Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Final Paper (Myo Sandar Oo, Myanmar)
Final Paper (Myo Sandar Oo, Myanmar)
MYO SANDAR OO
Assistant Director (Engineer)
Department of Archaeology and National Museum
Ministry of Religious Affair and Culture
Myanmar
June 2018
Acknowledgement
I would like to express my appreciation to Director General, Directors and the programmer
of Asia Corporation program on Conservation Science (ACPCS), under government of
National Research Institute and Cultural Heritage for kindly invitation and sharing
knowledge to me. I also many thanks to Dr. Sang Sun Jo (Senior Researcher) and my
research mentor, Ms Sehyum Kim,(Senior Researcher) of Safety and Disaster Prevention
Division for their guidance and sharing knowledge to emerge this report.
My appreciated thankful also goes to member of ACPCS Team, Ms. Hong Young Ju, Ms.
Lee Bonnie, Ms. Choi T. J and Ms. Suree Moon who very warmly welcome to me and
other participants during this program. They have made the possibility available for my
stay and help for all conditions during these three months.
My sincerely thanks go to the all members of Safety and Disaster Prevention Division for
their helps. And people who are sharing many knowledge to our ACPCS participants.
Last, I would like to thank all my colleagues and friends in Myanmar and Korea who
helped me conduct this report my research.
Myo Sandar Oo
1
Introduction
Among the diverse elements that characterize Myanmar’s architectural culture, wooden
buildings have neither been surveyed /studied in full measure as of yet, nor have they been
sufficiently evaluated or given protection as cultural properties. Korea possesses an
accumulation of expertise in the conservation and repair of wooden buildings. It is no
doubt that the ACPCS program is very useful for the significant traditional architectural
values between Myanmar and Korea. National Research Institute of Cultural Heritage
(NRICH) is a good opportunity for my study. I would like to research the “Comparative
study on the Cultural Heritage (Special Reference to Architectural Design of Ancient
Monuments (Wooden Buildings) in Myanmar and Korea.
Myanmar Buddhist Wooden Monasteries
Myanmar has long history and a diverse culture and abundance of archaeological
sites. Myanmar prehistoric sites and stone tools were found throughout Myanmar. Pyu
ancient cities and Mon kingdoms were found and flourished from 1st-9th century C.A.D,
Early Bagan and Bagan Empire 9th-13th C.A.D, small kingdoms, Ava, Hanthawaddy, Shan
States, Arakan 14th-17th C.A.D, Taungu Dynasty 16th-17th C.A.D and Konbaung Dynasty
18th-19th C.A.D can be observed in Myanmar history.
In the period of the Konbaung dynasty (1752 –1885) left examples of different
traditional wooden buildings. Zayats, tazaungs, pyathats, monasteries (pongyikyaung),
royal palaces (nandaw) all these buildings are represented in various differing from each
other both in volumetric composition and in type of decoration. Monasteries play a vital
role in Myanmar Architecture. Numerous wooden monasteries remain particularity along
the Ayeyarwady River from Mandalay to southern Bagan. These "Wooden Monasteries of
Konbaung Period" have been included in the Tentative List which Myanmar submitted to
the UNESCO World Heritage Committee in 4th October 1996.
Korea Buddhist Wooden Temples
The Republic of Korea is a developed country in East Asia. The Lower Paleolithic
era in the Korean Peninsula began roughly half a million years ago. The earliest known
Korean pottery dates to around 8000 BC, and the Neolithic period began after 6000 BC,
followed by the Bronze Age by 800 BC, and the Iron Age around 400 BC. From the 1st
2
century, Goguryeo, Baekje, and Silla grew to control the peninsula and Manchuria as the
Three Kingdoms of Korea (57 BC – 668 AD), until unification by Silla in 676. In 698, Dae
Jo-yeonge stablished Balhae in old territories of Goguryeo , which led to the North South
Period(698–926). In the late 9th century, Silla was divided into the Later Three Kingdoms
(892–936), which ended with the unification by Wang Geon's Goryeo dynasty (918-
1392).During the Goryeo period, laws were codified, a civil service system was introduced,
and culture influenced by Buddhism flourished.
Koreans built with various architecture materials and techniques during the Three
Kingdoms period. Although stone and brick were increasingly being used, wood was still
the most popular construction material. Wood construction advanced significantly during
this time as Koreans continued to adopt Chinese methods and skill, especially for Buddhist
temple construction,into their indigenous architectural traditions. There have been
Buddhist temples in the mountains of the Korean Peninsula for practicing religious faith
and spirituality since the 4th century CE. Among the Buddhist temples, the seven mountain
temples were registered on UNESCO's World Heritage Tentative List under the name of
"Traditional Buddhist Mountain Temples of Korea” in 12th December 2013.
