Professional Documents
Culture Documents
J-Yogurt Factors
J-Yogurt Factors
Yoghurt is fermented milk product and syneresis (Whey separation) is a textural defect in it.
During manufacturing yoghurt various factors affects its body and texture like composition, heat
treatment, homogenisation lactic culture and incubation condition, acidity etc. Cow and buffalo
compositional differences affect quality of yoghurt. Increasing amount of protein increase gel
firmness and decreases syneresis. Homogenisation affect product quality, higher viscosity and
firmness observed when homogenisation performed after heat treatment.Degree of denaturation
of whey protein is major factor affecting syneresis and yoghurt texture. Incubation temperature
(42-43oC) is also important factor affecting syneresis, lower the temperature, longer the time for
curd setting and higher temperature leads to more syneresis in yoghurt. Use of contamination
free lactic culture is desired condition for yoghurt manufacture. Type of acidification kinetics,
either slow or fast affects the protein network formation and whey separation.
Key words:Yoghurt, syneresis, composition, culture, heat treatment, temperature
INTRODUCTION Composition
Yoghurt is an important fermented milk The amount of total solids in the base milk,
product, obtained by the lactic fermentation to a large extent, determines the physical
of milk. Yoghurt is gaining in popularity due properties of the final yoghurt product.
its acceptability for the consumers as well as Syneresis from yoghurt is caused by a
their nutritional properties and potentially broken coagulum due to protein content
beneficial effects in human health. Good below 3.4 %, a low fat content and a high
quality yoghurt is firm and smooth mineral content of the milk, heating of the
consistency with a sweet aroma and pleasant coagulum during incubation or thereafter
taste. Syneresis (Whey separation) is a (Kroger, 1976).
textural defect in yoghurt. Rearrangement of The compositional variation between cow
the network of casein micelles is the main and buffalo milk influences the quality of
cause of syneresis. Due to shrinkage of gel, the curd. The curd prepared from buffalo
water will expel from the network which milk is firmer than the curd obtained from
leads to syneresis. cow milk. The higher curd tension of buffalo
The composition of the base milk, the milk curd has been attributed to the higher
fermentation process and the post levels of SNF (Ganguli and Menon, 1971)
fermentation treatment, all have and calcium (Sindhu and Roy, 1973; Yadav
considerable influence on the texture and and Singh, 1973). Higher rate of syneresis of
wheying-off in yoghurt. Adequate firmness rennet curd prepared from buffalo milk was
without syneresis is essential for top quality observed (Ganguli, 1974). This may hold
yoghurt. true for lactic curd from buffalo milk.
There are several methods to fortify yoghurt
a
Dairy Chemistry and Bacteriology section, NDRI, Bangalore-560030 *Email: verma.rekha@gmail.com
b
Assistant Professor, SMC College of Dairy Science, AAU, Anand-388110
c
M. Tech. Scholar, NDRI, Karnal-132001
for improvement of body and texture membrane with other milk proteins, as in
(Kulkarni et al., 1990). These include the case of homogenisation allows fat
evaporation of base milk to the desired dry globules to be incorporated into the gel by
matter level, reverse osmosis, addition of cross linking them to the matrix (van Vliet et
skimmed milk powder or the addition of al., 1982). Large fat globules as present in
evaporated milk. unhomogenised milk may decrease firmness
Protein of fermented products by interrupting the gel
The protein content is the most important network of casein particles (Aguilera and
factor which influences the rheological and Kessler, 1988). The firmness values for
physical properties of yoghurt. Increasing whole yoghurt are lower than skimmed
the amount of protein increases gel yoghurt (Salvador and Fiszman, 2004). If
firmness and decreases syneresis. The the milk has been homogenised, most of the
formation of the coagulum and hence the surface coat of fat globules consists of
consistency/viscosity of the product is miceller casein (Tamime and Marshall,
directly proportional to the level of protein 1997). On acidification, these globules will
present. Casein is more effective in this participate in the aggregation, hence in
regard than whey proteins (Molder et al., building the network. This implies that the
1983). The formation of gel is dependent on effective concentration of casein has been
the functional properties of the casein greatly increased thereby enhancing
fraction. firmness and stability against whey
According to Snoeren et al. (1982), milk separation.
