Professional Documents
Culture Documents
The Effects of Nutrition Education On Professionals' Practice and On The Nutrition of Aged Residents in Dementia Wards
The Effects of Nutrition Education On Professionals' Practice and On The Nutrition of Aged Residents in Dementia Wards
& 2007 Nature Publishing Group All rights reserved 0954-3007/07 $30.00
www.nature.com/ejcn
ORIGINAL ARTICLE
The effects of nutrition education on professionals’
practice and on the nutrition of aged residents in
dementia wards
MH Suominen1, SM Kivisto1 and KH Pitkala1,2
1
The Central Union for the Welfare of the Aged, Helsinki, Finland and 2Department of General Practice and Primary Health Care;
University of Helsinki, Helsinki University Hospital, Unit of General Practice, Helsinki, Finland
Objective: (1) To develop nutrition education for professionals in dementia wards. (2) To evaluate the effects of education and
determine the outcome of the education on the nutrition of aged residents.
Design: Educational intervention with before and after measurements. Both the learning outcomes of the professionals and the
effect on the aged residents were assessed.
Setting: Nursing home residents in dementia wards and professionals.
Subjects and methods: Twenty-eight professionals completed half-structured feedback questionnaires that were analysed
quantitatively and qualitatively. Assessments of 21 residents’ energy and nutrient intake and 19 residents’ nutritional status with
the MNA before and after the education.
Results: The learning process included six half-day training sessions. The professionals learned to use and interpret the MNA and
detailed food diaries. Keeping the food diaries and analysing them in multi-professional teams was experienced as the main
source for learning insights. After calculating the diets and discussing with others, professionals felt easier about responding to
the nutritional problems of the residents. After 1 year, the residents’ mean energy intake had increased 21% from 1230 to
1487 kcal. Before the education none but after 1 year 16% had a good nutritional status according to the MNA.
Conclusions: We used the constructive learning theory to educate professionals. Keeping and analysing food diaries and
reflecting on nutritional issues in small group discussions were effective training methods for professionals. The education had
positive effects on the nutrition of the residents in dementia wards.
European Journal of Clinical Nutrition (2007) 61, 1226–1232; doi:10.1038/sj.ejcn.1602639; published online 24 January 2007
Keywords: nursing home resident; dementia ward; malnutrition; nutrition care; MNA; food diary; education; constructive
learning theory
Introduction trition, for example, dementia, depression, stroke, falls and hip
factures (Morley and Kraenzle, 1994; Compan et al., 1999).
Malnutrition, low body mass index and unintentional weight Good nutritional status is essential for aged residents because
loss are common problems among the elderly and nursing of its importance in maintaining a functional status (Crogan
home residents (Mattila et al., 1986; Beck and Ovesen 1998; and Pasvogel, 2003) and preventing illnesses such as infections
Saletti et al., 2000; Suominen et al., 2005), who typically have and pressure ulcers (Lesourd, 1997; Frias Soriano et al., 2004).
many illnesses and clinical problems associated with malnu- Malnutrition seems to be widely underdiagnosed and under-
treated among nursing home residents (Abbasi and Rudman,
1993). Nutrition treatment seems to reduce mortality and
Correspondence: MH Suominen, The Central Union for the Welfare of the
Aged, Malmin kauppatie 26, FIN-00700 Helsinki, Finland.
have an effect on preserving the functional capacity of elderly
E-mail: merja.suominen@vanhustyonkeskusliitto.fi persons with multiple disorders (Akner and Cederholm, 2001;
Guarantor: MH Suominen. Milne et al., 2006). Some studies with enriched food have
Contributors: MHS, SMK and KHP have all participated in planning and
positive outcomes in terms of energy intake (Barton et al.,
organizing the study and writing the article.
Received 26 July 2006; revised 30 November 2006; accepted 30 November 2000; Lorefält et al., 2005) and weight gain as well as physical
2006; published online 24 January 2007 activity (Olin et al., 1996).
Effects of nutrition education in dementia wards
MH Suominen et al
1227
Low energy intake is common among aged nursing home Educational process
residents, and nurses often significantly overestimate resi- The aim of the nutrition education was to facilitate the
dents’ actual food intake (Pokrywka et al., 1997; Simmons professionals’ understanding of aged nursing home residents’
and Reuben, 2000; Westergren et al., 2002; Suominen et al., nutritional problems and to internalize the aims of good
2004). Professionals – both nurses and food service personnel nutritional care. We wanted them to be able to intervene in
– need more education about the nutritional problems of the nutritional problems of malnourished residents and to
older people in order to be better able to understand and enhance a good nutritional status for the residents.
respond to the individual nutritional needs of aged residents The educational process took place in five nursing homes
(Pokrywka et al., 1997; Barton et al., 2000; Crogan et al., and lasted for 6 months. The education included six training
2001; Suominen et al., 2004). Some nutritional education sessions (each 2–3 h) with lectures, small group discussions,
program studies have shown promising results in increasing homework tasks and personal feedback (Figure 2).
the nutritional knowledge among professionals and in In the beginning, the nutritionist (MHS) motivated the
preventing weight loss and cognitive decline in Alzheimer’s professionals with a lecture. She taught to the nurses and
disease among residents (Faxen-Irving et al., 1999; Riviere food service personnel about the facts and problems of
et al., 2001). nutrition and the nutritional assessment of aged people.
