NYERI Religius

You might also like

Download as pdf or txt
Download as pdf or txt
You are on page 1of 9

burns 45 (2019) 1605 –1613

Available online at www.sciencedirect.com

ScienceDirect

journal homepage: www.elsevier.com/locate/burns

Effects of religious and spiritual care on burn


patients’ pain intensity and satisfaction with pain
control during dressing changes

Nafiseh Keivan a, Reza Daryabeigi b , Nasrollah Alimohammadi c, *


a
Student Research Center, Faculty of Nursing and Midwifery, Isfahan University of Medical Sciences, Isfahan, Iran
b
Adult Health Nursing Department, Ulcer Repair Research Center, Faculty of Nursing and Midwifery, Isfahan
University of Medical Sciences, Isfahan, Iran
c
Critical Care Nursing Department, Ulcer Repair Research Center, Faculty of Nursing and Midwifery, Isfahan
University of Medical Sciences, Isfahan, Iran

article info abstract

Article history: Objective: Spiritual care, beside other nursing interventions, creates a balance in body, psyche
Accepted 2 July 2019 and soul in order to holistically recover one's health. This research aims to study the effects of
a religious and spiritual care program on the intensity of pain and the satisfaction with pain
control during the dressing changes for the burn patients in a hospital in Iran in 2017.
Methods: This research is a clinical trial study conducting 68 burn patients. The samples were
Keywords: randomly divided into ‘experimental’ and ‘control’ groups. The experiment consists of three
Religious-spiritual care sessions of spiritual care carried out by the help of the nurse, a clergy and the patient’s
Burn companion. These sessions have been done before, during and after the dressing change. The
Pain pain intensity and the satisfaction with pain control are measured by VAS1 and NRS2 devices.
Satisfaction The data is analyzed via SPSS version 20 and through the statistical exams of independent t-
Dressing change test, paired t-test, chi-squared test and Mann-Whitney exam.
Results: Before the intervention, there was no significant difference in the average rate of pain
(P = 0.25) and the satisfaction with pain control (P = 0.59) between the experimental and the
control groups. While, after the spiritual care program was conducted, there appeared a
significant difference (P < 0.001): there was a substantial reduction of pain intensity in the
experimental group and the satisfaction with pain control in this group increased as well.
Conclusions: A religious and spiritual care can help decrease the pain intensity caused by the
dressing change and can increase the satisfaction of these patients with pain control.
Therefore, it is recommended that the nurses apply the spiritual cares to alleviate the pain
and to increase the satisfaction with pain control in burn patients.
© 2019 Elsevier Ltd and ISBI. All rights reserved.

* Correspondence author.
E-mail address: Alimohammadi@nm.mui.ac.ir (N. Alimohammadi).
1
Visual Analogue Scale
2
Numerical Rating Scale
https://doi.org/10.1016/j.burns.2019.07.001
0305-4179/© 2019 Elsevier Ltd and ISBI. All rights reserved.
1606 burns 45 (2019) 1605 –1613

