Download as pdf or txt
Download as pdf or txt
You are on page 1of 6

Proceedings of The 2020 IEEE International

Conference on Real-time Computing and Robotics


September 28-29, 2020

Bionic Design of a Dexterous Anthropomorphic Hand Actuated by


Antagonistic PAMs*
Daoxiong Gong, Linyu Hao, Jianjun Yu, and Guoyu Zuo

In order to realize the same dexterous manipulation




Abstract—Dexterous anthropomorphic robotic hand has very


important applications in service robot for cooperating with abilities of human hand with a robotic hand, researchers
people in the daily living environment and using the tools studied the grasp and manipulation patterns of human hand.
specifically designed for people. In this paper, we designed a Melo et al summarized the main anthropomorphic robotic
dexterous anthropomorphic robotic hand mimicking the hands and compared them with the human hand features [4];
muscle-tendon-ligament structure of the human hand. The Jarque-Bou et al studied the hand kinematic data of human
robotic hand possesses the similar Degrees of Freedom (DOF) performing grasps and summarized the kinematic synergies of
configuration of the human hand. Each DOF is driven with a human grasping [5]; Feix et al studied the ways of human hand
pair of antagonistic pneumatic artificial muscles, and Bowden interacts with grasped objects and arranged 33 unique
wires are carefully laid for mimicking the tendons of the human prehensile grasp types in the GRASP Taxonomy [6]; Stival et
hand to facilitate the motion control of the robotic hand. Rubber
al also quantitatively studied the taxonomy of the grasp
bladders with force sensors are also employed as the skin of the
palm and the finger pad to enable the force control and
motion of the human hand based on the grasp shape, the finger
compliant manipulation of the robotic hand. As a result, the position and the muscle activity [7]. These studies provide a
robotic hand can reproduce the manipulations of the human valuable reference for the dexterous manipulation assessment
hand, and thus can be deployed on a robot to cooperate with as well as the motion control of the dexterous robotic hand.
people or on a homogeneous slave robot to improve its In order to endow a robotic hand with the similar
tele-operation performance. compliant manipulation abilities of human hand, researchers
I. INTRODUCTION adopt pneumatic artificial muscles (PAMs) as the actuator for
robot hand, because PAMs possess compelling properties in
Dexterous anthropomorphic hand has great significance in various aspects, including the inherent safety, high
both the scientific research and engineering application in the power-mass ratio, and flexibility of placement, especially the
field of cooperative/teleoperation robot. Dexterous PAMs possesses the similar actuating features the human
anthropomorphic hand possesses the similar structure muscle. Two most famous dexterous robotic hands actuated
(appearance) of human hand, as a result, it can realize the same by PAMs should be the SHADOW Hand [8] and the FESTO
dexterous manipulation abilities of human hand. Moreover, an Airic's arm [9]. The SHADOW Hand takes a truly
anthropomorphic robot hand instead of a gripper will promote anthropomorphic approach to robot manipulation with 20
the efficiency of human-robot collaboration. A person will actuated DOFs as well as touch sensors on the fingertips to
feel comfortable, effective, and friendly in the human-robot achieve the closest approximation capabilities of the human
interaction if the robot counterpart possesses the human-like hand. The FESTO Airic's arm also imitated the structure of
appearance or behavior. human arm/hand that consists of ulna and radius, hand and
When a service robot is deployed in the unstructured finger bones actuated by FESTO pneumatic muscles.
human daily living environment or a teleoperation robot is Researchers studied the structure of human hand and
sent to a dangerous place for accomplishing some complex mimicking the configuration features in the robot hand
tasks, there are a variety of objects need to be manipulated as designation to realize the human-like dexterous manipulation
well as a lot of tools specially designed for human being need abilities of human hand with a robotic hand. Nanayakkara et al
to be used, therefore, a dexterous anthropomorphic hand is reviewed the particular muscle-skeleton structure of the
appropriate for these applications. The DLR Hand, the human hand, especially the structure and function of the
DLR/HIT Hand II [1, 2], and the NASA Robonaut 2 Hand [3] human thumb, for inspiring the design to improve dexterous
are examples of dexterous robotic hand for operating with grasping and manipulating capabilities of the robotic hand
tools specially designed for people or for executing [10]; Cotugno et al emphasized the important role of the
teleoperation tasks in the space station. human thumb for the advanced human manipulation
capabilities and suggested that the morphology of the human
thumb should be taken as an inspiration for the design of
robotic hand [11]; Konnaris et al designed EthoHand, which
*Research supported by the National Natural Science Foundation of enables complex in-hand manipulation via a thumb with
China (Grant number: 61673003) and the Beijing Natural Science ball-joint [12].
Foundation (Grant number: 4192010).
Daoxiong Gong漓Linyu Hao, Jianjun Yu and Guoyu Zuo are with the Some researchers even try to reproduce the dexterity of
Faculty of Information Technology, Beijing University of Technology, and human hand in the robotic hand via highly biomimetic design
the Beijing Key Lab of Computational Intelligence and Intelligent System, for grasping and manipulating the daily tools/objects with
Beijing, 100124, China (D. Gong, Phone: +86-13522129549; E-mail: human-like dexterity. Xu and Todorov designed a biomimetic
gongdx@bjut.edu.cn. J. Yu, e-mail: yujianjun@bjut.edu.cn. G. Zuo, e-mail:
zuoguoyu@bjut.edu.cn).
robotic hand that closely mimics the human hand with

