Professional Documents
Culture Documents
BEP076SN Appraisals2
BEP076SN Appraisals2
com
The Business English podcast for professionals on the move
The American poet Carl Sandberg once said, “Nothing happens unless first we
dream.” To this we can add the words of time management expert Diana Scharf
Hunt: “Goals are dreams with deadlines.”
To reach our dreams, it’s necessary to set goals. Without goals, there is no change,
no development, no success. This is just as true for an individual as it is for an
organization. That’s why, along with feedback, goal setting is a very important part
of the appraisal process. So in this follow-up episode on job appraisals, we’ll be
focusing on strategies and expressions for setting goals during the appraisal
interview. Much of the language we’ll be learning in this episode is also useful in
any meeting where we need to discuss and set targets.
Try to answer the following questions. The answers will be posted in a few days at
www.businessenglishpod.com:
Listening Questions
1) What are the two important productivity measurements that Derrick discusses
with Wendy?
2) How does Derrick feel about Wendy making one-off (special) solutions for each
customer?
3) What does Derrick advise Wendy to tell a customer who has not booked enough
bandwidth?
Vocabulary
To rush into it: To hurry too much. “It’s better to plan carefully instead of rushing
into this kind of thing.”
That’s that: This is an expression used to indicate that a topic or task is finished or
completed. “Great! That’s that. Now, let’s move on to the next topic.”
To go the extra mile for someone: Idiom. To put in extra special effort for someone.
“Maxine always goes the extra mile for the customers.”
To rig something up: To set something up, often improvised. “Since we couldn’t get
the documents to print on the network, we rigged up a printer directly to my
computer.”
One-off solutions: A special solution that cannot be applied to anyone else. “We
specialize in tailor-made, one-off solutions that cater directly to your needs.”
Stats: Short for “statistics.” “Michael Jordan had some of the best stats in the
history of basketball.”
Star performer: Top performer. “Ever since she started working here, she has been
doing very well; she really is one of our star performers.”
Dialog
Derrick: Great. We’ve agreed on your training plan. Let’s just talk about your
productivity goals, and then we can wrap it up.
Wendy: All right.
Derrick: Starting with meetings per day. I think we can bump it up to 12.
Wendy: I know I can do 14.
Derrick: Yeah, but there’s no need to rush into it.
Wendy: All right, so 12 meetings a day.
Derrick: Great. That’s that. Okay. Now, average time per meeting. Currently,
you’re at 33 minutes per meeting. That must feel like a lot of work.
Wendy: Sure. I really like to go the extra mile for my customers.
Derrick: But that’s not always a good thing.
Wendy: Really?
Derrick: Well, I’d much rather see you be steady and consistent. Like the other
day, your team leader said you rigged up a special system.
Wendy: Yes. The customer hadn’t booked enough bandwidth, so I jury-rigged it.
Derrick: Hmm. I can tell you’re already really good with the equipment, which is great.
Wendy: Yeah.
Derrick: But we just can’t be doing one-off solutions like that all the time. The
customer learns to expect it, and efficiency goes down.
Wendy: Yes, I guess so.
Derrick: We end up spending too much time on the calls, and it’s hard on you too.
Wendy: So I should just say sorry?
Derrick: Yeah. Be polite, but be firm. The give them the option to rebook and hold the
meeting later, or hold it now with reduced bandwidth. Then move on to the next call.
Wendy: Okay.
Derrick: So overall, I’d like to see a reduction from your current average of 33
minutes per call to just 15 minutes per call.
Wendy: 15 minutes! Wow that’s fast.
Derrick: Yes, but I know you can do it.
Wendy: Okay, I’ll do my best.
Derrick: Great… with stats like this you’re going to be a star performer. Your team
leader thinks highly of you. And I’m confident you’re going to be a key member of
the team.
Wendy: Thank you.
Derrick: Good. Now, let’s schedule the next review…
Debrief
First, did you notice how Derrick is careful to maintain a clear structure in the
conversation?
Derrick: Great. We’ve agreed on your training plan. Let’s just talk about your
productivity goals, and then we can wrap it up.
