Professional Documents
Culture Documents
114 115 1 PB
114 115 1 PB
Po s s i b i l i t y o f u s i n g by - p ro d u c t s o f t h e s t e e l m a k i n g i n d u s t r y fo r
r e m ov i n g l e a d f ro m a q u e o u s s o l u t i o n s(•)
M.I. Martín*, F.A. López**, F.J. Alguacil**
A b st ra ct A study is made of the use of two steelmaking industry by-products (rolling mill scale and blast furnace sludge) as
adsorbent materials for removing Pb2+ ions from aqueous solutions. The adsorption of Pb2+ on these materials has
been studied by the determination of adsorption isotherms. Several variables that affect the process (contact time,
initial lead ion concentration and temperature) were evaluated. The adsorption processes are analysed using the
Langmuir theory. Desorption processes for the metal from loaded by-products were also studied under different
experimental conditions. This paper shows that these industrial residues are effective adsorbents for lead ions in
aqueous solutions within the range of working concentrations.
K ey wo rd s Rolling mill scale. Blast furnace sludge. Lead. Adsorption. Adsorption isotherms.
Po s i b i l i d a d d e u s a r s u b p ro d u c t o s d e l a i n d u s t r i a d e l a c e ro p a r a e l i m i n a r
plomo de soluciones acuosas
Resumen Se estudia el uso de dos subproductos de la industria del acero (cascarilla de laminación y lodo de horno alto) como
materiales adsorbentes para eliminar iones Pb2+ de soluciones acuosas. La adsorción de Pb2+ sobre estos materiales se
ha estudiado determinando las isotermas de adsorción. Se evaluaron diferentes variables que afectan al proceso (tiem-
po de contacto, concentración inicial de iones plomo y temperatura). Los procesos de adsorción se estudian usando
la teoría de Langmuir. Los procesos de desorción de los metales también se estudiaron bajo diferentes condiciones
experimentales. Este trabajo muestra que estos residuos industriales son adsorbentes efectivos de iones plomo en so-
luciones acuosas en el rango de las concentraciones de trabajo utilizadas.
Pa l a b ra s clav e Cascarilla de laminación. Lodo de horno alto. Plomo. Adsorción. Isotermas de adsorción.
(·) Trabajo recibido el día 26 de febrero de 2007 y aceptado en su froma final el día 29 de noviembre de 2007.
* Departamento de Ciencia e Ingeniería de Materiales e Ingeniería Química, Universidad Carlos III de Madrid, Avda. de la Universidad,
30, 28911 Leganés, Madrid, España.
** Departamento de Metalurgia Primaria y Reciclado de Materiales, Centro Nacional de Investigaciones Metalúrgicas (CENIM), Avda.
Gregorio del Amo, 8, 28040 Madrid, España.
258
POSSIBILITY OF USING BY-PRODUCTS OF THE STEELMAKING INDUSTRY FOR REMOVING LEAD FROM AQUEOUS SOLUTIONS
POSIBILIDAD DE USAR SUBPRODUCTOS DE LA INDUSTRIA DEL ACERO PARA ELIMINAR PLOMO DE SOLUCIONES ACUOSAS
same time finding cheaper replacements for water. The suspension was vacuum-filtered and the
expensive conventional sorbent materials in resulting solid was dried at 80 °C for 24 h before
different situations[2, 9-12]. In previous studies we being crushed to yield a powder of a particle size
have investigated the possibility of using a of less than 40 mm. The chemical composition of
steelmaking industry by-product -rolling mill scale- the sample was determined by wavelength dispersion
in the removal of copper ions from aqueous X-ray fluorescence analysis (WDXRF) using a
solutions[4]. Philips PW-1404 spectrometer. Carbon and sulfur
In the present work we have investigated the analyses in both cases were carried out by
capacity of rolling mill scale and blast furnace sludge combustion in a Leco CS-244 oven and infrared
to remove Pb2+ ions, which may be present in liquid detection.
effluents. The crystalline mineralogical composition of
Rolling mill scale is a steelmaking by-product these by-products was determined by X-ray
from hot rolling processes which contains variable diffraction (XRD) using a Siemens D-5000
amounts of oil and grease. Spain generates about diffractometer (Cu Kα radiation).