Spiritual care is a health care program which is supposed to


1. Introduction
increase the life quality and to promote the feeling of
wellbeing, and it thus decreases disappointment and hope-
Burn is the fourth frequent cause of trauma in the world [1]. It lessness of the patients [18]. In an international conference on
involves painful and stressful experiences that arise from the this subject, spirituality was defined as the aspect of humanity
wound and its treatment procedures [2]. that refers to the way individuals seek and express meaning
In Iran, about 724 thousand people are burned per year, 382 and purpose, and the way they experience their connected-
thousand of whom are hospitalized and about 2920 of whom ness to the moment, self, others, nature, and to the significant
die due to the intensity of burn. This number is so high that or the sacred. Religious factors are also an important aspect of
burn is known as the sixth cause of death in Iran. On the other spirituality [19]. Spiritual care responds to human's basic and
hand, these statistics show that the burn level experience is principal questions like the meaning of life, pain, suffering and
much higher in Iran compared to the statistic results in the death.
world [3,4]. According to the psychological definitions, religion is the
Burn, which is among the 5–12% of the most frequent effect of the emotions and events that every person may
accidents in the world, can be mortal and can cause problems experience in solitude and free from any dependence so that a
like pain, physical deficiencies and psychological and eco- relationship is created between the person and that whom he/
nomic problems [5]. In fact, burn injury is the most painful she considers devine. This relation is created through the heart
trauma one can undergo [6]. This pain does not merely arise or the reason or the religious deeds and rituals [20]. Various
from the wound itself, but mostly from the procedures such as studies have shown that religion is a supportive power that
dressing change, unsuitable dressing and also from cleansing helps to decrease the psychological pressures and to increase
the wound [7]. That is why an effective alleviation of pain is the satisfaction with life. Nevertheless, it was diagnosed that
assumed as a principal challenge to deal with for the the nurses do not pay attention to the religious/spiritual aspect
healthcare of this domain [8]. of the burn patients and that the patients’ spiritual and
In most hospitals, in spite of strong drugs and painkillers emotional sides are mostly ignored [21]. That is why the
prescribed to sedate the pain of the burn patients, the pain nursing system needs to adopt new theories to satisfy the
alleviation has still remained a main challenge [9,10]. That is religious and spiritual needs of the patients. Practicing
because in spite of these drugs, the degree of pain resulting religious cares such as prayer, religious vows and attending
from dressing changes is moderate to severe [11]. Hence, sacred religious places helps the patients to tolerate the pain
despite their availability and popular use, the medical pain- and to control their pain and stress in a more efficient way.
killers are not the only solution to control the pain. The non- Encouraging the patients who need to do prayers and religious
medical methods, which have a lower risk, may also be applied deeds to do so is thus considered an effective way in the cure
at the same time as the medical ones to sedate the pain in a process [22].
more efficient way [12]. In spite of the interconnection throughout history between
The patients’ responses to pain or suffering may be heavily religion, spirituality and medical practices, only in the last
influenced by their religious and cultural backgrounds [13]. decades has the scientific literature demonstrated the impor-
This matter highlights the importance of religious and tant role of religiosity and spirituality in the physical and
spiritual cares. The psychological associations in America mental health of the patients [23]. Unfortunately, in spite of the
recommend that the physicians get informed about the growth in a general interest in the spiritual aspect of the
religious and spiritual tendencies of their patients. This patients and despite the significant role of religiosity and
recommendation is based upon the idea that the care which spirituality in different parts of health career, no attention has
must be provided for a patient is beyond merely curing the been paid to this matter in pain control satisfaction domain of
patient and includes meeting his/her different needs. There- the burn patients. On the other hand, in spite of all the
fore, since religion responds to and fulfills many of human's researches done about the advantages of spirituality for
needs and his/her existential lack, many patients demand patients in pain, the effect of spirituality on pain control still
their spiritual and religious needs to be met as well [14,15]. needs to be studied [21,24]. Therefore, this study targets to
Today, the cultural, religious, and social differences in analyze the influence of a religious and spiritual care program
different societies are a considerable challenge for the health on both the pain intensity and the satisfaction with pain
care system. Understanding the unique perspective and control of burn patients in Islamic Republic of Iran as a country
beliefs of each patient is an essential component of providing with Muslim population.
competent health care. Among the religions and cultural
variations, Islam is a living religion with an estimated one
billion followers worldwide in 120 Islamic and non-Islamic 2. Materials and methods
countries (Muslims, being those who practice the religion of
Islam) [16]. In Islamic scholars’ view, beside the material 2.1. Patients and settings
dimension, a human has an immaterial structure called spirit
(divine soul), which forms his noble dimension. This structure This research (coded 396208 in Isfahan University of Medical
has a divine nature and a tendency toward God. This fact Sciences) is a randomized clinical trial study which has been
indicates that from the viewpoint of Islamic scholars, nursing done in Imam Musa Kazem Hospital of Isfahan in the general
and taking care of patients could include considerations of burn and intensive care units. The quantity of the sample, with a
both material and immaterial structures [17]. safety coefficient of 95% in the test, i.e. 1.96, and the test power
burns 45 (2019) 1605 –1613 1607

