REPUBLIC OF THE PHILIPPINES

COURT OF APPEALS
MANILA

SPECIAL SECOND DIVISION

UNITED PHILIPPINE LINES, CA-G.R. SP No. 169211

INC., CARNIVAL CRUISE LINES
and FERNANDO T. LISING, Members:

Petitioners, LAMPAS PERALTA, F.,

Chairperson
PEREZ, P. A. and
HERNANDEZ-AZURA,M.C.V.,* JJ.
-versus-

NATIONAL LABOR RELATIONS Promulgated:

COMMISSION (SECOND
DIVISION) and MIKE ANGELO September 12, 2022
LEONARDO VALDEPENAS,

Respondents.

x----------------------------------------------------------------------------x

RESOLUTION

LAMPAS PERALTA, J.:

After a careful and judicious study of the respective arguments

of petitioners in their motion for reconsideration 1 of the Court's
Decision dated July 20, 2022,2 and private respondent in his
comment/opposition3 to the motion, the Court is not swayed to
reconsider. The matters raised by petitioners in their motion had
been considered, weighed and passed upon by the Court in said
Decision. The motion thus fails to present any new and substantial
*
Vice Associate Justice Raymond Reynold R. Lauigan, per raffle dated July 18, 2022.
1
pp. 622-645, Rollo.
2
pp. 606-621, Ibid.
3
pp. 647-655, Ibid.
CA-G.R. SP No. 169211 2
United Philippine Lines, Inc., et al. vs. NLRC, et al.
RESOLUTION
x-----------------------------------------------------------------x

matter, or any cogent and compelling reason which would justify

reconsideration of the Court's ruling.
WHEREFORE, the motion for reconsideration is denied for lack
of merit.

SO ORDERED.

FERNANDA LAMPAS PERALTA

Associate Justice

WE CONCUR:

PABLITO A. PEREZ MARY CHARLENE V. HERNANDEZ-AZURA

Associate Justice Associate Justice