Elcano v. Hill (G.R. No.

L-24803)

May 26, 1977

FACTS:

Reginald Hill was accused of killing Agapito Elcano. Hill was subsequently acquitted on the ground that
his act was not considered criminal because of “lack of intent to kill, coupled with mistake.”

Pedro Elcano, father of the victim Agapito, filed a case for recovery of damages instead against Reginald
and his father, Marvin Hill, before the Court of First Instance of Quezon City.

The Hills filed a Motion to Dismiss, alleging, among others, that the action is barred by a prior judgment
which is now final and or in res-adjudicata. The CFI granted said motion. Hence, the instant petition.

ISSUE:

Whether the action for recovery of damages by the Elcanos is barred by the acquittal of Reginald Hill in
the criminal case filed against him. -- NO.

HELD:

The acquittal of Reginald Hill does not extinguish his liability for quasi-delict, and the acquittal is not a
bar for civil action for damages.

Under Art  2177, acquittal from an accusation of criminal negligence, shall not be a bar to a subsequent
civil action, nor for civil liability arising from criminal negligence, but for damages due to a quasi-delict or
culpa aquiliana.

Art 2177 means that a separate civil action lies against the offender in a criminal act, whether or not he
is criminally prosecuted and found guilty or acquitted, provided that the offended party is not allowed, if
he is actually charged also criminally, to recover damages on both scores, and would be entitled in such
eventuality only to the bigger award of the two, assuming the awards made in the two cases vary.

Culpa acquiliana includes voluntary and negligent acts which may or may not be punished by law.

In the case of Barredo vs. Garcia, the Supreme Court held that negligent act can result in civil liability
under the Penal Code and the Civil Code. In that case the Court said that an act of negligence may be a
proper subject matter either of a criminal action with its consequent civil liability arising from a crime or
of an entirely separate and independent civil action for fault or negligence under the Civil Code (1902).

Email ThisBlogThis!Share to TwitterShare to FacebookShare to Pinterest