MSc Quality Management

A Review of The Applicability of Principles of

Quality Management In Service Delivery Industry.

Alju Kallamparambil Shaju

B00505264

1
 ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS

I want to express my gratitude and acknowledgement to my supervisor, who made

this job possible.
Without the great direction, advice, and recommendations, my thesis would not
have been completed with ongoing assistance from Professor Turner Colin. I
would also want to express my thanks to him and acknowledge my obligation to
him.

I thank the Almighty God for all of His favours that made it possible for me to
complete my thesis as well as for providing me the stamina and willpower to do so.

Also, to be appreciated are my brother and other family members who provided
proofreading assistance for the thesis.

Last but not least, I would want to thank all of my friends for their inspiration and
support.

2
3
 Table of Contents

1. Introduction ................................................................................................................................. 6
1.1 Overview ............................................................................................................................... 6
1.2 Research Aim ........................................................................................................................ 7
1.3 Research Questions ............................................................................................................... 7
1.4 Research design ..................................................................................................................... 8
2. Literature review ....................................................................................................................... 10
2.1. Introduction ........................................................................................................................ 10
2.2. Impact of Quality Management Principles......................................................................... 10
2.3. Variables Associated with the Quality Management Principles ........................................ 12
2.4. Advantages of Application of Quality Management Principles......................................... 13
2.5. Research Gap...................................................................................................................... 16
2.6. Conclusion.......................................................................................................................... 16
3. Research Methodology ............................................................................................................. 20
3.1 Research Design .................................................................................................................. 20
3.2 Research Questions ............................................................................................................. 22
3.3 Data Sources ........................................................................................................................ 22
3.4 Data Analysis ...................................................................................................................... 27
3.5 Ethical considerations ......................................................................................................... 27
3.7 Future Research ................................................................................................................... 27
4. Data Collection-Literature Review ........................................................................................... 30
5. Discussion ................................................................................................................................. 51
6. Conclusion ................................................................................................................................ 62
References ..................................................................................................................................... 64

4
CHAPTER 1

5
 1. Introduction

1.1 Overview

The principles of quality management play a crucial role by offering a road map for the company
to follow on its quest to improve quality. It improves the company's ability to function and utilise
its resources in a responsible manner. ISO standards provide a set of principles to improve and
sustain an organization's quality, providing a foundational strategic approach to quality
management. Among the tenets provided by these norms are customer first, process
orientation, leadership, relationship management, improvement, engagement of employees, and
decisions. (Luburić, 2015). In order to ensure long-term success and increased productivity,
service industry leaders adhere to quality management standards. This study discussed the
application of quality management principles in the service sectors and the findings of the study
indicates that implementation of quality management principles in the service-based organisations
allows them to achieve their goals and objectives in an efficient manner by enhancing the
productivity of the operations (Luburić, 2015).”
“Organizational processes based on quality practises aim at delivering high quality end products
or services to customers. The principles of quality management serve as a guideline for doing
business in an effort to ensure the consistent delivery of high-caliber goods and services. The top
brass of these businesses uses these tenets as the basis for an overarching framework that directs
day-to-day operations toward greater efficiency and effectiveness. Challenges encountered and the
nature of the organisation are taken into account when deciding how to implement these quality
management concepts. One of the eight guiding principles of quality management is employee
participation. The other seven are leadership, customer focus, employee commitment, process
management, continuous improvement, strategic planning management, innovation, and supply
chain management. (Patyal & Koilakuntla, 2017). Top management's careful and accountable
attitude is essential for the implementation of quality management concepts. All operations carry
some degree of danger and therefore robust quality management systems. Enhancing the change
process's effectiveness in these areas calls for more collaborative effort from workers. (Vykydal,
2012). Employee turnover, reluctance to change, and other unknowns may all threaten an

6
organization's bottom line during a period of transition. Similarly, use of quality management
concepts in the organisation also offers similar unclear risks owing to deficiency in the
communication, coordination and information sharing which may lead to the failure of the
organisation in the highly competitive market. It's possible that the company will fail as a result of
these threats, but it's also possible that it will be able to thrive if it takes adaptive measures, such
as implementing customer loyalty measurement and benchmarking, to mitigate the dangers they
pose to the business's financial stability and reputation. (Barros et al., 2014). This research proposal
aims at developing a framework to critically review the applicability of the principles of Quality
Management in the service delivery industry.”

1.2 Research Aim

“This research report aims at critically reviewing the application of quality management principles
in the service sectors and its influence on the performance of the organisation. The goal of this
study is to explore the influence of quality management principles on the service sectors and
estimate its significance in improving the performance of the business in competitive global
market. The purpose of this literature study is to determine the factors that aid in the effective
implementation of quality management principles in the organisation by analysing a variety of
literatures and case studies based on the application of these principles in the service sectors. This
research aims to assess the value of quality management concepts in helping businesses gain a
competitive edge via enhanced customer attention, relationships, and engagement.”.

1.3 Research Questions

“Primary Questionnaire: What impact does quality management principles have on the
performance of service-based organisation?
Secondary Questions:

1. What are the variables associated with quality management principles that influence the
performance of service-based organisation?
2. What are the advantages of application of Quality management principles?

7
3. Are there any risks associated with application of quality management principles in the service-
based organisations?”

1.4 Research design

“The reliability and precision of a study's findings depend heavily on the research methodology
used. It's a well-organized method for getting the most accurate results possible from your research
instruments and methods. At get to the intended results of a study, a researcher has to know which
methods and resources will be most useful. (Snyder, 2019). In this research paper we would be
using secondary research methodology instead of primary research approach due to Covid-29
restrictions in UK, as we won’t be able to engage employees from the service-based organisations
in our research study. We propose a qualitative method for conducting a critical examination of
quality management concepts and their relevance in service-based organisations. The theoretical
data sets on the concepts of quality management and its effect on the service-based organisation
would be developed using publications and case studies that have been peer reviewed. These
qualitative data sets would undergo theoretical analysis in order to provide results and conclusions
relevant to the study topics.”
“The concepts of quality management and their relevance to service-based organisations would be
critically reviewed using a qualitative methodology. The concepts of quality management and their
impact on service-based organisations would be the subject of a theoretical data set developed
using peer-reviewed literature and case studies. To generate results and conclusions about the
study issues, a theoretical analysis of these qualitative data sets would be performed.”

8
CHAPTER 2

9
2. Literature review

2.1. Introduction

The service sector is a potential application area for quality management theory. Customers,
together with a dedication to development and leadership, are what drive this business, therefore
these ideas might be crucial. All stakeholders at every level of the company need to be engaged in
the process to improve quality standards and customer satisfaction in the service delivery business.
This is because a lack of interest or commitment from any one person or group will have a negative
impact on the result.
The literature review presented herein provides an overview of the applicability of the principles
of quality management in the service delivery industry. The purpose of this study was to highlight
some of the issues in the service delivery industry and provide solutions with a focus on improving
processes, efficiency, innovation and customer satisfaction.

2.2. Impact of Quality Management Principles

According to the views and opinion of AlShehail et al. (2021), they stated in their studies that it's
clear that quality management's concepts and techniques may be used in the service sector. The
service sector contains a wealth of ideas that may be used to improving quality management.
Continuous improvement is one such idea; it emphasises on keeping an eye on metrics related to
performance and listening to input from customers to make tweaks to operations and offerings.
This may be accomplished via the use of an effective communication strategy that clarifies
expectations and provides personnel with training on how to meet them. The service sector must
also put in place reliable mechanisms to make sure it meets customers' expectations consistently.
Last but not least, businesses in the service sector need to invest in their people by providing them
with the training and resources they need to provide exceptional customer service. They'll be able
to hone their skills to perfection, making them an invaluable asset to the company.
In the views of Hussain et al. (2019), organizations that provide services may benefit from using
quality management concepts. Although these guidelines have been proved to increase customer
satisfaction in other sectors, the services sector has been slow to adopt them due to the complexity
10
of the business. All service sectors have their own unique challenges, as do their customers. The
fact that there is no one path to quality management might make it hard to consistently apply these
guidelines. It has to be tailored to each individual circumstance, but that doesn't mean businesses
shouldn't make it a priority to learn about their clients' needs and priorities. Kumar et al. (2020),
also noted in their study that the application of quality management principles is a critical aspect
of the success of any organization, be it service or manufacturing. The study's overarching goal is
to ascertain the significance of these quality standards in service delivery and their effect on
performance. To thrive in today's highly competitive service industry, businesses must fully
embrace the ideas of customer-centric service delivery, quality management, and performance
monitoring. This project will analyse different modes of operation (such outsourcing) that may be
more efficient than conventional models, and will determine the components necessary to achieve
a high degree of operational efficiency without sacrificing customer satisfaction in the service
industry.
“Quality-based organisational procedures are geared at providing clients with superior goods and
services. To put it simply, quality management principles are a set of guidelines designed to
standardise the ways in which businesses operate so as to increase their productivity and the quality
of the goods and services they provide to customers. Top-level executives utilise these concepts
as the basis for an overarching framework that will direct the company's operations toward greater
efficiency and effectiveness. To what extent these quality management concepts are put into
practise depends on the specific circumstances of the organisation. The eight tenets of quality
management are as follows: employee participation, human resource management, leadership,
customer focus, employee commitment, process management, continuous improvement, strategic
planning management, innovation, and supply chain management. These quality management
concepts help businesses to remain flexible and productive in response to the ever-evolving needs
of their respective markets, therefore contributing to their overall excellence in practise and
performance. Quality management concepts have been widely implemented by businesses in order
to stay ahead in today's era of rapidly shifting market trends. Having a firm grasp of quality
management practises has been shown to improve a company's bottom line and ability to compete
in a dynamic marketplace. (Barros et al., 2014). Studies by Alsolamy et al. (2013), concludes that,
the need for high-quality service has grown with the public's growing knowledge and appreciation
of the importance of education, culture, and economic prosperity. Because of this, the company
11
has no choice but to implement quality management policies if it wants to continue operating
profitably and expanding. (Alsolamy et al., 2013).”

2.3. Variables Associated with the Quality Management Principles

Numerous shifts in management theory and practise have resulted from the rise of service-based
organisations in today's global economy. That's why experts in academia, business, and
government are always reevaluating the status quo of management dogma and methods. As per
othman et al. (2022), the framework for training professionals in the service delivery sector is
quality management principles (QMP). In this way, they serve as a framework for helping
businesses realise their customer-centric missions. Quality management plans (QMPs) facilitate
communication between management and staff on their shared goals, beliefs, and actions to
improve customer satisfaction. Organizations that provide services might benefit from adhering to
the Quality Management Principles. Total Quality Management aims to meet or exceed the
expectations of every client by consistently delivering exceptional goods and services. Total
Quality Management requires simultaneous implementation at several levels, including executive,
mid-, front-, and customer service. In order to succeed at Total Quality Management, we need to
use all of the methods and strategies that go along with it.
In the views of Fikri et al. (2020), they stated that organizations in the service sector arise to fill a
need in the market. Services must be developed and provided in a way that is in line with both
organisational quality goals and customer expectations if they are to consistently meet customers'
demands. Quality management concepts are universal, regardless of the kind of service being
offered or the specifics of the industry, location, culture, or personalities of the customers. The
service sector is a major user of quality management practises. There are numerous factors related
to quality management principles that might affect performance, which is why some businesses
struggle to successfully adopt them. The success of a business depends on its capacity to maintain
a high level of performance in every facet of its operations, from employee happiness and retention
to customer contentment, profit margins and cost management to corporate accountability and
reputation.
Although quality management concepts may be useful in a wide variety of contexts, it is crucial to
remember that they won't always be. Application of these concepts requires knowledge of the
12
specifics of the service delivery sector, which will allow for customization. Also, knowing what
quality means in any given business is crucial, since it has a significant impact on service delivery
and the approach an enterprise takes to providing those services. Quality is defined differently by
the healthcare industry and transportation companies for manufacturers than it is by the hotel and
food industries. Utari & Purnavati (2022), also stated that historically, the service delivery sector
has benefited from using the concepts of quality management. Customers in the service sector are
notoriously picky, and they are continuously on the lookout for new, better methods to get the
services they need. This occurs as a result of the presence of several elements that have a role in
shaping the service provision sector. Several service providers have challenges related to
infrastructure, human resources, technology, and political stability. Nonetheless, there are
takeaways from contemporary quality management theory that may be used to build a framework
that assists firms in increasing their efficiency via the use of best practises.