978-1-7281-7293-4/20/$31.00 © 2020 IEEE 493

Authorized licensed use limited to: NANJING UNIVERSITY OF AERONAUTICS AND ASTRONAUTICS. Downloaded on April 11,2021 at 03:02:09 UTC from IEEE Xplore. Restrictions apply.
artificial joint-ligament-tendon structure and elastic pulley A. Mechanical Structure Mimicking the Hand Bones
mechanisms [13]; Faudzi et al presented an index finger of Terlemez et al [16] studied the human motion data and
robotic hand that closely replicates the human finger with proposed a unified representation model, i.e., the MMM
bone-ligament-tendon structure, thin McKibben PAMs, (Master Motor Map) reference model, of human body. In this
extensor and pulley mechanism [14]; Tasi et al also designed paper, we propose a kinematic model of human hand based on
an Anatomically Correct, Biomechatronic Hand [15] that the MMM model for reproducing human-like hand
emphasizes the anatomical consistency with the human hand manipulation on the robotic hand. Also, we take some minor
and implements the function of finger-actuation with modifications on the MMM kinematic model, e.g., the
bone-ligament-tendon structure, intrinsic/extrinsic muscles, carpometacarpal (CMC) and the metacarpophalangeal (MCP)
as well as pulley system to realize the same synergistic joints of the thumb finger, for the convenience of manufacture
movements and the GRASP taxonomy of human hand. and actuation.
However, the mechanical structure as well as the tendon Human hand has 22 DOFs. As shown in Fig.1, there are
routing of these highly biomimetic designed robotic hands are two DOFs, i.e., flexion/extension (red arrow) and abduction/
very complex, which may pose a challenge to both the adduction (blue arrow) at the MCP joint, and one DOF at the
manufacture and the motion control of the system. A bionic 1st and 2nd joint of each finger. Linkage effect exist between
robotic hand highly similar to the human hand in construction the 1st and 2nd joint of the four fingers (except the thumb) and
will undoubtedly lead to high complexity in the mechanical it is indicated with brown dashed lines. The purple thin arrows
structure, very expensive to build as well as extremely at the base of palm indicate the capability of relative
difficulty in assembly and control. Therefore, a design scheme movement of metacarpale bones of human palm, which enable
based on the simplification of the internal anatomical structure us to scoop something in our palms.
and biomechanical relations is needed for the robotic hand to
realize the functional properties of human hand.
In this paper, we emphasize the functional similarity to
human hand at the same time simplify the structure to avoid
mechanical design complexity when we design the robotic
hand, especially we try to alleviate the coupling effect of
adjacent DOFs of fingers in favor of realizing the human-like
motion control on the robotic hand. We design a bionic robotic
hand with its 22 DOFs (18 independent and 4 dependent)
driven by antagonistic PAM pairs for mimicking the
muscle-skeleton structure of the human hand. The paper is
organized as follows: The detailed bionic design scheme
based on the human hand anatomy structure, including the
mechanical structures that mimic the hand bones, the
configurations of PAMs and Bowden cables that mimic the
hand muscles and tendons, and the rubber bladders mimic the Figure 1. The human hand’s bones and the DOF configurations
hand skins are specifically presented in section II. Simulations
are carried out to validate the design scheme in section III, in
which the human hand motion capture data from the KIT
Whole-Body Human Motion Database are adopted to
reproduce the same motion on the kinematic model of the
robotic hand. Finally, advantages and characteristics of the
design scheme of the bionic robot hand are discussed in
section IV.
II. BIONIC DESIGN MIMICKING THE HUMAN HAND STRUCTURE
In order to confer the ability of reproducing the motions
and functions of the human hand upon the dexterous
anthropomorphic robotic hand, we plan to achieve the
following design goals: Firstly, the robotic hand should
possess the similar kinematic model of human hand for
performing the same motions of the human hand. Secondly,
the mechanical structure should be as simple as possible for Figure 2. The DOF configurations of the robotic hand
easy fabrication, assembly, and maintenance. Thirdly, the
motion of every DOF should be decoupled for reducing the The DOF configuration of the robotic hand is shown in
coupling effect to facilitate its’ control. We take three Fig.2 and its mechanical structure is shown in Fig.3. Most of
measures to meet these requirements, and these measures are the DOFs are configured as the same as the counterpart of the
introduced in detail as follows. human hand. A modification of the DOF configuration is that
the abduction/adduction DOFs of the three fingers (i.e., the
index, the ring and the little finger) are placed on the root of
the metacarpals, instead of the root of corresponding fingers,

