Professional Documents
Culture Documents
CHapter 2 Mr. Ho
CHapter 2 Mr. Ho
Views Of Philosophers
• Views of Western Philosophers
From Islamic, Western &
• Views of Eastern Philosophers
Eastern Towards Source of
• Source of knowledge
Knowledge & Education
1
COPYRIGHT©H2O2T/PHILO-EDU/082022
LO
2
COPYRIGHT©H2O2T/PHILO-EDU/082022
Views of Islamic
Philosophers 3
COPYRIGHT©H2O2T/PHILO-EDU/082022
Islamic philosophy of education
1. Philosophy which is based on the teaching of Islam or revealed knowledge
(obtained from the holy book, al-Quran and As-Sunnah)
2. The role of Islamic Philosophy is to explain the relationship between man and 4
his Creator (Allah), between man and man, and between man and his
environment.
COPYRIGHT©H2O2T/PHILO-EDU/082022
Islamic Philosophy of Education
3. Islamic education is a process which educate and trains the human mind,
body, soul & emotion, guides educators to mould students based on the
teachings of Islam. 5
COPYRIGHT©H2O2T/PHILO-EDU/082022
Islamic Philosophy of Education
COPYRIGHT©H2O2T/PHILO-EDU/082022
Islamic Philosophy of Education
COPYRIGHT©H2O2T/PHILO-EDU/082022
Islamic Philosophy of Education
COPYRIGHT©H2O2T/PHILO-EDU/082022
Islamic Philosophy of Education
COPYRIGHT©H2O2T/PHILO-EDU/082022
Abdul Halim El-Muhammady (1993)
i. Islamic education is a process that educates and trains the mind and the
physical, spiritual and emotional domains of human beings grounded on the
Revelations, The Holy Quran and Sunnah (way or deeds of the Holy Prophet
Muhammad), the experiences of the venerable ancestors (Salaf Al-Salih) and 10
COPYRIGHT©H2O2T/PHILO-EDU/082022
Abd Halim Hj. Mat Diah (1989)
• Islamic education is a process for all the purposeful guidance of educators who
will shape Muslims based on the teaching of Islam.
11
COPYRIGHT©H2O2T/PHILO-EDU/082022
Aims of Islamic Education
i. To inculcate a noble character
ii. To educate the soul to be refined and perfect
12
iii. To teach students to do good, respectful and noble deeds
iv. To train students to be courteous and be good human beings
v. To inculcate cleanliness, purity and sincerity as well as noble practices in
students
COPYRIGHT©H2O2T/PHILO-EDU/082022
Goals of Islamic Education
1. To shape and develop human beings to become knowledgeable, faithful and
trustworthy, righteous and noble Muslims in addition to being responsible as
god loving and god fearing followers and Caliphs of Allah 13
2. To develop human beings who are obedient to Allah, live in peace and
harmony in society and so enjoy tranquility and protection in the hereafter
COPYRIGHT©H2O2T/PHILO-EDU/082022
Islamic Philosophy of Education
(Ministry of Education Malaysia, 1997)
COPYRIGHT©H2O2T/PHILO-EDU/082022
Views of Islamic Philosophers
1. Ibnu Rushd (1126 - 1198)
2. Al Ghazali (1058-1111)
15
3. Ibn Khaldun (1332-1406)
4. Al-Farabi (870 – 950)
COPYRIGHT©H2O2T/PHILO-EDU/082022
Views of Eastern
Philosophers 16
COPYRIGHT©H2O2T/PHILO-EDU/082022
Principles of Eastern philosophy of education
1. Eastern philosophy emphasizes moral values coupled with the roles
of super deity in shaping human behavior
2. “Eastern philosophies, unlike west, are more empirical philosophies, 17
COPYRIGHT©H2O2T/PHILO-EDU/082022
Principles of Eastern philosophy of education
4. Schools deserve to teach what is observable or what can be
experienced in real life. This implies that education should have
the capacity to prepare students to seek solutions to such crises 18
as they emerge in the future
5. Every human beings want to achieve wisdom and Nirvana
6. Good life if human beings are willing to change
7. Happiness is determined by attitude towards life
COPYRIGHT©H2O2T/PHILO-EDU/082022
Eastern Philosophy of Education - Confucius
COPYRIGHT©H2O2T/PHILO-EDU/082022
Confucius on Education
3. Education should seek to produce virtuous individuals
4. By raising moral standard, society will become more virtuous and the country
will be well-governed and its citizens law-abiding. 20
COPYRIGHT©H2O2T/PHILO-EDU/082022
Virtues of Confucius teaching
i. filial piety (xiao) viii. altruism
ii. respect for the elderly ix. kindness
iii. loyalty x. frugality
21
iv. respectfulness xi. tolerance
v. magnanimity xii. wisdom
vi. fidelity xiii. courage
vii. diligence
COPYRIGHT©H2O2T/PHILO-EDU/082022
Against favouritism/feudalism
COPYRIGHT©H2O2T/PHILO-EDU/082022
Eastern Philosophy of Education - Rabindranath
Tagore
i. Famous for his socio-religious and cultural innovations
ii. Education should aim for the all-round development of the individual
23
iii. Not only intellectual development
iv. But aesthetic development (music, art, literature, drama, dance)
COPYRIGHT©H2O2T/PHILO-EDU/082022
Eastern Philosophy of Education - Rabindranath
Tagore
v. Interact with the environment
✓Classes held outdoor
✓Gather knowledge from different sources of nature (surrounded with fields, 24
trees, plants)
✓Learning takes place in a natural setting/real world
✓Against bookish learning
✓Nature walks and excursions are part of the curriculum
COPYRIGHT©H2O2T/PHILO-EDU/082022
Eastern Philosophy of Education - Rabindranath
Tagore
vi. Schools should be made more lively and enjoyable.