2.4. Advantages of Application of Quality Management Principles

Problems with quality are experienced by service providers just as they are by companies in other
sectors. It is expected that the concepts of Quality Management in this sector would be used
throughout the whole service delivery process, from first customer contact through to the last steps
of a project's completion. According to Abbas (2020), since Quality Management provides a
company with a holistic framework for analysing and bettering goods and services, it is applicable
to the Service Delivery Sector. In addition, they detail how to effectively apply quality procedures
to maximise efficiency, savings, and revenue. The primary benefit, however, is that it offers a
standardised method for guaranteeing uniform results. It also aids in the education of staff
members as to what quality entails and how they may contribute to its attainment. It is important
to take into account the specifics of the service business while using the concepts of Quality
Management (Li et al., 2018). As an added complication, these guidelines need to be implemented
in a way that is compatible with the company's established practises. Many experts maintain that
this must be accomplished without sacrificing either the satisfaction of customers or the pursuit of
the company's financial objectives.
“Study by Radoica Luburic (2015), discusses the principles of quality management and their
beneficial effects on the service industries (central banks). According to the findings of this study,
13
senior management in the service sectors should adopt the principles of quality management in
order to achieve long-term success and higher productivity. This study found that service-based
firms benefited from adopting quality management ideas because it increased the effectiveness
with which they went about their everyday operations, therefore achieving their stated goals.
(Luburić, 2015). When applied to the service industry, quality management concepts change the
way all parties involved think about their role in the company, their impact on the environment,
and their commitment to the company's overall goals. To remain competitive in the face of ever-
shifting market conditions and consumer preferences, service-based businesses can greatly benefit
from adhering to the tenets of quality management. These include the ability to quickly adapt to
new situations and circumstances, reduce costs, increase the value provided to stakeholders, and
make more efficient use of available resources. Applying quality management concepts has a
positive influence on the organization's relationships with its internal and external stakeholders, as
well as on the efficiency and effectiveness of the flow of information inside the company and the
quality of its services and products. (Behara & Gundersen, 2001). The long-term success of an
organisation depends on its ability to strike a good balance between its immediate priorities and
its vision for the future. Quality management principles may help it do this.”
In the views of Bastas & Liyanage (2018), The efficient and effective provision of services may
be helped along by adhering to the principles of quality management. The International
Organization for Standardization (ISO) 9000 framework serves as the basis for these
recommendations. With these guidelines in place, businesses can give their consumers what they
want every time: consistently high-quality products and services. If quality control concepts are
applied to the service provisioning business, they may boost productivity and customer happiness.
Because services are often provided on a one-on-one basis, businesses may get valuable insight
from consumer comments. Customer satisfaction surveys may be used in tandem with an issue
management system to detect and address service issues before they affect the company's
reputation.

2.5. Risks Associated with Application of Quality Management Principles

Quality management concepts might be difficult to implement in sectors focused on providing

services. One possible explanation is that these businesses lack the same level of organisation and
14
culture as the manufacturing sector. This means that quality management in these businesses will
get fewer resources as a consequence. As per Akwei & Zhang (2018), The concepts of quality
management may be applied to almost every kind of business, including service businesses. In
comparison to other sectors, the service delivery business stands out for the complexity of its value
chain. Fortunately, this difficulty may be conquered with the use of methodical quality
management. The main potential drawback of using quality management concepts in the service
delivery sector is that it may be difficult for individuals to incorporate these procedures into their
regular work routines. When businesses and their staffs attempt to make the transition from
technical or operational to strategic excellence, or from quality based on production to quality
based on customer service, or from process control to value creation, this challenge may become
more apparent. Furthermore, Fox et al. (2021) also noted in their study that, it is not without risk
that service-based organisations use quality management concepts. A company's capacity to
sustain its competitive edge may be impacted by both internal and external variables, such as
changes in technology, the economy, social forces, and customer demand. A company that wants
to stay competitive must regularly assess its operations and make any required improvements.
According to Wang et al. (2020), they stated in their study that Businesses in the service industry,
such as IT, hotels, and retailers, are stressing quality to win over consumers. In order to guarantee
that all customers' needs are fulfilled or surpassed, service quality management has emerged as a
useful tool. To thrive in today's cutthroat business climate, service providers must employ quality
management concepts to create new goods and services and enhance their current ones. While
quality management is widely used in the service industry, there are dangers in using this
methodology. They also discovered various potential dangers linked to the implementation of
quality management practises in service-oriented businesses as a result of their research. One issue
is that there just aren't enough reliable measuring methods available. Companies in this industry
have a harder time than they should analysing the causes of any problems with their offerings.
(Emelyanova et al., 2019). It's possible that some employees at these businesses won't believe
anything is wrong until it happens to them many times, and until then, they won't do anything to
try to figure out why. Internal auditing, for example, is now both simpler and more difficult to
carry out as a result of technology advancements. For these audits to be effective and efficient,
businesses must coordinate the efforts of all relevant personnel, adding still another layer of
complexity to an already challenging situation.
15
2.5. Research Gap

“As per the study by David Vykydal, Petra Halfarova, Jaroslav Nenadal and Jiri Plura (2012),
discusses the management dangers that might arise from a lack of adherence to quality
management standards in the workplace. Top management's careful and accountable attitude is
essential for the implementation of quality management concepts. All operations carry some
degree of danger and therefore robust quality management systems. Enhancing the change
process's effectiveness in these areas calls for more collaborative effort from workers. (Vykydal,
2012). Employee turnover, reluctance to change, and other unknowns may all threaten an
organization's bottom line during a period of transition. Equally as unknown are the dangers
associated with an organization's inability to succeed in a highly competitive market as are the
benefits of using quality management concepts. These threats pose a threat to the firm's survival,
but they also provide an opportunity for the company to improve its operations and attract and
retain customers by implementing innovative strategies, such as the measuring and benchmarking
of client loyalty. (Barros et al., 2014).” Few studies have pinpointed the factors that lead to the
effective application of quality management concepts in the service sector, which in turn boosts
the sector's performance in the ever-changing marketplace. This study would help us better
understand quality management concepts and their consequences for businesses, as well as
uncover critical variables for success.

2.6. Conclusion

“This research would aim at identifying the variables associated with quality management
principles and its implementation in the service-based industry, and would also focus on
identifying its influence on the organisational process and risks associated with its implementation.
If implemented properly, these quality management concepts should help any organisation operate
more efficiently and effectively. Research and knowledge on how quality management principles
might be used in a service-based organisation are few. There has been a rise in the importance of
quality management as a result of the ever-evolving demands of both businesses and consumers,
and many businesses are adopting these concepts in an effort to boost productivity and customer

16
satisfaction. This research would help fill gaps in our understanding of how quality management
concepts might be used in service organisations to improve service quality.”
“The eight principles of quality management are as follows: employee participation, human
resource management, leadership, customer focus, employee commitment, process management,
continuous improvement, strategic planning management, innovation, and supply chain
management. Implementing these quality management concepts in an organisation is dependent
on factors such as open lines of communication, well-trained staff, and enhanced strategic
planning. These findings from the examination of relevant literature provide an answer to the first
research question. The goals of every business are to maximise efficiency and profitability, and
these tenets of quality management give the framework for doing just that. The primary benefit,
however, is that it offers a standardised method for guaranteeing uniform results. It also aids in the
education of staff members as to what quality entails and how they may contribute to its attainment.
Quality Management concepts need to be rethought in order to be applied to a sector of the
economy whose primary focus is on service provision, such as the service sector. With these
guidelines in place, businesses can give their consumers what they want every time: consistently
high-quality products and services. If quality control concepts are applied to the service
provisioning business, they may boost productivity and customer happiness. This answers the
second research question of this paper. “Organizational risks include staff turnover, resistance to
change, and the possibility of financial crises as a result of the application of quality management
principles. Similarly, the failure of an organisation in a highly competitive market may be
attributed to a lack of communication, coordination, and information sharing stemming from an
ineffective implementation of quality management concepts. This answers the third research
question in this research paper.”
“There to sum up, implementing quality management concepts in the service delivery sector has a
net positive effect and is not very challenging. An effective customer-centric policy approach must
be developed and implemented at the quality planning stage if a high level of customer satisfaction
is to be achieved. In addition, the business must commit to ongoing quality enhancements in order
to provide competitively priced goods and services of the highest possible standard. Sales will
increase and consumer loyalty will increase as a result of these actions. A Quality Management
System is crucial because it provides a road map for the company to follow on its journey to higher
quality. It improves the company's ability to function and utilise its resources in a responsible
17
manner. Many service-based businesses struggle to successfully apply these concepts to their
operations, despite the fact that doing so would undoubtedly improve their efficiency and
effectiveness. The implementation of these quality management principles is hindered by a number
of factors. These include insufficient training, a lack of employee engagement, a lack of support
from upper management, an inefficient communication flow, resistance to change, and a lack of a
quality-oriented culture within the organisation. (Mosadeghrad, 2006). This research report aims
at critically reviewing the applicability of the quality management principles in the service-based
organisations in order to identify the challenges, risks, success factors and mitigation strategies
towards these resistances.”

18
CHAPTER 3

19
3. Research Methodology

3.1 Research Design

“The goal of this study is to explore the influence of quality management principles on the service
sectors and estimate its significance in improving the performance of the business in competitive
global market. Top-level executives utilise these concepts as the basis for an overarching
framework that will direct the company's operations toward greater efficiency and effectiveness.
These quality management concepts are used depending on the specifics of the organisation and
the difficulties it faces (Patyal & Koilakuntla, 2017). The purpose of this literature study is to
determine the factors that aid in the effective implementation of quality management principles in
the organisation by analysing a variety of literatures and case studies based on the application of
these principles in the service sectors. This research aims to assess the value of quality management
concepts in helping businesses gain a competitive edge via enhanced customer attention,
relationships, and engagement.” i
“The reliability and precision of a study's findings depend heavily on the methodological
framework used. It's a well-organized method for getting the most accurate results possible from
your research instruments and methods. It is the responsibility of the researcher to determine which
methods and resources are most appropriate for achieving the desired results of the study (Snyder,
2019). Due to Covid-29 limitations in the UK, we will be unable to include workers from service-
based organisations in our research study, necessitating the use of secondary research methods in
this publication. A critical examination of quality management concepts and their relevance in
service-based organisations would be carried out using a qualitative methodology. The concepts
of quality management and their impact on service-based organisations would be the focus of a
theoretical data set compiled from scholarly papers and case studies. These qualitative data sets
would be theoretically analysed to get results and conclusions on the research questions.”
Rationale for methodology: With the use of a qualitative research technique and secondary data
gathering methods, we could access a plethora of information from various web resources. The
concepts of quality management in the service delivery business may be better understood with
the help of these peer-reviewed papers, which are also quite accessible. Using a qualitative strategy
would provide the study paper's non-statistical analysis and results. The theoretical framework of
20
the studies by the prior researchers would be developed using peer-reviewed publications from the
web sources, and this data would add to the research's precise results via a critical theoretical
examination. For a more in-depth understanding of the issue at hand and a more accurate
evaluation from which to draw conclusions for the research paper, qualitative research methods
are well suited. (Rahman, 2017).
Limitations of the methodology: Due to not including any people, studies by earlier researchers
on quality management principles would be employed, which is a major drawback of this
qualitative research approach in secondary research since it is not based on contextual sensitivities
and current experiences. By relying on scholarly publications to provide the groundwork for the
study's theoretical framework, rather than interviewing participants directly, the researcher in this
paper will be unable to learn about or make sense of their experiences. However, due to restrictions
imposed by Covid-19, we are unable to recruit any participants for the research paper, despite the
fact that using a qualitative approach in the primary research would yield more reliable results
because it would allow us to collect data in real time based on the experience of the participants.
“Data Sources: This research study will rely on a variety of sources, including peer-reviewed
publications, journals, new articles, and case studies. In order to create theoretical data sets, one
must first collect all the necessary knowledge, and this may be done by reading scholarly
publications. ResearchGate, Web of Science, MDPI, and SpringerLink would be scoured for
information. The information in this research paper would be searched using terms like "quality
principles," "quality management," "operations in the service industry," and "operational
efficiency." Articles would be picked using the criteria for inclusion and extrusion that will be
explained in more detail below.”

