Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Winter Is Coming: Major Downward Revision of 2023 Growth
Winter Is Coming: Major Downward Revision of 2023 Growth
Winter Is Coming: Major Downward Revision of 2023 Growth
Winter is coming
Recent economic developments bring growing concerns that part of the region will face technical
recession in the second half of the year and forcing a major downward revision of 2023 GDP
growth as well. Skyrocketing inflation keeps the central banks busy.
Katarzyna Rzentarzewska
(Chief CEE Macro Analyst)
Katarina Gumanova
(CEE Macro Analyst)
Source: Erste Group Research
The first half of the year delivered many positive surprises in terms of
economic performance. In Slovenia, GDP growth was above 9% and 8% in
the first and second quarters, respectively. Resilient domestic demand and
strong tourism are paving the way for another strong year in Croatia, with
the economy expanding by 7.4% y/y in the first half of the year. The
Hungarian economy grew at a very similar pace to that of Croatia. Romania
delivered whopping 5.8% y/y growth in the first two quarters. Furthermore, in
Czechia, Slovakia and Serbia, growth remained surprisingly strong. Only
Poland mostly stagnated in the first half of the year, as the dynamic growth
from the beginning of the year (2.5% q/q in 1Q22), driven by inventory
buildup, was practically wiped out in the second quarter (-2.1% q/q).
Downward revision of growth in EZ and Germany PMI vs. GDP growth in Czechia and Poland
(percent) (points, percent)
Source: Erste Group Research Source: S&P Global, Erste Group Research
The outlook is not that rosy, however. First and foremost, the external
environment has been weakening, with next year’s growth expectations
falling visibly. The ECB slashed the 2023 growth forecast for the Eurozone
to 0.9%. Apart from the ECB, we saw three German institutes revising their
forecasts for the German economy downwards. In particular, the IfW
institute in Kiel and Halle's IWH predict contraction in 2023 at magnitudes of
-0.7% and -1.4%, respectively, a U-turn from June forecasts that predicted
growth of 3.3% and 2.0%, respectively. Worsening outlook of the external
environment means deteriorating growth prospects for the region with
technical recession at the turn of 2022/2023 increasingly likely
Source: *without Romania and Serbia, EC, Erste Group Research Source: AGSI, Erste Group Research
Winter is coming
Distress over the gas supply during the coming winter only adds to the
already high level of uncertainty and concern. Although the level of gas
storage seems reassuring at this point (storage facilities at least 80% full,
with volume covering between 15% and 40% of annual consumption), the
price for energy security is high; there are non-negligible risks of a
stagflation scenario in Europe. Gas prices have skyrocketed as a
consequence of the combination of a few factors - gas shortages, increased
demand driven by storage buildup, as well as low liquidity on the gas and
power market. Furthermore, the search for substitutes made the prices of
other energy sources (such as coal) go up. Households and businesses will
feel the full impact of increasing costs of energy only in the quarters to
come.
The growth of private consumption and investment has slowed across the
region. The exceptions are Croatia and Romania, where private
consumption growth accelerated slightly in the second quarter. In the case
of investments, the growth was stronger compared to the beginning of the
year in Poland, Romania and Serbia.
Source: Eurostat, Erste Group Research Source: Eurostat, Erste Group Research
So far, the labor market has not shown any major deterioration, as CEE
economies began to slow in the second quarter. Actually, the number of
employed people went up in each of the countries in the region except for
Czechia (50tsd fewer employed in 2Q) and Slovakia (1tsd fewer employed
in 2Q), according to the latest Eurostat data. The unemployment rates show
the first signs of worsening in some of the CEE countries, however. In
Hungary and Croatia, the unemployment rate increased in July, while in
Poland and Slovakia, the unemployment rate remained flat. Furthermore,
the number of job vacancies went down in the second quarter in Czechia,
Croatia and Romania.
All in all, the labor market has never been so tight in the region, as:
• the unemployment rate is at very low levels
• labor market slack has been dropping
• the vacancy rate has been growing
Unemployment rate has been dropping Surging electricity and gas prices
(percent) (percent)
Source: Eurostat, Erste Group Research Source: Eurostat, Erste Group Research
The peak of inflation is still ahead in many CEE countries, however, as costs
of housing are expected to rise substantially, with higher electricity prices
fully reaching households and businesses only over the coming months.