44,000 t of mill scale every year [13] . The oil The N2 adsorption isotherm was determined at
component in rolling mill scale makes its recycling 77 K for samples previously degasified at 60 °C and
difficult, and its direct reuse in sintering may lead 10-5 torr for 120 min, using a Coulter SA-3100 unit.
to environmental pollution problems. Mill scale The isotherm data was used to determine the BET
with a high oil content is recycled after extracting specific area values of the materials studied. For the
the oil in a pretreatment stage or is dumped. Coarse removal of lead experiments the mill scale previously
scale with a particle size of 0.5-5 mm and an oil dried at 80 °C for 24 h was passed through a screen,
content of less than 1 % can be returned to the using only the < 0.5 mm fraction in the tests[12].
sinter strand without any pretreatment[13]. Pb2+ solutions were prepared by dissolving Pb(NO3)2
Blast furnace sludge is another by-product of the (chemical of reagent grade) in 0.01 M NaNO3, in
steelmaking industry. Gases generated during the order to maintain a constant ionic strength of the
manufacturing of pig iron are cleaned prior to their dissolution. 100 ml of the metal solution was added
emission into the atmosphere using any of several to 10 g of mill scale in Erlenmeyer flasks. Adsorption
systems. When a wet process is used the effluent tests with the mill scale were performed using
consists of a sludge, which is led to a Dorr thickener aqueous metallic solutions with concentrations
to increase its concentration. This study considers varying between 0.015 and 3.0 g/l. On the other
the concentrated sludge obtained from such a hand, 100 ml of the metal solution was added to 5
thickener. About 31,000 t of blast furnace sludge is g of sludge. Removal tests with the sludge were
produced in Spain every year[14]. performed using aqueous solutions with
concentrations varying between 0.015 and 10 g/l.
The samples were kept in constant suspension by
2. MATERIALS AND METHODS means of a thermostatically-controlled Lauda
MS-20 unit at different temperatures (between 20
The mill scale used in this work was supplied from and 80 °C) for an equilibrium time of 5 h. Tests were
a hot rolling mill in an electric steelshop in northern previously performed at different reaction times
Spain. It was dried at 80 °C for 24 h, revealing an in order to determine the equilibrium time. The
initial moisture content of 5 %. For its chemical equilibrium pH was pHeq = 5.0 ± 0.1. The pH was
analysis the mill scale was crushed to obtain a grain controlled using a Crison 517 pH-meter. The
size of < 40 mm. The chemical composition of the resulting suspensions were filtered and the solutions
ground sample was determined by wavelength analysed by atomic absorption spectrophotometry
dispersion X-ray fluorescence analysis (WDXRF) (AAS) with a Varian SpectrAA-220FS spectropho-
using a Philips PW-1404 spectrometer. The analysis tometer. Reproducibility of the results was ± 2 %.
of metallic iron was performed by titrating with a All experimental work used deionized water. The
0.1 N K 2 Cr 2 O 7 solution with barium adsorption tests were realized before with samples
diphenylamine-sulfonate as indicator. For this of the adsorbent materials and deionized water. The
determination the sample was first treated with a lead concentration in solution was determined being
bromine-methanol solution, filtering of the residual zero so much with mill scale as with sludge. The
oxides with a 20 mm crucible, with the Fe0 soluble amount of metallic ion adsorbed on the mill scale
in bromine-methanol passing into the filtrate[15]. and the sludge was determined by establishing the
The original sludge, provided by a Spanish difference between the initial concentration and
company, was a 57 % w/w suspension of solids in the equilibrium concentration.