“Inclusions:
1. Peer reviewed articles would be used.
2. Sources focused on application of quality management principles in service sector would
be used.
3. Papers reviewing conceptual issues on QMP would be used.
4. Structuring of the data collected to form data sets.
5. Sources between 2017 to 2022.
Exclusions:

21
 1. Sources before 2012.
2. Sources lacking critical analysis and adequate detail.
3. Sources and publications not based on application of QMP in service sectors.
4. Sources including conference proceedings, website document and other non-peer reviewed
articles.
“Data Extraction: We will use a literature summary grid table to organise the information gathered
and draw conclusions. In order to help organise the gathered data, it would be helpful to include
fields for author, publication year, quality type, sample size, nation settings, and results linked with
implications of quality management concepts in service-based organisations.””

3.2 Research Questions

“Primary Questionnaire: What impact does quality management principles have on the
performance of service-based organisation?

Secondary Questions:
1. What are the variables associated with quality management principles that influence the
performance of service-based organisation?
2. What are the advantages of application of Quality management principles?
3. Are there any risks associated with application of quality management principles in the service-
based organisations?”

3.3 Data Sources

1. Škarica & Implementation https://dl.acm.org/doi/abs/10.4018/IJPMAT.2018010101

Hrgović
of Total Quality
(2018)
Management
Principles in
Public Health
Institutes in the
Republic of
Croatia
2. Demilly et al. An overview of https://www.metrology-journal.org/articles/ijmqe/full_html/2018/01/ijmqe170027/ijmqe170027.html
2018 Quality
Management
System

22
 implementation
in a research
laboratory
3. Gremyr et al. Increasing the https://www.emerald.com/insight/content/doi/10.1108/IJQSS-10-2020-0170/full/html
2021 value of quality
management
systems
4. Manatos et “The European “https://www.emerald.com/insight/content/doi/10.1108/TQM-01-2016-0009/full/html”
al. 2017 standards and
guidelines for
internal quality
assurance: An
integrative
approach to
quality
management in
higher
education?”
5. Aamer et al. “TQM https://www.emerald.com/insight/content/doi/10.1108/TQM-11-2015-0141/full/html
2017 implementation
in a least
developed
country: an
exploratory
study of
Yemen”
6. Egwunatum Total quality https://www.emerald.com/insight/content/doi/10.1108/ECAM-08-2020-0639/full/html
et al. management
(TQM)
implementation
in the Nigerian
construction
industry
7. Nina Innovative “https://www.emerald.com/insight/content/doi/10.1108/IJQRM-12-2016-0235/full/html”
Aniskina & methods for
Ekaterina quality
Terekhova, management in
2019 educational
organizations
8. Raine “A proposed “https://www.emerald.com/insight/content/doi/10.1108/TQM-12-2017-0167/full/html”
Isaksson, preliminary
2019 maturity grid for
assessing
sustainability
reporting based
on quality

23
 management
principles”
9. Emmanuel Adopting total “https://www.emerald.com/insight/content/doi/10.1108/RMJ-01-2015-0009/full/html”
Adjei & quality
Monica management to
Mensah, enhance service
2016 delivery in
medical records:
Exploring the
case of the
Korle-Bu
Teaching
Hospital in
Ghana
10. Fayaz et al. Application of https://ndpublisher.in/admin/issues/JARv10n3a.pdf
2020 Total Quality
Management to
Ensure Food
Quality in Food
Industry
11. Mabele & An Investigation https://www.arcjournals.org/pdfs/ijmsr/v6-i2/5.pdf
Singh, 2018 into Benefits and
Challenges of
Total Quality
Management:
The Case of a
Gauteng
Municipality
12. Harischandra Total Quality https://oaji.net/articles/2015/1875-1446449099.pdf
Parshuram, management as
2019 applied to
service sector
with relevance to
Indian situations
13. Aletaiby et Influence of top https://link.springer.com/article/10.1007/s13202-021-01131-3
al., 2021 management
commitment
towards the
effective
implementation
of TQM in Iraqi
oil companies
14. Esa & Yusof, Perception of https://zenodo.org/record/1129055/files/10006525.pdf
2017 TQM
Implementation
and Perceived

24
 Cost of Poor
Quality: A Case
Study of Local
Automotive
Company’s
Supplier
15. Talapatra & Some obstacles http://ieomsociety.org/ieom2018/papers/401.pdf
Uddin, 2018 that affect the
TQM
implementation
in Bangladeshi
RMG Sector: An
empirical study
16. Mehfooz & “Implementation https://www.iosrjournals.org/iosr-jbm/papers/Vol17-issue9/Version-1/J017916677.pdf
Lodhi, 2017 barrier of ISo
9001 with in
service and
manufacturing
organizations in
Pakistan”
17. Khurniawan “An Analysis of https://www.macrothink.org/journal/index.php/ijld/article/download/17270/13405
et al. 2020 Implementing
Total Quality
Management in
Education:
Sucess and
Challenging
Factors”
18. Khatib et al. The Influence of https://www.scirp.org/journal/paperinformation.aspx?paperid=106294
2020 Integrating ISo
and TQM on
Project Risk
Management
19. Al-Din & “Extent of https://files.eric.ed.gov/fulltext/EJ1089774.pdf
Abouzid, Implementing
2016 the Total
Quality
Management
Principles by
Academic
Departments
Heads at Najran
University from
Faculty
Members’
Perspectives”

25
20. Marek The problem of “https://www.emerald.com/insight/content/doi/10.1108/TQM-02-2019-0047/full/html”
Bugdol, 2020 fear in TQM –
causes,
consequences
and reduction
methods – a
literature review
21. Vykydal et Risk Analysis https://www.researchgate.net/publication/258710753_Risk_Analysis_Related_to_Quality_Management_Principles
al. 2012 Related to
Quality
Management
Principles
22. Stravinskiene The Link https://www.mdpi.com/1911-8074/13/10/225/pdf
& Serafinas between
2020 Business
Process
Management
and Quality
Management
23. Abuaraki Examining the https://www.emerald.com/insight/content/doi/10.1108/TQM-05-2019-0147/full/html
osman relationship
Ahmed & between soft
Abdalla total quality
Abdelrahim management
Idris 2020 (TQM) aspects
and employees'
job satisfaction
in “ISo 9001”
Sudanese oil
companies
24. Leonardo Linking strategic “https://www.emerald.com/insight/content/doi/10.1108/BPMJ-02-2018-0038/full/html”
Sedevich- management
Fons, 2018 accounting and
quality
management
systems
25. Esin The Effects of https://www.hindawi.com/journals/ads/2014/537605/
Sadikoglu & Total Quality
Hilal olcay, Management
2014 Practices on
Performance and
the Reasons of
and the Barriers
to TQM
Practices in
Turkey

26
3.4 Data Analysis

“The data might be theoretically analysed. To do this, we would use a method called narrative
synthesis to analyse the data. Using this method, we would be able to compare and contrast the
results of various studies and reviews by different authors and researchers.”

3.5 Ethical considerations

“Guidelines and norms need to be established for research to be conducted in a morally sound way.
When researchers engage in unethical behaviour, it might taint their data and invalidate their
conclusions. Ethical considerations taken into account during research help guarantee that results
may be trusted. Institutional norms should be enforced to promote researchers' honesty and
integrity, since this ultimately yields more reliable results (Akaranga & Makau, 2016). Some of
the many ethical concerns I made during this study are detailed here:”
1. “Privacy was strictly adhered to the data collection.
2. Participants were not given an unrealistic picture of the study's significance.
3. To prevent confusion, we have made conflict of interest and other statements.
4. Both candour and openness were maintained.
5. The presentation of facts and figures has been designed to save readers from becoming
confused.
6. To prevent any potential for offence or discrimination, we avoided using any language that
may be considered such.
7. This study acknowledges and cites the work of other researchers using the APA reference
style (Sixth Edition).”

3.7 Future Research

“Primary research methods, such as a survey and interviews with service-sector personnel, should
be used in future studies to provide a more in-depth understanding of the present and real-time

27
difficulties in applying quality management concepts to business operations. It's possible that this
method might help us successfully identify appropriate ways for mitigating the risks and
difficulties involved with applying quality management concepts in a service-based organisation.”

28
CHAPTER 4

29
4. Data Collection-Literature Review

4.1. “Implementation of Total Quality Management Principles in Public Health Institutes in the
Republic of Croatia” by Škarica & Hrgovic (2018)

This research explores the quality management systems of Croatia's public health research
institutions. The article gives short theoretical context for understanding the business effects of
overall quality management concepts. Completeness of TQM implementation is the focus of this
study. The Kanji model served as the inspiration for the creation of the questionnaires. Total
quality management concepts have been adopted extensively, however their application differs
between organisations, in the opinion of quality managers. The study also sought to determine
whether there were any differences in how quality managers across organisations saw the
importance and relevance of implementing ISO 9001. According to the study's results, managers
have varying conceptions of ISO depending on whether their work emphasises constant tweaks to
processes or on the management of quality via the involvement of its human resources. Strategies
to promote the implementation of Quality management principles in organisations have been
discussed in detail in this research paper, such as increasing employee engagement and ensuring
an open line of communication within the company, all of which are grounded in the findings of
the research presented here. (Škarica & Hrgović, 2018).

4.2. “An overview of Quality Management System implementation in a research laboratory” by

Demilly et al. 2018

The purpose of this work is to demonstrate the value of a Quality Management System (QMS) in
a research laboratory by showing how it can be used to enhance the management of risks associated
with research programmes and to make findings more trustworthy. This paper also presents the
insights gained from feedback after INRA's (France's National Institute of Agronomic Research)
Quality process was implemented in a research laboratory, detailing the numerous issues that arose
and the solutions that were proposed to make the transition to a QMS process easier. The
operations of the QMS, which comprise laboratory structure and processes, are shown using the
Ishikawa 'Fishbone' diagram-based 7Ms (Management, Measurement, Manpower, Methods,
30
Materials, Machinery, Mother-nature) approach. Real-world applications illustrate the benefits and
improvements seen in the lab. (Demilly et al., 2018).

4.3. “Increasing the value of quality management systems” by Gremyr et al. 2021

Purpose

“While over a million businesses boast an ISO 9001-certified quality management system (QMS),
critics point out the high price tag and doubt the QMS's overall efficacy. In light of this criticism,
the value of quality management as a strategic tool is called into doubt. The goal of this research
is to investigate how management's views on quality management's value, expense, and strategic
significance vary among the various QMS applications.”

Design/Methodology/Approach

“The research relies on mixed-methods approach to data gathering, with quantitative data gathered
by survey from 8 organisations (n = 108) and qualitative data gleaned via interview with quality
managers from 12 organisations.”

Findings

“The article shows that quality management will be seen as costly and unappreciated more often
if it is used with a focus on compliance rather than on business or development. In addition, it
offers a more nuanced view of compliance-oriented use by showing that standardisation, which is
an element of compliance-oriented usage, is perceived as more real worth than documentation
when it comes to management's viewpoint of quality management.”

Originality/Value

“This article proposes three distinct QMS applications: business management, improvement, and
compliance-oriented usage. The authors argue that management's perceptions of quality
management's value, significance, and expense depend on the specific QMS application chosen.
(Gremyr et al., 2021).”