vii. Emphasis on self-motivation rather than on discipline
viii. foster intellectual curiosity. 25
COPYRIGHT©H2O2T/PHILO-EDU/082022
Views of Western
Philosophers 26
COPYRIGHT©H2O2T/PHILO-EDU/082022
Five major
educational philosophies
Contemporary schools of
thought
• Progressivism
• Existentialism
• Reconstructionism
COPYRIGHT©H2O2T/PHILO-EDU/082022
Influence of these philosophies on
1. Educational purposes
2. Curriculum
28
3. Method
4. Effects on the role of teachers and role of the schools
COPYRIGHT©H2O2T/PHILO-EDU/082022
Important to note..
✓ No one philosophy is not better than another
✓ No philosophy is right for everybody
✓ Each philosophy has its own good and bad points 29
COPYRIGHT©H2O2T/PHILO-EDU/082022
Perennialism
✓Based on realism shools of thought
✓Individual is both rational and spiritual being
COPYRIGHT©H2O2T/PHILO-EDU/082022
Perennialism
P
Helps student
u Truth is universal and
constant
uncover and
internalize truth
r 31
s
Training of both the
e intellect and the
spirit are integral
COPYRIGHT©H2O2T/PHILO-EDU/082022
Perrenialism
i. Subject-centered
Curriculum
ii. Study of literature, maths, languages, humanities, history
and
32
iii. Liberal education
Method
iv. Knowledge can be attained by reading great books
COPYRIGHT©H2O2T/PHILO-EDU/082022
Perennialism
i. Teacher Role
• Master of the discipline of
• Authority in the field Teacher 33
y
COPYRIGHT©H2O2T/PHILO-EDU/082022
Perennialism
S Basically, it is about rational and thinking logically.
y
COPYRIGHT©H2O2T/PHILO-EDU/082022
Perennialism
S
u The main reason of getting an education are; to shape moral values, to
learn the right way to learn, to train or develop the skills of reading,
36
m writing, and arithmetic (3Rs), and lastly to stress on life and humanity.
m
Students need to learn and analyse traditional great work.
a
r
y
COPYRIGHT©H2O2T/PHILO-EDU/082022
Drawn upon the idealism and realism
schools of thought
COPYRIGHT©H2O2T/PHILO-EDU/082022
Essentialism
Purpose i. Learn the essential elements of an
education
38
▪ cultural and historical heritage
▪ appropriate knowledge, skills, attitudes
and values
COPYRIGHT©H2O2T/PHILO-EDU/082022
Essentialism
i. Mastery of basic facts and concepts of essential Curriculum
disciplines as essential foundation for the general
education necessary to living a fulfilling life and Method
39
ii. Subject centered
iii. Elementary schools
▪ Reading, writing, mathematics
iv. Secondary schools
▪ Focus on the study of maths, science, humanities,
language and literature
COPYRIGHT©H2O2T/PHILO-EDU/082022
Essentialism
Teacher
Role of • Similar to perennialist philosophy
Teacher • Master of a particular subject field
and School • A model worthy of imitation
• Authority in areas of knowledge 40
School
• Conserve and transmit cultural and
historical heritage of traditional
disciplines
• Students learn knowledge, skill,
attitudes and values necessary to make
him a contributing member of society
COPYRIGHT©H2O2T/PHILO-EDU/082022
Essentialism
Summary
41
COPYRIGHT©H2O2T/PHILO-EDU/082022
Essentialism Teacher-centred.