REV. METAL. MADRID, 44 (3), MAYO-JUNIO, 258-264, 2008, ISSN: 0034-8570 259
M.I. MARTÍN, F.A. LÓPEZ, F.J. ALGUACIL
260 REV. METAL. MADRID, 44 (3), MAYO-JUNIO, 258-264, 2008, ISSN: 0034-8570
POSSIBILITY OF USING BY-PRODUCTS OF THE STEELMAKING INDUSTRY FOR REMOVING LEAD FROM AQUEOUS SOLUTIONS
POSIBILIDAD DE USAR SUBPRODUCTOS DE LA INDUSTRIA DEL ACERO PARA ELIMINAR PLOMO DE SOLUCIONES ACUOSAS
3.0 90
(b)
(a)
80
2.5
70
2.0 60
X (mg/g)
50
X (mg/g)
1.5
40
1.0 30
20 °C 20 °C
40 °C 20 40 °C
0.5 60 °C 60 °C
80 °C 10 80 °C
0.0 0
0 100 200 300 400 500 600 0 1 2000 3000 4000 5000 6000 7000
C (mg/L) C (mg/L)
Figure 1. Mass of Pb2+ ions adsorbed per unit of mass of adsorbent material as a function of the cation
equilibrium concentration in solution. X = Amount of metal ion adsorbed per unit of mass of mill
scale or sludge, C = Cation concentration at equilibrium. Equilibrium time = 5 h, (a) Mill scale, (b)
Sludge.
Figura 1. Masa de iones Pb2+ adsorbidos por unidad de masa de material adsorbente en función de
la concentración del catión en solución en el equilibrio. X = Cantidad de ión metálico adsorbido por uni-
dad de masa de cascarilla o lodo, C = Concentración del catión en el equilibrio. Tiempo de equilibrio
= 5 h, (a) Cascarilla, (b) Lodo.
and that ability of a particle to bind there is Figure 2 shows Langmuir isotherms for the
independent of whether or not adjacent sites are adsorption of Pb2+ in aqueous solution on mill scale
occupied[16]. and/or sludge at different temperatures. The metal
10000 300000
(a) (b)
9000
250000
8000
7000
200000
6000
C/X (1/dm)
C/X (1/dm)
5000 150000
4000
100000
3000 20 °C
20 °C
40 °C 40 °C
2000
60 °C 50000 60 °C
1000 80 °C 80 °C
0 0
0 100 200 300 400 500 600 0 1000 2000 3000 4000 5000 6000 7000
C (mg/L) C (mg/L)
F ig u re 2 . Langmuir isotherms. X = Amount of metal ion adsorbed per unit of mass of mill scale or
sludge, C = Cation concentration at equilibrium. Equilibrium time = 5 h, mill scale concentration = 100
g/l and sludge concentration = 50 g/l, (a) Mill scale, (b) Sludge.
Figura 2. Isotermas de Langmuir. X = Cantidad de ión metálico adsorbido por unidad de masa de
cascarilla o lodo, C = Concentración del catión en el equilibrio. Tiempo de equilibrio = 5 h, concentra-
ción de cascarilla = 100 g/l y concentración de lodo = 50 g/l, (a) Cascarilla, (b) Lodo.
REV. METAL. MADRID, 44 (3), MAYO-JUNIO, 258-264, 2008, ISSN: 0034-8570 261
M.I. MARTÍN, F.A. LÓPEZ, F.J. ALGUACIL
solution concentration was varied and the reaction capacity of sludge rises with the increase of
time was fixed at 5 h. The Langmuir values Xm and b temperature.