494

Authorized licensed use limited to: NANJING UNIVERSITY OF AERONAUTICS AND ASTRONAUTICS. Downloaded on April 11,2021 at 03:02:09 UTC from IEEE Xplore. Restrictions apply.
and these three joints are implemented with spherical plain front side and the back side of human hand are depicted in
bearing, which enable not only the abduction/adduction Fig.4. For simplicity, we suppose that every DOF of the
movement of these fingers, but also the transverse metacarpal human hand is actuated via a pair of antagonized
arch for holding things with the palms. There is no DOF on the muscle-tendon structure.
root of the metacarpal of the middle finger because we take it
as the reference of both the abduction/adduction and the
transverse metacarpal arch motion of fingers. The
modification will bring some advantages. If we
indiscriminately copy the human hand structure in the robotic
hand, the tensile forces of the PAMs actuating the spherical
joint may strongly couple each other, which may increase the
difficulty of the motion control of the robotic joint. We
therefore decompose the motion of the MCP joint into two
orthogonal rotation axes and deploy the abduction/adduction
DOFs at the root of metacarpal bones (except the middle
finger that is set as the reference orientation of
abduction/adduction of the fingers of the robotic hand), every
DOF is driven by a pair of antagonized PAMs, respectively.
Figure 4. The tendons of the human hand (front and back view)

We take PAMs as analog of human muscles, and Bowden


cables as analog of tendons to actuate the robotic hand, and
actuate each DOF of the robotic hand with a pair of
antagonistic PAMs and Bowden cables (Fig.5 and Fig.6). A
human hand has both intrinsic and extrinsic muscles, while
we arrange all the PAMs as extrinsic muscles and place them
far away the hand (i.e., at the torso of the robot) to avoid
hindering the manipulation of the robotic hand because of the
volume of the PAMs.

Figure 3. The mechanical structure of the bionic hand (front and back view)

TABLE I. THE MOTION RANGE OF JOINTS OF THE ROBOTIC HAND


Joint 1 Joint 2 Joint 3 Joint 4 Joint 5
Thumb 0~90° 0~90° 0~60° 0~45° 瀥瀥
Index F. 0~90° 0~90° 0~90° 0~15° 0~30°
Middel F. 0~90° 0~90° 0~90° 瀥瀥 瀥瀥
Ring F. 0~90° 0~90° 0~90° 0~15° 0~30°
Little F. 0~90° 0~90° 0~90° 0~15° 0~30°
* The motion of Joint1 and Joint2 of the 4 fingers are coupled with each other. (Shading row)