Summary
Teachers are always right.
42
Teacher is in authority.
COPYRIGHT©H2O2T/PHILO-EDU/082022
Essentialism
Summary To gain prosperous and perfection is based on mental and
intellectual readiness.
COPYRIGHT©H2O2T/PHILO-EDU/082022
The most prominent
Related to
American scholar
pragmatist
was John Dewey
philosophy
(1859 - 1952)
COPYRIGHT©H2O2T/PHILO-EDU/082022
Education should be life itself and not a
preparation to living
COPYRIGHT©H2O2T/PHILO-EDU/082022
Progressivism
Purpose i. Student learn the necessary skills to help them
interact with a constantly changing environment
ii. Learn problem-solving skills 47
COPYRIGHT©H2O2T/PHILO-EDU/082022
Progressivism
Curriculum i. Built around personal and social experiences of the
students
and ii. Learners are capable of thinking and exploring their own
needs and interests
method 48
COPYRIGHT©H2O2T/PHILO-EDU/082022
Progressivism
i. Viewed as a microcosm of the large society
Role of
ii. School is a living learning laboratory
the school
iii. School is a working model of democracy
50
COPYRIGHT©H2O2T/PHILO-EDU/082022
Progressivism
1. This school of thought advocates that truth is determined by
function.
2. Learning is active. S
3. This is because truth changes. u 51
COPYRIGHT©H2O2T/PHILO-EDU/082022
Existentialism
COPYRIGHT©H2O2T/PHILO-EDU/082022
Existentialism
COPYRIGHT©H2O2T/PHILO-EDU/082022
Existentialism
COPYRIGHT©H2O2T/PHILO-EDU/082022
Existentialism
COPYRIGHT©H2O2T/PHILO-EDU/082022
Summary of Existentialism
COPYRIGHT©H2O2T/PHILO-EDU/082022
Summary of Existentialism
5. Existentialism is about free choice. This is opposite of realism.
6. Teachers should respect the freedom of his students and support
their students to know, use and fulfil their freedom with all 58
goodness and positive values.
7. Education is not only to sharpen our minds, but we should also
focus on behaviour, feelings, values, and other subjective
components.
8. The teacher should also play his role to help his students to
succeed in their search for self-awareness.
COPYRIGHT©H2O2T/PHILO-EDU/082022
Reconstructionism
1. Theodore Brameld (1904-1987) was the founder of social reconstructionism, in reaction
against the realities of World War II.
2. He recognized the potential for either human annihilation through technology and human
cruelty or the capacity to create a beneficent society using technology and human compassion 59
C O P Y R I G H T© H 2 O 2 T/ P H I LO -
E D U / 0 8 20 2 2
Reconstructionism
3. Paulo Freire (1921 - 1997), a Brazilian educator/philosopher whose experiences living in
poverty led him to champion education and literacy as the vehicle for social change, saw
teaching and learning as a process of inquiry in which the child must invent and reinvent the
world. 60
C O P Y R I G H T© H 2 O 2 T/ P H I LO -
E D U / 0 8 20 2 2
Reconstructionism
COPYRIGHT©H2O2T/PHILO-EDU/082022
Reconstructionism
COPYRIGHT©H2O2T/PHILO-EDU/082022
Social reconstructionists,
believe that systems must be
changed to overcome
oppression and improve
human conditions.
Reconstructionism 63
COPYRIGHT©H2O2T/PHILO-EDU/082022
Reconstructionism
COPYRIGHT©H2O2T/PHILO-EDU/082022
Reconstructionism
to solve problems
4. Curriculum focuses on student
experience and taking social action on
real problems, such as violence, hunger,
international terrorism, inflation, and
inequality.
C O P Y R I G H T© H 2 O 2 T/ P H I LO -
E D U / 0 8 20 2 2
Reconstructionism
C O P Y R I G H T© H 2 O 2 T/ P H I LO -
E D U / 0 8 20 2 2
Reconstructionism
C O P Y R I G H T© H 2 O 2 T/ P H I LO -
E D U / 0 8 20 2 2
Reconstructionism
C O P Y R I G H T© H 2 O 2 T/ P H I LO -
E D U / 0 8 20 2 2
Summary of Reconstructionism
society.
3. Reconstructivism says that to get truth, it will depend on
scientific approach.
4. Truth will change as time change and truth change when
new solutions towards the problems are discovered.
C O P Y R I G H T© H 2 O 2 T/ P H I LO -
E D U / 0 8 20 2 2
Summary of Reconstructionism
5. The role of schools is to get the
student ready for any changes and
to reconstruct the society so that
students can adapt the changed 70
environment.