3
Contents
Acknowledgement
Introduction
1. History and Architecture Design of Wooden Buildings (Monasteries) in Myanmar 5
1.1 Shwe-In-Bin wooden Monastery (Mandalay) 5-6
1.2 Shwenandaw Kyaung wooden monastery (Mandalay) 6-7
1.3 Bagaya Wooden Monastery (Innwa) 7-8
2. Structural System of Traditional Wooden Monastery in Myanmar 9-10
3. Analysis on Conservation of Traditional Wooden Buildings in Myanmar
3.1 Major Laws Concerning the Preservation of Cultural Heritage 10
3.2 Organization Responsible for Preservation 11
3.3The general conditions of the monasteries before conservation 11-12
3.4 Process of conservation work carried out 12-13
4. History and Architecture Design of Wooden Buildings (Temples) in Korea
4.1Geungnakjeon Hall of Bongjeongsa Temple 13-14
(Andong-si,Gyeongsangbuk-do Provice)
4.2 Muryangsujeon Hall of Buseoksa Temple 14-15
( Yeongju-si,Gyeongsangbuk-do Provice)
4.3Daegwangbojeon Hall of Magoksa Temple 15-16
(Gongjusu, Chungcheongam-do Province)
5. Structural Systems of Traditional Wooden Temples in Korea 16-17
6. Analysis on Preservation and Conservation of Traditional Wooden
Buildings (temples) in Korea
6.1 Major Laws Concerning the Preservation of Cultural Heritage 17
6.2 Organization Responsible for Preservation 18
6.3 General conditions of the Temples before Conservation 18
6.4 Process of conservation work carried out and monitoring system 18-19
6.5 Others 19-22
7. Conclusion 23-24
Bibliography
4
1. History and Architecture Design of Wooden Buildings (Monasteries) in Myanmar
1.1 Shwe-In-Bin Wooden Monastery, (Mandalay)
The Shwe-In-Bin monastery was built in 1895 by a wealthy Chinese merchant U
Set Shwin and his wife Daw Bwa. Although constructed a decade after British
annexation, the monastery is remarkable for its classic proportions and its elaborate well-
preserved relief-carvings of scenes from Myanmar and Buddhist folklore. It is a unique
quality master piece of architectural excellence in Forms, Functions and Space.
This monastery is built on a nearly 2m high platform and supported by a total
of 167 sturdy oiled teak pillars. It is dominated in the east by a seven-tiered,9 by 9m
cruciform-shaped image room (Pyathat-Hsaung) with projecting gables in three
directions. Light enters this room through small porthole windows which are also the
focus for the diagonally arragned planking comprising the walls of the pyathat spire. This
apartment adjoins an approximately 14m by 5m ,tiered ein-daw roofed former chief
monk’s room (Sanu Hsaung).The largest apartment, the reception hall (Hsaung-Ma-
Gyi)over 32m long, which is marked externally by a series of three classic (Zei-Ta-
Wun)roofs is divided into two parts by a partition wall. The western section of the
reception hall which serves as a dormitory for monks is connected to the store room
(Bawga-Hsaung) by an interesting architectural feature in the form of a covered arched
hallway or kon-hsaung surmounted by a small tiered roof. Store room is marked
externally by three triple (Zei-Ta-Wun) roofs which are lower than those of the (Sanu-
Hsaung) to the east but higher than those of the covered (Kon-Saung hall) way to the
west. A total of eight masonary staircases, three on both the north and south sides and a
further one each at the east and west ends.
5
Fig. 4 Shwe-In-Bin Monastery
Fig. 3 South Elevation
6
Fig. 7 South Elevation Fig. 8 Shwe -Nan -Taw -KyaKyaung
7
Fig. 11 South Elevation Fig. 12 Bagaya Wooden Monastery
8
Fig. 13 Composition of Myanmar Wooden Monastery
9
3.2 Organization Responsible for Preservation
In Myanmar, the government organization responsible for the preservation,
restoration and conservation of culture heritage monuments is the Department of
Archaeology and National Museum. Preservation and safeguarding the cultural
heritage of the nation is main goal of the Ministry of Religious Affair and Culture.
The Ministry of Religious Affair and Culture ,other related Ministries, regional
authorities and non-profit social organization and association (including monks) are
working in close collaboration for the preservation and safeguarding of Tangible
and Intangible cultural heritage.