Because of the mechanical structure of the robotic hand Figure 5. The configuration of bowden wires of the bionic hand
(Fig.3), the axes of the MCP joint and the root joint of
corresponding metacarpal bone are orthogonal, and their Bowden cables are arranged to transmit the actuating force
motions are decoupled via the application of Bowden wires. and motion to the DOFs at the same time to avoid the motion
coupling of adjacent joints. The inner tendon of the Bowden
The motion range or hardware limits of the joints of the cable is constrained to move in the curved path of the outer
robotic hand are presented in table 1. The shading rows sheath, consequently, the tendon motion of every DOF will
indicate that the motion of the Joint1 and the Joint2 of the four not interfere each other, and the PAMs will not be misaligned
fingers are pairs of coupled joints. The Joint3 of the thumb because misalignment may cause bad effect on the PAMs.
represents the motion of the thumb inclines toward the palm, These advantages along with lightweight and space saving
and the Joint4 of the thumb represents the motion of the make the Bowden cable very suitable for transmitting the
thumb changing its orientation approaching or leaving the actuation of PAMs to the robotic hand.
palm plane, respectively.
We adopt the deployment of the antagonized PAMs pair
B. PAM and Bowden Cables Mimicking Muscles & Tendons as shown in Fig.6. The antagonistic PAMs pair actuate a joint
Muscles and tendons are attached on the hand bones and via tendons attached on the circumference of a pulley to
they drive the human hand to realize every kind of dexterous remain the contraction and relaxation direction of PAM
movement. The configuration of muscles and tendons on the

495

Authorized licensed use limited to: NANJING UNIVERSITY OF AERONAUTICS AND ASTRONAUTICS. Downloaded on April 11,2021 at 03:02:09 UTC from IEEE Xplore. Restrictions apply.
unchanged, which is good for the installation and application textures are designed on the bladders of the fingertip to mimic
of the PAMs. the fingerprint (Fig.7) for enhancing the roughness sensing
via the vibration signals, which is generated when the
The radius of the pulley can be calculated with the fingertip sliding on a rough surface.
following formula:
With the air bladder based pneumatic tactile sensors as the
H r- (1) pad of the fingers, the robotic hand can physically interact
where, H is the contraction or relaxation length of the PAM, with humans and the environment with the feature of
r is the radius of the pulley, and - is the turning angle of the “human-like compliant touch”. Because of the inherent
compliance of the mediator of compressible air in the bladder,
pulley, i.e., the rotary scope of the concerned joint.
the robotic hand is able to yield to unexpected impact when it
collides with obstacles (environment or human), and then
accordingly take measures to guarantee the safety of the
human, the robot as well as the environment. With the
equipment of air bladder based pneumatic tactile sensors, the
robotic hand may also explore the environment in a manner of
“action for perception” [18] to obtain the information of the
object’s surface roughness, softness/stiffness, and the
slippage of an object grasped in the hand. Furthermore, the
robotic hand can realize stable grasp and other manipulation
tasks via force sensing and control based on the tactile
sensing information.

III. SIMULATIONS
For validating the design scheme of the robotic hand, we
reproduce the typical daily motion of human hand on the
Figure 6. The arrangement of the antagonistic PAMs for a joint
robotic hand via simulations. The human hand motion capture
data are taken from the KIT Whole-Body Human Motion
C. Rubber Bladders Mimicking the Hand Skins Database [19] of the High Performance Humanoid
Technology (H²T) Lab, which shares high-quality human
Muscles and skins on the human hand bring human the motion capture data corresponding with the MMM model.
capabilities of soft touch and tactile feedback, which is very We mapping the human motion capture data to the robotic
important for dexterous robotic hand operating an object or hand to reenact the human-like grasping motion on the
interacting with human appropriately via both motion control designed robotic hand, where the linkage effect between the
and force control. 1st and 2nd joint of the four fingers are released, because the
motion capture data of the 1st and 2nd joint of the four fingers
in the KIT database are independent.
The simulation results are presented in Fig.8 and Fig.9.
Fig.8 presents the robotic hand grasping some items or
tools with regular shape, i.e., a sphere (golf ball), a cuboid (a
package of crackers), an elliptical cylinder (the handle of a
hammer) , or a circular truncated cone (a cup). Fig.9 presents
the robotic hand grasping some items or tools with irregular
shape, i.e., a cylinder with variable diameter (a spray bottle),
an item with variable shape (the head of a hammer), a slim
curve handle (the handle of a pitcher), or a thin curve slice
(the edge of a bowl). In these two figures, the red lines
indicate the pose of the hand bones, the dashed red lines
represent the initial configuration of the hand, and the solid
Figure 7. The rubber bladders and fingertip of the bionic hand red lines represent the final configuration of the hand
grasping a given item; the solid blue lines are the lines
Air bladder based pneumatic tactile sensors possess some connecting the CMC joints and the MCP joints of the robotic
special advantages for human-robot interaction. The flexible hand, respectively, therefore outline the pose of the palm of
air bladder is suit for bending, stretching, and adapting to the robotic hand; the black dotted lines depict the trajectories
different mechanical structure on the robot. Therefore, we of the fingertips of the robotic hand, therefore show the
apply air bladders at the robotic hand palm and finger grasping motion of the robotic hand. The items adopted in the
segments for mimicking the soft muscle pads and skins of motion capture experiments are common in the human daily
human hand (Fig.7). life environment, and the captured human motion are also
An air bladder based pneumatic tactile sensor can sense common routines in the human daily life. Therefore, these
the lumping force acted on the chamber by measuring the simulation results validate that the designed robotic hand can
pneumatic pressure change in the air bladder [17]. Regular reproduce those grasping motions of human hand, and the