coefficient of 80%, i.e. 0.84, consists of 32 persons per group. In with pain control, NRS was used which is scaled from 0 to 10,
general, 64 persons were taken into account for this study. The where zero stands for dissatisfaction with pain control and ten
samples were divided into two groups of ‘experimental’ and means a full satisfaction with pain control [30].
‘control’ by using random number table.
2.4. Procedures
2.2. Inclusion and exclusion criteria
In order to respect the ethical issues, the researcher asked for a
The criteria of selection of the patients were: being a Muslim, written permission from those in charge in the hospital, and
willingness to take part in the research [25], no addiction to also from the patients about the participation while explaining
drugs and narcotics [26], being aged more than 18 [27], having a the aims of the research to them. Thereafter, the spiritual care
burn level of more than 20%, being in acute phase (from 24 to program provided by the researcher was confirmed by the
72 h after the burning), capable to speak and communicate faculty members of the department of theology and Islamic
with a full consciousness and awareness about the people, studies as well as the department of nursing of University of
time and place [28], not to be hearing or visually impaired [8] Isfahan. The spiritual care program was implemented for three
and not suffering mental and cognitive disturbances like days (Tables 1–3).
delirium and dementia [9]. The criteria for exclusion from the As far as the control group was concerned, beside the
study consisted of: no more willingness to participate, getting routine control cares of the pain, this group received three 45–
into an emergency state (such as respiratory distress, a fall of 60 min sessions done by a research colleague not familiar with
the consciousness level, fluid and electrolyte disorders) [28], the research procedure. The sessions were held along three
and not participating in at least one session of the spiritual care days, where they shared and expressed freely their feelings,
program. memories and their experiences on care matters and
problems.
2.3. Instrument selection and application Regarding the experimental group, all information (includ-
ing demographic data, the information related to burn,
The data was gathered and analyzed through demographic morphine intake, the pain intensity measurements and the
checklist, Visual Analogue Scale (VAS) and Numerical Rating satisfaction with pain control) was gathered through the
Scale (NRS). The checklist involved personal and clinical questionnaires and inquiry before the spiritual care program.
information gathered through questions about gender, age, Then, data was analyzed via SPSS version 20 and through the
marital status, education, occupation, and the reason, area, statistical exams of independent t-test, paired t-test,
depth and percentage of burn. The morphine intake was chi-squared test and Mann–Whitney exam. Tables 1–3 show
studied as well because 5 mg of morphine was prescribed for what the experimental group received exactly as religious/
some of the patients before the dressing change. To measure spiritual procedure in each session.
the pain intensity, VAS was used. VAS is a pain measurement
instrument which is a horizontal 10 cm line with word anchors 2.5. Statistical analysis
at the extremes: i.e. “no pain” on one end and “worst possible
pain” on the other [12]. It is a widely used tool the Data was summarized using mean SD and frequency for
standardization of which is proved due to its validity and quantitative and qualitative variables. Patients’ basic infor-
reliability [26,28,29]. The samples were asked to mark the mation, demographic data, pain intensity and satisfaction
points of the scale on the horizontal line, which show the with pain control were presented with descriptive statistics,
severity of their pain, or to say its number to the researcher. with chi-squared test and independent t-test. Independent
Then that distance was estimated, and the level of pain t-test was used for comparison of age and burn percentages.
intensity was calculated. To measure the patient's satisfaction Chi-square test was used for comparison of qualitative

Table 1 – Contents of the spiritual care in first session.

First session:
Before the dressing change: The nurse researcher was present on the patient's bed with a supportive approach, creating a therapeutic
(around 20–30 min before) relationship with the patient. She did the following:
 Established a good relationship with the patient based on confidence, sympathy, understanding and
honesty
 Assured the patient about the confidentiality of the conversations [31].
 Let the patient express himself/herself freely and with no restrain
 Listened attentively, patiently and without any prejudgment to the patient's worries and anxieties as
well as his/her physical and psychological problems [32].
 Provided the patient with any necessary moral or psychological support [31] (either by pressing his/her
hand, or by smiling or using humor and anecdotes in case or through any relevant supportive
counseling, etc.)
During the dressing change: Recorded verses of Quran were played for the patients.
After the dressing change: The presence of a family member or a close friend there for the patient [33].
1608 burns 45 (2019) 1605 –1613

Table 2 – Contents of the spiritual care in second session.


Second session:
Before the dressing change: The nurse researcher was present on the patient's bed with a supportive approach, she did the following:
(around 20–30 min before)  Developed a good relationship with the patient [33]
 Encouraged the patient to express his/her religious beliefs [34]
 Helped and guided the patient to find a meaning in the disease according to the destiny, and, thus, to see
that all the events happen within God's will. (In believing optimistically in God's program for the world
and for each person, the Muslim patient could be saved from disappointment, pessimism and nihilistic
thoughts which could happen after the burn trauma.)
 Encouraged the patient to pray and to read holy texts [33]
 Gave any possible and needed moral, spiritual or psychological support to the patient (either by pressing
his/her hand, or by smiling or using humor and anecdotes in case or through any relevant supportive
psychological counseling, etc.)
During the dressing change: Some recorded verses of Quran were played for the patients.
After the dressing change: A clergy was present to talk about the religious philosophy of pain and troubles in the world and the reward
one gets in the other world for tolerating them. This makes the patience and tolerance toward the pain a
holy action for the believer patients [35].

variables such as gender and marital status. The Mann– depth and the percentage of burn and also the morphine intake
Whitney exam was used for comparison of education and also (Tables 4–6).
the depth of burn. All the tests were two-sided, and p < 0.05
was considered statistically significant. All calculations were 3.2. Pain intensity
performed with the statistical software SPSS Version 20.
The average score and the standard deviation of the pain
intensity of the two groups were not significantly different
3. Results before the study (p > 0.05). However, after the study, the
average score of pain intensity was significantly less in the
3.1. The Patients’ basic demographic and clinical experimental group than in the control group (p < 0.05)
characteristics (Table 7).