31
4.4. “The European standards and guidelines for internal quality assurance: An integrative
approach to quality management in higher education?” by Manatos et al. 2017

“The authors' central argument is that there has been a steady shift in the quality management in
higher education literature toward the concept of integration. Part 1 of the Standards and
Guidelines for Quality Assurance in the European Higher Education Area (ESG) (ENQA, 2009)
is considered in this paper as a foundation for the implementation of quality management practises
in universities, and the goal is to determine whether or not the ESG represent a genuinely effective
quality control model.”
“The authors conduct a multi-level examination of the ESG, looking at it from the perspective of
both process and organisational analysis, as well as quality management concepts.”
“Based on this research, it is clear that the ESG constitute a quality management model that
integrates several procedures, organisational tiers, and tenets of quality assurance. Despite the fact
that it is not a fully integrated model of quality management, this is the case. The ESG do, in fact,
place an emphasis on teaching and learning, as well as support processes, while ignoring other
activities often associated with universities, such as research and scholarship and the third goal.
Not only that, but they disregard the system approach concept and other quality management
principles that are integral to a systemic and comprehensive strategy for improving quality.”
“In this study, we provide a fresh evaluation of a widely debated framework for quality
management in higher education. As a new analytical framework, it examines the ESG via the lens
of integration. The significance of incorporating these norms into institutional management
systems and the need for further in-depth consideration of them is also highlighted. (Manatos et
al., 2017).”

4.5. “TQM implementation in a least developed country: an exploratory study of Yemen” by

Aamer et al. 2017

“The goal of this article is to gauge the degree to which Yemeni institutions are prepared to
implement TQM. It also evaluates the preparedness of different groups in Yemen.”
“To conduct this study, an evaluation instrument was created using data taken from the TQM
literature. Statements on the most widely accepted TQM principles formed the bulk of the

32
assessment's substance. An assessment team conducted data collection and used quantitative
techniques to evaluate the information in order to answer the study questions.”
“In general, the investigation revealed that several TQM concepts were being followed by Yemeni
firms, although to varying degrees. Customer-centricity was the most often used tenet, while
continuous improvement was the least used. Moreover, the statistics showed that TQM
preparedness in Yemeni institutions was at 58.93 percent. With this TQM readiness, Yemeni
businesses have a good chance of successfully implementing quality management strategies.”
“This study extends previous limited research in TQM readiness level measurement. It also adds
to the body of TQM knowledge within the context of Yemen. In addition, this study contributes to
the understanding of TQM implementation in a least developed countries (LDC) environment,
where LDC organizational culture has its particularities on implementing TQM.”
“This research helps fill in some of the gaps in our knowledge of TQM in a least developed nation
like Yemen. This study highlights which of the TQM principles are crucial to the widespread
implementation of quality management models and standards. The findings of this study have the
potential to further knowledge of TQM in Yemen. (Aamer et al., 2017).”

4.6. “Total quality management (TQM) implementation in the Nigerian construction industry”
by Egwunatum et al. (2022)

Purpose

“The widespread inability of the construction industry to adhere properly to the principles of
comprehensive quality management may be at the root of the low quality of finished building
projects (TQM). This is believed to be the root cause of the repeated allegations of structural
collapse in Nigeria. This study analysed TQM in the Nigerian construction industry with the
intention of decreasing the frequent occurrence of structural failures in building projects. For this
purpose, we will examine the condition of TQM implementation on infrastructure projects and the
obstacles that prevent its widespread adoption.”

33
Design/Methodology/Approach

“Using a simple sampling technique and a well-structured questionnaire, we were able to gather
data from a cross-section of the construction industry's top minds in the Nigerian state of Imo. The
data was analysed using a number of different methods, including frequency, percentage, mean,
and Pareto analysis.”

Findings

“The study found that the most important ways in which TQM principles are put into practise with
regard to structural failure rate are as follows: purchasing: making sure only materials meeting the
required quality standard are purchased; using the organization's quality improvement construction
process; and site management responsibility: making sure quality is supervised by project
management leadership and monitored and controlled throughout the building process to ensure
strict adherence to quality standards. Lack of timely salary and incentive payment, as well as a
lack of adequate machinery, apparatus, tools, and amenities for the effective execution of work on
construction sites, also were main determinants preventing TQM implementation on construction
projects. The potential for structural failure may be mitigated if construction firms require quality
certification of provided materials from their material suppliers.”

Research Limitations/Implications

“This research analysed the effectiveness of Total Quality Management (TQM) in Nigeria's
construction sector, specifically in Imo state. The research highlights the current state of TQM
practise and the main obstacles to TQM in building projects. Given the study's geographical
constraints, comparable work has to be done in other parts/states of Nigeria and maybe even in
other poor nations in Africa.”

Practical Implications

“Both the current state of TQM techniques and the obstacles standing in the way of widespread
adoption were uncovered. A sustainable quality management system to increase profit and value
maximisation and prevent chronic structural failure may be achieved with the use of this
framework, which will be valuable to construction businesses, other important stakeholders, and
regulatory bodies. (Egwunatum et al. 2022).”
34
4.7. “Innovative methods for quality management in educational organizations” by Nina
Aniskina & Ekaterina Terekhova, 2019

“To encourage employee participation in organisational decision-making, this research highlights

effective strategies for enhancing the quality of educational services via the use of novel
approaches.”
“The primary reasons of blockage of quality efforts are analysed based on a research of how
teachers and administration see such initiatives. The authors identify the problem of ineffective
QMS and draw inferences about why it's crucial to spread the quality spirit among educators and
administrators and to adopt quality management principles (such a leadership and staff
engagement) in schools and other learning institutions.”
“In order to accomplish goals like spreading a culture of quality, developing leaders, and enlisting
the support of all members of a school's staff in the management of quality, it is suggested that
they undergo training using the innovation and project (IP) method. This article provides a
description of the IP approach and provides examples of its use in order to develop effective
management systems predicated on the leadership and participation of managers and other
employees in the quality management processes. The authors provide guidelines for cutting-edge
training and assess its impact on QMS-betterment initiatives.”
“In this article, they share the insights from applying the technique's central tenet—a novel
workshop—to the tasks of formulating Pastukhov Academy's strategic plan, assembling its
administrative team, and engaging its workforce in quality control measures. In this article, we'll
look at how the academy has benefited from adopting an IP perspective, including how it has
helped its management teams grow and become more self-aware, and how it has raised the bar for
the quality of its educational programmes. Responsible social norms implementation may need an
IP-based approach.”
“The research is beneficial for educational institutions since the IP method it describes may be
used to improve the Quality Management System (QMS), the curriculum, and, ultimately, people's
quality of life. (Aniskina & Terekhova, 2019).”

35
4.8. “A proposed preliminary maturity grid for assessing sustainability reporting based on
quality management principles” by Raine Isaksson, 2019

“The effectiveness of an organization's sustainability efforts may be evaluated through

sustainability reports (SRs). The purpose of this research is to assess the current state of SRs'
monitoring and communication of sustainability and to provide next steps for improving SRs'
reporting by providing a maturity grid based on quality management ideas.”
“Evaluations of SRs that are accessible to the public have been made by quality management
students. The author has examined 55 student evaluations to determine how well-written the
reports are. Students' feedback and research on quality management practises were utilised to
develop a proposed maturity grid for sustainability reporting.”
“This points to the fact that SRs are not simple to decipher. The phrase "effect on key stakeholder
needs" is a better synonym for "sustainable component" in this context. Using process focus to
clearly characterise the scope of reporting as the complete value chain might enhance guidelines
for analysing reports.”
“The results can only be used to evaluate sustainability measurement methods. The organisations'
long-term viability is not evaluated. The study is still under progress, and the suggested matrix has
to be validated and refined.”
“The suggested sustainability reporting maturity grid provides a solid foundation for the
expansion and evaluation of SRs.”
“Findings point to the necessity for reporting sustainability throughout the whole value chain and
for putting greater emphasis on the requirements of key stakeholders, such as those related to
poverty and climate change. (Isaksson, 2019).”

4.9. “Adopting total quality management to enhance service delivery in medical records:
Exploring the case of the Korle-Bu Teaching Hospital in Ghana” by Emmanuel Adjei & Monica
Mensah, 2016

“The goal of this research is to find out how well total quality management (TQM) efforts may
assist the medical records department at Korle-Bu Teaching Hospital (KBTH) provide better care
to patients and other customers.”

36
“The research technique used in this study was a questionnaire. A total of 114 individuals working
in the KBTH medical records department served as participants in the research. Research was
conducted using questionnaires and in-person observations. A total of 98% of people participated
in the survey. Qualitative methods were used to analyse the data collected from the respondents.”
“The research concluded that the medical records department at KBTH had a strong grasp of the
advantages of TQM to records management service delivery, but that the department's current
values for TQM fell short of the framework of acceptable TQM practise, principles, and
standards.”
“There is a possibility that these results are not representative of Ghana as a whole, despite the
fact that the study's participants came from the country's busiest hospital.”
“This research shows that the medical records division at KBTH has to implement and refine
effective TQM standards in order to better serve the hospital's patients and other clients.”
“This study is the first to examine the potential benefits of Total Quality Management (TQM)
strategies such as empathy, customer satisfaction, top-level commitment, collaboration, effective
leadership and employee engagement, employee growth, and transparent dialogue on the quality
of medical records services provided by the Korle Bu Teaching Hospital (KBTH) in Ghana. (Adjei
& Mensah, 2016).”

4.10. “Application of Total Quality Management to Ensure Food Quality in Food Industry” by
Fayaz et al. 2020

The phrase "Total Quality Management" (TQM) refers to a management philosophy that
emphasises customer satisfaction by encouraging the active engagement of all team members and
focusing on the long-term success of both the business and its clientele. The overall goal of quality
management is to ensure that all processes are continually enhanced via the integration of both
standard management practises and specialist resources. TQM, or Total Quality Management, is a
method of running a business with the end goal of improving in every way that matters to the
customer. The idea is based on the conviction that flaws and blunders may be thwarted in favour
of the single-minded pursuit of process improvement. With the advent of HACCP, the focus has
shifted from the time-consuming and costly inspection and testing of finished products to the more
efficient and effective prevention of risks across the whole food production process. Basic threats
37
to food safety are also identified and managed by this system. Assuring that certified goods meet
international minimum standards requires an integrated approach to application of ISo standards
and the HACCP concept, which is essential for management of quality and safety of dairy products
and the protection of the needs of the consumer. The improvement and modernization of food
safety systems is facilitated by these standards, which guarantee and improve transparency in the
creation of quality and safety processes for food. Guidelines, rules, specifications, and criteria were
established by ISo to facilitate the development of a high-performing TQM system. (Fayaz et al.
2020).

4.11. “An Investigation into Benefits and Challenges of Total Quality Management: The Case
of a Gauteng Municipality” by Mabele & Singh, 2018

The research set out to discover whether or not Total Quality Management (TQM) is beneficial to
Gauteng local government and what obstacles stand in the way of the municipality reaching its
full TQM potential in terms of service delivery. Poor service delivery and social delivery
demonstrations are endemic to the Gauteng area. There are frequent strikes and billing crises in
the local government. If TQM is implemented, these obstacles will no longer exist, and the
municipalities of Gauteng will be able to fulfil their constitutionally mandated duties. The
information was gathered via a series of semi-structured interviews. The interview data was
analysed utilising the qualitative data analysis method of theme analysis. Fourteen out of the total
of sixteen Organizational Development workers at the Gauteng municipality were included in the
study's sample. As shown by the findings, TQM had been so badly executed that no evidence of
its use could be found in the municipality of Gauteng. The second big discovery was that the TQM
programme failed because upper management did not back its execution. The analysis also found
that the advantages of TQM had not been realised because of inadequate implementation of the
programme. Also, the research showed that some of the difficulties in implementing TQM came
from a lack of leadership commitment, an inefficient communication strategy, an organization-
wide culture that was not supportive of TQM, and political interference in municipal affairs.
(Mabele & Singh, 2018).

38
4.12. “Total Quality management as applied to service sector with relevance to Indian
situations” by Harischandra Parshuram, 2019

“This study investigates the challenges associated with implementing Total Quality Management
(TQM) in the service industry, including those related to meeting the training demands of workers
and other similar difficulties. Employees nowadays need to be able to make decisions on their own
or as a group if they are to contribute to world-class projects. If workers are given the authority to
make decisions within broad parameters and given sufficient guidance and training, they are more
likely to make choices that advance the organization's mission and vision. Changing their focus to
that of their customers. Customers get more value, workers help the company thrive, and public
perception of the company rises as a result. All of these calls for the installation of proactive and
empathic management, unencumbered by the ego so often associated with high office. Transparent
and welcoming leadership is essential for the long-term success of Total Quality Management,
which is a constant phenomenon. Executives should collaborate with employees rather than
looking down on them. There is no way to overstate the significance of collaboration and constant
progress. The gaps in a company's service standards might be seen via direct communication with
its clientele. While it's true that customers ultimately have all the power, modern businesses don't
have to treat their customers like masters. No one should blindly believe the results of a survey or
questionnaire. Negative consequences may result from biassed reactions. It is important to go
through client feedback and critique it critically. Top-down support for TQM is vital to its success.
Because of the humanistic approach used by TQM principles in their examination of organisations,
a unified TQM framework is more likely to be successfully implemented. TQM is implemented
based on the accessibility of financial and human resources. (Parshuram, 2019).”

