Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Competency Based Hrma Review
Competency Based Hrma Review
net/publication/335001418
CITATIONS READS
2 3,705
1 author:
Ramgopal Ratnawat
18 PUBLICATIONS 49 CITATIONS
SEE PROFILE
Some of the authors of this publication are also working on these related projects:
All content following this page was uploaded by Ramgopal Ratnawat on 06 August 2019.
experience of practitioners suggest that it is the attitude and through work experience, life experience, study, or training.
behaviour of the employees that plays a crucial role in their They did not mention anything of attitude and behaviour. Page
superior performance rather than only technical skills. The and Wilson (1994), based on a comprehensive review of 337
challenge before the managers is to know the attitude and citations including almost everything what has been said about
behaviour of the people at the time of selection or even while competency earlier, defined Competencies as “the skills,
working in the organizations. Competency based management abilities, and personal characteristics required by an “effective”
as an approach has been successful in not only identifying the or “good manager”. This definition includes both; the directly
good attitude and behaviour resulting into achieving good observable and testable competencies, such as knowledge and
performance but measuring it as well, as it is said that skills, and the less assessable competencies related to personal
measuring performance results into improving performance. characteristics or personal competencies. As mentioned above,
researchers and practitioners have interchangeably used
To understand competency based human resource Competency and Competence alike. Gilbert (1996) defined
management, it is imperative to first understand what competence as the state of being competent, refers to having
competency is. the ability to consistently produce the results (the worthy
outcomes of behaviour) that are required for the most efficient
There are variety of views about what exactly is meant by and effective achievement of the larger organizational goals.
„competence‟ and „competency‟. Some of the important This definition is in line with the definition of competency given
definitions of „competency‟ are being analysed below: in most of the dictionaries. It does not specify the visible and
invisible aspects of competency as such. Dubois (1998),
Oxford English Dictionary define competency as „the ability defined Competencies as those characteristics- knowledge,
to perform some task‟ while it mentions that competency is skills, mindsets, thought patterns, and like-that, when used
synonymous to competence. The origin of the concept of either singularly or in various combinations, result in successful
competency in the literature is in seminal work of McClelland performance‖. Evarts (1998), defined competency as an
(1973) in which while studying the usefulness of IQ tests, he underlying characteristic of a manager which causally relates to
argued that these tests at best be useful for admissions to his/her superior performance in the job. Woodall and Winstanley
school where the wards would be subjected to similar kind of (1998), expanding the scope of competency, defined it as the
assessment. The IQ tests cannot be good predictor of skills, knowledge and understanding, qualities and attributes,
performance of people in their future work life. Hence the sets of values, beliefs and attitudes which lead to effective
candidates should be tested for competency rather than managerial performance in a given context, situation or role.
Intelligence to know their potential to perform good in work life.
He defined competency as a personal trait or set of habits that Despite so many definitions, the meaning and definition of
leads to more effective or superior job performance. In other the term competency is still a subject to debate (Shippman et
words, an ―ability that adds clear economic value to the efforts al., 2000). However, we take the definition of Competency as
of a person on the job. Klemp (1980), in the context of the underlying characteristics of individuals comprising of their
education, defined competency as a characteristic of an knowledge, skills, attitudes, and behaviour based on their
individual that underlies effective work performance. Boyatzis beliefs and values, resulting into superior job performance.
(1982, 2007), based on the contingency theory of performance,
defined Competency as an underlying characteristic of an Competencies are used for a wide range of functions like
individual that is casually related to superior performance in a selection, retention, and development to organizational planning
job. Hornby and Thomas (1989) defined Competency as the (Rodriguez et al., 2002
ability to perform effectively the functions associated with
management in a work situation while Jacobs (1989), in the Most of the definitions of competency referred above
context of managerial role, defined Competency as an mention the underlying characteristics of individuals being a part
observable skill or ability to complete a managerial task of competencies. Obviously, these underlying characteristics
successfully. Spencer and Spencer (1993) defined are not visible. What is visible is the knowledge and skills as
Competencies as skills & abilities-things you can do -acquired depicted in the Iceberg model of competency as shown below:
characteristics of knowledge intensive firms. Traditional job- candidate /employee depending upon the purpose for which it is
based HRM does not provide the answers to the questions like being used. Competency based human resource practices
used competency framework as a foundation for recruitment,
How to simplify and integrate HR practices? selection, training and development, rewards, and other aspects
How to prompt employees to be innovative and take risk? of employee management (Horton, 2000).