3.3 The general conditions of the monasteries before conservation
In upper Myanmar have over 50 ancient wooden monasteries.Among them
most of the monasteries have been preserved by Department of Archaeology and
National Museum in line with budgetary considerations. Shwe-In-Bin monastery
that was annually preserved from 100 year ago. Shwenandaw wooden monastery
was mainly conserved by Department of Archaeology and National Museum in
1995 and it now on going conservation project with World Monument Fun (WMF)
from 2014.Bagayar wooden monasteries was recently conserved by our department
in 2000 and according to safeguarding cultural heritage program , it was surveys
recording the state of damage and technical specification of the building,
cooperatived with National Research Institute for Culture Properties( Tokyo) from
( 2012-2015).
Myanmar is in the tropical zone, and the climate is hot and humidity is high all
year, especially in the rainy season. According to our traditional building methods,
all of the monasteries were built by digging holes pillars. Thus, the parts of the
wood pillars in the ground were ruined several years later. Following this, the upper
part of the monastery leaned in different directions and eventually collapsed into a
heap of wood. The general conditions of the monasteries before conservation are as
follows;
Rainwater leaks through drains, windows and roofs so that some parts are badly
deteriorated.
10
During the rainy season there is water accumulation around the monastery that
whole year round, and therefore some supporting pillars under the monastery
sink and are fragile.
Due to water accumulation another problems is that the whole buildings is
leaning approximately 5~20 degrees towards the one side and in different
directions so that it is dangerous for the who live there.
The sculptures and carvings outside are decayed and eroded due to prolonged
exposure to weather.
3.4 Process of conservation work carried out
Before starting the conservation works, photographic record was taken from
each and every corner. The process of conservation work was carried out as follow:
First, the water accumulation under around the monastery was pumped out by
using a water pump.
Each of the pillars was dugout at the foundation in a square shape.
Some portions of the structure such as a projecting corrugated iron sheet roof at
the side of the monastery, roofs of the main structures, and side windows etc.
were dismantled temporarily in order to reduce the heavy weight of the whole
structure as far as possible.
Then the whole was pulled back and straightened upright by workers and then
supported with long wooden posts from the side that was leaning.
When the whole structure was straighter up vertically all the basement of the
Pillars were filled up with reinforced cement concrete in an octagonal shape in
order to reinforce the whole structure.
The ground level under and surrounding area of the monastery was positioned
slightly higher by elevating the base with soil and constructing a slope so that
water is not allowed to stagnate around the base again.
Some decayed wooden pillars, floor planks and iron sheet roofs were removed
and replaced with new ones.
Portions temporarily dismantled were replaced.
11
All the missing portions of the brick staircase were repaired to get the original
shape and design.
All the pillars and exposed parts of the building were applied with thick crude
oil in order to protect them from the effects of weather.
All the zinc sheets were applied with red oxide external pain in order to protect
them from rainwater.
13
Fig. 19 Front Elevation Fig. 20 1Geungnakjeon Hall of Bongjeongsa Temple
14
Fig. 21 Floor Plan Fig. 22 Section
15
engraved the head of dragon on the pillar of center partition. The ceiling is decorated
with patterns of the Chinese character 井 (jeong).They prepared the Buddhist altar in the
west and installed datjib (a canopy) above the altar, which makes the Buddhist statue
more dignified. For its structure, its elaborate decorations, and its architectural style, the
hall is regarded as a uniquely important cultural asset for the study of architectural
history of late Joseon.
16
The mountain temples of Magoksa, Bongjeongsa and Buseoksa were all
established during the Three Kingdoms period, but were standardized in their layout
and forms after the mid-Joseon Dynasty. These temples show the essence of Korean
mountain temples with their diverse axes and their harmony with the surrounding
valleys, also continuing on with their comprehensive functions of a religious facility.
17
6.2 Organization Responsible for Preservation
In Korea, Cultural Heritage Administration (CHA) manages important cultural
properties. The State-designated Cultural Heritage such as National Treasures and
Treasures are directly managed by CHA, and in the case of City/Province-designated
Cultural Heritage, CHA supports local governments for their management. The National
Palace Museum of Korea and National Research Institute of Maritime Cultural Heritage
are also under the control of CHA. Through the National Research Institute of Cultural
Heritage, CHA conducts a variety of research and investigation for scientific conservation
and the management of cultural properties. The Korean National University of Cultural
Heritage, a national university specialized in cultural heritage, was also established and run
by CHA.