4.13. “Influence of top management commitment towards the effective implementation of TQM
in Iraqi oil companies” by Aletaiby et al., 2021

“Total Quality Management (TQM) is a game-changer for every sector experiencing significant
structural change and rising competition since it improves performance. Despite its importance as
a source of petroleum for the world, Iraq is falling behind on the TQM journey owing to
deteriorating quality, most notably in its management systems. Therefore, the purpose of this

39
research is to help TQM flourish in Iraq's oil companies by examining current TQM methods and
the value of Top Management Commitment (TMC) in overcoming obstacles to TQM's widespread
adoption. The research triangulates literature and data from one of the main Iraqi oil corporations
to accomplish this goal using a mixed research technique and a single holistic case study strategy.
According to the findings, TMC is the single most important variable in determining the success
or failure of a company's efforts to adopt TQM. There is a correlation between the lack of top-
level management support for TQM and the difficulties encountered on the road to success, as this
study shows. For the first time, academics will be able to examine TQM procedures in the Iraqi
oil business, which will improve our knowledge of the country's oil industry and maybe inspire
other research. The purpose of this research was to determine the driving forces behind TQM and
the obstacles standing in the way of its spread. According to the results of the study, the top-level
commitment to TQM implementation is a major factor in the program's eventual success and is
correlated negatively with each identified obstacle to TQM's spread. The oil business was able to
overcome or lessen the effect of each obstacle to successful TQM deployment because it
strengthened and refined its TMC, as shown above. (Aletaiby et al., 2021).”

4.14. “Perception of TQM Implementation and Perceived Cost of Poor Quality: A Case Study
of Local Automotive Company’s Supplier” by Esa & Yusof, 2017

In quality management, the proof of successful application of Total Quality Management (TQM)
is of paramount importance. In this article, we investigate how workers at a regional automotive
supplier feel about the company's efforts to adopt total quality management. The primary purpose
of this research is to assess how employees feel about TQM's incorporation, followed by a look at
how the variables are related, and finally, an examination of how each of the 10 TQM factors
affects the price tag for subpar work (CoPQ). The degree to which TQM has been implemented is
considered to be average. Five of the variables have positive moderate to high correlation, and all
of the correlations are significant. Improvements in quality management, employee morale, and
customer appreciation are the three out of ten factors that have the most impact on how people rate
CoPQ. This research deepened the conversation on how these three factors impact TQM in general
and human resource development inside the company. An important suggestion is offered for
reducing internal mistake expenses, including troubleshooting and waste. Several areas for further
40
investigation that have been identified as potentially useful at the policy level have been proposed
as well. (Esa & Yusof, 2017).

4.15. “Some obstacles that affect the TQM implementation in Bangladeshi RMG Sector: An
empirical study” by Talapatra & Uddin, 2018

This report provides an empirical analysis of the challenges to TQM that RMG sector managers in
Bangladesh encounter. The need for product quality enhancement has grown in recent years as
businesses attempt to meet the difficulties presented by modern markets. Already, TQM
deployment has shown a favourable disposition toward quality enhancement. As a consequence,
RMG companies in Bangladesh are exploring how to use TQM. Their companies are unable to
adopt TQM at this time. Two methods are utilised to pinpoint the precise challenges: first, a
comprehensive literature analysis was undertaken to identify the challenges of TQM
implementation, and second, data were gathered from a sample of Bangladeshi RMG companies.
So far, 25 challenges have been uncovered. In the end, the expert's judgement was used to narrow
the list of potential roadblocks down to five. According to the results, the most significant
challenges include a lack of top-level quality commitment, customer focus, continuous
improvement, quality management practise, and understanding of quality cost. When it comes to
examining the challenges to TQM in this industry, this research is the first and only of its kind. As
a result, this article may help answer a pressing question of how TQM might be successfully
implemented in Bangladesh and elsewhere in the world's developing regions. (Talapatra & Uddin,
2018).

4.16. “Implementation barrier of ISo 9001 with in service and manufacturing organizations in
Pakistan” by Mehfooz & Lodhi, 2017

To ensure happy customers, the International Organization for Standardization (ISo) created the
9001 quality management guidelines. The International Organization for Standardization 9001
standard is the most widely used quality management system benchmark worldwide. The goal of
this study is to empirically assess the many obstacles to implementing ISo 9001 in Pakistan's
service and industrial sectors. A comprehensive literature review was performed, and all necessary

41
data was gathered, before beginning this investigation. The questionnaire was the primary tool for
collecting data in this investigation. The first step in this study has been the creation of a
questionnaire using the internet "Google form application software." This questionnaire is
universal across the service and industrial sectors. Throughout Pakistan's service and industrial
sectors, this survey was disseminated. Analysis of the survey results, which were collected
methodically via a Google drive sheet, revealed that the main obstacles to implementing ISo 9001
were a lack of understanding the benefits of confirming ISo 9001, a lack of employee involvement
and empowerment, a lack of reward and motivation, an ineffective performance measurement
system, a lack of focus to implement the PDCA (Plan/Do/Check/Act) cycle for continuous
improvement, and a lack of decision making authority. (Mehfooz & Lodhi, 2017).

4.17. “An Analysis of Implementing Total Quality Management in Education: Sucess and
Challenging Factors” by Khurniawan et al. 2020

“Today, people who are actively engaged in the educational process care more about the quality
of the education they are receiving. Recently, TQM, a practical management concept for dynamic
improvement, customer delight, and organisational excellence, has been adopted in the field of
education to raise the bar on instructional quality. The industrial industry, however, has started to
explore this idea. In order to better understand how to apply TQM in education, this research used
a qualitative approach by reviewing a large body of literature. Success in implementing TQM in
education relies on a number of elements, and this study should shed light on those aspects and
show how best to put them to use. So that schools may take the right measures while actively
adopting TQM in education, this study also explored the problems experienced in doing so. In
addition, we discussed how TQM is being used at Indonesia, especially in technical institutions.
By motivating educators to take an active part in delivering excellent education and building an
environment where high levels of dedication and team spirit are valued, Total Quality Management
has a direct impact on human development. There are several obstacles to implementing TQM in
academic settings. The lack of dedication from those in leadership positions and in the classroom
is a major roadblock. At the meanwhile, Indonesia's TQM implementation, especially in vocational
schools, might benefit from more high-tech facilities, more qualified instructors, and better overall
management. (Khurniawan et al. 2020).”
42
4.18. “The Influence of Integrating ISo and TQM on Project Risk Management” by Khatib et
al. 2020

“Companies in the 21st century have it rough since the business climate is ever-evolving.
Companies nowadays need to work smart and use best practises in quality and risks to survive in
the dynamic and competitive business world. Therefore, this research aimed to ascertain whether
combining the International Organization for Standardization (ISo) and total quality management
(TQM) enhanced project risk management capability. Qualitative primary research was used to
compile the data presented here. Due to their adoption of the ISo 31000 framework, interviews
were performed with the Dubai Electricity and Water Authority, the Roads and Transport
Authority, and the Dubai Maritime City Authority. Data was subjected to a content analysis
procedure. All three businesses seemed to benefit from TQM and ISo, suggesting that these
practises helped them weather economic and operational storms. If other businesses want to
increase their project risk management capabilities, they should follow suit and implement TQM
and ISo together. This study has both theoretical and practical significance. The study's novelty to
the field ensured that it contributed to the existing body of knowledge. There hasn't been a lot of
study done on how ISo and TQM can work together in the UAE. As a result, the previous studies
were expanded upon by this investigation. As a second benefit, our study served to close a gap in
the existing literature. This study paves the way for larger-scale studies on the issue in the future.
Through this study, we gained insight into how combining ISo with TQM may boost project
success and reduce risk. Though risks cannot be eliminated, they may be lessened and managed
before they derail an otherwise successful endeavour. Therefore, there is a great deal of potential
for the application of ISo and TQM to project management and project risk management.
Improvements in customer satisfaction and project risk management are on the horizon. (Khatib
et al. 2020).”

4.19. “Extent of Implementing the Total Quality Management Principles by Academic

Departments Heads at Najran University from Faculty Members’ Perspectives” by Al-Din &
Abouzid, 2016

43
“The purpose of this research was to determine, from the viewpoint of Najran University's teaching
staff, how well Academic Department Heads (ADH) are adopting the principles of Total Quality
Management (TQM). The research also attempted to establish whether or not there were
statistically significant discrepancies between the average estimate of a sample section of faculty
members and ADH's degree of implementation of TQM concepts (gender, faculty, and academic
rank and experience years). There are 200 professors that are part in the study. A total of 44
questions spread throughout six sections of the questionnaire: (effective leadership, Make
decisions based on facts, strategic planning, participation and teamwork, focus on the satisfaction
of the beneficiary, and the continuous improvement and excellence). The most important finding
was that TQM concepts were only moderately implemented (68.4%). The results also showed that
there were statistically significant differences between the responses of faculty members and those
of Academic Department Heads (ADH) at Najran University with regard to their evaluations of
the degree to which the principles of Total Quality Management (TQM) were being implemented
(gender, academic rank and experience years). Finding a clear functional description for the
position of the academic ADH that can describe the responsibilities and specialities at Najran
University is one of the suggestions made in light of this study's results. (Al-Din & Abouzid,
2016).”

4.20. “The problem of fear in TQM – causes, consequences and reduction methods – a literature
review” by Marek Bugdol, 2020

“The primary objective of this study is to investigate and understand the role that worry plays in
organisations that have adopted TQM. The purpose of this research is to pinpoint where worry
may arise within the TQM aspects, as well as to characterise the most prevalent types of worry,
their origins, their consequences, and methods for coping with them.”
“Systematic literature reviews are the primary research approach used. The chosen literature and
publications, database presentation, and content analysis are all based on the stated study purpose
as part of the implemented systematic review approach. The author also draws on his personal
experiences as a TQM consultant and a judge for the Polish Quality Award to support his
arguments.”

44
“This study discusses the origins, key categories, and effects of fear in the context of TQM
elements. It's also made clear that completely removing fear is an improbable goal. Inadequate
allocation of resources (such as a poor choice of quality team members) and the incorporation of
worry into social processes all contribute to an atmosphere of unease (e.g. in the quality team
forming process). It manifests itself when just structural empowerment is implemented rather than
mental empowerment, when contradicting expectations exist in regards to empowerment, when
some workers are required to invest too much time and energy, and when too much emphasis is
put on commitment.”
“This paper's introspective insights might be valuable to quality management professionals by
helping them avoid the pitfalls that give rise to the anxiety that stands in the way of quality
enhancement. All of the factors that make up TQM are covered in this study, but the manifestations
and causes of fear are not. But the collected data might serve as a springboard for other studies.
(Bugdol, 2020).”

4.21. “Risk Analysis Related to Quality Management Principles” by Vykydal et al. 2012

Implementing quality management concepts efficiently and effectively requires a responsible

attitude on the part of upper management. Analyzing the existing situation of Czech companies
reveals several gaps that might be filled to modify management risks. The post explains a few of
them and provides quick tips on how to handle them properly. The article's text is a reflection of
the writers' experience and the information they've gained via a thorough examination of the
settings of industrial businesses. Loyal customers are more likely to buy from you again and tell
their friends about you, both of which are essential to your company's long-term survival in today's
highly competitive marketplace. In the absence of regular monitoring of customer commitment,
how can danger be mitigated? These findings allow us to categorise customers into three distinct
groups: advocates, buyers, and retainers. The level of advocacy loyalty may be gauged by the
frequency with which consumers repurchase or promote a product. Consumers' propensity to
spend more money and buy more items from an organisation is reflected in their level of brand
loyalty.
Each risk can be usually seen from two perspectives:
a) as a danger (downside risk) or
45
b) as an opportunity (upside risk).
We hope this article has made it clear how serious a threat it is that there is so little available
knowledge on how to put quality management principles into practise successfully. We also sought
to demonstrate (by suggestions for customer loyalty assessment and benchmarking) that Czech
businesses have several openings for the removal of risks. (Vykydal et al. 2012).