We developed an educational program for professionals She instructed the nurses to complete the Mini Nutritional
(nurses and food service personnel) in dementia wards to Assessment test (MNA) (Guigoz et al., 2002) in a group
improve their skills of assessing the nutrition of aged session and also with the help of a video tape. Between the
residents and of responding to the problems in their first and second sessions, the participants assessed their
nutrition. The aims of this study were to evaluate the residents with the MNA test. In the second session, the
effectiveness of the educational program on the learning of results of the MNA tests were analysed in small groups. With
the professionals, to clarify its impact on the nutrition of the aid of the observations of the residents and the results
aged residents. of their MNA tests, the professionals decided whose food
consumption they would measure over three consecutive
days. The nutritionist showed how to weigh the foods, keep
the food diaries and use the computer-based food record
program AIVO (www.aivo.fi). Between the second and the
third sessions, the professionals weighed all the residents’
Methods food before and the leftovers after eating with an electronic
scale. The food diaries were analysed by the food record
Setting and participants program AIVO, after which the results of the energy and
The education was directed to 28 professionals in five nutrient intake were available for individuals and the entire
nursing homes in various areas of Finland. Of the profes- group. The energy contents of the recipes were calculated as
sionals, 23 were nurses and five were food service personnel. they were prepared for meals by the food service.
In wards specialized in dementia care in one of these nursing In the third and fourth sessions, the participants and the
homes, 21 residents’ energy and nutrient intake was nutritionist discussed the results of the MNA tests and food
calculated from food diaries, 20 residents’ nutritional status diaries in small groups. The most important topics in the
was assessed, and 20 residents’ BMIs were calculated before discussions were the residents’ BMIs, possible weight loss,
the education in January and February 2003 and after the illnesses, problems in eating, special diets, energy and protein
education in January and February 2004. The data of the intake on the basis of the food diaries, the selection of foods and
MNA and BMI for 19 residents were available both before their nutritional value. The professionals and the nutritionist
and after the education. All the studied residents were discussed their observations, the residents’ favourite foods, and
females and their mean age was 85 years. The assessments the mealtime schedule. After the discussion, the professionals
levels have been described in Figure 1. planned adjusted individual changes to the residents’ diets.
Satisfaction
with training Changes in knowledge
Measuring the BMI, MNA, energy
and protein intake of the residents
The feedback from the professionals after the educational intervention
Lectures
Homework: Measuring the
Homework: Applying food consumption of the
the planned diets to the residents
residents
Session 3-4. Analysing energy and
nutrient intake and comparing them
to recommendations. Planning
changes in the residents’diets
Figure 2 Educational process: incorporating nutrition as a part of the good care of nursing home residents.
Between the third and fifth sessions, the professionals made validated scale to estimate the nutritional status of aged
practical changes to the residents’ diets. The main idea was to individuals, and it has been used in numerous studies among
make the changes to their diets with the help of natural aged residents living in various settings (Guigoz et al., 2002).
foodstuffs instead of nutritional supplements. For instance, According to the MNA, poor nutritional status has been
the milk was changed to contain more fat. More fat was also associated with impaired functioning, increased in-hospital
added to porridge and sandwiches. Snacks and evening meals mortality, a higher rate of discharge to nursing homes, a
were added to the residents’ diets. The intake of protein was longer length of stay in hospitals, and also with residents
discussed, and the suggestions of ways to add protein content eating only a little from an offered food portion (Van Nes
into the resident’s diets were implemented. In the fifth session, et al., 2001; Suominen et al., 2005). The residents’ height and
the problems related to applying the new diets were discussed weight were measured at the baseline and at one year, and
with the nutritionist. The multi-professional team, including body mass index (BMI) was calculated, as described on the
the nurses and food service personnel, participated in this website http://www.mna-elderly.com/clinical-practice.htm.
discussion. After the fifth session, the professionals continued The professionals in one nursing home determined the
to apply the new diets, following up on the residents with the food consumption of the residents (N ¼ 21) in dementia
MNA and measuring food consumption if needed. After 6 wards with a precise weighing method before and after the
months, the outcomes of the educational intervention were education in January and February 2003 and in January and
discussed in the sixth session. February 2004. The time between the measurements was 1
Small group discussion, teamwork and discussions with year. The professionals weighed all the food before eating
the nutritionist were used in learning to respond individu- and the leftovers after eating over 3 days. Any additional
ally to the problems in the residents’ nutrition. The snacks during the study period were investigated by making
professionals were also able to study literature on nutrition an inventory of all the food the elderly residents had in their
available to them so that they could apply the information rooms before and after the study days. In addition, the
individually to the nursing home residents. nurses asked whether relatives had given the residents
something to eat when meeting them. The food diaries were
analysed by the AIVO program (www.aivo.fi).