6.3 General Conditions of the Temples before Conservation
In Korea, have 966 traditional wooden temples. Among them , State-designated
Cultural Heritage, National Treasure and Treasures (95) temples are directly managed by
Cultural Heritage Administration (CHA).The Cultural Heritage Administration (CHA) is
mainly repaired at Geungnakjeon Hall of Bongjeongsa Temple in (2001~2003), and
Daegwangbojeon Hall of Magoksa Temple in (1998~2000).Muryangsujeon Hall of
Buseoksa Temple was mainly repaired in (1930s) by Japanese Colonial Government.
Korea is a peninsula surrounded by three seas and 80% of it covered by mountains
and forests. By the passage of time, these cultural heritage of wooden temples have been
influenced with the global warming, air pollution and corrosion, etc…And the overall
maintained are deterioration of environment. According to Korea traditional wooden
buildings methods, all of the wooden Buddhist temples were built with column head or
brackets architrave support of the roof eaves. Several years later, the general conditions of
the temples before conservation are as follows;
(a) Sagging of the girder and outer shawl.
(b) Cracks and detachment of wall.
(c) Inclination of columns and deflection of beams.
(d) Corrosion and deformation of the members due to prolonged exposure to weather.
6.4 Process of Conservation Work carried out
Both before and during repair work, through survey and research are conducted.
18
Traditional techniques are inherited for practical use. The newest technology is
applied to recording surveys. In principle, Repair work is to maintain the
original forms and respectively individual Cultural properties.
Compilation and publishing detailed documentation of contents of repair work
the grounds for conducting the repair work and revealed facts through the
repair.
Design and management are executed by technical experts in repair work.
Preserved in their original condition, as well as, their surroundings protected
from indiscriminate development.
6.5 Others
I have other submits that is concerned with investigation and conservation of
cultural heritages and trips by ACPCS team. The places of field visited are as follows;
19
Dr .Jo and Ms.
3. 19th-April Gongju Mogoksa Temple
Sehyum Kim(SDPD)
Muwisa Temple
(Geungnakbojeon Hall)
4. 25th-April Gangjin
Wolnam Temple(three story stone pagoda and
Stele for state preceptor Jingak)
Baengmyeonsa Temple Site Mr. Sihyum Kim and
National Maritime Museum Survey Team
Mokpo ( SDPD)
National Research Institute of Maritime Museum
5. 26th-April
Monument for the Victory at Myeongnyang
Haenam Battle
Daeheungsa Temple
6. 27th-April Jangheung Borimsa Temple(East Stupa)
Seokjangri Site Exhibition Hall
Gong San Seong ( Fortress)
7. 3rd-May Gongju
Songsan Village
Jemin river (Jemincheon ) Side ACPCS Group
Excavation Site of Wanggungri
8. 4th-May Iksan Iksan National Museum
Miruksa Temple Site
20
Fig. 31 Study of regular monitoring in Seokguram Grotto, Bunhwangsa Temple and Stone Ice Storage
Fig. 32 Study of regular survey in Muwisa Temple, Monument for the Victory at Myeongnyang Battle and Wolnam Temple
Fig. 33 Study of regular survey in Daeheungsa Temple, Buseoksa Temple and Bongjeongsa Temple
21
Fig. 35 Study of World Heritage Site in Miruksa Temple, Excavation Site of Wanggungri and Gong San Seong (Fortress)
Fig. 36 Study in Gyeongbokgung Palace and World Heritage Site of Changdeokgung Palace and Cheomseongdae
Fig. 37 Study in National Palace Museum, National Museum of Korea, Gyeongju National Museum
Fig. 38 Study in Seokjangri Site Exhibition Hall, Iksan National Museum and National Maritime Museum
22
VII. Conclusion
We could note that in the main of the art and architecture of Myanmar is
much direct from India, in contrast to the Korean influenced through China. In term of the
Myanmar wooden monastery is dedicated to Theravada Buddhism and Korea wooden
temples is dedicated to Mahayana Buddhism. The view of the Comparative Study on the
Architectural Design of Traditional Buddhist Wooden Temples in Myanmar and Korea are
as follows;
Structural Composition
Layout Plan Myanmar monasteries were built in unit type for four main functions
of building and Korea temples were built in separate type for several functions.
Foundation System According to Myanmar traditional building methods, all of the
monasteries were built by digging holes pillars. Thus, the parts of the wood pillars
in the ground were ruined several years later. In Korea temples, Column bases were
rectangular stone with smooth surfaces.