The results demonstrated that the patients in experimental 3.3. Satisfaction with pain control
and control groups were not significantly different in terms of
demographic data, neither in terms of the characteristics The independent t-test exam showed that the average score
related to the burn. These data were about gender, age, marital of the satisfaction with pain control was not significantly
status, education, occupation, and the reason, the area, the different in the two groups before the study (p > 0.05). While

Table 3 – Contents of the spiritual care in third session.

Third session:
Before the dressing change: The nurse researcher was present on the patient's bed with a supportive approach, she did the following:
(around 20–30 min before)  Created a trusting relationship with the patient
 Encouraged the patient to repent for his/her sins [36].
 Provided the patient with any necessary moral or psychological support (either by pressing his/her
hand, or by smiling or using humor and anecdotes in case or through any relevant psychological
counseling, etc.)
 Gave hope and empowered and encouraged the patient's internal forces (by complimenting on his/her
skills and abilities, depicting a bright future for him/her etc.)
 Suggested positive sentences and healthy constructive thoughts
 Encouraged the patient to pass time with those whose presence is peaceful and soothing for the him/her
 Assured the patient about the availability and accessibility of the nurse for any moral and psychological
support [34].
During the dressing change: Some recorded verses of Quran were played for the patients.
After the dressing change: A clergy was present on the patient's bed in order to:
 Answer the patient's religious questions and concerns
 Talk about the religious philosophy of pain and the reward one gets in the world hereafter for
undergoing them
 Pray for the patient [34]
 Recount the life of religious models and prophets like Abraham, Jacob, Joseph, Muhammad and etc. The
goal is to make the patient see these figures as a model and to tolerate the pain more easily having these
examples which have also undergone hardships in mind.
burns 45 (2019) 1605 –1613 1609

Table 4 – The average of age and the percentage of burn in the two groups.
Variation Experimental group Control group Independent t-test

Mean Standard deviation Mean Standard deviation t P


Age 33.94 13.76 34.12 9 0.06 0.95
Percentage of burn 48.50 17.20 46.28 14.09 0.56 0.57

Table 5 – Demographic data.


Variation Experimental group Control group x2 P

Quantity Percentage Quantity Percentage


Gender
Female 12 37.5 15 46.9 0.58 0.45
Male 20 62.5 17 53.1
Marital status
Single 10 31.2 8 25 – 0.44
Married 22 68.8 23 71.9
Divorced 0 0 1 3.1
Education
Illiterate 2 6.2 2 6.2 0.90 Z = 0.13
Below high school diploma 15 46.9 13 40.6
High school diploma 6 18.8 12 37.6
University education 9 28.1 5 15.6
Job
Governmental employed 4 12.5 4 12.5 0.38 –
Self-employed 13 40.6 12 37.5
Retired 2 6.2 2 6.2
Housewife 10 31.2 13 40.62
Unemployed 3 9.5 1 3.1

Table 6 – The distribution of the frequency of the reason of burn, the area of burn, the level of burn, and the amount of the
morphine used in both groups.
Variation Experimental group Control group x2 P

Quantity Percentage Quantity Percentage


Mechanism
Electric 4 12.5 6 18.8 – 0.63
Chemical 1 3.1 2 6.2
Thermal 27 84.4 24 75
Burn sites
Torso and the upper organs 19 59.4 14 43.8 – 0.26
Torso and the lower organs 0 0 1 3.1
Torso and the upper and lower organs 13 40.6 17 53.1
Depth
2 11 34.4 13 40.6 Z = 0.51 0.61
2&3 21 65.6 19 59.4
Morphine intake 27 84.4 25 78.1 0.41 0.52

Table 7 – The average score of pain intensity caused by dressing change during different moments for both groups.
Time Experimental group Control group Independent t-test

Mean Standard deviation Mean Standard deviation t P


Pre intervention 8.50 1.64 7.74 2.18 1.16 0.25
First session post intervention 6.94 2.29 8.25 2.13 2.38 0.02
Second session after the study 6.03 2.12 8.44 1.74 4.97 <0.001
The third session after the study 4.44 2.33 8.34 2.09 7.07 <0.001
The variation analysis exam in repeating F 22.92 1.05
the observations P <0.001 0.38
1610 burns 45 (2019) 1605 –1613

Table 8 – The average score of the satisfaction with pain control in both groups before and after the study.
Time Experimental group Control group Independent t-test

