Professional Documents
Culture Documents
BOLOR Et - Al FINAL THESIS 1
BOLOR Et - Al FINAL THESIS 1
and occupying the little spaces between niches and crypts. They may can
notice that some families inhabit someone else’s mausoleum just to have a
place to rest. Others are staying for sentimental reason. Others may find
comfort and happiness while living in cemetery. Lack of food and basic
needs is the main concern, plus the problem they faced when one of the
family gets sick. They still prefer the facilities in the cemeteries, even though
they are facing a lot of dilemmas. They do not need to find an expensive
place to live because they thought cemeteries are open for the people who
living in there. In return for their staying, they are maintaining the cleanliness
of some crypts and niches. They are paid willingly by the deceased families
for their upkeep and services. They earn a lot when the day of the dead has
come, the All Souls’ Day. Others found extra income by putting up a sari-sari
store, selling candles and flowers for the relatives of the dead and working as
place for the dead, but also for the living individuals. Poverty continue to
prevail in our town, and we can’t seek any ways to end it up.
Saint Benilde International School (Calamba) Inc.
By letting the poor people housed the cemetery, they are more likely
cemeteries. They show the toughness they have. It reminds everyone that
Theoretical Framework
score that socially healthier people should not see society as unpleasant and
see themselves as important members. They should care about and feel safe
This study was also anchored in the theory of social change. A widely
permanent home.
Saint Benilde International School (Calamba) Inc.
live for the life they want and prevent themselves from city’s dangerous
people’s living inside the cemetery. It reveals the diversity and complexity of
and facing a big challenge in their social life. This research will give the
readers an idea about the struggles of poor people living in the Necropolis. It
will be an advantage for the readers to know their story and how they end
for poor. Lack of basic needs, electricity and water are some common
problems they used to experience. The thought of them sleeping above the
tombs is really disturbing, but for them, it is their only choice that would be
practical for a living. Many of blessed people in this country can see the
cemetery?
a survey.
This study limits its coverage on the people living in the cemetery and
the main purpose is to identify the problems they encounter in living with the
dead.
has an impact on their personal life such as the names of the family member,
their ages and what are their incomes. Each of the respondents will be asked
the same questions. This study focuses on the people with lived experience in
the Necropolis.
Saint Benilde International School (Calamba) Inc.
The result of the study will have a great benefit for the following:
Students. The result will provide students a knowledge about people living
inside the cemetery. Students may value the things they have now. They will
learn the struggles and challenges faced by the poor people who live
alongside the dead. It will give them a realization about not all people have
the same standard in living and how lucky they are for not experiencing the
Teachers. This study would serve as a guide to the teachers on what they can
people inside the cemetery. They will also be aware about the status of the
family and the kids who are unfortunately experiencing dilemmas at their
Future Researchers. They may use this study as a guide to set out another
the life of poor people. It would help them to be a better analyst and it can
Government. This study will be a wake-up call to the officials of all the
governments in town. The people of Calamba City, Laguna will have the
Community. This study will help them informed the status of the people living
inside the cemetery. Community plays a vital role in the development of the
people and it will be a help to open up their minds and seek ways to end
Definition of Terms
otherwise interred.
Dead – A person or animal that is no longer alive. Those who have died.
Diversity – The fact of many different types of things or people being included
in something.
or tombs.
Saint Benilde International School (Calamba) Inc.
Chapter 2
This chapter present the related literature and studies after the
thorough and in-depth search done by the researchers about the Lived
Experiences in the Necropolis. This will serve as the supporting system of the
Related Literature
Local Studies
Virginia Javier, 90, said “residents now locked the gates to their tombs, which
wasn’t the case several years ago.” She also said that, “Since Duterte
she is paid to take care of. As dusk fell, many people advised an interpreter
cemeteries who have built lives and communities among the city's dead.
Saint Benilde International School (Calamba) Inc.
“In the Philippines, public cemeteries are home to not only the dead
but to the living providing thousands of families with an escape from the
kids are flying kites and playing basketball in between graves, and families
are sleeping on top of tombs and spending their days among the dead.
double as homes and the dead are cared for and honored rather than
feared.”
capital of the Philippines, the poorest citizens have taken to living where no
one else will – alongside the dead in Manila, Some of these slums have
on top of graves, or inside mausoleums. It’s free, but there are no basic
services such as sanitation, electricity and clean water, let alone adequate
shelter. Cemetery slums have existed here since the 1950s, and generations
of families now live in Manila North, the oldest and largest cemetery in the
slum-dwellers from 800 families, as well as one million dead. Some of the
dead for generations, For the Gerbuellas clan, five generations of their family
have been living at the Manila South Cemetery. Every year, they must
vacate their home so that people can pay respects for their dead. Every
year when families visits their dead in cemetery all over the Philippines, many
who are comfortably living among them for a day or two must vacate their
abode so that relatives can pay their respect for their dead. For
have been doing this once a year. The Gerbuellas, now headed
by Mang Dagul, who is the eldest of 5 siblings, along with their respective
the cemetery, ever since their parents settled in the area. All the 5 siblings –
now with their own set of children, grandchildren and great grandchildren
plus their in-laws – live comfortably among the dead. Their main source of
income is preparing the crypts for the dead, and maintaining and cleaning
of old ones for families who are willing to pay a fee for their upkeep.