496

Authorized licensed use limited to: NANJING UNIVERSITY OF AERONAUTICS AND ASTRONAUTICS. Downloaded on April 11,2021 at 03:02:09 UTC from IEEE Xplore. Restrictions apply.
(a) Grasp on a golf ball
(a) Side grasp on a spray bottle

(b) Side grasp on a package of crackers (b) Top grasp on the head of a hammer

(c) Grasp on the handle of a pitcher


(c) Side grasp on the handle of a hammer

(d) Side grasp on a cup (d) Side grasp on a bowl

Figure 8. The robot hand grasp some itmes/tools with regular shape Figure 9. The robot hand grasp some items/tools with irregular shape

robotic hand can be applied to cooperate and co-exist with operating a daily object or using a tool specially designed for
human in the daily life environment. human because they share the similar kinematic model.
(2) Every DOF of the robot hand is driven by a pair of
IV. CONCLUSION antagonized PAMs via Bowden wires, which are elaborately
In this paper, we studied the design of an anthropomorphic deployed to mimic the muscle-tendon-ligament structure of
dexterous robot hand with every DOFs actuated by human hand and to decouple the motion of every DOFs. It
antagonistic PAMs. By means of reenacting the human hand makes the motion of every DOF independent, which is
motion of the KIT database on the model of the designed favorable for achieving the human-like manipulations on the
robotic hand, we validated that the designed robotic hand is robotic hand via the most common and intuitive scheme of
able to perform the same manipulation of the human hand. joint-to-joint motion mapping.
The proposed design scheme of the bionic robot hand (3) The air bladder based pneumatic tactile sensors are
possesses the following remarkable characteristics and applied to the robotic hand endowing it the ability of
advantages: “human-like compliant touch” and “human-like tactile
(1) The kinematic model of the designed robotic hand is sensing”, which will be benefit for a robot equipped with the
based on the anatomy structure of the human hand with minor proposed robotic hand to co-operate with human beings for
modifications on the KIT model of human hand. This scheme fulfilling certain tasks.
guarantees that the designed dexterous anthropomorphic robot Dexterous anthropomorphic robot hand is one of the hot
hand be able to mimic or reenact the motion of human hand issues of modern robotics and has a wide range of applications.

497

Authorized licensed use limited to: NANJING UNIVERSITY OF AERONAUTICS AND ASTRONAUTICS. Downloaded on April 11,2021 at 03:02:09 UTC from IEEE Xplore. Restrictions apply.
In future study, we will carry out the following works: (1) the [19] C. Mandery, Ö. Terlemez, M. Do, N. Vahrenkamp, and T. Asfour, “The
human-like motion control of the bionic robot hand for KIT Whole-Body Human Motion Database”, Proceedings of the 2015
realizing the GRASP Taxonomy; and (2) the machine learning International Conference on Advanced Robotics (ICAR), pp. 329 - 336,
2015.
of the robotic hand to acquire knowledge for using some tools.
As a result, the designed robotic hand can be applied to a
service robot for improving its performance of cooperating
with people in the daily life environment, or applied to a
homogeneous slave robot for improving its performance of
using tools specially designed for people in the
tele-manipulation applications.