4.22. “The Link between Business Process Management and Quality Management” by
Stravinskiene & Serafinas 2020

Increasing expenses, robust competition, swiftly expanding technology, more demanding and
mercurial customers, and, in social terms, shifting societal needs are just some of the many
difficulties that businesses must confront in today's era of rapid globalisation and digitalization.
Effective and efficient administration of corporate organisations is realised in this setting. The
study provides theoretical answers to the following problems at the heart of the scientific issue:
When talking about QM, where does Business Process Management (BPM) fit in? Should QM
revolve around BPM? Specifically, this research hopes to reduce the disparity between BPM and
QM by providing a theoretical rationale for their interdependence. A literature review and an
assessment of the applicable scientific literature form the basis of the study technique. The results
demonstrate that various QM and BPM paradigms are often confused with one another and overlap
with one another. The Business Process Management (BPM) paradigm may be seen as a crucial
aspect of all other important quality management paradigms. Business process management
(BPM) is a horizontal field "crossing" several quality management frameworks (e.g., TQM, SMS,
Lean, Six Sigma). The findings are instructive for businesses using quality management systems.
Integrating Business Process Management (BPM) with quality management systems and
technologies paves the way for a more productive and efficient business. (Stravinskiene &
Serafinas 2020).

4.23. “Examining the relationship between soft total quality management (TQM) aspects and
employees' job satisfaction in ISO 9001 Sudanese oil companies by Abuaraki osman Ahmed &
Abdalla Abdelrahim Idris 2020”

46
Purpose

“Aspects of total quality management (TQM) that focus on soft metrics, such as employee
happiness on the work, are known as "soft TQM." The purpose of this study is to draw connections
between the top five soft TQM components and employee happiness in "ISo 9001" certified oil
businesses in Sudan using this methodology.”

Design/Methodology/Approach

“Employees at all five state-owned oil firms in Sudan, who have all implemented the ISo-9001
quality management system, filled out questionnaires to compile the data. The study's population
includes 1,505 full-time workers, and its sample size, 253, was chosen using a stratified random
sampling method. For these data, we used a multiple regression model.”

Findings

“The study's findings revealed that "top management commitment," "employee empowerment,"
"teamwork," "training and education," and "employee participation" accounted for 74% of the
variation in workers' levels of satisfaction with their jobs. At the 5% level of significance, the
results demonstrated a favourable relationship between the soft TQM components and workers'
job satisfaction. It was also shown that there is a positive and statistically significant correlation
between employee happiness and each of the five soft TQM characteristics. At the same time, the
findings revealed that the "employee empowerment" feature of soft TQM had the strongest
correlation coefficient (β) (0.189) with workers' levels of job satisfaction.”

Practical Implications

“Specifically, the research suggests that human resources professionals in businesses using TQM
should adjust their methods to prioritise the development of "soft" parts of the initiative in order
to better meet the needs of their clients and increase employee happiness. In order to reap the long-
term infrastructure benefits that come from employees' job satisfaction, policymakers and top
management should publicly support TQM programmes and allocate the resources necessary to
train their staff in the quality management system that enhances their empowerment and
involvement. Employees are encouraged to support and comply to quality management systems

47
inside their firms because "soft features of TQM" increase their work happiness, according to the
research. (Ahmed & Idris 2020).”

4.24. “Linking strategic management accounting and quality management systems” by

Leonardo Sedevich-Fons, 2018

Purpose

“Since quality management has been shown to have positive impacts on performance and is
increasingly being adopted by businesses, it is becoming a topic of study among management
accountants and academics. Therefore, this study aims to investigate the connections between
these two wide fields and to provide recommendations for how to take them into account together.”

Design/Methodology/Approach

“Strategic management accounting (SMA) and the ISO 9000 quality management system are two
examples of management innovations that are dissected in this paper (QMS). The study would
have to look at the pros and cons of using the two frameworks together, as well as create a model
that takes their best features and combines them.”

Findings

“Theoretically, these management approaches are shown to be compatible and complimentary; as

a result, combining them into a single strategy might boost an organization's overall performance.
It is also believed that combining them might help disseminate SMA methods and allow for QMSs
to be fully used (Fons, 2018).”

4.25. “The Effects of Total Quality Management Practices on Performance and the Reasons of
and the Barriers to TQM Practices in Turkey” by Esin Sadikoglu & Hilal olcay, 2014

“The link between TQM practises and outcomes has been the subject of conflicting and unclear
findings in previous research. This research looked at the causes and roadblocks of TQM practises

48
among Turkish businesses, as well as their effects on different performance indicators. This
research used a cross-sectional survey design, with plants serving as the sampling unit. Firms in
the Kocaeli-Gebze organised Industrial Zone and other Turkish Quality Association members were
used to compile the sample. With a response rate of 48.4%, we were pleased with the 242 useable
surveys we received. The team here engaged in some multiple regression and exploratory factor
analysis. The results of this research reveal that various TQM techniques have vastly varying
impacts on various measures of performance. The research showed that the main challenges
Turkish businesses face are a lack of staff participation, employee knowledge and dedication, an
inadequate company structure, and a lack of resources. For continued performance improvement,
businesses should keep implementing TQM throughout the board. To overcome the obstacles that
limit the successful adoption of TQM procedures, companies can promote employee
involvement/commitment/awareness to TQM, strengthen company structure, and offer resources.
(Sadikoglu & olcay, 2014).”

49
CHAPTER 5

50
5. Discussion

Information gleaned from the literature review centres on the factors that may make or break an
organization's efforts to adhere to quality standards, as well as any associated benefits, drawbacks,
and solutions. Literature 1–8 is based on the factors that affect the success of a company's efforts
to implement quality management principles; literature 9–14 is based on the benefits of
implementing quality principles; literature 15–20 is based on the difficulties that companies
encounter when putting these principles into practise; and literature 21–25 is based on the
preventative measures that companies can take to lessen the impact of these dangers. The results
of the literature review are as follows.

Research papers Aim Findings

Variables associated with implementation of quality principles

1.0 “Implementation of The article gives short As different managers focus on

Total Quality theoretical context for different aspects of quality
Management Principles understanding the business management (such as people-based
in Public Health effects of overall quality management or constant
Institutes in the management concepts. The improvement), their perspectives on
Republic of Croatia” by goal of this study is to ISo will naturally vary. Staff buy-in
Škarica & Hrgovic assess the level of and improved lines of
(2018) implementation of communication are powerful means
generalised quality of promoting the adoption of
management principles. quality management practises
inside organisations. (Škarica &
Hrgović, 2018).
2.0 “An overview of “This study's objective is to The results of this study suggest that
Quality Management "determine the value of a company's bottom line may benefit
System implementation implementing quality from better supplier relationships

51
in a research management principles in and a firmer grip on the appraisal
laboratory” by Demilly order to improve the and management of outsourced
et al. 2018 organization's operations tasks. The second major discovery
and performance via more of this study is that a company's
efficient risk management." productivity and trustworthiness in
its operations improve after using
quality management systems and
adopting its principles (Demilly et
al., 2018).
3.0 “Increasing the value Considering strategic According to the results of this
of quality management relevance, cost, and respect study, the adoption of quality
systems” by Gremyr et al. inside the organisation, this standards with a focus on
2021 study aims to critically compliance is expensive and
examine how quality unsettling for managers, but it
management systems match ultimately benefits the organisation
with and correlate with the as a whole (Gremyr et al., 2021).
views of management on
quality performance.
4.0 “The European The primary objective of this According to the results, a
standards and guidelines study is to determine the successful QMS is the result of a
for internal quality criteria and rules for the well-integrated system that takes a
assurance: An organization's integrated methodical and comprehensive
integrative approach to quality management approach to implementing quality
quality management in systems. standards under the guidance of
higher education?” by capable leaders (Manatos et al.,
Manatos et al. 2017 2017).
5.0 “TQM The purpose of this study is Critical aspects determining QMS
implementation in a least to determine what factors implementation readiness include
developed country: an guarantee preparedness for financial stability, customer focus,
exploratory study of QMS adoption.

52
Yemen” by Aamer et al. and staff enthusiasm (Aamer et al.,
2017 2017).
6.0 “Total quality This research provides an in- Factors that contribute to the
management (TQM) depth analysis of how application of quality management
implementation in the various businesses have concepts include organisational
Nigerian construction implemented TQM. structure, responsibility,
industry” by Egwunatum monitoring, quality supervision, and
et al. (2022) effective communication
(Egwunatum et al., 2022).
7.0 “Innovative methods The purpose of this study is The application of quality concepts
for quality management to determine whether and in the organisation is greatly aided
in educational how novel approaches by the leadership and commitment
organizations” by Nina contribute to enhanced of the management to deliver
Aniskina & Ekaterina quality. creative training (Aniskina &
Terekhova, 2019 Terekhova, 2019).
8.0 “A proposed The study's focus is on how This paper concludes that
preliminary maturity sustainability might affect sustainability boosts an
grid for assessing quality management organization's operational
sustainability reporting practises. operations and provides value
based on quality throughout the whole supply chain,
management principles” which in turn helps strengthen
by Raine Isaksson, 2019 quality management standards.
(Isaksson, 2019).

Advantages

9.0 “Adopting total The purpose of this study is In order to have a meaningful impact
quality management to to analyse the effect of TQM on service industry performance,
enhance service delivery on the high quality of Total Quality Management (TQM)
in medical records: methods, standards, and concepts

53
Exploring the case of the services provided by the need widespread buy-in from all of
Korle-Bu Teaching company. an organization's constituents.
Hospital in Ghana” by (Adjei & Mensah, 2016).
Emmanuel Adjei &
Monica Mensah, 2016
10. “Application of Total The purpose of this paper is The benefits of adhering to TQM
Quality Management to to analyse the benefits of principles include fewer mistakes,
Ensure Food Quality in TQM for the purpose of better management, happier
Food Industry” by Fayaz quality control in the food customers, and higher quality
et al. 2020 business. products. (Fayaz et al., 2020).
11. “An Investigation The study aims to examine TQM principles have several
into Benefits and the pros and cons of using advantages, including increased
Challenges of Total TQM concepts inside an productivity, a more cooperative
Quality Management: organisation. attitude, more employee
The Case of a Gauteng involvement, and clearer lines of
Municipality” by Mabele communication. Lack of leadership
& Singh, 2018 and staff dedication have been noted
as problems. (Mabele & Singh,
2018).
12. “Total Quality The purpose of this paper is Organizations benefit from value
management as applied to pinpoint the factors creation, long-term viability, and
to service sector with connected to quality employee-friendly management
relevance to Indian management principles and practises when TQM concepts are
situations” by their impact on productivity. implemented with the support of top
Harischandra management and a humanistic
Parshuram, 2019 perspective. (Parshuram, 2015).
13. “Influence of top The purpose of this study is Implementing quality standards in a
management to determine how senior setting where upper and lower
commitment towards the leadership's dedication to management work together boosts
effective implementation quality impacts the output, guarantees process

54
of TQM in Iraqi oil company's ability to put efficiency, and removes roadblocks
companies” by Aletaiby those principles into to innovation. (Aletaiby et al.,
et al., 2021 practise. 2021).
14. “Perception of TQM The purpose of this study is Improving customer attention and
Implementation and to determine the factors that adding value to the business may be
Perceived Cost of Poor motivate workers to follow achieved by taking into account
Quality: A Case Study of the company's quality factors like incentive and
Local Automotive policy. recognition throughout the
Company’s Supplier” by application of quality standards.
Esa & Yusof, 2017 (Esa & Yusof, 2017).