6. Stresses on active learning and
problem solving techniques.
7. The right way to know a social
problem is by discussion
techniques and using the creative
and critical thinking skills
C O P Y R I G H T© H 2 O 2 T/ P H I LO -
E D U / 0 8 20 2 2
Self-assessment
Which educational philosophy is most
compatible with your beliefs? 71
Why?
C O P Y R I G H T© H 2 O 2 T/ P H I LO -
E D U / 0 8 20 2 2
Applying Educational Philosophies
Philosophy Aim of Key Teaching Teacher Role
(Proponents/ Education Points Strategies
dates)
Existentialism
72
Progressivism
Reconstructionism
Perrenialism
Essentialism
C O P Y R I G H T© H 2 O 2 T/ P H I LO -
E D U / 0 8 20 2 2
Source of knowledge
What is knowledge?
While agreement with the definition isn’t universal, The definition
involves three conditions and philosophers say that when a person 73
COPYRIGHT©H2O2T/PHILO-EDU/082022
What is knowledge?
Confucius
COPYRIGHT©H2O2T/PHILO-EDU/082022
Source of knowledge
1. Revelation
2. Intuition
75
3. Empirical
4. Authority
5. Rational
COPYRIGHT©H2O2T/PHILO-EDU/082022
Revelation
1. When senses, reason and intuition fail to give us the solutions of all
problems we human beings are facing on this planet, we need
super knowledge to make our life successful. Here divine power 76
COPYRIGHT©H2O2T/PHILO-EDU/082022
Intuition
1. Knowledge acquired without the involvement of conscious mind is
called intuitive knowledge, thus is not involving any rational
process. Intuition is higher than reasoning and sensation. 77
COPYRIGHT©H2O2T/PHILO-EDU/082022
Intuition
3. Intuitive knowledge can be based on faith, belief, culture, etc and is
beyond intellect.
78
4. Examples of intuition:
• You have probably heard people say things like “I don’t know, it’s just
a gut feeling” or “I don’t know, it just came to me, and I know it’s
true.”
COPYRIGHT©H2O2T/PHILO-EDU/082022
Empirical
1. Knowledge via empiricism involves gaining knowledge through
objective observation and the experiences of your senses - is
obtained through objective observations or direct experience of 79
real-world perception
2. Empiricism represents a collection of facts. For these facts to be
useful, we need to organize them, think about them, draw meaning
from them, and use them to make predictions. In other words, we
need to use rationalism together with empiricism to make sure that
we are being logical about the observations that we make.
COPYRIGHT©H2O2T/PHILO-EDU/082022
Empirical
3. It is the knowledge that tells us what the world is like, what things
exist, and what their characteristics are
80
4. It is essential for the emergence of the notion of science and
scientific thought, as opposed to religious and philosophical
knowledge.
COPYRIGHT©H2O2T/PHILO-EDU/082022
Authority
1. When we accept information from respected individual, expertise,
scholars, trusted organization, etc, we are gaining knowledge via
authority.
81
figures.
4. Thus, we need to question “authoritative” sources of knowledge
and develop an attitude of skepticism so that we do not blindly
accept whatever is presented to us.
COPYRIGHT©H2O2T/PHILO-EDU/082022
Rationalism
1. Gaining knowledge via rationalism involves logical reasoning. With
this approach, ideas are precisely stated and logical rules are
applied to arrive at a logically sound conclusion 83
COPYRIGHT©H2O2T/PHILO-EDU/082022
Rationalism
3. For example:
“All humans are mortal;
84
I am a human;
Therefore, I am mortal.”
• This conclusion is logically derived from the major and minor
premises in the syllogism.
COPYRIGHT©H2O2T/PHILO-EDU/082022
Rationalism
4. Consider, however, the following syllogism:
“Attractive people are good;
85
Nellie is attractive;
Therefore, Nellie is good.”
COPYRIGHT©H2O2T/PHILO-EDU/082022
Rationalism
5. This syllogism should identify for you the problem with gaining
knowledge by logic. Although the syllogism is logically sound, the
content of both premises is not necessarily true. If the content of 86
COPYRIGHT©H2O2T/PHILO-EDU/082022
Rationalism
6. However, if the content of either of the premises is false (as is the
premise “Attractive people are good”), then the conclusion is
logically valid but empirically false and therefore of no use to a 87
scientist. Logic deals with only the form of the syllogism and not its
content. Obviously, researchers are interested in both form and
content.
COPYRIGHT©H2O2T/PHILO-EDU/082022