trust, Carty Ojai, LLC
Christopher Danch
2
16200 Maricopa Highway Robert L. Smith
3 Ojai, CA 93023 12777 Tree Ranch Road
Tel. (805) 640-8534 Ojai, CA 93023
4 chrisdanch@gmail.com Tel. (805) 558-6322
5
Attorney for Cross-Defendants Angie Marie treeranch@ymail.com
Genasci and Christopher Paul Danch,
6 Trustees Susan M. Glennon
of the Genasci-Danch Family Trust; and 292 Cruzero Street
7 Donald and Wendy Givens Ojai, CA 93023
8 Tel. (805) 646-4816
Paul R. Huff theglennonnest@aol.com
9 The Huff Law Firm APC
21 S. California Street, Suite 205
10
Ventura, CA 93001 Robin Schwartzburd
11 Tel. (805) 667-8940 411 Franklin Drive
Fax (805) 850-7399 Ojai, CA 93023
12 phuff@hufffirm.com Tel. (805) 272-5877
Attorneys for Barnard Properties, LLC robin.schwartzburd@gmail.com
13

14 Alessandro (Alex) Lobba Melinda Hass

Alessandro Lobba and Mary E. Jackson, 11947 Koenigstein Road
15 individually as Trustees of the Lobba-Jackson Santa Paula, CA 93060
Family Trust Tel. (213) 713-4360
16
947 Casitas Vista Road mlynnbooking@gmail.com
17 Ventura, CA 93001
Tel. (805) 895)-7056 Malinda K. Vaughn
18 alobba@gmail.com Mitchell B. Vaughn
19
12283 Ojai Santa Paula Road
Christine Steiner Ojai, CA 93023-9323
20 2560 Ladera Road Tel. (805) 890-6616
Ojai, CA 93023 vaughnmb@aol.com
21 Tel. (31) 600-3220
22 csteiner@csteinerlaw.com Rebecca D. Schwermer
P. O. Box 174
23 William Slaughter Santa Paula, CA 93061
Slaughter, Reagan & Cole, LLP Tel. (805) 551-3494
24
625 East Santa Clara Street, Suite 101 octoberbabies2@verizon.net
25 Ventura, CA 93001
Tel. (805) 658-7800 Jennifer Jordan Day and Joel Fox
26 Fax (805) 644-2131 909 North Rice Road
slaughter@srllplaw.com Ojai, CA 93023
27
Attorneys for The Boyd S. Dron and Karin Tel. (213) 321-5253
28 Dron Joint Living Trust, and Sisar Mutual jenniferjordanday@gmail.com
1 Water Company
Brigitte Lovell, Trustee of Lovell Living
2
Julia Taft-Whitman, President CEO Trust
3 Taft Corporation’ 295 Encino Drive
111 West Topa Topa Street Oak View, CA 93022
4 Ojai, CA 93023 Tel. (915) 227-9412
5
Tel. (805) 794-2837 loveb9@gmail.com
juliawhitman@gmail.com
David L. Osias, Esq.
6
Allen Matkins Leck Gamble Mallory &
Jaide Whitman, President
7 Natsis LLP
Julia Whitman, Director
One America Plaza
8 Conservation Endowment Fund
600 West Broadway, 27th Floor
P.O. Box 6
San Diego, CA 92101-0903
9 Oak View, CA 93022
Tel. (619) 233-1155
Tel. (805) 649-2333
10 Fax (619) 233-1158
Tel. (805) 804-7005
dosias@allenmatkins.com
11 jaide.whitman@gmail.com
Attorneys for Cross-Defendant
TaftGardensOffice@gmail.com
12
Jeff Bacon as Trustee of the Villa Nero Trust
Dated January 25, 2000
Catherine Ferro &
13
Catherine Eileen Ferro Inter Vivos Trust
Laura M. Peakes
14 312 Montana Road
John E. Peakes, Jr.
Ojai, CA 93023
15 316 Verano Drive
Tel. (805) 326-1686
Ojai, CA 93023
cepharoah@gmail.com
16 Tel. (805) 402-0249
jpeakesjr@aol.com
17 Susan C. White
Steven J. White
18 Kelsey Klein
2 Shorewood Drive
Paula Kee
Bellingham, WA 98225
19 1042 Fairview Road
Tel. (425) 891-9249
Ojai, CA 93023
20 curranwhite1@hotmail.com
Tel. (805) 640-5154
21 kelseyklein88@gmail.com