Mean Standard deviation Mean Standard deviation t p


Before the study 2.16 0.50 2.53 0.46 0.54 0.59
After the study 6.53 0.44 2.25 0.40 7.17 <0.001

this score raised significantly in the experimental group of the religious and spiritual care on both the pain intensity
after the study (p < 0.05). The paired t-test also demonstrat- and the satisfaction with pain control at the time of the
ed that the average score of the satisfaction with pain dressing change in the burn patients suffering an intense pain.
control has raised in experimental group after the experi- The results demonstrate a fall in pain intensity and a
ment compared to this score in the same group before the consequent rise in the satisfaction of the patients with pain
experiment (p < 0.05). Nevertheless, these scores have not control after the experimental interventions.
significantly changed in the control group after the study Various studies all over the world have shown that religion
(p < 0.05) (Table 8). is a supportive power that helps to decrease the psychological
pressures and to increase the satisfaction with life. The use of
spiritual practices in treatment has more often been related to
4. Discussion improved tolerance of both acute [45] and chronic [46] pain
rather than to reduced intensity of pain. However, a review of
Management of the pain caused by burn has always been a studies using mindfulness-based interventions that often
challenging issue [11]. In the last century, there have been include a meditation component found that some studies also
dramatic shifts in our approach toward understanding, report a reduction in pain intensity [47]. In one study
assessment, and management of pain [24]. In recent years, a investigating the effectiveness of meditation, the positive
great deal of attention has been paid to the mind, the body, the effect of meditation was dependent on having a spiritual focus.
spirit and the psyche of human in order to develop a holistic Participants were divided into groups that used relaxation and
treatment [37]. Thereby, the attention to spirituality has been either a secular or a spiritual meditation that included the use
recognized as a part of the holistic nursing care which can of phrases with spiritual (but not necessarily religious)
enhance the patients’ satisfaction effectively [38]. content. The group that used the meditation with spiritual
Many studies show the relation between the attention paid content demonstrated a significantly greater improvement in
to the spiritual and religious needs of the patients and their mood and spiritual well-being, and the pain tolerance was
general spiritual and psychological well-being which helps to increased to nearly the double of that of the other group [48].
cope better with pain. Nabolsi and Carson, for example, found Accordingly, the pain intensity is much less for the patients
that the patients’ faith and spiritual beliefs may facilitate who see God as forgiving, merciful and caring than for those
coping with illness and may strengthen their inner strength, who have a vengeful angry ignoring image of God [24]. A study
hope, acceptance, and self-care, and would help them on the role of pastoral care in the treatment of patients with
understand that life has a meaning [39]. More recent evidence burn injury showed that the patients under religious care had a
also suggests that the use of spirituality and religiosity can be higher TBSA (Total Body Surface Area), longer stay, more
regarded as an active and positive coping process with physician and facility charges and more mortality (p < 0.001).
beneficial effects [40]. For instance, in case of those patients This study concludes with affirming the religious affiliation as
who deal with persistent pain, the use of positive spiritual a possible marker of a better treatment and suggests to finally
coping practices, such as asking God for strength and support, consider the spiritual needs of the burn patients [49]. Several
help to adjust better to pain and to have a significantly better other studies have found that those who consider themselves
mental health [24]. In this regard, Beckelman et al. studied spiritual and religious or engage in religious activities score
people with heart disease between 2004 and 2005 and better in terms of mood, well-being, and pain intensity than
indicated that spiritual well-being is inversely associated with those who do not regard themselves as spiritual or religious
depression [41]. Bussing also demonstrated the role of spiritual [50,51]. Although some of these studies suggest an association
beliefs in reducing depression, pain and social isolation, and in between the spiritual/religious activity and lower levels of pain
increasing life satisfaction [42]. Hosseini et al.’s findings intensity, the overall evidence suggests that the spiritual well-
showed that spiritual care could reduce anxiety in Shia being has a stronger link with higher pain tolerance and higher
Muslim patients undergoing CABG (Coronary Artery Bypass levels of psychological well-being, including satisfaction in
Graft) [43]. general [52].
According to Booker’s study on pain, human beings need In the present study, according to the independent t-test,
spiritual interventions to control and deal with their pain [44]. the average score of pain intensity in dressing change has been
However, despite the growing interest in spirituality and its shown to be significantly lower in the experimental group than
wide adoption by some sections of the health profession such in the control group (p < 0.05) after the intervention. The
as palliative care, it has received little attention in the field of average point of pain intensity in the experimental group had
pain management in particular [24]. Hence, through a concrete been 8.5 and has decreased to 4.44 after the spiritual care
approach, the present study has tried to measure the influence program has been applied. This is while the average pain
burns 45 (2019) 1605 –1613 1611