Source: Eurostat, Erste Group Research Source: Bloomberg, Erste Group Research
has also been reduced. We thus expect the producer price pressure to go
down in coming months following the turn of the intermediate goods PPI
Index. Furthermore, food and oil prices have also eased to the level that, if
kept constant, would warrant a negative contribution to the inflation numbers
next year.
Source: Euostat, Erste Group Research Source: Bloomberg, Erste Group Research
Whereas the Czech central bank seems to have reached the peak of its
tightening cycle at 7%, and the upcoming economic slowdown and easing
inflationary pressures may open the room for a cut in February 2023 (with a
risk of an earlier, November cut), other central banks are likely to continue
hiking rates in the near term. In Hungary, the key rate and one-week deposit
rate were merged in June and have moved in tandem ever since,
eliminating the duality of the interest rate system. Currently, the key rate
stands at a whopping 11.75%, and we expect it to rise to 13.75% by the end
of 1Q23. Apart from interest rate increases, the MNB decided to introduce
additional measures to reduce interbank liquidity and increase the
effectiveness of its transmission mechanism.
The outlook for rates is different in Poland. Despite surging inflation, the
tightening cycle is coming to an end, and we expect the key rate to sit at 7%
by year-end – up 25bp from its current stance. The NBP will likely turn a
blind eye to inflation increases at the beginning of next year, excusing itself
with the external character of inflation. Governor Glapinski has even
indicated monetary easing at the end of 2023, though we doubt that, due to
the likely persistence of inflation.
In Romania, the NBR turned dovish in August, in line with our expectations,
as it hiked by ‘only’ 75bp vs. the 100bp expected by the market consensus.
It is likely that tightening will continue at a more reduced speed. We expect
two more rate hikes, altogether by 75bp, by year-end, which would bring the
key rate up to 6.25%. The credit facility rate, as the relevant operational
instrument under firm liquidity management, would thus peak at 7.25%. In
Serbia, the NBS stepped up the pace and delivered a 50bp increase in
September. We expect another 100bp in hikes by year-end, with more to
come in 1Q23.
Volatility has been the name of the game for free-floating CEE currencies in
3Q22 as well. Although the movements were not as pronounced as earlier
in the year when the war in Ukraine broke out, the forint and zloty have
weakened by around 14% and 4% compared to the end of June,
respectively. On the other hand, the koruna and leu have seen mild
appreciation – though both have benefitted from central bank interventions,
especially the former. In fact, thanks to CNB interventions, the Czech
koruna remains anchored close to 24.50 vs. the EUR and is unlikely to
diverge from that level anytime soon. The central bank has ample firepower
for interventions, courtesy of the large FX reserves it amassed during the
intervention-floor policy several years ago.
Source: Bloomberg, Erste Group Research Source: Bloomberg, Erste Group Research
The Hungarian forint has been on a weakening streak this year, with brief
periods of respite. Nonetheless, it remains the region’s most battered
currency, as it weakened by a whopping 14% compared to late February.
The sizeable tightening of the local central bank has done little to soothe the
pressure on the forint. The underlying weakness of the Hungarian currency
is predominantly due to the dispute with the EU over rule of law issues and
the threat of cuts or freezes of EU funds, as well as the high dependence of
the country on Russian gas. The widening trade deficit is not helping, either.
Although the zloty has been hit less than the forint, it also remains on a
weaker footing, due to global factors, such as tightening on both sides of the
Atlantic (US, Eurozone) and the stronger US dollar. On top of that, local
factors are also at play. Even though the country reached an agreement
with the EU on unlocking its Recovery and Resilience Facility in June, we
have yet to see the funds start flowing into the economy, as several legal
hurdles remain in place. Moreover, the central bank seems to be nearly
done with its tightening, despite the still soaring inflation. In Romania, the
central bank retains its tight grip on the currency, as it cannot afford a
weaker leu. Even though the RON appreciated somewhat in late August, on
favorable flows into the currency, post-wheat harvest exports and seasonal
remittances from abroad, it reversed course later on and is back to 4.93 vs.
the EUR.
4.68-4.70 during the rest of the year. In the forint’s case, clear positive signs
from the talks with the EC and easing of tensions on energy markets are
needed to mitigate the pressure on the currency. We expect the EURHUF
pair at 390 by year-end. The Czech koruna will likely stay close to 24.50 this
year, with some appreciation potential later on in 2023. On the other hand,
the Romanian leu is likely to weaken towards 5.00 vs. the EUR by late
December.