REFERENCES
[1] M. Greenstein, et al., “The hand of the DLR hand arm system:
Designed for interaction,” The International Journal of Robotics
Research, vol. 31, no.13, pp. 1531-1555, 2012.
[2] H. Liu, K. Wu, and et al, “Multisensory Five-Finger Dexterous Hand:
The DLR/HIT Hand II,” Proceedings of the 2008 IEEE/RSJ
International Conference on Intelligent Robots and Systems,
pp.3692-3697, 2008.
[3] L. B. Bridgwater, C. Ihrke, and et al, “The robonaut 2 hand-designed to
do work with tools,” Proceedings of the IEEE International Conference
on Robotics and Automation (ICRA), pp. 3425–3430, 2012.
[4] E. N. G. Melo, O. F. A. Sánchez, and D. A. Hurtado,
“Anthropomorphic robotic hands: a review,” Ingenieríay Desarrollo.
Universidad del Norte. Vol. 32, no.2, pp. 279-313, 2014.
[5] N. J. Jarque-Bou, A. Scano, and et al, “Kinematic synergies of hand
grasps: a comprehensive study on a large publicly available dataset,”
Journal of NeuroEngineering and Rehabilitation, doi: 10.1186/
s12984-019-0536-6, 2019.
[6] T. Feix, J. Romero, and et al, “The GRASP Taxonomy of Human Grasp
Types,” IEEE Transactions on Human-machine Systems, vol. 46, no. 1,
pp.66-77, 2016.
[7] F. Stival, S. Michieletto, and et al, “A quantitative taxonomy of human
hand grasps,” Journal of Neuro-Engineering and Rehabilitation, doi:
10. 1186/s12984-019-0488-x, 2019.
[8] https://www.shadowrobot.com/
[9] https://www.festo.com/
[10] V. K. Nanayakkara, G. Cotugno, and et al, “The Role of Morphology of
the Thumb in Anthropomorphic Grasping: A Review,” Frontiers in
mechanical engineering, DOI: 10.3389/fmech.2017.00005, 2017.
[11] G. Cotugno, K. Althoefer, and T. Nanayakkara, “The Role of the
Thumb: Study of Finger Motion in Grasping and Reachability Space in
Human and Robotic Hands,” IEEE Transactions on Systems, Man, and
Cybernetics: Systems, vol. 47, no. 7, pp.1061-1070, 2017.
[12] C. Konnaris, C. Gavriel, and et al, “EthoHand: A Dexterous Robotic
Hand with Ball-Joint Thumb Enables Complex In-hand Object
Manipulation,” Proceedings of the 6th IEEE RAS/EMBS International
Conference on Biomedical Robotics and Biomechatronics (BioRob),
pp.1154-1159, 2016.
[13] Z. Xu and E. Todorov, “Design of a Highly Biomimetic
Anthropomorphic Robotic Hand towards Artificial Limb
Regeneration,” Proceedings of the 2016 IEEE International
Conference on Robotics and Automation (ICRA), pp.3485-3492, 2016.
[14] A. A. M. Faudzi, J. Ooga, and et al, “Index Finger of a Human-Like
Robotic Hand Using Thin Soft Muscles,” IEEE Robotic and
Automation Letters, vol. 3, no. 1, pp.92-99, 2018.
[15] B. J. Tasi, M. Koller, and G. Cserey, “Design of the Anatomically
Correct, Biomechatronic Hand,” https://arxiv.org/ftp/arxiv/papers
/1909/1909.07966.pdf, 2019.
[16] Ö. Terlemez, S. Ulbrich, C. Mandery, M. Do, N. Vahrenkamp, and T.
Asfour, "Master Motor Map (MMM) — Framework and toolkit for
capturing, representing, and reproducing human motion on humanoid
robots," Proceedings of the 2014 IEEE-RAS International Conference
on Humanoid Robots, pp. 894-901, 2014.
[17] D. Gong, R. He, J. Yu, and G. Zuo, “A Pneumatic Tactile Sensor for
Co-Operative Robots,” Sensors, vol. 17, doi:10.3390/s17112592, 2017.
[18] R.S. Dahiya, G. Metta, M. Valle, and G. Sandini, “Tactile
sensing-From humans to humanoids,” IEEE Transactions on Robotics,
vol. 26, 1–20, doi:10.1109/TRO.2009.2033627. 2010.

498

Authorized licensed use limited to: NANJING UNIVERSITY OF AERONAUTICS AND ASTRONAUTICS. Downloaded on April 11,2021 at 03:02:09 UTC from IEEE Xplore. Restrictions apply.

You might also like