22 Laura R. Schreiner, a.k.a Laura Rearwin

418 Crestview Drive
23 Susan Capper
Ojai, CA 93023
12870 Tree Ranch Road
24 Tel. (805) 479-5400
Ojai, CA 93023
laura@rearwin.com
25 Tel. (805) 794-6421
chelsue@aol.com
26 Paul J. Deneen
12170 Ojai Santa Paula Road
Lindy & Karen C. Goetz
27 Ojai, CA 93023-9358
12338 Linda Flora
Tel. (805) 218-0211
28 Ojai, CA 93023-9721
paul@carbide.com
1 Tel. (805) 649-2526; (805) 794-2312
lindygoetz@roadrunner.com Jennifer Carafelli
2
Robin Schwartzburd
3 Joyce L. Heath 211 Village Commons Boulevard, No. 21
Joyce Heath, Trustee of the Heath Family Camarillo, CA 93012
4 Living Trust, Tel. (805) 340-2540
5
P.O. Box 1323 carafelli@gmail.com
Ojai, CA 93024
6 Tel. (805) 290-6231 Timothy Mahoney
mamaheath55@gmail.com 10244 Ojai Santa Paula Road
7 Ojai, CA 93023
8 Thomas M. German Tel. (323) 252-3309
301 N. Drown Avenue honedog@mac.com
9 Ojai, CA 93023
Tel. (805) 646-2130
10
kittycatgirl214@gmail.com Thomas Adams
11 Adams & Associates
Ronald W. Bowman 21781 Ventura Boulevard, Suite 10005
12 Trustee of the Bowman Trust dated April 8, Woodland Hills, CA 93003
2011 Tel. (805) 229-1529
13
672 W. Villanova Road tom@adamsassocs.com
14 Ojai, CA 93023 Attorneys for Cross-Defendant 235 La Luna
Tel. (805) 732-4014 Owners, an unincorporated association
15 ron@l-binc.com
Salvatore Scarpato
16
Andrew P. Byrne, Esq. 106 Calhoun Lane
17 1140 Highland Avenue, Ste. 250 Georgetown, TX 78633
Manhattan Beach, CA 90266 Tel. (805) 797-8767
18 Tel. (310) 505.7170 salscarpato@att.net
19
Andy@ByrneLaw-LA.com
Attorney for Cross-Defendant Roman Robert Kyle
20 Catholic Archdiocese of Los Angeles, a sole The Robert Kyle Living Trust
Corporation 715 Sunset Place
21 Ojai, CA 93023
22 Amy Hueppe Tel. (626) 260-5509
1025 Moreno Drive robertkyle61@gmail.com
23 Ojai, CA 93023
Tel. (310) 699-4619 William R. Thatcher
24
amychueppe@gmail.com 12195 Linda Flora Drive
25 Ojai, CA 93023-9723
thelostplanetairmen@yahoo.com
26
Glenn Bator David Bishop
27
338 Montana Road Sophie Loire
28 Ojai, CA 93023 Tel. (805) 403-5370
1 Tel. (805) 798-1802 frenchiephotos@yahoo.com
denibator@aol.com
2
Chet Hilgers
3 Harry Anthony Williams Mellanie Hilgers
915 Daly Road mellaniehilgers@gmail.com
4 Ojai, CA 93023
5
Tel. (661) 609-1253 Stephanie Gustafson
Tel. (805) 794-6922 Tel. (805) 646-1423
6 awilliam@me.com sgustafson@ovs.org
7 Bryan M. Sullivan, Esq.
8 EARLY SULLIVAN WRIGHT GIZER & Erin E. Holebrook
McRAE LLP Jerald M. Montoya
9 6420 Wilshire Boulevard, 17th Floor Steven J. Dadaian
Los Angeles, CA 90048 Erick L. Solares
10
Tel. (323) 301-4660 Julie Del Rivo
11 bsullivan@earlysullivan.com Tucker Wisdom-Stack
Attorneys for Cross-Defendant 100 South Main Street, 1300
12 Jeff Bacon as Trustee of the Villa Nero Trust Los Angeles, California 90012-3702
Dated January 25, 2000 Tel. (213) 687-6000
13
Fax (213) 687-8300
14 Kristi Schoeld Tucker.Wisdom-Stack@dot.ca.gov
Neil Jorgensen
15 Tel. (805)272-8360 Kathleen Janetatos Smith, Trustee of the
neilkristi@googlemail.com Smith Family 2020 Revocable Trust dated
16
January 3, 2020, Roe 426
17 Robert Turnage Tel. (805) 844-2093
9902 Sulphur Mountain Road kathismith@sbcglobal.net