How to transform the organizational strategies into
employee performance? There are several methods like competency-based
How to transform HRM from an administrative to strategic interviews, competency mapping questionnaires, assessment
function? and development centres, critical incident technique,
How to from the functional structure especially when the psychometric tests, by which competency mapping is done. The
concept of job position is disappearing? organizations use competency mapping to draw the competitive
advantage from human resources. To have the competitive
Application of competency-based approach provides advantage at organizational level , the core competencies play
answers to these questions (McLAgan,1997) an important role. Core competency is an area of specialized
expertise that is the result of harmonizing complex streams of
While traditional HR is based on task-analysis and job technology and work activity (Prahalad, and Harnel, 1990). For
description to determine the character of the process of the organizations to have sustainable competitive advantage,
recruitment and selection, induction, training, performance the competencies must be valuable, rare, and difficult or costly
appraisal and employee development, the competency-based to imitate and there should not be direct or easy substitutes for
HR relies on identifying and developing the employee competencies (King fowler, and Zaithmal, 2001). The core
competencies to enable them to perform their jobs effectively. competencies of an organization are unique capabilities which
According to Oleksyn (2010) cited in Sienkiewicz,2014, the cannot be easily imitated by the competitors. Usually core
universal main purpose of using competency-based approach to competencies are put into two categories namely Core
HRM include Technical Competencies, and Core Marketing Competencies at
-to provide essential competencies-of individuals, of individual level. Identifying job competencies has traditionally
organizations, and the whole society to ensure high quality of used more art than science. Despite availability of all the above
living and work methods, there has not been a systematic process based on
-to achieve a high level of effectiveness and sound performance models. Competencies are most often
competitiveness identified through a combination of “techniques” and “models”
- to provide and develop individual‟s abilities to perform (Marrelli, 1998). Some organizations might use interviews
professional work and thus enable them to be self-fulfilled, focusing on superior versus other performers while others might
provide for their families and live a decent life use brainstorming to identify competencies against job
-to adjust competencies as per changing needs. responsibilities, job profiles, or other combinations (Langdon
and Marelli (2002). Neither method results in accurate or
8. Competency Frameworks / Competency Models complete competency identification. Furthermore, Gayeski et al
A competency framework is a list of competencies in context (2007) rightly argue that many job requirements change rapidly.
along with their definitions, and effective and ineffective So, using data from an expert performer today may not yield
behaviour along with the measurement criteria. A competency competencies that will be necessary to perform the same job
framework or a competency model as it is popularly known as, successfully in future. They further state that the current
helps managers identify the required competencies to methods to identify competencies tend to be slow and
effectively perform a given job. A competency model is a expensive as they consume lot of time and money especially in
descriptive tool that identifies the knowledge, skills, abilities, and the context of mergers and acquisitions situations. Hence there
behaviour needed to perform effectively in the organization is a need for a continuous evolution of methods of identifying
(Chung Herrera, Enz, and Lankau (2003). Once the required the competencies. Computer based methods can be a help in
competencies are known, it is easier to match the competencies this regard.
of the candidates with the identified competencies to make a
better selection decision. However, the challenge lies in 10. Competency Based Human Resource Management
identifying the competencies required for the given jobs. in Practice
Competency based human resource management has been
Incorporation of Competency Based Frameworks (CBF) has
in practice in different parts of the world across the industries.