Wendy: All right.
Here Derrick is using the type of signposting language that we studied for
presentations in BEP 102. He is always careful to make it clear to Wendy (and to
himself) what they have already talked about and what they are going to talk about
next. Maintaining a clear structure is important to a successful appraisal.
Derrick: Starting with meetings per day. I think we can bump it up to 12. Setting
targets.
Wendy: I know I can do 14.
Derrick: Yeah, but there’s no need to rush into it.
Wendy: All right. So 12 meetings a day.
Here Derrick and Wendy are negotiating the goal. Derrick uses idiomatic language
to negotiate the goal both upwards…
And downwards…
Let’s study more examples of language you can use to negotiate the goal upwards
and downwards. Starting with upwards…
The last expression, “to raise the bar,” comes from the track and field sporting
activity, the high jump. This is the event in which you try to jump over a raised bar.
In the business context, to raise the bar means to set a higher goal.
All of the expressions we just studied are great informal, idiomatic expressions for
negotiating the goal upwards and downwards. Informal, idiomatic language sounds
friendly, and helps keep the atmosphere non-confrontational, that is, helps keeps
the meeting from becoming a battle or a fight.
Now, what is the second productivity goal that Derrick wants to talk about?
Derrick: Okay. Now, average time per meeting. Currently, you’re at 33 minutes
per meeting. That must feel like a lot of work.
Wendy: Sure. I really like to go the extra mile for my customers.
Derrick: But that’s not always a good thing.
Wendy: Really?
Derrick: Well, I’d much rather see you be steady and consistent.
Wendy is obviously enthusiastic about her work. But from the business point of
view, this enthusiasm causes her efficiency to go down, which means the company
loses money. So Derrick wants Wendy to spend less time on each meeting in order
to increase her all-around productivity. Derrick’s challenge is to communicate this
idea to Wendy without demotivating her, that is, without damaging her motivation
or morale.
Derrick: … Currently, you’re at 33 minutes per meeting. That must feel like a lot of
work.
Actually, as is often the case, what is good for the employee is also good for the
company. Derrick focuses on the benefit to Wendy of changing her behavior –
which is she can make her work easier.
Next, he states his idea more directly by using a form of diplomatic criticism. When
Wendy says she likes to go the extra mile, that is, put in extra effort for her
customers, Derrick says…
In this sentence “but” and “not always” act as softeners, just like those we’ve
studied in other episodes on diplomatic language, such as BEP 24 or BEP 70.
• Actually, though, there may be one or two problems with that approach.
• To be honest, there’s another side to this as well.
Another great way to handle diplomatic criticism is to use the “although” structure,
which we have studied as a method for diplomatic disagreement in BEP 29: We can
put our criticism in the “although” part of a sentence, then put a positive comment,
to act as a softener, in the main part of the sentence.
• Although you need to pay more attention to details, I can tell you are really
enthusiastic about your work. That’s good.
Back in the dialog, Derrick is very careful to give a specific example of what he
means. As we discussed last time, base your feedback on real examples.
Derrick: … Like the other day, your team leader said you rigged up a special
system.
Wendy: Yes. The customer hadn’t booked enough bandwidth, so I jury-rigged it.
Derrick: Mm hmm. I can tell you’re already really good with the equipment, which
is great.
Wendy: Yeah.
The expression “rigged up” and “jury-rigged” refer to improvising something, that
is, making something up – creating an original or innovative solution. Derrick
emphasizes the positive aspect of this, which is that Wendy obviously is “already
really good with the equipment,” that is, her technical skill level is high. But how
does the dialog continue?
Derrick: But we just can’t be doing one-off solutions like that all the time. The
customer learns to expect it, and efficiency goes down.
Wendy: Yes, I guess so.
Derrick: We end up spending too much time on the calls, and it’s hard on you too.
Again, Derrick is placing the emphasis on the benefit to Wendy of changing her
behavior. In addition to letting her know the business case for spending less time on
meetings, he has underlined that doing so will also be easier for her. What’s next?