Saint Benilde International School (Calamba) Inc.
space with the dead, a visit to Manila North Cemetery raises serious questions
about government boasts that the economy is ready for take-off. The
tombs.
outside the cemetery in casual labor. Small children run through the rock-
filled lanes in bare feet, their faces and thin bodies covered with dirt. “They
already know that they should not make homes out of cemeteries,” said Dr.
diseases division. “It’s dangerous to their health. The problem is they are being
asked to leave but they keep on coming back,” he said. The country’s
to a projected 142 million by 2040. The high birth rate is tied to the strong
populated city in the world. Close to a quarter of its 13 million residents are
illegal tenants. The Manila North Cemetery houses over a million of the dead
as well as thousands of the living, mostly the city’s poorest. The Manila North
build relationships and create families within its four walls. It has a thriving
economy. Illegal wires tap into the main electrical supply and power the
homes here. Each week, unauthorized connections are taken down, and in
power again. Water is bought in plastic containers filled from a deep well
The cemetery is owned by the city and was laid out in 1904 on 130
acres of land, making it the largest and one of the oldest in the Philippines.
The mausoleums range from simple painted tombs to complex and ornate
Similar to Becky Pemberton (2016) 'The Beverly Hills of the dead': The
cemetery where mourning relatives live ALONGSIDE the dead in tombs with
Philippines where people not only visit the dead buried there, but also live
alongside them.
Saint Benilde International School (Calamba) Inc.
mansion-like tombs that are equipped with everything from kitchens to air-
their deceased at all times. Many of these tombs are as large as regular
house - some even bigger - and while some family members spend a few
days visiting, there are those who have made the cemetery their permanent
address.
Foreign Literature
However, according to Sahar Zand (2017) Living with the Dead, “Most
of us don't like to think or talk about death, but there are some people who
do. In the Toraja region of Sulawesi, in Indonesia, the dead are a constant
Along with Lauren Clark (2019) Death Ritual. How one million tribe keep
their dead relatives at home, feeding and cuddling their rotten body.
The Toraja, people of Indonesia often do not bury their deceased loved ones
the Toraja people mummify the bodies of the deceased and care for their
There are around one million Torajan people, most of whom live in the
South Sulawesi region, who believe that after death the soul remains in the
Their skin and flesh are preserved from decaying and rotting - which
so the family will store lots of dried plants beside the body to mask the odor.
As well as Chantal Da Silva (2017) living with the dead: The Indonesian
village treating relatives' corpses as if they’re alive, In most cultures the dead
Indonesia's Torajan people keep the bodies of their relatives to "live" at home
with them, sometimes for years after their deaths. Providing corpses with their
own rooms, they are washed and their clothes are regularly changed. Food
and cigarettes are brought to them twice a day and they have a bowl in the
corner that acts as their "toilet". The bodies of the dead are injected with a
preservative called Formulin, which stops the bodies from decomposing. The
tradition for the million plus Toraja community dates back centuries. With
animist beliefs - the doctrine that every natural thing in the universe has a soul
- the line between this world and the next world is blurred.
Saint Benilde International School (Calamba) Inc.
between the dead and the living still continues through a ritual
called ma'nene, or the “cleaning of the corpses.” The ritual involves digging
up the coffins of dead loved ones every couple of years and grooming and
cleaning them. Then, family members typically pose with their deceased
Indonesians Hold, Feed, And Live with Dead Bodies of Their Relatives, one
several centuries.
The ethnic group, consisting of one million people, believe that the soul
of a person remains near the body even after death and that a well-
preserved body brings them good fortune. After someone passes away, the
families go through great efforts to care for them by providing them with
food, clothing, water, and even a bowl to use as a "toilet." To remove the
stench of decaying odors, the bodies are mummified and special leaves and
preserve the flesh and skin from rotting, the bodies are then wrapped in
blankets and live in the homes until their funerals – which can often take
Deceased, Indonesia's Toraja people keep their dead relatives in their homes,
treating them as if they were alive until they can be given expensive,
Western culture, the complete opposite is true for Indonesia's Toraja people.