intensity score of the control group has raised from 7.74 to 8.34.
Author agreement
The researcher thus concludes that the religious/spiritual care
can have an effective role in sedating the pain of the burn
patients. All authors have seen and approved the final version of the
In a study that affirms the findings of the present research, manuscript being submitted. The article is the authors’
Jahanizadeh et al. have shown the effect of the spiritual care on original work, has not received prior publication and is not
decreasing the pain intensity of the patients suffering breast under consideration for publication elsewhere.
cancer [53]. Also, a study on the effect of the recitation of God’s
name, Allah, on pain and stress of dressing change for the burn
patients (like what has been done through the recitation of Funding
Quran’s verses in the present research) shows the positive
effect of this recitation on these Muslim patients [54]. The study was partially funded by the Isfahan University of
With regards to the satisfaction with pain control, nearly no Medical Sciences and partially by the first author personally.
study has been done to measure and analyze this factor in burn
patients who have received a spiritual care program. A few
researches have studied the satisfaction in general and with a Conflicts of interest
limited experimental intervention for burn patients. For
example, one of the aims of Bishop et al’s review study was The authors declare no conflicts of interest
to show that the presence of family members during the
patients’ dressing change can enhance the satisfaction of the
patients and their family and can therefore reduce the pain, Acknowledgements
anxiety and the amount of the drugs taken [55]. In the present
study, too, the researcher has benefited from the presence and This article has been extracted from the thesis coded 396208 in
support of a family member in the first session after the Isfahan University of Medical Sciences. We would like to
dressing change as a spiritual approach and the results acknowledge and thank the dear patients who accepted to be
confirm the enhance of the satisfaction with pain control in our samples of study, the managers and personnel of Imam
these burn patients. Musa Kazem burn hospital, the Research Center of the Faculty
The average point of the satisfaction with pain control of of Nursing and Midwifery in Isfahan University of Medical
the patients in this research is calculated with NRS. This Sciences, Mr Kolivand (the clergy of the center), Parviz Nadimi
score has raised from 2.16 to 6.53 in the experimental group (research colleague) and Shafigheh Keivan (the translator) for
and has slightly changed from 2.53 to 2.25 in the control their help and support in this study.
group. Hence, according to the independent t-test and the
paired t-test results, the average point of the satisfaction REFERENCES
with pain control in the experimental group has really raised
after the experimental intervention (p < 0.05) while it has
stayed quite steady in the control group. Due to its
[1] Peck MD. Epidemiology of burns throughout the world. Part I:
relationship with pain intensity, the assessment of the distribution and risk factors. Burns 2011;37(7):1087–100.
satisfaction of the patients with the pain is influential on the [2] Van der Heijden MJE, De Jong A, Rode H, Martinez R, Van Dijk
quality of the treatment and must thus be taken into M. Assessing and addressing the problem of pain and distress
consideration by the medical teams. during wound care procedures in pediatric patients with
burns. Burns 2018;44(1):175–82.
[3] Kafi S, Atashkar S, Amir AS, Rezvani S. Relationship of post-
traumatic stress disorder with psychological defense styles in
5. Conclusion burn patients. Q Horiz Med Sci 2013;19(3):155–60.
[4] Ghadimi Gili E, Fathi M, Kraskian A, Ahadi H. Evaluation of the
This study demonstrates that a religious/spiritual care can be effect of hypnosis on the anxiety reduction in burn dressing
considered an effective nursing intervention, which reduces change. Med J Mashhad Univ Med Sci 2016;59(3):163–70.
pain and increases satisfaction with pain control. Due to its [5] McLatchie G, Borley N, Chikwe J. Oxford handbook of clinical
surgery. 4th edition Oxford: Oxford University Press; 2013.
efficiency, security and simplicity, this care program should
[6] Yuxiang L, Lingjun Z, Lu T, Mengjie L, Xing M, Fengping S, et al.
be taken in to consideration as a suitable complementary
Burn patients’ experience of pain management: a qualitative
method in the treatment of burn patients. Nevertheless, this study. Burns 2012;38(2):180–6.
method is limited to and dependent on the personal beliefs of [7] Upton D. Psychological aspects of wound care: implications for
the patients towards spirituality and religion and the clinical practice. J Community Nurs 2014;28(2):52–7.
difference in their spiritual needs that may influence the [8] Kipping B, Rodger S, Miller K, Kimble RM. Virtual reality for
pain. This aspect, however, was out of the control and acute pain reduction in adolescents undergoing burn wound
care: a prospective randomized controlled trial. Burns 2012;38
analysis of this research. Thus, regarding the results of this
(5):650–7.
study on one hand, and its limitations on the other, studies
[9] Small C, Stone R, Pilsbury J, Bowden M, Bion J. Virtual
on the same subject, though with greater quantity of restorative environment therapy as an adjunct to pain control
samples, longer duration than three days and on patients during burn dressing changes: study protocol for a
of other religions is recommended. randomized controlled trial. Trials 2015;16(1):1–7.
1612 burns 45 (2019) 1605 –1613