Challenges

15. Some obstacles that The purpose of this article is This research shows that the
affect the TQM to take a close look at the company's problems stem from
implementation in obstacles that businesses upper management's lack of
Bangladeshi RMG experience when trying to dedication to quality, cost,
Sector: An empirical put TQM practises into continuous improvement, and
study” by Talapatra & practise. customer focus. (Talapatra &
Uddin, 2018 Uddin, 2018).
16. “Implementation In order to better understand Failure to apply ISO 9001 is due to
barrier of ISo 9001 with the challenges that service- a lack of employee motivation,
in service and based organisations face engagement, incentive,
manufacturing while trying to adopt ISo empowerment, performance, and
organizations in 9001, this study sets out to focus. (Mehfooz & Lodhi, 2015).
Pakistan” by Mehfooz & catalogue such obstacles.
Lodhi, 2017
17. “An Analysis of The goal of this research is to The largest difficulty is the lack of
Implementing Total determine how well TQM participation of senior management
Quality Management in ideas have been received in in the process, despite the fact that

55
Education: Sucess and the academic world, and quality principles have a good
Challenging Factors” by what obstacles have stood in impact on motivation, dedication,
Khurniawan et al. 2020 the way of their wider and team spirit to sustain quality in
adoption. the organisation. (Khurniawan et al.,
2020).
18. “The Influence of The purpose of this The results indicate that the risks of
Integrating ISo and investigation is to determine low employee engagement and
TQM on Project Risk how ISo and quality damaged reputations are a result of
Management” by Khatib principles affect operational a poor application of quality
et al. 2020 dangers in an organisation. principles inside the organisation,
and that these risks might be reduced
thanks to the synergy between ISo
and quality principles. (Khatib et al.,
2020).
19. “Extent of The purpose of this study is This research found that internal
Implementing the Total to determine how much barriers to applying TQM principles
Quality Management progress has been made in contributed to an average
Principles by Academic implementing quality implementation rate of 68.4%. An
Departments Heads at principles despite internal organisation would benefit greatly
Najran University from process barriers. from having a clear functional
Faculty Members’ definition and a strategic strategy to
Perspectives” by Al-Din implementing these principles. (Al-
& Abouzid, 2016 Din & Abouzid, 2016).
20. “The problem of fear The research team here Fear of applying quality standards in
in TQM – causes, hopes to learn what holds the organisation is often due to
consequences and people back from putting isolating factors such as a lack of
reduction methods – a TQM ideas into practise in structural empowerment, a negative
literature review” by their organisation. work-life balance, and a lack of
Marek Bugdol, 2020 social (Bugdol, 2020).

56
Mitigation

21. “Risk Analysis The study's overarching goal Risks must be prioritised and
Related to Quality is to determine the best categorised before they can be
Management Principles” course of action to minimise mitigated. Effective tactics for
by Vykydal et al. 2012 the hazards associated with monitoring and compliance might
putting quality principles be used, depending on the causes, to
into practise. keep the attention on customer
pleasure and loyalty. (Vykydal et
al., 2012).
22. “The Link between The study's overarching goal The results of this research suggest
Business Process is to determine the best ways that reducing risks and successfully
Management and to incorporate quality implementing quality principles in
Quality Management” by assurance practises into an an organisation may be influenced
Stravinskiene & organization's operations in by offering creative training and
Serafinas 2020 order to better respond to fostering loyalty among workers via
customer needs and establish incentives and recognition.
lasting success. (Stravinskiene & Serafinas, 2020).
23. “Examining the The purpose of this study is “It is impossible to bring about
relationship between soft to determine how human organisational change or
total quality resources may help reduce compliance without the support and
management (TQM) the dangers of implementing buy-in of the staff. Human resources
aspects and employees' quality standards in an play an important part in and are
job satisfaction in ISo organisation. linked to employee happiness on the
9001 Sudanese oil job by formulating a plan to boost
companies by Abuaraki their sense of agency in the
osman Ahmed & Abdalla workplace. (Ahmed & Idris, 2020).”
Abdelrahim Idris 2020”
24. “Linking strategic The study's goal is to Maintaining financial stability in the
management accounting examine strategic event of a mishap and creating

57
 and quality management management accounting and effective reward and bonus plans to
systems” by Leonardo its function in reducing risks eliminate the risks associated with
Sedevich-Fons, 2018 associated with the process are two of strategic
implementing quality management accounting's most
assurance rules. important contributions to keeping
an organisation running efficiently
throughout the change process.
(Leonardo Sedevich Fons, 2018).
25. “The Effects of Total The purpose of this research Possible roadblocks to
Quality Management is to investigate the implementing TQM principles
Practices on challenges faced by the include a deficiency in resources,
Performance and the organisation while resistance from key stakeholders,
Reasons of and the implementing TQM and the organization's current
Barriers to TQM techniques and principles, as structure. Efforts to properly
Practices in Turkey” by well as potential solutions. manage these risks might benefit
Esin Sadikoglu & Hilal from the development of a strategy
olcay, 2014 plan to involve stakeholders and
ensure openness. (Sadikoglu &
Olcay, 2014).

There are several ideas that may be used for improving the quality management system in the
service sector. One such idea is "continuous improvement," which entails always keeping tabs on
how things are going and making adjustments based on what you learn. This may be accomplished
via the use of an effective communication strategy to convey expectations to workers and coaching
on how to meet them. The service sector must also put in place solid mechanisms to guarantee
consistent adherence to client specifications. Last but not least, the businesses in the service sector
need to invest in their people by providing them with the training and resources they need to
provide first-rate customer service. This will help them become industry leaders, which will benefit
the company greatly. “The ultimate goal of every quality-focused business is to provide clients
with goods and services of the highest possible standard (Mosadeghrad, 2006). To put it simply,

58
quality management principles are a set of guidelines designed to standardise the ways in which
businesses operate so as to increase their productivity and the quality of the goods and services
they provide to customers. Top-level executives utilise these concepts as the basis for an
overarching framework that will direct the company's operations toward greater efficiency and
effectiveness. To what extent these quality management concepts are put into practise depends on
the specific circumstances of the organisation. The eight tenets of quality management are as
follows: employee participation, human resource management, leadership, customer focus,
employee commitment, process management, continuous improvement, strategic planning
management, innovation, and supply chain management. These quality management concepts help
businesses to remain flexible and productive in response to the ever-evolving needs of their
respective markets, therefore contributing to their overall excellence in practise and performance.
Quality management concepts have been widely implemented by businesses in order to stay ahead
in today's era of rapidly shifting market trends. Organizational success in the face of intense market
competition is correlated with adherence to quality management concepts (Barros et al., 2014).”
Variables such as organisational commitment to continuous improvement, employee satisfaction,
clear lines of communication, outsourced activity management, compliance efficiency, strong
leadership, organisational structure, financial security, employee motivation, quality supervision,
and a focus on sustainability have been linked to the successful application of quality management
principles in the service sector. To a large extent, these factors determine how well quality
management concepts are put into practise inside an organisation.
According to the analysed literature, these benefits can be summarised as follows: quality
standards are maintained; effective services are delivered; stakeholders are satisfied; risks are
minimised; operational costs are cut; employee turnover is low; customers are satisfied; employees
are engaged; top management is committed; and barriers to innovation are removed.
Organizational performance may benefit from adhering to quality standards since doing so
increases value and boosts the company's standing in the eyes of customers throughout the world.
Organizational stability and reputation in the global market are at danger due to the difficulties in
implementing quality management concepts. Problems can arise when upper management isn't
invested in the transition, when workers aren't motivated, when compensation and benefits are too
onerous to bear, when they don't feel like they belong to a team, when they have trouble

59
establishing healthy work-life boundaries, and when they are resistant to the process of change.
All of these things have the potential to ruin a corporation financially and reputationally.
According to the surveyed works, prioritisation and categorization of these risks might help reduce
them by facilitating a more thorough analysis of the threats. The development of efficient tactics
focused on the happiness of both workers and customers might help to eradicate these dangers.
The potential for failure to fully execute quality standards might be mitigated with the use of
internal reward and recognition programmes. It could help to conduct training sessions for staff
and to keep communications open in order to make the transition to the new organisation as smooth
as possible. Risks and difficulties in implementing quality management principles might be
mitigated with the help of a well-thought-out strategy to enhance communication and decision-
making.

60
CHAPTER 6

61
6. Conclusion

This report concludes with a critical review of the applicability of quality management principles
in the service delivery industry. “The goal of this study was to explore the influence of quality
management principles on the service sectors and estimate its significance in improving the
performance of the business in competitive global market. Employee turnover, reluctance to
change, and other unknowns may all threaten an organization's bottom line during a period of
transition. Equally as unknown are the dangers associated with an organization's inability to
succeed in a highly competitive market as are the benefits of using quality management concepts.
It's possible that the company will fail as a result of these threats, but it's also possible that it will
be able to thrive if it takes adaptive measures, such as implementing customer loyalty measurement
and benchmarking, to mitigate the dangers they pose to the business's financial stability and
reputation. Organizations that provide services may benefit from using quality management
concepts. Although these guidelines have been proved to increase customer satisfaction in other
sectors, the services sector has been slow to adopt them due to the complexity of the business. All
service sectors have their own unique challenges, as do their customers. The fact that there is no
one path to quality management might make it hard to consistently apply these guidelines. It has
to be tailored to each individual circumstance, but that doesn't mean businesses shouldn't make it
a priority to learn about their clients' needs and priorities.
“The ideas of quality management and their relevance in service-based organisations have been
critically reviewed using a qualitative methodology. A theoretical data set on the concepts of
quality management and its impact on service-based organisations has been developed using peer-
reviewed literature and case studies. These qualitative data sets have been theoretically analysed
in order to provide results and insights into the study issues. 25 The data utilised in this report was
gathered from a variety of sources, including publications published in peer-reviewed journals, as
well as both new and previously published articles, and case studies. ” This paper found that the
following factors significantly influenced the implementation of quality principles: continuous
improvement, employee satisfaction, effective flow of communication, control of outsourced
activities, reliability, compliance efficiency, effective leadership, organisational structure,
financial stability, employee motivation, quality supervision, and a focus on sustainability.
Maintaining quality standards, delivering effective service, pleasing stakeholders, lowering risks,
62
cutting operational costs, retaining employees, fostering employee engagement, gaining top-level
management's support, and removing roadblocks to innovation are all benefits of adhering to
quality principles. The highlighted difficulties include, but are not limited to, a lack of top-level
buy-in for the change process, low motivation among workers, intolerable incentive programmes,
a dearth of team spirit, isolation, poor work-life balance, and opposition from employees towards
the change process. Its prioritisation and categorization might help reduce risks by letting the
company give them the close scrutiny they deserve. The development of efficient tactics focused
on the happiness of both workers and customers might help to eradicate these dangers. The
potential for failure to fully execute quality standards might be mitigated with the use of internal
reward and recognition programmes. It could help to conduct training sessions for staff and to keep
communications open in order to make the transition to the new organisation as smooth as possible.
Risks and difficulties in implementing quality management principles might be mitigated with the
help of a well-thought-out strategy to enhance communication and decision-making.
Future Research: “Primary research methods, such as a survey and interviews with service-sector
personnel, should be used in future studies to provide a more in-depth understanding of the present
and real-time difficulties in applying quality management concepts to business operations. It's
possible that this method might help us successfully identify appropriate ways for mitigating the
risks and difficulties involved with applying quality management concepts in a service-based
organisation.”
Limitations: The study presented here is based on secondary sources gleaned via a thorough
literature assessment. Our capacity to collect timely data on the viability of quality management
in the context of the service sector is limited by the fact that our study did not include anybody
with knowledge or expertise in the field. Accurate data may be gathered for this research paper by
doing primary research in the form of interviews and surveys. Although this work draws on the
findings of a number of research publications, these results may have changed after their initial
publication.