were calculated respectively as the slope and the C/X-
intercept of each isotherm line at different temperatures
and are shown in table III. The experimental results 3.2.3. Thermodynamic values
fit the Langmuir model well for both studied materials
(R2 > 0.994 – mill scale and R2 > 0.990 - sludge). The values for the apparent equilibrium constant
In table III is observed also that the adsorption of (Kc) of the adsorption process of lead in aqueous
Pb2+ on mill scale is practically independent of solution on by-products of the steelmaking industry
temperature and the adsorption capacity of this adsorbent were calculated with respect to temperature[17] at
material is very low (Xm = 2.74 mg/g – T = 60 °C) different initial concentration values and constant
(Fig. 3 a)); but the adsorption of metal on sludge is mill scale or sludge concentration (100 g/l – mill scale
dependent of temperature (Fig. 3 b)). The adsorption and 50 g/l – sludge) and residence time (5 h):
Table III. Langmuir parameters as a function of temperature. Rolling mill scale concentration = 100
g/l, blast furnace sludge concentration = 50 g/l
Ro lling mi ll s ca le Bla st fu rn a ce s lu d ge
4 90
(a) Rolling mill scale (b) Blast furnace sludge
80
3
Xm (mg/g)
Xm (mg/g)
70
2
60
1 50
10 20 30 40 50 60 70 80 90 10 20 30 40 50 60 70 80 90
T (°C) T (°C)
Figure 3. Variation of Xm with temperature. Xm indicate the adsorption capacity of the adsorbent material.
Equilibrium time = 5 h, mill scale concentration = 100 g/l and sludge concentration = 50 g/l, (a) Mill
scale, (b) Sludge.
Figura 3. Variación de Xm con la temperatura. Xm indica la capacidad de adsorción del material ad-
sorbente. Tiempo de equilibrio = 5 h, concentración de cascarilla = 100 g/l y concentración de lodo =
50 g/l, (a) Cascarilla, (b) Lodo.
262 REV. METAL. MADRID, 44 (3), MAYO-JUNIO, 258-264, 2008, ISSN: 0034-8570
POSSIBILITY OF USING BY-PRODUCTS OF THE STEELMAKING INDUSTRY FOR REMOVING LEAD FROM AQUEOUS SOLUTIONS
POSIBILIDAD DE USAR SUBPRODUCTOS DE LA INDUSTRIA DEL ACERO PARA ELIMINAR PLOMO DE SOLUCIONES ACUOSAS
Kc = % adsorción / 100 – % adsorción (2) on the wall of the blast furnace and damage the
refractories.
Previous experiments [15] have shown that
∆G°, ∆H° and ∆S° for the adsorption processes of
Table IV also shows the thermodynamic values
desorption of Pb2+ from these loaded steelmaking
lead. In the case of the mill scale, the Kc values are industry by-products, cannot be achieved using water
practically independent of temperature. Kc values and can be achieved with HCl 1 M, but chemical
increased with temperature in the case of the Pb attack by diluted mineral acids (HCl 1 M) also
adsorption process on sludge. These values were promoted the dissolution of the by-product.
calculated from the Kc values using equation 3 and Thus the stability of the loaded mill scale was
equation 4: studied for various times to assess the possibility of
dumping the material in a landfill. In the experiment
∆G° = - R T ln Kc (3) performed for a short time “leaching analysis” [17] mill
scale loaded with Pb2+ (0.07 mg/g) was used and 200
ln Kc = ∆H° / R T + ∆S / R
ml of distilled water was added to 12.5 g of the loaded
(4) mill scale in an Erlenmeyer flask. The samples were
REV. METAL. MADRID, 44 (3), MAYO-JUNIO, 258-264, 2008, ISSN: 0034-8570 263
M.I. MARTÍN, F.A. LÓPEZ, F.J. ALGUACIL
The removal of lead occurs through an adsorption [5] M.I. MARTÍN, F.A. LÓPEZ, C. PÉREZ, A. LÓPEZ-
process of lead ions on the surface of steelmaking DELGADO AND F.J. ALGUACIL, J. Chem. Tech-
industry material. The experimental results were well nol. Biot. 80 (2005) 1223-1229.
fitted, in each case, with the Langmuir isotherms. [6] F.A. LÓPEZ, C. PÉREZ, E. SAINZ AND M. ALON-
The adsorption processes of lead ions on sludge SO, J. Chem. Technol.Biot. 62 (1995) 200-206.
depend on the temperature, with the amount of [7] F.J. ALGUACIL, Rev. Metal. Madrid 39 (2003)
removed (adsorbed) ions increasing as the 205-209.