[10] Mendoza A, Santoyo FL, Agulló A, Fenández-cañamaque JL, [33] Jensen Sh. Nursing health assessment: a best practical
Vivó C. The management of pain associated with wound care in approach. 2nd edition Philadelphia: Wolters Kluwer Health;
severe burn patients in Spain. Int J Burns Trauma 2016;6(1):1–10. 2015 p. 224.
[11] Hsu KC, Chen LF, Hsiep PH. Effect of music intervention on [34] Taylor C, Lillis C, Lemon P, Lynn P. Fundamentals of nursing.
burn patients’ pain and anxiety during dressing changes. 8th edition Philadelphia: Lippincott Williams & Wilkins; 2015.
Burns 2016;42(8):1789–96. p. 1716–9.
[12] Hinkle JA, Cheever KH. Brunner & Suddarth’s textbook of [35] Asadi M, asadzandi M, Ebadi A. Effects of spiritual care
medical surgical nursing. 13th edition Philadelphia: Lippincott based on Ghalb salim nursing model in reducing anxiety of
Williams & Wilkins; 2014. patients undergoing CABG surgery. Iran J Crit Care Nurs
[13] Speck P. Culture and spirituality: essential components of 2014;7(3):142–51.
palliative care. Postgrad Med J 2016;92:341–5. [36] Mahdavi B, Fallahi K, Mohammadi F, Hosseini M. The effect of
[14] Mueller PS, Plevak DJ, Rummans TA. Religious involvement, group spiritual care on quality of life in family caregivers of
spirituality, and medicine: implications for clinical practice. elders with Alzheimer disease. J Health Promot Manage 2015;4
Mayo clinic proceedings. Elsevier; 2001. (3):34–42.
[15] Carpenito-Moyet LJ. Nursing care plans & documentation: [37] Mary T, Oneill D, Mako C. Addressing spiritual pain. J Catholic
nursing diagnoses and collaborative problems. Philadelphia: Health Assoc United States 2011;2(1):43–5.
Lippincott Williams & Wilkins; 2009. [38] Fatemi M, Nazari R, Safavi M, Naini M, Savadpour M. The
[16] Alimohammadi N, Taleghani F. Health and healthy human relationships between nurses’ spirituality and patients
being in Islamic thought: reflection on application for the ‘satisfaction in the hospitals of Ardabil university of medical
nursing concept: a philosophical inquiry. J Educ Health Promot science. Med Ethics J 2016;5:141–59.
2015;4:1–8. [39] Nabolsi M, Carson A. Spirituality, illness and personal
[17] Taleghani F, Alimohammadi N, Mohammadi E, Akbarian R. responsibility: the experience of Jordanian Muslim men with
Nursing in Islamic thought: reflection on application nursing coronary artery disease. Scand J Caring Sci 2011;25(1):716–24.
metaparadigm concept: a philosophical inquiry. Iran J Nurs [40] Büssing A, Michalsen A, Balzat HJ, Grünther RA, Ostermann T,
Midwifery Res 2013;18(4):272–9. Neugebauer EA, et al. Are spirituality and religiosity resources
[18] Ettun R, Schultz M, Bar-sel G. Transforming pain into beauty: for patients with chronic pain conditions? Pain Med 2009;10
on art, healing, and care for the spirit. Evid Based Complement (2):327–39.
Altern Med 2014;1(1):1–7. [41] Bekelman DB, Becker DM, Wittstein IS, Hendricks DE,
[19] Yoon SJ, Suh SY, Kim SH, Park J, Kim YJ, Kang B, et al. Spiritual Yamashita TE, Gottlieb SH. Spiritual well-being and
well-being among palliative care patients with different depression in patients with heart failure. J Gen Intern Med
religious affiliations: a multicenter Korean study. J Pain 2007;22(4):470–7.
Symptom Manage 2018;1:1–9. [42] Borji M, Tarjoman A. Investigating the effect of religious
[20] Zand S, Rafiei M. Assessing religious care needs of patients in intervention on mental vitality and sense of loneliness among
hospital. Teb va Tazkieh 2010;19(4)21–34 Text in Persian. the elderly referring to community healthcare centers. J Relig
[21] Sheini-Jaberi P, Zarea K, Shariati A, Moradi M. Holistic care as a Health 2018;1–8.
response to the needs of burn patients: a qualitative content [43] Hosseini M, Davidson PM, Fallahi Khoshknab M, Green A.
analysis. J Clin Nurs Midwife 2014;3(1):17–27. Spiritual and religious interventions in health care: an
[22] Zand S, Rafiei M. Patients’religious care: a neglected need in integrative review. Iran Rehabil J 2013;11(1):87–93.