The Croatian kuna is in its last few weeks as the country’s currency. As of
January 1, 2023, Croatia will become the 20th member of the Euro Area,
with the conversion rate set at 7.5345 against the euro. Meanwhile, the EU’s
single currency has recently been consistently trading very close to parity
against the US dollar. Signals from both the ECB and the Fed point to
further significant interest rate hikes. In addition, gas storage facilities in
Europe are filling up quickly, which means that the risks of energy shortages
are steadily decreasing. We thus see the euro strengthening towards 1.05
vs. the USD by year-end.
Bond market
Source: Bloomberg, Erste Group Research Source: Bloomberg Erste Group Research
CEE Macro & FI Research Page 9
Forecasts
Government bond yields
current 2022Q4 2023Q1 2023Q2 2023Q3
Croatia 10Y 3.2 3.5 3.5 3.5 3.4
spread (bps) 144 224 224 216 211
Czechia 10Y 4.5 4.4 4.2 3.9 3.7 FX
spread (bps) 276 311 290 255 238 current 2022Q4 2023Q1 2023Q2 2023Q3
Hungary 10Y 9.3 8.2 8.1 7.3 6.9 EURHRK 7.53 7.53 7.53 7.53 7.53
spread (bps) 752 692 682 601 565
Poland 10Y 6.0 6.0 6.1 5.9 5.8 EURCZK 24.52 24.50 24.36 24.29 24.21
spread (bps) 429 474 484 456 451
Romania10Y 8.1 8.5 8.3 8.0 7.8 EURHUF 407.72 390.00 385.00 380.00 380.00
spread (bps) 636 724 699 666 646
Slovakia 10Y 2.8 3.2 3.3 3.4 3.5 EURPLN 4.73 4.68 4.70 4.66 4.65
spread (bps) 102 194 204 206 221
Slovenia 10Y 2.76 2.70 2.80 2.80 2.80 EURRON 4.92 5.00 5.02 5.05 5.07
spread (bps) 102 144 154 146 151
Serbia 5Y 6.4 6.8 6.9 6.6 6.5 EURRSD 117.30 117.60 117.60 117.60 117.60
spread (bps) 469 554 564 526 521
DE10Y* 1.74 1.26 1.26 1.34 1.29 EURUSD 1.00 1.05 1.10 1.10 1.13
* Spreads based on Bloomberg consensus forecast
Appendix
Group Research
Head of Group Research Fixed Income Institutional Sales
Friedrich Mostböck, CEFA® +43 (0)5 0100 11902
Group Securities Markets
CEE Macro/Fixed Income Research Head: Thomas Einramhof +43 (0)50100 84432
Head: Juraj Kotian (Macro/FI) +43 (0)5 0100 17357
Katarzyna Rzentarzewska (Fixed income) +43 (0)5 0100 17356 Institutional Distribution Core
Malgorzata Krzywicka (Fixed income, Poland) +43 (0)5 0100 17338 Head: Jürgen Niemeier +49 (0)30 8105800 5503
Katarina Gumanova +43 (0)5 0100 17336
Institutional Distribution DACH+
Croatia/Serbia Head: Marc Friebertshäuser +49 (0)711 810400 5540
Alen Kovac (Head) +385 72 37 1383 Bernd Bollhof +49 (0)30 8105800 5525
Mate Jelić +385 72 37 1443 Andreas Goll +49 (0)711 810400 5561
Ivana Rogic +385 72 37 2419 Mathias Gindele +49 (0)711 810400 5562
Ulrich Inhofner +43 (0)5 0100 85544
Czech Republic Sven Kienzle +49 (0)711 810400 5541
David Navratil (Head) +420 956 765 439 Rene Klasen +49 (0)30 8105800 5521
Jiri Polansky +420 956 765 192 Christopher Lampe-Traupe +49 (0)30 8105800 5523
Michal Skorepa +420 956 765 172 Karin Rattay +43 (0)5 0100 84118
Michael Schmotz +43 (0)5 0100 85542
Hungary Klaus Vosseler +49 (0)711 810400 5560
Orsolya Nyeste +361 268 4428 Slovakia
János Nagy +361 272 5115 Šarlota Šipulová +421 2 4862 5619
Monika Směliková +421 2 4862 5629
Romania
Ciprian Dascalu (Head) +40 3735 10108 Institutional Distribution CEE & Insti AM CZ
Eugen Sinca +40 3735 10435 Head: Antun Burić +385 (0)7237 2439
Dorina Ilasco +40 3735 10436 Jaromir Malak +43 (0)5 0100 84254
Vlad Nicolae Ionita +40 7867 15618
Czech Republic
Slovakia Head: Ondrej Čech +420 2 2499 5577
Maria Valachyova (Head) +421 2 4862 4185 Milan Bartoš +420 2 2499 5562