63
References

1. Aamer et al. (2017). TQM implementation in a least developed country: an exploratory

study of Yemen. The TQM Journal, 29(3). Retrieved from
https://www.emerald.com/insight/content/doi/10.1108/TQM-11-2015-0141/full/html
2. Adjei, E., & Mensah, M. (2016). Adopting total quality management to enhance service
delivery in medical records: Exploring the case of the Korle-Bu Teaching Hospital in
Ghana. Records Management Journal, 26(2). Retrieved from
https://www.emerald.com/insight/content/doi/10.1108/RMJ-01-2015-0009/full/html
3. Ahmed, A. o., & Idris, A. A. (2020). Examining the relationship between soft total quality
management (TQM) aspects and employees' job satisfaction in “ISo 9001” Sudanese oil
companies. The TQM Journal, 33(1). Retrieved from
https://www.emerald.com/insight/content/doi/10.1108/TQM-05-2019-0147/full/html
4. Akaranga, S. I., & Makau, B. K. (2016). Ethical Considerations and their Applications to
Research: a Case of the University of Nairobi . Journal of Educational Policy and
Entrepreneurial Research , 3(12), 1-9. Retrieved from
https://profiles.uonbi.ac.ke/kuria_paul/files/429-825-2-pb.pdf
5. Al-Din, H. M., & Abouzid, M. M. (2016). Extent of Implementing the Total Quality
Management Principles by Academic Departments Heads at Najran University from
Faculty Members’ Perspectives . Journal of Education and Practice , 7(2). Retrieved from
https://files.eric.ed.gov/fulltext/EJ1089774.pdf
6. Aletaiby et al. (2021). Influence of top management commitment towards the effective
implementation of TQM in Iraqi oil companies. Journal of Petroleum Exploration and
Production , 11, 2039–2053. Retrieved from
https://link.springer.com/article/10.1007/s13202-021-01131-3
7. Aniskina, & Terekhova. (2019). Innovative methods for quality management in
educational organizations. International Journal of Quality & Reliability Management,
36(2). Retrieved from https://www.emerald.com/insight/content/doi/10.1108/IJQRM-12-
2016-0235/full/html

64
8. AlShehail, o. A., Khan, M., & Ajmal, M. (2021). Total quality management and
sustainability in the public service sector: the mediating effect of service innovation.
Benchmarking: An International Journal, 29(2), 382-410.
9. Abbas, J. (2020). Impact of total quality management on corporate green performance
through the mediating role of corporate social responsibility. Journal of Cleaner
Production, 242, 118458.
10. Akwei, C., & Zhang, L. (2018). Integrating risk and performance management in quality
management systems for the development of complex bespoke systems (CBSs).
Production Planning & Control, 29(15), 1275-1289.
11. Alsolamy et al. (2013). Total Quality Management & Service Sector. INTERNATIoNAL
JoURNAL of MANAGEMENT & INFoRMATIoN TECHNoLoGY, 6(3), 880-884.
Retrieved from
https://www.researchgate.net/publication/331082685_Total_Quality_Management_Servi
ce_Sector
12. Behara, R. S., & Gundersen, D. E. (2001). Analysis of quality management practices in
services. International Journal of Quality & Reliability Management, 18(6), 584-603.
Retrieved from https://business.fau.edu/images/business/centers/center-for-
services/files/publications/Behara%20et%20al%20IJQRM%202001.pdf
13. Barros et al. (2014). QUALITY MANAGEMENT PRINCIPLES AND PRACTICES
IMPACT oN THE CoMPANIES’ QUALITY PERFoRMANCE. International Conference
on Quality Engineering and Management, 237-247. Retrieved from
https://repositorium.sdum.uminho.pt/bitstream/1822/36188/1/Barros.etal.pdf
14. Bastas, A., & Liyanage, K. (2018). Sustainable supply chain quality management: A
systematic review. Journal of cleaner production, 181, 726-744.
15. Bugdol, M. (2020). The problem of fear in TQM – causes, consequences and reduction
methods – a literature review. The TQM Journal, 32(6). Retrieved from
https://www.emerald.com/insight/content/doi/10.1108/TQM-02-2019-0047/full/html
16. Demilly et al. (2018). An overview of Quality Management System implementation in a
research laboratory. Int. J. Metrol. Qual. Eng., 9(2). Retrieved from
https://www.metrology-
journal.org/articles/ijmqe/full_html/2018/01/ijmqe170027/ijmqe170027.html
65
17. Egwunatum et al. (2022). Total quality management (TQM) implementation in the
Nigerian construction industry. Engineering, Construction and Architectural
Management, 29(1). Retrieved from
https://www.emerald.com/insight/content/doi/10.1108/ECAM-08-2020-0639/full/html
18. Esa, F., & Yusof, Y. (2017). Perception of TQM Implementation and Perceived Cost of
Poor Quality: A Case Study of Local Automotive Company’s Supplier. International
Journal of Industrial and Manufacturing Engineering, 11(2).
19. Emelyanova, D. S., Kolesnichenko-Ianushev, S. L., & Tokarev, M. A. (2019).
organizational and economic problems of applying quality management systems at
engineering companies. π-Economy, 12(2), 92-102.
20. Fayaz et al. (2020). Application of Total Quality Management to Ensure Food Quality in
Food Industry. Journal of Animal Research, 10(3), 329-338. Retrieved from
https://ndpublisher.in/admin/issues/JARv10n3a.pdf
21. Fikri, A. R., Ratnasari, R. T., Ahmi, A., & Kirana, K. C. (2022). Market orientation and
business performance: the mediating role of total quality management and service
innovation among Moslem fashion macro, small and medium enterprises in Indonesia.
Journal of Islamic Accounting and Business Research, (ahead-of-print).
22. Fox, S. (2021). Active inference: Applicability to different types of social organization
explained through reference to industrial engineering and quality management. Entropy,
23(2), 198.
23. Gremyr et al. (2021). Increasing the value of quality management systems. International
Journal of Quality and Service Sciences, 13(3). Retrieved from
https://www.emerald.com/insight/content/doi/10.1108/IJQSS-10-2020-0170/full/html
24. Hussain, M., Khan, M., Ajmal, M., & Khan, B. A. (2019). Supply chain quality
management and organizational performance: empirical evidence from telecom industry in
the UAE. Benchmarking: An International Journal.
25. Kumar, V., Verma, P., Mangla, S. K., Mishra, A., Chowdhary, D., Sung, C. H., & Lai, K.
K. (2020). Barriers to total quality management for sustainability in Indian organizations.
International Journal of Quality & Reliability Management.
26. Isaksson, R. (2019). A proposed preliminary maturity grid for assessing sustainability
reporting based on quality management principles. The TQM Journal, 31(3). Retrieved
66
 from https://www.emerald.com/insight/content/doi/10.1108/TQM-12-2017-
0167/full/html
27. Khatib et al. (2020). The Influence of Integrating ISo and TQM on Project Risk
Management. American Journal of Industrial and Business Management, 10(12).
Retrieved from https://www.scirp.org/journal/paperinformation.aspx?paperid=106294
28. Khurniawan et al. (2020). An Analysis of Implementing Total Quality Management in
Education: Succes and Challenging Factors. International Journal of Learning and
Development, 10(2).
29. Leonardo Sedevich Fons. (2018). Linking strategic management accounting and quality
management systems. Business Process Management Journal, 24(6). Retrieved from
https://www.emerald.com/insight/content/doi/10.1108/BPMJ-02-2018-0038/full/html
30. Li, D., Zhao, Y., Zhang, L., Chen, X., & Cao, C. (2018). Impact of quality management on
green innovation. Journal of cleaner production, 170, 462-470.
31. Luburić, R. (2015). Quality Management Principles and Benefits of their Implementation
in Central Banks. Journal of Central Banking Theory and Practice , 3, 91-121. Retrieved
from
https://www.researchgate.net/publication/282733869_Quality_Management_Principles_a
nd_Benefits_of_their_Implementation_in_Central_Banks
32. Mabele, B. L., & Singh, S. (2018). An Investigation into Benefits and Challenges of Total
Quality Management: The Case of a Gauteng Municipality. International Journal of
Managerial Studies and Research (IJMSR), 6(2), 44-54. Retrieved from
https://www.arcjournals.org/pdfs/ijmsr/v6-i2/5.pdf
33. Manatos et al. (2017). The European standards and guidelines for internal quality
assurance: An integrative approach to quality management in higher education? The TQM
Journal, 29(2). Retrieved from
https://www.emerald.com/insight/content/doi/10.1108/TQM-01-2016-0009/full/html
34. Mehfooz, N., & Lodhi, M. S. (2015). Implementation barrier of ISo 9001 with in service
and manufacturing organizations in Pakistan. IoSR Journal of Business and Management,
17(9), 66-77. Retrieved from https://www.iosrjournals.org/iosr-jbm/papers/Vol17-
issue9/Version-1/J017916677.pdf

67
35. Mosadeghrad, A. M. (2006). Why TQM programmes fail? A pathology approach. TQM
Journal, 26(2). Retrieved from
https://www.researchgate.net/publication/263656925_Why_TQM_programmes_fail_A_p
athology_approach
36. Othman, H., Ibrahim, I., Amer, A., Kasdi, S. A., Feisal, A., & Ismail, M. F. B. (2022).
Employee’s Perspective of organizational Service Quality orientation. Innovations in
Science and Technology Vol. 4, 1-13.
37. Parshuram, H. (2015). Total Quality Management As Applied To Service Sector With
Relevance To Indian Situations. Journal of Management Research and Analysis, 2(2), 127-
132. Retrieved from https://oaji.net/articles/2015/1875-1446449099.pdf
38. Patyal, V. S., & Koilakuntla, M. (2017). The impact of quality management practices on
performance: an empirical study. Benchmarking: An International Journal, 24(2).
Retrieved from https://www.emerald.com/insight/content/doi/10.1108/BIJ-11-2015-
0109/full/html
39. Rahman, M. S. (2017). The Advantages and Disadvantages of Using Qualitative and
Quantitative Approaches and Methods in Language “Testing and Assessment” Research:
A Literature Review . Journal of Education and Learning, 6(1). Retrieved from
https://files.eric.ed.gov/fulltext/EJ1120221.pdf
40. Sadikoglu, E., & olcay, H. (2014). The Effects of Total Quality Management Practices on
Performance and the Reasons of and the Barriers to TQM Practices in Turkey. Advances
in Decision Science. Retrieved from https://www.hindawi.com/journals/ads/2014/537605/
41. Škarica, I., & Hrgović, A.-M. V. (2018). Implementation of Total Quality Management
Principles in Public Health Institutes in the Republic of Croatia. International Journal of
Productivity Management and Assessment Technologies, 6(1), 1-16. Retrieved from
https://dl.acm.org/doi/abs/10.4018/IJPMAT.2018010101
42. Škarica, I., & Hrgović, A.-M. V. (2018). Implementation of Total Quality Management
Principles in Public Health Institutes in the Republic of Croatia. International Journal of
Productivity Management and Assessment Technologies, 6(1), 1-16. Retrieved from
https://dl.acm.org/doi/abs/10.4018/IJPMAT.2018010101

68
43. Snyder, H. (2019). Literature review as a research methodology: An overview and
guidelines. Journal of Business Research, 104, 333-339. Retrieved from
https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S0148296319304564
44. Stravinskiene, I., & Serafinas, D. (2020). The Link between Business Process Management
and Quality Management. Journal of Risk Financial Manag, 13(225).
45. Talapatra, S., & Uddin, M. K. (2018). Some obstacles that affect the TQM implementation
in Bangladeshi RMG Sector: An empirical study. Proceedings of the International
Conference on Industrial Engineering and operations Management, 6(8). Retrieved from
http://ieomsociety.org/ieom2018/papers/401.pdf
46. Utari, N. M. P., & Purnawati, N. K. (2020). Total Quality Management Influence on
Company Performance in PT. PLN (Persero) UP3 South Bali. American Journal of
Humanities and Social Sciences Research (AJHSSR), 4(2), 116-122.
47. Vykydal. (2012). Risk Analysis Related to Quality Management Principles. Scientific
proceedings Faculty of Mechanical Engineering, 20(1), pp. 87-92. Retrieved from
https://www.researchgate.net/publication/258710753_Risk_Analysis_Related_to_Quality
_Management_Principles
48. Wang, M. W. C., Tan, C. L., & Wahid, N. A. (2020). Service Quality, Facilities
Management Practices and outsourcing Service Provider Capabilities: A Critical Review
and Conceptual Framework for Facilities Management Companies. Global Business &
Management Research, 12(2).

69