medical education. J Edu Dev Med Sci 2016;8(20):49–57. [44] Booker SQ. Older African Americans’ beliefs about pain,
[23] Koenig H, King D, Carson VB. Definitions. In handbook of religion biomedicine, and spiritual medicine. J Christ Nurs 2015;32
and health. New York: Oxford University Press; 2012. p. 37–8. (3):55–148.
[24] Siddal PJ, Lovell M, Macleod R. Spirituality: what is its role in [45] Wachholtz AB, Pargament KI. Is spirituality a critical
pain medicine? Pain Med 2015;16(1):51–60. ingredient of meditation? Comparing the effects of spiritual
[25] Varvani Farahani P, Hekmatpour D, Shamsikhani S. meditation, secular meditation, and relaxation on spiritual,
Effectiveness of muscle relaxation on pain, pruritus and vital psychological, cardiac, and pain outcomes. J Behav Med
signs of patients with burns. J Crit Care Nurs 2013;6(2):87–94. 2005;28:369–84.
[26] Lalegani H, Esmaeeli S, Karimi M, Moghani M, Jivad N. The [46] Wachholtz A, Pearce M. Does spirituality as a coping
effect of deep-slow and regular breathing on pain intensity of mechanism help or hinder coping with chronic pain? Curr Pain
burn dressing. J Crit Care Nurs 2014;6(4):223–8. Headache Rep 2009;13:127–32.
[27] De Jong A, Bremer M, Hofland HW, Schuurmans MJ, [47] Reiner K, Tibi L, Lipsitz JD. Do mindfulness-based
Middelkoop E, Van loey NE. The visual analogue thermometer interventions reduce pain intensity? A critical review of the
and the graphic numeric rating scale: a comparison of self- literature. Pain Med 2013;14:230–42.
report instruments for pain measurement in adults with [48] Amy B, Kenneth I. Is spirituality a critical ingredient of
burns. Burns 2015;41(2):333–40. meditation? Comparing the effects of spiritual meditation,
[28] Mazlom S, Hosseini Amiri M, Tavoosi SH, et al. Effect of direct secular meditation, and relaxation on spiritual, psychological,
transcranial current stimulation on pain intensity of burn cardiac, and pain outcomes. J Behav Med 2005;28(4):369–84.
dressing. Evid Based Care 2014;4(4):35–46. [49] Hultman CS, Saou MA, Roach ST, Hultman SC, Cairns BA,
[29] Gift AG. Visual analogue scales: measurement of subjective Massey S, et al. To heal and restore broken bodies: a
phenomena. Nurs Res 1989;38(5):286–8. retrospective, descriptive study of the role and impact of
[30] Carrougher GJ, Ptacek J, Sharar SR, Wiechman S, Honari S, pastoral care in the treatment of patients with burn injury.
Patterson DR, et al. Comparison of patient satisfaction and Ann Plast Surg 2014;72(3):289–94.
self-reports of pain in adult burn-injured patients. J Burn Care [50] Rippentrop AE, Altmaier EM, Chen JJ, Found EM, Keffala VJ. The
Res 2003;24(1):1–8. relationship between religion/spirituality and physical health,
[31] Moeini M, Taleghani F, Mehrabi T, Musarezaie A. Effect of a mental health, and pain in a chronic pain population. Pain
spiritual care program on levels of anxiety in patients with 2005;116:311–21.
leukemia. Iran J Nurs Midwifery Res 2014;19(1):88–93. [51] Lucchetti G, Lucchetti AG, Badan-Neto AM, et al.
[32] Otis-Green S, Sherman R, Perez M, Baird RP. An integrated Religiousness affects mental health, pain and quality of life
psychosocialspiritual model for cancer pain management. in older people in an outpatient rehabilitation setting. J
Cancer Pract 2002;10(1):58–65. Rehabil Med 2011;43:316–22.
burns 45 (2019) 1605 –1613 1613

[52] Dezutter J, Robertson LA, Luyckx K, Hutsebaut D. Life [54] Avazeh A, Ghorbani F, Vahedin Azimi A, Rabie Siahcali S, et al.
satisfaction in chronic pain patients: the stress buffering role The effect of reciting the word “Allah” on pain and anxiety of
of the centrality of religion. J Sci Study Relig 2010;49:507–16. dressing change in burn patients. Quran Med 2011;1(2):7–43.
[53] Jahanizade M, Shahriari M, Alimohammadi N, Hazini A. Effect [55] Bishop SM, Walker MD, Spivak IM. Family presence in the
of spiritual care on pain of breast cancer patients: a clinical adult burn intensive care unit during dressing changes. Crit
trial. Medsurg Nurs J 2017;6(1):51–60. Care Nurse 2013;33(1):14–24.

You might also like