Matej Hornak +421 902 213 591 Jan Porvich +420 2 2499 5566
Major Markets & Credit Research Institutional Asset Management Czech Republic
Head: Gudrun Egger, CEFA® +43 (0)5 0100 11909 Head: Petr Holeček +420 956 765 453
Ralf Burchert, CEFA® (Sub-Sovereigns & Agencies) +43 (0)5 0100 16314 Petra Maděrová +420 956 765 178
Hans Engel (Global Equities) +43 (0)5 0100 19835 Martin Peřina +420 956 765 106
Margarita Grushanina (Austria, Quant Analyst) +43 (0)5 0100 11957 David Petráček +420 956 765 809
Peter Kaufmann, CFA® (Corporate Bonds) +43 (0)5 0100 11183 Blanka Weinerová +420 956 765 317
Heiko Langer (Financials & Covered Bonds) +43 (0)5 0100 85509 Petr Valenta +420 956 765 140
Stephan Lingnau (Global Equities) +43 (0)5 0100 16574 Croatia
Carmen Riefler-Kowarsch (Financials & Covered Bonds) +43 (0)5 0100 19632 Head: Antun Burić +385 (0)7237 2439
Rainer Singer (Euro, US) +43 (0)5 0100 17331 Zvonimir Tukač +385 (0)7237 1787
Bernadett Povazsai-Römhild, CEFA® (Corporate Bonds) +43 (0)5 0100 17203 Natalija Zujic +385 (0)7237 1638
Elena Statelov, CIIA® (Corporate Bonds) +43 (0)5 0100 19641 Hungary
Gerald Walek, CFA® (Euro, CHF) +43 (0)5 0100 16360 Head: Peter Csizmadia +36 1 237 8211
Gábor Bálint +36 1 237 8205
CEE Equity Research Ádám Szönyi +36 1 237 8213
Head: Henning Eßkuchen +43 (0)5 0100 19634 Romania and Bulgaria
Daniel Lion, CIIA® (Technology, Ind. Goods&Services) +43 (0)5 0100 17420 Head: Ruxandra Lungu +40 373516562
Michael Marschallinger, CFA® +43 (0)5 0100 17906
Nora Nagy (Telecom) +43 (0)5 0100 17416 Group Institutional Equity Sales
Christoph Schultes, MBA, CIIA® (Real Estate) +43 (0)5 0100 11523 Head: Brigitte Zeitlberger-Schmid +43 (0)50100 83123
Thomas Unger, CFA® (Banks, Insurance) +43 (0)5 0100 17344 Werner Fürst +43 (0)50100 83121
Vladimira Urbankova, MBA (Pharma) +43 (0)5 0100 17343 Josef Kerekes +43 (0)50100 83125
Martina Valenta, MBA +43 (0)5 0100 11913 Cormac Lyden +43 (0)50100 83120
Czech Republic
Croatia/Serbia Head: Michal Řízek +420 224 995 537
Mladen Dodig (Head) +381 11 22 09178 Jiří Fereš +420 224 995 554
Anto Augustinovic +385 72 37 2833 Martin Havlan +420 224 995 551
Magdalena Basic +385 72 37 1407 Pavel Krabička +420 224 995 411
Davor Spoljar, CFA® +385 72 37 2825 Poland
Head: Jacek Jakub Langer +48 22 257 5711
Czech Republic Tomasz Galanciak +48 22 257 5715
Petr Bartek (Head) +420 956 765 227 Wojciech Wysocki +48 22 257 5714
Jan Safranek +420 956 765 218 Przemyslaw Nowosad +48 22 257 5712
Grzegorz Stepien +48 22 257 5713
Hungary Croatia
József Miró (Head) +361 235 5131 Matija Tkalicanac +385 72 37 21 14
András Nagy +361 235 5132 Hungary
Tamás Pletser, CFA® +361 235 5135 Nandori Levente + 36 1 23 55 141
Krisztian Kandik + 36 1 23 55 162
Poland Balasz Zankay + 36 1 23 55 156
Cezary Bernatek (Head) +48 22 257 5751 Romania
Piotr Bogusz +48 22 257 5755 Liviu Avram +40 3735 16569
Łukasz Jańczak +48 22 257 5754
Krzysztof Kawa +48 22 257 5752 Group Fixed Income Securities Markets
Jakub Szkopek +48 22 257 5753 Head: Goran Hoblaj +43 (0)50100 84403
Disclaimer
This publication was prepared by Erste Group Bank AG or any of its consolidated subsidiaries (together with consolidated
subsidiaries "Erste Group") independently and objectively as other information pursuant to the Circular of the Austrian Financial
Market Authority regarding information including marketing communication pursuant to the Austrian Securities Supervision Act.