many benefits for the organizations. However, implementation
Sylvia Horton (2009) found that competency based human
of CBF has limited success if the competencies are poorly
resource management practices are used in British central Govt
developed, not properly explained and understood by
jobs for recruitment and selection, training and development,
employees, and difficult to use. The effectiveness of CBF also
performance evaluation, compensation, work force and
lessens if it is taken as an HR thing (Benayouny,2017)
succession planning, and career guidance. Separate
9. Competency Mapping competency frameworks have been designed incorporating core
competencies and specialist competencies. These frameworks
Competency mapping is the process of identifying and differentiate effective behaviour and ineffective behaviour with
describing the competencies in terms of knowledge, skills, respect to the given competencies. The competency
abilities, and behaviour required to perform a job effectively and frameworks have also been used for identifying leadership
comparing these with the competencies possessed by the potential.
References
1. Benayouny, Abdelghani (2017) Competency Based 7. Chung Herrera, B.G.,Enz, C.A.and Lankau,M.J. (2003)
Frameworks: benefits and Challenges, International Grooming Future Hospitality Leaders: A Competency
Journal of Management and Applied Science, Vol3, Issue Model, Cornell hotel and restaurant Administration
9. Quarterly,44 (3),17-25
2. Boyatzis, R. E., Goleman, D., & Rhee, K. (1999). 8. Dubois D. (1998). Competency-Based HR Management.
Clustering Competence in Emotional Intelligence: Insights Black Well Publishing
From The Emotional Competencies Inventory. The 9. Ennis, M.R. (2008). Competency Models: A Review of
Handbook of Emotional Intelligence. Literature and the Role of the Employment and Training
3. Braokmann,M. Cleark,L ,Mehau,Ph and Winch,Ch (2008) Administration (ETA). Retrieved from
Competency Based Vocational Education and http://www.careeronestop.org/competencymodel/info_doc
Training(VET):The Cases of England and France: uments/OPDRLiteratureReview.pdf
Vocational Learning(3) 10. Gallon,M.R., Stillman, H.M. and Coates, D.(1995) Putting
4. Byham,W. C.(2006), “Developing Core Competency Thinking into Practice, Research
Dimension/Competency-Based Human Resource Technology Management,38,3,AB / INFORM, p 20-28
Systems: A Monograph”. 11. Gholipur, R.A., Mahmoodi,S.M., Jandaghi,D., &
5. Capaldo, G., Iandoli, L., & Ponsiglione, C. (2004). Fardmanesh, H.(2012) Presentation Model of Managerial
Entrepreneurial Competencies and Training needs of Competency Approach in Management Development,
Small Firms, 14th Annual IntEnt Conference. Federico II Interdisciplinary Journal of Contemporary Research in
(Italy),: University of Napoli. Business,3(9),506-520
6. Celia,B.R. and Karthik,M.(2012) Competency Mapping of 12. Gilbert, T. (1996). Human Competence. Silver Spring,
Employees in Power Sector with Special Reference to MD: International Society for Performance Improvement
Chennai, ZENITH International Journal of Multi-
Disciplinary Research,Vol.2,Issue 1.
13. Hogg B. (1989). Realizing the Potential of Your 25. Page C. and Wilson (1994). Management Competencies
Employees Through Assessment and Development. in New Zealand. On the inside looking in?, Wellington.
London: Tata- McGraw-Hill Training Series. Ministry of Commerce – 5.
14. Hornby D. and Thomas R. (1989). Toward a Better 26. Prahlad, C.K., and Harmel, Garry (1990), The Core
Standard of Management. Personnel Management, 21 Competence of The Corporation, Harvard Business
(1): 52-55. Review, May-June 1990, pp 79-91
15. Industry Canada, Management Competencies, and SME. 27. Sharma, N. and Khanna,K. (2015) Competency Mapping,
Performance Criteria: A Pilot Study. December 2003, Indian Journal of Research, PERIPEX, Vol3, Issue 1
retrieved from http://strategis.ic.gc.ca/epic/internet/insbrp- 28. Sherron, C. (2000). Psychometric Development of the
rppe.nsf/en/rd00850e.html Adaptive Leadership Competency Profile - PhD Thesis.