18 Ojai, CA 93023
19
Tel. (916) 837-3907 Tom Maloney
Robert.turnage@sbcglobal.net Executive Director
20 Authorized Representative for Cross- Ojai Valley Land Conservancy
Defendant Meher Mount Corporation P.O. Box 1092
21 Ojai, CA 93024
22 Tel. (805) 649-6852 Ext. 1
tom@ovlc.org
23 Linda J.G. MacDougall, Trustee of The Linda
J.G. MacdDugall Living Trust Adam C. Kear
24
Marsha Kee Strong-Chandler 1940 N. Saint Andrews Pl.
25 Richard Holt Robinson Los Angeles, CA 90068
119 E. Channel Islands Blvd. Phone (323) 481-9392
26 Port Hueneme, CA 93041 ackear@gmail.com
(805) 202-6379 Attorney for Cross-Defendant Senior Canyon
27
speakerholistic@gmail.com Mutual Water Company (co-counsel w/Ryan
28 Blatz)
1 Gerrold Grigsby
Karen Grigsby William Francis Tarantino
2
9799 Ojai Santa Paula Road Justin Fisch
3 Ojai, CA 93023 Morrison & Foerster LLP
Tel. (805) 649-1624 425 Market St. |
4 grigsbyranch@gmail.com San Francisco, CA 94105
5
Tel. (415) 268-7850
James A. Vickman jfisch@mofo.com
6 Vickman & Associates wtarantino@mofo.com
424 South Beverly Drive Attorneys for Ventura Land Trust
7 Beverly Hills, CA 90212
8 Tel. (310) 553-8533
Fax (310) 553-0557
9 jv@vickmanassociates.com
Attorneys for Cross-Defendant New
10
Civilization, a California corporation Amy Elmore
11 110 Park Road
Nancy J. Johnson Ojai, Ca 93023
12 Berliner Cohen LLP Tel. (805) 746-1551
10 Almaden Blvd., 11th Floor elmoreaw@gmail.com
13
San Jose, CA 95113
14 Tel. (408) 286-5800 Christopher Stolz
Fax (408) 998-5388 Valerie Levett
15 Nancy.Johnson@berliner.com 11871 Koenigstein Rd.
Attorneys for Cross-Defendant Union Pacific Santa Paula, CA 93060
16
Railroad Company, a Delaware corporation – kitstolz@gmail.com
17 Roe 411
Brandon Hansen
18 Claire S. Brian and Brad D. Brian, Trustees of P.O. Box 1516
19
the Brad & Claire Brian Living Trust, Roes Oak View, CA
30 and 31 Tel. (805) 207-1869
20 1150 So Arroyo Blvd. brandon@weldo.com
Pasadena, CA 91105 Pro Per for Brandon Hansen, Jamie Hansen,
21 cbrian8587@gmail.com Ralph Hansen, Landon Hansen, Sandra
22 brad.brian@mto.com Hansen, Ojai Highlands LLC, BH Holding
LLC, 403 Bryant LLC, and 401 Bryant LLC
23 Michael W. Price, Trustee of the Michael W.
Price Trust, Roe 197 Via First Class Mail
24
Leslie L. Clark, Trustee of the Leslie L. Clark Warren W. Greene
25 Trust, Roe 51 Bonnie M. Greene
10886 Creek Rd 958 E. Main Street
26 Ojai, CA 93023 Ventura, CA 93001
michael@nomadgal.com Tel. (805) 652-1080
27
leslie@nomadgal.com Fax (805) 652-0400
28
1 Stacey Birchfield Via First Class Mail
Double Vision Development, LLC Lewis A. Enstedt
2
1810 Miramar Drive 12617 Macdonald Drive
3 Ventura, CA 93001 Ojai, CA 93023
Tel. (805) 340-0929 (310) 613-3937
4 stacey.birchfield@gmail.com
5
Thomas G. Gehring, Esq.
6 Julia J. Park, Esq.
Thomas G. Gehring & Associates, a
7 Professional Corporation
8 1534 17th Street, Suite 203
Santa Monica, CA 90404
9 Tel. (310) 264-7744
Fax (310) 264-7746
10
tom@tomgehring.com
11 julia@tomgehring.com
Attorneys for Cross-Defendant Teen
12 Challenge of Southern California, Inc., a
California nonprofit corporation
13

14

15

16

17

18

19

20

21

22

23

24

25

26

27

28