This publication serves interested investors as additional source of information and provides general information, information
about product features or macroeconomic information without emphasizing product selling marketing statements. This
publication does not constitute marketing communication pursuant to Art. 36 (2) Austrian Securities Supervision Act as no direct
buying incentives were included in this publication, which is of information character. This publication does not constitute
investment research pursuant to § 36 (1) Austrian Securities Supervision Act. It has not been prepared in accordance with legal
requirements designed to promote the independence of investment research and it is not subject to the prohibition on dealing
ahead of the dissemination of investment research. The information only serves as non-binding and additional information and is
based on the level of knowledge of the person in charge of drawing up the information on the respective date of its preparation.
The content of the publication can be changed at any time without notice. This publication does not constitute or form part of,
and should not be construed as, an offer, recommendation or invitation to subscribe for or purchase any securities, and neither
this publication nor anything contained herein shall form the basis of or be relied on in connection with or act as an inducement
to enter into any contract or inclusion of a security or financial product in a trading strategy. Information provided in this
publication are based on publicly available sources which Erste Group considers as reliable, however, without verifying any such
information by independent third persons. While all reasonable care has been taken to ensure that the facts stated herein are
accurate and that the forecasts, opinions and expectations contained herein are fair and reasonable, Erste Group (including its
representatives and employees) neither expressly nor tacitly makes any guarantee as to or assumes any liability for the up-to-
dateness, completeness and correctness of the content of this publication. Erste Group may provide hyperlinks to websites of
entities mentioned in this document, however the inclusion of a link does not imply that Erste Group endorses, recommends or
approves any material on the linked page or accessible from it. Neither a company of Erste Group nor any of its respective
managing directors, supervisory board members, executive board members, directors, officers of other employees shall be in
any way liable for any costs, losses or damages (including subsequent damages, indirect damages and loss of profit) howsoever
arising from the use of or reliance on this publication. Any opinion, estimate or projection expressed in this publication reflects
the current judgment of the author(s) on the date of publication of this document and do not necessarily reflect the opinions of
Erste Group. They are subject to change without prior notice. Erste Group has no obligation to update, modify or amend this
publication or to otherwise notify a reader thereof in the event that any matter stated herein, or any opinion, projection, forecast
or estimate set forth herein, changes or subsequently becomes inaccurate. The past performance of securities or financial
instruments is not indicative for future results. No assurance can be given that any financial instrument or issuer described
herein would yield favorable investment results or that particular price levels may be reached. Forecasts in this publication are
based on assumptions which are supported by objective data. However, the used forecasts are not indicative for future
performance of securities or financial instrument. Erste Group, its affiliates, principals or employees may have a long or short
position or may transact in the financial instrument(s) referred to herein or may trade in such financial instruments with other
customers on a principal basis. Erste Group may act as a market maker in the financial instruments or companies discussed
herein and may also perform or seek to perform investment services for those companies. Erste Group may act upon or use the
information or conclusion contained in this publication before it is distributed to other persons. This publication is subject to the
copyright of Erste Group and may not be copied, distributed or partially or in total provided or transmitted to unauthorized
recipients. By accepting this publication, a recipient hereof agrees to be bound by the foregoing limitations. This document is
only made to or directed at investment professionals (as that term is defined in Article 19(5) of the Financial Services and
Markets Act 2000 (Financial promotion) Order 2005 (“FPO”)) or to persons for whom it would otherwise be lawful to distribute it.
Accordingly, persons who do not have professional experience in matters relating to investments should not rely on this
document.