For them, death is not something to dread and avoid, but a central part of
living that involves honoring the deceased with the utmost care to aid their
passage into the afterlife. Funerals are major celebrations that take years of
preparation. In the meantime, the dead bodies remain in their family homes.
Their loved ones change their clothes, give them food and water daily, and
swat the flies off their rotting skin. It wouldn't be an overstatement to say that
death is the central concern for the Toraja people and that funerals take
precedence over nearly every other familial event. When a family member
dies, he or she is still cared for until a funeral can be given, often for weeks or
Aurelie Marrier D’unienville (2019) the dead live with their loved ones on this
Indonesian Island. Toraja country stretches for hundreds of miles across the
connected by a network of dirt tracks that wind their way through lush rice
topic that generally inspires dread. It marks the sudden and irreversible
rupture of a person from their loved ones. Even if one believes in an afterlife,
the immediate severing of the connection between the dead and the living
is absolute.
you should know about this Indonesian tribe that lives with their dead
mourn the passing of our relatives but this particular tribe in South Sulawesi,
Indonesia does it a little bit differently. Toraja people actually mummify (not
the Egyptian way) their dead relatives until they are financially and
(1) Mummifying and preserving the dead. After a member of their tribe
takes their last breath, Torajans will carefully coat the skin and flesh of the
water, wrote The Sun. To mask the strong stench of dead bodies, they would
store dried plants near it. The dead bodies will then be kept in a room of their
Saint Benilde International School (Calamba) Inc.
(tongkonan). (2) They call the dead “toma kula” which means “the sick”.
They also believe that the souls of their dead relatives don’t actually leave
the human world. In fact, they call their dead relatives “toma kula”, which
means a sick person, until the funeral takes place. (3) The “rambu solo”
ceremony aka the funeral. Once they are ready to let go of their deceased
relatives, a grand funeral which normally costs more than USD 50,000 (approx.
RM 200,000) will be held. BBC wrote that their funerals are a celebration
protestant Christians. That said, some of them are Catholic Christians due to
the influence of Dutch colonial missionaries in the region. (4) The “ma’nene” –
the cleansing of the corpses. After the “rambu solo” ceremony, their clan will
gather again every one to three years for another ritual called the
corpses”.
They will be given a new set of clothes and relatives from everywhere in
the world will gather for a reunion. According to BBC, friends and families of
the dead will offer food and cigarettes to their dead relatives.
Saint Benilde International School (Calamba) Inc.
Synthesis
Manila, Philippines is the most densely populated city in the world. Most
Manila but to the whole country. Many people believe that graveyards are
not just for the resting souls of the dead, it is also housed by the living. A lot of
people in the world are homeless, due to lack of finances. They can’t even
afford a house to live nor an apartment to rent, so they choose to live in the
cleanliness. They even look for a job or sideline in order for them to survive life.
There are people who choose to live next to their deceased relatives,
not because they want it, but owing the fact that it is part of their beliefs. In
called Torajans. They believe that the dead are part of day-to-day life. They
do not bury their deceased loved one for years or even decades. Torajans
mummify the bodies of the deceased and taking care of it by preserving the
ones. Graveyards are the right place to rest the body of the dead. There
were just a lot of incident reports that mostly poor families living inside the
cemetery.
Just as the case in Manila, people in Calamba City, housed the place
of the dead and they also believe that cemeteries are not just for death
people. Mostly, these cases are relevant to the issue of Poverty. Due to lack
of financial support, family with jobless parents, thought of living the cemetery
is their only option, since it is free, and in that place, they make a way for
Chapter 3
RESEARCH METHODOLOGY
of the data.
Research Design
2012). This strand of research is discovery-oriented and the findings are not
data through prolonged contact with a life situation in natural settings by the
(Merriam, 2013).
The study used the purposeful random sampling for the selection of the
(2016), this was the most appropriate sampling for the study since this looked
sample is larger than one can handle. While this is a type of sampling that
uses small sample sizes, its goal is to increase credibility, not to encourage
select ten (10) respondents from different families from Barangay. Lecheria,
Data-Gathering Procedure
from the research adviser. Thereafter, upon the approval of the research
adviser, a formal letter was sent to the concerned person. Personal interviews
were conducted during the time and date agreed upon. The result of the
Instrumentation
questions which in turn were used as interview questions for the respondents.
Using the said instrument, the researchers personally approached the ten (10)
respondents from different families and explained the endeavor of his inquiry
and the purpose of the interview. The interview started and completed on
Ethical Considerations
the school. Ethical considerations were taken into account throughout the
asked the consent of the participants and explained to them the importance
of the objective of the study. The data and the information gathered were
kept in confidential. The works of other researchers and authors were properly
organized.