Flooring System, two country are used in same material wood but Myanmar
monasteries' floor is elevated about 2.5 3m above the ground and has wide open
wooden platform which is surrounding the building. In Korea temples, flooring
placed on the ground level but they have small holes for ventilation.
Column and Bracket System, Round shape column were used in most of wooden
temples between two countries. Korea's bracket system is graceful column bracket
system. According to Korea traditional wooden buildings method, all of the wooden
Buddhist temples were built with column head or brackets architrave support of the
roof eaves.
Roofing, Myanmar wooden Buddhist temples has crowned by tiered roofing
systems. Korea wooden Buddhist temples, simple basic gable and hip roof are
used.
Painting and Wood Carving, In Myanmar wooden Buddhist temples with carved
wooden multi figures, all the pillars and exposed parts of the building were applied
with thick crude oil. In Korea wooden Buddhist temples with embellishing with a
multi-colored decorative painting.
23
Conservation and Preservation Practices
• In Conservation State, In Myanmar, needs to be clarified in the future through the
survey, studies and comparative analyses. In Korea, the cultural heritage has been
researched, documented, conserved and restored in their original condition as well
as their surrounding under the law.
• In Preservation State, in two countries, all Buddhist temples' main structures were
composed of wood. In preservation practices, main causes of deterioration of
wooden architecture cultural heritage are Climates and Environment,
Biodeterioration, Natural Disaster (Earthquake, Flood, Landslide, and Fire .etc).
In Myanmar, Buddhist Monasteries need annual maintenance fund and
monitoring system are still required.
In Korea, all the Temples installed Firefighting System and Pest
Management System. Making regular investigation; research and survey for
structural stability of wooden temples, analysis on safety data, on the safety data,
study on the assessment standard for structural stability and preventive techniques
against natural disasters. In addition, the urgent on-site inspection on situations of
cultural heritage damaged by the natural disaster such as the earthquake is carried
out. Cultural heritage management system; well protected from indiscriminate
development.
My profession is greatly benefited by this comparative research. Relays
from my experiences in Myanmar architectures, I could compare this knowledge to
the Korean architectures. And as a result, the studies get me more insight into the
history and development of Myanmar and Korea architectures from ancient up to
the present time and gravitate towards the future conservation and preservation.
24
Bibliography
1. Daw Lwin Mar Oo, 2005," Problems and Needs for Cultural Heritage Protection
and Restoration Activities in Myanmar", Training Course on Cultural Heritage
Protection in Asia-Pacific Region.
2. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Korean_Buddhist_temples
3. http://en.Wikipedia.org/wiki/Traditional Buddhist Mountain Temples of Korea
4. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bagaya_Monastery
5. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Korean_architecture#Religious_architecture_
6. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Shwenandaw_Monastery
7. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Shweinbin_Monastery
8. https://whc.unesco.org/en/tentativelists/
9. http://www.dbpia.co.kr
10. http://www.law.go.kr
11. http://www.nrich.go.kr/english/index.do
12. Kim Dong-uk, 2013, “History of Korean Architecture", translated by Lim Jong
–hyun, edited by Gregory A. Tisher, Suwon: University of Kyonggi press, 2013.
13. Lim, Manntaek, 2005, “The Scientific Methods for the Restoration and
Preservation of Building Cultural Properties”, Architectural Institute of Korea,
Review of Architecture and Building Science, vol 49, No 12.
14. National Research Institute of Cultural Heritage, 2017, Workshop on the scope
of the material and techniques Stone, Wood and Earth, the 1st ISCARSAH
Workshop 2017.
15. Raymond Myo Myint Sein,2015, "The Early Studies on Kombaung Period
(1752-1885) Wooden Buildings in Myanmar Research Studies Performed in
Late 1960's and Early 1970's",Traditional Wooden Buildings in Myanmar,
National Research Institute for Cultural Properties, Tokyo, March 2015.
16. Tokyo National Research Institute for Cultural Properties, Mar 2017,
"Safeguarding of Cultural Heritage in Myanmar", the Agency for Cultural
Affairs of the Japanese Government 2012-2015. Independent Administrative
Institution National Institutes for Cultural Heritage.
25
17. U Min Min, 2009," Problems and Needs for Cultural Heritage Protection and
Restoration Activities in Myanmar", Training Course on Cultural Heritage
Protection in Asia-Pacific Region.
18. Yang, Tae-Hyeon ,Cheon, Deuk-Youm , 2011, “A Study on the Construction
Method of 5-story Wooden Stupa Represented in Nungsa Temple”, Journal of
the Architectural institute of Korea planning and design, vol 27 No.12.
19.
26