Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Pattern and Economic Assessment of Unused Medication For Cardiovascular Disease Treatment
Pattern and Economic Assessment of Unused Medication For Cardiovascular Disease Treatment
SUMMARY
Underutilization and inadequate disposition of expired medic- Therapeutic Chemical (ATC) system. The difference among the
inal drugs represent an important problem. The objective of this grouped drugs was tested with ANOVA or Chi square as cor-
study was describing the pattern and amount of unused cardio- respond. The cost of each drug identified was obtained through
vascular drugs in Metropolitan area of Monterrey, in the Nuevo the consultation of price in at least three pharmacies. During
León state, Mexico. Through several dissemination ways, inhab- the time of collection, a total of 207963 units were collected, of
itants were invited to deposit their unused medication at sever- which lipid modifying agents were the more abundant, the esti-
al collection centers distributed across the metropolitan area, mated cost of all cardiovascular drugs was of 0.03 USD per in-
the period of collection was of 12 months. Individual drugs were habitant. These results shown that an important quantity of car-
identified, counted, and classified according to the Anatomical diovascular drugs is wasted and represent an important cost.
Introduction domestic product (GDP) (Xu et prevalent diseases and the Econom ic Bu rden of Non-
al., no date). It is estimated most expensive ones. Among communicable Diseases, in
T he u nder utilization of that across Organization for these are cardiovascular dis- 2010, heart diseases cost 863
drugs results in a loss of eco- Economic Co-operation and eases, as reported by Gracia- billion USD worldwide. This
nomic resources and ref lects Development countries in 2013 Vásquez and co-workers. They is estimated to increase by
poor treatment compliance, in spending on drugs correspond- repor ted that cardiovascular 22% by 2030 (Bloom et al.,
addition to representing a risk ed to 20% of the health budget drugs were the second group 2011). In Mexico, cardiovas-
of accidental poisoning in chil- (OECD, 2015). Therefore, one of phar maceuticals with the cular diseases, in conjunction
dren, environmental contami- of the main challenges faced highest u nder utilization i n with mental health conditions,
nation and self-medication by health systems is finding their study (Gracia-Vásquez et are the dominant contributors
( Nar vaez y Ji menez, 2012; the most efficient way to use al., 2015). to the global economic bur-
Koza k et al., 2016; Paut the budget. This involves re- Cardiovascular diseases are den of noncommunicable dis-
Kusturica et al., 2016; Makki ducing losses due to the un- the most prevalent medical eases (Rosas-Peralta, et al.,
et al., 2019). Regarding the derutilization of pharmaceuti- conditions with the highest 2017).
economic aspect, the World cals. To design resource opti- mor tality rate. They caused The objective of this study
Health Organization reported mization strategies, it is neces- 32% of deaths worldwide in was to determine the pattern of
that health spending is increas- sar y to k now the causes of 2019 ( World Healt h unused/expired cardiovascular
ing faster than the rest of the drug underuse, as well as the Organization, 2021) and 20% drugs and estimate their cost
world economy; In 2016, the main types of unused dr ugs of deaths in Mexico in 2017 in a sample of unused drugs
world spent $ 7.5 trillion USD and the costs they represent ( I nst it uto Nacional de collected in the Metropolitan
on health, representing close (West et al., 2014; Bekker et Estadística y Geografia, 2019). area of Monter rey, Mexico
to 10% of the world's gross al., 2018), mainly for the most Accord i ng to T he Global (MMM).
Ivonne A. Camacho-Mora. Doctor Sandra L. Gracia-Vásquez. Doctor Yolanda A. Gracia-Vásquez. Doctor Lucía G. Cantú- Cárdenas
of Pharmacy, Nova Southeastern of Phar macy, NSU, USA. of Science, UANL, Mexico. (Corresponding author). Doctor
University (NSU) USA, Professor, UANL, Mexico. Professor, UANL, Mexico. of Phar macy, NSU, USA.
Professor, Universidad Autónoma Patricia González-Barranco. Mónica A. Ramírez- Cabrera. Professor UANL, Mexico.
de Nuevo León (UANL), Mexico. Doctor of Science, Universidad Doctor of Science, UANL, Address: Av. Universidad s/n,
Patricia C. Esquivel-Ferriño. UANL, Mexico. Professor, Mexico. Professor, UANL, Ciudad Universitaria, CP 66451,
Doctor of Science, Universidad UANL, Mexico. Mexico. San Nicolás de los Garza,
Autónoma de Nuevo León Evangelina Ramírez-Lara. Doctor Omar González-Santiago. Doctor Nuevo León, México; E-mail:
(UANL), Mexico. Professor, of Science, UANL, Mexico. of Science, UANL, Mexico. lucia.cantucr@uanl.edu.mx
UANL, Mexico. Professor, UANL, Mexico. Professor, UANL, Mexico.
Materials and Methods under the Anatomic Health for classification and the ATC System; in addition,
Therapeutic Chemistry (ATC) registration based on stratified the following information was
The study was conducted in system, (5) accounting and reg- random sampling with propor- included: brand, generic name,
northeast Mexico, in the MMM istration of solid drugs (tablets tional allotment. Once classi- potency, pharmaceutical formu-
in Nuevo Leon state. During 12 and capsules) from the cardio- fied, the medicines were sepa- lation, administration route,
months, a group of professors vascular group, and (6) cost rated from their primary and origin, expiration date, and
and students from the School estimation of non-utilized and/ secondary packages and kept unit quantity.
of Chemical Sciences of the or expired medication and anal- stored under the custody of the The medications’ cost was
Universidad Autónoma de ysis of the results. Ministry of Health until final estimated by averaging the
Nuevo León, in collaboration Program dissemination con- disposal. The packaging mate- commercial cost of three med-
with the State Ministr y of sisted of news bulletins that rials were treated according to icines containing the active
Health, collected and classified invited the public to deliver the Official Mexican Standard ingredient (patented and gener-
medical dr ugs from several unnecessar y, expired, or (Norma Of icial Mexicana) ic); the latter information was
collection centers. The overall non-utilized medication to col- NOM-161 that establishes the consulted by telephone call or
process included six different lection centers. The collection criteria to classify the special through the web pages of dif-
stages: (1) “Final disposal of was conducted with containers handling of waste (SEMARNAT, ferent Mexican pharmacies.
non-utilized and/or expired specifically designed for the 2013). Upon final disposal, the The medicine’s unit cost was
medication” program dissemi- study; these were gathered at medication was incinerated, ac- obtained by dividing the cost
nation, (2) drug collection from 28 different collection centers cording to the provisions of the of the commercial package by
homes in Monterrey’s metro- across several pharmacies in Official Mexican Standard the number of units (tablets/
politan area (Nuevo Leon, the region. NOM-098-SEMARNAT 2002 capsules) contained in the com-
Mexico), (3) random sampling The collected medication (SEMARNAT, 2004). mercial package. The commer-
of 30% of collected medication, was transported to the state The cardiovascular dr ugs cial value of the total sample
(4) medication classification delegation of the Ministry of were classified according to (expired and/or unused