16. Jacobs R. (1989). Getting the Measure of Management University of North Texas
Competence. Personnel Management, 21 (6): 32-37. 29. Sienkiewicz et al (2014) Competency Based Human
17. King Wilcox, A., Fowler, S.W. and Zeithmal,C.P.(2001), Resource Management: Life Long Learning Perspective,
“Managing Organizational Competencies for Competitive Warsaw report, Instytut Badan Edukacyjnych.
Advantage: The Middle Management Edge”, Academy of 30. Spencer L. & Spencer S. (1993). Competence at Work:
Management Executive, Vol.19 ,No.2 Model for Superior Performance. John Wiley & Sons, New
18. Klemp, George O., Jr.(1980), “The Assessment of York.
Occupational Competence. Final Report: I. Introduction 31. Suguna,P. and Selv,T.T.I. (2013) Competency Mapping -
and Overview” report sponsored by National Inst. of A Drive for Garment for Garment Firms in Tirupur District,
Education (DHEW), Washington, DC. International Journal of Scientific and Research
19. Langdon, Dannyy G. and Marelli, Annie F. (2002 ) A Publications,Vol.3,Issue5.
New Model for Systematic Competency Identification, 32. Sutton,A. and Watson,S.(2013) Can Competencies at
Performance Improvement, Vol 41, Issue4, Selection Predict Performance and Development Needs?,
https://doi.org/10.1002/pfi.4140410405 accessed 18th Journal of Management development,Vol32, No.9
April2018. 33. Sylvia Horton, (2000) Competency management in the
20. LeBrasseur, R., H. Blanco, and J. Dodge (2002) British civil service, International Journal of Public Sector
Competencies of CEOs In Technology-Oriented SME: An Management, Vol. 13 Issue: 4, pp.354-
Exploratory Study of Skills for Survival & Initial Growth. 368, https://doi.org/10.1108/09513550010350508
Halifax: Laurentian University. 34. Thomas,W.Y.Man and Theresa, Lau J. (2000)
21. Lislie Jean B.(2009), The Leadership Gap: What You Entrepreneurial Competencies of SME Owner / Managers
Need, and Don‟t Have When It Comes to Leadership , in the Hong Kong Services Sector: A Qualitative Analysis.
Centre for Creative Leadership, Research Study Enterprising Culture, 08,235.
(http://www.ccl.org/wp- https://doi.org/10.1142/S0218495800000139, accessed
content/uploads/2015/04/leadershipGap.pdf assessed 9th April 2018.
11th April 2018) 35. Winterton, J. (2002). Entrepreneurship: Towards a
22. MacClleland, D. C. (1973), Testing for Competence rather Competence Framework for Developing SME Managers.
than Intelligence, American Psychologist , Jan 1973. United States Association for Small Business and
23. McLaGan,P.A.(1997) Competencies: The Next Entrepreneurship (USASBE) Conference.
Generation, Training and Development ,51,40-48 36. Yukl, G. (2001). Leadership in organization. Prentice hall.
24. Maria Etiennette Irigoin, Paula Tarnapol Whitacre, Dana 37. Zane Berge, Marie de Verneil, Nancy Berge, Linda
M. Faulkner and Gloria Coe (2002) Mapping Davis,and Donna Smith, (2002) The Increasing Scope of
Competencies for Communication for Development and Training and Development Competency . Benchmarking:
Social Change, based on the Conference “Competencies: An International Journal,Vol.9Issue:1,pp.43-
Communication for Development and Social Change” 61, https://doi.org/10.1108/14635770210418579
Held at the Rockefeller Foundation Bellagio Study and
Conference Center Bellagio, Italy.