casein is able to immobilise as much as 2.82 After homogenising whole milk at different
g water per g protein and shows a conditions, Plock et al. (1992) found a linear
voluminosity of 3.57 ml/g. Corresponding increase in gel firmness with decreasing fat
hydration values for undenatured and globule diameter. The covering of the
denatured whey proteins are 0.32 g and 2.34 homogenisation-induced enlarged fat
g water per g protein, respectively. Parnell- globule surface area with fragments of milk
Clunies (1985) reported lower water holding proteins leads to the development of a
capacity and protein hydration in yoghurt secondary fat globule membrane, which is of
from unheated milk than heated milk. great importance for the characteristics of
Results on firmness and syneresis of yoghurt fermented dairy products (Schkoda, 1999).
with a modified whey protein/casein ratio The texture-enhancing capability of fat in
are somewhat contradictory. There is, yoghurt (Lucey et al., 1998; Patrignani et
however, a tendency towards less viscous, al., 2007) is related to the ability of
softer gels for products with an increased homogenized fat globules to participate in
whey protein content compared to products the gel network formation (Aguilera &
showing similar protein content on casein Kessler, 1988; Sodini et al., 2004) and
basis (Jelen et al., 1987; Morris et al., 1995). consequently strengthen the yoghurt gel
In any case, it is suggested to limit the structure (Lucey et al., 1998). The effects of
increase in the whey protein/casein ratio due incorporating the fat globules into the gel
to potential off-flavour effects (De Boer, network also depend on the globule size and,
1996). consequently, the homogenisation
Fat procedure. A higher efficiency is achieved
Partial replacement of the native fat globule by multiple stage homogenisation at low
According to Grigorov (1996), optimum Grig, 1979). The type and activity of
hydrophilic properties of the proteins and microorganisms present in the starter culture
hence coagulation of the yoghurt milk are have a great influence on the quality and
obtained when milk is heated to 85oC for 30 flavour characteristics of the curd (Law,
min. 1981). Increased rate of acid production has
In heated milks, the gel is formed as the been observed in mixed strains of
casein micelles gradually increase in size Streptococcus thermophilus and
and form chain matrix. This behaviour Lactobacillus bulgaricus as compared to
results in an even distribution of the protein their individual ability (Accolas et al.,
throughout the yoghurt and the aqueous 1977). Yoghurt culture produces more acid
phase is immobolised within the network; in buffalo milk than in cow milk (Thomas et
the resultant coagulum is firm and less al., 1966; Singh and Ranganathan, 1978).
susceptible to syneresis (Tamine and The classical yoghurt starter culture is a
Robinson, 1999). An investigation of milks mixture of Streptococcus thermophilus and
subjected to heat (95oC for 10 min) revealed Lactobacillus bulgaricus, usually in 1:1
filamentous appendages composed of β- ratio. Lactic acid bacteria that produce extra
lactoglobulin/ κ-casein. The interaction cellular polysaccharides (EPS) are also used
appears to involve sulphydryl linkage and, in the yoghurt industry to improve the
possibly, the involvement of various salts. physical stability of the product. The use of
For example, calcium phosphate and citrates slime producing yoghurt cultures reduces
(Harwalkar and Kalab, 1981). These susceptibility to syneresis (Sehellhaass and
appendages tend to become “diffuse” after Morris, 1985; Toba et al., 1990). The
fermentation, but their presence in the bacterial cells synthesize EPS, which may
coagulum of heated milks inhibited micellar occur as a capsule intimately associated with
coalescence, giving rise to curds with the cell surface, or secreted into the
reduced tendencies to syneresis (Tamine and extracellular environment in the form of
Robinson, 1999). slime. EPS producing starter cultures are
Lactic cultures and incubation conditions used in fermented milk to improve viscosity,
The use of contamination free lactic culture prevent syneresis, improve consistency and
in a desired state of activity is an essential minimise mechanical damage (Shah, 2002).