Measurements and data analysis After the educational process, the professionals completed
The nurses assessed the residents’ nutritional status with the half-structured questionnaires regarding their experience of
MNA test (Guigoz et al., 2002). The MNA is a simple and well- the education. The questions consisted of views on their own
Table 1 Nursing home residents’ energy intake before and after professionals’ the education. Compared to the reference values 1570 kcal/day for
women over 75 years (National nutritional council, 1999)
Energy intake (kcal) Before the education After the education P-value
n % n %
o1200 9 43 2 10 0.005
1200–1570 12 57 13 57
41570 0 0 6 29
Table 2 The nursing home residents’ nutritional status indicated by the MNA test before and after professionals’ education
Malnutrition indicator score on the MNA test Before education After education P-value
n % n %
Studying alone
Lecture
0 1 2 3 4 5
Figure 3 The professionals’ evaluation of how useful various methods were for their own learning: ‘1 ¼ not at all’, ‘2 ¼ very little’,
‘3 ¼ something’, ‘4 ¼ quite much’, ‘5 ¼ very much’.
assessment methods, the professionals found them very also have real positive effects on the nutrition of older
helpful in their work. The professionals were very motivated residents.
to respond to residents’ nutritional problems after calculat- Our study shows that it is possible to increase the energy
ing their diets and nutritional status. After learning about and protein intake of frail elderly residents. In addition, their
these issues, they felt that it was easier to respond to the calcium intake increased significantly. However, it was
nutritional problems and accordingly to make the proper contrary to our hypothesis that even the nutritional status
changes to the residents’ diets. After the education, they of some elderly residents could be improved. The demented,
found that they had the facts and proper advice to institutionalized residents represent the frailest part of the
implement individual nutritional care. The professionals aged population. Among them, the mean body weight
also responded that during the education they had learnt to usually decreases at a mean rate of 2 kg/year (Muurinen
evaluate how the residents’ meals correspond to the nutri- et al., 2003; Soini et al., 2004), and the mean BMI decreases at
tional recommendations given to this age group. The work the speed of 0.52 kg/m2/year among Alzheimer’s patients
in multi-professional teams was found to be very useful. A (Cronin-Stubbs et al., 1997). Therefore, it was expected that
lack of time and problems in the flow of information were our study residents’ BMIs would decrease even more than
the most difficult points of the project. actually happened in our study. What is more, among old
and frail nursing home residents, the MNA test scores were
expected to decrease at the 1 year follow-up. Therefore, it is
Discussion surprising that some old residents’ nutritional status im-
proved before the 1 year follow-up. However, a proportion of
The nutrition education for the professionals in nursing residents lost weight despite our intervention. The same
homes had a positive impact on the mean energy and phenomenon has been observed in a previous study (Lauque
protein intake, and on the results of the MNA tests of many et al., 2004). Our dementia ward residents suffered from
frail residents living in dementia wards. After the education moderate to severe dementia and were at the end stage of
and the assessment of the residents’ food and nutrient the disease. Therefore, it can be speculated whether at some
intake, the professionals were very surprised at their over- point of the terminal stage the demented individuals no
estimation of the residents’ food intake. The professionals longer respond to nutritional intervention.
felt that it was easier to respond to the residents’ nutritional Several studies show that nutritional treatment, particu-
needs after calculating the energy content of the residents’ larly balanced nutritional supplements, is beneficial to frail
diets and discussing nutritional matters in their multi- elderly people (Akner and Cederholm, 2001; Milne et al.,
professional teams. To our knowledge, this outcome among 2006). The effects of enriched food is more controversial.
frail and old residents living in dementia wards has rarely Our study is in line with previous ones showing that energy
been examined in previous studies. Educational studies in intake may be increased with enriched food (Olin et al.,
particular are scarce. It is easier to show the effect of 1996; Barton et al., 2000; Lorefält et al., 2005). Very few
education on the learning outcomes of professionals than studies aim at training and changing the professionals’
its impact on changing the practice of nutritional care or, practice in these issues, although standardized training
especially, on the nutritional status and weight of elderly programs have been suggested (Pokrywka et al., 1997). The
residents. Our small study shows that adult education may few educational studies aiming at improving frail elderly