temperature rises. The adsorption of the Pb2+ on blast [8] F. PÉREZ-MORENO, F. PRIETO-GARCÍA, A. RO-
furnace sludge can be considered an endothermic JAS-HERNÁNDEZ, Y. MARMOLEJO-SANTILLÁN, E.
process. In the case of adsorption process of lead ions SALINAS-RODRÍGUEZ AND F. PATIÑO-CAR-
on millscale its adsorption is not dependent on the DONA, Rev. Metal. Madrid 42 (2006) 391-395.
temperature. [9] E. ROMERA, F. GONZÁLEZ, A. BALLESTER, M.L.
The data obtained shows that rolling mill scale B LÁZQUEZ AND J.A. M UÑOZ , Rev. Metal.
and blast furnace sludge are effective sorbents of Pb2+ Madrid 43 (2007) 29-41.
and perform well over a wide range of concentrations. [10] F.A. LÓPEZ, F. MEDINA, J. MEDINA AND M.A.
The results indicate that the blast furnace sludge, PALACIOS, Ironmaking Steelmaking 18 (1998)
that has a higher specific surface has a greater affinity 292-295.
for the metals than the rolling mill scale, that has a [11] P. ASHODAN, M. SAXENA AND S.R. ASOLEKAR,
lower specific surface, at all the temperatures studied. Resour. Conserv. Recy. 43 (2005) 239-262.
The treated by-products cannot be recycled in the [12] S. KUMAR, R. KUMAR AND A. BANDOPADH-
steelmaking process because of their metal content. YAY, Resour. Conserv.Recy. 48 (2006) 301-314.
So these loaded by-products must either be treated [13] IISI, The Management of Steel Plant Ferruginous
to desorb the metals or dumped in a controlled By-Products, Committee on Environmental
landfill. Affairs and Committee on Technology (Eds.),
The utilisation of the sludge and the mill scale as 1994, Brussels.
metallic ions sorbents provides a potential use for [14] A. LÓPEZ-DELGADO, C. PÉREZ AND F.A. LÓPEZ,
these industrial waste products. Water Res. 32 (1998) 989-996.
[15] M.I. MARTÍN, Tesis Doctoral, Facultad de Cien-
cias Químicas, Universidad Complutense de
REFERENCES Madrid, 2004.
[16] M. D ÍAZ -P EÑA AND A. R OIG -M UNTANER ,
[1] A. KABATA-PENDIAS AND H. PENDIAS, 2001. Química Física, vol. 2, Ed. Alhambra Univer-
Trace elements in soils and plants, CRC Press Inc., sidad, Madrid, España (1988), pp. 1034-1041.
Florida. [17] A. LÓPEZ-DELGADO, C. PÉREZ AND F.A. LÓPEZ,
[2] L. CURKOVIC, S. CERJAN-STEFANOVIC AND Carbon 34 (1996) 423- 426.
A. R ASTOVÈAN -M IOÉ , Water Res. 35(14) [18] FEDERAL REGISTER, 1986. Toxicity Characteristics
(2001) 3436-3440. Leaching Procedure (TCLP), 51(216), Friday,
[3] P.D. JOHNSON, M.A. WATSON, J. BROWN AND November 7, USA, 40643-40654.
I.A. JEFCOAT, Waste Manage 2 (2002) 471-480. [19] SPANISH LAW 29/1985, 2 August 1985, Real
[4] F.A. LÓPEZ, M.I. MARTÍN, C. PÉREZ, A. LÓPEZ- Decreto 849/1986, 11 April 1986, BOE 103, 30
DELGADO AND F.J. ALGUACIL Water Res. 37 April, 1986. http://www.gestion-ambiental.com/nor-
(2003) 3883-3890. ma/ley/REAL_DECRETO_ 849-1986.htm.
264 REV. METAL. MADRID, 44 (3), MAYO-JUNIO, 258-264, 2008, ISSN: 0034-8570