pre-requisite for the manufacture of Polysaccharide production is normally
fermented milk. The basic role of starter highest under aerobic conditions. EPS
culture is to supply a large number of produced by yoghurt bacteria give a thicker
desirable microorganisms in their optimum texture and higher viscosity, enhance
state of activity. This is attained in a starter smoothness, impart desirable body and
culture by promoting the growth of culture texture characteristics and prevent gel
microorganisms under optimum conditions fracture and wheying off (Skriver et al.,
of incubation time and temperature and 2002).
nutritional supply of the culture media Normally there are greater interactions
(Tamime and Deeth, 1980). among bacteria, EPS and protein at 43oC as
In general, Streptococci and Lactobacilli are compared to 32oC. The yoghurt is usually
the two major groups of microorganisms made at 42-43oC and greater interactions
that are used in fermented milk products for among bacteria and EPS are expected to
acid production (Davis, 1975; Tamime and occur. It seems that not the amount of
polysaccharides but rather the type, charge the casein micelles begin to swell and, as
and molecular mass of EPS are important for almost all colloidal calcium phosphate is
rheological properties (Laws and Marshall, dissociated, start to precipitate. This
2001; Pleijsier et al., 2002; Ruas-Madiedo et precipitation leads to sufficient decrease in
al., 2002). voluminosity of casein micelles (Van
The conditions of incubation influence the Hooydonk et al., 1986) and to the formation
properties of the final product. Two different of clusters and chains that link together to
fermentation procedures are usually applied: form a gel, composed of a continuous three-
the short incubation method and the long dimensional network with the milk serum
incubation method. By providing the containing whey proteins, lactose and salts
microorganisms their optimum temperature entrapped as liquid phase (Staff, 1998).
range, incubation times of less than 6 h can Since the protein is most insoluble and has
be achieved. When incubation should take lowest water binding properties at its iso-
place overnight due to technical electric point, the yoghurt gel is very
requirements, temperature has to be reduced sensitive at this pH (Binanchi Salvadori,
to around 30°C, leading to a fermentation 1997; Staff, 1998). Above pH 4.5 a weak
time of 10 –12 h to reach the desired end pH coagulum is obtained (Kroger, 1976). For a
(Staff, 1998). It is generally accepted that lower pH, the gel is generally firmer,
the lower the fermentation temperature, the presumably because the protein-protein
longer it takes to reach a certain pH and bonds are stronger (Walstra, 1997).
therefore firmness, but the final product is Enhanced acidification to pH values below
much firmer (Walstra et al., 1999). There 4.0 may lead to body and texture defects
are also reports to the contrary. Lankes et such as gel shrinkage and syneresis (Jaros
al. (1998) reported that yoghurt and Rohm, 2003).
manufactured at 42°C had higher gel The type of acidification kinetics, either
firmness than the product fermented at slow or fast, affects the protein network
30°C. Similarly, Haque et al. (2001) found a formation, including coagulum permeability
systematic increase in gel strength with and whey separation. A granular, lumpy,
increase in the temperature of fermentation grainy and sandy structure is the result of a
from 37°C to 46°C. Any agitation during very slow or irregular acidification due the
incubation leads to whey separation. presence of inhibitory substances in milk or
Acidity bacteriophages or too little inoculum or
Lactose fermentation, with lactic acid incompatibility among the strains due to the
production determines the precipitation of production of bacteriocins (Rasic and
casein particles in yoghurt. Yoghurt milk Kurman, 1978). However, too rapid
will become solid at an acidity of about 0.6 acidification, due to starter inoculum, or
% lactic acid. pH at this point is about 5.3 incubation temperatures higher than the
depending on the type of milk and protein normal ones should be avoided in either the
content (Davis, 1956). High acid yoghurt initial phase of fermentation or during
may have titratable acidity of above 1.0 %. incubation, as it can lead to dense
A „solidity‟ of gel will begin to be seen at aggregation of protein particles, with a
approximately pH 5.6. Lowering the pH decrease in bound water, causing micelles
causes demineralisation of casein micelles dehydration, grainy clot formation and whey
(Lucey and Singh, 1998). Below a pH of 5.5 separation which is not reabsorbed by the
coagulum in the subsequent phases Davis, J.G. (1956) Yogurt and Other
(Yuguchi et al., 1989). Cultured Milks. J Soc Dairy Technol,
CONCLUSION 9:69.