“To be firm” means “to be strong” – not to easily change your mind. Derrick is
taking this opportunity to train Wendy, reminding her of the principal of always
giving the customer more than one option.
Derrick: So overall, I’d like to see a reduction from your current average of 33
minutes per call to just 15 minutes per call.
Wendy: 15 minutes! Wow that’s fast.
In this segment, Derrick clearly states his goal for Wendy. Sometimes, as a boss,
you don’t need to be negotiating the target – you just need to state it. What are
some other ways to state your expectations?
After stating a clear goal for Wendy, Derrick follows up showing confidence in her
ability to achieve it.
How does the dialog end? To finish up the performance appraisal, Derrick ends with
more confidence-building language to boost, or raise, Wendy’s morale.
Derrick: Great… with stats like this, you’re going to be a star performer. Your team
leader thinks highly of you. And I’m confident you’re going to be a key member of
the team.
“Stats” is short for “statistics,” by which Derrick is referring to Wendy’s KPIs or key
performance indicators. He is sure that when she reaches her goals for the next
appraisal, she is going to be counted among the team’s “star” or best performers.
As we’ve seen throughout this episode, it’s not enough simply to set goals. We also
have to manage the employee’s expectations and emotions. Derrick is showing us
that in addition to giving feedback and setting goals, a third very important goal of
the performance appraisal is to create and nourish in your employees a positive
attitude toward their work.
© 2007 All rights reserved: businessenglishpod.com 7
BEP 76 ADV – Performance Apprais als 2: Setting G oals
When we’ve finished the appraisal, it’s important to schedule the next meeting.
Now it’s your turn to talk. We’re going to practice stating expectations to an
employee. Imagine you are a manager at ConStar. You’re holding a series of
performance appraisal interviews. You’ll be hearing several cues. Each cue tells you
the name of an employee and your goal for him or her. Based on each cue, create a
couple sentences in which you set the employee’s target. For example, if you hear,
“Sandra – increase meetings per day 30%,” first you might use an expression to
negotiate the goal up, like, “Sandra, I’d like to raise the bar.” Then, you need to
state your expectations, for example by saying, “I expect you to increase meetings
per day by 30% in the next six months.” In other cues, you may also need to use
expressions for negotiating the goal down, for example, “ease into it,” and “take it
one step at a time.” Are you ready? Let’s give it a try.
Cue 3: Cindy – reduce the number of failed meetings to one per month.
Learner:
How did you do? Let’s listen to some examples. Remember, though, that many
different answers are possible for each question.
Cue 3: Cindy – reduce the number of failed meetings to one per month.
Answer: Cindy, I’d like to raise the bar. Let’s reduce your total number of failed
meetings to just one per month.
It’s good to go back and do the practice again. This time substitute different
language to build fluency.
Be sure check out the study notes for this and other episodes, which you can
access at www.businessenglishpod.com. There you’ll find a complete transcript,
vocabulary explanations, and language practice. In addition, take advantage of our
online learning center, which has many more great language exercises. That’s
www.businessenglishpod.com.
Study Notes
5) It’s very important that you work hard to ____________ this goal.
7) Can you make ___________ you remember to punch out your timecard
every day.
Study Strategy
Imagine you are giving a performance appraisal to your boss. What kind of
feedback will you give to him or her? What kind of goals will you set? Prepare a
dialog using the language, structures and strategies we have studied in this two-
part series. When you’re finished, you may wish to record your dialog together with
a friend. Then you can listen to see how you sound. Be careful though – don’t let
your boss find out!
© 2007 All rights reserved: businessenglishpod.com 10
BEP 76 ADV – Performance Apprais als 2: Setting G oals
Answers
Listening Questions
1) The first is the number of meetings that Wendy handles per day, that is, the
number of customers she helps. The second is the average amount of time
she spends on each meeting.
2) Derrick discourages Wendy from making one-off solutions because doing so
causes efficiency to go down. He would much rather she be “steady and
consistent” than spend a lot of time on any particular meeting.
3) Derrick tells her to be “polite but firm.” He encourages her to give the
customer an option – either rebook or hold the meeting now with less
bandwidth.