Saint Benilde International School (Calamba) Inc.
Chapter 4
This chapter presents the analysis and interpretation made by the researchers
Interview Question #1: What makes them think to live in a place full of dead?
Matrix 1
question number 1.
OBSERVATION
magulang ko kaya
nangungupahan lang po
Saint Benilde International School (Calamba) Inc.
kami dito.”
lang ako.”
tumira.”
experiences to prove
experiences.
done researches.
based on her
experiences.
question.
Saint Benilde International School (Calamba) Inc.
Interview Question #2: What are the things they like about living in a
cemetery?
Matrix 2
question number 2.
OBERSEVATION
ng sementeryo eh ngayon
hindi na.”
confidently.
answered the
Respondent 6
questions, calmly with
confidence.
Rizal.”
connection to his
husband.
Saint Benilde International School (Calamba) Inc.
Interview Question #3: What are the common challenges they encounter
Matrix 3
question number 3.
OBSERVATION
buhayan na iba.”
maingay.” experiences.
na.”
[hahaha]…maraming dayo
dito.”
naming [hehehe].”
lang”
Interview Question #4: How they manage to live in a place full of dead?
Matrix 4
question number 4.
OBSERVATION
na to.”
Saint Benilde International School (Calamba) Inc.
kami…makakalipat ng
naaapektuhan ng mga
ang paligid.”
walang pa-abiso.”
was saying.
rin.”
Chapter 5
This chapter presents the summary of the study pointing out the
showing perseverance in living their lives inside the Necropolis. They able to
share life experiences while living in the cemetery with their families.
similarities on how they manage their life while living there. Being used to it is
their only way to survive life. Happiness is still shown in their faces even though
they are struggling and facing a lot of challenges. The struggles of having a
baby while they are still surviving life as an adult is very disturbing. They are
unable to provide the right needs of the baby such as milk, diapers or even
themselves. The money they once earned for cleaning crypts and taking
care of niches is just enough for a day and not for a lifetime expense.
It is fortunate if they are given large amount of money as their profit for
working in the cemetery to be able to buy the other needs of the member of
each family.
Each respondent has their own way of living the life just to survive. They
already found comfort and happiness. They are no longer afraid of living
near the niches because they are used to it. Cemeteries became part of
their life, it was normal for them to see niches without fear because inside it
was a dead person. Even the kids, who are brave enough to play on top of
some niches. It does not matter to them what it is, as long as they are
enjoying. They thought graveyards are not just for dead, but also for the
living.
Saint Benilde International School (Calamba) Inc.
Recommendations
Based on the findings and data gathered, this study also provides these
recommendations:
donations for money or stuffs to help the people to survive life. Also,
students can also provide learnings for the children in the cemetery.
They can teach them basic lessons and knowledge about the things
around them. They must assure that their area is not prone on some
cemetery should also seek for a job. They should ask government
officers to help them find a stable job in order for them to provide the
the cemetery. They should make an action on helping the poor people
to survive life. Furthermore, the city government should use money for
vitamins for the new born children and toddlers to avoid diseases.
Saint Benilde International School (Calamba) Inc.
REFERENCES
[1] Adam, D. (2017) The New York Times: hard life among the dead in the
Philippines
[2] Becky, P. (2016) The Beverly Hills of Dead: The cemetery where mourning
relatives live alongside the dead in tombs with bedrooms, kitchen and air-
[3] Chantal, D.S. (2017) Living with the Dead: The Indonesian Village treating
[4] Isumi, S. & James, F. (2017) The University of Arizona Press: Living with the
[5] Joel, S. (2019) The Living Dead: How the Toraja people of Indonesia honor
their deceased
[6] Joyce, L., Zyra Marie, L., Fe Laurine, L., Abigail, M., James Louies U.,
Reynaldo, I. & Rebecca Leslie, C. (2018) Living with the Dead: A Qualitative
Cebu City.
[7] Karen, L. (2017) In the Philippines, the living share space with the dead
[8] Lauren, C. (2017) Death Ritual: How a million strong tribe keep their dead
relatives at home
Saint Benilde International School (Calamba) Inc.
[9] Lynzy, B. (2018) Graveyard Living: Inside the cemetery slums of Manila
[14] Tamara, J. (2019) This group of Indonesians hold, feed and live with dead
[15] Tommy, T. & Aurelie Marrier, D. (2019) (Photos) The dead live with their
[16] Veronica, F. (2019) 4 Things you should know about this Indonesian Tribe
APPENDICES
APPENDIX A
Dear Respondents,
Laguna.”
In line with this, the research are requesting for your permission to become
The Researchers
Alarcon, Marco
APPENDIX B
Interview Questions
3) What are the common challenges they encounter while living in the
cemetery?