There is currently considerable growth in Davis, S.J.C. (1975) Lactic Acid Bacteria in
industrialized scale in the economical Beverages and Food. Ed by Corr, J.G.;
importance of yoghurts. In the last few Cutting, C.V. and Whiting, G.C.
years, this tendency has driven the Academic Press Inc. (London) Ltd.,
manufacturers to develop and produce London, N.W.I. U.K. p.245.
yoghurt with firm body and texture and De Boer, R. (1996) Yoghurt and Other
having minimum syneresis. Compositional Fermented Dairy Products. In: Advances
and processing parameters like solid content, in Membrane Technology for Better
fat content, protein content, heat treatment, Dairy Products. Bull Int Dairy Fed. No.
homogenization, incubation temperature 311, Brussels. Pp: 21-24.
(42-43oC), pH / acidity etc. affect the Ganguli, A.S. and Menon, K.K.G. (1971)
syneresis in yoghurt. While manufacturing Electrolyte Characteristics of Indian Cow
yoghurt these parameters should be taken and Buffalo Milk. Indian J Dairy Sci,
into account to decrease syneresis and it will 24:133.
have positive effect on consumer Ganguli, N.C. (1974) Physico-Chemical
acceptance, shelf life and market demand of Make Up of Buffalo Milk in
product. Standardisation of Techniques of
REFERENCES Handling, Processing and Manufacture of
Accolas, J. F.; Veaux, M. and Aucliar, J. Products. XIX. Intertnational Dairy
(1977) Yoghurt Technology and Congress, B5(C): 358.
Biochemistry. LeLait, 51:249. Grigorov, H. (1966a-c) Processing of XVI
Aguilera, J. M. and Kessler, H. G. (1988) International Dairy Congress.
Physico-Chemical and Rheological International Dairy Federation, Brussels,
Properties of Milk Fat Globules with F: 5. Pp. 643,649,655.
Modified Membranes. Haque, A.; Richardson, R.K. and Morris,
Milchwissenschaft, 43:411-415. E.R. (2001) Effect of Fermentation
Bianchi Salvadori, B. (1997) Lactic Acid Temperature on the Rheology of Set and
Bacteria and Acidification. Annu Stirred Yogurt. Food Hydrocolloids,
Microbiol Enzimol, 46:79-95. 15:593-602.
Dannenberg, F. and Kessler, H.G. (1988a) Harwalkar, V.R. and Kalab, M. (1981)
Effect of Denaturation of β- Effect of Acidulants and Temperature on
Lactoglobulin on Texture Properties of Microstructure, Firmness and
Set - Style Nonfat Yoghurt. 1. Syneresis. Susceptibility to Syneresis of Skim Milk
Milchwissenschaft, 43: 632-635. Gels. Scanning Electron Microcopy, III,
Dannenberg, F. and Kessler, H.G. (1988b) 503-515.
Effect of Denaturation of β- Jaros, D. and Rohm, H. (2003) Controlling
Lactoglobulin on Texture Properties of the Texture of Fermented Dairy
Set - Style Nonfat Yoghurt. 2. Firmness Products:The Case of Yoghurt. In: Dairy
and Flow Properties. Milchwissenschaft, Processing, Ed. by Smit, G.,Woodhead
43:700-704. Publishing Limited, Pp:155-184.
