Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Similar Literary Quality Demystifying TH
Similar Literary Quality Demystifying TH
Similar Literary Quality Demystifying TH
Slifkin
W
e share with many of our peers a love and ary quality means. The purpose of this article is to: (1)
passion for teaching young adult (YA) illuminate some of the controversy about the meaning
literature in AP (Advanced Placement) of similar literary quality and how that meaning has
English Literature courses—where teachers tend to changed over the years; (2) describe the importance
teach canonical texts. We echo Gallo’s (2001) concern of regarding YA literature as similar literary quality to
when he writes: “It bothers me a great deal when the canon; and (3) offer suggestions to The College
high school English teachers or university professors Board about creating an addendum about the meaning
condemn YA books because they believe they are of similar literary quality on the exam.
shallow and poorly written. Those people are ignorant
elitists who haven’t done their homework, haven’t Defining Literary Quality
read an adequate sampling of the novels, short stories,
Voices from the Front Lines of Education
nonfiction, and poetry for teens that is available for
We contacted a number of people from various parts
classroom use and independent reading” (37). As ex-
of the country, including those from rural, suburban,
perienced high school classroom AP English literature
and urban settings who represent a
teachers, we have experienced the
wide demographic, in order to gain
merit of teaching YA literature and
As experienced high a holistic view on similar literary
encouraged students to write about
merit. Among those contacted was
it on question 3 of the AP English
literature exam, the open question.
school classroom AP a representative from the American
Library Association, who explained
The value we place on YA English literature teach- that literary merit is often displayed
literature, however, is not a com-
by award-winning texts (see http://
monly held value in all classrooms, ers, we have experienced
ala.org/ala/yalsa/booklistsawards/
or even amongst readers at the AP
level, which led us to question the the merit of teaching YA outstandingbooks/policiesproce-
dures.cfm). Some qualifying YA
phrasing of question 3 on the AP literature and encouraged titles were suggested, such as Mon-
Literature and Composition exam
ster, Feed, Push, and The Absolutely
when the prompt reads: “You may students to write about it
True Diary of a Part-Time Indian;
choose a work below or another
appropriate novel or play of similar on question 3 of the AP also mentioned was the graphic
novel, Persepolis.1 Similarly, a
literary quality.” The testing com-
English literature exam, librarian in the Midwest echoed
munity and those it serves will
this sentiment and added that they
benefit from a more clearly refined the open question. should also be well written, using
annotation about what similar liter-
1984 Feed
Anthem
The Handmaid’s Tale
10
11
12
13
14
15
16