Plock, J.; Hub, M.; Kennel, R. and Kessler, Singh, J. and Ranganathan. (1978) A
H.G. (1992) Bedeutung des Comparision of the Activity of
Homogenisierens bei der Herstellung Lactobacillus bulgaricus and one of its
Fetthaltiger Sautrmilch produkte. dmz mutants in Different Types of Milk. J
Deutsche Milchwissenchaft, 49:1558- Dairy Res, 45:123.
1563. [Cited from DSA, 1993, 53:8021]. Skriver, A.; Stenby, E.; Folkenberg, D.M.;
Rasic, J.L. and Kurmann, J.A. (1978) Runge, M. and Jensen, N. B. (2002)
Yoghurt : Scientific Grounds, Tools in the Development of Future
Technology, Manufacture and Starter Cultures for Fermented Milk. In:
Preparations. Technical Dairy Publishing Fermented Milk., Bull. Int. Dairy Fed.
House, Copenhagen, Denmark. No. 0301. Pp. 55-61.
Ruas-Madiedo, P.; Hugenholtz, J. and Zoon, Snoeren, T.H.M.; Damman, A.J. and Klok,
P. (2002) An Overview of the H.J. (1982) The Viscosity of Skim Milk
Functionality of Exopolysaccharides Concentrates. Neth Milk Dairy J, 36:305-
Produced by Lactic Acid Bacteria. Int 316.
Dairy J, 12:163-171. Sodini, I.; Remeuf, F.; Haddad, S. and
Salvador, A. and Fiszman, S.M. (2004) Corrieu, G. (2004) The relative effect of
Textural and Sensory Charactericts of milk base, starter, and process on yogurt
Whole and Skimmed Flavored Set - Type texture: a review. Crit Rev Food Sci, 44,
Yogurt during Long Storage. J Dairy Sci, 113-137.
87:4033-4041. Staff, M.C. (1998) Cultured Milk and Fresh
Samuelson,E.G. and Christiansen,P.(1978) Cheese. In: The Technology of Dairy
Stability and viscosity of fermented milk Products, Ed. by Ralph Early, second
products. XX Int Dairy Congress, p 838. edition, Blackie Academic &
Schkoda, P. (1999) Serumbindung und Professional, London, Pp: 123-157.
Rheologie Fermentierter Milch Produkte Tamime, A.Y. and Deeth, H.C. (1980)
- Modellierung von Strukturparametern, Yoghurt: Technology and Biochemistry.
Doctoral Thesis, Technische Universital J Food Prot, 43:939-977.
munchen, VDI - Verlag, Dusseldorf. Tamime, A.Y. and Grig, R.I.W. (1979)
Sehellhaass, S.M. and Morris, H.A. (1985) Some Aspects of Yoghurt Technology.
Rheological and Scanning Electron Dairy India Int, 44:8.
Microscopic Examinations of Skim Milk Tamime, A.Y. and Marshall, V.M.E. (1997)
Gels Obtained by Fermenting with Ropy Microbiology and Technology of
and Non-Ropy Strains of Lactic Acid Fermented Milks. In: Microbiology and
Bacteria. Food Microst, 4:279-284. Biochemistry of Cheese and Fermented
Shah,N.P. (2002) The exopolysaccharide Milk. Ed. by Law, B.A., 2nd Edition, Pp.
production by starter cultures and their 57-152.
influence on textural characteristicts of Tamime, A.Y. and Robinson, R.K. (1999)
fermented milk. Bull. Int. Dairy Fed. No. Yoghurt Science and Technology.
0301. Pp: 101. Woodhead Publishing Limited,
Sindhu, J.S. and Roy, N.K. (1973) Cambridge, England.
Partitioning of Buffalo Milk Minerals. I. Thomas, K.C.; Nambudripad, V.K.N. and
Study Through Dialysis. Dudani, A. T. (1966) Comparative
Milchwissenschaft, 28:340. Studies on the Growth and Biochemical